Would you change this air filter?

motoGleamer
Posts
212
Joined
3/26/2019
Location
Beverly Hills, CA, USA

Posting this to get others thoughts and learn. Are you guys changing this? I normally change every ride but am wondering if this is unnecessary. This filter looks like it still works well and I do worry about tiny debris getting into the airbox with each change and would ideally limit if possible.

20231003 120433 0 ​​​​​​​

3
|
wrc777
Posts
3268
Joined
5/21/2020
Location
Greenwood, IN, USA
10/3/2023 12:36pm

No I would not change that. 

24
1
COAL-TRAIN
Posts
672
Joined
2/5/2013
Location
Harbor City, CA, USA
10/3/2023 12:38pm

Looks like you just rode around the block lol. She's fine

12
bvm111
Posts
10193
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Las Vegas, NV, USA
10/3/2023 12:46pm

i’m meticulous about my filter maintenance… that being said, id run that if it had Maxima FFT oil on it! 

1
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
10/3/2023 12:50pm

Drive it on...

You can change this stuff too often and unnecessarily, just like oil.

4

The Shop

PDUB481
Posts
137
Joined
3/3/2009
Location
O Fallon, IL, USA
10/3/2023 1:41pm

YES, Ron Lechien would be disappointed, You didn't use the blue stuff 

6
Kiernan mx
Posts
172
Joined
9/10/2023
Location
Rotorua, NZ
10/3/2023 2:17pm

That model of Yamaha needed a lot less filter maintenance than the older of even newer models. That’s got plenty of use left. Just make sure the oil isn’t drying out is all. 

GrapeApe
Posts
9134
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
10/3/2023 2:21pm Edited Date/Time 10/4/2023 7:29am

If my dog and I need a break from the family, yes, we would go out in the garage and change that filter. Otherwise, no.

23
motomind132
Posts
281
Joined
5/12/2023
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
10/3/2023 2:21pm

I have a day at the sand track, 2 days at a dust bowl practice track and a race on my filter. No toil. Clean as a whistle behind it and all down the boot. That's a bit more then I would normally leave it. I run normally 5-6 engine hours depending on conditions. This is also on a yz250f as well.

1
SPYGUY
Posts
2201
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
10/3/2023 2:36pm

No, it's barely dirty.

I've seen people that say they change their air filter every ride "whether it needs it or not". And to me, that makes no sense whatsoever.

10
Bruce372
Posts
6329
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/3/2023 2:54pm

In the 90s, I used to know a guy that owned high performance cars, he never emptied the ash tray, just bought a new car.

3
1
Rosso391
Posts
3776
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
YO MAMA, MN, USA
10/3/2023 3:02pm

If I can still see my air filter oil color, its still clean.

5
1
Jaybird67k
Posts
567
Joined
10/27/2013
Location
Vidor, TX, USA
10/3/2023 3:20pm

That's not even caked on good like I like mine. When it's all brown is when I clean.......lol.

I do check my intake boot when it's caked on thick just to see how good the filtration system is working. You be surprised how much these filters can take and still breath.

JB500
Posts
327
Joined
7/14/2018
Location
Granger, IN, USA
10/3/2023 3:35pm
I have a day at the sand track, 2 days at a dust bowl practice track and a race on my filter. No toil. Clean as...

I have a day at the sand track, 2 days at a dust bowl practice track and a race on my filter. No toil. Clean as a whistle behind it and all down the boot. That's a bit more then I would normally leave it. I run normally 5-6 engine hours depending on conditions. This is also on a yz250f as well.

I’m having involuntary twitches reading this. I’m the over maintainer that oil and filter companies love. 

1
Heavyhitter
Posts
393
Joined
3/20/2023
Location
Sultan, WA, USA
10/3/2023 3:41pm

I would get a no toil/ twin air/ d2 filter and cage kit on that thing!

 

but that filter looks fine. 

1
plowboy
Posts
14858
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
10/3/2023 3:45pm
GrapeApe wrote:

If my dog and I need a break from the family, yes, we would go out in the garage and change that filter. Otherwise, no.

This man has the game figured out.Cool

8
crusher773
Posts
2033
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Coweta, OK, USA
10/3/2023 9:13pm

There is zero chance I'm even thinking about changing that sucker.

2
10/4/2023 12:16am

How many days, weeks, or months between rides?

Just clean it and be done with it.

1
10/4/2023 1:00am Edited Date/Time 10/4/2023 1:01am

Raced with a guy years ago and his bikes were always abused. He had a 6 month old 1991 YZ250 and it wasn't running right and sounded choked up. Someone asked if the air filter was clogged and he replied "filter.? what filter?" Took the seat off and the airbox was half full of mud. No idea how that thing was still running. He would literally ride bikes till they died.

1
adamw21
Posts
224
Joined
12/14/2020
Location
Martin, TN, USA
10/4/2023 1:37am

It’s clean and probably is good for another ride BUT a rule of thumb I always use is it’s cheaper and easier to clean and oil filters then it is to shim valves and do top ends 

 

after I ride I take the filters off spray carb cleaner on a paper towels wipe around the air boot and install a wash cover and wash the bike. I try to keep the air box as spotless as the whole bike. I let the filter soak in a bucket with oxy clean and wash it with dawn 

 

I oil the filter with green no toil one to two days before I’m riding and let it dry.  I install it right before I load the bike up or the night before. I can’t stand dirty air boxes or filters sitting in the bike 

 

using this method on three different bikes that I have put 60+ hours on I have never once shimmed a valve or had one to move any real distance 

2
cwel11
Posts
2800
Joined
12/4/2019
Location
Orangeville, PA, USA
10/4/2023 2:35am

To each their own but I pop the cover off after a ride and my filter looks like the OP’s I’m not even thinking about changing it. I’m all about maintaining my stuff and keeping it in good running order but changing that filter or changing it every ride regardless is overkill IMO

5
CPR
Posts
7294
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
10/4/2023 2:39am

This is the good thing about having a meticulous air filter regime; you know it’s been well cleaned and thoroughly oiled, so yes you can leave it in with confidence.

1
Rickyisms
Posts
5946
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
USA
10/4/2023 2:56am

I wish my filter could look like that after one ride. 

sandtrack315
Posts
2877
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
10/4/2023 3:13am Edited Date/Time 10/4/2023 3:14am

Absolutely wouldn’t even think about changing it. I go 2-3 hours in the sand, but I ride alone, so that’s a factor. As another poster said, if I can see the oil color, I’m riding it. I also don’t wash my bike, as I only wash it with an air box cover on. So every 2-3 rides/hours she get the full detail with wash, filter, oil and oil filter. 
 

Only time I am changing that filter is if water got on it or it’s been sitting in the bike for more than 2 months. 

1
1
lumpy790
Posts
11872
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
10/4/2023 7:04am

IMG 9619

MaxPower
Posts
2703
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
10/4/2023 11:15am

Was this a serious question? 

2
10/5/2023 1:21pm

mine look worse than that when they're freshly installed..

2
c0ncEpT
Posts
1320
Joined
5/13/2015
Location
Harrison Twp., MI, USA
10/5/2023 1:49pm

My 2016 YZ250F would be absolutely caked after 1 ride at a sandy track or a dusty trail.

 

The filter shown looks damn near new.

Sandusky26
Posts
3552
Joined
7/28/2021
Location
Eastern, NC, USA
10/7/2023 10:06am

IMG 20231007 112341542 HDR

2
ToolMaker
Posts
10513
Joined
11/19/2011
Location
Escondido, CA, USA
10/7/2023 11:41am

As I understand it, the filter goes through stages.

Well oiled, the sticky of the oil keeps the fine dirt from passing. If the oil's fresh, it migrates through the debris catching more debris on top of debris. Eventually, the debris coating the filter does not collect more debris from adhesion but the holes between the debris get so small, the actual debris becomes the filter. Eventually the oil becomes so dry added with vibration, debris starts to break off and go into the engine creating holes where new debris just passes into the intake as well.

Post a reply to: Would you change this air filter?

The Latest