Eli out at Yamaha?

kevin204
Posts
4153
Joined
12/29/2006
Location
Kawartha Lakes, ON CA
Fantasy
4/16/2025 9:41pm
KurtJ99 wrote:
Reed did a fantastic job at Two-Two racing in what many, myself included, thought was a fools errand. He was in the hunt in supercross and...

Reed did a fantastic job at Two-Two racing in what many, myself included, thought was a fools errand. He was in the hunt in supercross and MX (red-plate I think?) until that famous crash at Spring Creek. 

Not sure if Tomac has the desire to setup a similar program for a single year (at a time?), but I don't see him as not being competitive on his own program. He could get the right people around him like Reed did and not be limited by his team support. 

Reed had that 2011 450MX title on lock until the crash at Millville. He had the red plate the whole series and a decently comfortable lead and appeared to have Dungey and RV covered in speed more often than not.. probably the best he ever looked, honestly. 

Also, I’m obviously not super knowledgeable about it or I wouldn’t be asking.. but is it not possible to swap a bike from a hydraulic clutch to a cable clutch? It’s pretty easy to swap the other way. 

22
1
toomanykaws
Posts
508
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Henderson, NV US
4/16/2025 9:45pm
Seems kind of strange that Yamaha and Monster can’t put the money together to keep him. Hasn’t Roger said before he always wished he could have got ET3 on his team? Maybe it could be the time.
10
1
4/16/2025 9:45pm
KurtJ99 wrote:
Reed did a fantastic job at Two-Two racing in what many, myself included, thought was a fools errand. He was in the hunt in supercross and...

Reed did a fantastic job at Two-Two racing in what many, myself included, thought was a fools errand. He was in the hunt in supercross and MX (red-plate I think?) until that famous crash at Spring Creek. 

Not sure if Tomac has the desire to setup a similar program for a single year (at a time?), but I don't see him as not being competitive on his own program. He could get the right people around him like Reed did and not be limited by his team support. 

kevin204 wrote:
Reed had that 2011 450MX title on lock until the crash at Millville. He had the red plate the whole series and a decently comfortable lead...

Reed had that 2011 450MX title on lock until the crash at Millville. He had the red plate the whole series and a decently comfortable lead and appeared to have Dungey and RV covered in speed more often than not.. probably the best he ever looked, honestly. 

Also, I’m obviously not super knowledgeable about it or I wouldn’t be asking.. but is it not possible to swap a bike from a hydraulic clutch to a cable clutch? It’s pretty easy to swap the other way. 

It would take some work to change to a cable clutch, modifying the left side crankcase, but it could be done..

2
6
CPR
Posts
6688
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
4/16/2025 9:53pm
KurtJ99 wrote:
Reed did a fantastic job at Two-Two racing in what many, myself included, thought was a fools errand. He was in the hunt in supercross and...

Reed did a fantastic job at Two-Two racing in what many, myself included, thought was a fools errand. He was in the hunt in supercross and MX (red-plate I think?) until that famous crash at Spring Creek. 

Not sure if Tomac has the desire to setup a similar program for a single year (at a time?), but I don't see him as not being competitive on his own program. He could get the right people around him like Reed did and not be limited by his team support. 

kevin204 wrote:
Reed had that 2011 450MX title on lock until the crash at Millville. He had the red plate the whole series and a decently comfortable lead...

Reed had that 2011 450MX title on lock until the crash at Millville. He had the red plate the whole series and a decently comfortable lead and appeared to have Dungey and RV covered in speed more often than not.. probably the best he ever looked, honestly. 

Also, I’m obviously not super knowledgeable about it or I wouldn’t be asking.. but is it not possible to swap a bike from a hydraulic clutch to a cable clutch? It’s pretty easy to swap the other way. 

It would take some work to change to a cable clutch, modifying the left side crankcase, but it could be done..

Sounds like a job someone like Roger would enjoy.

12

The Shop

ando
Posts
4181
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth AU
4/16/2025 10:11pm
Call me crazy but Eli has far more ROI than either  Deegan or Cooper. He’s faster and far more proven than either of them, he has...

Call me crazy but Eli has far more ROI than either  Deegan or Cooper. He’s faster and far more proven than either of them, he has more titles than both them combined. Don’t get me wrong, Cooper is damn good close in sx but I’d still give the nod to Eli and he’s not even in the same league outdoors. No doubt deegs will shred the 450 but imo Eli beats him next 2 years easy. He also far more popular than Cooper and although he has less social media that Deegan, he’s universally liked. I doubt there’s a single person that says they hate Eli or would choose to not buy a product he endorses but that cannot be said for Deegan. IMO star is making an extremely stupid move if they choose those two over Eli.

ROI also takes into account the initial investment; Eli probably has more overall star power than the other two but is it worth what he’s asking?

He’s also clearly at the back end of his career, he hasn’t finished a full series since 2022 MX.  People paying the bills will be scrutinising those things.

10
1
truck
Posts
3596
Joined
6/10/2015
Location
Louisville, KY US
Fantasy
4/16/2025 11:06pm

Not sure there's a better match from a personality standpoint than Roger and John and Eli Tomac. The ultimate "get off my lawn" lineup that might just be crazy enough to work. Would love to see it. 

25
1
4/17/2025 12:26am

                   I believe, assuming that Eli and Yamaha cannot come to an agreement, that Eli calls it a career.  Would like to see him on a Duck, but setting up a new bike , with little data, sounds like a bit more than he wants at this point in his life.

7
1
LP31
Posts
318
Joined
1/10/2024
Location
Noosa, QLD AU
4/17/2025 12:27am
mtbkris2 wrote:

KTM would be the nail in the coffin for his career imo. I just don’t see the ktm suiting the bull dog riding style 

Have you seen Herlings ride…

46
1
4/17/2025 1:16am
                   I believe, assuming that Eli and Yamaha cannot come to an agreement, that Eli calls it a...

                   I believe, assuming that Eli and Yamaha cannot come to an agreement, that Eli calls it a career.  Would like to see him on a Duck, but setting up a new bike , with little data, sounds like a bit more than he wants at this point in his life.

Eli Watson to race. If he goes for another two years regardless of which team it will mean a good bunch more millions in the bank account.

3
2
LP31
Posts
318
Joined
1/10/2024
Location
Noosa, QLD AU
4/17/2025 1:24am

I can see Redbull KTM working out, why would you risk the Ducati.

Rev the Ducati to the moon and it locks up on a jump etc

Eli has had a few tough years through injury and most likely would of had 2 more SX titles in 23 and 25.

1
4
Goon645
Posts
358
Joined
10/3/2019
Location
Pyramid Valley AQ
Fantasy
4/17/2025 1:34am

Dang the full circle move would be so sick. I mean it’s 100% not happening but imagine. IMG 3849 0

29
Pop Shmoke
Posts
1798
Joined
6/17/2020
Location
Boston, MA US
4/17/2025 1:45am

I cant remember who it was but they mentioned that technically star has paid eli a lot of money 2 years in a row for him to be out with injury not racing, so maybe that helps make up the difference for him taking less going fwd. Maybe not, but hes made a lot of money. 

2
3
cwel11
Posts
2601
Joined
12/4/2019
Location
Orangeville, PA US
4/17/2025 2:45am

IDC if he’s on a Tao Tao as long as he’s still out there blowing up berms. 

34
2
Spoonguy
Posts
3433
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA US
4/17/2025 4:04am

How bad ass would it be to have Tomac on a Ducati, Triumph. Looking at Bloss and Oldenberg's results a Beta for that matter.

3
2
PRM31
Posts
3522
Joined
8/7/2009
Location
Northern, VA US
Fantasy
4/17/2025 4:11am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2025 4:14am

Somewhere I thought I read Ducati was not going to be ready for ‘26 SX. Any TLD insiders have an update on that? I’ll bet Ciabatti is looking into whether it could work. As long as Eli isn’t demanding stupid money, they can make it work. Monster Ducati. What better way to sell more Ducatis! Probably pretty set on using Showa though. KTM would be, dare I say, more ready to race as a team and bike. We know they will use KYB if they have to.

2
1
wrc777
Posts
3157
Joined
5/21/2020
Location
Greenwood, IN US
Fantasy
4/17/2025 4:19am

The destroyer of clutches needs to be on a bike with a known good clutch system. That rules out the Ducati and Triumph for now.

KTM has a new bike coming for next SX season. I am sure it will not have a cable clutch, but it will have the most durable clutch system in the series. It is also rumored to have more comfort like the 19-22 bike. The smooth KTM engine character might be the biggest problem for Tomac. They make a lot of power it just doesn't feel like it compared to the Yamaha.

2
3
EAmato88
Posts
584
Joined
1/23/2019
Location
Egg Harbor City, NJ US
4/17/2025 4:20am
mtbkris2 wrote:

KTM would be the nail in the coffin for his career imo. I just don’t see the ktm suiting the bull dog riding style 

LP31 wrote:

Have you seen Herlings ride…

Yeah, weve seen him ride. Have you seen him crash? Theres no way Tomac goes to the orange shit box

5
24
Three7one
Posts
32
Joined
10/17/2019
Location
Powhatan, VA US
4/17/2025 4:33am

The powerhouse team kawasaki of Tomac and sexton would be mind blowing…

6
5
Bearuno
Posts
5277
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
4/17/2025 4:53am

It would take some work to change to a cable clutch, modifying the left side crankcase, but it could be done..

Not really, L2S.

Though, it is Very dependent on the particular bike, And the room / area left by the Slave Cylinder mount area. Most, if not All, the Slave Cylinders on MXers / Dirt Bikes, are situated between the Ignition cover, and the Countershaft Sprocket and Chain. It's a tight area, but, in most case, not insurmountable

It just a matter of  a new end plate  / housing / lever set up, working on the Clutch Shaft Inner Rod - be it a pure  push rod, or rack and pinion set up, so to speak. 

I tried to find the picture of Joel Smets' Cable Clutch he ran on his first KTMs for a while, but I'm buggered if I can find the file I put it in - Logically it would (also) be in the KTM one, but, at times, I'm thoroughly Illogical.  Hang on - I found it - well, one of the pics - there were others with a more machined aluminium finish / look to them: Joel Smets Cable Clutch set up on his early KTMs  jpg

Someone in Europe, sold such a kit for a while.

14
AMetts
Posts
1163
Joined
6/15/2022
Location
Lincolnton, NC US
4/17/2025 5:05am

I thought a while back when they mentioned this that Yamaha would have all the leverage in this contract talk, they know he only wants to race a couple more years and they know he doesn't want to help develop a new bike or even test a ton on a bike he hasn't been on yet. 

My bet is he maybe takes a big bonus heavy contract if they offer or maybe goes to KTM, its not a cable clutch but its probably the most durable and best clutch design of the OEMs. 

1
MOTO13
Posts
521
Joined
12/22/2017
Location
Elkhorn, WI US
4/17/2025 5:10am

Eli is still under the Star Yamaha tent for the '25 Nationals...correct?

5
4/17/2025 5:14am

He needs a cable clutch 

Eli to ClubMX, stamp it

I like ClubMX but I hope that doesn’t happen. That bike isn’t good enough for Tomac. This is a bummer situation for Eli. It sucks if he decides to just walk away.

3
6
TAUTOG
Posts
1604
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA US
4/17/2025 5:15am

I really find it hard to believe Monster and Yamaha can't find the money. They found it for Craig lol

29
4/17/2025 5:18am
MOTO13 wrote:

Eli is still under the Star Yamaha tent for the '25 Nationals...correct?

Yes

1
4/17/2025 5:31am

Not to put this all on Eli because we have no clue what's he's asking for in a contract and we have no clue what Star is offering. But should he just take a lot less money and, like Ametts said above, have it be very bonus heavy? Essentially bet on himself because really he's not coming back for money right? He wants one more real shot at a title and he truly believes he can win. Star has to be the best place for him to accomplish that. It's easy for a nobody like me to tell Eli Tomac to take less money thoug

22
1
4/17/2025 5:42am
Matty B reported talks between Eli and Yamaha aren't going well. Seems he's not in the budget with them signing Webb and Deegan. It's in Matt's...

Matty B reported talks between Eli and Yamaha aren't going well. Seems he's not in the budget with them signing Webb and Deegan. It's in Matt's latest YouTube vid. Mathes was tweeting similar things. I guess Star doesn't have a bottomless pit of money. Where could Eli end up? 

Who is Matty B?  I listen to a ton of moto podcasts, but I’ve never heard of that.

2
10
MOTO13
Posts
521
Joined
12/22/2017
Location
Elkhorn, WI US
4/17/2025 5:46am

IMHO, Eli would take less money to stay on a known commodity like the Star Yamaha bike. He obviously likes the bike and has had a lot of success on it. There is no way he needs the money at this point in his life. He wants another championship or two before he calls it a career and starting on a new brand is probably not in his best interest. Plus, what happens if Haiden doesn't gel with the 450 class or gets hurt? Star can't be stupid enough to just send Eli packing. He's one of the greatest ever and his riding has been nothing short of great. It's not like he's slowed down at all. I am stunned that Star would even consider letting Eli go.

10
5
twotwosix
Posts
2222
Joined
9/29/2016
Location
TN US
4/17/2025 5:51am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2025 5:51am

If Eli is smart, he will find a way to stay on a Yamaha, unless he truly plans on putting in another 2-3 years. He has that bike where he wants it and he can win on it currently. If he switches brands and can't gel with the new bike, the end of his career may look much different than it does right now. He doesn't need to be switching brands for just one more full season. 

6
2
kijen
Posts
1214
Joined
10/1/2010
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
4/17/2025 5:51am

Maybe talk to a college, Alabama or Georgia, get Yamaha to start a College SX/MX team, he could make millions on NIL. Kidding of course, just crazy all the money out there for stick and ball sports. 

1
twotwosix
Posts
2222
Joined
9/29/2016
Location
TN US
4/17/2025 5:54am
I like ClubMX but I hope that doesn’t happen. That bike isn’t good enough for Tomac. This is a bummer situation for Eli. It sucks if...

I like ClubMX but I hope that doesn’t happen. That bike isn’t good enough for Tomac. This is a bummer situation for Eli. It sucks if he decides to just walk away.

The Club bike is plenty fine. Phil put it in the top 10 in the 450 Nationals and Shock has podiumed with it in 250 SX. 

6
6

Post a reply to: Eli out at Yamaha?

The Latest