SMX playoff rnd 1 track

aeffertz
Posts
12661
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
9/4/2023 10:07pm
It doesn't matter whether a "fast section" or not. What is different is that there are head on collisions with walls right there on every section...

It doesn't matter whether a "fast section" or not. What is different is that there are head on collisions with walls right there on every section of the infield. 

aeffertz wrote:
Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than...

Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than crossing over a barrier mid rhythm section in 3rd. I’m sorry but I’m failing to see what’s inherently more dangerous on this vs. any other SX track. 

What gear would you prefer to be accelerating into that wall with?

I’d rather hit a stationary object at a lower speed than a higher speed if I had the choice. What kind of question is that? Grinning

1
5
9/4/2023 10:10pm
aeffertz wrote:
Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than...

Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than crossing over a barrier mid rhythm section in 3rd. I’m sorry but I’m failing to see what’s inherently more dangerous on this vs. any other SX track. 

What gear would you prefer to be accelerating into that wall with?

aeffertz wrote:

I’d rather hit a stationary object at a lower speed than a higher speed if I had the choice. What kind of question is that? Grinning

The type of question that is necessary when they build shit like this. And your best defense seems to be that certain other tracks also have inadequate runout. Yes, those are dangerously designed, too. But this one is even worse.

2
aeffertz
Posts
12661
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
9/4/2023 10:10pm

SX isn't held in a wide open field. There's always going to be stationary shit you can crash into. 

1
3
9/4/2023 10:11pm
aeffertz wrote:

SX isn't held in a wide open field. There's always going to be stationary shit you can crash into. 

This is mostly stationary shit. The odds get worse.

The Shop

9/4/2023 10:14pm
It doesn't matter whether a "fast section" or not. What is different is that there are head on collisions with walls right there on every section...

It doesn't matter whether a "fast section" or not. What is different is that there are head on collisions with walls right there on every section of the infield. 

aeffertz wrote:
Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than...

Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than crossing over a barrier mid rhythm section in 3rd. I’m sorry but I’m failing to see what’s inherently more dangerous on this vs. any other SX track. 

What gear would you prefer to be accelerating into that wall with?

Well generally speaking higher gear=higher speed and lower gear=lower speed and since I would rather hit the wall at a lower speed I would like to be in first gear. 

aeffertz
Posts
12661
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
9/4/2023 10:15pm
aeffertz wrote:

SX isn't held in a wide open field. There's always going to be stationary shit you can crash into. 

This is mostly stationary shit. The odds get worse.

We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is the most dangerous aspect of SX.I'm not entirely sure where the super scary head on collision could happen here vs any other SX round that is run right up next to the sidelines/stands.
image-20230905001235-1

3
2
9/4/2023 10:15pm
aeffertz wrote:
Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than...

Well I completely disagree. I think if you’re coming out a corner in first gear going over one of the barriers is a bit different than crossing over a barrier mid rhythm section in 3rd. I’m sorry but I’m failing to see what’s inherently more dangerous on this vs. any other SX track. 

What gear would you prefer to be accelerating into that wall with?

Mutty39 wrote:
Well generally speaking higher gear=higher speed and lower gear=lower speed and since I would rather hit the wall at a lower speed I would like to...

Well generally speaking higher gear=higher speed and lower gear=lower speed and since I would rather hit the wall at a lower speed I would like to be in first gear. 

Let me present a different scenario: build the track where there aren't walls.

12
1
9/4/2023 10:18pm
aeffertz wrote:

SX isn't held in a wide open field. There's always going to be stationary shit you can crash into. 

This is mostly stationary shit. The odds get worse.

aeffertz wrote:
We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is...

We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is the most dangerous aspect of SX.I'm not entirely sure where the super scary head on collision could happen here vs any other SX round that is run right up next to the sidelines/stands.
image-20230905001235-1

You picked the one 180 in the whole pic. There's multiple places to get pushed while on the gas. 

Reality: Riders will think this thing is sketch as shit (and so would you if you raced it). But, they will race it, and hopefully the odds will play out in their favor. If this was every week, there would be an issue at some point.

aeffertz
Posts
12661
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
9/4/2023 10:29pm Edited Date/Time 9/4/2023 10:29pm

This is mostly stationary shit. The odds get worse.

aeffertz wrote:
We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is...

We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is the most dangerous aspect of SX.I'm not entirely sure where the super scary head on collision could happen here vs any other SX round that is run right up next to the sidelines/stands.
image-20230905001235-1

You picked the one 180 in the whole pic. There's multiple places to get pushed while on the gas.  Reality: Riders will think this thing is...

You picked the one 180 in the whole pic. There's multiple places to get pushed while on the gas. 

Reality: Riders will think this thing is sketch as shit (and so would you if you raced it). But, they will race it, and hopefully the odds will play out in their favor. If this was every week, there would be an issue at some point.

I didn't cherry pick but you are starting to see my point in how they designed the track and how/where they cross those barriers. If you look at the sections, you can see the odds of a high speed head on collision is pretty slim, even in the early stages of the track being built.

image-20230905002150-1

image-20230905002514-2

image-20230905002748-4

9/4/2023 10:32pm
aeffertz wrote:
We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is...

We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is the most dangerous aspect of SX.I'm not entirely sure where the super scary head on collision could happen here vs any other SX round that is run right up next to the sidelines/stands.
image-20230905001235-1

You picked the one 180 in the whole pic. There's multiple places to get pushed while on the gas.  Reality: Riders will think this thing is...

You picked the one 180 in the whole pic. There's multiple places to get pushed while on the gas. 

Reality: Riders will think this thing is sketch as shit (and so would you if you raced it). But, they will race it, and hopefully the odds will play out in their favor. If this was every week, there would be an issue at some point.

aeffertz wrote:
I didn't cherry pick but you are starting to see my point in how they designed the track and how/where they cross those barriers. If you...

I didn't cherry pick but you are starting to see my point in how they designed the track and how/where they cross those barriers. If you look at the sections, you can see the odds of a high speed head on collision is pretty slim, even in the early stages of the track being built.

image-20230905002150-1

image-20230905002514-2

image-20230905002748-4

OP's post shows five or more crossings over multiple lanes perpendicular to walls, while you are only posting the 180s parallel. 

TDeath21
Posts
6515
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO, USA
9/4/2023 10:39pm
Dave v3.0 wrote:

I thought this was supposed to be a hybrid supercross/motocross track.  Where's the motocross portion?  Elevation changes, natural terrrain, off cambers?

Anytime they ever say hybrid, they just mean a longer SX track with higher speeds. Similar to Atlanta Motor Speedway SX races. 0 MX ever involved. Not really even sure why they try to say that.

11
1
CPR
Posts
7004
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
9/5/2023 1:44am

I was hoping to see something exciting and new in the SMX tracks. I don’t see it here, although round 3 looks more promising.
Either way, let’s just hope it delivers good racing. We won’t care if it does.

4
1
64smoker
Posts
525
Joined
2/7/2023
Location
Ramsgate, GB
9/5/2023 3:56am

Looks like a piss poor version of the monster cup 

6
2
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
9/5/2023 4:12am Edited Date/Time 9/7/2023 1:51pm

Still hopeful for good racing, I'm sure it'll be good to watch, but I stand by the previous sketchy statement.

I wasn't thinking so much head on more as in general impact or getting spat off the side of a jump or landing in a g out and getting wonky and firing yourself into a concrete barrier. The same happens with tuff blocks or hay bales, but at least those have some give and movement.

Either way, I just hope the racing is good, and these folks get a good pay day, and the barriers get the previously-mentioned thin layer of monster energy vinyl padding, rather than one of the barriers getting thinly padded with a splattered monster energy athlete.

5
Buckland
Posts
375
Joined
1/23/2017
Location
USA
9/5/2023 4:27am
aeffertz wrote:
I’m not entirely sure why everyone is so pressed over the barriers? The layout seems to make it when you cross over them that it’s a...

I’m not entirely sure why everyone is so pressed over the barriers? The layout seems to make it when you cross over them that it’s a low speed section. No different than hitting whoops or a quad running along the sidelines of a stadium. Track is shaping up nicely. 

I'm hoping for the best and no issues, but the walls run parallel to the lanes along rhythm sections. How often do riders land on tough blocks or get pushed off line and have to bail into the gap between lanes? Inserting a concrete barrier into that space doesn't seem like a safe idea.

The corners indicate to me that the track designer considered the walls, and their solution to the problem was "slower speed crossovers." Beyond that they can claim they tried their best to work with what they were given, which is crap (like Ricky's Daytona sprinkler excuses).

9
wrc777
Posts
3215
Joined
5/21/2020
Location
Greenwood, IN, USA
Fantasy
9/5/2023 5:30am
aeffertz wrote:
We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is...

We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is the most dangerous aspect of SX.I'm not entirely sure where the super scary head on collision could happen here vs any other SX round that is run right up next to the sidelines/stands.
image-20230905001235-1

We will see where the netting and extra padding wind up, but you really can't see someone getting launched off that berm and hitting their head on a concrete barrier? There is a picture of a triple running between two concrete barriers. You can't see someone getting messed up on the launch and smacking their head (or body) on the concrete? As someone else said it is about where tuff blocks usually are and those get hit all the time. I can totally see someone landing on a tough block and getting high sided right onto the concrete barriers.

5
1
lumpy790
Posts
11646
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
9/5/2023 5:56am

What if ….. someone say like top in points Sexton after putting in a great hot lap messes up and runs off the side of the track and nails one of these barriers and trashes the bikes frame?

Sorry Chase since the registered bike can not compete … your out .

The USGP was supposed to be built just like this. Could it be that the FIM looked at this and said no? Thats why it was built on the dirt track?

RacerX has a list but where’s the cut off?

https://racerxonline.com/smx/2023/points/450smx

 

IMG 9511.jpeg?VersionId=XO8sGzitcE3puAOEoog74v6

2
hasko158
Posts
874
Joined
8/14/2010
Location
Charlotte, NC, USA
9/5/2023 5:56am
aeffertz wrote:

SX isn't held in a wide open field. There's always going to be stationary shit you can crash into. 

This is mostly stationary shit. The odds get worse.

aeffertz wrote:
We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is...

We're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I'm all about saftey but I personally don't see how them going over those barriers like this is the most dangerous aspect of SX.I'm not entirely sure where the super scary head on collision could happen here vs any other SX round that is run right up next to the sidelines/stands.
image-20230905001235-1

Its more about it lining the sides of the track, most crashes involve a rider flying off the side. The track looks really narrow and going to be one line. 

1
davis224
Posts
7513
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL, USA
Fantasy
9/5/2023 6:12am

I'm more worried about ruts going down to the top of the barriers and developing a nasty kicker than someone running into the barrier.

3
truck
Posts
3858
Joined
6/10/2015
Location
Louisville, KY, USA
Fantasy
9/5/2023 7:02am

Steps to mitigate the danger and building jumps over all the walls doesn't change the fact that it's just a bad idea to begin with. 

Get ready for constant red flags as well. There's no access to most of the track without crossing the track. 

1
prozach
Posts
1304
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Eureka, CA, USA
9/5/2023 7:16am

Positive, way less chance of a head on collision with someone going the other way in the lane next to you.   Also, less chance of riders going off track and gaining an advantage. 🤷‍♀️ 

2
731chopper
Posts
4227
Joined
1/2/2015
Location
DFW, TX, USA
9/5/2023 7:17am

Seems like a very odd location. I would’ve preferred the dirt track like MXGP did but I’m trying to reserve too much judgement until seeing how this track races. 

1
9/5/2023 7:29am Edited Date/Time 9/5/2023 10:03am
Richy wrote:
Still hopeful for good racing, I'm sure it'll be good to watch, but I stand by the previous sketchy statement. I wasn't thinking so much head...

Still hopeful for good racing, I'm sure it'll be good to watch, but I stand by the previous sketchy statement.

I wasn't thinking so much head on more as in general impact or getting spat off the side of a jump or landing in a g out and getting wonky and firing yourself into a concrete barrier. The same happens with tuff blocks or hay bales, but at least those have some give and movement.

Either way, I just hope the racing is good, and these folks get a good pay day, and the barriers get the previously-mentioned thin layer of monster energy vinyl padding, rather than one of the barriers getting thinly padded with a splattered monster energy athlete.

There's a bunch of ouchie stuff on all portions off-track. It is easy to imagine many dangerous scenarios. Other motorsports have spent decades increasing runoff in high traffic zones and removing unintentional targets. Example: this facility has those lanes purely to increase the safety of its events in an off-track situation.

Obviously, a track designer would try to mitigate those issues, and hope the probabilities hold up such that nothing unfortunate occurs this time, but clearly this location places much of its weight on that hope.

3
9/5/2023 8:55am

I honestly can't believe they're going to Chicago for the 2nd round. And the south side for that matter... facepalm. No one but Wheelie Boyz live there.

5
aeffertz
Posts
12661
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
9/5/2023 9:52am
 

 

gt757
Posts
299
Joined
12/28/2011
Location
MX
9/5/2023 9:52am

The barriers didn't seem like a big problem back in the day

 

 

3
garasaki
Posts
208
Joined
1/20/2021
Location
Mount Vernon, IA, USA
9/5/2023 9:56am

There was a local race here at a dirt track facility that had a couple ponds.  When I saw the initial pics, I thought "yep someone is going to end up in the drink".  I took a close look at the track layout and decided "enh, looks like it'd be pretty hard to end up there.  They obviously designed the layout to minimize the risk."  

Sure enough, on race day, someone had to fish a bike out of the pond.  A nice one too.  And it entered from a straight that had those same concrete barriers up between the track and the pond. 

It's real difficult to predict where a bike or rider is going to end up in the case of an accident.  These barriers seem like a real bad idea.

3
3
JBlain619
Posts
1846
Joined
6/10/2010
Location
Severna Park, MD, USA
9/5/2023 9:57am Edited Date/Time 9/5/2023 9:57am
lumpy790 wrote:
What if ….. someone say like top in points Sexton after putting in a great hot lap messes up and runs off the side of the...

What if ….. someone say like top in points Sexton after putting in a great hot lap messes up and runs off the side of the track and nails one of these barriers and trashes the bikes frame?

Sorry Chase since the registered bike can not compete … your out .

The USGP was supposed to be built just like this. Could it be that the FIM looked at this and said no? Thats why it was built on the dirt track?

RacerX has a list but where’s the cut off?

https://racerxonline.com/smx/2023/points/450smx

 

IMG 9511.jpeg?VersionId=XO8sGzitcE3puAOEoog74v6

They tech multiple frames. Seth had to have one replaced at Ironman after the first moto. I have pics of the first frame and the culprit LOL.

 

revkev151
Posts
113
Joined
1/4/2023
Location
Orange, CA, USA
9/5/2023 10:00am
Rosso391 wrote:
I honestly can't believe they're going to Chicago for the 2nd round. And the south side for that matter... facepalm. No one but Wheelie Boyz live...

I honestly can't believe they're going to Chicago for the 2nd round. And the south side for that matter... facepalm. No one but Wheelie Boyz live there.

Joliet is not exactly "south side of Chicago"

2
-MAVERICK-
Posts
67073
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario, CA
9/5/2023 11:05am

Post a reply to: SMX playoff rnd 1 track

The Latest