Herlings

Flatliner
Posts
4062
Joined
11/3/2009
Location
CA
6/11/2023 2:07pm
Idp57 wrote:

How do you know?

mxxxeR1 wrote:

Because he's not amercan

Mxracer06y wrote:
More like because its the same story, year after year after year. There's a reason why guys like tomac, dungey, webb, RC.. etc go their entire...

More like because its the same story, year after year after year.

There's a reason why guys like tomac, dungey, webb, RC.. etc go their entire careers with few hard crashes, and very few injuries(the tomac heel thing is a fluke, since it wasnt rider error / crash) These guys know when to push and when to back off and live to fight another day. You can't win them all

and there's a reason why guys like herlings can't make a single year without crashing out and hurting themselves. How many years has herlings raced 450's? How many of those years has he been injured, or crashed out?

It's not coincidence. When you ride over your limit or on the razors edge of that limit ALL the time you're eventually going to crash. Stewart is another one. These guys are blazzingly fast but it comes at a cost... Do you want to be known as the fastest guy that crashes all the time? or the guy who brings home world titles? He really needs to evaluate this

Really not hard to predict he would crash himself out and get hurt. I just didn't think it would happen this quickly

RC crashed his brains out in 99' ,  missed time, and came into 2000 fresh off a broken collar bone.  RD broke his neck.

 

Sometimes things happen.

 

The man has the most gp wins in history, and in my opinion is still the fastest mx racer on the planet right now.  went 1-1- at ironman on a bike different than what he was used to.  Think anyone right now in the states would win lommel?  450 or 250 class?  I don't.

10
14
6/11/2023 2:18pm
mxxxeR1 wrote:

Because he's not amercan

Mxracer06y wrote:
More like because its the same story, year after year after year. There's a reason why guys like tomac, dungey, webb, RC.. etc go their entire...

More like because its the same story, year after year after year.

There's a reason why guys like tomac, dungey, webb, RC.. etc go their entire careers with few hard crashes, and very few injuries(the tomac heel thing is a fluke, since it wasnt rider error / crash) These guys know when to push and when to back off and live to fight another day. You can't win them all

and there's a reason why guys like herlings can't make a single year without crashing out and hurting themselves. How many years has herlings raced 450's? How many of those years has he been injured, or crashed out?

It's not coincidence. When you ride over your limit or on the razors edge of that limit ALL the time you're eventually going to crash. Stewart is another one. These guys are blazzingly fast but it comes at a cost... Do you want to be known as the fastest guy that crashes all the time? or the guy who brings home world titles? He really needs to evaluate this

Really not hard to predict he would crash himself out and get hurt. I just didn't think it would happen this quickly

Flatliner wrote:
RC crashed his brains out in 99' ,  missed time, and came into 2000 fresh off a broken collar bone.  RD broke his neck.   Sometimes...

RC crashed his brains out in 99' ,  missed time, and came into 2000 fresh off a broken collar bone.  RD broke his neck.

 

Sometimes things happen.

 

The man has the most gp wins in history, and in my opinion is still the fastest mx racer on the planet right now.  went 1-1- at ironman on a bike different than what he was used to.  Think anyone right now in the states would win lommel?  450 or 250 class?  I don't.

Cmon RC and Dunge? Yes, sometimes things happen. But using RC and Dunge to make your point? They were nearly bulletproof. RC never missed an outdoor season. And Dungey missed just one I believe. Sometimes things happen. But when they happen over and over, it's called a pattern 

11
6/11/2023 2:55pm
mattyhamz2 wrote:
Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.   With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go...

Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.

 

With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go the harder you hit the ground. He doesn’t need to go 100% to win. Perfect example is Jett. Jett gets to the lead pulls out a bit and maintains that instead of going balls out trying to win by a huge margin. If JH did more of that, he’d have more wins and more titles. 

segers wrote:

He was by no means balls to the wall this season 😉

I know he’s still building back from his injury and I really haven’t watched much GP this year, more so just highlights so I can’t exactly speak for this year, but I’ve can’t really remember JH maintaining a 5-10 second lead and bringing it home like that. I always think of him as riding hard from start to finish. But I’ve been wrong before and I’ll be wrong again. 

6/11/2023 3:07pm
mattyhamz2 wrote:
Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.   With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go...

Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.

 

With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go the harder you hit the ground. He doesn’t need to go 100% to win. Perfect example is Jett. Jett gets to the lead pulls out a bit and maintains that instead of going balls out trying to win by a huge margin. If JH did more of that, he’d have more wins and more titles. 

Oh yeah. Be as fast as Jett Lawrence. Why don't all the pros do that? Just... be two seconds a lap faster than everyone else.

I think you may have misread what I was saying. JH usually has quite a bit more speed than the guys he’s racing. I’m not saying be as fast as Jett. Hell, I’m not even a Jett fan and if you look through my post history you’ll see that. I’m saying he’s faster than his competition and I don’t believe JH has to ride at 100% to beat Prado, Seewer, Coldehoff or any others.
 

Lars was on a podcast talking about Jett during supercross and how he works to get to the front and maintain a small lead rather than try to win by a huge margin since winning by 5-10 seconds is no different than winning by 30 seconds. JH can do the exact same thing in my eyes.

2

The Shop

jeffro503
Posts
27629
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR US
6/11/2023 3:14pm
cjg23307 wrote:

Knew it was only a matter of time. Over 60% of wins in the 250 class, guys good but he isn’t what everyone thinks he is. 

Except he is " That good".  He can have days on an MX track , that out of 8 billion people on this planet....not one of them could beat him. 

He hauls ass in on a bike , and when he goes down , he goes down hard. The dude puts everything into trying to win. If you or anyone tries to diminish that , than either you're clueless , or just plain stupid. 

25
2
6/11/2023 3:15pm

Please, if you have to squabble about who's faster, leave Jett out of it.

The fight if I recall, has always been between the USA and the Euros.

4
3
Flatliner
Posts
4062
Joined
11/3/2009
Location
CA
6/11/2023 3:25pm
Cmon RC and Dunge? Yes, sometimes things happen. But using RC and Dunge to make your point? They were nearly bulletproof. RC never missed an outdoor...

Cmon RC and Dunge? Yes, sometimes things happen. But using RC and Dunge to make your point? They were nearly bulletproof. RC never missed an outdoor season. And Dungey missed just one I believe. Sometimes things happen. But when they happen over and over, it's called a pattern 

Its a stretch ill admit. but several of RC's greatest wrecks could have been serious injuries too, an element of luck was definitely at play.

 

Some guys I suppose are just more injury prone. I stand by what I said regarding his speed though.. I think him, and jago are the fastest guys in their respective classes.

1
2
cjg23307
Posts
469
Joined
1/3/2009
Location
Savage, MD US
6/11/2023 4:39pm
cjg23307 wrote:

Knew it was only a matter of time. Over 60% of wins in the 250 class, guys good but he isn’t what everyone thinks he is. 

jeffro503 wrote:
Except he is " That good".  He can have days on an MX track , that out of 8 billion people on this planet....not one of...

Except he is " That good".  He can have days on an MX track , that out of 8 billion people on this planet....not one of them could beat him. 

He hauls ass in on a bike , and when he goes down , he goes down hard. The dude puts everything into trying to win. If you or anyone tries to diminish that , than either you're clueless , or just plain stupid. 

Never once stated he was a bad rider. He can ride the wheels off a bike. Just personally for me he’s not a favorite. Also don’t like his attitude…. I know he’s a fan favorite just not mine. 

3
1
Zycki11
Posts
7677
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
6/11/2023 4:44pm

Out is out and Prado is doing what needs to be done. Getting great starts as always, putting sprint laps in and making everyone push. Mistakes happen. It’s his to lose 

3
Falcon
Posts
12172
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
6/11/2023 4:49pm

Ducking Deegan by racing the GPs, probably a smart move 

Nobody gave you props for this fine cast, so I'll acknowledge its greatness. 

6
1
Zycki11
Posts
7677
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
6/11/2023 4:59pm

Herlings on the other hand has hit a moment that I find interesting. He had lightning speed but in his later years has not found a way to stay off the ground and at some point his speed will take a hit. 

Great dude who is brilliant in his own right and it just makes what Everts, Cairolli, RC, such a monumental achievement. To be able to stay injury free and rack up 9 and 10 titles is amazing 

4
mx313
Posts
1532
Joined
10/5/2021
Location
Brisbane City, QLD AU
6/11/2023 5:38pm
cjg23307 wrote:

Knew it was only a matter of time. Over 60% of wins in the 250 class, guys good but he isn’t what everyone thinks he is. 

JOLS95 wrote:
So? A win is a win. Should you not count 250 wins you shouldn’t count them for anyone. Everts or whatever their name is. a championship...

So? A win is a win. Should you not count 250 wins you shouldn’t count them for anyone. Everts or whatever their name is.

a championship is as good as the riders in it. He can’t help he had no competition in his later mx2 days.

 

same with Jett now, he might win this 450 title because the other guys aren’t there. Fair to say that?

The point is 450 wins should have more weight to them.

I will compare 2 riders. There could be better examples but I'm going to use.

Jeremy Martin vs Ken roczen???

Who is a better mx racer??

J-mart has 2 titles and 20 overalls (all 250)

Kenny has 2 titles and 23 overalls. But 21 of those wins are 450.

(I didn't think about mxgp before typing this which will weight to Kenny. So let's just compare ama stats)

8
agn5008
Posts
1878
Joined
3/8/2021
Location
PA, PA US
Fantasy
6/11/2023 6:41pm
cjg23307 wrote:

Knew it was only a matter of time. Over 60% of wins in the 250 class, guys good but he isn’t what everyone thinks he is. 

JOLS95 wrote:
So? A win is a win. Should you not count 250 wins you shouldn’t count them for anyone. Everts or whatever their name is. a championship...

So? A win is a win. Should you not count 250 wins you shouldn’t count them for anyone. Everts or whatever their name is.

a championship is as good as the riders in it. He can’t help he had no competition in his later mx2 days.

 

same with Jett now, he might win this 450 title because the other guys aren’t there. Fair to say that?

mx313 wrote:
The point is 450 wins should have more weight to them. I will compare 2 riders. There could be better examples but I'm going to use...

The point is 450 wins should have more weight to them.

I will compare 2 riders. There could be better examples but I'm going to use.

Jeremy Martin vs Ken roczen???

Who is a better mx racer??

J-mart has 2 titles and 20 overalls (all 250)

Kenny has 2 titles and 23 overalls. But 21 of those wins are 450.

(I didn't think about mxgp before typing this which will weight to Kenny. So let's just compare ama stats)

JMart was better on 250s in his prime. 
Roczen was better on 450s in his prime. 

1
7
6/11/2023 6:58pm
mattyhamz2 wrote:
Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.   With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go...

Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.

 

With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go the harder you hit the ground. He doesn’t need to go 100% to win. Perfect example is Jett. Jett gets to the lead pulls out a bit and maintains that instead of going balls out trying to win by a huge margin. If JH did more of that, he’d have more wins and more titles. 

This year Herlings has not tried to go balls out.

1
1
6/11/2023 8:07pm
Flatliner wrote:
Its a stretch ill admit. but several of RC's greatest wrecks could have been serious injuries too, an element of luck was definitely at play.  ...

Its a stretch ill admit. but several of RC's greatest wrecks could have been serious injuries too, an element of luck was definitely at play.

 

Some guys I suppose are just more injury prone. I stand by what I said regarding his speed though.. I think him, and jago are the fastest guys in their respective classes.

You really summed it up. I think it's really a genetic thing. Some guys just break when they crash. A crash that RC got back up after and kept going immediately would have resulted in an injury for JH

1
6/11/2023 8:40pm
mattyhamz2 wrote:
Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.   With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go...

Hope he heals up quick and gets back on a bike soon.

 

With that said, the dude is blazing fast but the faster you go the harder you hit the ground. He doesn’t need to go 100% to win. Perfect example is Jett. Jett gets to the lead pulls out a bit and maintains that instead of going balls out trying to win by a huge margin. If JH did more of that, he’d have more wins and more titles. 

Oh yeah. Be as fast as Jett Lawrence. Why don't all the pros do that? Just... be two seconds a lap faster than everyone else.

mattyhamz2 wrote:
I think you may have misread what I was saying. JH usually has quite a bit more speed than the guys he’s racing. I’m not saying...

I think you may have misread what I was saying. JH usually has quite a bit more speed than the guys he’s racing. I’m not saying be as fast as Jett. Hell, I’m not even a Jett fan and if you look through my post history you’ll see that. I’m saying he’s faster than his competition and I don’t believe JH has to ride at 100% to beat Prado, Seewer, Coldehoff or any others.
 

Lars was on a podcast talking about Jett during supercross and how he works to get to the front and maintain a small lead rather than try to win by a huge margin since winning by 5-10 seconds is no different than winning by 30 seconds. JH can do the exact same thing in my eyes.

In the race that Herlings got hurt he was 16pts down on Prado, and Prado was 1-2 seconds behind him. 16pts is a lot when you consider that Prado has had the red plate pretty much all season and pretty much hole shots every race. Herlings last injury was during a photoshoot. I think you're right about young Herlings but a big issue with him is that he's made of glass. If he had this crash whike leading by 20 seconds I'd have to agree with you but this one doesn't fit that narrative IMO.

5
TDeath21
Posts
6515
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
6/11/2023 9:12pm
mxxxeR1 wrote:

Because he's not amercan

Mxracer06y wrote:
More like because its the same story, year after year after year. There's a reason why guys like tomac, dungey, webb, RC.. etc go their entire...

More like because its the same story, year after year after year.

There's a reason why guys like tomac, dungey, webb, RC.. etc go their entire careers with few hard crashes, and very few injuries(the tomac heel thing is a fluke, since it wasnt rider error / crash) These guys know when to push and when to back off and live to fight another day. You can't win them all

and there's a reason why guys like herlings can't make a single year without crashing out and hurting themselves. How many years has herlings raced 450's? How many of those years has he been injured, or crashed out?

It's not coincidence. When you ride over your limit or on the razors edge of that limit ALL the time you're eventually going to crash. Stewart is another one. These guys are blazzingly fast but it comes at a cost... Do you want to be known as the fastest guy that crashes all the time? or the guy who brings home world titles? He really needs to evaluate this

Really not hard to predict he would crash himself out and get hurt. I just didn't think it would happen this quickly

Flatliner wrote:
RC crashed his brains out in 99' ,  missed time, and came into 2000 fresh off a broken collar bone.  RD broke his neck.   Sometimes...

RC crashed his brains out in 99' ,  missed time, and came into 2000 fresh off a broken collar bone.  RD broke his neck.

 

Sometimes things happen.

 

The man has the most gp wins in history, and in my opinion is still the fastest mx racer on the planet right now.  went 1-1- at ironman on a bike different than what he was used to.  Think anyone right now in the states would win lommel?  450 or 250 class?  I don't.

RC has admitted many times he moved up too early. SX in the premier class in only your 3rd year as a pro is a lot, especially for him pre-Aldon. He came into the 99MX season amazing as always though and stayed on the 125 there. Dungey had the one crash where he fractured his vertebrae and another in SX training. I think a collarbone there. That’s it. Has Herlings ever put 3 seasons consecutively together without missing time?

1
Aryen
Posts
846
Joined
9/1/2014
Location
Eindhoven NL
6/11/2023 10:29pm
Aryen wrote:

Broke his neck and will be out for some time. 

Paul333 wrote:

Really?

Was confirmed by Dutch Mx site Motocrossplanet. 

ayearinmx
Posts
2760
Joined
3/5/2007
Location
GB
6/11/2023 11:29pm

I honestly can't remember Jeffrey crashing out of a lead before. I'm sure it's happened, but nothing stands out... And maybe he's done it and still gone onto win the race, but to say he gets injured because he 'races' too fast is just wrong

1
Lastander
Posts
1232
Joined
10/9/2016
Location
SE
6/12/2023 12:32am Edited Date/Time 6/12/2023 12:33am
cjg23307 wrote:
My favorite rider out of both series is gasjer. Has nothing to do with being American or not. Herlings can’t even thank Ktm, he’s cocky just...

My favorite rider out of both series is gasjer. Has nothing to do with being American or not. Herlings can’t even thank Ktm, he’s cocky just not my cup of tea. 

And you cant even spell his fucking name

2
jemcee
Posts
12520
Joined
8/11/2008
Location
AU
6/12/2023 12:37am

I used to kinda roll my eyes a little when people would say he was unlucky but I don't know anymore.. The last few crashes have come from nowhere and he's copped full consequence from them..

I've joked in the past that maybe he angered the MX gods by staying in mx2 for so long to get his GP wins up.. (It is just a joke I don't mean it I don't wanna start that tired old argument again haha)

6/12/2023 1:19am Edited Date/Time 6/12/2023 3:31am

Would be great to see some respect for one of the most impressive riders of our era. Yeah, he's has some crazy misfortune, but, there's few riders out there that can inspire the fans to the level he can. Some say he's cocky, but hell, he's no damn robot, I love the fact he talks, at times, like one of us... it's great.  Some of you guys might remember JS7 being a little cocky, but also the faces he made at the end of a post race interview, priceless.  We need more of it!

Remember, a few years ago, Jeffrey was landed on, from high above. Brutal, but, even with a broken shoulder blade, WON the race.  This weekend, seems to be reported a fractured vertebrata in his neck.  He gained a championship point, over stopping to check his health.  Respect.  Anyone that says anything bad about this incredible athlete, is a fool.

Hats off to the great man, all the best for a fast and full recovery.

24
1
tek14
Posts
4890
Joined
1/26/2014
Location
Vantaa FI
6/12/2023 1:24am

Racing is better when Herlings is in. Lets hope he comes back one more time. 

4
6/12/2023 2:21am

Man what a bummer for Herlings, he can’t seem to catch a break. Seewer crashes harder than that seemingly every race and he’s always fine but for some reason whenever Jeffrey hits the ground he gets hurt. It sucks because I feel like he really never pushed all that hard this year and was mainly focused on staying healthy and being there in the end to win it.

Hoping for a speedy recovery for The Bullet

3
M.B.
Posts
97
Joined
8/19/2013
Location
LV
6/12/2023 2:57am

Can somebody translate what he said in his instagram story ? I believe about shiny weekend in germany

Paul333
Posts
2151
Joined
2/15/2012
Location
Virginia Beach, VA US
6/12/2023 2:58am

Anybody arguing Herlings doesn't ride over his head to "Dominate" and it causes crashes & injuries at many times in his career is either misinformed or paid to post. The "Bullet" nickname, and self-described "Fasted Man on the Planet" title has probably cost him a few titles. 

All his crashes...No

All his injuries...No

A sizeable portion...Obviously Yes. 

 

4
10
6/12/2023 3:09am Edited Date/Time 6/12/2023 3:10am

Some of You Americans are really ignorant, does it matter who is the healthiest or does it matter who has the best results. The man has the record most Grand Prix wins in history Has won 5 world titles has beaten all of the Americans starting from last position.. and still some talk shit now that’s funny 

10
13

Post a reply to: Herlings

The Latest