Discussion for those that have ordered a Stark Varg..everyone else go away!

#434
Posts
1912
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
DE
10/5/2022 9:15am
Magoofan wrote:
Stark CEO with all yo $$$$$. [img]https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1c/7d/91/1c7d9135b80cca59c13ee0f04201a8fc.gif[/img]
Stark CEO with all yo $$$$$.

I think he was already good when he sold his 24MX shares…
3
1
early
Posts
10109
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
10/5/2022 9:24am
Magoofan wrote:
Stark CEO with all yo $$$$$. [img]https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1c/7d/91/1c7d9135b80cca59c13ee0f04201a8fc.gif[/img]
Stark CEO with all yo $$$$$.

Lol, the $100 down payments might get him some jack and cokes and white trash hookers
4
wvumounty
Posts
382
Joined
10/2/2018
Location
Butler, PA, USA
10/5/2022 9:25am
Working tirelessly… Does everyone walk to work?


3
2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
10/5/2022 9:29am
Magoofan wrote:
Stark CEO with all yo $$$$$. [img]https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1c/7d/91/1c7d9135b80cca59c13ee0f04201a8fc.gif[/img]
Stark CEO with all yo $$$$$.

early wrote:
Lol, the $100 down payments might get him some jack and cokes and white trash hookers
You say that like it's a bad thing....
5
3

The Shop

10/5/2022 9:58am
Gary Duck wrote:
Just make sure to buy a gas-burning generator for when you don't have enough power for moto 2. That's if these things ever even make it...
Just make sure to buy a gas-burning generator for when you don't have enough power for moto 2.

That's if these things ever even make it to the showroom... Triumph, anyone???
Funny you mention this. I plunked my $100 bucks down and thought It will either never be made and/or delivered or it could come 2 years...
Funny you mention this. I plunked my $100 bucks down and thought It will either never be made and/or delivered or it could come 2 years later. It could also be delivered and at the time (when everything was selling for high dollar) I thought it could also go up in value by delivery date due to a great success and demand. Then I could flip it for money (j/k) My guess is that won't happen with the recession though. I didn't get a confirmation order from stark like the OP and other friends of mine have but I emailed support and they assured me I'm in the que and gave me an order number PT20506.
I am stoked about the advent of the electric MX bike. I own 24 acres in a neighborhood surrounded by 1 acre lots. I think I have 34 neighbors that border my property. I currently have a tiny track to putt around on when it's naturally wet but I've never invested in a water system due to the fact that if we rode our current 4 strokes frequently we would get shut down. The second I get a few of these Electric bikes I am going big and building a backyard freaking national track compete with water system 12 minutes from downtown Bend!!! With the zoning of my property it allows for off road vehicle parks. The noise issue would ensure it would never pass but with electric I may be able to pull it off. At least a couple of special events a year in a beautiful location with massive views of the Cascade mountain range. Regardless if I ever open the place up it's a game changer to just have a legit track at my house. I've got some pics of the spot from this old thread when I built my shop back in 2014 https://www.vitalmx.com/forums/Moto-Related,20/Building-the-new-Moto-garage,1278367 I'll always have ICE motorcycles but this electric revolution is opening doors for our sport and I'm stoked!!!
What zoning do you have? I think I know where you live, have many friends in drw and lived out there for many years myself.
Gary Duck
Posts
789
Joined
4/16/2019
Location
USA
10/5/2022 10:07am
Gary Duck wrote:
Just make sure to buy a gas-burning generator for when you don't have enough power for moto 2. That's if these things ever even make it...
Just make sure to buy a gas-burning generator for when you don't have enough power for moto 2.

That's if these things ever even make it to the showroom... Triumph, anyone???

1
swordfish
Posts
1950
Joined
9/2/2021
Location
Somewhere, AB, CA
10/5/2022 10:24am
luke11 wrote:
Fuck I’ve been on the babd wagon but to go from late 2022 originally to Jan 2024 is a piss take. I’d be intrested to know...
Fuck I’ve been on the babd wagon but to go from late 2022 originally to Jan 2024 is a piss take. I’d be intrested to know if they’ve genuinely been sidelined by something out of their control they were promised they’d have in time or if they were just over ambitious from the get go?
Typical over promise and under deliver using other peoples money. I bet they are paying some fat salaries.
Maybe he can use some of his 24MX money.
2
9
R VanKamp77
Posts
499
Joined
8/15/2022
Location
Portland, TN, USA
10/5/2022 10:38am
I ordered the 80hp, white, hand brake, 18 inch rear enduro. Delivery for June 2023 I always said to everyone who started annoying me about getting...
I ordered the 80hp, white, hand brake, 18 inch rear enduro. Delivery for June 2023

I always said to everyone who started annoying me about getting an E mountain bike, I am a DHiller, and I absolutely hate e-bikes, aka ChEater bikes. And so, I always reply, the only time I decide to spend money on an Ebike, it will be on a proper electric Dirtbike.
The whole point of an enduro mountain bike is to workout a bit while practicing skills, so if you get an ebike enduro mountain bike, you are basically defeating the purpose of it. And don't come to me with the whole, oh you can cover so much more distance in a shorter amount of time. If that's what you want, then get a friking XC bike or just go roadie alright,

Anyway, I digress from my beef with e-mountain bikes. lol

Next bashing is, Absolutely only hand brake, finally no more rubbish foot brake. I don't ever want to feel like a retard trying to brake with my foot, want to or like to brake with you foot?, go get a car, period. And don't argue about how you grew up learning on foot brake, blah blah blah sob story, hand braking is simply better, period.

ive had a wr250f for the past 5 years, it's been a learning experience and the last 2 years have actually started to be fun. But now, I think it will be a new era with the Varg, I'll finally be able to bomb the sh1t out of downhills with it, like on my downhill bike.

Next bashing, lots of comments about gas generators, blah, blah blah. By the time you get the Varg, you can also get the Ford F150 EV or Rivian, and if 2023 delivery, the cybertruck hopefully. All those vehicles have 240v outlets up pto 5kwh in the bed, go Ride, come back, plug to truck, and you are back to full charge in 1 hour.

Don't break your heads trying to figure out cheap-a$$ ways to charge you bike, embrace the fully electric future, and it will all make sense. You don't need to care whether the track has chargers or not, get an EV truck, and there you have your solution. You'll save thousands from not using any gas/diesel EVERY year.

Yes, this assumes many thing, that you have a single family home that has solar panels so you can charge your truck overnight. But that's the point of embracing an electric future, you just have to do it, because whether you want it or not, IT IS WHAT IT IS, and that is an inevitable electric future.




NotCore wrote:
Tell me more about using solar panels to charge your truck overnight....
Jut come up with $60k in infrastructure so that you can better use your $90k truck to charge your $15k dirtbike.

I think this is really going to take off! Grinning
12
3
SPYGUY
Posts
2184
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
10/5/2022 11:17am
The only difference between the 60hp and 80hp version is a few lines of software code. Mechanically they have the same components. Motor, battery, inverter, etc...
The only difference between the 60hp and 80hp version is a few lines of software code. Mechanically they have the same components. Motor, battery, inverter, etc, all the same.

Think of the 60hp version as 75% of the bikes max capability. The 80hp is 100% of max capability. You buying the 60hp version just means you're limited to 75% of maximum possible horsepower.

Dont view this as a negative though. 60hp is already going to be the fastest dirtbike you've ever ridden. It'll probably output about 45-47ftlb of torque which is about 20% higher than a modern 450. But that's just the power. Dont forget you have no transmission and no clutch, just pure acceleration.

Ive pulled many holeshots on my 50hp/42ftlb Alta Redshift MXR against modern 450s. I can wheelie simply by flicking my right wrist on my Alta MXR. Even the 60hp Varg is going to be incredible acceleration. The 80hp version is just going to be even more insane.

Electric motors can output a lot of power. In fact, im willing to bet under the right circumstances the stark varg motor could output much more than 80hp. The limitation is in the battery, mainly. Its rumored the Alta MXR motor is capable of producing over 100hp, for what its worth.

I chose the 80hp as a novelty, really. The truth is ill likely never use anywhere near 80hp on a motocross track, and i suspect a vast majority of owners wont either. But it sure will be fun to play around with from time to time.
So if you’re running a 50hp map, for instance, battery life shouldn’t be any different on the 60hp model versus the 80hp model?
1
sandtrack315
Posts
2859
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
10/5/2022 11:55am
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history.

Say they find an issue with a component, and need to engineer a new one. It might be another month before they can get the materials.

The unknown unknowns are what make production hard, and it's even hard when it takes a while to fix those issues.

I don't plan to buy one in the near future, but I respect what they are doing. It could be an awesome bike.
24
3
JM485
Posts
5826
Joined
10/1/2013
Location
Davis, CA, USA
10/5/2022 12:25pm
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history. Say they find an issue with a...
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history.

Say they find an issue with a component, and need to engineer a new one. It might be another month before they can get the materials.

The unknown unknowns are what make production hard, and it's even hard when it takes a while to fix those issues.

I don't plan to buy one in the near future, but I respect what they are doing. It could be an awesome bike.
I think it’s also safe to say they don’t follow the European energy market either. In case some of you geniuses haven’t noticed, since most of these pre-orders were taken we’ve had massive supply disruptions, a war break out in Europe, and energy prices go parabolic. Obviously it sucks deliveries are getting pushed back, but holy hell man just look at how much the world has changed around you in the last 6 months! We’re living in an entirely different world then we were in January of this year, every business on earth has felt the effects of what is happening with energy markets and geopolitics. It’s easy to stick your head in the sand and just point the finger at others struggling to make things happen, but you’d really have to be living under a massive rock to not see how bad Europe has been turned on it’s head.
22
1
sandtrack315
Posts
2859
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
10/5/2022 12:35pm
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history. Say they find an issue with a...
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history.

Say they find an issue with a component, and need to engineer a new one. It might be another month before they can get the materials.

The unknown unknowns are what make production hard, and it's even hard when it takes a while to fix those issues.

I don't plan to buy one in the near future, but I respect what they are doing. It could be an awesome bike.
JM485 wrote:
I think it’s also safe to say they don’t follow the European energy market either. In case some of you geniuses haven’t noticed, since most of...
I think it’s also safe to say they don’t follow the European energy market either. In case some of you geniuses haven’t noticed, since most of these pre-orders were taken we’ve had massive supply disruptions, a war break out in Europe, and energy prices go parabolic. Obviously it sucks deliveries are getting pushed back, but holy hell man just look at how much the world has changed around you in the last 6 months! We’re living in an entirely different world then we were in January of this year, every business on earth has felt the effects of what is happening with energy markets and geopolitics. It’s easy to stick your head in the sand and just point the finger at others struggling to make things happen, but you’d really have to be living under a massive rock to not see how bad Europe has been turned on it’s head.
Yup, easy to sit here and complain and be a critic, hard to invent a new hardware product from the ground up.

I work in software, we borrow as much code as possible, write some custom stuff, and package it. It's so hard to do what Stark is doing, they aren't using the chassis from another company, they aren't using much at all from another company, they are doing it all. It's a huge ask, and my only critique would be they should have padded their delivery time estimates to underpromise and overdeliver. If you've ordered something from Apple, you've seen this happen.
7
2
10/5/2022 1:30pm
This might be an unpopular opinion:

Maybe don't hype up a product for a year when you aren't anywhere near a production model.

This is "how to run a business like a dummy" type stuff. You need a physical product with 1000's of hours of testing before you go and start taking orders saying "it'll be ready in 1 year, no problem".

I personally think Triumph is going about it the smartest way. Tell the public you plan on making a bike, give NO DATE as to when. Do R&D for a year getting it good enough to race. Test in racing conditions via MXGP without production rules. Come out with a production bike for the public after race proven results and performance.
27
5
crowe660
Posts
2284
Joined
8/15/2020
Location
USA
10/5/2022 1:36pm
What comes first, The Stark or the Cybertruck?
9
KONG
Posts
768
Joined
9/2/2021
Location
FR
10/5/2022 1:47pm
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history. Say they find an issue with a...
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history.

Say they find an issue with a component, and need to engineer a new one. It might be another month before they can get the materials.

The unknown unknowns are what make production hard, and it's even hard when it takes a while to fix those issues.

I don't plan to buy one in the near future, but I respect what they are doing. It could be an awesome bike.
JM485 wrote:
I think it’s also safe to say they don’t follow the European energy market either. In case some of you geniuses haven’t noticed, since most of...
I think it’s also safe to say they don’t follow the European energy market either. In case some of you geniuses haven’t noticed, since most of these pre-orders were taken we’ve had massive supply disruptions, a war break out in Europe, and energy prices go parabolic. Obviously it sucks deliveries are getting pushed back, but holy hell man just look at how much the world has changed around you in the last 6 months! We’re living in an entirely different world then we were in January of this year, every business on earth has felt the effects of what is happening with energy markets and geopolitics. It’s easy to stick your head in the sand and just point the finger at others struggling to make things happen, but you’d really have to be living under a massive rock to not see how bad Europe has been turned on it’s head.
Yup, easy to sit here and complain and be a critic, hard to invent a new hardware product from the ground up. I work in software...
Yup, easy to sit here and complain and be a critic, hard to invent a new hardware product from the ground up.

I work in software, we borrow as much code as possible, write some custom stuff, and package it. It's so hard to do what Stark is doing, they aren't using the chassis from another company, they aren't using much at all from another company, they are doing it all. It's a huge ask, and my only critique would be they should have padded their delivery time estimates to underpromise and overdeliver. If you've ordered something from Apple, you've seen this happen.
Supply chain crisis, new brand, niche market, small quantities, they're probably the last in line.
Dry
1
7
bigk218
Posts
1465
Joined
1/2/2018
Location
Summerville, SC, USA
10/5/2022 1:49pm
Very on par with a start up. They need to hype things to get funders then HR and management spends all day discussing things that don’t matter preventing the brains and workers from just getting it done. Not saying this is what is happening but just my outsider worthless 2cents from friends involved in much smaller startups.
4
2
face biter
Posts
541
Joined
2/25/2019
Location
Lake Dallas, TX, USA
10/5/2022 2:49pm
My order pushed back 3 months to March 2023 [img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2022/10/05/572017/s1200_Screenshot_20221005_072152.jpg[/img]
My order pushed back 3 months to March 2023
My order date was December 15th 2021 and they’re now showing an anticipated delivery of September 30th of 2023.

I think they’re just throwing jibberish out at the moment.

Smile
1
10/5/2022 3:51pm
what is a Chad?
an attractive western european male, 6 ft tall and fornicates with lots of females
15
10/5/2022 4:02pm Edited Date/Time 10/6/2022 2:06am
My order pushed back another 9 month’s, 12 month delay total. first delivery date said I would have it for an event in August this year, I was hoping to have it for an event in July 23 which is not looking possible now.

This is a bit ridiculous, it’s good to have an ambitious delivery date, but to advertise targets that are not obtainable is unprofessional on Starks part.
3
1
yota
Posts
1421
Joined
6/23/2008
Location
Crystal River, FL, USA
10/5/2022 4:09pm
I understand the supply chain issues but just suddenly popping out emails announcing delays of 1 to 2 more years is not great planning. a 2-year delay is more than supply chain issues. and everyone is bitching about how Triumph is going about this.
2
Jake_CR250R
Posts
320
Joined
1/30/2012
Location
Ozark, MO, USA
10/5/2022 4:37pm
I have no dog in this fight. All I know is things aren't great in Europe right now, the British pound nearly crashed last week with the UK trying to max tax adjustments for their energy bill crisis. Look at Triumph too, a large established company and they're having issues getting their MX bike program up and going.
8
1
Lowlander
Posts
231
Joined
3/31/2012
Location
Perth, AU
10/5/2022 6:00pm
To put the delays into context. I waited 361 days for a VW to be delivered. Why such a delay with one of the biggest car manufacturers in the world? A couple of microchips.

The initial order was supposed to be delivered by Mar 22 (a 5-month lead time) and I just received it 10 days ago. So pretty much a 6-month delay on a 5-month lead time with a massive manufacturer who has the production & manufacturing process sorted.

So, as much as Stark would have been promised by its suppliers for components that would have been the basis for original delivery dates (with a hint of a stretch target/optimism). I'm sure there are a lot of big companies climbing the walls for those components too.

I'm sure for the buyers that are not patient enough to wait 18 months for a first-of-a-kind, you will be able to sell your deposit/build slot to lots of other buyers out there.

7
1
Gungadin
Posts
233
Joined
7/8/2022
Location
Sarasota, FL, USA
10/5/2022 7:00pm
These Stark bikes have fundamental engineering deficiencies. The battery, inverter/controller and motor all overheat when used at only a modest duty cycle. When the motors overheat the expensive rare earth magnets in the rotor are permanently degraded.
Battery range is an issue, but before it goes flat, at high duty - a sand moto say - it has overheated.
Hence the tightly controlled 10 minute sessions at the ride impression gig earlier this year.
Similar very high performance EVs are using flooded cell battery cooling with a temp monitor for each cell. The cells all behave slightly differently so for a best practice battery individual cells are 'characterised' and the battery is assembled to take account of it.
Lots more but I can see how the chip programming and production to control this without very careful testing could be very tricky.
Don't hold your breath waiting for these bikes.
13
sandtrack315
Posts
2859
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
10/5/2022 7:11pm
Rosso391 wrote:
This might be an unpopular opinion: Maybe don't hype up a product for a year when you aren't anywhere near a production model. This is "how...
This might be an unpopular opinion:

Maybe don't hype up a product for a year when you aren't anywhere near a production model.

This is "how to run a business like a dummy" type stuff. You need a physical product with 1000's of hours of testing before you go and start taking orders saying "it'll be ready in 1 year, no problem".

I personally think Triumph is going about it the smartest way. Tell the public you plan on making a bike, give NO DATE as to when. Do R&D for a year getting it good enough to race. Test in racing conditions via MXGP without production rules. Come out with a production bike for the public after race proven results and performance.
This is a great strategy if you’re self funded. If you need venture capital money, which any new manufacturing company does, you need that VC money, which basically means hyping up your product and promising the moon.
4
Gungadin
Posts
233
Joined
7/8/2022
Location
Sarasota, FL, USA
10/5/2022 7:18pm
This is a great strategy if you’re self funded. If you need venture capital money, which any new manufacturing company does, you need that VC money...
This is a great strategy if you’re self funded. If you need venture capital money, which any new manufacturing company does, you need that VC money, which basically means hyping up your product and promising the moon.
Wass was probably hoping to sell Stark pre-natal for a billion to private equity on the strength of the early hype.
4
6
#434
Posts
1912
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
DE
10/5/2022 11:50pm Edited Date/Time 10/5/2022 11:52pm
Gungadin wrote:
These Stark bikes have fundamental engineering deficiencies. The battery, inverter/controller and motor all overheat when used at only a modest duty cycle. When the motors overheat...
These Stark bikes have fundamental engineering deficiencies. The battery, inverter/controller and motor all overheat when used at only a modest duty cycle. When the motors overheat the expensive rare earth magnets in the rotor are permanently degraded.
Battery range is an issue, but before it goes flat, at high duty - a sand moto say - it has overheated.
Hence the tightly controlled 10 minute sessions at the ride impression gig earlier this year.
Similar very high performance EVs are using flooded cell battery cooling with a temp monitor for each cell. The cells all behave slightly differently so for a best practice battery individual cells are 'characterised' and the battery is assembled to take account of it.
Lots more but I can see how the chip programming and production to control this without very careful testing could be very tricky.
Don't hold your breath waiting for these bikes.
So you say the motor and inverter degrade from high temperatures. How? They’re water cooled.

The battery pack is air cooled, but designed in a way that every cell has contact to the battery case housing for heat transfer. This is a much better design than the Alta, which only had overheating problems when pushed to the max.

So where exactly do you see/know the problem with the Stark? And how do you explain Dylan Woodcock putting a 20 min moto on the bike at said test?

I’m an engineer and I love talking about that stuff. So please share your thoughts, knowledge and explanations of the problems you see with the Varg.


11
1
Gungadin
Posts
233
Joined
7/8/2022
Location
Sarasota, FL, USA
10/6/2022 3:11am
#434 wrote:
So you say the motor and inverter degrade from high temperatures. How? They’re water cooled. The battery pack is air cooled, but designed in a way...
So you say the motor and inverter degrade from high temperatures. How? They’re water cooled.

The battery pack is air cooled, but designed in a way that every cell has contact to the battery case housing for heat transfer. This is a much better design than the Alta, which only had overheating problems when pushed to the max.

So where exactly do you see/know the problem with the Stark? And how do you explain Dylan Woodcock putting a 20 min moto on the bike at said test?

I’m an engineer and I love talking about that stuff. So please share your thoughts, knowledge and explanations of the problems you see with the Varg.


Love to discuss this but we can only speak in the broadest general terms because there are no Starks to properly test, or dismantle and examine.
Based on their quoted specs and basic electrical engineering it is extremely unlikely anyone did a full power 20 minute run.

There were zero tests at that fair; only brief ride impressions on a handful of cobbled togther prototypes by tamed journos.

If you have any actual info on who the component suppliers are, particularly for the battery cells, the inverter and it's chips and the motor it would be handy.
High performance EVs have far more complicated cooling requirements than IC with its big deltas and easy to get to hot areas. The EVs have small Delta's and in some cases may need heating not cooling to perform.
Anyway, and as usual the EV racing car guys are a lot further ahead. Getting some basic info from that area will show how much work Stark may need to do to run a 60kW motor via a 6kWh battery for more than a few seconds.
1
10
swordfish
Posts
1950
Joined
9/2/2021
Location
Somewhere, AB, CA
10/6/2022 3:45am
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history. Say they find an issue with a...
Sounds like a lot of you have never launched a hardware product with the toughest supply chain in history.

Say they find an issue with a component, and need to engineer a new one. It might be another month before they can get the materials.

The unknown unknowns are what make production hard, and it's even hard when it takes a while to fix those issues.

I don't plan to buy one in the near future, but I respect what they are doing. It could be an awesome bike.
JM485 wrote:
I think it’s also safe to say they don’t follow the European energy market either. In case some of you geniuses haven’t noticed, since most of...
I think it’s also safe to say they don’t follow the European energy market either. In case some of you geniuses haven’t noticed, since most of these pre-orders were taken we’ve had massive supply disruptions, a war break out in Europe, and energy prices go parabolic. Obviously it sucks deliveries are getting pushed back, but holy hell man just look at how much the world has changed around you in the last 6 months! We’re living in an entirely different world then we were in January of this year, every business on earth has felt the effects of what is happening with energy markets and geopolitics. It’s easy to stick your head in the sand and just point the finger at others struggling to make things happen, but you’d really have to be living under a massive rock to not see how bad Europe has been turned on it’s head.
Yup, easy to sit here and complain and be a critic, hard to invent a new hardware product from the ground up. I work in software...
Yup, easy to sit here and complain and be a critic, hard to invent a new hardware product from the ground up.

I work in software, we borrow as much code as possible, write some custom stuff, and package it. It's so hard to do what Stark is doing, they aren't using the chassis from another company, they aren't using much at all from another company, they are doing it all. It's a huge ask, and my only critique would be they should have padded their delivery time estimates to underpromise and overdeliver. If you've ordered something from Apple, you've seen this happen.
People who have fronted cash don’t care. That’s why companies plan ahead and have contingency plans. That’s why pragmatic thinking and planning wins. Don’t over promise and under deliver. Do the opposite.
2
3
swordfish
Posts
1950
Joined
9/2/2021
Location
Somewhere, AB, CA
10/6/2022 3:46am
This is a great strategy if you’re self funded. If you need venture capital money, which any new manufacturing company does, you need that VC money...
This is a great strategy if you’re self funded. If you need venture capital money, which any new manufacturing company does, you need that VC money, which basically means hyping up your product and promising the moon.
Gungadin wrote:
Wass was probably hoping to sell Stark pre-natal for a billion to private equity on the strength of the early hype.
Bingo.
5
#434
Posts
1912
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
DE
10/6/2022 4:47am Edited Date/Time 10/6/2022 4:58am
#434 wrote:
So you say the motor and inverter degrade from high temperatures. How? They’re water cooled. The battery pack is air cooled, but designed in a way...
So you say the motor and inverter degrade from high temperatures. How? They’re water cooled.

The battery pack is air cooled, but designed in a way that every cell has contact to the battery case housing for heat transfer. This is a much better design than the Alta, which only had overheating problems when pushed to the max.

So where exactly do you see/know the problem with the Stark? And how do you explain Dylan Woodcock putting a 20 min moto on the bike at said test?

I’m an engineer and I love talking about that stuff. So please share your thoughts, knowledge and explanations of the problems you see with the Varg.


Gungadin wrote:
Love to discuss this but we can only speak in the broadest general terms because there are no Starks to properly test, or dismantle and examine...
Love to discuss this but we can only speak in the broadest general terms because there are no Starks to properly test, or dismantle and examine.
Based on their quoted specs and basic electrical engineering it is extremely unlikely anyone did a full power 20 minute run.

There were zero tests at that fair; only brief ride impressions on a handful of cobbled togther prototypes by tamed journos.

If you have any actual info on who the component suppliers are, particularly for the battery cells, the inverter and it's chips and the motor it would be handy.
High performance EVs have far more complicated cooling requirements than IC with its big deltas and easy to get to hot areas. The EVs have small Delta's and in some cases may need heating not cooling to perform.
Anyway, and as usual the EV racing car guys are a lot further ahead. Getting some basic info from that area will show how much work Stark may need to do to run a 60kW motor via a 6kWh battery for more than a few seconds.
This is what I don’t get. On one hand you say the have „engineering deficiencies“ and on the other hand you say we can only discuss it in the broadest sense because we have no actual bikes. You make strong claims for that though.

And you don’t even care to answer my question.. motor and electronics are water cooled via a big radiator with a backup fan. So no problems there, right?

For the battery we can draw comparisons: the Alta worked for most users. It had a bit less power, but a much less effective battery cooling.
Where do you see the problems/engineering deficiencies for the Varg?
And what would the component suppliers tell you about it? We know they use 21700 cells and had engineering support from Croatia.

Where do you see a problem with a 60 kW motor and a 6 kWh battery? There are road legal EVs with comparable numbers. The Porsche has 500 kW and a 80 kWh battery for example.

Here, at 32:20 Dylan Woodcock talks about his 20 min on the supercross track with the Varg:
https://youtu.be/pB7Nxbz2AB4

Edited: video time was wrong
6
1

Post a reply to: Discussion for those that have ordered a Stark Varg..everyone else go away!

The Latest