Team Honda HRC frame modification 🤔

mxav8r
Posts
602
Joined
10/26/2006
Location
Atl, GA, USA

Looking at pictures from DIRT BIKE magazine online feature "Fant Files" I noticed a pretty radical frame modification by Team Honda. 

Team Honda has added/welded on an additional plate of aluminum near the head pipe area. 

Col Nichols CRF450R-98-scaled-2

 Also of note, is the use of small bead/tack welds around the plate vs a continuous bead of weld. I am not a welder so it would be interesting to know why this would be the case (weight, strength, rigidity)?

Col Nichols CRF450R-100-scaled

 In the above picture you can also see special numbers added to the head pipe..

Is this frame modification done by USA Team Honda or do these frames come directly from HRC Japan?

Overall, this is a big (and legal, AMA allows material to be ADDED not REMOVED) modification in an obvious area that is very unusual for secretive Honda HRC.

17
1
|
Mm471
Posts
341
Joined
11/20/2015
Location
Saint Cloud, MN, USA
2/7/2023 11:10am

Between this and the custom air box ML512 covered in pit bits honda is going all out on these bikes

ML512
Posts
16991
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
Fantasy
2/7/2023 11:29am

Pit Bits later today will cover that frame modification along with the interview I did with Chase Sexton, also coming out today.

37
mx313
Posts
1532
Joined
10/5/2021
Location
Brisbane City, QLD, AU
2/7/2023 11:52am

Hey ml.

Do the factory bikes run off the production line frames?

Or are there frames hand made?

2
Oleary465
Posts
128
Joined
9/21/2020
Location
USA
2/7/2023 11:54am
mx313 wrote:

Hey ml.

Do the factory bikes run off the production line frames?

Or are there frames hand made?

production frames, they can add material but can't take away

The Shop

pkiczuk
Posts
404
Joined
6/1/2018
Location
Colchester, CT, USA
2/7/2023 11:56am Edited Date/Time 2/7/2023 11:58am

Michael, you're killing it lately man. On top of your shit! And good eye to the OP on this one! 

19
Xeno
Posts
3740
Joined
12/30/2010
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
2/7/2023 12:26pm
ML512 wrote:

Pit Bits later today will cover that frame modification along with the interview I did with Chase Sexton, also coming out today.

We still want to know about the wire/sensor going into the front of the ignition cover on the CRF250R.

Thanks for your diligence Michael.

Xeno
Posts
3740
Joined
12/30/2010
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
2/7/2023 12:28pm

Good catch mxav8r. I've seen similar stiffening plates on swingarms.

jbonemalone
Posts
301
Joined
12/4/2016
Location
Otis, LA, USA
2/7/2023 3:32pm

Mikey gets it.   Awesome content lately.  

hubbardmx50
Posts
2813
Joined
11/17/2016
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
2/7/2023 7:53pm Edited Date/Time 2/8/2023 8:36am

Honda owners, racers and test riders around the world the last ten years: The thing is rigid, beats us up in the second motos and is sketchy in fast straightaways. Can we please make some changes towards stability and comfort?

Honda Japan: So make it turn better?

6
Austin_Rankin
Posts
1119
Joined
9/3/2019
Location
Georgetown, KY, USA
2/7/2023 8:02pm

in all actuality that is a nice piece spot welded on in a great spot. good work hrc

 

1
2/7/2023 9:03pm
Honda owners, racers and test riders around the world the last ten years: The thing is rigid, beats us up in the second motos and is...

Honda owners, racers and test riders around the world the last ten years: The thing is rigid, beats us up in the second motos and is sketchy in fast straightaways. Can we please make some changes towards stability and comfort?

Honda Japan: So make it turn better?

Chase said the opposite:

"So it just takes a lot of different things to make it work and it's definitely a lot more stable for me and a lot of different characteristics."

1
DR176
Posts
125
Joined
12/3/2014
Location
San Luis Obispo, CA, USA
2/7/2023 9:28pm

Question for you ML. According to Keefer and what he's been told by the engineers, the current gen honda actually has a super soft chassis and the twitchy feeling is the frame "rebounding" of sorts. So, if that's the case, that plate makes a lot of sense. Is that the theory? That them stiffening it up in that area is actually making it more compliant because it's not springing back as much? 

1
hubbardmx50
Posts
2813
Joined
11/17/2016
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
2/7/2023 9:55pm
Honda owners, racers and test riders around the world the last ten years: The thing is rigid, beats us up in the second motos and is...

Honda owners, racers and test riders around the world the last ten years: The thing is rigid, beats us up in the second motos and is sketchy in fast straightaways. Can we please make some changes towards stability and comfort?

Honda Japan: So make it turn better?

Chase said the opposite: "So it just takes a lot of different things to make it work and it's definitely a lot more stable for me...

Chase said the opposite:

"So it just takes a lot of different things to make it work and it's definitely a lot more stable for me and a lot of different characteristics."

I'm just referring to Honda's attitude over the last ten years. I think they're finaling figuring it out and listening to feedback though. Excited to see what they come out with in 2025. 

1
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
2/8/2023 1:44am Edited Date/Time 2/8/2023 1:45am

Generally with racecars, when gussets / chassis reinforcement / roll cage cussets are stitch welded or spot welded it's either because the extra rigidity isn't wanted to a point where welding it continuously isn't warranted OR welding it continuously would cause the weld to crack (like with the typical dimple die'd A-Pillar / windscreen tube gussets on roll cages).

I'd guess they just didn't see any rigidity benefit / saw a weight penalty to welding it entirely and didn't want to grow the heat affected zone from welding, and they obviously aren't concerned about it cracking giving the very low flex/movement present at that already beefy junction?

I'm sure it's feel-able (if that's a word) to Chase / Jett / fast homies, but real world the location probably doesn't make a huge difference with the plate all on one tube, I imagine it's similar to adding wall thickness in a specific area like hydroformed bicycle frames.

7
Bearuno
Posts
5446
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
2/8/2023 2:28am Edited Date/Time 2/8/2023 2:42am

 As a Frame Maker / Life Long Welder, I'm fascinated by this addition to the CRF frame.

I wish I knew that frame better. I'll try to get to my local Honda dealer in the next few days to get a better take on it.

It is quite a thin gauge plate, when compared to what would be a fairly thick section of the frame, usually. But, maybe the CRF is (for an aluminium frame) quite thin where the plating is.

I'd love to see more of it, to see just how far it goes down the downtube.

I can spot a crack in one of the Tack welds - the one to the right and slightly above the cable / wire that is cable tied to, I think the plate (unless that mount is on the std frame?) . Curious as to the the dark  diagonal mark between the said Tack, and the cable tied point - a cut in the plate done to form it to the frame, or, just a marker? I'm stuck on a small screen , so resolution is not that great.

The 'crack in the tack' - pretty bloody common in aluminium tacks during cooling, but, perhaps  a result of the 'working' of the frame while in use? 

The "it honestly doesn't even  feel like a Honda anymore"  quote might disturb Honda a bit, one would think.

Good find by mxav8r from the  Dirt Bike article, and  and ML512.  As I wrote earlier, I'd love to see more pictures of it, but, perhaps it may not be possible .........Woohoo

5
davis224
Posts
7503
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL, USA
Fantasy
2/8/2023 3:53am
Bearuno wrote:
 As a Frame Maker / Life Long Welder, I'm fascinated by this addition to the CRF frame. I wish I knew that frame better. I'll try...

 As a Frame Maker / Life Long Welder, I'm fascinated by this addition to the CRF frame.

I wish I knew that frame better. I'll try to get to my local Honda dealer in the next few days to get a better take on it.

It is quite a thin gauge plate, when compared to what would be a fairly thick section of the frame, usually. But, maybe the CRF is (for an aluminium frame) quite thin where the plating is.

I'd love to see more of it, to see just how far it goes down the downtube.

I can spot a crack in one of the Tack welds - the one to the right and slightly above the cable / wire that is cable tied to, I think the plate (unless that mount is on the std frame?) . Curious as to the the dark  diagonal mark between the said Tack, and the cable tied point - a cut in the plate done to form it to the frame, or, just a marker? I'm stuck on a small screen , so resolution is not that great.

The 'crack in the tack' - pretty bloody common in aluminium tacks during cooling, but, perhaps  a result of the 'working' of the frame while in use? 

The "it honestly doesn't even  feel like a Honda anymore"  quote might disturb Honda a bit, one would think.

Good find by mxav8r from the  Dirt Bike article, and  and ML512.  As I wrote earlier, I'd love to see more pictures of it, but, perhaps it may not be possible .........Woohoo

Screenshot 20230208 055159 Chrome

 Looks like a small plate with an eye for a zip tie.

2
sandman768
Posts
8149
Joined
3/21/2014
Location
Saratoga Springs, NY, USA
2/8/2023 5:22am

I don’t know man…. Anyone ever hear of a placebo? Does the AMA even have a method to determine if the teams are using stock frames? 

3
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
2/8/2023 5:56am Edited Date/Time 2/8/2023 5:57am
Bearuno wrote:
 As a Frame Maker / Life Long Welder, I'm fascinated by this addition to the CRF frame. I wish I knew that frame better. I'll try...

 As a Frame Maker / Life Long Welder, I'm fascinated by this addition to the CRF frame.

I wish I knew that frame better. I'll try to get to my local Honda dealer in the next few days to get a better take on it.

It is quite a thin gauge plate, when compared to what would be a fairly thick section of the frame, usually. But, maybe the CRF is (for an aluminium frame) quite thin where the plating is.

I'd love to see more of it, to see just how far it goes down the downtube.

I can spot a crack in one of the Tack welds - the one to the right and slightly above the cable / wire that is cable tied to, I think the plate (unless that mount is on the std frame?) . Curious as to the the dark  diagonal mark between the said Tack, and the cable tied point - a cut in the plate done to form it to the frame, or, just a marker? I'm stuck on a small screen , so resolution is not that great.

The 'crack in the tack' - pretty bloody common in aluminium tacks during cooling, but, perhaps  a result of the 'working' of the frame while in use? 

The "it honestly doesn't even  feel like a Honda anymore"  quote might disturb Honda a bit, one would think.

Good find by mxav8r from the  Dirt Bike article, and  and ML512.  As I wrote earlier, I'd love to see more pictures of it, but, perhaps it may not be possible .........Woohoo

davis224 wrote:
 Looks like a small plate with an eye for a zip tie.

Screenshot 20230208 055159 Chrome

 Looks like a small plate with an eye for a zip tie.

Good spot, I use them daily.

They're most often supplied with a crazy strong, instant (and I really mean instant, unlike most adhesives claiming it) glue made by Loctite.

GPrider
Posts
780
Joined
4/10/2014
Location
La Mesa, CA, USA
2/8/2023 7:38am

couple thoughts, first, didn't Keefer just do a video with Colts mechanic going over the bike. He never even brought it up which is odd. I would think Keefer would had been all over it. And the other thing is in the interview with Chase he said initially nobody like it until the matched it up with that different style shock he uses. So being that the public doesn't get that shock it isn't much use to a production bike?

zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX, USA
2/8/2023 8:12am

I’m kind of surprised no one seems to be taking this as bad publicity for Honda. I’d be upset if my top rider said they’ve had to make so many changes to make the bike not feel the same as what is for sale

6
4
FWYT
Posts
3558
Joined
5/25/2014
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
2/8/2023 8:20am
Richy wrote:
Good spot, I use them daily. They're most often supplied with a crazy strong, instant (and I really mean instant, unlike most adhesives claiming it) glue...

Good spot, I use them daily.

They're most often supplied with a crazy strong, instant (and I really mean instant, unlike most adhesives claiming it) glue made by Loctite.

What are these little pieces you are referring to? They sound handy.

1
GrapeApe
Posts
8889
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
2/8/2023 8:22am
I’m kind of surprised no one seems to be taking this as bad publicity for Honda. I’d be upset if my top rider said they’ve had...

I’m kind of surprised no one seems to be taking this as bad publicity for Honda. I’d be upset if my top rider said they’ve had to make so many changes to make the bike not feel the same as what is for sale

If there were any doubts left about him leaving Honda for KTM next year, that quote should erase them lol

 

4
1
TeamGreen
Posts
37228
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
2/8/2023 8:36am
Richy wrote:
Good spot, I use them daily. They're most often supplied with a crazy strong, instant (and I really mean instant, unlike most adhesives claiming it) glue...

Good spot, I use them daily.

They're most often supplied with a crazy strong, instant (and I really mean instant, unlike most adhesives claiming it) glue made by Loctite.

FWYT wrote:

What are these little pieces you are referring to? They sound handy.

C8635F6E-85E2-400D-96B3-642E989A3EC6.jpeg?VersionId=lmP

 

2/8/2023 4:28pm
I’m kind of surprised no one seems to be taking this as bad publicity for Honda. I’d be upset if my top rider said they’ve had...

I’m kind of surprised no one seems to be taking this as bad publicity for Honda. I’d be upset if my top rider said they’ve had to make so many changes to make the bike not feel the same as what is for sale

"it doesn't even feel like a Honda" is definitely not something you'd want as an mfg. You'd want "Feeling like a Honda" sold as highly desirable

6
[YM]
Posts
193
Joined
9/15/2021
Location
USA
2/8/2023 6:25pm
Bearuno wrote:
 As a Frame Maker / Life Long Welder, I'm fascinated by this addition to the CRF frame. I wish I knew that frame better. I'll try...

 As a Frame Maker / Life Long Welder, I'm fascinated by this addition to the CRF frame.

I wish I knew that frame better. I'll try to get to my local Honda dealer in the next few days to get a better take on it.

It is quite a thin gauge plate, when compared to what would be a fairly thick section of the frame, usually. But, maybe the CRF is (for an aluminium frame) quite thin where the plating is.

I'd love to see more of it, to see just how far it goes down the downtube.

I can spot a crack in one of the Tack welds - the one to the right and slightly above the cable / wire that is cable tied to, I think the plate (unless that mount is on the std frame?) . Curious as to the the dark  diagonal mark between the said Tack, and the cable tied point - a cut in the plate done to form it to the frame, or, just a marker? I'm stuck on a small screen , so resolution is not that great.

The 'crack in the tack' - pretty bloody common in aluminium tacks during cooling, but, perhaps  a result of the 'working' of the frame while in use? 

The "it honestly doesn't even  feel like a Honda anymore"  quote might disturb Honda a bit, one would think.

Good find by mxav8r from the  Dirt Bike article, and  and ML512.  As I wrote earlier, I'd love to see more pictures of it, but, perhaps it may not be possible .........Woohoo

davis224 wrote:
 Looks like a small plate with an eye for a zip tie.

Screenshot 20230208 055159 Chrome

 Looks like a small plate with an eye for a zip tie.

Hopefully there are better shots in Pit Bits

Darrin Willis
Posts
1105
Joined
11/16/2020
Location
Red Deer County, AB, CA
2/8/2023 7:23pm

Oh shit  . Gonna be a bunch of vital members saying their frames have gone from to stiff to to springy. 

4
CASH476
Posts
631
Joined
2/27/2009
Location
Perth, AU
2/8/2023 9:01pm

What if the plate's just there to cover up where they removed a bunch of material?

3
4
2/9/2023 12:41pm
Honda owners, racers and test riders around the world the last ten years: The thing is rigid, beats us up in the second motos and is...

Honda owners, racers and test riders around the world the last ten years: The thing is rigid, beats us up in the second motos and is sketchy in fast straightaways. Can we please make some changes towards stability and comfort?

Honda Japan: So make it turn better?

It’s been done already 04 was the last yr of good penatration & clean looking welds. Newer Honda frames r made with cheaper materials. They even look cheap compared to 02-04. Some 06,s hv gaps- holes in the welds. I don’t see a super thin plate with tack welds 5- 7 mm out making much of a difference. Bolting a skid plate on you can feel it’s much more rigid. 

6
2/9/2023 12:53pm

I'm not interested in a new Honda because I'm looking for comfort. Not stiffness and rigidity. But they keep making it more "rigid" every year!

1

Post a reply to: Team Honda HRC frame modification 🤔

The Latest