Make amatuer mx better

BoxcarWilly
Posts
1316
Joined
10/5/2023
Location
Thunder Bay, ON, CA
6/25/2024 6:58am

Step 1: Race Off-road. 

8
1
uncledaddy69
Posts
2689
Joined
4/2/2011
Location
Huntington Beach, CA, USA
6/25/2024 7:07am
cdm806 wrote:
How about not having 24 classes?  250f/125t A/B/C, 450f/250t A,B,C, 50 shaft, 50 chain, 65, 85, Girls under 12, Women 12+, Schoolboy, Vet A, Vet B/C. ...

How about not having 24 classes?  250f/125t A/B/C, 450f/250t A,B,C, 50 shaft, 50 chain, 65, 85, Girls under 12, Women 12+, Schoolboy, Vet A, Vet B/C.  15 motos x2 and go home.  Sounds good to me. Not everybody needs a trophy, but the promoters want your $50 per class, so nothing will change

 

Agree. There also needs to be a solution for sandbaggers (more classes makes it worse imo) The winner of the 450 beginner class at the last race at Glen Helen I did was scrubbing all the jumps on the REM track, it was ridiculous. 
 

All I want to do is race a 20 to 30 minute moto against guys who are around the same speed as me.

1
mgifracing
Posts
1912
Joined
1/25/2007
Location
Newton, KS, USA
6/25/2024 7:09am

I know at our Kansas series the race order gets rearranged every race so the same classes aren't last all of the time. My complaint lately, I remember there use to be a 3 to make a class rule, Seems that has went by the waste side to make sure we get that one last entry fee.

38special
Posts
685
Joined
6/30/2010
Location
USA
6/25/2024 7:32am
It seems pretty common around here that a lot of the vet guys race 2 classes.  I do wish we wo go back to just a...

It seems pretty common around here that a lot of the vet guys race 2 classes.  I do wish we wo go back to just a simple open age groups and drop the B/C classes.  We always have more guys in the B/C and the front guys would be in the mix with the regular age group.

Agree.  The main problem is too many classes, specifically Vet classes. 

But the promoters like it because their Vet class payout goes WAY down if there's only 5 entries versus 20 in the money-paying classes.

1

The Shop

6/25/2024 7:48am

Step 1: Race Off-road. 

With the boom of GP series (at least in the North East) I have little desire to race MX anymore when I can get two 30min motos or a 2hr scramble for $40. Plus the times and motos are set beforehand so I don’t have to show up at 7am then sit around all day waiting.

3
yz133rider
Posts
5026
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA, USA
6/25/2024 7:59am
cdm806 wrote:
How about not having 24 classes?  250f/125t A/B/C, 450f/250t A,B,C, 50 shaft, 50 chain, 65, 85, Girls under 12, Women 12+, Schoolboy, Vet A, Vet B/C. ...

How about not having 24 classes?  250f/125t A/B/C, 450f/250t A,B,C, 50 shaft, 50 chain, 65, 85, Girls under 12, Women 12+, Schoolboy, Vet A, Vet B/C.  15 motos x2 and go home.  Sounds good to me. Not everybody needs a trophy, but the promoters want your $50 per class, so nothing will change

 

Agree. There also needs to be a solution for sandbaggers (more classes makes it worse imo) The winner of the 450 beginner class at the last...

Agree. There also needs to be a solution for sandbaggers (more classes makes it worse imo) The winner of the 450 beginner class at the last race at Glen Helen I did was scrubbing all the jumps on the REM track, it was ridiculous. 
 

All I want to do is race a 20 to 30 minute moto against guys who are around the same speed as me.

Bingo. I’ve laid it out before, there needs to be qualifying and be grouped by speed, not by age, ego, or feelings.

3
1
ZinAZ
Posts
339
Joined
10/11/2022
Location
boston, MA, USA
6/25/2024 9:11am
lumpy790 wrote:

tracks juggle the order around to try and accommodate riders that are racing in multiple classes so they are not back to back.

cwtoyota wrote:
I've thought about this problem and there is a way to mostly solve it. Do a statistical analysis of how riders blend between classes.    Obviously...

I've thought about this problem and there is a way to mostly solve it.

Do a statistical analysis of how riders blend between classes.   

Obviously nobody is riding the 65cc 9-11 class and the 50+ Masters.   
A statistical analysis will show the ones that are not so obvious.

Most motocross promoters and tracks don't have a degree in statistics, so ask ChatGPT to do it for you based on your entry lists or race results from the previous year(s).

The racers will self-mitigate this issue to some extent.   
Most of us will avoid signing up for classes that are back to back or classes that are at the extreme opposite ends of the day's schedule.



There's no good solution that preserves the 33 different classes and divisions with five lap motos.
If there was a series that charged $100 to enter a class, combined classes and raced two 25+2 or 30+2 motos, I would be all over it.  The track gets the same entry money they do when we all race two different classes, but they don't have to drop the gate as many times or produce as many trophies...   

Hot take:  I don't think the average motocross racer is fit enough or interested in 30 minute motos.

yz133rider wrote:

How can off-road have huge turnouts for 90-120 minute races and motocrossers aren’t fit enough for 25 minute motos? Stop sprinting…

because the people racing arent professionals training for this, I can ride 2+ hours easily in the desert, riding race pace on the track for 12-15mins and im smoked.  I bet 95% of riders couldnt do 25+ min motos unless you want to see people putting around the track to just survive for 25mins.  short races 5-7laps/10-15mins, keeps the pace up and the racing interesting.

4
1
LungButter
Posts
8683
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
6/25/2024 9:16am
That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.   There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting...

That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.
 

There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting laps by 25% in one moto doesn’t result in a 12.5% refund.

I'm pretty sure MXSports doesn't have anything to do with promoting the Amateur Days at the Nationals.

1
2
rbspecial138
Posts
156
Joined
1/29/2017
Location
Spanish Springs, NV, USA
6/25/2024 9:18am

10 Person minimum for a class.

If they post the schedule of classes before the day begins, the last motos scheduled will have no turnout so promoter will never do this.

1
yz133rider
Posts
5026
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA, USA
6/25/2024 9:23am
cwtoyota wrote:
I've thought about this problem and there is a way to mostly solve it. Do a statistical analysis of how riders blend between classes.    Obviously...

I've thought about this problem and there is a way to mostly solve it.

Do a statistical analysis of how riders blend between classes.   

Obviously nobody is riding the 65cc 9-11 class and the 50+ Masters.   
A statistical analysis will show the ones that are not so obvious.

Most motocross promoters and tracks don't have a degree in statistics, so ask ChatGPT to do it for you based on your entry lists or race results from the previous year(s).

The racers will self-mitigate this issue to some extent.   
Most of us will avoid signing up for classes that are back to back or classes that are at the extreme opposite ends of the day's schedule.



There's no good solution that preserves the 33 different classes and divisions with five lap motos.
If there was a series that charged $100 to enter a class, combined classes and raced two 25+2 or 30+2 motos, I would be all over it.  The track gets the same entry money they do when we all race two different classes, but they don't have to drop the gate as many times or produce as many trophies...   

Hot take:  I don't think the average motocross racer is fit enough or interested in 30 minute motos.

yz133rider wrote:

How can off-road have huge turnouts for 90-120 minute races and motocrossers aren’t fit enough for 25 minute motos? Stop sprinting…

ZinAZ wrote:
because the people racing arent professionals training for this, I can ride 2+ hours easily in the desert, riding race pace on the track for 12-15mins...

because the people racing arent professionals training for this, I can ride 2+ hours easily in the desert, riding race pace on the track for 12-15mins and im smoked.  I bet 95% of riders couldnt do 25+ min motos unless you want to see people putting around the track to just survive for 25mins.  short races 5-7laps/10-15mins, keeps the pace up and the racing interesting.

If you back it down to 80-90% of your race pace you’d be amazed how you can keep spinning laps.

 

moto just has a broken thought process around it.

 

and as far as watching people putt around if I’m honest watching amateur motos is already a non event, nobody truly watches it unless someone they know is in the class. It’s generally boring as hell and that’s from a mega fan and a racer , so yeah if they go a little slower it doesn’t change a thing.

 

it would be cool to watch strategy and line choice and fitness actually matter.

 

where a 4 lap race with 5 people on the gate nothing matters besides sprinting.  Starts barely matter because there’s 5 freaking people, fitness barely matters because the moto is 8 minutes long, there is no strategy besides go fast/don’t die.

3
2
nealb129
Posts
338
Joined
1/22/2017
Location
Taylors, SC, USA
6/25/2024 10:59am
yz133rider wrote:

How can off-road have huge turnouts for 90-120 minute races and motocrossers aren’t fit enough for 25 minute motos? Stop sprinting…

ZinAZ wrote:
because the people racing arent professionals training for this, I can ride 2+ hours easily in the desert, riding race pace on the track for 12-15mins...

because the people racing arent professionals training for this, I can ride 2+ hours easily in the desert, riding race pace on the track for 12-15mins and im smoked.  I bet 95% of riders couldnt do 25+ min motos unless you want to see people putting around the track to just survive for 25mins.  short races 5-7laps/10-15mins, keeps the pace up and the racing interesting.

yz133rider wrote:
If you back it down to 80-90% of your race pace you’d be amazed how you can keep spinning laps.   moto just has a broken...

If you back it down to 80-90% of your race pace you’d be amazed how you can keep spinning laps.

 

moto just has a broken thought process around it.

 

and as far as watching people putt around if I’m honest watching amateur motos is already a non event, nobody truly watches it unless someone they know is in the class. It’s generally boring as hell and that’s from a mega fan and a racer , so yeah if they go a little slower it doesn’t change a thing.

 

it would be cool to watch strategy and line choice and fitness actually matter.

 

where a 4 lap race with 5 people on the gate nothing matters besides sprinting.  Starts barely matter because there’s 5 freaking people, fitness barely matters because the moto is 8 minutes long, there is no strategy besides go fast/don’t die.

Wait.. no one is watching me jump halfway across a 40ft table top and then landing on my shifter? Takes the pressure off for sure!

 

cut out the B/C classes. 2 classes per displacement 125 beginner, 125. 85cc beginner, 85cc. A/Pro class.

more laps spun is better for those actually racing I.e. those actually funding the sport. 

2
zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX, USA
6/25/2024 11:22am

I don't have the answers, but id like for someone to try something different

Limit classes, do what you can to move from 35 classes to 20-25 classes

combine gates but score separately when able to

Run a 3 moto format

 

I believe most tracks around here for a race equates to $4.50 per lap, or $3.50 per lap if running 2  classes.

 

Up to the race fee by $5, run a 3 moto format, and you are at $3.33 per lap

 

More laps for your buck, shorter day at the track, and MAYBE you can get more people in, and be less reliant on people racing 2 classes.

1
1
6/25/2024 11:42am
Skerby wrote:
Went to a race last weekend and was happy to draw motos 2 & 7 out of 24 some classes. Got me to thinking: what if...

Went to a race last weekend and was happy to draw motos 2 & 7 out of 24 some classes.

Got me to thinking: what if we just published the moto schedule BEFORE sign up? Everyone with half a brain will sign up for the early motos so they can go home at a decent time, and then just cancel whatever races nobody signs up for. 

Downvote away, Im gonna die on this hill.

The tracks here in NE post the schedule for the most part ahead of time. I think we should break up the day, let the youth riders run their both motos in the morning, then let the bigger bikes run the afternoons, alternate every week. If you are  vet and its your week to be afternoon, then you show up at sign up between 10am and 11 am. We would be out of there by 5pm, if you are in the morning sign up 7am to 8am and be out of there by noon.

6/25/2024 11:44am
I don't have the answers, but id like for someone to try something different Limit classes, do what you can to move from 35 classes to...

I don't have the answers, but id like for someone to try something different

Limit classes, do what you can to move from 35 classes to 20-25 classes

combine gates but score separately when able to

Run a 3 moto format

 

I believe most tracks around here for a race equates to $4.50 per lap, or $3.50 per lap if running 2  classes.

 

Up to the race fee by $5, run a 3 moto format, and you are at $3.33 per lap

 

More laps for your buck, shorter day at the track, and MAYBE you can get more people in, and be less reliant on people racing 2 classes.

Part of the problem is the tracks want us running more classes. It is more money in entry fees for them

2
LungButter
Posts
8683
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
6/25/2024 12:18pm

Part of the problem is the tracks want us running more classes. It is more money in entry fees for them

Facts, they are trying to stay in business.

If you want less classes you have to be willing to pay more in entry fees.

1
6/25/2024 12:24pm

Part of the problem is the tracks want us running more classes. It is more money in entry fees for them

LungButter wrote:

Facts, they are trying to stay in business.

If you want less classes you have to be willing to pay more in entry fees.

obviously, I would pay more for a shorter day and more time on the track. I get it..it's a business and we are lucky to have them around

3
lumpy790
Posts
11872
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
6/25/2024 12:29pm

runs all the classes with 2 more laps but split the classes into 2 days. Shorter time for the promoter but You pay $10 more per class each day and 2x the gate fee but get more ride time. 

LungButter
Posts
8683
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
6/25/2024 12:37pm
lumpy790 wrote:
runs all the classes with 2 more laps but split the classes into 2 days. Shorter time for the promoter but You pay $10 more per...

runs all the classes with 2 more laps but split the classes into 2 days. Shorter time for the promoter but You pay $10 more per class each day and 2x the gate fee but get more ride time. 

Seems like dang near twice the operating costs for the promoters.

As far as I know, most insurance for this type of stuff is sold per day.

8tensolutions
Posts
3582
Joined
11/15/2009
Location
Salt Lake City, UT, USA
6/25/2024 1:39pm
ThatOneKid wrote:
I raced High Point’s Sunday Amateur day, I was moto 27 of 31. I had originally signed up for two classes but took a hard fall...

I raced High Point’s Sunday Amateur day, I was moto 27 of 31. I had originally signed up for two classes but took a hard fall in the Friday practice and decided to just do one class. Unfortunately that meant I had a long Sunday for 2 different times on the track.

Sign ups started late, practice started late, and I didn’t race my first moto until after 2:00. We had an RV rental to return so we ended up skipping moto 2. I kept an eye on the live timing and if we had waited, the 2nd moto for my class would have run at 6:30, and that was also after they cut the 2nd motos to 3 laps. 

One of the biggest problems was all of the 50 classes not being able to make it around the track, so they would take a break and fix the track before all of their motos. At that point make the 50s all at one block on the schedule, and fix the track once since they wont’ beat it up much. 

Thankfully I practiced Friday and got a decent bit of seat time in, and yes racing Sunday was fun and the track was awesome, but man was it a lot of sitting around. 

That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.   There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting...

That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.
 

There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting laps by 25% in one moto doesn’t result in a 12.5% refund.

It's not THE National Promoter if you are trying to lay this on Davey too.  The local track promoters run the amateur days, not MX Sports.  They have nothing to do with it, but tracks are welcomed to do it to add to the weekend and make camping much more fun and viable for fans.

SoCalMX70
Posts
3603
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
6/25/2024 1:55pm Edited Date/Time 6/25/2024 2:08pm
lumpy790 wrote:
runs all the classes with 2 more laps but split the classes into 2 days. Shorter time for the promoter but You pay $10 more per...

runs all the classes with 2 more laps but split the classes into 2 days. Shorter time for the promoter but You pay $10 more per class each day and 2x the gate fee but get more ride time. 

LungButter wrote:
Seems like dang near twice the operating costs for the promoters. As far as I know, most insurance for this type of stuff is sold per...

Seems like dang near twice the operating costs for the promoters.

As far as I know, most insurance for this type of stuff is sold per day.

It is per day.

Splitting a regular "local race" into 2 days is a non-starter on both sides of that. A lot of riders and families won't do it, and promoters/tracks aren't going to eat all that extra expense for insurance, diesel, water, EMTs, and flaggers.

Edit: I will clarify that large annual events exceeding a certain number of riders (500, 700, whatever) should certainly be broken into 2+ days... I'm sure most are anyway.

1
kijen
Posts
1248
Joined
10/1/2010
Location
Jacksonville, FL, USA
6/25/2024 2:16pm

Small bikes race sat, big bike race sunday, looking at local races near us, there don't appear to be very many dads sons racing, so the kids have their time and so do the vets. Or have a vet series or big bike series, 125cc and up?

2
ZinAZ
Posts
339
Joined
10/11/2022
Location
boston, MA, USA
6/25/2024 3:06pm
kijen wrote:
Small bikes race sat, big bike race sunday, looking at local races near us, there don't appear to be very many dads sons racing, so the...

Small bikes race sat, big bike race sunday, looking at local races near us, there don't appear to be very many dads sons racing, so the kids have their time and so do the vets. Or have a vet series or big bike series, 125cc and up?

agreed 50-supermini race one day, 125-450 race day two

2
Soul Indigo
Posts
933
Joined
5/25/2023
Location
Phuket, TH
6/25/2024 5:32pm
ThatOneKid wrote:
I raced High Point’s Sunday Amateur day, I was moto 27 of 31. I had originally signed up for two classes but took a hard fall...

I raced High Point’s Sunday Amateur day, I was moto 27 of 31. I had originally signed up for two classes but took a hard fall in the Friday practice and decided to just do one class. Unfortunately that meant I had a long Sunday for 2 different times on the track.

Sign ups started late, practice started late, and I didn’t race my first moto until after 2:00. We had an RV rental to return so we ended up skipping moto 2. I kept an eye on the live timing and if we had waited, the 2nd moto for my class would have run at 6:30, and that was also after they cut the 2nd motos to 3 laps. 

One of the biggest problems was all of the 50 classes not being able to make it around the track, so they would take a break and fix the track before all of their motos. At that point make the 50s all at one block on the schedule, and fix the track once since they wont’ beat it up much. 

Thankfully I practiced Friday and got a decent bit of seat time in, and yes racing Sunday was fun and the track was awesome, but man was it a lot of sitting around. 

That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.   There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting...

That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.
 

There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting laps by 25% in one moto doesn’t result in a 12.5% refund.

It's not THE National Promoter if you are trying to lay this on Davey too.  The local track promoters run the amateur days, not MX Sports...

It's not THE National Promoter if you are trying to lay this on Davey too.  The local track promoters run the amateur days, not MX Sports.  They have nothing to do with it, but tracks are welcomed to do it to add to the weekend and make camping much more fun and viable for fans.

Who is the local track promoter that runs/owns High Point?

8tensolutions
Posts
3582
Joined
11/15/2009
Location
Salt Lake City, UT, USA
6/25/2024 5:59pm
That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.   There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting...

That’s so lame man. Especially for a national promoter. THE national promoter.
 

There’s no real incentive for local promoters to have an efficient schedule/day/operation. Cutting laps by 25% in one moto doesn’t result in a 12.5% refund.

It's not THE National Promoter if you are trying to lay this on Davey too.  The local track promoters run the amateur days, not MX Sports...

It's not THE National Promoter if you are trying to lay this on Davey too.  The local track promoters run the amateur days, not MX Sports.  They have nothing to do with it, but tracks are welcomed to do it to add to the weekend and make camping much more fun and viable for fans.

Who is the local track promoter that runs/owns High Point?

The guy who runs it called into Pulp last week and was talking to Phil about prep etc.  I am not sure of his name.

 

SEEMEFIRST
Posts
14268
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX, USA
6/25/2024 6:06pm

Step 1: Race Off-road. 

Learned that in the late 80's. 

But I still worked at a motocross track as a side job.

Here's the problem. As long as LL,s is the benchmark, nothing will change. Promoters love that little Johnny can run 3-4 classes. I don't like it, but I understand why it happens. 

I've been on the flag stand from sun up until sun down for a long ass time, and I think the classes are ridiculous, but if someone is going to throw cah at your feet, are you going to bitch?

Man, let me tell you, a 800 rider weekend is a bitch as the chief. 

2
Soul Indigo
Posts
933
Joined
5/25/2023
Location
Phuket, TH
6/25/2024 6:54pm
It's not THE National Promoter if you are trying to lay this on Davey too.  The local track promoters run the amateur days, not MX Sports...

It's not THE National Promoter if you are trying to lay this on Davey too.  The local track promoters run the amateur days, not MX Sports.  They have nothing to do with it, but tracks are welcomed to do it to add to the weekend and make camping much more fun and viable for fans.

Who is the local track promoter that runs/owns High Point?

The guy who runs it called into Pulp last week and was talking to Phil about prep etc.  I am not sure of his name.

 

And who is his boss?

 

8tensolutions
Posts
3582
Joined
11/15/2009
Location
Salt Lake City, UT, USA
6/25/2024 6:58pm

Who is the local track promoter that runs/owns High Point?

The guy who runs it called into Pulp last week and was talking to Phil about prep etc.  I am not sure of his name.

 

And who is his boss?

 

Dude, you are reaching here.  MX Sports does not run the amateur days.  That's all i can tell you.

Soul Indigo
Posts
933
Joined
5/25/2023
Location
Phuket, TH
6/25/2024 8:09pm

The guy who runs it called into Pulp last week and was talking to Phil about prep etc.  I am not sure of his name.

 

And who is his boss?

 

Dude, you are reaching here.  MX Sports does not run the amateur days.  That's all i can tell you.

I am aware MX Sports does not run amateur days. I never mentioned MX Sports.

 

6/25/2024 9:15pm
yz133rider wrote:

How can off-road have huge turnouts for 90-120 minute races and motocrossers aren’t fit enough for 25 minute motos? Stop sprinting…

ZinAZ wrote:
because the people racing arent professionals training for this, I can ride 2+ hours easily in the desert, riding race pace on the track for 12-15mins...

because the people racing arent professionals training for this, I can ride 2+ hours easily in the desert, riding race pace on the track for 12-15mins and im smoked.  I bet 95% of riders couldnt do 25+ min motos unless you want to see people putting around the track to just survive for 25mins.  short races 5-7laps/10-15mins, keeps the pace up and the racing interesting.

yz133rider wrote:
If you back it down to 80-90% of your race pace you’d be amazed how you can keep spinning laps.   moto just has a broken...

If you back it down to 80-90% of your race pace you’d be amazed how you can keep spinning laps.

 

moto just has a broken thought process around it.

 

and as far as watching people putt around if I’m honest watching amateur motos is already a non event, nobody truly watches it unless someone they know is in the class. It’s generally boring as hell and that’s from a mega fan and a racer , so yeah if they go a little slower it doesn’t change a thing.

 

it would be cool to watch strategy and line choice and fitness actually matter.

 

where a 4 lap race with 5 people on the gate nothing matters besides sprinting.  Starts barely matter because there’s 5 freaking people, fitness barely matters because the moto is 8 minutes long, there is no strategy besides go fast/don’t die.

What’s the real problem? You didn’t win a moto yet. If not what makes you feel you would if the races where 8 laps.  The races are 4 or 5 laps, adapt .i only do 4/5 lap sprints . I did a full tank in 30 min just to enjoy the 125 . But it’s more fun letting it hang out & being aggressive every inch of the track. Sing up for more classes it’s more fun doing starts and 4 lap races. Than putting around for 20+ min. Bmx pro,s do 1 lap it’s exciting.  The fastest man in the world title is 100m.  I think Mx is close to having it right.  Everyone gets a chance to race. I personally don’t think they should be racing anything smaller than a 85.  

1
3
mx510
Posts
1994
Joined
2/26/2011
Location
Gig Harbor, WA, USA
6/25/2024 9:27pm

J Day off road anyone??? 2- 30 minute motos! 

1

Post a reply to: Make amatuer mx better

The Latest