Triumph September, maybe?

7/29/2023 9:33am
I've spent 30 years working in manufacturing, that's why I made the comment, if a robot has an issue it will keep repeating until it is...

I've spent 30 years working in manufacturing, that's why I made the comment, if a robot has an issue it will keep repeating until it is caught, a person will make random intermittent mistakes, which makes it more difficult to catch.

Not true. People would like to believe that because we've been hoodwinked to believe that robots are perfect. As someone who has spent the better part of 30 years designing automation systems, emphatically not true. A robot typically might have 3 components, electrical, hydraulic, and or pneumatic. A slight change in air pressure or a seal that leaks will yield different results. A change in voltage might effect the performance of the hydraulic pump, a sketchy ground may allow perfect results 98 out of 100 cycles, and sometimes only less than 1% will it cause erratic result. I could go on and on. I will tell you that I have a passport with every space stamped because people around the globe could not figure out why a system went 3000 cycles perfect and then 1 cycle shit. Then I had to jump on a plane to go diagnose and repair. Same with our cars and bikes, they have intermittent issues. The most difficult problems to diagnose. I will say however, that a properly designed and proper working system outperforms a human every time.

12
1
7/29/2023 9:40am
HonDawg17 wrote:
Its overhype now. People losing interest fast. We aren't gonna sit around for 1 component a week until the bike is built. What a waste of...

Its overhype now. People losing interest fast. We aren't gonna sit around for 1 component a week until the bike is built. What a waste of time.

You say that but we will all be here for the next round of component video drops

2
1
7/29/2023 10:02am
I've spent 30 years working in manufacturing, that's why I made the comment, if a robot has an issue it will keep repeating until it is...

I've spent 30 years working in manufacturing, that's why I made the comment, if a robot has an issue it will keep repeating until it is caught, a person will make random intermittent mistakes, which makes it more difficult to catch.

FarleyMX25 wrote:

Well I’m a skilled tradesman so I personally wouldn’t have an issue with buying it. I would be more inclined to buy it actually. 

If you were making it for yourself, would you make it while you are hung over?

30 years in manufacturing and you don’t think quality control would catch a bunch of shit welds from the drunk guy, shit can his ass and find someone way more professional about their trade to do the job? My current bike is a TM which is about as hand made as any dirt bike is going to get and I can 100% assure you that every aspect of that bike whether it be the frame, gear box or the rear shock is top notch. 

3
TeamGreen
Posts
37011
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
7/29/2023 10:11am

I’m just so upset that they didn’t reveal more. I’m going to put on a public display of my anger thru interpretive dance! 
47FF79AC-30F7-47FE-86CF-B9E0DFE25718

 0DB939BD-A92E-4A93-BAA6-A17A3E84793D

 

21

The Shop

7/29/2023 12:54pm
soggy wrote:
Well that video was a big nothing burger. 

Well that video was a big nothing burger. 

Welcome to Mx sx media 

DonM wrote:
WTF does the mx media have to do with the way Triumph has decided to roll out their product? I truly think that people blame MX...

WTF does the mx media have to do with the way Triumph has decided to roll out their product? I truly think that people blame MX media when they don't understand and or comprehend...

Welcome to Mx Sx marketing**

philG
Posts
10980
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
7/29/2023 2:56pm

One word.

Fustrating.

Thats not even a word. 

12
1
agn5008
Posts
1983
Joined
3/8/2021
Location
PA, PA, USA
Fantasy
7/29/2023 3:12pm
agn5008 wrote:

You never go full waffle. 

ML512 wrote:

Eli Tomac runs full waffle.

mimafia wrote:
Pretty sure that was just a Tropic Thunder movie reference, not an opinion on grips 

Pretty sure that was just a Tropic Thunder movie reference, not an opinion on grips Smile

I’m glad someone got it 😂

2
7/29/2023 3:53pm

FB IMG 1690669620987

 Saw this posted on FB, too good not to share. 

6
1
7/29/2023 4:07pm

One word.

Fustrating.

philG wrote:

Thats not even a word. 

Ask James if that is a word.

3
3
PTshox
Posts
1589
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
7/29/2023 4:55pm

One thing about  Triumph I am interested in/ optimistic about is this is an English company. England has some of the best engine/transmission companies in the world. It’s the land of F1 engines/ transmissions etc.

 

Thus I’m very curious to see what they come up with in the engine department. They know what they are up against. They have access to pretty much the BEST engine folks in the world. This has a shot at being a very strong 250F in the motor department. And, Dave Arnold knows chassis stuff. Like really knows chassis stuff.

 

So… spit it out. Show us what you got! 

5
wwdiii
Posts
2575
Joined
4/15/2019
Location
League City, TX, USA
7/29/2023 5:06pm

Let’s all just get worked over a bike most of us aren’t going to buy.   
 

3
1
7/29/2023 5:38pm
FarleyMX25 wrote:

Well I’m a skilled tradesman so I personally wouldn’t have an issue with buying it. I would be more inclined to buy it actually. 

If you were making it for yourself, would you make it while you are hung over?

30 years in manufacturing and you don’t think quality control would catch a bunch of shit welds from the drunk guy, shit can his ass and...

30 years in manufacturing and you don’t think quality control would catch a bunch of shit welds from the drunk guy, shit can his ass and find someone way more professional about their trade to do the job? My current bike is a TM which is about as hand made as any dirt bike is going to get and I can 100% assure you that every aspect of that bike whether it be the frame, gear box or the rear shock is top notch. 

You are under the misunderstanding that every weld is inspected on a manufacturing line!

1
2
aeffertz
Posts
12590
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
7/29/2023 6:26pm

If you were making it for yourself, would you make it while you are hung over?

30 years in manufacturing and you don’t think quality control would catch a bunch of shit welds from the drunk guy, shit can his ass and...

30 years in manufacturing and you don’t think quality control would catch a bunch of shit welds from the drunk guy, shit can his ass and find someone way more professional about their trade to do the job? My current bike is a TM which is about as hand made as any dirt bike is going to get and I can 100% assure you that every aspect of that bike whether it be the frame, gear box or the rear shock is top notch. 

You are under the misunderstanding that every weld is inspected on a manufacturing line!

How many hypotheticals are you going to present?

"But what if the guy is hungover? And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?" Surely you understand that Triumph isn't some fly by night company, right? Or do you just prefer robots take every job imaginable away from humans? I can print a picture of a painting off my computer through my printer or I could buy the hand painted version. I know which one I would put more value in even if at the end of the day I have the same picture on my wall.

1
7/29/2023 7:12pm
30 years in manufacturing and you don’t think quality control would catch a bunch of shit welds from the drunk guy, shit can his ass and...

30 years in manufacturing and you don’t think quality control would catch a bunch of shit welds from the drunk guy, shit can his ass and find someone way more professional about their trade to do the job? My current bike is a TM which is about as hand made as any dirt bike is going to get and I can 100% assure you that every aspect of that bike whether it be the frame, gear box or the rear shock is top notch. 

You are under the misunderstanding that every weld is inspected on a manufacturing line!

aeffertz wrote:
How many hypotheticals are you going to present? "But what if the guy is hungover? And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?" Surely you understand...

How many hypotheticals are you going to present?

"But what if the guy is hungover? And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?" Surely you understand that Triumph isn't some fly by night company, right? Or do you just prefer robots take every job imaginable away from humans? I can print a picture of a painting off my computer through my printer or I could buy the hand painted version. I know which one I would put more value in even if at the end of the day I have the same picture on my wall.

"But what if the guy is hungover?"

I pointed out that a skilled welder will have off days, if they are hungover the probability of them producing weld defects is higher.

"And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?"

Every weld on every bike will not be inspected, if you worked in manufacturing you would understand not every part is inspected, when parts are inspected not every defect is detected, if you were a welder you would understand some defects can't be detected by visual inspection, Triumph will not be X-Raying and ultrasonic and destructive testing every weld.

"Surely you understand that Triumph isn't some fly by night company, right?"

Triumph is not a fly by night company, but just like every other manufacturer they do not have perfect manufacturing and quality systems, if they did why would they ever recall any product they sold...

https://www.arfc.org/motorcycles/triumph/recalls.aspx

 

https://www.triumphmotorcycles.com/owners/recalls

No manufacturing process is perfect, a skilled welder and a robotic welder will both produce defects, some may be detected, some may not and some defects may get to customers. Some defects will not be noticed by customers, some may be safety critical and catastrophic and they will be noticed. If you've worked in manufacturing you will understand this.

"Or do you just prefer robots take every job imaginable away from humans?"

That's not going to happen, but if it does I pledge loyalty to our AI/robotic overlords.

2
8
bigk218
Posts
1456
Joined
1/2/2018
Location
Summerville, SC, USA
7/29/2023 7:51pm

I’ll just say my curiosity is beyond peaked 

1
mx 219
Posts
4040
Joined
8/15/2010
Location
South Central, PA, USA
7/29/2023 7:51pm

One word.

Fustrating.

philG wrote:

Thats not even a word. 

garagedog wrote:

Ask James if that is a word.

And Ricky

1
7/29/2023 8:06pm

One word.

Fustrating.

philG wrote:

Thats not even a word. 

Actually it is,  its in the urban dictionary.

Maybe it describes some of the posters on this forum!

2
Goldmember
Posts
671
Joined
12/23/2021
Location
Tel Aviv, IL
7/29/2023 9:13pm
bigk218 wrote:

I’ll just say my curiosity is beyond peaked 

'piqued'

2
McG194
Posts
4120
Joined
9/7/2017
Location
Palm Coast, FL, USA
7/29/2023 9:33pm
I've spent 30 years working in manufacturing, that's why I made the comment, if a robot has an issue it will keep repeating until it is...

I've spent 30 years working in manufacturing, that's why I made the comment, if a robot has an issue it will keep repeating until it is caught, a person will make random intermittent mistakes, which makes it more difficult to catch.

FarleyMX25 wrote:

Well I’m a skilled tradesman so I personally wouldn’t have an issue with buying it. I would be more inclined to buy it actually. 

If you were making it for yourself, would you make it while you are hung over?

If you are a "skilled" tradesman then it doesn't matter if you are hung over. I was a precision grinder years ago and if I couldn't hold a 0.0001 tolerance hung over, I'd quit. 

5
2
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
7/29/2023 9:46pm
philG wrote:

Thats not even a word. 

LOL, good catch! Man I must’ve stared at that for like 30 seconds

7/29/2023 9:50pm
FarleyMX25 wrote:

Well I’m a skilled tradesman so I personally wouldn’t have an issue with buying it. I would be more inclined to buy it actually. 

If you were making it for yourself, would you make it while you are hung over?

McG194 wrote:
If you are a "skilled" tradesman then it doesn't matter if you are hung over. I was a precision grinder years ago and if I couldn't...

If you are a "skilled" tradesman then it doesn't matter if you are hung over. I was a precision grinder years ago and if I couldn't hold a 0.0001 tolerance hung over, I'd quit. 

I doubt you are perfect and have never made a mistake.

Chase Sexton, Eli Tomac and Jett Lawrence are all skilled professional motocross racers, but they makes mistake all the time!

It doesn't matter what your skill is or how skilled you are, mistakes happen.

3
aeffertz
Posts
12590
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
7/29/2023 10:38pm

If you were making it for yourself, would you make it while you are hung over?

McG194 wrote:
If you are a "skilled" tradesman then it doesn't matter if you are hung over. I was a precision grinder years ago and if I couldn't...

If you are a "skilled" tradesman then it doesn't matter if you are hung over. I was a precision grinder years ago and if I couldn't hold a 0.0001 tolerance hung over, I'd quit. 

I doubt you are perfect and have never made a mistake. Chase Sexton, Eli Tomac and Jett Lawrence are all skilled professional motocross racers, but they...

I doubt you are perfect and have never made a mistake.

Chase Sexton, Eli Tomac and Jett Lawrence are all skilled professional motocross racers, but they makes mistake all the time!

It doesn't matter what your skill is or how skilled you are, mistakes happen.

And computers have notoriously never failed. Now I see your point!

1
7/29/2023 11:03pm

This video gives me the impression this project is behind schedule. A piece meal presentation like this is atypical for Triumph, but it’s a novel product so the roll out may be a huge tease intentionally. Still, the omission of plastics tells me Triumph still hasn’t settled on the design. A missing engine, more concerningly, tells me the are deciding between prototypes. I applaud them for bringing in the heavyweights to build and test the bike, but I’m a little worried that there may be too many cooks in the kitchen. They’ve made it very clear that they want to avoid the cannondale mistake of bringing a bike to market prematurely and would like to arrive with a competitive bike from day one instead of a work in progress that will be sorted out by gen 2. That’s quite a task and has plenty of pitfalls along the way. 
 

Either way, I hope it shows up on time and is a good bike. 

11
Marty1028
Posts
949
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Lafayette, IN, USA
7/29/2023 11:16pm
"But what if the guy is hungover?" I pointed out that a skilled welder will have off days, if they are hungover the probability of them...

"But what if the guy is hungover?"

I pointed out that a skilled welder will have off days, if they are hungover the probability of them producing weld defects is higher.

"And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?"

Every weld on every bike will not be inspected, if you worked in manufacturing you would understand not every part is inspected, when parts are inspected not every defect is detected, if you were a welder you would understand some defects can't be detected by visual inspection, Triumph will not be X-Raying and ultrasonic and destructive testing every weld.

"Surely you understand that Triumph isn't some fly by night company, right?"

Triumph is not a fly by night company, but just like every other manufacturer they do not have perfect manufacturing and quality systems, if they did why would they ever recall any product they sold...

https://www.arfc.org/motorcycles/triumph/recalls.aspx

 

https://www.triumphmotorcycles.com/owners/recalls

No manufacturing process is perfect, a skilled welder and a robotic welder will both produce defects, some may be detected, some may not and some defects may get to customers. Some defects will not be noticed by customers, some may be safety critical and catastrophic and they will be noticed. If you've worked in manufacturing you will understand this.

"Or do you just prefer robots take every job imaginable away from humans?"

That's not going to happen, but if it does I pledge loyalty to our AI/robotic overlords.

I'm gonna give my 2 cents here, I think the biggest thing here between hand welding these frames and robot welding them is the variation in the welding. There is a higher probability of a human not producing the same weld frame after frame. I work in an automotive factory where everything is welded with Yaskawa robot welders and 95% of the time they are spot-on perfect. I would 100% rather have a frame that's been thrown in a robot and had a QC pass, rather than a special-build frame by the boys at rework that make 18 an hour that just know how to hold a mig stick and they don't know what the knobs on their welder doLaughing

1
2
7/30/2023 12:42am

I feel this bike might be the Cannondale MX400 of this generation 

14
7/30/2023 12:44am
FarleyMX25 wrote:
I think this is a cool way to roll out a new bike. They’re showing you what went into designing it and what all things they...

I think this is a cool way to roll out a new bike. They’re showing you what went into designing it and what all things they took into consideration. I like the hand welding by a skilled tradesman instead of everything being robotically welded that in itself shows me their craftsmanship of building this new bike. 

Would you want to buy the bike if the skilled tradesman was hung over from the previous night?

FarleyMX25 wrote:
Obviously you’ve never worked in any sort of manufacturing facility. You do realize that the car your drive the motorcycle you ride weren’t put together by...

Obviously you’ve never worked in any sort of manufacturing facility. You do realize that the car your drive the motorcycle you ride weren’t put together by a robot completely and there “hung over” workers in there every day. What if the robot has an issue and no one catches it? 

I have a made in England motorcycle and it’s hard to tell what is worse, the handmade “craftsmanship” or the poorly executed aluminum welding that caused many early frames to crack. 

The good part is that these bikes won’t be made in England.

3
Richy
Posts
3093
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK, GB
7/30/2023 1:14am
I have a made in England motorcycle and it’s hard to tell what is worse, the handmade “craftsmanship” or the poorly executed aluminum welding that caused...

I have a made in England motorcycle and it’s hard to tell what is worse, the handmade “craftsmanship” or the poorly executed aluminum welding that caused many early frames to crack. 

The good part is that these bikes won’t be made in England.

To be fair, we can turn out a shit job over here just like any other country, and it's disappointing.

We've (England) got some bodge jobs out there but also produce and supply some of the undisputed best motorsport parts for top level motorsports all around the world.

Unfortunately, like most places we have good and bad 👍

7/30/2023 1:17am
I have a made in England motorcycle and it’s hard to tell what is worse, the handmade “craftsmanship” or the poorly executed aluminum welding that caused...

I have a made in England motorcycle and it’s hard to tell what is worse, the handmade “craftsmanship” or the poorly executed aluminum welding that caused many early frames to crack. 

The good part is that these bikes won’t be made in England.

Richy wrote:
To be fair, we can turn out a shit job over here just like any other country, and it's disappointing. We've (England) got some bodge jobs...

To be fair, we can turn out a shit job over here just like any other country, and it's disappointing.

We've (England) got some bodge jobs out there but also produce and supply some of the undisputed best motorsport parts for top level motorsports all around the world.

Unfortunately, like most places we have good and bad 👍

I’m not complaining, it’s just a fact. 
 

I’ll die with the bike, I just wish it had less character.

1
1
Bearuno
Posts
5377
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
7/30/2023 2:28am

I’m not complaining, it’s just a fact. 
 

I’ll die with the bike, I just wish it had less character.

T595 / 955i, I assume?

7/30/2023 2:35am

You are under the misunderstanding that every weld is inspected on a manufacturing line!

aeffertz wrote:
How many hypotheticals are you going to present? "But what if the guy is hungover? And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?" Surely you understand...

How many hypotheticals are you going to present?

"But what if the guy is hungover? And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?" Surely you understand that Triumph isn't some fly by night company, right? Or do you just prefer robots take every job imaginable away from humans? I can print a picture of a painting off my computer through my printer or I could buy the hand painted version. I know which one I would put more value in even if at the end of the day I have the same picture on my wall.

"But what if the guy is hungover?" I pointed out that a skilled welder will have off days, if they are hungover the probability of them...

"But what if the guy is hungover?"

I pointed out that a skilled welder will have off days, if they are hungover the probability of them producing weld defects is higher.

"And what if the bike doesn't get inspected!?"

Every weld on every bike will not be inspected, if you worked in manufacturing you would understand not every part is inspected, when parts are inspected not every defect is detected, if you were a welder you would understand some defects can't be detected by visual inspection, Triumph will not be X-Raying and ultrasonic and destructive testing every weld.

"Surely you understand that Triumph isn't some fly by night company, right?"

Triumph is not a fly by night company, but just like every other manufacturer they do not have perfect manufacturing and quality systems, if they did why would they ever recall any product they sold...

https://www.arfc.org/motorcycles/triumph/recalls.aspx

 

https://www.triumphmotorcycles.com/owners/recalls

No manufacturing process is perfect, a skilled welder and a robotic welder will both produce defects, some may be detected, some may not and some defects may get to customers. Some defects will not be noticed by customers, some may be safety critical and catastrophic and they will be noticed. If you've worked in manufacturing you will understand this.

"Or do you just prefer robots take every job imaginable away from humans?"

That's not going to happen, but if it does I pledge loyalty to our AI/robotic overlords.

I love a good shear wave

Post a reply to: Triumph September, maybe?

The Latest