Gross Negligence by FELD / AMA

kbsci
Posts
399
Joined
1/7/2024
Location
Richmond, VA US
1/10/2026 8:42pm

This is an airbag, right? That’s exactly where his body hit the ground. I don’t know how it’s triggered but that thing could be what saved his life. Also, the Nicky Hayden butt patch. Justin is a rockstar.

IMG 1262 3IMG 1261 2.jpeg?VersionId=VaH93.Z.QXiX0BGJhJBa2
5
1/10/2026 8:43pm

So after the zing thread we’ve got even more couch quaterbacks in here. 

1
41
ACBailey89
Posts
415
Joined
2/10/2021
Location
Bend, OR US
1/10/2026 8:44pm

To be fair to FELD/AMA it probably seemed longer than it actually was and the first medic was taking care of Mookie and the others getting as fast as they could to barcia. As for the official he probably would of done more harm than good by trying to help.


Just a tough situation that’s impossible to get right. If the medic went to barcia im sure everyone would be losing there minds that Mookie was unattended. Impossible situation that just sucks. Hoping Barcia and Mookie are ok.

8
16
1/10/2026 8:44pm
CPR wrote:
So you watched the video and still claim that communications between officials, track workers, or medics with Barcia may have resulted in him being left unattended...

So you watched the video and still claim that communications between officials, track workers, or medics with Barcia may have resulted in him being left unattended on the track?!

731chopper wrote:

I said y'all have no idea what was said down there. 🤦🏻‍♂️

No one needs to know what was said to see the poor response by ALL, not just the medic crew.  It's not like Barcia told them all to stay away because he wanted to nap for awhile by himself.

13
2

The Shop

Village Idiot
Posts
2384
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW US
1/10/2026 8:45pm
Did you watch the video!!??  You didn’t. Clearly you didn’t.  Or you are an absolute idiot  

Did you watch the video!!??  You didn’t. Clearly you didn’t.  Or you are an absolute idiot  

731chopper wrote:
I did watch the video and don’t believe I’m an absolute idiot. I believe you are letting your emotions get the best of you making a...

I did watch the video and don’t believe I’m an absolute idiot. I believe you are letting your emotions get the best of you making a comment like that to me. 

Y'all use the term as if there's something wrong with it. 🤔

3
1/10/2026 8:46pm

I've seen our local amateur track response to downed riders be 100 fold better than the response to that situation.  Inexcusable.  Hope Bam is ok (reports are he is in pain, but has feeling in all extremities).

13
1
dkg
Posts
1883
Joined
9/12/2010
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA US
1/10/2026 8:48pm
brocster wrote:
I was there. He was left un attended and not moving for a while when all hands were on Malcom, Barcia was just laying there like...

I was there. He was left un attended and not moving for a while when all hands were on Malcom, Barcia was just laying there like a wet rag. Fukn sad!!! 

731chopper wrote:
Well we all saw that and it looks terrible. My point was that we don’t know what was said between the medics or track crew down...

Well we all saw that and it looks terrible. My point was that we don’t know what was said between the medics or track crew down there. I get it that we’re all worried about Justin and emotions are running high but gross negligence is an extreme accusation. 

Appreciate the point you are making, so without accusing anyone of gross negligence or even negligence, it isn’t a good look.

2
1
Leemur891
Posts
387
Joined
5/12/2022
Location
Fort Collins, CO US
Fantasy
1/10/2026 8:48pm

Gutted for JB and praying he is going to be alright. Aside from the head hit, his right leg was basically backwards. At some point you’ve gotta ask whether it’s worth it to keep going.

1
1/10/2026 8:50pm

Clownshow.... that was disgraceful 

8
3
731chopper
Posts
4224
Joined
1/2/2015
Location
DFW, TX US
1/10/2026 8:50pm
No one needs to know what was said to see the poor response by ALL, not just the medic crew.  It's not like Barcia told them...

No one needs to know what was said to see the poor response by ALL, not just the medic crew.  It's not like Barcia told them all to stay away because he wanted to nap for awhile by himself.

I think it’s a good idea to get all of the facts before making a judgement. Maybe they did make a mistake. Maybe there was a lapse of judgement. I, personally, think it’s ridiculous to claim gross negligence without getting all of the facts. 

4
23
yak651
Posts
8552
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI US
Fantasy
1/10/2026 8:52pm
CPR wrote:
So you watched the video and still claim that communications between officials, track workers, or medics with Barcia may have resulted in him being left unattended...

So you watched the video and still claim that communications between officials, track workers, or medics with Barcia may have resulted in him being left unattended on the track?!

731chopper wrote:

I said y'all have no idea what was said down there. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Take the L bro and move on

19
3
1/10/2026 8:54pm
No one needs to know what was said to see the poor response by ALL, not just the medic crew.  It's not like Barcia told them...

No one needs to know what was said to see the poor response by ALL, not just the medic crew.  It's not like Barcia told them all to stay away because he wanted to nap for awhile by himself.

731chopper wrote:
I think it’s a good idea to get all of the facts before making a judgement. Maybe they did make a mistake. Maybe there was a...

I think it’s a good idea to get all of the facts before making a judgement. Maybe they did make a mistake. Maybe there was a lapse of judgement. I, personally, think it’s ridiculous to claim gross negligence without getting all of the facts. 

I think everyone here is just disappointed with the complete lack of response, by anyone, not just the medic crew.  Not one person goes over to him to see if he's even conscious.  He's just laying there for days either trying to move or having a seizure.  I'm not calling negligence at the moment, I'm just calling a very poor response by the whole team down there.

18
1
1/10/2026 8:58pm

Anyone of you been into ground level and seen how hard it is to see across the lanes?

The noise of the bikes the crowd etc.

I’m guessing the medic attending mookie couldn’t see Justin on the ground as there were bikes and riders in the way.

1
11
1/10/2026 9:02pm
Anyone of you been into ground level and seen how hard it is to see across the lanes?The noise of the bikes the crowd etc.I’m guessing...

Anyone of you been into ground level and seen how hard it is to see across the lanes?

The noise of the bikes the crowd etc.

I’m guessing the medic attending mookie couldn’t see Justin on the ground as there were bikes and riders in the way.

I understand your point, but they have radios.  And you can see some of the team guys standing on the sidelines gesturing for help.  

7
1
1/10/2026 9:02pm

Just curious what the keyboard medics think the difference in outcome would have been if medical personnel were attending to Justin faster?  Would his injuries be less? Would his recovery time be quicker? Was the “scene” secure or did it in fact need personnel to block before attending to Justin.  Sounds like reports from riders that he was laying there for a long time after the red flag while medical personnel treated him properly for the suspected injuries.  

I will 100% agree that it looked like the first time that track worker had ever picked up a bike. 

5
22
TG130
Posts
1233
Joined
4/13/2008
Location
US
1/10/2026 9:02pm
davis224 wrote:
I rolled my eyes at the title thinking "what now?", but after watching I'm in agreement. That was maddening to watch. I was scared his bike...

I rolled my eyes at the title thinking "what now?", but after watching I'm in agreement. That was maddening to watch. I was scared his bike was going to whiskey into him when the track worker was picking it up. Anderson seemed like the only person who even saw Barcia laying there.

sumdood wrote:
When I saw the dust from the rear wheel is when I noticed the bike was still running, not trying pile on the guys cause I...

When I saw the dust from the rear wheel is when I noticed the bike was still running, not trying pile on the guys cause I wasn't there but.... who the fuck doesn't hit the kill switch before you try to pick up a downed bike ? Sorry but fuckin dirt dee duuur... that was a clown show. And yeah I've flagged before and I know it's hectic so I'm hesitant to judge, but goddamn come on...

They look like they don't ride at all and have no idea how to handle a motorcycle.

5
2
trwright3
Posts
120
Joined
3/27/2011
Location
Denver, CO US
1/10/2026 9:03pm
Did you watch the video!!??  You didn’t. Clearly you didn’t.  Or you are an absolute idiot  

Did you watch the video!!??  You didn’t. Clearly you didn’t.  Or you are an absolute idiot  

731chopper wrote:
I did watch the video and don’t believe I’m an absolute idiot. I believe you are letting your emotions get the best of you making a...

I did watch the video and don’t believe I’m an absolute idiot. I believe you are letting your emotions get the best of you making a comment like that to me. 

Na your an absolute idiot bro. 

5
5
1/10/2026 9:04pm
No one needs to know what was said to see the poor response by ALL, not just the medic crew.  It's not like Barcia told them...

No one needs to know what was said to see the poor response by ALL, not just the medic crew.  It's not like Barcia told them all to stay away because he wanted to nap for awhile by himself.

731chopper wrote:
I think it’s a good idea to get all of the facts before making a judgement. Maybe they did make a mistake. Maybe there was a...

I think it’s a good idea to get all of the facts before making a judgement. Maybe they did make a mistake. Maybe there was a lapse of judgement. I, personally, think it’s ridiculous to claim gross negligence without getting all of the facts. 

I think everyone here is just disappointed with the complete lack of response, by anyone, not just the medic crew.  Not one person goes over to...

I think everyone here is just disappointed with the complete lack of response, by anyone, not just the medic crew.  Not one person goes over to him to see if he's even conscious.  He's just laying there for days either trying to move or having a seizure.  I'm not calling negligence at the moment, I'm just calling a very poor response by the whole team down there.

And then add the dirt digger almost sending Bams bike into him because he didn’t hit the kill switch… how many times are they just going to allow that to happen?

Im sure the medic that attended to Mookie first would see this video and kick himself. I can’t imagine being in the situation, Im not a first responder so Im trying to have some grace, but it atleast shows there is absolutely room to improve on situational assessment on the staff/team there.

Now the other complete lack of response and the dirt diggers poor decision making is ridiculous and unacceptable to me.

15
1
soggy
Posts
8422
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
UT US
1/10/2026 9:06pm

God Damn please tell me Barcia is okay....looks like his body is trying to move but misfiring.  Horrible to watch.

It looked like his left leg did move a tiny bit at one point so I’m hoping for the best. 

1
1/10/2026 9:06pm
Leemur891 wrote:
Gutted for JB and praying he is going to be alright. Aside from the head hit, his right leg was basically backwards. At some point you’ve...

Gutted for JB and praying he is going to be alright. Aside from the head hit, his right leg was basically backwards. At some point you’ve gotta ask whether it’s worth it to keep going.

My fiance thought the same thing -- that Barcia's right leg looked backwards.  I think that was an optical illusion.  I even grabbed my Alpinestars boots to show her where the shin logos are to illustrate that Barcia's toes were all pointed the right direction.

1
1/10/2026 9:07pm

Ouch!!

1/10/2026 9:07pm

The person trying to pick up the bike, was that a female? I can't imagine they only hire guys. But whoever it was sure struggled.

6
maxer
Posts
240
Joined
12/9/2020
Location
Grapevine, TX US
Fantasy
1/10/2026 9:08pm
Anyone of you been into ground level and seen how hard it is to see across the lanes?The noise of the bikes the crowd etc.I’m guessing...

Anyone of you been into ground level and seen how hard it is to see across the lanes?

The noise of the bikes the crowd etc.

I’m guessing the medic attending mookie couldn’t see Justin on the ground as there were bikes and riders in the way.

Then get more medics. Get trained track crew. Implement a better radio system. WE point this shit out so it gets FIXED. You don't just throw your hands up like a fucking idiot and go "shit happens I guess"

these promoters make more than enough money to have a better solution

25
2
1/10/2026 9:08pm

Perhaps Mookie being the first downed rider that the other riders would encounter on the next lap dictated that he get seen to first, especially being in a blind spot.

3
1/10/2026 9:09pm

The first chapter in EMT class is about medical ethics and standard of care. 

Once you have your hands on a patient, you have a responsibility to stay with them until passed off to a higher standard of care. 

Whatever that FD(?) guy learned after moving Barcia (!) would dictate hold manual C-spine until help arrives.

Yet, there he is standing on the side of the track while his patient lay all alone.

 

Another notch on the A-Stars/Asterisk/Bodnar belt.

 

16
5
Village Idiot
Posts
2384
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW US
1/10/2026 9:10pm
Did you watch the video!!??  You didn’t. Clearly you didn’t.  Or you are an absolute idiot  

Did you watch the video!!??  You didn’t. Clearly you didn’t.  Or you are an absolute idiot  

731chopper wrote:
I did watch the video and don’t believe I’m an absolute idiot. I believe you are letting your emotions get the best of you making a...

I did watch the video and don’t believe I’m an absolute idiot. I believe you are letting your emotions get the best of you making a comment like that to me. 

trwright3 wrote:

Na your an absolute idiot bro. 

Don't recall seeing him at the family reunion... 🤔

1
3
maxer
Posts
240
Joined
12/9/2020
Location
Grapevine, TX US
Fantasy
1/10/2026 9:12pm
kylemenz1 wrote:
Just curious what the keyboard medics think the difference in outcome would have been if medical personnel were attending to Justin faster?  Would his injuries be...

Just curious what the keyboard medics think the difference in outcome would have been if medical personnel were attending to Justin faster?  Would his injuries be less? Would his recovery time be quicker? Was the “scene” secure or did it in fact need personnel to block before attending to Justin.  Sounds like reports from riders that he was laying there for a long time after the red flag while medical personnel treated him properly for the suspected injuries.  

I will 100% agree that it looked like the first time that track worker had ever picked up a bike. 

I'm no expert but I'll go out on a limb and say getting to a guy unresponsive having what looks to be a seizure is probably pretty fucking time sensitive. Genius

15
4
truck
Posts
3463
Joined
6/10/2015
Location
Louisville, KY US
Fantasy
1/10/2026 9:17pm
CPR wrote:
So you watched the video and still claim that communications between officials, track workers, or medics with Barcia may have resulted in him being left unattended...

So you watched the video and still claim that communications between officials, track workers, or medics with Barcia may have resulted in him being left unattended on the track?!

731chopper wrote:

I said y'all have no idea what was said down there. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Give me your best hypothetical conversation that makes it OK to not attend to him for that long. 

Just admit you spouted off before you watched the video..... 

2
4
SoCalMX70
Posts
3445
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA US
1/10/2026 9:18pm
731chopper wrote:
I think it’s a good idea to get all of the facts before making a judgement. Maybe they did make a mistake. Maybe there was a...

I think it’s a good idea to get all of the facts before making a judgement. Maybe they did make a mistake. Maybe there was a lapse of judgement. I, personally, think it’s ridiculous to claim gross negligence without getting all of the facts. 

I think everyone here is just disappointed with the complete lack of response, by anyone, not just the medic crew.  Not one person goes over to...

I think everyone here is just disappointed with the complete lack of response, by anyone, not just the medic crew.  Not one person goes over to him to see if he's even conscious.  He's just laying there for days either trying to move or having a seizure.  I'm not calling negligence at the moment, I'm just calling a very poor response by the whole team down there.

m121c wrote:
And then add the dirt digger almost sending Bams bike into him because he didn’t hit the kill switch… how many times are they just going...

And then add the dirt digger almost sending Bams bike into him because he didn’t hit the kill switch… how many times are they just going to allow that to happen?

Im sure the medic that attended to Mookie first would see this video and kick himself. I can’t imagine being in the situation, Im not a first responder so Im trying to have some grace, but it atleast shows there is absolutely room to improve on situational assessment on the staff/team there.

Now the other complete lack of response and the dirt diggers poor decision making is ridiculous and unacceptable to me.

You know, it wouldn't hurt to have a rule where every bike has to have a minimum size red button for a killswitch in the same place (I know a lot of the teams move their buttons).

Then, as part of whatever orientation the track crew and EMTs get, have them all shut off a running bike. Just an idea... I'll let you experts workshop it.

9
2
731chopper
Posts
4224
Joined
1/2/2015
Location
DFW, TX US
1/10/2026 9:19pm
trwright3 wrote:

Na your an absolute idiot bro. 

Coming from the guy who can’t spell, that hurts. 

7
Post a reply to: Gross Negligence by FELD / AMA

This forum thread has been locked.

The Latest