RC, JS, or JL

RC!

I mean, RC was willing to die for wins. You cant bet against that. I really feel he would have found a way... flying W and all.

JS and JL have a "reputation" and "style" to "protect"... RC gave no fu-ks. He just twisted it farther and held on. 

I can't bet against RC

Idk, but I’d give my left nut to watch it. 

There is a reason why pretty much everyone said  "never bet against RC"

Would be a hell of a show, but impossible to bet against RC. James quit MX in his prime, who knows the levels he could have brought it too and Jett is young as well and growing but there is no world where I see AP and J coop being a challenge to prime RC or James. 

Lawrence

Right or wrong, it also seems like a different mentality. Jett is a bad dude on a dirt bike, but RC was the guy who started what we know as the current landscape in moto. 

Pretty sure Carmichael was still winning when he called it quits, imagine if he raced for another 5 years.

If we’re talking all Rookie or sophomore seasons, I think statistically Jett. (After 17 career starts JL -16wins, RC-11 wins, JS-2 Wins)

If we’re talking all of them in their prime, we won’t know what version of Jett was prime until he’s done.  Even ET3 took years beyond 2015 to look back and see his peak.  I believe he himself claims that he’s as fast and fit as he’s ever been currently.  So hard to compare anyone who is currently young and winning to other folks prime which has passed.

You left out Chad Reed. Only one of the bunch still racing...and just smoked the field qualifying for Loretta's. He's smoke the others you mentioned, at least right now.

The op didn’t leave Reed out, Reed never had an undefeated season. The riders mentioned are the only ones to have an undefeated season lol.

Chad is awesome and I love the dude as much as anyone, but I don’t know if his vet class regional results put him in the same ballpark as these 3 in their prime outdoors 

RC all day, every day. 

RC all day long. The dude is willing to full throttle out of a massive swap. Go back and watch him and James at southwick. To much grit outdoors and would find the way to hand Jett his you know what. He did the same thing with James.

Like everyone else said, RC would die for the win. Literally all fucks to be given are off the table, RC is going to win that.

If they're on two-strokes I'm going with Stew. RC never had to ride a 250 against him. Unpopular opinion, but I think the 259 is the best a 125 and 250 have ever been ridden.

All in the absolute peak of their career? Give kx250 James a 4stroke and watch him school those boys with pure agression.

Realistically Stewart and RC brains would have turned to mush trying to contemplate what Jett was even doing to them with his race craft. 

RC all day....he didn't love winning as much as he despised losing. 

As much as I love all 3 and especially love the way Jett rides, I'd have to say RC. He could consistently beat JS7, and JS7 would win or wreck trying. 

It would be interesting to see Jett go balls out for one or two motos, since that was all RC and JS knew 😂

Deegan passes all of them with 5 minutes left in the moto, thanks his haters, and humps an inflatable goat on the podium. Sick.

RV

Dude had his hands full with Reed in 2011. He ain't beating Ricky outdoors.

RC would hunt Jettson down, chew him up and spit him out! This is coming from a HUUUGE Bubba fan. RC is the baddest and will always be THE baddest dude ever on a motocross track.

lolololol!

Hands down, Stewart all day everyday! Most talented of the three. 

Your not wrong.

🤯

The only time Chad would be near those three outdoors is on the gate.