Eli out at Yamaha?

MOTO13
Posts
493
Joined
12/22/2017
Location
Elkhorn, WI US
4/22/2025 7:22am

Eli on a steel framed KTM? I hope they have lots of frames. I don't see him wanting any part of that bike.

10
13
tomlopez
Posts
1161
Joined
5/2/2021
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL US
Fantasy
4/22/2025 7:48am

2017-2020 Eli spanks this version. In speed, that is. This Eli is tougher mentally and hes a better starter on the Yamaha. 

tomlopez wrote:
I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if...

I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if not slightly faster). Several riders have stated that the level has gone up in the past few seasons, so if anything, I think current Tomac might be faster than prime Kawasaki Tomac.

CPR wrote:
Tomac was faster than Webb earlier this year, but Roczen? Kenny finished in front of and had faster lap times than Eli in two of the...

Tomac was faster than Webb earlier this year, but Roczen? Kenny finished in front of and had faster lap times than Eli in two of the first three rounds. The fourth round was a triple crown, again Roczen beat Tomac in two of the three races.

 

Tomac's finishing positions were less than impressive because of horrendous starts. In every race, he was moving through the field at a rate nobody else could match. He went from last to 5th at A1, waxed the entire field (including beating Kenny by over 10 sec) at SD with Jett, and at Glendale, he had that insane Main Event 2 ride where he went from near last to 4th in like 10 minutes, and then destroyed the field in the final main. The only round where the speed wasn't blow-your-doors off impressive was A2. He started around like 15th I think, and only got up to 6th or 7th, and it took all moto for him to make up that ground. Still not a bad finishing position when taking into account his start.

19
alphado
Posts
4034
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Erie, PA US
4/22/2025 8:46am

Forced retirement?

9
stewie94
Posts
4637
Joined
2/25/2013
Location
La Plata, MD US
4/22/2025 8:47am
MOTO13 wrote:
I think we can all agree for the most part, Yamaha letting Eli go is a really bad idea. I'm still stunned Star would even consider...

I think we can all agree for the most part, Yamaha letting Eli go is a really bad idea. I'm still stunned Star would even consider it. 

no its not cause they have deegs as their future , this isn’t a bill belicheck / tom brady situation where they let tom go Tampa & now the pats for the last 3 to 4 seasons been stuck in QB hell , star already got their Eli & coop replacement in deegs 

7

The Shop

4/22/2025 9:35am

If I'm Star for 26, I keep Coop and Eli as they are my two best shots at titles. I also keep JCoop, but I move him into CC's spot on the same bike, but under the 250 tent(or whatever that whole deal is). Then for 26 outdoors, Deegs moves up to the 450 outdoors next to JCoop. Towards the middle/end of outdoors 26 I see where everyone is and how the years gone to decide which way to go for 27.

7
4
tomlopez
Posts
1161
Joined
5/2/2021
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL US
Fantasy
4/22/2025 9:39am
mattyhamz2 wrote:
If I'm Star for 26, I keep Coop and Eli as they are my two best shots at titles. I also keep JCoop, but I move...

If I'm Star for 26, I keep Coop and Eli as they are my two best shots at titles. I also keep JCoop, but I move him into CC's spot on the same bike, but under the 250 tent(or whatever that whole deal is). Then for 26 outdoors, Deegs moves up to the 450 outdoors next to JCoop. Towards the middle/end of outdoors 26 I see where everyone is and how the years gone to decide which way to go for 27.

I just don't think JCoop would take that kind of deal. He has earned a pay increase, and it sounds like that's what he's getting. With all the uncertainty surrounding Tomac, Webb's inability to compete in outdoors, and not knowing how Deegan will look in his first year or two on a 450, I think it's a good idea to keep JCoop around for another couple years. He's proven to be halfway decent in SX, and is a really solid MX rider. He's a good close-to-guaranteed top 5ish finisher for the time being.

4
2
JazzyJJ
Posts
1761
Joined
12/1/2020
Location
Nunya, WY US
4/22/2025 9:44am
mattyhamz2 wrote:
If I'm Star for 26, I keep Coop and Eli as they are my two best shots at titles. I also keep JCoop, but I move...

If I'm Star for 26, I keep Coop and Eli as they are my two best shots at titles. I also keep JCoop, but I move him into CC's spot on the same bike, but under the 250 tent(or whatever that whole deal is). Then for 26 outdoors, Deegs moves up to the 450 outdoors next to JCoop. Towards the middle/end of outdoors 26 I see where everyone is and how the years gone to decide which way to go for 27.

tomlopez wrote:
I just don't think JCoop would take that kind of deal. He has earned a pay increase, and it sounds like that's what he's getting. With...

I just don't think JCoop would take that kind of deal. He has earned a pay increase, and it sounds like that's what he's getting. With all the uncertainty surrounding Tomac, Webb's inability to compete in outdoors, and not knowing how Deegan will look in his first year or two on a 450, I think it's a good idea to keep JCoop around for another couple years. He's proven to be halfway decent in SX, and is a really solid MX rider. He's a good close-to-guaranteed top 5ish finisher for the time being.

Put Webb on a SX only deal. Seems like that's what he wants anyway 

21
AZ35
Posts
2899
Joined
6/1/2008
Location
Peoria, AZ US
Fantasy
4/22/2025 9:53am

Pretty crazy to think that Sexton, Tomac, Anderson, Stewart, and Barcia might all be switching teams/brands next year.

Half of the top 10 on new rides, cannot recall a past year with so many team changes (if they happen).

7
ForToo
Posts
364
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
WI US
4/22/2025 10:04am

It surely won't be an ugly separation.  Star Yamaha needs to focus on 450  budget allocation for '26 and beyond; leaving substantial dollars on the table for a waffling retirement isn't feasible.  Eli knows this and regardless of where he lands, it'll be lucrative and hopefully successful.

Phil109
Posts
635
Joined
7/7/2019
Location
Montgomery, TX US
4/22/2025 10:37am

What about Eli going back to Kawi if the sexton deal falls through? Did they end on bad terms? I don’t recall. Maybe this has been brought up but I didn’t read the whole thread. 

1
8
tomlopez
Posts
1161
Joined
5/2/2021
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL US
Fantasy
4/22/2025 12:04pm
Phil109 wrote:
What about Eli going back to Kawi if the sexton deal falls through? Did they end on bad terms? I don’t recall. Maybe this has been...

What about Eli going back to Kawi if the sexton deal falls through? Did they end on bad terms? I don’t recall. Maybe this has been brought up but I didn’t read the whole thread. 

It sounds like Kawasaki didn't give Tomac enough freedom to make the bike changes that he wanted. I don't think it was necessarily due to the people he worked with face-to-face at the test track, but rather those in corporate across the Pacific. He also prefers a cable clutch, so that was a big selling point for the YZ over staying on the KX. Other than that, I don't think there were any known issues between him and Kawasaki. I don't think there were money issues - everyone says he took a pay cut to go to Star back in 2022.

4
4
4/22/2025 2:17pm
parkman wrote:
When was he faster? Pre-shoulder injury in 2015 MX? It wasn't just his win in San Diego, they remember his speed. The results didn't show...

When was he faster? Pre-shoulder injury in 2015 MX? It wasn't just his win in San Diego, they remember his speed. The results didn't show the full story, tip over, starts etc., but more often than not, he was the fastest guy on the track and you could visibly see it. To validate that claim, in 3 out of 4 races, he had the fastest lap and he had more passes than any other rider. Did anyone actually pass him in a race all year? If I recall correctly, I actually am not sure anyone did. To me, he looked 100% like the Beast mode of old. 

2017-2020 Eli spanks this version. In speed, that is. This Eli is tougher mentally and hes a better starter on the Yamaha. 

tomlopez wrote:
I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if...

I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if not slightly faster). Several riders have stated that the level has gone up in the past few seasons, so if anything, I think current Tomac might be faster than prime Kawasaki Tomac.

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the stats. He had 5 straight wins and managed the end of the year over Anderson. I still put '17 Eli as his peak speed. Dunge dieseled his way to the title but he had nothing for Eli

7
ACBraap
Posts
1165
Joined
2/10/2012
Location
Seattlish, WA US
Fantasy
4/22/2025 2:35pm
wnorton729 wrote:
I wonder if Star and Yamaha are rethinking the Webb signing now that sexton just put 20 seconds on him in a sx race… Not to...

I wonder if Star and Yamaha are rethinking the Webb signing now that sexton just put 20 seconds on him in a sx race… Not to mention, if somehow he loses this title.

Not a chance in hell that Sexton would have done that to Tomac. 

I like Coop, but I just don’t see him having staying power when all the big dogs are on the gate and healthy. Not to mention for 3 more years..

I don’t and never will run a factory Mx team, but if I did… Hell would freeze over before I even thought about letting Eli Tomac walk. 

ando wrote:
Hypothetical for your factory team - Eli is asking double what Webb is.  Webb has been in the SX title hunt all the way in both...

Hypothetical for your factory team - Eli is asking double what Webb is.  Webb has been in the SX title hunt all the way in both 2024 and 2025.  Eli hadn’t finished a full championship in either SX or MX the last two years.  Do you still pay Eli whatever he’s asking?  

As race fans, we think of this question as whether the riders race results justify their salary.  The question to a brand has to be 'does this rider on our bike, with the expected results they will achieve, increase our sales relative to what the rider cost'.  Yeah, I think Tomac sells more bikes than Webb..

9
CPR
Posts
6565
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
4/22/2025 2:46pm
tomlopez wrote:
I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if...

I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if not slightly faster). Several riders have stated that the level has gone up in the past few seasons, so if anything, I think current Tomac might be faster than prime Kawasaki Tomac.

CPR wrote:
Tomac was faster than Webb earlier this year, but Roczen? Kenny finished in front of and had faster lap times than Eli in two of the...

Tomac was faster than Webb earlier this year, but Roczen? Kenny finished in front of and had faster lap times than Eli in two of the first three rounds. The fourth round was a triple crown, again Roczen beat Tomac in two of the three races.

 

tomlopez wrote:
Tomac's finishing positions were less than impressive because of horrendous starts. In every race, he was moving through the field at a rate nobody else could...

Tomac's finishing positions were less than impressive because of horrendous starts. In every race, he was moving through the field at a rate nobody else could match. He went from last to 5th at A1, waxed the entire field (including beating Kenny by over 10 sec) at SD with Jett, and at Glendale, he had that insane Main Event 2 ride where he went from near last to 4th in like 10 minutes, and then destroyed the field in the final main. The only round where the speed wasn't blow-your-doors off impressive was A2. He started around like 15th I think, and only got up to 6th or 7th, and it took all moto for him to make up that ground. Still not a bad finishing position when taking into account his start.

I’m not arguing that Tomac wasn’t impressive, or fast, but just stating facts; Roczen beat Tomac and had a faster fastest lap time in 66% of the early rounds. 
You stated that Tomac was “faster by a decent margin”. Without any subjective opinions,  the facts say he was in some races but not in others. That is all.

1
9
visser62
Posts
2445
Joined
5/2/2013
Location
Seattle, WA US
4/22/2025 2:50pm

As others have said, it'd be pretty damn cool to see #3 and #94 together on Suzuki.

17
4/22/2025 2:59pm

Has Team Hurricane called yet?

3
stewie94
Posts
4637
Joined
2/25/2013
Location
La Plata, MD US
4/22/2025 4:07pm

2017-2020 Eli spanks this version. In speed, that is. This Eli is tougher mentally and hes a better starter on the Yamaha. 

tomlopez wrote:
I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if...

I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if not slightly faster). Several riders have stated that the level has gone up in the past few seasons, so if anything, I think current Tomac might be faster than prime Kawasaki Tomac.

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the...

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the stats. He had 5 straight wins and managed the end of the year over Anderson. I still put '17 Eli as his peak speed. Dunge dieseled his way to the title but he had nothing for Eli

Eli tweaking his knee at ATL kinda put Eli in manage mode  forreal forreal , if it wasent for tht knee , he might’ve had snuck in 1 or 2 more wins 

9
2
4/22/2025 7:02pm
tomlopez wrote:
I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if...

I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if not slightly faster). Several riders have stated that the level has gone up in the past few seasons, so if anything, I think current Tomac might be faster than prime Kawasaki Tomac.

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the...

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the stats. He had 5 straight wins and managed the end of the year over Anderson. I still put '17 Eli as his peak speed. Dunge dieseled his way to the title but he had nothing for Eli

stewie94 wrote:
Eli tweaking his knee at ATL kinda put Eli in manage mode  forreal forreal , if it wasent for tht knee , he might’ve had snuck...

Eli tweaking his knee at ATL kinda put Eli in manage mode  forreal forreal , if it wasent for tht knee , he might’ve had snuck in 1 or 2 more wins 

Yup, you jogged my memory. I do remember him starting '22 mx a little banged up

3
4/22/2025 7:26pm
wnorton729 wrote:
I wonder if Star and Yamaha are rethinking the Webb signing now that sexton just put 20 seconds on him in a sx race… Not to...

I wonder if Star and Yamaha are rethinking the Webb signing now that sexton just put 20 seconds on him in a sx race… Not to mention, if somehow he loses this title.

Not a chance in hell that Sexton would have done that to Tomac. 

I like Coop, but I just don’t see him having staying power when all the big dogs are on the gate and healthy. Not to mention for 3 more years..

I don’t and never will run a factory Mx team, but if I did… Hell would freeze over before I even thought about letting Eli Tomac walk. 

ando wrote:
Hypothetical for your factory team - Eli is asking double what Webb is.  Webb has been in the SX title hunt all the way in both...

Hypothetical for your factory team - Eli is asking double what Webb is.  Webb has been in the SX title hunt all the way in both 2024 and 2025.  Eli hadn’t finished a full championship in either SX or MX the last two years.  Do you still pay Eli whatever he’s asking?  

ACBraap wrote:
As race fans, we think of this question as whether the riders race results justify their salary.  The question to a brand has to be 'does...

As race fans, we think of this question as whether the riders race results justify their salary.  The question to a brand has to be 'does this rider on our bike, with the expected results they will achieve, increase our sales relative to what the rider cost'.  Yeah, I think Tomac sells more bikes than Webb..

You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what bike at the time.  Never ever crosses my mind.  I have many times purchased products of sponsors who were sponsoring specific riders and still do to this day.  I have no explanation why that is.

21
1
CPR
Posts
6565
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
4/22/2025 9:32pm
TbonesPop wrote:
You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what...

You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what bike at the time.  Never ever crosses my mind.  I have many times purchased products of sponsors who were sponsoring specific riders and still do to this day.  I have no explanation why that is.

Shhh don’t tell the manufacturers that 😂

8
ando
Posts
4103
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth AU
4/22/2025 10:52pm

I’m sure no-one including Eli saw the last couple of years playing out this way.  

Nonetheless if it was a slam dunk to re-sign him it would already have been done.

1
2
Mavetism
Posts
5673
Joined
4/15/2019
Location
Hannover DE
4/22/2025 11:08pm
AZ35 wrote:
Pretty crazy to think that Sexton, Tomac, Anderson, Stewart, and Barcia might all be switching teams/brands next year.Half of the top 10 on new rides, cannot...

Pretty crazy to think that Sexton, Tomac, Anderson, Stewart, and Barcia might all be switching teams/brands next year.

Half of the top 10 on new rides, cannot recall a past year with so many team changes (if they happen).

Which is pretty cool when we look back a couple years when people thought most of them would be retired by now.

1
Mavetism
Posts
5673
Joined
4/15/2019
Location
Hannover DE
4/22/2025 11:12pm

2017-2020 Eli spanks this version. In speed, that is. This Eli is tougher mentally and hes a better starter on the Yamaha. 

tomlopez wrote:
I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if...

I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if not slightly faster). Several riders have stated that the level has gone up in the past few seasons, so if anything, I think current Tomac might be faster than prime Kawasaki Tomac.

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the...

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the stats. He had 5 straight wins and managed the end of the year over Anderson. I still put '17 Eli as his peak speed. Dunge dieseled his way to the title but he had nothing for Eli

Remember that he always had to come from behind in 2017-2019 compared to 2022 where he was pretty much the best avg starter all of the sudden. He didn't need to bring his peak speed. I do think though 2023 A1 Tomac was the fastest Tomac we have ever seen in SX, that was ridiculous.

1
4/23/2025 4:28am
tomlopez wrote:
I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if...

I disagree. He was faster than Webb and Roczen by a decent margin to start 2025, and was on par with Jett and Chase's speed (if not slightly faster). Several riders have stated that the level has gone up in the past few seasons, so if anything, I think current Tomac might be faster than prime Kawasaki Tomac.

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the...

I think there's an argument for '22 Tomac being comparable to his best Kawi years. I didn't realize how good he was until I checked the stats. He had 5 straight wins and managed the end of the year over Anderson. I still put '17 Eli as his peak speed. Dunge dieseled his way to the title but he had nothing for Eli

Mavetism wrote:
Remember that he always had to come from behind in 2017-2019 compared to 2022 where he was pretty much the best avg starter all of the...

Remember that he always had to come from behind in 2017-2019 compared to 2022 where he was pretty much the best avg starter all of the sudden. He didn't need to bring his peak speed. I do think though 2023 A1 Tomac was the fastest Tomac we have ever seen in SX, that was ridiculous.

God damn, that's a great point. Yeah his starts got drastically better on the Star bike. Ok, you guys are selling me here and pointing out some solid observations lol. Starts were really his biggest issue this sex season before he got hurt, too. The last time we saw him getting starts that bad he was on the Kawi. Odd 

2
dang472
Posts
605
Joined
6/26/2014
Location
Kingston, IL US
Fantasy
4/23/2025 5:49am
TbonesPop wrote:
You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what...

You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what bike at the time.  Never ever crosses my mind.  I have many times purchased products of sponsors who were sponsoring specific riders and still do to this day.  I have no explanation why that is.

CPR wrote:

Shhh don’t tell the manufacturers that 😂

I will say that kids seem to be influenced by what the pros race (at least mine are a little). At 15, I started racing Suzukis because of Pastrana and contingency and haven’t stopped since. My 14yr old wanted a Honda like Jett but they missed the boat to capture a customer because their mini bike sucks. My Illinois boys are riding KX minis and are excited about Chase going green. That might follow them until they’re buying their own bikes.

12
4/23/2025 6:10am
TbonesPop wrote:
You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what...

You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what bike at the time.  Never ever crosses my mind.  I have many times purchased products of sponsors who were sponsoring specific riders and still do to this day.  I have no explanation why that is.

CPR wrote:

Shhh don’t tell the manufacturers that 😂

dang472 wrote:
I will say that kids seem to be influenced by what the pros race (at least mine are a little). At 15, I started racing Suzukis...

I will say that kids seem to be influenced by what the pros race (at least mine are a little). At 15, I started racing Suzukis because of Pastrana and contingency and haven’t stopped since. My 14yr old wanted a Honda like Jett but they missed the boat to capture a customer because their mini bike sucks. My Illinois boys are riding KX minis and are excited about Chase going green. That might follow them until they’re buying their own bikes.

I wasn't really getting into the discussion of which rider sells the most bikes but I agree with you. If anyone is buying bikes based on a rider, it's the younger demographic. I'm 47. What my favorite rider rides is at the bottom of the list when I'm choosing which bike I buy. Is it arguable that Haiden is the most popular rider on either gate? And it's a younger fanbase that will probably want a Yamaha because of him. JMO

5
Lastander
Posts
1232
Joined
10/9/2016
Location
SE
4/23/2025 6:41am

What if he takes KC Carlyle’s spot at Nami????

IMG 2855 3
19
Racerman967
Posts
660
Joined
1/1/2019
Location
Littleton, CO US
4/23/2025 9:42am

Everybody keep saying why would Star do this. It is not Star's decision. The factory pays for the 450 team, Star just runs it. If Yamaha has a rider budget and Yamaha does not want to commit to that then someone is going. Just a business decision. If they do not want to spend the money to have Cooper/ Eli and possibly Deegan then one will go away. And unfortunately the 30+year old rider is going to lose out to the 19/20 year old. Happens in all sports

skeef
Posts
1435
Joined
7/18/2018
Location
AZ US
Fantasy
4/23/2025 2:25pm

Can we argue about who sells the most bikes yet?

1
1
ohh_454
Posts
2693
Joined
6/24/2023
Location
Nuevo, CA US
Fantasy
4/23/2025 2:31pm
ando wrote:
Hypothetical for your factory team - Eli is asking double what Webb is.  Webb has been in the SX title hunt all the way in both...

Hypothetical for your factory team - Eli is asking double what Webb is.  Webb has been in the SX title hunt all the way in both 2024 and 2025.  Eli hadn’t finished a full championship in either SX or MX the last two years.  Do you still pay Eli whatever he’s asking?  

ACBraap wrote:
As race fans, we think of this question as whether the riders race results justify their salary.  The question to a brand has to be 'does...

As race fans, we think of this question as whether the riders race results justify their salary.  The question to a brand has to be 'does this rider on our bike, with the expected results they will achieve, increase our sales relative to what the rider cost'.  Yeah, I think Tomac sells more bikes than Webb..

TbonesPop wrote:
You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what...

You know what strikes me as odd.  I have never once in my life ever purchased a bike based on what pro rider was riding what bike at the time.  Never ever crosses my mind.  I have many times purchased products of sponsors who were sponsoring specific riders and still do to this day.  I have no explanation why that is.

Hey I wanted to ride Kawis as a kid cause my favorite rider was Emig. Maybe a kids favorite rider has some kind of influence in the parents decision on what they buy? 

4

Post a reply to: Eli out at Yamaha?

The Latest