Kawasaki smoker needs to lead to rule change

2/1/2025 4:20pm
Moto Nomad wrote:

Wouldn't it make more sense to do classes based on horsepower, not displacement? 

In amateur racing, doesn't it make more sense to do classes based on rider speed, not the bike?

3
Spoonguy
Posts
3522
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA, USA
2/1/2025 4:22pm

I own a 250 4T and 250 2T as well as the wife's 350 4T. I never really timed it out, but I swear I am faster on the 4T. Less wheelspin, better throttle to rear wheel connection, more "planted". So in the 250 class, I really don't think equalizing the displacement rule would change anything, 450 class might be a different matter though. I remember KTM 380s, Husky 390s, RM 370s, always thought that was a killer engine package. That being said the 2T is gobs more fun and if Kawi makes a 300 2T I will buy one.

1
1
2/1/2025 5:27pm
I think that we should simply have a:Open Class (ride whatever you like, up to 500cc combustion only)250 4 stroke Pro Class (with 250 2 stroke...

I think that we should simply have a:

Open Class (ride whatever you like, up to 500cc combustion only)

250 4 stroke Pro Class (with 250 2 stroke allowed, no motor work (or simple mods only), privateers only.

125 2 stroke development class

Electric only class, no limits

That would be an amazing day at the races to watch that.

LungButter wrote:

Define: Privateer

Well, essentially no direct factory support and some type of budget cap. The "typical" situation would be single rider efforts, riders who are directly sponsored by companies, but not directly by manufacturers (except for perhaps discounts or on their contingency program). It is pretty easy to define. The only wiggle room are teams who still get called privateers.... Rock River Yamaha is not a privateer effort.

2
jock
Posts
1667
Joined
9/25/2006
Location
Postmans Ridge, QLD, AU
Fantasy
2/1/2025 7:18pm

Why does it need to be production bike?

Because motogp style bikes on the start line would make being a privateer in the main event impossible. We can’t do that in our sport.

The last year works bikes were allowed was 1985, Rick Johnson won the championship on a production based YZ250...racing against Honda's $100,000 works RC250RC...Privateers raced the...

The last year works bikes were allowed was 1985, Rick Johnson won the championship on a production based YZ250...

s1600 Rick Johnson LA Coliseum SX 1985-3978525574.jpg?VersionId=csAT9NorbqDKXp

racing against Honda's $100,000 works RC250RC...

1985 RC250M 44

Privateers raced the main events in 1985, it's not the bike, it's the rider.

Jeff Ward won the 85 title on a Kawasaki SR250 factory bike.

4
1

The Shop

2/1/2025 7:35pm

Because motogp style bikes on the start line would make being a privateer in the main event impossible. We can’t do that in our sport.

The last year works bikes were allowed was 1985, Rick Johnson won the championship on a production based YZ250...racing against Honda's $100,000 works RC250RC...Privateers raced the...

The last year works bikes were allowed was 1985, Rick Johnson won the championship on a production based YZ250...

s1600 Rick Johnson LA Coliseum SX 1985-3978525574.jpg?VersionId=csAT9NorbqDKXp

racing against Honda's $100,000 works RC250RC...

1985 RC250M 44

Privateers raced the main events in 1985, it's not the bike, it's the rider.

jock wrote:

Jeff Ward won the 85 title on a Kawasaki SR250 factory bike.

My mistake, Johnson won the 1984 Motocross Championship on a production based bike.

2
1
2/14/2025 12:16pm
jmo443 wrote:

Santa clause is going to be a real life person before any of this happens….

What, Santa,s not real?

2
1
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
2/14/2025 12:43pm
Pop Shmoke wrote:
With rumors that the new kx 2 smoker will be a “race bike” somewhere from the 125 to 150 or 250 to 300 range I think...

With rumors that the new kx 2 smoker will be a “race bike” somewhere from the 125 to 150 or 250 to 300 range I think this should be the time the ama finally gets with the program and allows 250 2 strokes in the 250 class. Its beyond time. For a while there hasnt been a lot of push since most manufacturers werent making 2 strokes anymore, but now that kawi has joined the fray this should be revisited. Its allowed in most other places now. 

MXA did a comparison of how much it would cost to get a yz250 and a yz250f up to 50hp and its pretty telling. They took a brand new 2019 yz250f and went up against a 12 year old yz250. To get the brand new yz250f up to 49hp cost $9,050. To get the 2007 yz250 up to 49hp was $2,200. Thats a massive difference, especially considering the cost savings of a used 12 year old yz250 vs a brand new yz250f. 

We always talk about how expensive the sport is these days, well this is the low hanging fruit. Just a simple rule change could save people massive amounts of money and make them competitive vs extremely tricked out 250 screamers. Making the sport cheaper makes it accessible for lots more people and also making competetive bikes much cheaper gives privateers a much better shot vs the factorys. Its time to get with the times. I hope kawi can give them the push. 

https://motocrossactionmag.com/two-vs-four-shootout-yz250-two-stroke-vs-yz250f-four-stroke/

Nice wish. How do you plan to get this rule change to happen? 

1
3strokemx
Posts
2684
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
2/14/2025 12:53pm

I wouldn't be surprised if it looks exactly like this with green plastic.
image 1189.png?VersionId=OzSGvRUNHpDR8fY

7
BobPA
Posts
8331
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
USA
2/14/2025 12:56pm

I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke 100 out of 100 times for strictly MX, and I grew up on two strokes. Peak power means diddly squat when it only produces said power for a few hundred RPM's. The amateur side did this years ago and four strokes still rule the roost.

6
7
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
2/14/2025 5:24pm
BobPA wrote:
I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke...

I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke 100 out of 100 times for strictly MX, and I grew up on two strokes. Peak power means diddly squat when it only produces said power for a few hundred RPM's. The amateur side did this years ago and four strokes still rule the roost.

The 250 2t won in Canada when they were evenly matched up. 250 2t 53hp vs 250F 47hp roughly.

2
3
yak651
Posts
8743
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI, USA
Fantasy
2/14/2025 5:28pm

Funny DC will say Honda will take their ball and go home if this is allowed, while tomorrow there will be no factory supported Honda on the 450 line…come to think of it there isn’t a 250 in the East either???Hmm, what’s the threat again???

3
2
2/14/2025 6:30pm Edited Date/Time 2/14/2025 7:23pm
3strokemx wrote:
I wouldn't be surprised if it looks exactly like this with green plastic.

I wouldn't be surprised if it looks exactly like this with green plastic.
image 1189.png?VersionId=OzSGvRUNHpDR8fY

I, for one, would be very surprised if Kawasaki produced a Yamaha DT230 copy motor with KTM copy plastics

2
2/14/2025 6:41pm
8500rpm wrote:
Is there evidence in other motorsports that the sport went 20 years backwards to old tech just to please the middle class? Could be, I don't...

Is there evidence in other motorsports that the sport went 20 years backwards to old tech just to please the middle class? Could be, I don't know? 

My guess is we will see all electric mx sx within 10years but no two strokes. There might be in 3rd world countries but not in North America and Europe. Could even be we see a new Sur-ron size e bike supercross to 'make the sport bigger and accessible' for gen Z. 

You know, I also wish things were like the were 15 years ago when I could afford more toys, but that's me, no manufacturers care about how I feel.The show must go on. 

 

Worked for pit bikes.  Lower point of entry financially.  Super fun.  Accessible.  More people got involved.  This has happened across Motorsports.  Puch scooters.  Old Harley’s.  Grom’s 


Not all an excellent example, but allowing the middle class affordance definitely helps the sport.  We’re like, 70-80% of the American population.

1
BobPA
Posts
8331
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
USA
2/15/2025 8:31am
BobPA wrote:
I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke...

I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke 100 out of 100 times for strictly MX, and I grew up on two strokes. Peak power means diddly squat when it only produces said power for a few hundred RPM's. The amateur side did this years ago and four strokes still rule the roost.

burn1986 wrote:

The 250 2t won in Canada when they were evenly matched up. 250 2t 53hp vs 250F 47hp roughly.

I remember that..It was also 10 years ago. Have the more recent champs been on two-strokes?

2
2/15/2025 9:00am Edited Date/Time 2/15/2025 10:36am
BobPA wrote:
I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke...

I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke 100 out of 100 times for strictly MX, and I grew up on two strokes. Peak power means diddly squat when it only produces said power for a few hundred RPM's. The amateur side did this years ago and four strokes still rule the roost.

burn1986 wrote:

The 250 2t won in Canada when they were evenly matched up. 250 2t 53hp vs 250F 47hp roughly.

BobPA wrote:

I remember that..It was also 10 years ago. Have the more recent champs been on two-strokes?

No, because they changed the rule after Kaven Benoit’s second title to disallow 2 strokes for guys who are actually competitive.

Benoit won his first MX2 title choosing 2T or 4T based on track. In response, CMRC changed rules to force riders to choose one bike through whole series and also 2T must run stock engine while 4T mods were still allowed. Kaven chose the stock 2T to defend and won again. CMRC then further tightened up the rules to disallow riders (like Kaven) who had ever finished top 5 or non-Canadian citizens from running even a stock 2T, effectively eliminating the option for nearly all serious championship competitors. 

12
1
Justthefacts
Posts
229
Joined
2/20/2022
Location
Bettendorf, IA, USA
2/15/2025 12:32pm

I find it a bit amusing here.  The 4 stroke guys are like, it wouldn't matter, the 4 stroke is the best and can't be beat.  Then, when people point out facts and history, chirp chirp chirp. Then on the 2 stroke side, they always hold out hope they'll get cc for cc.  Never gonna happen with those in charge.  Never.  It's like this never ending circle of going no where.  If 4 strokes were so good, they'd allow 150cc, and 300cc in classes.  They can't even do that.  

1
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
2/15/2025 1:48pm Edited Date/Time 2/15/2025 1:48pm
BobPA wrote:

I remember that..It was also 10 years ago. Have the more recent champs been on two-strokes?

Pretty sure Kaven Benoit was on a 2t as late as ‘23. There are still 2t allowed in Canadian MX 250 class. There’s Fantics, YZ, and the Austrians still racing 2t.

2
-MAVERICK-
Posts
66571
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario, CA
2/15/2025 1:51pm
burn1986 wrote:
Pretty sure Kaven Benoit was on a 2t as late as ‘23. There are still 2t allowed in Canadian MX 250 class. There’s Fantics, YZ, and...

Pretty sure Kaven Benoit was on a 2t as late as ‘23. There are still 2t allowed in Canadian MX 250 class. There’s Fantics, YZ, and the Austrians still racing 2t.

Benoit was set to race the 2 stroke, but they were having too many problems with it, so he rode the 4 stroke. 

He hasn't raced a 2 stroke at the Nationals since his back to back championships in 2014-2015. 

3
CPR
Posts
6916
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
2/15/2025 2:07pm
burn1986 wrote:

The 250 2t won in Canada when they were evenly matched up. 250 2t 53hp vs 250F 47hp roughly.

BobPA wrote:

I remember that..It was also 10 years ago. Have the more recent champs been on two-strokes?

No, because they changed the rule after Kaven Benoit’s second title to disallow 2 strokes for guys who are actually competitive.Benoit won his first MX2 title...

No, because they changed the rule after Kaven Benoit’s second title to disallow 2 strokes for guys who are actually competitive.

Benoit won his first MX2 title choosing 2T or 4T based on track. In response, CMRC changed rules to force riders to choose one bike through whole series and also 2T must run stock engine while 4T mods were still allowed. Kaven chose the stock 2T to defend and won again. CMRC then further tightened up the rules to disallow riders (like Kaven) who had ever finished top 5 or non-Canadian citizens from running even a stock 2T, effectively eliminating the option for nearly all serious championship competitors. 

Similar thing happened in Australia, where equal displacement was working well, but every time someone on a 2t won, or even holeshot, the factory 4t teams would complain to the point that the rules were changed.

8
1
2/15/2025 2:27pm
Zoom wrote:
Rule was changed about 10 years ago in AMA Amateur racing.  When that rule was changed, several riders tried the 250 2-stroke and still the wins...

Rule was changed about 10 years ago in AMA Amateur racing.  When that rule was changed, several riders tried the 250 2-stroke and still the wins were dominated by 4-strokes. Just sayin'...

Flatliner wrote:
It worked with some success in Canada,  Jimmy D raced up north for a season and yamaha 250f was obviously slower than the ktm two stroke...

It worked with some success in Canada,  Jimmy D raced up north for a season and yamaha 250f was obviously slower than the ktm two stroke ridden by benoit,  very track dependant.

 

They changed the rules to limit mods on the two strokes after that.   It did seem to help some guys without support, but nobody was riding a factory yz250.

I asked about the premix class 125-150 about running VP c12 .  They said yes & they don’t check fuel.  Same rule applies to a 125 racing the 250 pro class in Canada. I believe. Where is the torque & hp of a 250f now ? I heard 50+ hp out of a 250f . They carry there power much further than a 05 - 2012 250f now.   In 05 Indy all the teams said 23 ft lbs but nothing on hp.  A 2mm ovr bore 2mm stroker crank 1mm up 1mm down . Could hit 23 + torque.   Leaded fuel is allowed in 125c, 125 bc correct ?  At LL

3
2/15/2025 2:37pm
BobPA wrote:
I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke...

I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke 100 out of 100 times for strictly MX, and I grew up on two strokes. Peak power means diddly squat when it only produces said power for a few hundred RPM's. The amateur side did this years ago and four strokes still rule the roost.

This engine beat the 250f mod bikes in 04 . For the championship. A couple of the pipes created for the DBP where never returned to Japan . From teams tested them.  IMG 1386 1IMG 1603

2
2/15/2025 4:34pm
BobPA wrote:
I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke...

I feel like the guys pushing for this rule have not ridden a 250f since 2004. It would be pointless. I would take the four stroke 100 out of 100 times for strictly MX, and I grew up on two strokes. Peak power means diddly squat when it only produces said power for a few hundred RPM's. The amateur side did this years ago and four strokes still rule the roost.

Chad Johnson won the 06 title on a yz250 in AX when it was highly contested by riders & 4-sts.  They changed the tracks after that to make them 4-st tracks. 

OldTech
Posts
1280
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur, AL, USA
2/15/2025 4:52pm
I find it a bit amusing here.  The 4 stroke guys are like, it wouldn't matter, the 4 stroke is the best and can't be beat...

I find it a bit amusing here.  The 4 stroke guys are like, it wouldn't matter, the 4 stroke is the best and can't be beat.  Then, when people point out facts and history, chirp chirp chirp. Then on the 2 stroke side, they always hold out hope they'll get cc for cc.  Never gonna happen with those in charge.  Never.  It's like this never ending circle of going no where.  If 4 strokes were so good, they'd allow 150cc, and 300cc in classes.  They can't even do that.  

It would be interesting a 2T was allowed to be developed as a modern engine. Up to but maybe not 450cc

burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
2/15/2025 4:52pm Edited Date/Time 2/15/2025 4:54pm
This engine beat the 250f mod bikes in 04 . For the championship. A couple of the pipes created for the DBP where never returned to...

This engine beat the 250f mod bikes in 04 . For the championship. A couple of the pipes created for the DBP where never returned to Japan . From teams tested them.  IMG 1386 1IMG 1603

The whole issue with those aluminum framed 125s was the airbox choking the motor. Without modding the airbox (widely opening it up) those bikes were seriously anemic.

2
1
Village Idiot
Posts
2585
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW, USA
2/15/2025 4:54pm
This engine beat the 250f mod bikes in 04 . For the championship. A couple of the pipes created for the DBP where never returned to...

This engine beat the 250f mod bikes in 04 . For the championship. A couple of the pipes created for the DBP where never returned to Japan . From teams tested them.  IMG 1386 1IMG 1603

burn1986 wrote:
The whole issue with those aluminum framed 125s was the airbox choking the motor. Without modding the airbox (widely opening it up) those bikes were seriously...

The whole issue with those aluminum framed 125s was the airbox choking the motor. Without modding the airbox (widely opening it up) those bikes were seriously anemic.

Yep, like having your nose pinched while you're trying to run sprints - I can't breathe.

 

1
burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
2/15/2025 4:55pm

Yep, like having your nose pinched while you're trying to run sprints - I can't breathe.

 

Yep Lol 

1
OldTech
Posts
1280
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur, AL, USA
2/15/2025 4:59pm

Damn I thought the 96 with the flat top piston ran better 

web mx
Posts
979
Joined
3/3/2010
Location
USA, MI, USA
2/15/2025 5:08pm
yak651 wrote:
Funny DC will say Honda will take their ball and go home if this is allowed, while tomorrow there will be no factory supported Honda on...

Funny DC will say Honda will take their ball and go home if this is allowed, while tomorrow there will be no factory supported Honda on the 450 line…come to think of it there isn’t a 250 in the East either???Hmm, what’s the threat again???

Chance Hymas is in Detroit and got 6th for Honda.

burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
2/15/2025 6:27pm Edited Date/Time 2/15/2025 7:01pm
OldTech wrote:

Damn I thought the 96 with the flat top piston ran better 

The steel framed Hondas ran significantly better. Talon Vohland ran a 95 cylinder on his Honda 125 in ‘99. Racing teams started modifying the airboxes (to a certain extent) to squeeze as much out of the CRs as they could. But Honda had given up any real 2t development by that time. 

Post a reply to: Kawasaki smoker needs to lead to rule change

The Latest