Gypsy bigger than Matthes...

ACBraap
Posts
1169
Joined
2/10/2012
Location
Seattlish, WA US
Fantasy
2/4/2025 2:08pm
Echo wrote:
Jase is a down to earth bloke and definitely more likeable than matthes. Speaking as a brit I feel like american consumers have a harder time...

Jase is a down to earth bloke and definitely more likeable than matthes. Speaking as a brit I feel like american consumers have a harder time listening to non north american voices / people. The rest of the world is so used to and exposed to you guys as the main character basically but not the other way around. If Jase was the exact same dude but was from anywhere in the states I don't think he gets the same volume of criticism. That being said gyspy will never be as big as pulp within the moto world but has a higher potential outside of it. They fill different roles and theres a place for both.

It's not the non North American voice, it's the bro speak.

19
Zacka 161
Posts
1661
Joined
7/30/2009
Location
Mount Waverley, VIC AU
2/4/2025 2:08pm
cameron96 wrote:
2 different styles 1 is weekly breakdown and bench racingThe other is Rogan style deep interviews. it’s great we have both and not 1 or the otherIn fact...

2 different styles 


1 is weekly breakdown and bench racing

The other is Rogan style deep interviews. 

it’s great we have both and not 1 or the other


In fact we have like 40 moto podcasts weekly now days..  

Rogan does not do ‘deep’ interviews. He does long interviews but they aren’t deep, insightful, researched or intelligent. It’s like a group of dudes drinking around a fire for a few hours. It’s not deep bro. 

13
11
jemcee
Posts
12775
Joined
8/11/2008
Location
AU
2/4/2025 2:23pm
enketchum wrote:

I can't get on the gypsy bandwagon with him constantly spewing his views on privateers being cut from the sport.... sorry not sorry 

Untitled 39
1
MKMX
Posts
496
Joined
3/3/2021
Location
Timbuktu, WA AU
2/4/2025 2:28pm

Gypsy: asks question.

Guest: starts to answer.

Also Gypsy: answers question.

20

The Shop

truck
Posts
3703
Joined
6/10/2015
Location
Louisville, KY US
Fantasy
2/4/2025 2:29pm
Echo wrote:
Jase is a down to earth bloke and definitely more likeable than matthes. Speaking as a brit I feel like american consumers have a harder time...

Jase is a down to earth bloke and definitely more likeable than matthes. Speaking as a brit I feel like american consumers have a harder time listening to non north american voices / people. The rest of the world is so used to and exposed to you guys as the main character basically but not the other way around. If Jase was the exact same dude but was from anywhere in the states I don't think he gets the same volume of criticism. That being said gyspy will never be as big as pulp within the moto world but has a higher potential outside of it. They fill different roles and theres a place for both.

Nonsense. Could listen to DV, musquin, Anstie, etc for as long as they're willing to talk. Listen to different podcasts with Lewis all the time. It's not the accent, it's the personality that turns me off. I can't listen to gypsy. I've tried and the shtick is just too much. 

Totally understand why some don't like matthes but for all his quirks I've never questioned whether he's being himself or not, and I guess that appeals to me more.  Ton of good info as well. The ads don't bother me at all. Fast forward through the long one, barely hear the short ones mixed in. Beats paying for it. 

19
2
2/4/2025 2:30pm Edited Date/Time 2/4/2025 2:42pm
shuggs wrote:
Can only listen to Gypsy in the cut outs of interviews, 15mins tops.  Maybe I’m just to old but the minute he spends asking a question...

Can only listen to Gypsy in the cut outs of interviews, 15mins tops.  Maybe I’m just to old but the minute he spends asking a question & ‘bro’ crap & the f bombs are just to much me.  IMO his voice is worse the WChristen.

But hey I suppose he’s making a living out of it🤷‍♂️

I’m about to turn 24 and it’s too much for me. I much prefer The Whiskey Throttle Show’s long form interviews, especially since Ping is such a history nut. Gypsy has had some incredible interviews that I don’t see any other moto media getting out of people, lots of credit due there. Just not my style. I’m a big fan of radio shows so I have a huge spot for the main Pulp show, Steve really executes it well. Plus I’ve been listening to it for close to 10 years now. 

5
1
2/4/2025 2:35pm
Echo wrote:
Jase is a down to earth bloke and definitely more likeable than matthes. Speaking as a brit I feel like american consumers have a harder time...

Jase is a down to earth bloke and definitely more likeable than matthes. Speaking as a brit I feel like american consumers have a harder time listening to non north american voices / people. The rest of the world is so used to and exposed to you guys as the main character basically but not the other way around. If Jase was the exact same dude but was from anywhere in the states I don't think he gets the same volume of criticism. That being said gyspy will never be as big as pulp within the moto world but has a higher potential outside of it. They fill different roles and theres a place for both.

truck wrote:
Nonsense. Could listen to DV, musquin, Anstie, etc for as long as they're willing to talk. Listen to different podcasts with Lewis all the time. It's...

Nonsense. Could listen to DV, musquin, Anstie, etc for as long as they're willing to talk. Listen to different podcasts with Lewis all the time. It's not the accent, it's the personality that turns me off. I can't listen to gypsy. I've tried and the shtick is just too much. 

Totally understand why some don't like matthes but for all his quirks I've never questioned whether he's being himself or not, and I guess that appeals to me more.  Ton of good info as well. The ads don't bother me at all. Fast forward through the long one, barely hear the short ones mixed in. Beats paying for it. 

Obviously he's being himself. Nobody puts on an act of being a miserable prick. That wouldn't make sense

2
3
2/4/2025 2:35pm

i think you can see with both hosts who they were influenced by

 

Pulp was by Howard Stern, and Gypsy by Rogan,  both shows have their place in the sport . both give us huge amoutns of free content, 

11
Crisp
Posts
91
Joined
1/15/2019
Location
AU
2/4/2025 2:49pm
3strokemx wrote:

Why can't we vote for Cooksy?   This is rigged!

CPR wrote:

Because DC…….. 😂

Post of the day. Thanks for the laugh 🤣🤣🤣

1
peelout
Posts
18380
Joined
1/6/2011
Location
Ogden, UT US
2/4/2025 3:57pm

 

13
2
Cygrace74
Posts
1152
Joined
7/2/2017
Location
Westport, MA US
2/4/2025 4:41pm

Only problem with Pulp is that anything of the last 20 years Steve’s memory is horrendous, wrong mentions of results or champions being off by 3-4 years constantly. Makes it frustrating to listen to when he’s trying to compare results or careers 

3
6
2/4/2025 5:08pm

Gypsy  and Pulp are not comparable 

7
T-Fish
Posts
3247
Joined
12/14/2009
Location
Sparta, WI US
Fantasy
2/4/2025 5:36pm

Lewis Phillips is a better interviewer than both. 

8
4
2/4/2025 5:39pm
T-Fish wrote:

Lewis Phillips is a better interviewer than both. 

I enjoy Kellen and Lewis's podcast more than Pulp or Gypsy 

6
3
2/4/2025 5:40pm
Jace.We know you will read this.  Take it in.  Reads to me like everyone pretty much likes you.  Most of us just cant stand the repetitive...

Jace.

We know you will read this.  Take it in.  Reads to me like everyone pretty much likes you.  Most of us just cant stand the repetitive "like" - 'right?"-"bro"  talk.  Ease up your personal "parallels" and I think your fan base will broaden considerably.  This is not me talking, this is what the 1st page has given you.  

Thank you for all of your hard work, efforts and love for the sport, it is better with you in it!!!

Herr Lich wrote:

And the 'fucks' as well. You don't need to swear all the time, if at all.

I love listening  to Phil swear though for some reason, LOL.

4
1
2/4/2025 5:43pm

I prefer the Whiskey  Throttle  format where he follows  the timeline  of their life and career.

6
1
bv164
Posts
5
Joined
8/23/2015
Location
San Antonio, TX US
Fantasy
2/4/2025 5:45pm

I prefer Pulp…I especially like listening to the archived 1 on 1 interviews with old school riders like Emig, Chicken, Guy Cooper, Ezra Lusk, RJ, Wardy, Bailey, Stanton, Kehoe, Holland and many others.  He seems to ask questions that I would ask.  I can’t get into Gypsy…I’ve heard “Bro” way too many times already.

3
APLMAN99
Posts
12478
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
2/4/2025 6:31pm

I have to admit, I can stomach the Gypsy show slightly better than I could a year ago. I think he’s shown some incremental improvement in not answering his questions for the guests himself first. He doesn’t seem to try to tell stories to parallel theirs quite as much, but it’s still there. 

I’d probably listen to him more if he could just grow up a little and speak just a little bit more like an adult. I’m no prude with the language, but I only have a limited amount of ‘free’ time to listen to podcasts and I’m not going to be playing a Gypsy episode in my office and have people drop in while he needs to use 6 f-bombs just to get through a single sentence. But it’s his show, and if he needs to talk that way it’s certainly his prerogative. 

Ping used to be my favorite of the moto shows, and I guess he still is but again with such limited listening time I’ve found other subjects taking the lion’s share of it. I probably look at Whiskey Throttle a couple of times a month to see if there’s a new interview of someone I’m interested in, but I don’t listen to really anything on the current racing on Whiskey Throttle. 

I haven’t listened to much SML after Anton announced that he was leaving either. No real reason other than time. 

4
kage173
Posts
3062
Joined
11/27/2015
Location
TX US
2/4/2025 6:37pm

I like them both. Why is it one or the other? The more content the better.

2
tomlopez
Posts
1184
Joined
5/2/2021
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL US
Fantasy
2/4/2025 6:57pm

I feel like this is a generational divide question. I'd bet a large majority of Gen Xers & older would prefer Matthes, and a large majority of Millennials & younger would prefer Gypsy. Matthes is a bit more old-school and talks like an average dude his age would talk, so I can see his demographic relating to his style. He doesn't get nearly as deep and introspective as Gypsy... to my knowledge, he's a lot more surface-level and vanilla. Gypsy is like Joe Rogan... less of an interview and more of him trying to converse with people. He doesn't hide the fact that he wants to influence the conversation just as much as his guest, but that's okay to me - I think the best conversations come from the "question asker" opening themselves up first.

I'm a younger guy in my 20s and heavily prefer Gypsy to Matthes. Matthes has always given establishment vibes to me, which makes sense, since he literally is part of the SX/MX establishment. I understand the disdain for Gypsy's bro-speak, but I just don't care anymore - that's how 80% of guys under 40 talk these days, with the exception of Wall Street bankers and Neurosurgeons, maybe. To me, his attitude and purpose seems more good-faith than Matthes... there's something about Matthes that seems slimy to me, for some reason.

6
4
Trickamoto
Posts
651
Joined
2/6/2018
Location
Beverly Hills, CA US
2/4/2025 7:01pm

It's not BRO....it's Broiiiii.

3
1
inflammable
Posts
2219
Joined
10/2/2009
Location
Abilene, TX US
2/4/2025 7:55pm

Is the vote for audience size, or body fat percentage?

2
4
ShipLap
Posts
1615
Joined
8/15/2018
Location
Moab, UT US
2/4/2025 8:24pm

Gypsy is a foul mouth cuss-face.
Matthes is a left-wing wuss bag.

I'd go with RC and RV, and Stew over both of them.

2
23
Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW AU
2/4/2025 8:46pm

Gypsy  and Pulp are not comparable 

Except that both like to blow riders.

1
4
crusher773
Posts
2017
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Coweta, OK US
2/4/2025 9:17pm
1.Ping/Whiskey Throttle2.Gypsy3.PulpI prefer Ping because he seems to cover the span of the person’s life similar to a biography and they come across more authentic. All...

1.Ping/Whiskey Throttle

2.Gypsy

3.Pulp

I prefer Ping because he seems to cover the span of the person’s life similar to a biography and they come across more authentic. All three rock and the sport is fortunate to have them. 

Herr Lich wrote:

What does your tinfoil hat look like? | Texas Gun Talk - The Premier Texas  Gun Forum

Call Ping a tinfoil hat all you want.  The side he is on, is turning out to be right about a lot of things.  He is on the side that really is making America great again.

7
15
2/4/2025 9:26pm
3strokemx wrote:

Gypsy certainly has the bigger ego.  

UpTiTe wrote:

Not by a long shot. 

Go approach both of them at a race, see which one has a conversation with you. 

BobPA wrote:

You would have to pay me to talk to Matthes...Only like $8, but still.

That's bullshit and you know it. How could a motocross fan not enjoy a conversation with someone with that much moto knowledge. 

3
jambalaya
Posts
1400
Joined
1/16/2021
Location
Spring Valley, CA US
2/4/2025 10:17pm

I’ve never listened to Gypsy. I stopped listening to pulp a while ago just because of how repetitive it is with Matthes and the guys he likes. 

I still really enjoy the race recap shows and will listen to fly moto 60 even though callers are tough. His new thing with Blair isn’t bad. 

jambalaya
Posts
1400
Joined
1/16/2021
Location
Spring Valley, CA US
2/4/2025 10:18pm
1.Ping/Whiskey Throttle2.Gypsy3.PulpI prefer Ping because he seems to cover the span of the person’s life similar to a biography and they come across more authentic. All...

1.Ping/Whiskey Throttle

2.Gypsy

3.Pulp

I prefer Ping because he seems to cover the span of the person’s life similar to a biography and they come across more authentic. All three rock and the sport is fortunate to have them. 

Herr Lich wrote:

What does your tinfoil hat look like? | Texas Gun Talk - The Premier Texas  Gun Forum

crusher773 wrote:
Call Ping a tinfoil hat all you want.  The side he is on, is turning out to be right about a lot of things.  He is...

Call Ping a tinfoil hat all you want.  The side he is on, is turning out to be right about a lot of things.  He is on the side that really is making America great again.

Shouldn’t we see how this plays out first before we start calling it the right side of things?

8
1
2/4/2025 10:38pm

Just listening to the latest UFC Unfiltered podcast with Jim Norton and Matt Serra, and Gypsy is on there.🙃

1

Post a reply to: Gypsy bigger than Matthes...

The Latest