Should the MXDN go to a bi-yearly format?

10/13/2023 10:34am

I only managed to watch a low quality stream in a foreign language as I'm traveling at the moment but didn't I see that there were 108000 people there this year, the event definitely doesn't seem to be struggling

3
mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD US
10/13/2023 10:34am
250 cross wrote:
If you don't send a really good team every year chances are somebody else is going to win. I have no problem with that. Having more...

If you don't send a really good team every year chances are somebody else is going to win. I have no problem with that. Having more countries in contention is better for everyones interest and excitment. Just wish there was a better way to help cover costs for the tracks and teams.

Exactly, send the people that want to go. Not that hard to understand

2
10/13/2023 10:39am

No , if  a farm worker , an orchard builder , and a carpenter can take a holiday from their day Jobs and make their way from Nz to race to the other side of the world , then pro  racers  can do one more weekend a year 

11
4
mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD US
10/13/2023 10:42am
scott_nz wrote:
No , if  a farm worker , an orchard builder , and a carpenter can take a holiday from their day Jobs and make their way...

No , if  a farm worker , an orchard builder , and a carpenter can take a holiday from their day Jobs and make their way from Nz to race to the other side of the world , then pro  racers  can do one more weekend a year 

Not everybody thinks the same,and thats ok. I guess contracts mean nothing. Lol. 

4

The Shop

ATKpilot99
Posts
10443
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI US
10/13/2023 10:43am Edited Date/Time 10/13/2023 10:44am

Hell I think it should go back to MXdN with 450s one weekend then Trophee des with 250s the next every year . 

1
KurtJ99
Posts
2436
Joined
2/6/2017
Location
CA US
10/13/2023 10:44am Edited Date/Time 10/13/2023 10:45am
Let me ask you this... I doubt you'll be able to answer honestly, but if the USA was winning every year, would you still be asking...

Let me ask you this... I doubt you'll be able to answer honestly, but if the USA was winning every year, would you still be asking this question?

USA won last year (albeit on home turf  we win every year for 1 year!), and we struggled to send a team this year - so it's a good question to ask.

Yes, we should send a team every year. Yes, I wish the top racers were motivated to go. 

The schedule and sport are evolving. Monster Cup came and went;  now WSX and SMX have tilted the schedule. An every other year race, perhaps with less races (1 or 2 SMX versus 3) on the MXDN year might free up time and make it easier to attend. I just doubt it would address fundamentals and the money machine at Infront raking in MXDN revenue annually is not going to to give up that $.

Riders will have other reasons to not want to go. Bummer but unless the US teams want it and the riders want it we'll keep replaying this same song, at least for non-US MXDN.

captmoto
Posts
5866
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA US
10/13/2023 10:49am Edited Date/Time 10/13/2023 10:50am

Yes, it is a different world than it was 40 years ago. The sport is bigger, faster and way more advanced. Remember when all we had were 12 pro races a year? There was plenty of time for MXON. A guy could get married before the season started and still get in a full year of racing and MXON. 

Maybe there would be more interest from teams and riders if it wasn't a big deal every year.

3
2
DonM
Posts
8676
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
Fantasy
10/13/2023 10:51am
I only managed to watch a low quality stream in a foreign language as I'm traveling at the moment but didn't I see that there were...

I only managed to watch a low quality stream in a foreign language as I'm traveling at the moment but didn't I see that there were 108000 people there this year, the event definitely doesn't seem to be struggling

It was 102,000 over the three days

1
bvm111
Posts
10113
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Las Vegas, NV US
10/13/2023 11:06am

no 

3
aees
Posts
2787
Joined
8/20/2015
Location
US
10/13/2023 12:08pm

Needs to be every year. To many variables that keep riders out as it is already.

Imagine this was every forth year, and US had this years situation. That's 8 years without a proper heads up with rest of the world for the fans. The event would die.

1
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13241
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA US
10/13/2023 12:09pm

No.  Not unless the current annual schedule would totally imperil the event, which seems unlikely given the 23 running.  

Some riders only get one year to have a chance to represent, because of performance and health.  And I think ultimately getting the teams together each year is essential to the event's character.  If a country can't pull it together for a year, it's on that nation's organizing body and that country is out of the discussion about the event . . . like, no "if only" BS.

1
10/13/2023 12:16pm

As a non American, I believe it should NOT be every year.

Yes, you might be disappointed if your country has great riders in an off year, but that's the way it goes.

2
5
The Moth
Posts
277
Joined
2/3/2023
Location
Los Angeles, CA US
10/13/2023 12:27pm
visser62 wrote:
I don't care about the U.S. winning, and I usually root for the Netherlands, but I think it should be every four years. Being like Tanel...

I don't care about the U.S. winning, and I usually root for the Netherlands, but I think it should be every four years. Being like Tanel Leok and doing 30 straight is really cool, but every rider should say, "I only get a couple of these in my career while I'm at the top, I need to go do it." Then it becomes a generational thing. FIFA, Olympics, even the Baseball World Classic gets some hype.

The window of opportunity is too small in moto for the MXdN to be every 4 years.  Keep tradition alive, and keep it at every year.  The only ones complaining are U.S. based teams.  It's a great event with a long history that pits country against country, and most everyone I know, looks forward to it every year.

1
10/13/2023 12:39pm

Every year.

Start fund raising for 2024 MXoN at A-1

3
ARM670
Posts
2209
Joined
12/11/2020
Location
Napoleon, OH US
10/13/2023 1:39pm

Every year!

2
Sunhouse
Posts
3658
Joined
3/2/2009
Location
NO
10/13/2023 2:24pm

What a great idea! We remove the absolute best race and highlight of the year.

Maybe we could replace it with 12 rounds of Hyper Duper Megascrub Cross in a stadium? 

5
1
Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW AU
10/13/2023 3:11pm
ga_pike wrote:
When you look at other major international sporting events like the Ryder Cup and the Olympics, they are contested every 2 or 4 years.  Would the...

When you look at other major international sporting events like the Ryder Cup and the Olympics, they are contested every 2 or 4 years.  Would the MXDN benefit from moving to a different schedule?  

Also, what about a separate event that pitted the different series against each other?  AMA Pro Motocross vs MXGP vs Canadian MX series vs Japan MX series vs Australian series?  You could select teams of 5 from each series to compete in the different classes and it would be for series pride on off years from country pride.  

InkedDV 7

stillwelding
Posts
3235
Joined
1/22/2007
Location
Santa Clarita, CA US
10/13/2023 3:17pm
Let me ask you this... I doubt you'll be able to answer honestly, but if the USA was winning every year, would you still be asking...

Let me ask you this... I doubt you'll be able to answer honestly, but if the USA was winning every year, would you still be asking this question?

Hey Peckerwood, you can stop asking that question about 1993.

mxpro252
Posts
459
Joined
11/15/2013
Location
WA US
10/13/2023 3:19pm

No

2
ns503
Posts
4585
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies CA
10/13/2023 3:24pm

Hard NO

2
CPR
Posts
6865
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
10/13/2023 4:37pm

Yeah nah

2
1
1911
Posts
4968
Joined
4/2/2008
Location
LAS VEGAS, NV US
10/13/2023 6:27pm

Every two years? How about twice a year?? Woohoo

3
1
Nighttrain
Posts
2771
Joined
12/5/2011
Location
Charleston, SC US
10/13/2023 11:03pm

If Feld or DC solely owned and profited from the MXdN there would be much gnashing of teeth and utter despair from the MXGP crowd.  Add venues in South America, Asia, and New Zealand. Let Luongo only pocket the European versions. Then it would truly be an Olympics of MX.

2
DadBod86
Posts
228
Joined
7/31/2022
Location
Pittsworth, QLD AU
Fantasy
10/13/2023 11:19pm

Should be every year. If your country doesn't have the nuts to race, that's your problem.  The event should be be the mxdn, the wmxdn and a junior event. All classes counting towards the win to encourage each country to get out of their own way to raise participation in the sport instead of killing it. If your country can't support each class it shows their incompetence to run their organisation and give support to those who grow the sport. Motocross is dying. Make it inclusive or find another hobby. 

1
10/14/2023 1:02am

Yearly. The racing in Ernee was fucking first class. I wouldn't want to wait 4 yrs to see that. My life ain't long enough. 

 

4
vrossi
Posts
26
Joined
8/22/2023
Location
groesbeek NL
10/14/2023 2:49am

It should be every year, and the pride and prise money for the winning team should be sky high I’ll bet there are no complaints then 

motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI US
10/14/2023 4:01am
I only managed to watch a low quality stream in a foreign language as I'm traveling at the moment but didn't I see that there were...

I only managed to watch a low quality stream in a foreign language as I'm traveling at the moment but didn't I see that there were 108000 people there this year, the event definitely doesn't seem to be struggling

Well the promoter sure isn't struggling Wink

10/14/2023 4:29am
vrossi wrote:

It should be every year, and the pride and prise money for the winning team should be sky high I’ll bet there are no complaints then 

There needs to be good prize money. This is how the riders earn a living.

If my boss asked me to travel across the world for work but no pay during my holiday then I ain't going to be happy. Especially the USA dudes, they need to take a break before SX boot camp starts. The Euros have plenty of time before their season starts.

All pro riders need proper compensation each time they line up. Also important to remember the grind and risk that these guys go through. Every gate drop could be their last.

1
1
10/14/2023 4:30am
I only managed to watch a low quality stream in a foreign language as I'm traveling at the moment but didn't I see that there were...

I only managed to watch a low quality stream in a foreign language as I'm traveling at the moment but didn't I see that there were 108000 people there this year, the event definitely doesn't seem to be struggling

Well the promoter sure isn't struggling Wink

Yup...he is banking huge...

1
Crush
Posts
21092
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney AU
10/14/2023 6:04am

Fuck no. How is this even a question? Look how many people were at the event!

Is it perfect? No. Could the promoters make it easier for teams to get there? Yes.

Could the teams make it easier on themselves. Also yes.

But none of that means the event is fundamentally flawed. 

9

Post a reply to: Should the MXDN go to a bi-yearly format?

The Latest