Triumph September, maybe?

stremme12
Posts
1222
Joined
3/10/2015
Location
HA, HI, USA
8/15/2023 11:59am Edited Date/Time 8/15/2023 12:01pm
tek14 wrote:

So far just Copy of Yamaha old frame and current KTM engine. Still waiting that ground breaking innovation RC was talking... 

Triumph is using a CNC machined aluminum frame that is tig welded together. How is that even remotely similar to the old steel Yamaha frame? You...

Triumph is using a CNC machined aluminum frame that is tig welded together. How is that even remotely similar to the old steel Yamaha frame?

You guys live in a very superficial world, basing everything on looks and appearance and not taking into consideration any substance whatsoever. Such is the shallow world we live in now.

Did you consider that they're comparing to Yamaha's first aluminum 250 frame and not the older steel frame?

I'm not sure what context you read that it's being compared to an old Yamaha steel frame.

1
5
8/15/2023 12:10pm Edited Date/Time 8/15/2023 12:10pm
stremme12 wrote:
Did you consider that they're comparing to Yamaha's first aluminum 250 frame and not the older steel frame? I'm not sure what context you read that...

Did you consider that they're comparing to Yamaha's first aluminum 250 frame and not the older steel frame?

I'm not sure what context you read that it's being compared to an old Yamaha steel frame.

I think my point still remains - it's silly to draw comparisons based on superficial appearances alone.

11
stremme12
Posts
1222
Joined
3/10/2015
Location
HA, HI, USA
8/15/2023 12:13pm Edited Date/Time 8/15/2023 12:15pm
stremme12 wrote:
Did you consider that they're comparing to Yamaha's first aluminum 250 frame and not the older steel frame? I'm not sure what context you read that...

Did you consider that they're comparing to Yamaha's first aluminum 250 frame and not the older steel frame?

I'm not sure what context you read that it's being compared to an old Yamaha steel frame.

I think my point still remains - it's silly to draw comparisons based on superficial appearances alone.

About as silly as you saying people are comparing the Triumph frame to an old steel frame. 

You drew that comparison yourself. No one said it was like the old steel frame. 

2
4
philG
Posts
11300
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
8/15/2023 12:15pm
AMetts wrote:
Another disappointing video, showed some random parts and the same 4 inch square section of the motor 10 times.  I gathered that it had really broad...

Another disappointing video, showed some random parts and the same 4 inch square section of the motor 10 times. 

I gathered that it had really broad usable power they mentioned over and over. It appears to have a long oil screen like the KTM motors do. 

That is the engine equivalent of 'nice personality' 

 

3

The Shop

Press516
Posts
6040
Joined
9/11/2018
Location
Gilbert, AZ, USA
8/15/2023 12:16pm
tek14 wrote:

So far just Copy of Yamaha old frame and current KTM engine. Still waiting that ground breaking innovation RC was talking... 

I'd say "copy" is a horribly inaccurate description of what we see.  As mentioned above, the design has clearly been influenced by those other products, but unlike reverse engineered China bikes, I'd suggest nothing "engineered" is interchangeable between the bikes you mentioned.

As for "innovation", I'd agree...  Haven't seen anything yet that makes me think we're seeing some notable development.  

1
1
mxjeff575
Posts
483
Joined
7/14/2011
Location
Festus, MO, USA
8/15/2023 12:37pm

The upper motor mounts shown in the video look exactly like KTM mounts.  

3
8/15/2023 12:41pm
Press516 wrote:
I'd say "copy" is a horribly inaccurate description of what we see.  As mentioned above, the design has clearly been influenced by those other products, but...

I'd say "copy" is a horribly inaccurate description of what we see.  As mentioned above, the design has clearly been influenced by those other products, but unlike reverse engineered China bikes, I'd suggest nothing "engineered" is interchangeable between the bikes you mentioned.

As for "innovation", I'd agree...  Haven't seen anything yet that makes me think we're seeing some notable development.  

A major manufacturer who has not built a motocross specific motorcycle in decades, is now re-entering the market with a bike built completely from the ground up. It’s a shame that critical point is being overlooked and under-appreciated here. 

24
3
Press516
Posts
6040
Joined
9/11/2018
Location
Gilbert, AZ, USA
8/15/2023 1:19pm
Press516 wrote:
I'd say "copy" is a horribly inaccurate description of what we see.  As mentioned above, the design has clearly been influenced by those other products, but...

I'd say "copy" is a horribly inaccurate description of what we see.  As mentioned above, the design has clearly been influenced by those other products, but unlike reverse engineered China bikes, I'd suggest nothing "engineered" is interchangeable between the bikes you mentioned.

As for "innovation", I'd agree...  Haven't seen anything yet that makes me think we're seeing some notable development.  

A major manufacturer who has not built a motocross specific motorcycle in decades, is now re-entering the market with a bike built completely from the ground...

A major manufacturer who has not built a motocross specific motorcycle in decades, is now re-entering the market with a bike built completely from the ground up. It’s a shame that critical point is being overlooked and under-appreciated here. 

There is a reason why the bikes have looked virtually identical for the last 20 years... 

 

5
1
64smoker
Posts
528
Joined
2/7/2023
Location
Ramsgate, GB
8/15/2023 1:29pm

I don’t get what people where expecting , oems have been spendings multi millions of pound on devolopment for these 4 strokes for the last 2 decades , it was always going to be similar to what’s out there already , it’s good for the sport we should be behind them ! 

16
Pegasus
Posts
2
Joined
4/10/2015
Location
GB
8/15/2023 1:30pm

I'd get it one piece at a time and it wouldn't cost me a dime
You'll know it's me when I come through your town
I'm gonna ride around in style, I'm gonna drive everybody wild
'Cause I'll have the only one there is a round

6
1
Cali
Posts
250
Joined
3/22/2019
Location
Bakersfield, CA, USA
8/15/2023 2:40pm
ga_pike wrote:

So RC rides it Sept 5th.  I'm assuming we should be able to see the full bike at that point.

Nah he's just riding the engine & frame 😂

1
2
Paul333
Posts
2394
Joined
2/15/2012
Location
Virginia Beach, VA, USA
8/15/2023 2:41pm Edited Date/Time 8/15/2023 2:49pm

I don't care that they got ideas from the past or other manufacturers, everything has been done before. Just show it to us, stop acting like you are reinventing the wheel, and release it ASAP. 

4
PTshox
Posts
1600
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/15/2023 2:44pm

Looks like the cam sprocket is on the right side of the motor... vs left for pretty much all the other MX bikes from Japan and AU. That's different. Possibly presents some different port layouts. Hmm.... 

2
1
TeamGreen
Posts
37817
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
8/15/2023 2:55pm

17EEE1E1-9CB5-4B22-9A1A-D83BCF087471.jpeg?VersionId=vRuOLK4iT7F5

9
plowboy
Posts
14856
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
8/15/2023 3:03pm
TeamGreen wrote:

17EEE1E1-9CB5-4B22-9A1A-D83BCF087471.jpeg?VersionId=vRuOLK4iT7F5

Manny knows...cool is cool.  Always was.  

Is there anyone close these days?

2
1
mx_phreek
Posts
2275
Joined
10/7/2009
Location
Manchester, GB
8/15/2023 3:12pm

I mean they could of at least got rid of the KTM Torx bolts

3
3
plowboy
Posts
14856
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
8/15/2023 3:19pm
mx_phreek wrote:

I mean they could of at least got rid of the KTM Torx bolts

Lol...as long as they're made of good stuff.Silly

2
soggy
Posts
9128
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
8/15/2023 3:41pm
PTshox wrote:
Looks like the cam sprocket is on the right side of the motor... vs left for pretty much all the other MX bikes from Japan and...

Looks like the cam sprocket is on the right side of the motor... vs left for pretty much all the other MX bikes from Japan and AU. That's different. Possibly presents some different port layouts. Hmm.... 

Ktm 250 and 350 are on the right side. 

2
8/15/2023 3:48pm Edited Date/Time 8/15/2023 3:55pm

So, what we have teased out thus far:

✅ An aluminum frame in a general shape that was comfortable and predictable in its last seen implementation.

✅ A KTM-style engine (MXA: "The 2023 KTM 250SXF is not just the most powerful engine from mid-and-up but also from low-to-mid. You read that right.").

✅ KYB Suspension 

Man, huge disappointment. Sounds just terrible.

25
1
ADynes
Posts
280
Joined
5/26/2011
Location
USA
8/15/2023 4:24pm Edited Date/Time 8/15/2023 4:25pm
PTshox wrote:
Looks like the cam sprocket is on the right side of the motor... vs left for pretty much all the other MX bikes from Japan and...

Looks like the cam sprocket is on the right side of the motor... vs left for pretty much all the other MX bikes from Japan and AU. That's different. Possibly presents some different port layouts. Hmm.... 

soggy wrote:

Ktm 250 and 350 are on the right side. 

And Honda 

PigLover
Posts
64
Joined
9/8/2019
Location
Ellensburg, WA, USA
8/15/2023 4:43pm

Tired of these new manufacturers copying the old guard. What next, hydraulic brakes? Foot pegs that are too sharp? I don’t think I could clutch my pearls any harder. 

1
3
sowers711
Posts
103
Joined
5/20/2017
Location
Tecumseh, MI, USA
8/15/2023 5:19pm

87A3A774-F764-4C57-8970-FFA95192D342.jpeg?VersionId=hxGcM66.9X5WiEhAvV3eJLkU5t4aP

1
4
8/15/2023 5:33pm
stremme12 wrote:

So on the Vital Facebook page it said there is key differences between the Triumph motor and the KTM. What are the key differences between them?

Triumph logos!

1
6
soggy
Posts
9128
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
8/15/2023 5:42pm
sowers711 wrote:

87A3A774-F764-4C57-8970-FFA95192D342.jpeg?VersionId=hxGcM66.9X5WiEhAvV3eJLkU5t4aP

The vultures are gonna be all over this. 

2
2
aeffertz
Posts
12837
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
8/15/2023 5:54pm
sowers711 wrote:

87A3A774-F764-4C57-8970-FFA95192D342.jpeg?VersionId=hxGcM66.9X5WiEhAvV3eJLkU5t4aP

Why are you guys so pressed to say this is just another rebranded KTM? That frame is clearly very different, the motor is different from the KTM/Husky/GASGAS motor and not to mention Triumph wasn't acquired by KTM...

10
1
plowboy
Posts
14856
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
8/15/2023 6:21pm

I remember hearing John Banks CCM way back.  The sexiest sound ever.  If they could replicate that...they'll sell 'em all.Cool. Of course that was the open header days.Blush

Rogers exhaust, on the old Suzi, was the most ear piercing, brain melting sound besides the AT-37 aircraft, I ever experienced.

1
MX915
Posts
468
Joined
1/17/2018
Location
Central, NJ, USA
8/15/2023 6:24pm
aeffertz wrote:
Why are you guys so pressed to say this is just another rebranded KTM? That frame is clearly very different, the motor is different from the...

Why are you guys so pressed to say this is just another rebranded KTM? That frame is clearly very different, the motor is different from the KTM/Husky/GASGAS motor and not to mention Triumph wasn't acquired by KTM...

"not to mention Triumph wasn't acquired by KTM.."


"Hold my beer" - Stefan Pierer

 

1
Pop Shmoke
Posts
2272
Joined
6/17/2020
Location
Boston, MA, USA
8/15/2023 6:34pm Edited Date/Time 8/16/2023 8:12am
More of the same. MX bike technology is mature and has plateaued. Yamaha's highly succesful forward intake cylinder head is the only real innovation for 10...

More of the same.

MX bike technology is mature and has plateaued.

Yamaha's highly succesful forward intake cylinder head is the only real innovation for 10 years.

How successful it is in the long term will come down to how good the men preparing it are and how willing the factory is to spend on development.

Theres plenty more technological leaps that are feasible with current engineering and technology. A few off the top of my head are:

-Carbon fiber frame (completely mature and ubiquitous in the mountain bike world)

-Carbon fiber sub frame

-Carbon fiber swing arm

-Air shock, have been raced on but not available to public yet

-Dry sump oil system to change weight distribution and less drag on crank spinning in oil

-Pneumatic valve springs, used in formula 1, motogp

-Variable valve timing

-Freevalve- camless electronically operated valves that allows unlimited variable timing and a huge reduction in reciprocating and dead weight, elimination of throttle body

-Flexwork valve system, electrohydraulically operated valves with unlimited variable valve timing

-Engine used as a structural member of the frame, allowing much less weight and much stiffer “frame” for less material

-Electric water pump, no oem has this yet


 

None of these are coming tomorrow, but in time were probably going to end up seeing a few of these get used as bikes progress further. 
 

8
Fireblade2k
Posts
82
Joined
10/31/2019
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL, USA
8/15/2023 7:30pm

Screenshot 20230815-222909.png?VersionId=Y7o92G025v7PkpjPP430

 

Screenshot 20230815-221617

2
4
Tyler D
Posts
2497
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
La, CA, USA
8/15/2023 8:35pm
More of the same. MX bike technology is mature and has plateaued. Yamaha's highly succesful forward intake cylinder head is the only real innovation for 10...

More of the same.

MX bike technology is mature and has plateaued.

Yamaha's highly succesful forward intake cylinder head is the only real innovation for 10 years.

How successful it is in the long term will come down to how good the men preparing it are and how willing the factory is to spend on development.

Pop Shmoke wrote:
Theres plenty more technological leaps that are feasible with current engineering and technology. A few off the top of my head are: -Carbon fiber frame (completely...

Theres plenty more technological leaps that are feasible with current engineering and technology. A few off the top of my head are:

-Carbon fiber frame (completely mature and ubiquitous in the mountain bike world)

-Carbon fiber sub frame

-Carbon fiber swing arm

-Air shock, have been raced on but not available to public yet

-Dry sump oil system to change weight distribution and less drag on crank spinning in oil

-Pneumatic valve springs, used in formula 1, motogp

-Variable valve timing

-Freevalve- camless electronically operated valves that allows unlimited variable timing and a huge reduction in reciprocating and dead weight, elimination of throttle body

-Flexwork valve system, electrohydraulically operated valves with unlimited variable valve timing

-Engine used as a structural member of the frame, allowing much less weight and much stiffer “frame” for less material

-Electric water pump, no oem has this yet


 

None of these are coming tomorrow, but in time were probably going to end up seeing a few of these get used as bikes progress further. 
 

direct injection

exotic piston and rod materials

ceramic roller crank bearing

1
1

Post a reply to: Triumph September, maybe?

The Latest