KTM broke in half.

S.Loyer
Posts
1749
Joined
1/4/2012
Location
Palmer, AK, USA
4/17/2022 7:45am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2022 7:45am
Luxon MX wrote:
I'm glad the internet engineers have already found the problem and concluded that our product is junk. Can't wait for the internet lawyers to jump in...
I'm glad the internet engineers have already found the problem and concluded that our product is junk. Can't wait for the internet lawyers to jump in too!

I'm not at Atlanta, but from what I can tell at this point is that the pinch bolt at the stem failed, which caused the top clamp to fail, and then the bike to "break in half".

The KTM design uses the top triple clamp to clamp around the steering stem with a pinch bolt instead of the "standard" Japanese bike design where the top clamp is sandwiched between the adjuster nut and the lock nut. It's a pretty elegant design, but if the bolt fails, then the assembly becomes very weak and the clamp will fail. This is the same design that KTM/Husky/GasGas use on all of their stock clamps and factory clamp and multiple aftermarket companies use on their clamps for these bikes.

Here's the actual broken part from today:



You can see the broken bolt on the right, which allowed the clamp to break (on the left). Note the fresh break of the clamp and that there's no fretting or other evidence of a previous crack. That shows this happened all at once and the clamp itself wasn't the problem, it was the bolt. We use bolts that are stronger than the stock KTM bolts (random samples tested to failure for each batch we receive), so either the bolt was over-torqued to the point that it was on the edge of failure, or it came loose and that allowed things to give way.

This is the first failure of this kind for us, but it's not all that uncommon with this general design. Multiple other aftermarket clamps and stock KTM clamps have all failed in the same way. Not because the clamps are bad, but because the bolt failed; most likely because it was over torqued or came loose.

Regardless, we'll take a closer look at the clamps when we get them back to see if there's anything that I'm missing from the photos, but it seems pretty clear cut. If this were a design problem, we'd see this a whole lot more instead of this one incident. Freddie Noren has been on this same setup all year successfully and finished 11th in the 450 class today.

Here's a few examples of the same failure, stock and aftermarket, I'm sure there's plenty more I don't have photos of:








So you know this a failure that happens and you do nothing to prevent it?
1
36
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
4/17/2022 7:45am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2022 2:49pm
Did they show it on the broadcast? I happened to look just as Alves was casing the roller into the split sand section. Didn’t realize the bike was broken until a track worker tried to stand it up to move it off the track and it didn’t come along with the bars.

Alves scrambled off the track and was getting medical attention and I think eventually a mule ride.
4/17/2022 7:46am
I’m not an engineer, so that being said…

If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of maintenance to keep it safe, why would aftermarket companies utilize this design rather than switching to a more traditional triple clamp design for their KTM clamps?
24
1
S.Loyer
Posts
1749
Joined
1/4/2012
Location
Palmer, AK, USA
4/17/2022 7:54am
I’m not an engineer, so that being said… If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of...
I’m not an engineer, so that being said…

If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of maintenance to keep it safe, why would aftermarket companies utilize this design rather than switching to a more traditional triple clamp design for their KTM clamps?
Thank you
4
6

The Shop

yak651
Posts
9107
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI, USA
4/17/2022 8:26am
I’m not an engineer, so that being said… If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of...
I’m not an engineer, so that being said…

If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of maintenance to keep it safe, why would aftermarket companies utilize this design rather than switching to a more traditional triple clamp design for their KTM clamps?
It’s easier to make fun of internet engineers than improve a product
3
6
Sandusky26
Posts
3553
Joined
7/28/2021
Location
Eastern, NC, USA
4/17/2022 8:31am
I build houses for a living and I wish I had customers like half the guys in this thread.

Im supposed to go work on a pocket door on Monday, I’m gonna tell her it’s a freak accident and charge her double.
7
9
AJ565
Posts
2361
Joined
3/12/2012
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
4/17/2022 8:31am
Sandusky26 wrote:
Luxon vs Ride Engineering, who would win in a fight?
Looks like a draw.
9
MX Culture
Posts
3298
Joined
6/19/2009
Location
Lake Geneva, WI, USA
4/17/2022 8:37am
I'm just here to see how Remy is doing.
anyone?
4/17/2022 8:45am
Someone should call Arthur Draper. He doesn’t get paid until you do.

24
amilky912
Posts
19
Joined
3/2/2012
Location
Newport, NC, USA
4/17/2022 8:45am
I’m just here to see what BobfromPA has to say about the situation
2
3
JM485
Posts
5826
Joined
10/1/2013
Location
Davis, CA, USA
4/17/2022 8:46am
Brent wrote:
There are a couple of specific reasons, but sharing the details here is pointless and would only invite more poo throwing from the monkeys. That said...
There are a couple of specific reasons, but sharing the details here is pointless and would only invite more poo throwing from the monkeys.

That said, I believe Luxon is a good, well constructed clamp- and maybe no upper clamp of this basic weight saving design could survive an apparent front compression impact that this bike in ATL possibly suffered regardless of who made it.

Maybe something different happened, who knows.

Same broken upper clamp on a 2022 KTM two stroke happened at a local race at Glen Helen about three weeks ago, I believe it was a stock clamp that broke the same way in the same place.

If you apply enough force, anything will break.
If you’re going to come into a thread and claim another product is superior and would not have suffered the same failure, I don’t think it’s too much to ask for specific reasons why you feel that way. Based on the photos I have seen both clamp designs use the same pinch bolt setup and visually have a similar amount of material in that particular area where the failure occurred, so the only other point of deviation would be material choice. Unless X-Trig is using 7000 series alloys I don’t see enough deviation to make a measurable difference.
5
1
4/17/2022 9:17am
bvm111 wrote:
it was only 15Nm … back at 20Nm, going to throw that on the pre ride check list! Thanks for the info Billy….Get the torque wrenches...
it was only 15Nm … back at 20Nm, going to throw that on the pre ride check list!

Thanks for the info Billy….Get the torque wrenches out fellas!
Just to screw with your head- when was the last time your torque wrench was calibrated?
bvm111 wrote:
oh man that really screwed with my head… man you got me, good one! Blink
Just a bit of fun man, FFS, cool down.🙄
8
4/17/2022 9:20am
Sandusky26 wrote:
I build houses for a living and I wish I had customers like half the guys in this thread. Im supposed to go work on a...
I build houses for a living and I wish I had customers like half the guys in this thread.

Im supposed to go work on a pocket door on Monday, I’m gonna tell her it’s a freak accident and charge her double.
‘Racing’ bro, ‘racing’. No warranty on racing products.
4
Kenny Lingus
Posts
1087
Joined
9/9/2016
Location
Watkins Glen, NY, USA
4/17/2022 9:22am
Damned if you do. Damned if you don't.
2
Hammer 663s
Posts
3115
Joined
6/2/2016
Location
None, AE, USA
4/17/2022 9:26am
Manual calls for red locktite on that bolt. We check our triple clamp torque and headsets on a very regular basis, at least monthly. Here's a good KTM setup vid for doing it right. It's worth taking the time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nWf18AhTOk

We run luxon bar mounts. Bent the lower in a big crash a few weeks ago. Destroyed the bars too and some other small parts. Some impacts are beyond a design to take. Cheap, light, strong. Pick 2.

Hammer 663s

7
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
4/17/2022 9:43am
I’m not an engineer, so that being said… If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of...
I’m not an engineer, so that being said…

If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of maintenance to keep it safe, why would aftermarket companies utilize this design rather than switching to a more traditional triple clamp design for their KTM clamps?
The design isn't inherently flawed to begin with, if the bolts are torqued correctly and nothing comes loose, then it works fine. The same thing can be said for multiple other parts on the bike.

That said, we could revise the design and use the more "traditional" style. But that brings up multiple other issues as we have to work around the geometry that's there (the frame, etc.). It's typically beneficial to maintain the same or similar features to stock than to change things up completely:

* Customers are already used to the KTM/Husky/GasGas clamps, and keeping the same design gives them what they're used to.
* The owner's manuals, instructions, etc. all refer to the same design that way.

* Spare parts are easy to come by in a rush situation. The stock steering stem, steering stem nut, bolts, bar mounts, etc. are all compatible with our triple clamps.

* Keeping the same design maintains compatibility with other parts. For example, steering dampers are all designed to work around the stock KTM design. A traditional locknut is a lot taller than the KTM style, which may interfere with other aftermarket parts.

* If we were to move to an adjuster nut under the clamp and a locknut on top, we would have to thin out the triple clamp to make room for the thickness of the adjuster nut. This would remove a significant amount of material in an area that's highly stressed. Making the clamp thicker to compensate either raises up the top nut further so it interferes with the bar mounts and/or even more interference with other aftermarket parts (point above).
* Making the entire triple clamp taller to remove that issue completely changes the geometry - bar mounts move higher, triple clamps are higher on the fork tubes (in this case they would be above the top of the fork tubes), etc.

So it's not as simple as just changing the design to the more traditional style. That's why you see all the aftermarket companies using the same style of design in this spot.
40
1
Sandusky26
Posts
3553
Joined
7/28/2021
Location
Eastern, NC, USA
4/17/2022 9:47am
Sandusky26 wrote:
I build houses for a living and I wish I had customers like half the guys in this thread. Im supposed to go work on a...
I build houses for a living and I wish I had customers like half the guys in this thread.

Im supposed to go work on a pocket door on Monday, I’m gonna tell her it’s a freak accident and charge her double.
‘Racing’ bro, ‘racing’. No warranty on racing products.
5 minutes or 5 miles whichever comes first.
3
4
4/17/2022 9:51am
Manual calls for red locktite on that bolt. We check our triple clamp torque and headsets on a very regular basis, at least monthly. Here's a...
Manual calls for red locktite on that bolt. We check our triple clamp torque and headsets on a very regular basis, at least monthly. Here's a good KTM setup vid for doing it right. It's worth taking the time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nWf18AhTOk

We run luxon bar mounts. Bent the lower in a big crash a few weeks ago. Destroyed the bars too and some other small parts. Some impacts are beyond a design to take. Cheap, light, strong. Pick 2.

Hammer 663s

CREDIT: Keith Bontrager.
3
#434
Posts
1912
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
DE
4/17/2022 11:13am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2022 11:39am
chuckie108 wrote:
Being a generic internet engineer myself- I’d like to know if some of the actual engineers on here have an opinion on this. It appears to...
Being a generic internet engineer myself- I’d like to know if some of the actual engineers on here have an opinion on this. It appears to me that the only way to cause this type of failure would be to load the front wheel with a large force back towards the down tube through the front wheel. Like hitting a wall, or flipping the bike down the track. It’s seams to me, the big forces you’d see during normal riding, casing a triple for example, would load the tripe clamp in the other direction. Point being, all the fear of the Austrian’s “inferior design” may not actually be realistic. Unless you plan on running into a wall anytime soon, or front braking forces rise substantially.
I‘m an engineer and the explanations (also in other threads) given by Luxon are sound. Of course he wants to promote/protect his product, but I never read something from his side that I disagreed with from a technical standpoint. Also his products and design methods are technically above the average moto billet parts hop up shop. If I was to buy a triple clamp tomorrow it would be from him, Xtrig or the KTM power part clamps.
In my opinion the Japanese style top triple clamp design is a safer design, because it is less likely to fail if anything on the triple clamp is loose/not torqued to spec. However, if the pinch bolt on the KTM style triple clamps is roughly torque to spec, I don’t see how it could lead to such a catastrophic failure.

Edit: I think that the loads on the area that failed are more complex when landing from a big jump than just a load from the front or the back on the forks. So it’s hard to say which load or situation killed the triple clamp. Is there a video?
10
1
ckadlec796
Posts
28
Joined
2/2/2018
Location
Hayward, WI, USA
4/17/2022 11:17am
MX Culture wrote:
I'm just here to see how Remy is doing.
anyone?
Ramy is ok. He has a badly sprained ankle but no broken bones.
4
PTshox
Posts
1600
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
4/17/2022 11:28am
Manual calls for red locktite on that bolt. We check our triple clamp torque and headsets on a very regular basis, at least monthly. Here's a...
Manual calls for red locktite on that bolt. We check our triple clamp torque and headsets on a very regular basis, at least monthly. Here's a good KTM setup vid for doing it right. It's worth taking the time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nWf18AhTOk

We run luxon bar mounts. Bent the lower in a big crash a few weeks ago. Destroyed the bars too and some other small parts. Some impacts are beyond a design to take. Cheap, light, strong. Pick 2.

Hammer 663s

CREDIT: Keith Bontrager.
Why the credit Keith Bontrager? Keith is an interesting dude.....
1
2
Wildeye511
Posts
772
Joined
10/1/2014
Location
Las Vegas, NV, USA
4/17/2022 12:16pm
I’m not an engineer, so that being said… If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of...
I’m not an engineer, so that being said…

If we’ve established that the KTM design is flawed to begin with and requires an excessive amount of maintenance to keep it safe, why would aftermarket companies utilize this design rather than switching to a more traditional triple clamp design for their KTM clamps?
Luxon MX wrote:
The design isn't inherently flawed to begin with, if the bolts are torqued correctly and nothing comes loose, then it works fine. The same thing can...
The design isn't inherently flawed to begin with, if the bolts are torqued correctly and nothing comes loose, then it works fine. The same thing can be said for multiple other parts on the bike.

That said, we could revise the design and use the more "traditional" style. But that brings up multiple other issues as we have to work around the geometry that's there (the frame, etc.). It's typically beneficial to maintain the same or similar features to stock than to change things up completely:

* Customers are already used to the KTM/Husky/GasGas clamps, and keeping the same design gives them what they're used to.
* The owner's manuals, instructions, etc. all refer to the same design that way.

* Spare parts are easy to come by in a rush situation. The stock steering stem, steering stem nut, bolts, bar mounts, etc. are all compatible with our triple clamps.

* Keeping the same design maintains compatibility with other parts. For example, steering dampers are all designed to work around the stock KTM design. A traditional locknut is a lot taller than the KTM style, which may interfere with other aftermarket parts.

* If we were to move to an adjuster nut under the clamp and a locknut on top, we would have to thin out the triple clamp to make room for the thickness of the adjuster nut. This would remove a significant amount of material in an area that's highly stressed. Making the clamp thicker to compensate either raises up the top nut further so it interferes with the bar mounts and/or even more interference with other aftermarket parts (point above).
* Making the entire triple clamp taller to remove that issue completely changes the geometry - bar mounts move higher, triple clamps are higher on the fork tubes (in this case they would be above the top of the fork tubes), etc.

So it's not as simple as just changing the design to the more traditional style. That's why you see all the aftermarket companies using the same style of design in this spot.
Thank you for that info.
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
4/17/2022 12:20pm
actually...I just re-read this and while there were a couple of dumbass comments, we also have 30+year machinists in here simply spitballing ideas and theories on...
actually...I just re-read this and while there were a couple of dumbass comments, we also have 30+year machinists in here simply spitballing ideas and theories on things, and doing so quite respectfully. I knew the Luxon guy would get dragged into this as soon as I saw this thread and he has done a fine job of explaining things though was a bit defensive cause his name was brought up. I suppose I would be defensive a little as well.

your disdain for your users (even post retirement) is mind-boggling.
This was directed at one or two users here. Not all of them.

My users? They're Michael's headache now. Wink

As far as a burner account that someone else suggested? Not worth the time.
6
2
RandomUserName
Posts
1180
Joined
9/5/2021
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
4/17/2022 12:26pm
actually...I just re-read this and while there were a couple of dumbass comments, we also have 30+year machinists in here simply spitballing ideas and theories on...
actually...I just re-read this and while there were a couple of dumbass comments, we also have 30+year machinists in here simply spitballing ideas and theories on things, and doing so quite respectfully. I knew the Luxon guy would get dragged into this as soon as I saw this thread and he has done a fine job of explaining things though was a bit defensive cause his name was brought up. I suppose I would be defensive a little as well.

your disdain for your users (even post retirement) is mind-boggling.
GuyB wrote:
This was directed at one or two users here. Not all of them. My users? They're Michael's headache now. ;) As far as a burner account...
This was directed at one or two users here. Not all of them.

My users? They're Michael's headache now. Wink

As far as a burner account that someone else suggested? Not worth the time.
yeah, that's fine. But you yourself have admitted at your burnout with the admin role here, and it's evident with your continued staring-down-your-glasses-at-users perspective even AFTER all of us becoming "michael's headache"..

Enjoy your retirement.
11
18
rbm33
Posts
489
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Duncan, OK, USA
4/17/2022 2:23pm
chuckie108 wrote:
Being a generic internet engineer myself- I’d like to know if some of the actual engineers on here have an opinion on this. It appears to...
Being a generic internet engineer myself- I’d like to know if some of the actual engineers on here have an opinion on this. It appears to me that the only way to cause this type of failure would be to load the front wheel with a large force back towards the down tube through the front wheel. Like hitting a wall, or flipping the bike down the track. It’s seams to me, the big forces you’d see during normal riding, casing a triple for example, would load the tripe clamp in the other direction. Point being, all the fear of the Austrian’s “inferior design” may not actually be realistic. Unless you plan on running into a wall anytime soon, or front braking forces rise substantially.
#434 wrote:
I‘m an engineer and the explanations (also in other threads) given by Luxon are sound. Of course he wants to promote/protect his product, but I never...
I‘m an engineer and the explanations (also in other threads) given by Luxon are sound. Of course he wants to promote/protect his product, but I never read something from his side that I disagreed with from a technical standpoint. Also his products and design methods are technically above the average moto billet parts hop up shop. If I was to buy a triple clamp tomorrow it would be from him, Xtrig or the KTM power part clamps.
In my opinion the Japanese style top triple clamp design is a safer design, because it is less likely to fail if anything on the triple clamp is loose/not torqued to spec. However, if the pinch bolt on the KTM style triple clamps is roughly torque to spec, I don’t see how it could lead to such a catastrophic failure.

Edit: I think that the loads on the area that failed are more complex when landing from a big jump than just a load from the front or the back on the forks. So it’s hard to say which load or situation killed the triple clamp. Is there a video?
And to build off what you said this failure most likely wasn’t due to one impact. It would be interesting to see a stain gauge on that part of the factory triple clamp under a hard landing. Although I’m sure there is plenty of FEA Models run under different scenarios. However, as with any fea with the results are only as good as your assumptions and I’m sure there are a lot of assumptions involved with constraints and dynamic loads a part like this.
1
sandman768
Posts
8306
Joined
3/21/2014
Location
Saratoga Springs, NY, USA
4/17/2022 2:57pm
Manual calls for red locktite on that bolt. We check our triple clamp torque and headsets on a very regular basis, at least monthly. Here's a...
Manual calls for red locktite on that bolt. We check our triple clamp torque and headsets on a very regular basis, at least monthly. Here's a good KTM setup vid for doing it right. It's worth taking the time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nWf18AhTOk

We run luxon bar mounts. Bent the lower in a big crash a few weeks ago. Destroyed the bars too and some other small parts. Some impacts are beyond a design to take. Cheap, light, strong. Pick 2.

Hammer 663s

Good video 👍
Roczoff
Posts
234
Joined
1/23/2022
Location
Missoula, MT, USA
4/17/2022 3:05pm
I'm surprised that the pro-freedom types aren't saying it's the rider's responsibility to make sure his bike is safe, and that the Japanese design wussifies the sport.

Properly installed, adjusted, and maintained -and not smashed into an immovable object at 40mph- there's no issue.

And having a structure absorb energy in a crash is often very good for the driver/rider's health, but that's another discussion.

When danger hits close to home, personal responsibility can become very unpopular.

(Flame suit activated!)
10
20
Chris_Buehler
Posts
8761
Joined
7/21/2019
Location
PORTLAND, CT, USA
4/17/2022 3:11pm
Just to screw with your head- when was the last time your torque wrench was calibrated?
bvm111 wrote:
oh man that really screwed with my head… man you got me, good one! Blink
Just a bit of fun man, FFS, cool down.🙄
Ya he needs to cool down. That response was really off the rails. Smh
2
3
4/17/2022 3:24pm
Sandusky26 wrote:
I build houses for a living and I wish I had customers like half the guys in this thread. Im supposed to go work on a...
I build houses for a living and I wish I had customers like half the guys in this thread.

Im supposed to go work on a pocket door on Monday, I’m gonna tell her it’s a freak accident and charge her double.
I'm lost here, what does putting a pocket door in have anything to do with being a manufacturer of a product? You build your own custom tracks bro?
6
5
4/17/2022 3:34pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2022 3:40pm
Werid Suzuki has no problem running a simular design for the factory supported teams....


Makes you wonder, is it the part or the people that are installing/working on the parts that suzuki was thinking about when they went rogue on producing an inferior part according to the internet experts.
2
14

Post a reply to: KTM broke in half.

The Latest