Would AJ's ride made a difference on Alta's outcome if 2 years ago?

Falcon
Posts
12480
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
10/19/2020 11:06am
A friend of mine got smoked by an Alta at Cahuilla this weekend. He's a solid Vet "A" rider on a 2020 YZ450F.
Yeah, I'm interested in electric bikes. Cool
5
Tim507
Posts
3484
Joined
6/8/2010
Location
Oregon City, OR, USA
10/19/2020 11:15am
I'm 68 and I really want to ride an Electric MX Bike!

Hope they (KTM or Honda) make it to the market in a few years if not sooner......

I'm currently waiting in an E-Pure Trials Bike. It has shipped from France and should be here in a few weeks.

https://www.electric-motion.fr/en/
9
1
mikec265
Posts
1668
Joined
10/19/2015
Location
Edinboro, PA, USA
10/19/2020 12:27pm
gt80rider wrote:
First off... electric is not new tech... its old.. super old... Tesla (the real one) was doing it back just after the turn of the 1900s...
First off... electric is not new tech... its old.. super old... Tesla (the real one) was doing it back just after the turn of the 1900s...

Secondly.. its no cleaner than gas......

Third.... gas engines are MUCH easier to ride... electric has too much torque down low, making for an odd (yet fast) feel... feels fast from a dead stop, but that isn't an advantage...

Electric is the way those that run the show, want things to go now.... nothing more, nothing less.. this isn't zero point energy here....
It's pretty obvious that you have not ridden an Alta.
I know people who had the same opinion as you, but then they rode mine! I was skeptical at first, then I saw Hill on one at straight rhythm, test rode one, and got a tattoo.
10
1
FGR01
Posts
6137
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
USA
Fantasy
10/19/2020 1:30pm
Not fighting for or against the Alta, I really have no dog in that fight. But I have thousands of laps on that track AJ was riding in the video and I have never seen it that dry and slick. I would say that track and those conditions played very well to the strong points of the Alta. His opinion may have differed on a different track or set of conditions.

The Shop

vetmxr
Posts
1113
Joined
1/10/2009
Location
USA
10/24/2020 9:46am
Falcon wrote:
A friend of mine got smoked by an Alta at Cahuilla this weekend. He's a solid Vet "A" rider on a 2020 YZ450F. Yeah, I'm interested...
A friend of mine got smoked by an Alta at Cahuilla this weekend. He's a solid Vet "A" rider on a 2020 YZ450F.
Yeah, I'm interested in electric bikes. Cool
Its not the bike.....Wink
2
FLmxer
Posts
7310
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
SouthWest, FL, USA
Fantasy
10/24/2020 10:42am
I posted AJ's video in the Electric section a few days ago. I got one of these yesterday and its tech is so amazing. All the different power settings in a phone app. They even race these on mtb trails.

1
10/24/2020 11:51am
FLmxer wrote:
I posted AJ's video in the Electric section a few days ago. I got one of these yesterday and its tech is so amazing. All the...
I posted AJ's video in the Electric section a few days ago. I got one of these yesterday and its tech is so amazing. All the different power settings in a phone app. They even race these on mtb trails.

What kind of mtn bike trails you have? That’s thing wouldn’t make it up my driveway where I live haha.
3
FLmxer
Posts
7310
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
SouthWest, FL, USA
Fantasy
10/24/2020 12:27pm
You would be surprised. It goes like 28mph i think and you can buy knobbies. They have huge races in the mountains all over the world with hundreds of entries. I been riding mine all over my yard and its really soft ground but no problem. Fun little toys.
https://youtu.be/flBIjrThWPc
https://youtu.be/iHLWINh9y9U
https://youtu.be/BLR6p-eT71w
2
2
mark_swart
Posts
2523
Joined
11/2/2011
Location
Chapin, SC, USA
10/26/2020 12:12pm
I am bummed that Alta didn't succeed but I don't think that AJ's ride would have been a huge boost. I still think it is relevant and important as we move toward electric.
I feel like this is the best hope for our sport to evolve and actually grow. A base platform could be used for moto, offroad, and dual sport with simple power mods to fit each one. That would offer an economy of scale in production that we simply cannot get now. Maybe the R comes with top level suspension, the L comes with simpler stuff at a lower cost. Plug in lightning/ turn assemblies so that you can easily throw on a light kit for road use.
And now you have a much easier sell to parents, wives, etc, because that $10k bike isn't just a weekend toy.
Then add in maintenance, or the lack thereof. The electric will simply make the sport more accessible. Then there's the noise elimination.
So much potential to advance our sport all the way across the board....
2
1
mwr
Posts
151
Joined
4/23/2011
Location
USA
10/26/2020 2:11pm Edited Date/Time 10/26/2020 2:12pm
Skylebones wrote:
I'm honestly excited about electric bikes only because we've had so many local tracks close because of noise issues. If that fixes the problem and more...
I'm honestly excited about electric bikes only because we've had so many local tracks close because of noise issues. If that fixes the problem and more tracks stay open, sign me up!
Sawfish wrote:
They’ll complain about dust next. Even if there isn’t any. Or some endangered lizard.
An endangered lizard is a pretty good reason not to be an a-hole. Dust? That can be mitigated.
4
#76
Posts
622
Joined
7/6/2012
Location
GB
10/27/2020 1:03pm
Try living in the U.K. with how small it is, add noise from Moto tracks....this is why my MXR is docking on Nov 2nd!.

Can't bloody wait!. Woohoo
2
fullysicmate
Posts
1647
Joined
1/4/2013
Location
Queensland, AU
10/27/2020 1:28pm
gt80rider wrote:
First off... electric is not new tech... its old.. super old... Tesla (the real one) was doing it back just after the turn of the 1900s...
First off... electric is not new tech... its old.. super old... Tesla (the real one) was doing it back just after the turn of the 1900s...

Secondly.. its no cleaner than gas......

Third.... gas engines are MUCH easier to ride... electric has too much torque down low, making for an odd (yet fast) feel... feels fast from a dead stop, but that isn't an advantage...

Electric is the way those that run the show, want things to go now.... nothing more, nothing less.. this isn't zero point energy here....
You clearly have no clue..
3
3
DuroTools
Posts
755
Joined
9/9/2015
Location
Middletown, CT, USA
11/7/2020 3:20pm
Zoom wrote:
I was a Regional Manager for Alta and trust me HD was not the downfall of Alta. There was an agreement between Alta and HD for...
I was a Regional Manager for Alta and trust me HD was not the downfall of Alta.

There was an agreement between Alta and HD for Alta to build an entry level bike for Harley. The deal went sideways and the deal broke up. There was another OE that came into the picture and was interested in doing a 100% acquisition of Alta. We were pumped. It looked like a great deal.

After that OE saw the bleeding, they pulled the plug on the deal. Many investors were interested but the bleeding was too great at that point.

It was really hard for a high tech, start up, dirt bike company based in Silicon Valley to sell enough units to pay the bills. We were selling one product, a dirt bike. If that same dirt bike was branded as a Honda/Kawasaki/Yamaha and had ATV's, UTV's, street bikes, other dirt bikes, lawn mowers, generators etc. also being sold it would have worked.

I truly believe that if Alta could have made it to 2020, with the help of the pandemic and people getting outdoors more on trails and tracks with dirt bikes sales going through the roof, they would have made it.

I loved the bike, the company, the people and my job. No regrets. Well, one. Wish I would have kept at least one of my 5 demos!
flykay wrote:
Thanks for sharing that Zoom. Its sad that so many blame HD then. So your opinion is solely towards the tough challenge business wise,start up etc...
Thanks for sharing that Zoom. Its sad that so many blame HD then.
So your opinion is solely towards the tough challenge business wise,start up etc or where there also factors as location and being in California?
Zoom wrote:
Harley was an easy target and had history with their partnership with Beull. Yes, being based in Silicon Valley made it difficult, but it also helped...
Harley was an easy target and had history with their partnership with Beull.

Yes, being based in Silicon Valley made it difficult, but it also helped attract a group of engineers from Tesla that joined the team early to help create the battery.back.

The Alta battery was the secret sauce. It was the most powerful compact battery in transportation in the world.
Is it still the best battery or could a newer technology be made to make the bike lighter? If an e dirtbike could get under 240 lbs I might buy one.
Zoom
Posts
1397
Joined
10/21/2012
Location
Cypress, TX, USA
11/8/2020 7:54am
flykay wrote:
Thanks for sharing that Zoom. Its sad that so many blame HD then. So your opinion is solely towards the tough challenge business wise,start up etc...
Thanks for sharing that Zoom. Its sad that so many blame HD then.
So your opinion is solely towards the tough challenge business wise,start up etc or where there also factors as location and being in California?
Zoom wrote:
Harley was an easy target and had history with their partnership with Beull. Yes, being based in Silicon Valley made it difficult, but it also helped...
Harley was an easy target and had history with their partnership with Beull.

Yes, being based in Silicon Valley made it difficult, but it also helped attract a group of engineers from Tesla that joined the team early to help create the battery.back.

The Alta battery was the secret sauce. It was the most powerful compact battery in transportation in the world.
DuroTools wrote:
Is it still the best battery or could a newer technology be made to make the bike lighter? If an e dirtbike could get under 240...
Is it still the best battery or could a newer technology be made to make the bike lighter? If an e dirtbike could get under 240 lbs I might buy one.
Alta did a test on rotating engine mass.

The conclusion was that the rotating engine mass of a 450 4-stroke engine was equivalent to 50lbs.

The Alta had zero rotating engine mass. That's why it was so much fun to corner and lay over in a rut. Same reason a 125 is easier to rail ruts because it has a lot less rotating engine mass than a 450. The more rotating engine mass, the more a bike wants to stand up in a corner.

When a rider would ask me how much it ways before they did a demo ride, I would tell them to ride it then tell me what the weight felt like. Most said the weight felt like a 250. Not 250lbs, but like a 250F, which is close to 230lbs. An Alta was about 260.

Where the weight was noticed was when you had to put the bike on a stand or pick it up from a crash.
1
1
kkawboy14
Posts
11486
Joined
6/5/2015
Location
USA
11/8/2020 10:30am
yz133rider wrote:
If Alta would have not gotten involved with hd they’d likely be around still.
Not true!

They needed a lot more money, that’s why they went to HD.

They just needed another $50 million to be in good shape! Look how much Tesla has lost since they have been in business.
11/8/2020 12:08pm
Where is that Honda, surely its getting closer along in development towards release?
1
1
DuroTools
Posts
755
Joined
9/9/2015
Location
Middletown, CT, USA
11/9/2020 12:35am
Zoom wrote:
Harley was an easy target and had history with their partnership with Beull. Yes, being based in Silicon Valley made it difficult, but it also helped...
Harley was an easy target and had history with their partnership with Beull.

Yes, being based in Silicon Valley made it difficult, but it also helped attract a group of engineers from Tesla that joined the team early to help create the battery.back.

The Alta battery was the secret sauce. It was the most powerful compact battery in transportation in the world.
DuroTools wrote:
Is it still the best battery or could a newer technology be made to make the bike lighter? If an e dirtbike could get under 240...
Is it still the best battery or could a newer technology be made to make the bike lighter? If an e dirtbike could get under 240 lbs I might buy one.
Zoom wrote:
Alta did a test on rotating engine mass. The conclusion was that the rotating engine mass of a 450 4-stroke engine was equivalent to 50lbs. The...
Alta did a test on rotating engine mass.

The conclusion was that the rotating engine mass of a 450 4-stroke engine was equivalent to 50lbs.

The Alta had zero rotating engine mass. That's why it was so much fun to corner and lay over in a rut. Same reason a 125 is easier to rail ruts because it has a lot less rotating engine mass than a 450. The more rotating engine mass, the more a bike wants to stand up in a corner.

When a rider would ask me how much it ways before they did a demo ride, I would tell them to ride it then tell me what the weight felt like. Most said the weight felt like a 250. Not 250lbs, but like a 250F, which is close to 230lbs. An Alta was about 260.

Where the weight was noticed was when you had to put the bike on a stand or pick it up from a crash.
Someone gave this a thumbsdown so I wonder if they disagree. I have a 2015 yz250fx that is so fun at the track but when I land to flats either over jumping or under jumping it feels like a boat slapping down. I think it's because it weighs 254 lbs and my FC 250 weighs 30 lbs less. That's really interesting to hear about the weight feeling like less but just wonder of that is only when cornering. I still hope they get the weight down on the new Honda!
1
11/9/2020 4:31am
As the insider told us, it was neither HD nor the amount of sales. Innovation requires big shoulders to be able to survive to the losses until your size becomes big enough. Tesla made it, Amazon made it, Alta didn't
2
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
11/12/2020 1:25pm
any alta owners mind sharing where they had their suspension done?
1

Post a reply to: Would AJ's ride made a difference on Alta's outcome if 2 years ago?

The Latest