How MX safety has evolved in the last 30 years?

RDX
Posts
111
Joined
11/7/2016
Location
MX
Edited Date/Time 1/19/2018 8:46am
To me not much.

It is true that we got better suspensions, helmets, boots, knee braces and so on than on Ricky Johnson's era, but at the same time the sport has grown so much technically that today any amateur kid at the track jumps, scrubs, goes faster and do things that most of the pros long time ago wouldn't even dream about.

A1 and Houston had some sections where it looked like BMX at 50 miles an hour. The one where Wilson got hurt and Roczen almost washed? Man, those guys are monsters.

The bikes are good. Riders and teams take it more and more professionally every year. Everyone, even amateurs take it seriously.

This made our sport to grow up a lot lately.
But safety did not. At least not at the same pace as the sport itself.

Neck braces came to save our backs and broke our collarbones. Chest protectors don't do much more than 30 years ago. Apart from boots, knee braces and helmets, what do we have to minimize the damage?
|
CalRMX
Posts
207
Joined
4/17/2015
Location
Brea, CA, USA
1/18/2018 6:07pm
Stay home and sit on the couch, about the safest way I know of not getting hurt.

We all know the risks.
kzizok
Posts
8426
Joined
10/19/2010
Location
USA
1/18/2018 6:34pm
There are numerous safety related products that you failed to acknowledge (that have evolved in the last thirty years).
yz133rider
Posts
5027
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA, USA
1/18/2018 6:58pm
CalRMX wrote:
Stay home and sit on the couch, about the safest way I know of not getting hurt.

We all know the risks.
Very helpful lol
Wandell
Posts
7849
Joined
12/17/2008
Location
Cairo, GA, USA
1/18/2018 7:02pm
I've been riding since 1980. Helmets have become lighter and vented, but actual protection hasn't evolved much until the last few years. Most chest/roost deflectors are only slightly updated over Bob Hannah's 1981 Flak Jak. I doubt any modern boot is more protective than the original Scott plastic boots that were only popular for a few years. Probably the best products I've seen come along are knee braces and the controversial neck braces.

The Shop

Joko
Posts
1548
Joined
1/2/2011
Location
Haddam, CT, USA
Fantasy
1/18/2018 7:45pm
If you think of the bike as safety equipment, power suspension and handling improvements keep you off the ground better today than a ‘73 TM400
Wandell
Posts
7849
Joined
12/17/2008
Location
Cairo, GA, USA
1/18/2018 8:06pm
I think that is the op's point. Bikes have advanced tremendously in the last 30 years, while a lot of riding/protective gear hasn't . Sure, bikes are safer in terms of suspension, brakes and handling. But they are also more powerful, yet easier to ride and you could argue this makes it more of a risk of hitting the ground harder.
Hank_Thrill
Posts
4662
Joined
9/22/2008
Location
Arlen, TX, USA
1/18/2018 8:32pm
Nearly every other professional racing format limits the power of the vehicles at some point. If this sport wants to decrease the injury rates, namely the 450 SX class, they will need to step in and put some type of performance limiter on the engines. It would also bunch up the pack and make for closer racing I would imagine.

Injuries will always happen in a dangerous sport, but things can be done to reduce the severity and frequency of these injuries.
1/18/2018 8:58pm
Nearly every other professional racing format limits the power of the vehicles at some point. If this sport wants to decrease the injury rates, namely the...
Nearly every other professional racing format limits the power of the vehicles at some point. If this sport wants to decrease the injury rates, namely the 450 SX class, they will need to step in and put some type of performance limiter on the engines. It would also bunch up the pack and make for closer racing I would imagine.

Injuries will always happen in a dangerous sport, but things can be done to reduce the severity and frequency of these injuries.
I think the same guys would be winning if they were on restricted motorcycles.
1/18/2018 9:32pm
I'm fairly certain there is a limit to the amount of protection you can offer a human being that is strapped to the exterior of a cage-less 40+HP two-wheeled machine by nothing more than two opposable thumbs and a bit of gravity; propelling itself over a bunch of obstacles while maintaining balance amidst complicated centrifugal and gyroscopic forces.
1/18/2018 10:44pm Edited Date/Time 1/18/2018 10:45pm
There's not much you can do, the only equipment that can evolve is helmets and boots.

You can't really counter dirt digs.
Hank_Thrill
Posts
4662
Joined
9/22/2008
Location
Arlen, TX, USA
1/18/2018 11:25pm Edited Date/Time 1/18/2018 11:26pm
Nearly every other professional racing format limits the power of the vehicles at some point. If this sport wants to decrease the injury rates, namely the...
Nearly every other professional racing format limits the power of the vehicles at some point. If this sport wants to decrease the injury rates, namely the 450 SX class, they will need to step in and put some type of performance limiter on the engines. It would also bunch up the pack and make for closer racing I would imagine.

Injuries will always happen in a dangerous sport, but things can be done to reduce the severity and frequency of these injuries.
I think the same guys would be winning if they were on restricted motorcycles.
I agree, the cream always rises to the top.
levimx22
Posts
1220
Joined
4/25/2011
Location
Coalgate, OK, USA
1/18/2018 11:27pm
NETS
Motofinne
Posts
11547
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
FI
1/18/2018 11:44pm Edited Date/Time 1/18/2018 11:49pm
The helmets have taken a huge step forward and the goggles are more safe with the high end thick injection molded lenses. But other than that i can't see anything big on the safety front.

Neck braces? Maybe, it depends if you believe that they work or not. I haven't seen any actual scientific studies about that(feel free to guide me to one if you know someone that has done that).

Knee braces have been around for 20 years. The OTS braces are better now than 10 years ago but that is mostly comfort and fitment. Custom is still the way to go if you have the money for it(i don't).

I'm still waiting for an airbag system that Dainese and Alpinestars have for road racing. Like ML mentioned in an other thread, it will be multiple years before we see the first units on an MX track. But i'm sure it's coming. I think Alpinestars offers it for their offroad riders(Dakar etc)?

The easiest way to get injuries down is to slow down everything(slower tracks since the current bikes are really fast).
lumpy790
Posts
11692
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
1/19/2018 6:15am
#1 improvement that is a million times safer and has redesigned how every helmet is manufactured for more safety.

From this ....



To this ......



kaptkaos
Posts
1087
Joined
11/17/2015
Location
Miami, FL, USA
1/19/2018 6:33am
Joko wrote:
If you think of the bike as safety equipment, power suspension and handling improvements keep you off the ground better today than a ‘73 TM400
I bet that 73 TM400 wasnt doing 70 ft tables and triples at 45 mph! It was running around a big turn track in the countryside and barely jumping and didnt have the acceleration to rip your arms off or take you for a ride, buck you off, and then chase you and impale you against the face of a jump!

So in fact, the new bikes are way more dangerous.
kaptkaos
Posts
1087
Joined
11/17/2015
Location
Miami, FL, USA
1/19/2018 6:36am
Motofinne wrote:
The helmets have taken a huge step forward and the goggles are more safe with the high end thick injection molded lenses. But other than that...
The helmets have taken a huge step forward and the goggles are more safe with the high end thick injection molded lenses. But other than that i can't see anything big on the safety front.

Neck braces? Maybe, it depends if you believe that they work or not. I haven't seen any actual scientific studies about that(feel free to guide me to one if you know someone that has done that).

Knee braces have been around for 20 years. The OTS braces are better now than 10 years ago but that is mostly comfort and fitment. Custom is still the way to go if you have the money for it(i don't).

I'm still waiting for an airbag system that Dainese and Alpinestars have for road racing. Like ML mentioned in an other thread, it will be multiple years before we see the first units on an MX track. But i'm sure it's coming. I think Alpinestars offers it for their offroad riders(Dakar etc)?

The easiest way to get injuries down is to slow down everything(slower tracks since the current bikes are really fast).
Last year I would have agreed with you on slowing things down, but Marvin was pretty well slowed down before he hit the shoulder on the turf. Eli was maybe a bit faster. Both got hurt because a bare shoulder hit the ground.

Deano was going pretty fast and hit hard. True chest shoulder protection might not have prevented injury, but possibly lessened it.
1/19/2018 6:49am
Joko wrote:
If you think of the bike as safety equipment, power suspension and handling improvements keep you off the ground better today than a ‘73 TM400
Either way you are pushing the edge. It's just that now you are doing it at double the speed. Not safer.
lumpy790
Posts
11692
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
1/19/2018 6:57am
Motofinne wrote:
The helmets have taken a huge step forward and the goggles are more safe with the high end thick injection molded lenses. But other than that...
The helmets have taken a huge step forward and the goggles are more safe with the high end thick injection molded lenses. But other than that i can't see anything big on the safety front.

Neck braces? Maybe, it depends if you believe that they work or not. I haven't seen any actual scientific studies about that(feel free to guide me to one if you know someone that has done that).

Knee braces have been around for 20 years. The OTS braces are better now than 10 years ago but that is mostly comfort and fitment. Custom is still the way to go if you have the money for it(i don't).

I'm still waiting for an airbag system that Dainese and Alpinestars have for road racing. Like ML mentioned in an other thread, it will be multiple years before we see the first units on an MX track. But i'm sure it's coming. I think Alpinestars offers it for their offroad riders(Dakar etc)?

The easiest way to get injuries down is to slow down everything(slower tracks since the current bikes are really fast).
kaptkaos wrote:
Last year I would have agreed with you on slowing things down, but Marvin was pretty well slowed down before he hit the shoulder on the...
Last year I would have agreed with you on slowing things down, but Marvin was pretty well slowed down before he hit the shoulder on the turf. Eli was maybe a bit faster. Both got hurt because a bare shoulder hit the ground.

Deano was going pretty fast and hit hard. True chest shoulder protection might not have prevented injury, but possibly lessened it.
I noticed in Bam Bams Houston podium interview he was wearing some protection under his jersey so there is something out there
mauidex
Posts
2069
Joined
9/12/2011
Location
Haiku, HI, USA
1/19/2018 7:23am
you can provide the best safety equipment on the planet but won't do fuk all if you dont wear it...........lets recap, wilson, tomac, musquin............a jersey does not offer much shoulder protection

and the guy who almost lost his arm comes back wearing nothing either. He did get used to a wrist brace because he thought he needed it..........its all in the head.........maybe some of the up and comers will realize they're not invincible and at least try to use something but I'm not holding my breath!!Unsure Unsure
kkawboy14
Posts
11486
Joined
6/5/2015
Location
USA
1/19/2018 7:27am
Moto lost some cool stuff when JT got sick of the industry!
125mx.fi
Posts
36
Joined
1/23/2012
Location
Vantaa, FI
1/19/2018 7:48am
There is really advanced chest/back/shoulder protection available from few manufacturers (Leatt, Acerbis, etc), that's not a problem. Problem is that no one is really interested to wear them. Male mind is programmed so that in twenties you feel invincible. We see results of that every weekend.
JMX82
Posts
1600
Joined
5/9/2013
Location
Hyllykallio, FI
1/19/2018 7:48am
One thing that everyone seems to forget is the weight of the bikes and what it does to safety. One of the most fundamental law of physics states that force equals mass times acceleration and reducing mass would decrease impact force when riders are hitting the ground. With four stroke revolution current bikes are faster and heavyer than before and it surtenly doesn't help with preventing injuries. I think lighter and less powerfull bikes would cause a lot less injuries.
gt80rider
Posts
7214
Joined
4/19/2008
Location
Boulder, CO, USA
1/19/2018 8:13am
"Have you noticed how much MX safety has de-evolved in the last 30 years?"

Fixed the title for ya!
Wandell
Posts
7849
Joined
12/17/2008
Location
Cairo, GA, USA
1/19/2018 8:25am
Of course full face helmets are a lot safer than the older open faced helmets. But I don't think full faced helmets advanced much in safety from the Bell Moto III, until recently. I think that the new MIPS equipped helmets and 6D helmets are a safety improvement. But I don't think my Bell Moto 8 is any safer than my old Bell Moto 3. It's a lot lighter and cooler, but I don't think its really any safer. Now, compare the advancements in football helmets. I have no doubt that the Ridell Speed my son wore last season is a lot safer than the suspension helmets that I started with as a kid.
Moto_Geek
Posts
1826
Joined
6/26/2007
Location
Golden, CO, USA
1/19/2018 8:33am
All padding absorbs impact energy better then previous and the material use to make safety equipment is more durable and comfortable. Helmets have safety releases. Gloves have knuckle protection. Some wear mouth guards now. People where body armor that covers areas more fully.
mxr746
Posts
66
Joined
7/22/2014
Location
Marietta, GA, USA
1/19/2018 8:46am
Rxr has an interesting concept with the inflatable chest protectors, but they appear as though they would not ventilate very well. Any reviews?

Post a reply to: How MX safety has evolved in the last 30 years?

The Latest