Are Tusk fork seals just plain junk?

Marty1028
Posts
955
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Lafayette, IN, USA

Rebuilt my WP 4CS forks with a set of the Tusk seals, probably 15 ish hours ago. Went out to a practice day Saturday and noticed that my caliper was completely covered in fork oil at the end of the day, and after washing walked out to the garage to find both forks leaking on the floor. I figured I should at least get 30 hours out of these, or am I just ignorant and should be doing seals and oil more often?

|
Moto520
Posts
3643
Joined
2/4/2013
Location
Schaumburg, IL, USA
10/3/2023 6:40pm

Well….yeah.   As of right now they are junk to me

1
10/3/2023 6:44pm

Almost all non oem fork seals are junk from my experience. 

23
BobPA
Posts
8334
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
USA
10/3/2023 6:44pm

15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do you ride in lots of mud, sand, or dust?

 

I have been using SKF seals exclusively for the last few years. They are not the cheapest by any means, but I (and my friends) have had excellent luck with them. Forks also operate much smoother after they are installed. Just spend a few more bucks and forget about it. I had well over 100 hours on my last set, changed the oil a few times and they never leaked. I eventually replaced them because I got nervous they were in there for so long.

 

13
Loftin79
Posts
202
Joined
5/22/2012
Location
USA
10/3/2023 6:50pm

Yes

The Shop

Marty1028
Posts
955
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Lafayette, IN, USA
10/3/2023 6:53pm
BobPA wrote:
15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do...

15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do you ride in lots of mud, sand, or dust?

 

I have been using SKF seals exclusively for the last few years. They are not the cheapest by any means, but I (and my friends) have had excellent luck with them. Forks also operate much smoother after they are installed. Just spend a few more bucks and forget about it. I had well over 100 hours on my last set, changed the oil a few times and they never leaked. I eventually replaced them because I got nervous they were in there for so long.

 

Always followed proper alignment procedure when installing front wheel, and forks were installed flush to the milled mark on the upper part of the clamp. I mainly race XC, and the last three rounds here in Indiana has been nothing but a dust bowl, we haven't had a good rain in months. Saturday was my first day on moto in a long time, definitely cased a bunch, but no real severe bottoming going on.

hubbardmx50
Posts
2814
Joined
11/17/2016
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
10/3/2023 7:18pm

Save the hassle and go OEM. Not worth it 

5
10/3/2023 7:23pm
BobPA wrote:
15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do...

15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do you ride in lots of mud, sand, or dust?

 

I have been using SKF seals exclusively for the last few years. They are not the cheapest by any means, but I (and my friends) have had excellent luck with them. Forks also operate much smoother after they are installed. Just spend a few more bucks and forget about it. I had well over 100 hours on my last set, changed the oil a few times and they never leaked. I eventually replaced them because I got nervous they were in there for so long.

 

+1 on the SKF seals!

3
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
10/3/2023 7:30pm

Call this guy... get these seals. He kinda knows a thing or two about fork and shock seals along with the mfg'ers of them. 

Mike Marquez 

Click Suspension

236 Goss Ave.

Santa Cruz, CA 95065

Phone: (831) 588-6720

 

1
NSP139
Posts
1270
Joined
5/6/2021
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
10/3/2023 7:42pm
BobPA wrote:
15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do...

15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do you ride in lots of mud, sand, or dust?

 

I have been using SKF seals exclusively for the last few years. They are not the cheapest by any means, but I (and my friends) have had excellent luck with them. Forks also operate much smoother after they are installed. Just spend a few more bucks and forget about it. I had well over 100 hours on my last set, changed the oil a few times and they never leaked. I eventually replaced them because I got nervous they were in there for so long.

 

+1 on the SKF seals!

+2 on SKF seals!!!

2
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
10/3/2023 8:01pm

btw the seal may have blown quick due to small damage to the fork tubes. Always run your finders over them and check for damage/ nicks before putting them back together. Often you can use a small file to knock them down (I use these really small files for that... google 10Pcs Needle File Set). Then and follow that by polishing the area with 600 or higher grit wet/dry sand paper. 

2
Timo
Posts
1465
Joined
1/9/2021
Location
Wichita, KS, USA
10/3/2023 8:01pm
BobPA wrote:
15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do...

15 hours is pathetic from a set of seals. But there are a bunch of factors involved. Do you have your fork legs aligned correctly? Do you ride in lots of mud, sand, or dust?

 

I have been using SKF seals exclusively for the last few years. They are not the cheapest by any means, but I (and my friends) have had excellent luck with them. Forks also operate much smoother after they are installed. Just spend a few more bucks and forget about it. I had well over 100 hours on my last set, changed the oil a few times and they never leaked. I eventually replaced them because I got nervous they were in there for so long.

 

+1 on the SKF seals!

NSP139 wrote:

+2 on SKF seals!!!

+3 you can get 100 hours from the HD set.

mxnick
Posts
1018
Joined
12/4/2007
Location
Nor Cal, CA, USA
10/3/2023 8:08pm Edited Date/Time 10/3/2023 8:08pm

I generally would avoid any Tusk product. 

4
8
Marty1028
Posts
955
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Lafayette, IN, USA
10/3/2023 8:43pm

+1 on the SKF seals!

NSP139 wrote:

+2 on SKF seals!!!

Timo wrote:

+3 you can get 100 hours from the HD set.

Looks like ill order some SKFs! Im gonna try to hold out on these tusk seals in the meantime. Only two rounds left in the season.

Marty1028
Posts
955
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Lafayette, IN, USA
10/3/2023 8:44pm
mxnick wrote:

I generally would avoid any Tusk product. 

Their tires seem OK. This is the first time I have ran their seals though.

PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
10/3/2023 8:46pm

Call Mike... it's a better and less expensive product. Go read his bio. He knows what he's doing. If you rode a fox fork on your mtn bike you've ridden products he was a key member of the development team. 

10/3/2023 8:54pm
NSP139 wrote:

+2 on SKF seals!!!

Timo wrote:

+3 you can get 100 hours from the HD set.

Marty1028 wrote:

Looks like ill order some SKFs! Im gonna try to hold out on these tusk seals in the meantime. Only two rounds left in the season.

You might want to replace your brake pads, they are never the same after being coated in fork oil.

2
StillSmokin
Posts
739
Joined
3/18/2022
Location
Edmond, OK, USA
10/3/2023 9:12pm

Tusk seals and parts are for when you're rebuilding your bike to sell it to some jabroni on Craigslist.

4
6
10/3/2023 9:16pm Edited Date/Time 10/5/2023 6:37am

Dang, I just ordered some Tusk seals and they arrive tomorrow. So far, I’ve always been impressed with Tusk products and figured I’d give them a shot. 

5
Derpin' DJ
Posts
6414
Joined
5/27/2011
Location
Newcastle, AU
10/3/2023 10:10pm

Wouldn't surprise me if the OEMs get their seals from SKF, so yeah, go SKF

1
Marty1028
Posts
955
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Lafayette, IN, USA
10/3/2023 10:40pm

Just looked on RM OEM section. Its the same price for all OEM bushings and seals, and the seals are made by SKF. But all of it's cheaper than the 75 bucks for the green SKF dust and oil seal kit.

Bearuno
Posts
5481
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
10/3/2023 10:41pm
PTshox wrote:
Call this guy... get these seals. He kinda knows a thing or two about fork and shock seals along with the mfg'ers of them.  Mike Marquez ...

Call this guy... get these seals. He kinda knows a thing or two about fork and shock seals along with the mfg'ers of them. 

Mike Marquez 

Click Suspension

236 Goss Ave.

Santa Cruz, CA 95065

Phone: (831) 588-6720

 

Neezer is   a Man who Knows about Suspension.

I dealt with him in my years of doing Fox suspension here in OZ.

Thank you so much for putting that up, I'd lost track of him since he left Fox. I'd like to catch up with him again.

As for seals - OEM or SKF is all I have used for years. I'll try Neezers (his?) stuff some time soon, I'd say.

PNWMXer
Posts
1770
Joined
1/13/2022
Location
Washington, WA, USA
10/4/2023 4:51am
Derpin' DJ wrote:

Wouldn't surprise me if the OEMs get their seals from SKF, so yeah, go SKF

I believe KTM/WP does. Not sure about the others.

2
lumpy790
Posts
11629
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
10/4/2023 6:36am
PTshox wrote:
btw the seal may have blown quick due to small damage to the fork tubes. Always run your finders over them and check for damage/ nicks...

btw the seal may have blown quick due to small damage to the fork tubes. Always run your finders over them and check for damage/ nicks before putting them back together. Often you can use a small file to knock them down (I use these really small files for that... google 10Pcs Needle File Set). Then and follow that by polishing the area with 600 or higher grit wet/dry sand paper. 

Fork tube nicks applies to any kind of fork seals damage. Worn or Loose bushings is another thing that allows the tube to move far enough sideways to pull the seal so it doesn’t seal and leak. 

1
studworx
Posts
835
Joined
1/24/2022
Location
Canada, QC, CA
10/4/2023 6:40am

A prepped tube with OEM seals is equally as good as any SKF and 50% the price

2
lumpy790
Posts
11629
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
10/4/2023 6:43am

One little other trick I have used on K&L seals in the past is pulling the spring out of the seal and shortening it a little bit so the seal is pulled a little tighter against the fork tube.

1
10/4/2023 6:47am

We ONLY use SKF, OEM, RaceTech,on most builds or K Tech seals if trying to save a few bucks....  Everything else we tried has been junk....

mx317
Posts
5350
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/4/2023 6:55am
studworx wrote:

A prepped tube with OEM seals is equally as good as any SKF and 50% the price

I have to disagree with that. One thing all newer KTM, Husky, Gas Gas OEM seals are SKF. My 49mm Showas on my Honda leaked with less than 5 hours on the bike until I replaced them with SKF. 20 hours and still leak free. Plus, you get different seals from the OEMs at times. Most are made by NOK or Nippon, but they are using some China seals now as well as other parts made there. The 50% price difference isn't correct for all bikes because you are getting a seal and wiper with SKF seals. I'm not trying to be a jerk, but that has been my experience.

3
1
endurox
Posts
2099
Joined
3/22/2014
Location
Garden City, ID, USA
10/4/2023 7:11am

Another plus on the SKF seals and wipers.

KurtJ99
Posts
2491
Joined
2/6/2017
Location
USA
10/4/2023 7:35am
PTshox wrote:
btw the seal may have blown quick due to small damage to the fork tubes. Always run your finders over them and check for damage/ nicks...

btw the seal may have blown quick due to small damage to the fork tubes. Always run your finders over them and check for damage/ nicks before putting them back together. Often you can use a small file to knock them down (I use these really small files for that... google 10Pcs Needle File Set). Then and follow that by polishing the area with 600 or higher grit wet/dry sand paper. 

This - not obvious but it’s necessary for a proper repair. Factory connection told me same. 

Post a reply to: Are Tusk fork seals just plain junk?

The Latest