How is it a world championship?

183Matt
Posts
856
Joined
10/9/2019
Location
Mineral, CA, USA
9/24/2023 12:12pm
183Matt wrote:
Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the...

Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the Continental United States.

 

Madmax31 wrote:
You people are so weird.  Who gives a s**t wtf they call it?  Is this all you can think to bitch about?   It was a great...

You people are so weird.  Who gives a s**t wtf they call it?  Is this all you can think to bitch about?  

It was a great series, great tracks, and very entertaining thanks DC and crew.  

How is it weird to ask a clarifying question?  I didn’t see how it’s a bitch either, but whatever.

1
RACING
Posts
1952
Joined
6/9/2023
Location
Waddafeuque, FR
9/24/2023 12:31pm
Mit12 wrote:
If they want to call the nationals or SX a world championship they can. The series is open to riders all over the world. The SX...

If they want to call the nationals or SX a world championship they can. The series is open to riders all over the world. The SX series scares most of the riders from other countries away.

No they can't. Yet they do.

Laughing

3
wreckitrandy
Posts
4224
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC, USA
9/24/2023 1:50pm
soyMotero wrote:
If having athletes from around the World is what makes a championship a "World Championship", then the Spanish, Portuguese, British, French, Italian... and pretty much every...

If having athletes from around the World is what makes a championship a "World Championship", then the Spanish, Portuguese, British, French, Italian... and pretty much every Football (Or as americans call it, soccer) leagues are World Championships.

Oh! BTW, Herlings, De Wolf, Lucas Coenen and Prado raced rounds of the Spanish Motocross Championship, therefore is a World Championship, so... Jose Butron is a Motocross World Champion then.

Yeah and there's a good chance that they faced if not stiffer, at least MORE competition in those 'national' championships. I mean get real. If going to Dubai and racing in front of more camels than people simply because the government there ponies up the coin for the sanction makes it a world championship, be proud of it I guess... I'm sure the Luongo dynasty appreciates your steadfast loyalty very little. 

1
DonM
Posts
8903
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
Fantasy
9/24/2023 3:39pm
Mit12 wrote:
If they want to call the nationals or SX a world championship they can. The series is open to riders all over the world. The SX...

If they want to call the nationals or SX a world championship they can. The series is open to riders all over the world. The SX series scares most of the riders from other countries away.

Tumic wrote:
Pretty sure FIM has the rights to call their series world championship, not AMA. just like when there was a shit storm around the world enduro...

Pretty sure FIM has the rights to call their series world championship, not AMA.

just like when there was a shit storm around the world enduro championship a couple of years ago and KTM/Husky left the series and created their own ”new” world championship, but they could not call it that since FIM had the rights to it.

 

They call it what they want because they don’t give a shit about the FIM…

2

The Shop

Crush
Posts
21129
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
9/24/2023 4:51pm
kage173 wrote:
Here's a question - if the 2 time "World champion can barely finish top 5 in a national championship, then how can you call him a...

Here's a question - if the 2 time "World champion can barely finish top 5 in a national championship, then how can you call him a "World champion"?

Always cracks me up how Euros think just because they get a bunch of tiny little European countries together that now it's the "world". 

So you think the National champ would show up to the World Champs and just win it tho, cause I got news for you. Ain’t that easy.

1
2
Crush
Posts
21129
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
9/24/2023 4:53pm Edited Date/Time 9/24/2023 4:55pm
The brain drain trust here believes because riders come here to race it makes it a world championship. as a regular thinking American this is patently...

The brain drain trust here believes because riders come here to race it makes it a world championship.

as a regular thinking American this is patently false.

world, should travel the fucking world. Its that simple

It really is. 

Draw of prize money or salary does not equal a world championship. 

1
3
9/24/2023 4:58pm

Okay how about the Wealthiest Pay Out Championship in the World.

Will that work or should we add National and Regional in the name to? 

1
109
Posts
473
Joined
4/2/2012
Location
Murrieta, CA, USA
9/24/2023 4:59pm
183Matt wrote:
Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the...

Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the Continental United States.

 

Brent wrote:
...then how can  MXGP claim to be a World Championship?  It hasn't come to the USA for quite a few years now... I think Feld and...

...then how can  MXGP claim to be a World Championship? 

It hasn't come to the USA for quite a few years now...

I think Feld and the AMA created their own unique hybrid MX/SX series - it is the only one on the planet that I know of.

There is no other series quite like the 2023 version of AMA SuperMotocross, so I think they can call it a world championship in this discipline until another series copies the exact same format?

soyMotero wrote:
The FIA Formula 1 Championship didn't race in the US between 2008 and 2011, I that means that Lewis Hamilton is a 6 time F1 "World"...

The FIA Formula 1 Championship didn't race in the US between 2008 and 2011, I that means that Lewis Hamilton is a 6 time F1 "World" Champion  and the 2008 European F1 champion, Button is also the 2009 European F1 Champion, and so on...

 

Didn't know Brazil, Australia and Japan were in Europe.

1
Beeby
Posts
2084
Joined
9/3/2009
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
9/24/2023 5:10pm

Neither rider that won last night will actually consider themselves “World Champion”

1
bvm111
Posts
10146
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Las Vegas, NV, USA
9/24/2023 5:16pm

IMG 8192 14

2
2
TeamGreen
Posts
37444
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
9/24/2023 5:29pm

Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the globe- carries the prestige of our Supercross series…especially among the pro racers themselves. Last nights SMX Finals represents the culmination the US Supercross and Motocross season’s best performers. Again, the highest paid professional racers in the sport of Motocross where there…even the ones that couldn’t race due to being injured (Eli & Malcolm, for example).

Combined with this…last night I watched a solid collection of the worlds best motocross racers from…

Australia 

Japan

Germany

France 

Scotland

Sweden 

And somewhere around 25+ states

Also, there’s this little gem…

The number of OEM Factory Teams, OEM supported teams, private teams and also…ACTUAL PRIVATEERS…is incomparable to ANY other professional motocross racing series…ANYWHERE. 

The Industry Representation at U.S. SX/MX/SMX is INEXPLICABLE compared to any other MX series…anywhere. 

For me, that’s one indication of a legitimate a World Class World Championship especially when it comes to the Supercross side of things…which SMX draws on quite heavily. 

I’ll also take note of Triumph debuting their New Motocross Models at…The SMX World Championship Final. 

For the record, that makes 8 manufacturers present last night…dare I say,”On track”…? Which is technically correct; but, is a little too literal. Laughing

Now, if ya wanna argue “Outdoor Motocross”. Well, I’m gonna have to say that MXGP carries the Global Prestige there. 

4
SydAus
Posts
211
Joined
8/8/2019
Location
AU
9/24/2023 5:35pm
aeffertz wrote:

Because you can name a series whatever you want to. 

MX690 wrote:

Yep and I think its awesome that Dean Ferris won the Australian motocross world championship.

Herr Lich wrote:

Yeah, and he's probably won the WA, NSW, and Victoria motocross world championships as well.Smile

What has Ferris got to do with this thread 💁‍♂️

mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
9/24/2023 5:56pm
kage173 wrote:
Here's a question - if the 2 time "World champion can barely finish top 5 in a national championship, then how can you call him a...

Here's a question - if the 2 time "World champion can barely finish top 5 in a national championship, then how can you call him a "World champion"?

Always cracks me up how Euros think just because they get a bunch of tiny little European countries together that now it's the "world". 

Crush wrote:
So you think the National champ would show up to the World Champs and just win it tho, cause I got news for you. Ain’t that...

So you think the National champ would show up to the World Champs and just win it tho, cause I got news for you. Ain’t that easy.

According to some on vital the usa is the easier series,  easy titles,$$. Lol 

4
CPR
Posts
7065
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
9/24/2023 5:56pm Edited Date/Time 9/24/2023 6:00pm
TeamGreen wrote:
Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the...

Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the globe- carries the prestige of our Supercross series…especially among the pro racers themselves. Last nights SMX Finals represents the culmination the US Supercross and Motocross season’s best performers. Again, the highest paid professional racers in the sport of Motocross where there…even the ones that couldn’t race due to being injured (Eli & Malcolm, for example).

Combined with this…last night I watched a solid collection of the worlds best motocross racers from…

Australia 

Japan

Germany

France 

Scotland

Sweden 

And somewhere around 25+ states

Also, there’s this little gem…

The number of OEM Factory Teams, OEM supported teams, private teams and also…ACTUAL PRIVATEERS…is incomparable to ANY other professional motocross racing series…ANYWHERE. 

The Industry Representation at U.S. SX/MX/SMX is INEXPLICABLE compared to any other MX series…anywhere. 

For me, that’s one indication of a legitimate a World Class World Championship especially when it comes to the Supercross side of things…which SMX draws on quite heavily. 

I’ll also take note of Triumph debuting their New Motocross Models at…The SMX World Championship Final. 

For the record, that makes 8 manufacturers present last night…dare I say,”On track”…? Which is technically correct; but, is a little too literal. Laughing

Now, if ya wanna argue “Outdoor Motocross”. Well, I’m gonna have to say that MXGP carries the Global Prestige there. 

No one would argue that AMA SX is not the premier SX series in the world, with the highest level of SX riders. BUT that still doesn’t make it a world championship.

Now if there was a real world SX championship that traveled internationally, with a broader spectrum of riders, would AMA SX riders dominate? Absolutely. But that still doesn’t make the current national series a world championship.

And as @Crush said above, the level of pay has nothing to do with it. I don’t get the seeming American obsession with money? Last I looked, no world title is based on an earnings criteria.

Oh and the OEM factory teams you refer to, are US factory teams, representing the US arm of the manufacturer, they’re not the actual OEM factory. They would be from Japan and Austria.

I will agree on MXGP as being a legitimate global series, however it needs to pick up its game to get back to the level of prestige it once had.

I don’t really care who calls what a world title, but if it’s not actually real, let’s not pretend it’s anything other than a promotion tactic. 

4
1
9/24/2023 6:14pm
183Matt wrote:
Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the...

Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the Continental United States.

 

Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these riders come to the USA to race. Cool

1
2
CPR
Posts
7065
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
9/24/2023 6:19pm
183Matt wrote:
Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the...

Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the Continental United States.

 

lostboy819 wrote:
Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these...

Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these riders come to the USA to race. Cool

Yep, supercross.

mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
9/24/2023 7:43pm
TeamGreen wrote:
Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the...

Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the globe- carries the prestige of our Supercross series…especially among the pro racers themselves. Last nights SMX Finals represents the culmination the US Supercross and Motocross season’s best performers. Again, the highest paid professional racers in the sport of Motocross where there…even the ones that couldn’t race due to being injured (Eli & Malcolm, for example).

Combined with this…last night I watched a solid collection of the worlds best motocross racers from…

Australia 

Japan

Germany

France 

Scotland

Sweden 

And somewhere around 25+ states

Also, there’s this little gem…

The number of OEM Factory Teams, OEM supported teams, private teams and also…ACTUAL PRIVATEERS…is incomparable to ANY other professional motocross racing series…ANYWHERE. 

The Industry Representation at U.S. SX/MX/SMX is INEXPLICABLE compared to any other MX series…anywhere. 

For me, that’s one indication of a legitimate a World Class World Championship especially when it comes to the Supercross side of things…which SMX draws on quite heavily. 

I’ll also take note of Triumph debuting their New Motocross Models at…The SMX World Championship Final. 

For the record, that makes 8 manufacturers present last night…dare I say,”On track”…? Which is technically correct; but, is a little too literal. Laughing

Now, if ya wanna argue “Outdoor Motocross”. Well, I’m gonna have to say that MXGP carries the Global Prestige there. 

CPR wrote:
No one would argue that AMA SX is not the premier SX series in the world, with the highest level of SX riders. BUT that still...

No one would argue that AMA SX is not the premier SX series in the world, with the highest level of SX riders. BUT that still doesn’t make it a world championship.

Now if there was a real world SX championship that traveled internationally, with a broader spectrum of riders, would AMA SX riders dominate? Absolutely. But that still doesn’t make the current national series a world championship.

And as @Crush said above, the level of pay has nothing to do with it. I don’t get the seeming American obsession with money? Last I looked, no world title is based on an earnings criteria.

Oh and the OEM factory teams you refer to, are US factory teams, representing the US arm of the manufacturer, they’re not the actual OEM factory. They would be from Japan and Austria.

I will agree on MXGP as being a legitimate global series, however it needs to pick up its game to get back to the level of prestige it once had.

I don’t really care who calls what a world title, but if it’s not actually real, let’s not pretend it’s anything other than a promotion tactic. 

Dont be naive,alot of is about $$ or they would  be okay making 100k a year at the factory level. 

2
9/24/2023 8:03pm
Because you can be from anywhere in the world and race for the championship.    How is this even a topic. It’s the racers racing each...

Because you can be from anywhere in the world and race for the championship. 
 

How is this even a topic. It’s the racers racing each other not the locations racing each other. 

 

Riders from around the world can't rock up to the SMX and race, they have to qualify in the American Motorcycling Association's Supercross or Motocross series first, that doesn't make it a "World Championship", that makes it an American domestic championship, which has some foreign riders.

5
1
9/24/2023 8:10pm
183Matt wrote:
Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the...

Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the Continental United States.

 

lostboy819 wrote:
Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these...

Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these riders come to the USA to race. Cool

image-20230925131041-1

mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
9/24/2023 8:19pm
183Matt wrote:
Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the...

Regardless of who wins (by the way congrats to lil Deegan BTW), how is this Super Motocross thing a world championship?  The series never leaves the Continental United States.

 

lostboy819 wrote:
Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these...

Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these riders come to the USA to race. Cool

image-20230925131041-1

Cpr said it isnt about money.

2
9/24/2023 8:21pm

World Series Baseball

DonM wrote:

You do realize that baseball is played in more that one country and many of the players come from those countries….

I have some unsettling news for you about Mx too 

1
1
9/24/2023 8:22pm Edited Date/Time 9/24/2023 8:23pm
lostboy819 wrote:
Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these...

Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these riders come to the USA to race. Cool

image-20230925131041-1

mxb2 wrote:

Cpr said it isnt about money.

World Championship in small font, $$$ in large font...

image-20230925132226-1

mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
9/24/2023 8:32pm

image-20230925131041-1

mxb2 wrote:

Cpr said it isnt about money.

World Championship in small font, $$$ in large font...

World Championship in small font, $$$ in large font...

image-20230925132226-1

Yep, like i said it has alot to do with $$ 

1
CPR
Posts
7065
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
9/24/2023 10:02pm
lostboy819 wrote:
Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these...

Half the top riders are from other country's so that's a pretty good reason to call it a World Championship. There is a reason all these riders come to the USA to race. Cool

image-20230925131041-1

mxb2 wrote:

Cpr said it isnt about money.

What I said was the level of pay doesn’t determine whether it’s a world title.
Happy to hear your explanation if that’s incorrect.

3
1
9/24/2023 10:08pm Edited Date/Time 9/24/2023 10:09pm

Reading posts, you can tell who's american and who's not. World Championship run in 3 cities of the same country. That would almost be funny to call it a national serie in any over part of the world. South Africa might aswell crown a world champion next year. 

2
1
Cabin09
Posts
30
Joined
1/29/2023
Location
Rotorua, NZ
9/24/2023 10:14pm
TeamGreen wrote:
Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the...

Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the globe- carries the prestige of our Supercross series…especially among the pro racers themselves. Last nights SMX Finals represents the culmination the US Supercross and Motocross season’s best performers. Again, the highest paid professional racers in the sport of Motocross where there…even the ones that couldn’t race due to being injured (Eli & Malcolm, for example).

Combined with this…last night I watched a solid collection of the worlds best motocross racers from…

Australia 

Japan

Germany

France 

Scotland

Sweden 

And somewhere around 25+ states

Also, there’s this little gem…

The number of OEM Factory Teams, OEM supported teams, private teams and also…ACTUAL PRIVATEERS…is incomparable to ANY other professional motocross racing series…ANYWHERE. 

The Industry Representation at U.S. SX/MX/SMX is INEXPLICABLE compared to any other MX series…anywhere. 

For me, that’s one indication of a legitimate a World Class World Championship especially when it comes to the Supercross side of things…which SMX draws on quite heavily. 

I’ll also take note of Triumph debuting their New Motocross Models at…The SMX World Championship Final. 

For the record, that makes 8 manufacturers present last night…dare I say,”On track”…? Which is technically correct; but, is a little too literal. Laughing

Now, if ya wanna argue “Outdoor Motocross”. Well, I’m gonna have to say that MXGP carries the Global Prestige there. 

CPR wrote:
No one would argue that AMA SX is not the premier SX series in the world, with the highest level of SX riders. BUT that still...

No one would argue that AMA SX is not the premier SX series in the world, with the highest level of SX riders. BUT that still doesn’t make it a world championship.

Now if there was a real world SX championship that traveled internationally, with a broader spectrum of riders, would AMA SX riders dominate? Absolutely. But that still doesn’t make the current national series a world championship.

And as @Crush said above, the level of pay has nothing to do with it. I don’t get the seeming American obsession with money? Last I looked, no world title is based on an earnings criteria.

Oh and the OEM factory teams you refer to, are US factory teams, representing the US arm of the manufacturer, they’re not the actual OEM factory. They would be from Japan and Austria.

I will agree on MXGP as being a legitimate global series, however it needs to pick up its game to get back to the level of prestige it once had.

I don’t really care who calls what a world title, but if it’s not actually real, let’s not pretend it’s anything other than a promotion tactic. 

"And as @Crush said above, the level of pay has nothing to do with it. I don’t get the seeming American obsession with money?"

I'm with you on this. And it carries across many sports. My theory on this, is that it has everything to do with the general culture of sport as they grow up.

For Aussies and Kiwi kids (and many others) we're surrounded by rugby (union and/or league), cricket, soccer, basketball etc... in all of those sports theres a progression of representing club/school > regional rep teams > provincial/state teams > national honours. So its natural to see/understand the progression to what you and I see as meaningful international competition. That isn't defined by $.

But for many Nth American sports (Baseball, Football, Basketball etc..). There's school > college > pro. The pathway isn't the same at all to what we experience. And the "ultimate success" is the high $ pro league. And the more $ earned equates to more success. I realise I'm simplifying it.... but I can see where lots of the viewpoints come from, and why they're often contrary to many non-americans on this forum

2
Tumic
Posts
2889
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall, SE
9/24/2023 10:37pm

”2023 SMX 450 champion” not even the guys who won could be bothered to call it a world championship.

 

IMG 0852 0

2
1
Alan Dove
Posts
371
Joined
12/29/2020
Location
GB
9/25/2023 12:09am
TeamGreen wrote:
Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the...

Off the top of my head…SMX involves the Absolute Highest Paid Professional racers and teams in the sport of Motocross. No other Motocross racing series -around the globe- carries the prestige of our Supercross series…especially among the pro racers themselves. Last nights SMX Finals represents the culmination the US Supercross and Motocross season’s best performers. Again, the highest paid professional racers in the sport of Motocross where there…even the ones that couldn’t race due to being injured (Eli & Malcolm, for example).

Combined with this…last night I watched a solid collection of the worlds best motocross racers from…

Australia 

Japan

Germany

France 

Scotland

Sweden 

And somewhere around 25+ states

Also, there’s this little gem…

The number of OEM Factory Teams, OEM supported teams, private teams and also…ACTUAL PRIVATEERS…is incomparable to ANY other professional motocross racing series…ANYWHERE. 

The Industry Representation at U.S. SX/MX/SMX is INEXPLICABLE compared to any other MX series…anywhere. 

For me, that’s one indication of a legitimate a World Class World Championship especially when it comes to the Supercross side of things…which SMX draws on quite heavily. 

I’ll also take note of Triumph debuting their New Motocross Models at…The SMX World Championship Final. 

For the record, that makes 8 manufacturers present last night…dare I say,”On track”…? Which is technically correct; but, is a little too literal. Laughing

Now, if ya wanna argue “Outdoor Motocross”. Well, I’m gonna have to say that MXGP carries the Global Prestige there. 

That's an indication of a very strong National championship regulated by a National regulatory authority.

2
1
Sully
Posts
9478
Joined
8/24/2006
Location
JP
9/25/2023 12:14am

Why did this thread not end on page 1 when aeffertz said, "Because you can name a series whatever you want to"?

Supercross season needs to hurry up and get here...

5
9/25/2023 1:19am Edited Date/Time 9/25/2023 1:25am

There is a "world championship" race every year where countries send their best riders to compete against other countries. Funnily enough, the country overflowing with "world championships" as long as it's on home soil and packed with home riders, aren't so keen on that one.. ;-)

14
1
Post a reply to: How is it a world championship?

This forum thread has been locked.

The Latest