Paul Malin commenting style

Spergen
Posts
760
Joined
5/16/2011
Location
GB
8/4/2023 5:52am
Rotaholic wrote:
So refreshing that he can just say a riders name without having to push the bike team sponsors down our throat..... and he makes the pass...

So refreshing that he can just say a riders name without having to push the bike team sponsors down our throat..... and he makes the pass on his blue rockstar monster penrite mobil1 alpinestar geico backed kawazuki, it does my head in.

 

Snap, feel exactly the same way, annoys the crap out of me, but......  I would assume they have to give the full sponsor title every time, not their fault just the system.

1
8/4/2023 6:07am

Malin, is the best in the game. Knows the sport, calls passes before they happen, tells you that they are rehearsing a pass at a particular place for the next lap, and lo and behold they make the pass. 

Wedge is good, but I think misses stuff that’s happening, maybe because he is carrying the others. RC and Stewart aren’t very good at all in my opinion. 

3
1
Richy
Posts
3086
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK GB
8/4/2023 6:13am

He's not my cup of tea to listen to commentating and I can't put my finger on why, but I really have to have a deep respect for the bloke and I can still appreciate the clear effort he has put in and continues to put in.

His level of knowledge of all things MXGP, right down to the macro level, and the things he picks up on as a former top-notch rider himself is as good as anyone else out there and I'm sure in many cases better.

I don't know if it's the "Ooooooooh!!" when something happens or the tone of some things, it's good for the dude to be excited about what he's watching so I can't knock him for it, to be honest it sounds a lot like a 'me' problem now I say it all out loud, the guy is certainly great at his job either way.

1
1
Sc2
Posts
372
Joined
6/4/2018
Location
GB
8/4/2023 7:17am

I love his style/ enthusiasm  , especially when a rider nearly decks it and gives it his trademark sound 

It's almost sounds like a fan is comontating at times 

The Shop

8/4/2023 9:43am

There will be the Jett Lawrence of announcing sitting eight here on this forum- but Malin has MxGp locked down (God bless) and AMA have Weedge (who doesn't even really ride). 

- if they want a super star they need to open up a trial system for prospective talent.

 

Grant Langston was really REALLY good

1
Xavier
Posts
618
Joined
7/7/2008
Location
Hossegor FR
8/4/2023 11:25am

Paul is doing a fantastic job. I like when he has a US commentator helping in the booth as well, it's always a + when JT$ shows up. I wonder how good would it be to have him and James Tongue ?! 

1
2
ohh_454
Posts
2696
Joined
6/24/2023
Location
Nuevo, CA US
Fantasy
8/4/2023 11:41am

He’s definitely at the top of the game. It’s gotta be hard as hell calling the race by himself and not having someone to bounce off of. Put bubba in the booth with him at des nations!!

8/4/2023 11:44am

Add me in as another that loves Malin's work.

 

The other thing that helps, though, is that the coverage (like Malin) is only focused on the race once the gate drops. They don't jam pre-recorded interviews and sideline reporters down our throats. I also don't think I've ever even seen Malin shown on screen, which is awesome - I'm here for the racing.

7
Sc2
Posts
372
Joined
6/4/2018
Location
GB
8/4/2023 1:01pm
motokiwi wrote:
There will be the Jett Lawrence of announcing sitting eight here on this forum- but Malin has MxGp locked down (God bless) and AMA have Weedge...

There will be the Jett Lawrence of announcing sitting eight here on this forum- but Malin has MxGp locked down (God bless) and AMA have Weedge (who doesn't even really ride). 

- if they want a super star they need to open up a trial system for prospective talent.

 

Grant Langston was really REALLY good

Langston and Malin in the booth would of been something I would of  like to seen 

2
plowboy
Posts
14032
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS US
8/4/2023 2:44pm

I grew up listening to the Cards and Dodgers on the radio with my grandpa.  Magic.  Malin has that old time ability to paint a picture for the listener.  Play by play but enough color for the listener to understand as if they were there.  Dude is legend.

6
yak651
Posts
8554
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI US
Fantasy
8/4/2023 3:04pm

Yeah but he really needs to throw some more “inside/outside” in there to get his point across

2
dingaling
Posts
243
Joined
5/15/2021
Location
AU
8/4/2023 3:27pm
luke11 wrote:
I think it’s an unpopular opinion but I really don’t like James commentating. He gives some good insights but it seems to be tucked between him...

I think it’s an unpopular opinion but I really don’t like James commentating. He gives some good insights but it seems to be tucked between him saying the same ‘funny’ line again and again. It’s so annoying. 

Although I don't find JS annoying I also don't think he's great? Alot of his insights are good but often he's quite bad at explaining so you have to read into what he says to understand? For example when Masterpool was doing well at Thunder Valley all he had to say was on top of riding great one of the reasons why he was doing so well was maybe his suspension setup was good better that day? Not that he had an "advantage" over factory guys because he's a privateer? Like what?

He often rambles and says the same thing 3 times while explaining something. I get no one is perfect. I prefer him to RC. 100% he'll get better though. 

GL was the best.

1
mx332
Posts
38
Joined
3/17/2013
Location
New Market, MD US
8/4/2023 3:32pm

My wife and I use "He got it all wrong" a lot around the house.

2
O&GDriller
Posts
550
Joined
7/16/2019
Location
Chattanooga, TN US
8/5/2023 5:32am

Malin is perfection personified in announcing. Just as good as the F1 announcers. Wedge is a boy amongst men in comparison. 

3
1
VHM
Posts
490
Joined
9/11/2020
Location
NO
Fantasy
8/5/2023 5:37am Edited Date/Time 8/21/2023 12:30pm
Add me in as another that loves Malin's work.   The other thing that helps, though, is that the coverage (like Malin) is only focused on...

Add me in as another that loves Malin's work.

 

The other thing that helps, though, is that the coverage (like Malin) is only focused on the race once the gate drops. They don't jam pre-recorded interviews and sideline reporters down our throats. I also don't think I've ever even seen Malin shown on screen, which is awesome - I'm here for the racing.

The only time you can see him is probably early saturdays during their live Studio Show, where him and Lisa interviewing a few riders before the EMX and qualification races.

2
Fox88
Posts
968
Joined
2/11/2012
Location
Galveston Island, TX US
Fantasy
8/5/2023 5:42am

Malin used a phrase to describe a sketchy sequence, something like "well that would have tightened that old balloon knot right up!"  Haha

Audie Murphy
Posts
14
Joined
7/29/2023
Location
Bill's pub, MP US
8/5/2023 5:51am
Its a huge difference from watching the MXGPs to watching AMA, the one thing i notice is that Paul Malin doesnt try to sell you anything. ...

Its a huge difference from watching the MXGPs to watching AMA, the one thing i notice is that Paul Malin doesnt try to sell you anything.  He lets you decide which bikes doing well.  He hasnt even one time mentioned that Febrvre is on a 24 KX prototype.  If it was in AMerica, they would be saying "oh man everybody better be worried about that new Kawasaki next year".  I hate media and i want to form my own opinions.  just present the facts and let the people decide.  Carmichael wont shut up about Star yamaha, and he made a lot of money from them hmmmmm.  how is he going to remain partial about the new Triumph?  i cant see him criticizing it when he supposedly did the development.

Two things about Ricky's announcing. He is so far up Star racing's ass and he does not like KTM's. I think Malin and Emig are the two best in the business. 

1
8/21/2023 8:10am

Did anyone catch Paul referring to Seewer as "rubber man" after he got up from his crash in the MXGP highlights? Grinning Makes me think he had JH84's interview with Lewis in mind since they spoke a bit about Jeremy's injury resistance. 

ARM670
Posts
2082
Joined
12/11/2020
Location
Napoleon, OH US
8/21/2023 8:18am
Its a huge difference from watching the MXGPs to watching AMA, the one thing i notice is that Paul Malin doesnt try to sell you anything. ...

Its a huge difference from watching the MXGPs to watching AMA, the one thing i notice is that Paul Malin doesnt try to sell you anything.  He lets you decide which bikes doing well.  He hasnt even one time mentioned that Febrvre is on a 24 KX prototype.  If it was in AMerica, they would be saying "oh man everybody better be worried about that new Kawasaki next year".  I hate media and i want to form my own opinions.  just present the facts and let the people decide.  Carmichael wont shut up about Star yamaha, and he made a lot of money from them hmmmmm.  how is he going to remain partial about the new Triumph?  i cant see him criticizing it when he supposedly did the development.

Two things about Ricky's announcing. He is so far up Star racing's ass and he does not like KTM's. I think Malin and Emig are the...

Two things about Ricky's announcing. He is so far up Star racing's ass and he does not like KTM's. I think Malin and Emig are the two best in the business. 

Ricky is very biased, just like his comment to weege, "come ride 2 strokes with me I have every color but red". I felt that was aliitle petty. Did Honda let him go? yes, but now he is paid to call a race not sell bikes.

MXMattii
Posts
4955
Joined
3/6/2010
Location
BE
8/21/2023 11:05am Edited Date/Time 8/21/2023 11:06am
Did anyone catch Paul referring to Seewer as "rubber man" after he got up from his crash in the MXGP highlights?  Makes me think he had JH84's...

Did anyone catch Paul referring to Seewer as "rubber man" after he got up from his crash in the MXGP highlights? Grinning Makes me think he had JH84's interview with Lewis in mind since they spoke a bit about Jeremy's injury resistance. 

He also said that Seewer had the brain of a gold fish, being passed twice in the same corner, riding the slower outside. Did Seewer make a move on Paul' girl? Laughing Dry

2
Robgvx
Posts
3988
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
GB
8/21/2023 11:14am
Did anyone catch Paul referring to Seewer as "rubber man" after he got up from his crash in the MXGP highlights?  Makes me think he had JH84's...

Did anyone catch Paul referring to Seewer as "rubber man" after he got up from his crash in the MXGP highlights? Grinning Makes me think he had JH84's interview with Lewis in mind since they spoke a bit about Jeremy's injury resistance. 

MXMattii wrote:
He also said that Seewer had the brain of a gold fish, being passed twice in the same corner, riding the slower outside. Did Seewer make...

He also said that Seewer had the brain of a gold fish, being passed twice in the same corner, riding the slower outside. Did Seewer make a move on Paul' girl? Laughing Dry

‘Memory of a goldfish’, meaning a very short memory. He failed to remember getting passed using that line just one lap ago.

There’s no offence in that saying. 

1
MXMattii
Posts
4955
Joined
3/6/2010
Location
BE
8/21/2023 11:15am
Robgvx wrote:
‘Memory of a goldfish’, meaning a very short memory. He failed to remember getting passed using that line just one lap ago. There’s no offence in...

‘Memory of a goldfish’, meaning a very short memory. He failed to remember getting passed using that line just one lap ago.

There’s no offence in that saying. 

I know, was just joking around.

2
8/21/2023 11:50am

" ooooohhhhh that must of hurt! Right on the old crown jewels!"

 Gotta luv him!

My favourite used to be the Canadian national  coverage years ago ( dont know what its like now) but always on the action wherever it was on the track and the commentators were very very enthusiastic to say the least.

 

2
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65193
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
8/21/2023 12:00pm
" ooooohhhhh that must of hurt! Right on the old crown jewels!"  Gotta luv him! My favourite used to be the Canadian national  coverage years ago...

" ooooohhhhh that must of hurt! Right on the old crown jewels!"

 Gotta luv him!

My favourite used to be the Canadian national  coverage years ago ( dont know what its like now) but always on the action wherever it was on the track and the commentators were very very enthusiastic to say the least.

 

Brian Koster and Marc Travers. 

They no longer announce the series. 

1
Elliot
Posts
2222
Joined
5/8/2021
Location
GB
8/21/2023 12:31pm
" ooooohhhhh that must of hurt! Right on the old crown jewels!"  Gotta luv him! My favourite used to be the Canadian national  coverage years ago...

" ooooohhhhh that must of hurt! Right on the old crown jewels!"

 Gotta luv him!

My favourite used to be the Canadian national  coverage years ago ( dont know what its like now) but always on the action wherever it was on the track and the commentators were very very enthusiastic to say the least.

 

Or ''he needs to take a trip to the berry farm''.

1
Nairb#70
Posts
3561
Joined
2/25/2020
Location
Ivoryton, CT US
8/21/2023 12:51pm

Paul Malin ranks up there with Jackie Stewart. Just an absolute natural.

8/21/2023 12:58pm
plowboy wrote:
I grew up listening to the Cards and Dodgers on the radio with my grandpa.  Magic.  Malin has that old time ability to paint a picture...

I grew up listening to the Cards and Dodgers on the radio with my grandpa.  Magic.  Malin has that old time ability to paint a picture for the listener.  Play by play but enough color for the listener to understand as if they were there.  Dude is legend.

Vin Scully was fantastic. 

Post a reply to: Paul Malin commenting style

The Latest