Greensboro Jury Awards $15M in Motocross Accident Injury

lostboy819
Posts
12809
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
12/21/2019 10:10pm Edited Date/Time 12/21/2019 10:17pm
brocster wrote:
People suing tracks are not always what it seems. You can have the best medical insurance in the world, but if they feel someone else may...
People suing tracks are not always what it seems. You can have the best medical insurance in the world, but if they feel someone else may be responsible your injuries may not be covered. Hence, the rider suing the track to attempt to get out from under a $700k medical bill that the insurance didn’t cover. Having medical insurance is not always the catch all and they are getting smarter about people who ride dirt bikes knowing there is a pretty good chance someone else, more times than not could be responsible to stick the medical bill on.

I would venture to say that this was the case here and in the case of Sarah Whitmore.
Agree, but Sarah Whitmore should have know better to ride a junk bike. Does she not have some personal responsibility for her own safety. I bet most of us would never got on a bike like that and much less jump it. Where does personal responsibility come in to play ? Motocrosser's we aint the smartest group of people I guess.
2
resetjet
Posts
2560
Joined
3/16/2012
Location
Tampa, FL, USA
12/22/2019 6:48am
In the end they could not produce a signed waiver. The way we scribble our names and could sign mickey mouse at these tracks needs to be addressed.
1
Johnny Lock
Posts
916
Joined
6/21/2018
Location
USA
12/22/2019 7:51am
zippytech wrote:
That just sucks. I am a firm believer that you choose to ride and nobody makes you ride so when shit happens it's only the fault...
That just sucks. I am a firm believer that you choose to ride and nobody makes you ride so when shit happens it's only the fault of the rider not the property.
Falcon wrote:
True, but tracks have a responsibility to limit the riders' exposure to hazards and also to limit their own exposure to liability. I'd like to see...
True, but tracks have a responsibility to limit the riders' exposure to hazards and also to limit their own exposure to liability. I'd like to see pictures so I know what the track was doing. There are times when I've been surprised that a track operator would allow certain hazards to exist on his property.
Oh really? Why not just put a bunch of pillows around the track or better yet just ride the bike for the rider and they can watch - I could find fault with any track.

And people will always crash and break their bodies riding motocross. You paid to practice or race, you signed a waiver. If you or your kid gets hurt, so sorry but fuck off and deal with it. You don’t like how a track looks or is run (see Glen Helen threads) or can’t identify hazards then that is your problem. For fucks sake you’re riding a two wheeled rocket over obstacles. Getting hurt is a 100% probability.
1
3
oldblood
Posts
1860
Joined
4/21/2016
Location
Placerville, CA, USA
12/22/2019 10:21am Edited Date/Time 12/22/2019 10:33am
The irony is, when I was a kid there weren't any nearby official riding areas. So we would go to open areas and make all kinds of sketchy tracks using whatever to build jumps(car hoods, old waterheaters, old metal culverts ,etc).
While this turned out bad they provided a safe area for many who would otherwise resort to our methods.
2
1

The Shop

lostboy819
Posts
12809
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
12/22/2019 10:24am
oldblood wrote:
The irony is, when I was a kid there weren't any nearby official riding areas. So we would go to open areas and make all kinds...
The irony is, when I was a kid there weren't any nearby official riding areas. So we would go to open areas and make all kinds of sketchy tracks using whatever to build jumps(car hoods, old waterheaters, old metal culverts ,etc).
While this turned out bad they provided a safe area for many who would otherwise resort to our methods.
Agree 100%
Tokyo_Tiddler
Posts
2196
Joined
7/25/2009
Location
Somewhere in, NJ, USA
12/22/2019 3:28pm
If the rider lost control of the motorcycle and went off the track, he should share some responsibility, not withstanding that any obviously dangerous objects along side the track should be addressed, but short of cutting down every tree 200 feet near the track and removing every rock also, there should be some sort of reasonable balance as there will be sprinkle fixtures and fences with posts at parts of the track. The awards seems excessive and I don't mean to downplay the extent of the injury.
OldYZRider1
Posts
847
Joined
7/10/2009
Location
Bushnell, IL, USA
12/22/2019 5:07pm Edited Date/Time 12/22/2019 5:13pm
Was this kid a budding NFL running back whos future earning potential was torpedoed to justify such a large award? And a 1” exposed edge of a metal culvert doesn’t sound like a significant thing to me; its difficult to have an edge of a culvert not exposed. Perhaps they could have used a plastic culvert but its edge could probably inflict the same damage. Its reasonable that someone placed a hay bale to protect the edge in hindsight after the accident but doesn't a haybale actually block the proper function of the culvert? This could cause some other dangerous situation such as a mudhole alongside the track that could stop a bike and throw the rider head first over the bars.

Point is people can and do achieve death and horrendous injuries in all sorts of weird unpredictable manners. Its not like the rider wasn’t engaged in a known perilous activity at the time. But in the increasingly litigious society we live in anymore, someone other than the individual has to be at fault. I swear juries like this one seem to feel business owners should have the omniscience of God.
5
2
BRX-WRX
Posts
237
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Blue Springs, MO, USA
12/22/2019 8:52pm
Would riding there without waiver be the same as trespassing ? Some ignore the entrance signs entering the property.
CM_84
Posts
764
Joined
8/3/2018
Location
AU
12/22/2019 9:23pm
A waiver doesn’t mean shit if the track owners a negligent by leaving things that a rider can be injured off the side of the track.

Everyone who is saying stuff like “we all know the risks” do you guys walk around the side of the track and go home if you see something dangerous? I have NEVER seen that.

Tracks owe a duty of care to make sure they don’t make the already incredibly dangerous sport more dangerous by not protecting riders as best they can when they come off the track.

Just a general comment on stuff I have seen over the years, I’m not familiar with the details on this incident.
1
1
Johnny Ringo
Posts
8217
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ, USA
12/22/2019 10:41pm Edited Date/Time 12/22/2019 10:45pm
Was this kid a budding NFL running back whos future earning potential was torpedoed to justify such a large award? And a 1” exposed edge of...
Was this kid a budding NFL running back whos future earning potential was torpedoed to justify such a large award? And a 1” exposed edge of a metal culvert doesn’t sound like a significant thing to me; its difficult to have an edge of a culvert not exposed. Perhaps they could have used a plastic culvert but its edge could probably inflict the same damage. Its reasonable that someone placed a hay bale to protect the edge in hindsight after the accident but doesn't a haybale actually block the proper function of the culvert? This could cause some other dangerous situation such as a mudhole alongside the track that could stop a bike and throw the rider head first over the bars.

Point is people can and do achieve death and horrendous injuries in all sorts of weird unpredictable manners. Its not like the rider wasn’t engaged in a known perilous activity at the time. But in the increasingly litigious society we live in anymore, someone other than the individual has to be at fault. I swear juries like this one seem to feel business owners should have the omniscience of God.
So you have to be a future star athlete to have any value in fully functioning legs? Hot take

Did some of you know it’s possible to feel bad for both the kid, parents, and track owner?
3
2
Robgvx
Posts
4138
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
GB
12/23/2019 3:45am
CM_84 wrote:
A waiver doesn’t mean shit if the track owners a negligent by leaving things that a rider can be injured off the side of the track...
A waiver doesn’t mean shit if the track owners a negligent by leaving things that a rider can be injured off the side of the track.

Everyone who is saying stuff like “we all know the risks” do you guys walk around the side of the track and go home if you see something dangerous? I have NEVER seen that.

Tracks owe a duty of care to make sure they don’t make the already incredibly dangerous sport more dangerous by not protecting riders as best they can when they come off the track.

Just a general comment on stuff I have seen over the years, I’m not familiar with the details on this incident.

1
plowboy
Posts
14858
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
12/23/2019 5:17am
When my youngest was 4 or 5, she was playing with the kid next door. They had one of those tiny inflatable pools set up on the concrete patio. She face planted and was hurt pretty bad. At the ER, they asked WHERE the accident occurred. When I asked why it mattered, they stated that if it happened on our property then my insurance covered everything. If it was on the neighbors property then my insurance would AUTOMATICALLY sue the neighbor for the bill. Of course I told them it happened at our place.

My point is, not every lawsuit you read about is instigated by the injured person. I don't know the motives of the folks in this case so I'll reserve judgement.
4
kage173
Posts
3099
Joined
11/27/2015
Location
USA
12/23/2019 5:53am Edited Date/Time 12/23/2019 5:55am
Was this kid a budding NFL running back whos future earning potential was torpedoed to justify such a large award? And a 1” exposed edge of...
Was this kid a budding NFL running back whos future earning potential was torpedoed to justify such a large award? And a 1” exposed edge of a metal culvert doesn’t sound like a significant thing to me; its difficult to have an edge of a culvert not exposed. Perhaps they could have used a plastic culvert but its edge could probably inflict the same damage. Its reasonable that someone placed a hay bale to protect the edge in hindsight after the accident but doesn't a haybale actually block the proper function of the culvert? This could cause some other dangerous situation such as a mudhole alongside the track that could stop a bike and throw the rider head first over the bars.

Point is people can and do achieve death and horrendous injuries in all sorts of weird unpredictable manners. Its not like the rider wasn’t engaged in a known perilous activity at the time. But in the increasingly litigious society we live in anymore, someone other than the individual has to be at fault. I swear juries like this one seem to feel business owners should have the omniscience of God.
You must have missed the part of the story where they moved the hay bales to cover the culvert before the authorities arrived. Then they lied under oath saying that the culvert had been protected the entire time.

They're lucky they aren't going to jail. If they had told the truth and they had provided the signed waiver it would have been a different story.
RonJon
Posts
386
Joined
9/13/2016
Location
Torquay, AU
12/23/2019 6:02am
If you can't accept the liability that something terrible could happen if you or your child ride a dirtbike, you shouldn't ride a dirtbike. Not the kids fault, but not the facility's either. Money hungry parents.
1
5
Talisker
Posts
886
Joined
10/25/2018
Location
Houston, TX, USA
12/24/2019 5:43am Edited Date/Time 12/24/2019 5:44am
Man.....after reading all the post, I’m starting to realize everything I grew up riding and riding next too is a liability.

tingo
Posts
1202
Joined
8/16/2016
Location
Orlando, FL, USA
12/24/2019 7:01am
resetjet wrote:
In the end they could not produce a signed waiver. The way we scribble our names and could sign mickey mouse at these tracks needs to...
In the end they could not produce a signed waiver. The way we scribble our names and could sign mickey mouse at these tracks needs to be addressed.
I’ve always been surprised at this, too. Seems like a good idea to ask for a drivers license when people sign. Snap a quick photo of the DL sitting next to the signature. Not sure what privacy laws come into play when doing something like that, but it seems like a much better way to not only find a particular signature, but also to evidence that Joe Lawsuit really signed the waiver. Negligence is a different issue. As is trying to literally cover something up after the fact. As is lying.
1
KHI Guy
Posts
386
Joined
3/21/2017
Location
Cleveland, OH, USA
12/24/2019 9:37am
resetjet wrote:
In the end they could not produce a signed waiver. The way we scribble our names and could sign mickey mouse at these tracks needs to...
In the end they could not produce a signed waiver. The way we scribble our names and could sign mickey mouse at these tracks needs to be addressed.
tingo wrote:
I’ve always been surprised at this, too. Seems like a good idea to ask for a drivers license when people sign. Snap a quick photo of...
I’ve always been surprised at this, too. Seems like a good idea to ask for a drivers license when people sign. Snap a quick photo of the DL sitting next to the signature. Not sure what privacy laws come into play when doing something like that, but it seems like a much better way to not only find a particular signature, but also to evidence that Joe Lawsuit really signed the waiver. Negligence is a different issue. As is trying to literally cover something up after the fact. As is lying.
I think there are a lot of ways using technology to where this can be done expediently and accurately. Maybe use an iPad type device? First screen shows the waiver that you need to checkmark before it goes to page two where you type your name then sign. Or sign the waiver online before you go to the facility, then verify electronically at the gate before you get admitted? I seriously doubt most on here would allow their drivers license to be photographed.
coastlinecascot
Posts
1038
Joined
7/10/2016
Location
USA
12/24/2019 10:53am
plowboy wrote:
When my youngest was 4 or 5, she was playing with the kid next door. They had one of those tiny inflatable pools set up on...
When my youngest was 4 or 5, she was playing with the kid next door. They had one of those tiny inflatable pools set up on the concrete patio. She face planted and was hurt pretty bad. At the ER, they asked WHERE the accident occurred. When I asked why it mattered, they stated that if it happened on our property then my insurance covered everything. If it was on the neighbors property then my insurance would AUTOMATICALLY sue the neighbor for the bill. Of course I told them it happened at our place.

My point is, not every lawsuit you read about is instigated by the injured person. I don't know the motives of the folks in this case so I'll reserve judgement.
Why would the medical staff concern themselves with insurance law? Or want to know who the insurance company will sue. This would set them up to be subpoened to a lawsuit.
fox1nz
Posts
422
Joined
11/8/2015
Location
NZ
12/24/2019 12:10pm
I think cunt is the right word for this
2
misterwaterfallin
Posts
352
Joined
7/2/2019
Location
Seattle, WA, USA
12/24/2019 12:27pm
plowboy wrote:
When my youngest was 4 or 5, she was playing with the kid next door. They had one of those tiny inflatable pools set up on...
When my youngest was 4 or 5, she was playing with the kid next door. They had one of those tiny inflatable pools set up on the concrete patio. She face planted and was hurt pretty bad. At the ER, they asked WHERE the accident occurred. When I asked why it mattered, they stated that if it happened on our property then my insurance covered everything. If it was on the neighbors property then my insurance would AUTOMATICALLY sue the neighbor for the bill. Of course I told them it happened at our place.

My point is, not every lawsuit you read about is instigated by the injured person. I don't know the motives of the folks in this case so I'll reserve judgement.
Why would the medical staff concern themselves with insurance law? Or want to know who the insurance company will sue. This would set them up to...
Why would the medical staff concern themselves with insurance law? Or want to know who the insurance company will sue. This would set them up to be subpoened to a lawsuit.
Haven’t been in a hospital lately have you? Was it car accident, at work, etc are all questions they ask as sooner or later you go over financial responsibility forms.
coastlinecascot
Posts
1038
Joined
7/10/2016
Location
USA
12/24/2019 12:52pm
plowboy wrote:
When my youngest was 4 or 5, she was playing with the kid next door. They had one of those tiny inflatable pools set up on...
When my youngest was 4 or 5, she was playing with the kid next door. They had one of those tiny inflatable pools set up on the concrete patio. She face planted and was hurt pretty bad. At the ER, they asked WHERE the accident occurred. When I asked why it mattered, they stated that if it happened on our property then my insurance covered everything. If it was on the neighbors property then my insurance would AUTOMATICALLY sue the neighbor for the bill. Of course I told them it happened at our place.

My point is, not every lawsuit you read about is instigated by the injured person. I don't know the motives of the folks in this case so I'll reserve judgement.
Why would the medical staff concern themselves with insurance law? Or want to know who the insurance company will sue. This would set them up to...
Why would the medical staff concern themselves with insurance law? Or want to know who the insurance company will sue. This would set them up to be subpoened to a lawsuit.
Haven’t been in a hospital lately have you? Was it car accident, at work, etc are all questions they ask as sooner or later you go...
Haven’t been in a hospital lately have you? Was it car accident, at work, etc are all questions they ask as sooner or later you go over financial responsibility forms.
In the last 3 months, i had 3 surguries on my ankle and wrist with more than a week in the hospital. They asked what happened not where.
1
misterwaterfallin
Posts
352
Joined
7/2/2019
Location
Seattle, WA, USA
12/24/2019 1:22pm
In the last 3 months, i had 3 surguries on my ankle and wrist with more than a week in the hospital. They asked what happened...
In the last 3 months, i had 3 surguries on my ankle and wrist with more than a week in the hospital. They asked what happened not where.
I to had surgery last week and was asked all of the above. As usual with our health care system YMMV
coastlinecascot
Posts
1038
Joined
7/10/2016
Location
USA
12/24/2019 1:35pm
In the last 3 months, i had 3 surguries on my ankle and wrist with more than a week in the hospital. They asked what happened...
In the last 3 months, i had 3 surguries on my ankle and wrist with more than a week in the hospital. They asked what happened not where.
I to had surgery last week and was asked all of the above. As usual with our health care system YMMV
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to get reimbursed. Actually have an appt on Friday. I'll asked the orthopedic if they give a shit about the liability side.
misterwaterfallin
Posts
352
Joined
7/2/2019
Location
Seattle, WA, USA
12/24/2019 1:38pm
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to...
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to get reimbursed. Actually have an appt on Friday. I'll asked the orthopedic if they give a shit about the liability side.
That clearly not true. Hospitals have negotiated rates with insurance companies. As a part of this, they have to ask the necessary questions up front. They also have to provide different info depending on the situation IE if you’re hurt at work and they have to assess if you can go back immediately or not
coastlinecascot
Posts
1038
Joined
7/10/2016
Location
USA
12/24/2019 1:44pm
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to...
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to get reimbursed. Actually have an appt on Friday. I'll asked the orthopedic if they give a shit about the liability side.
That clearly not true. Hospitals have negotiated rates with insurance companies. As a part of this, they have to ask the necessary questions up front. They...
That clearly not true. Hospitals have negotiated rates with insurance companies. As a part of this, they have to ask the necessary questions up front. They also have to provide different info depending on the situation IE if you’re hurt at work and they have to assess if you can go back immediately or not
Do you know that for a fact? Or just assuming? My family member does claims approvalfor blue cross. She never heard of that.
CM_84
Posts
764
Joined
8/3/2018
Location
AU
12/24/2019 2:01pm
CM_84 wrote:
A waiver doesn’t mean shit if the track owners a negligent by leaving things that a rider can be injured off the side of the track...
A waiver doesn’t mean shit if the track owners a negligent by leaving things that a rider can be injured off the side of the track.

Everyone who is saying stuff like “we all know the risks” do you guys walk around the side of the track and go home if you see something dangerous? I have NEVER seen that.

Tracks owe a duty of care to make sure they don’t make the already incredibly dangerous sport more dangerous by not protecting riders as best they can when they come off the track.

Just a general comment on stuff I have seen over the years, I’m not familiar with the details on this incident.
Robgvx wrote:
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2019/12/23/393539/s1200_0F7878A1_FF53_4FF6_84F5_BD198B10425D.jpg[/img]

Namur is probably the most picturesque track in history. But how do you think anyone would fair trying to start a track like that these days?
How would it look if they had a GP there and a kid launched off the side and was seriously hurt?
Times have changed, and if you think making the sport more dangerous is cool, then fuck it, let’s mark the track with steel stakes.

Car racing used to have some great venues, but does anyone really think they should still race F1 cars with trees next to the track because it looks cool?

And is Namur’s old walls really justification for amateur tracks to have steel culverts next to the track? I have seen a kid hit a dozer that was parked too close to the track, that’s madness, and an injury that is so easily avoided.

“We” keep saying this sport should grow, but a lot of the organisers, track owners, promoters are a bunch of amateurs (not all of them though).

Sure, riders have to take responsibility for what happens, but track owners also have a responsibility to make the track as safe as reasonably possible.
1
zippytech
Posts
1532
Joined
9/8/2018
Location
Bethesda, OH, USA
12/24/2019 2:15pm
I crashed a Dr 500 back in the 90's and busted up my knee. When I got to the hospital they asked , when, what and where I was and doing.
APLMAN99
Posts
13099
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
12/24/2019 9:12pm
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to...
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to get reimbursed. Actually have an appt on Friday. I'll asked the orthopedic if they give a shit about the liability side.
That clearly not true. Hospitals have negotiated rates with insurance companies. As a part of this, they have to ask the necessary questions up front. They...
That clearly not true. Hospitals have negotiated rates with insurance companies. As a part of this, they have to ask the necessary questions up front. They also have to provide different info depending on the situation IE if you’re hurt at work and they have to assess if you can go back immediately or not
Hospitals don't determine liability.

They do ask questions (if they are a good facility) to determine if there are any factors that may be needed to be known for care. If you have insurance, they will always bill that insurance unless it is occupational or they have alternate billing instructions such as your auto insurance for a claim covered under your medical payments portion of that policy.

Ultimately the patient is the liable entity either way, but the medical provider will bill who they are instructed to. They don't determine whether someone else is liable.

MX558
Posts
2003
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/24/2019 9:19pm
CG118 wrote:
FTE. What would happen under New Zealand’s ACC?
scott_nz wrote:
Not sure what FTE would know about nz acc law but All his medical bills would be covered and if he was working in nz he...
Not sure what FTE would know about nz acc law but All his medical bills would be covered and if he was working in nz he would get 80% of any wage income he was getting till he could get back to work full time , once you have accepted acc Payment (which funds the ambulance anyway) you can not sue for Personal injury

However if it was a private bike park, worksafe (Our government osh enforcer) could investigate and prosecute you for negligence if they deemed the pipe was dangerous and you leaving it uncovered was at least reckless ,

OSHA could find wrong doing in anything on every facility
coastlinecascot
Posts
1038
Joined
7/10/2016
Location
USA
12/24/2019 10:33pm
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to...
The hospital staff could care 2 shits about the liable of my accident. They just care about the codes they input and my insurance information to get reimbursed. Actually have an appt on Friday. I'll asked the orthopedic if they give a shit about the liability side.
That clearly not true. Hospitals have negotiated rates with insurance companies. As a part of this, they have to ask the necessary questions up front. They...
That clearly not true. Hospitals have negotiated rates with insurance companies. As a part of this, they have to ask the necessary questions up front. They also have to provide different info depending on the situation IE if you’re hurt at work and they have to assess if you can go back immediately or not
APLMAN99 wrote:
Hospitals don't determine liability. They do ask questions (if they are a good facility) to determine if there are any factors that may be needed to...
Hospitals don't determine liability.

They do ask questions (if they are a good facility) to determine if there are any factors that may be needed to be known for care. If you have insurance, they will always bill that insurance unless it is occupational or they have alternate billing instructions such as your auto insurance for a claim covered under your medical payments portion of that policy.

Ultimately the patient is the liable entity either way, but the medical provider will bill who they are instructed to. They don't determine whether someone else is liable.

Yes forgot they do ask if its work related.
1

Post a reply to: Greensboro Jury Awards $15M in Motocross Accident Injury

The Latest