Seperated Shoulder

yzjs7
Posts
1137
Joined
7/4/2013
Location
Antioch, CA, USA
3/19/2014 10:44pm
So he you've dislocated or seperated? My ligaments are gone I tore them resulting in my raised collarbone.
yzjs7
Posts
1137
Joined
7/4/2013
Location
Antioch, CA, USA
3/19/2014 10:47pm
It's such a wishy washy area with doctors. Some say surgery some don't. All I know is I didn't have surgery and I have full range of motion.
hillbilly
Posts
9079
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Afton, TN, USA
3/19/2014 10:50pm
If the little bone is popped up you're out there.

I've seen so many have more trouble after surgery that you better think long and hard about how much pain you can take,

Rehab is what separates winners from losers, Push thru the pain and a good surgeon can fix it,leave it in that sling and whine,
We will call you nemo.
Old Mate
Posts
2259
Joined
3/9/2009
Location
Sussex Inlet, AU
3/20/2014 12:00am
My son had just rode Villopoto's bike to 2 x 2nd place 450 ama out door motos, we got a call asking him to ride the factory kawa and come back to usa, i said he cant come yet as he has given his word to ride the Dortmund sx and this happened with 2 corners to go! This is 2009, he snapped every ligament and tendon front and back in his shoulder. German doctors rang me here in aus and asked if they could medical journal the operation as they had never seen a shoulder only held on by skin. any way he had operations in germany,usa and aus, he is nearly back to his best, he finished second to his brother in aus sx this year in front of hill and pieck. It was funny because when they came back from the podium, he said to Matt, so what, you beat a guy with one arm.. he can now lift the arm up above his head for the first time since the crash but cant lift a tiny dumbell, he is so confident that it will recover enough to win this year and head back for ama sx next season. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HuJXlno4hI

The Shop

plowboy
Posts
14319
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
3/20/2014 12:47am
disbanded wrote:
I do all my own surgeries. My grandma went to the hospital once and they killed her.
That is some funny shit right there. My wife tells me I can't get hurt any more...I've reached my lifetime maximum benefit. I'm a broke down sumbitch. All the other old timers say that pain is a good thing...the only way to tell yer still alive.
plowboy
Posts
14319
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
3/20/2014 12:54am
Old Mate wrote:
My son had just rode Villopoto's bike to 2 x 2nd place 450 ama out door motos, we got a call asking him to ride the...
My son had just rode Villopoto's bike to 2 x 2nd place 450 ama out door motos, we got a call asking him to ride the factory kawa and come back to usa, i said he cant come yet as he has given his word to ride the Dortmund sx and this happened with 2 corners to go! This is 2009, he snapped every ligament and tendon front and back in his shoulder. German doctors rang me here in aus and asked if they could medical journal the operation as they had never seen a shoulder only held on by skin. any way he had operations in germany,usa and aus, he is nearly back to his best, he finished second to his brother in aus sx this year in front of hill and pieck. It was funny because when they came back from the podium, he said to Matt, so what, you beat a guy with one arm.. he can now lift the arm up above his head for the first time since the crash but cant lift a tiny dumbell, he is so confident that it will recover enough to win this year and head back for ama sx next season. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HuJXlno4hI
Damn Aussie's are all rawhide and sprung steel...tough buggers the lot. Hope it gets better and follows his dream.
downard254
Posts
4073
Joined
12/10/2012
Location
Bremen, OH, USA
3/20/2014 3:07am
yzjs7 wrote:
Motors coming soon actually. Yes it is my right shoulder. Seat bounced up and over the bars a year ago. My shoulder doesnt have any pain...
Motors coming soon actually. Yes it is my right shoulder. Seat bounced up and over the bars a year ago. My shoulder doesnt have any pain. Rmz did you keep your arm in a sling for a few weeks? I do stretch mine everyday til I hear it pop but ya no pain. When I stretch it I do hear crackling.
Don't worry too much about the cracking. Hell I have cracking sounds all over my body. Kind of thought it was normal. The wrist I broke in '85 sounds like a popcorn poper on full boil, and don't even get me started on my back.
DoctorJD
Posts
2977
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Somewhere in..., GA, USA
3/20/2014 5:40am
I separated both of mine last January, I'm just now able to have full range of motion. Trying to sleep was the worst, as it was almost impossible to get comfortable. My wife got tired of hearing me scream in pain in the middle of the night when I'd roll over and catch it just right. Torn labrum(s) was the diagnosis the orthopedist gave me, can't remember the grade of separation, but it wasn't worthy of surgery. I wasn't riding moto much back then, but I was still able to continue cycling without a lot of pain (mountain biking was iffy sometimes). Bottom line:
151
Posts
536
Joined
9/15/2009
Location
Olive Branch, MS, USA
3/20/2014 6:33am Edited Date/Time 3/20/2014 6:36am
Hi guys, I should say first that I'm no doctor. I did badly jack up my left shoulder about (holy shit) wait never mind my math was off. I almost said 18 years ago... It was 11, whoa.

Any how I had previously seperated my shoulder (pretty sure its called the AC). This time I seperated it along with some other nasty injuries. No surgery due to no insurance or cash at the time. Some doctors have told me that surgery is a last option, others have told me its a good idea for most of these injuries.

Back on topic, my AC seperation apparently was a "total" seperation. To this day if I put my shoulder in a position that takes pressure off the AC area, I can hold the bone between my fingers and move it all around.

I am trying to get to the point.

Okay the point is, After everything other than some nerve damage healed as good as it was going to, my shoulder muscles all continued to atrophy (shrink) to the point where I no longer had a left detoid that could be seen, just bone, worse than a 10 year old skinny girl.

For several years, I guess it was 10 years to be exact, I talked to therapist and doctors and lots of cool smart people but none of the recommended exercises would bring back my deltoid muscle in any way.

Finally last year I stumbled across a picture of a guy who had a MX shoulder injury that leg to a condition called "winged Scapula".

It makes your shoulder blade stick out and jacks with the mechanics of your shoulder. I guess what happened was my seperated shoulder messed up the way the shoulder moved, causing the winged scapula which further messed with the proper way all the parts of the shoulder should work together and led to where I lost all use of the deltoid muscles.

Finally I found some methods of correcting a winged scapula and that seems to be allowing my deltoids to get back to work. For the first time in ten years or so I can lift more than a pound over my head!!!

I guess the reason I am sharing this is in case any of you with seperated ACs run into the same issue I did. The shoulder is a somewhat complex joint and if one of the parts is not holding the rest in their normal balance of work, it can cause hard to diagnose long term messed up crap to happen.

Good luck guys!
Bry745
Posts
166
Joined
7/14/2010
Location
Greenville, WI, USA
3/20/2014 7:40am
Had a grade 3 separation about 8 or 9 years ago at with no surgery, doctors said it was unnecessary. Tip of my collarbone sticks up a little but no long term effects (yet) at this point at age 45. Still have full ROM and had no issues with strength or lifting weights, although it did take a few months to get motion and strength back. Everybody is different of course, and we're all at the mercy of our doctors' knowledge (or lack thereof sometimes).
sybro
Posts
165
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Montreal, CA
3/20/2014 7:51am
I've got mine separated last summer, was affraid I would suffer for the rest of my life with the tip of the collabone not really attached to the shoulder. Ended up ok after about 6 months, still floating around but my full range of movement back.

separation and dislocation explained


--- Dislocated shoulder. In this injury, a fall or blow causes the top of your arm bone to pop out of the shoulder socket.

Unlike a lot of joints in your body -- your elbow, for instance -- the shoulder is incredibly mobile. You can twist and move your upper arm in almost any direction. But there's a price for this ease of movement. The shoulder joint is inherently unstable, prone to slipping out of place.

In severe cases of dislocated shoulder, the tissue and nerves around the shoulder joint get damaged. If you keep dislocating your shoulder, you could wind up with chronic instability and weakness.



--- Separated shoulder. Despite the name, this injury doesn't directly affect the shoulder joint. Instead, a fall or blow tears one of the ligaments that connects the collarbone to shoulder blade.

Since it's no longer anchored, the collarbone may move out of position and push against the skin near the top of your shoulder. Although separated shoulders can cause deformity, people usually recover fully with time.
3/20/2014 7:54am
Going on 15 years since I suffered my first 3rd degree separation. Full motion and strength came back in about a year. Bad news is when you land on it again I personally believe it hurts worse the second and third times. Recovery is much quicker though. That or I just know how to deal with it. I am used to my shirts hanging funny off the low shoulder and the popping at night when I roll over doesn't wake me up . I guess if a I really concentrate I do feel a dull ache in it. At 46 I still go out and try to land on it, my skills have greatly diminished and I didn't have much to start with. Good news is I can tell when weather is approaching.......
hvaughn88
Posts
8361
Joined
6/19/2013
Location
Conway, AR, USA
3/20/2014 8:01am
The one common truth I have derived from all of this is that we sure do tend to tear up some effing shoulders, haha!
BobbyM
Posts
21439
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
3/20/2014 8:07am
yzjs7 wrote:
Who here has one? I do, "no surgery / stage 3" and it's been a little over a year since I did it. Other than the...
Who here has one? I do, "no surgery / stage 3" and it's been a little over a year since I did it. Other than the bone sticking up and some crackle pops in it I wouldnt even know I had it.
separation vs dislocation...big difference.
yzjs7
Posts
1137
Joined
7/4/2013
Location
Antioch, CA, USA
3/20/2014 8:14am
Dear motocross: you have kicked my ass but you will not defeat me...I hope lol.
seth505
Posts
10202
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
SD, CA, USA
3/20/2014 9:55am
I had grade 3 AC separation, was from dirtjumps though (bicycle).

My clavicle still sticks out far and my shoulder gets sore/fatigued easily but I have full range of motion and such.
hvaughn88
Posts
8361
Joined
6/19/2013
Location
Conway, AR, USA
3/20/2014 10:22am
seth505 wrote:
I had grade 3 AC separation, was from dirtjumps though (bicycle). My clavicle still sticks out far and my shoulder gets sore/fatigued easily but I have...
I had grade 3 AC separation, was from dirtjumps though (bicycle).

My clavicle still sticks out far and my shoulder gets sore/fatigued easily but I have full range of motion and such.
mine was from a bicycle accident, as well. I was riding my fixie and didn't have my pedal straps on yet, hit a bump hard enough to knock my foot off the pedal, which then sent my foot up behind the front fork, resulting in an unintentional footjam endo from about 30 mph. I went over the bars and landed about 15-20 feet down the road directly on my shoulder. The embarrassing part is I was riding down the street to my buddies house for a BBQ so I had about 2 pound of marinated hamburger meat in my backpack that I landed on, too. Needless to say, my buddies still give me shit to this day about it.
Old Mate
Posts
2259
Joined
3/9/2009
Location
Sussex Inlet, AU
3/20/2014 10:25am
Old Mate wrote:
My son had just rode Villopoto's bike to 2 x 2nd place 450 ama out door motos, we got a call asking him to ride the...
My son had just rode Villopoto's bike to 2 x 2nd place 450 ama out door motos, we got a call asking him to ride the factory kawa and come back to usa, i said he cant come yet as he has given his word to ride the Dortmund sx and this happened with 2 corners to go! This is 2009, he snapped every ligament and tendon front and back in his shoulder. German doctors rang me here in aus and asked if they could medical journal the operation as they had never seen a shoulder only held on by skin. any way he had operations in germany,usa and aus, he is nearly back to his best, he finished second to his brother in aus sx this year in front of hill and pieck. It was funny because when they came back from the podium, he said to Matt, so what, you beat a guy with one arm.. he can now lift the arm up above his head for the first time since the crash but cant lift a tiny dumbell, he is so confident that it will recover enough to win this year and head back for ama sx next season. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HuJXlno4hI
plowboy wrote:
Damn Aussie's are all rawhide and sprung steel...tough buggers the lot. Hope it gets better and follows his dream.
Cheers Plowboy, hopefully build on last season and have a great year, push-ups and downward movement is very strong, just lifting the arm is crap.
TL_36
Posts
14
Joined
10/27/2013
Location
Herrick, IL, USA
3/20/2014 10:51am
Third degree A/C separation about 6 months ago. No surgery, it would have taken me out of school for too long. I would say I was feeling fairly normal at two months although I haven't ridden much since then. It does seem to get fatigued after a long set on the drums.

Damn motocross!!
FLmxer
Posts
7303
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
SouthWest, FL, USA
Fantasy
3/20/2014 11:05am
Did mine and broke coricoid process and both corners of socket off. Doc wanted two plates and lots of screws. I said let me try therapy and in two months one handed pull ups. If there was hardware I'm there it would still be sucking years later. The sit in chair with pulley hooked too top of door pulling each arm up with other was key to success. Amazing therapy exercise.
Radical
Posts
2882
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
3/20/2014 2:50pm
I dislocated my shoulder in 1999 on a bmx track. My shoulder was completely out of socket with my arm about 3 inches lower than usual, and my shoulders were way wider than usual. It was completely out, and down.

At the ER, they had me lay face down and stretch my arm over head to get an x-ray. When I did, the shoulder popped back in.

They put me in a sling and said there's nothing you can do about it.
I then saw an Ortho surgeon who told me that for a pro athlete they usually would not do surgery. (I believe he treated a lot of the pros in baseball/football).

He said that if they did do surgery, they would take the tendon/ligament that connects the outside of the shoulder and reattach it to the scapula to pull it down and remove the bump. That sounded an aweful lot like robbing Peter to pay Paul. It didn't make sense. He also said that if you do this, then the two ends of the AC joint would touch and cause pain (bone on bone at this point since the cartilage in the AC joint is shot). If the ends rub and cause pain, they would do another surgery to simply trim a bit off the end of the scapula so the ends would no longer rub.

Then he answered a question of mine and basically said that if you hold the bump down while it heals, once the scar tissue forms, there would be no bump. It's not the ligament/tendon holding it in place. It's the scar tissue.

I was pissed that no one told me this when the injury occurred!

So, after a few days, maybe a week, I can't remember, I formed a pad out of medical tape, placed it over the bump, then got one of those lower back support things you see people wear at Home Depot, etc... put both straps over the medical tape pad, and sinch'd it down, holding the the bump where it needed to be. It hurt like hell for a half hour because scar tissue had already formed, then it was fine. Pain was no worse than the day before. I kept it like that for 3 days, then took it off and the bump stayed down for several hours.

Thinking I was over the hump, when I went to sleep that night, I didn't tighten it as tight as usual. In the morning, the bump was back. I let off the pressure a little too soon.

At that point, I couldn't really tell what was what in my shoulder. It didn't seem like what I could feel by pressing on my shoulder matched what I saw on the anatomy images on the internet, so I got a little nervous about what I was doing, kind of gave up and decided to let the bump happen.

Well, I ended up with only a small bump. It was worth it. Today, the shoulder doesn't affect me when riding. Actually, doing nothing is the worst thing to do.

Today, at 51, I have almost no bump at all. It's gotten better over time. I believe that taking the pressure off the damaged tendon/ligament allowed it to partially heal. And today, for some reason, the bump is almost gone. Whether the tendon/ligament has healed more, or the muscle around the area is stronger I can't say, but holding the bump down for a few days, for me was totally worth it.

I'm convinced that if a person starts holding the bump down within a few hours of the injury (about the time they put your arm in a sling), that there would be no additional pain (maybe less because it's more stable) and that as my doctor stated, in many cases there would be no bump at all.

If you're going to try this, the downward pressure doesn't need to be severe, just enough to hold the clavical in place.
I would convince your doctor to work with you on this and maybe help in determining how much pressure is needed. If done right way, I don't believe it would take much pressure at all.

I'm putting this out there because I may be the only one in the world who's ever tried this, and I personally believe it should be the standard treatment.

Disclaimer: I'm not a doctor. I'm an engineer.

Have a great day!
Radical
Hank_Thrill
Posts
4652
Joined
9/22/2008
Location
Arlen, TX, USA
3/20/2014 5:48pm
Whew, there for a minute I thought JS7 was out for the rest of the series!
yzjs7
Posts
1137
Joined
7/4/2013
Location
Antioch, CA, USA
3/20/2014 6:02pm
I saw Matt Moss at the Oakland sx with a taped shoulder. Wish my doctor/kaiser would have taped mine. Oh well coulda woulda shoulda.
rmzrider91
Posts
180
Joined
12/8/2013
Location
Tipton, IN, USA
3/20/2014 6:16pm
I guess I should state that mine was a Stage 3 AC separation. I was off work for right at 6 weeks and in a sling most of the time. Gets boring sitting around the house. I would sit around and move that bone all around (which I still can) and thought to myself that this thing isn't ever gunna heal! Went to the doc for my 6 week checkup and he had me do range of motion and light strength test and said I was cleared to do whatever I wanted with no restrictions. I thought there was no way! Next day I was back out riding the 450 with out any problems other then maybe feeling alittle weak
wildbill
Posts
4382
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Christmas Valley, OR, USA
3/21/2014 12:00am
I really miss racing.

seth505
Posts
10202
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
SD, CA, USA
3/21/2014 12:08am
seth505 wrote:
I had grade 3 AC separation, was from dirtjumps though (bicycle). My clavicle still sticks out far and my shoulder gets sore/fatigued easily but I have...
I had grade 3 AC separation, was from dirtjumps though (bicycle).

My clavicle still sticks out far and my shoulder gets sore/fatigued easily but I have full range of motion and such.
hvaughn88 wrote:
mine was from a bicycle accident, as well. I was riding my fixie and didn't have my pedal straps on yet, hit a bump hard enough...
mine was from a bicycle accident, as well. I was riding my fixie and didn't have my pedal straps on yet, hit a bump hard enough to knock my foot off the pedal, which then sent my foot up behind the front fork, resulting in an unintentional footjam endo from about 30 mph. I went over the bars and landed about 15-20 feet down the road directly on my shoulder. The embarrassing part is I was riding down the street to my buddies house for a BBQ so I had about 2 pound of marinated hamburger meat in my backpack that I landed on, too. Needless to say, my buddies still give me shit to this day about it.
Damn, that sounds gnarly! Mine was caught on camera. Aftermath anyway, with my bike bouncing off into the woods...

4/24/2015 9:38pm
I also had a shoulder stabilization surgery a year ago. By following the doctors advice and attending physical therapy sessions, I am perfectly fine now.
tvo314
Posts
776
Joined
5/9/2009
Location
USA
4/24/2015 10:47pm
I had a third degree separation about 5 years ago. I opted not to have surgery, so now I have a pretty funny bump. It doesn't bother me too much unless I have a backpack on for too long.
motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
4/25/2015 4:19am
JW381 wrote:
Separating (from my WebMD knowledge) is when the ball basically hyper-extends out of the socket, stretching or even tearing a ligament, but then goes back on...
Separating (from my WebMD knowledge) is when the ball basically hyper-extends out of the socket, stretching or even tearing a ligament, but then goes back on it's own. So it just kinda falls out of it's place but doesn't dislocate. If that makes sense.

I hated having my shoulder pop out. It hurt, but it just felt weird and you have to kinda hunch over to take the pressure off the muscle which puts strain on your neck and upper back. First time I did it I was complaining about that neck stress and the track medic freaked out and called an ambulance.

2/3 times the doc put me under to set it back in place because the muscles had tightened up so much, but one doc didn't - THAT was the weirdest feeling on earth. It was like busting a nut when it went back in tho, instant relief. Then the pain pills. I wish I could have just broken a bone like a normal person though, it really makes lifting weights or any kind of physical activity that involves shoulder movement above my shoulder line pretty difficult and uncomfortable. Don't even get me started on jacking off, my switch hitting days are over.
JW381 you are talking dislocation. Separation has nothing to do with the socket. I've lived with a degree three sep in my left shoulder for nearly 20 years. I was riding again as soon as the pain started to wear down back when I did it. I was able to keep playing softball and throwing with it all that time. The last couple years I haven't been using it for that anymore and I'm losing that range of motion and it is feeling arthritic but hell I'm going on 56 and have beaten the crap out of my body over the years Tongue



Post a reply to: Seperated Shoulder

The Latest