Stark Varg is just a Toy

Beagle
Posts
1765
Joined
8/3/2023
Location
Toulouse FR
10/18/2024 4:01am
fs wrote:
Are you sure it is limiting because of battery temperature? When the light comes on does it say battery temp, motor temp, or inverter temp? It...

Are you sure it is limiting because of battery temperature? When the light comes on does it say battery temp, motor temp, or inverter temp? It could be any of those 3. I would actually lean towards motor. So does it just give a temperature warning light or specify on which component it is thermal limiting?

Beagle wrote:

Motor and inverter are liquid cooled, the battery is not.

That being said I'm not sure if the light specifically indicates battery temp ?

fs wrote:

I know that. My company designed the friggin thing. Still, the motor is most prone to overheat.

Hadn't seen you here for a while, what's up? Would you be involved with Flux by any chance?

fs
Posts
36
Joined
11/8/2011
Location
HR
10/18/2024 4:10am
Beagle wrote:

Hadn't seen you here for a while, what's up? Would you be involved with Flux by any chance?

Hi Beagle.

Not involved with flux. Been pretty busy. Now we have pretty good experience with MOSFET based inverters in addition to IGBT. That is the reason for the poll on electric dirt riders. We are looking at producing MOSFET based inverters also. Looking to see what we can do traction wise. That is both a personal interest and also a potential product differentiator if we can get it right. So pretty busy...

3
davis224
Posts
7363
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL US
Fantasy
10/18/2024 4:52am
Toste wrote:
I am pro e-moto and would own a Stark Vark (although not as my one and only bike) if I could afford it.BUT... I really don't...

I am pro e-moto and would own a Stark Vark (although not as my one and only bike) if I could afford it.

BUT... I really don't understand why the Stark leadership is so insistent on racing with gas bikes at the pro level when it's clear the bike could not do a full moto with a national caliber rider aboard.

For their own good, it seems like they should be advocating for a separate class/series with conditions that are more favorable to their bike.

soggy wrote:
It’d be much harder to start, fund, and field there own series. There’s so many hang ups, it’s just not practical. They are a manufacturer not...

It’d be much harder to start, fund, and field there own series. There’s so many hang ups, it’s just not practical. They are a manufacturer not a promoter.

It sounds like the varg would struggle with two 30’s but it would handle SX. 

You sure? I highly doubt it will do 20 minutes plus 2 on an AMA SX track ridden by a top 10 rider. It would either...

You sure? I highly doubt it will do 20 minutes plus 2 on an AMA SX track ridden by a top 10 rider. It would either overheat or run out of juice.

Obviously, forget about outdoors. It would do great in arenacross though.

It's weird seeing all the varied run times that people have posted, I'm sure nobody is making their stories up, but my friend who bought a varg let a top 10 250sx pro ride it at his private track, and he was able to do a 30 minute moto on 50% (unsure on power settings and effort used), on a firmer track.

1
rivvs
Posts
87
Joined
9/15/2011
Location
saguenay CA
10/18/2024 7:31am

The thing I hate the most about the electric mxbike community is that everybody is lying about the real performance of the bike. I built a custom electric Honda and I have overheating problem. But I go on diy ebike forum everybody says it is not possible etc. The specs of my bike are very close to those of the stark. I can get 80hp out of it too. But the overheating is the problem.

7
2

The Shop

LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID US
10/18/2024 8:18am
ksithumper wrote:

Ask Jonny Walker.

He hasn't proved it yet.

For the record, I hope he does.

I was mostly just being a smart ass and throwing that out there to rib Phil for saying the Stark sucks cause it can't do Supermoto.  

1
1
Smith246
Posts
417
Joined
1/21/2024
Location
Jerramungup , WA AU
10/18/2024 8:30am
Smith246 wrote:
I would say at 56hp I got around 17-18 mins of decent ride time. When the light comes and it limits power the battery just seems...

I would say at 56hp I got around 17-18 mins of decent ride time. When the light comes and it limits power the battery just seems to disappear after that.

Yeah I'm pretty sure my bike isn't faulty it's just the bikes limitations. I rode again today at 52hp and the light didn't come on till 20% so that is another step forward, got around 20 mins ride time with a few stops dicking around with suspension. 

I didn't really like it at 20% to be honest, ill get used to it if that's what I have to do but I'm so used to 4 stroke engine braking it was a little hard to adjust. 

I'm definitely not giving up on the stark just sharing my experience in the hope it may help others. 

On another not, when I was done with the stark today I hoped straight on my 350sxf and I think the stark may have ruined every other bike for me. Holy crap it felt like a heavy slow diesel tractor 🤣

fs wrote:
Are you sure it is limiting because of battery temperature? When the light comes on does it say battery temp, motor temp, or inverter temp? It...

Are you sure it is limiting because of battery temperature? When the light comes on does it say battery temp, motor temp, or inverter temp? It could be any of those 3. I would actually lean towards motor. So does it just give a temperature warning light or specify on which component it is thermal limiting?

It is definitely a battery issue as it is a battery indicator light that appears and stark have also said it is battery related. I'm no electric wizard of any sort but I believe it is restricting current draw to stop the battery running hot, not because the battery is already running hot. There is 2 different warning lights that can appear on the stark phone, a battery one and a powertrain one I am only getting the battery one. 

It sounds like you are someone who knows alot about this stuff so any feedback or advice you could give me would be much appreciated.  

 

1
10/18/2024 8:32am
rivvs wrote:
The thing I hate the most about the electric mxbike community is that everybody is lying about the real performance of the bike. I built a...

The thing I hate the most about the electric mxbike community is that everybody is lying about the real performance of the bike. I built a custom electric Honda and I have overheating problem. But I go on diy ebike forum everybody says it is not possible etc. The specs of my bike are very close to those of the stark. I can get 80hp out of it too. But the overheating is the problem.

It's not a problem exclusive to electrics.  Its a people problem, anything people are involved in will have inaccuracy's . Some people are doing it intentionally for whatever reason.  Some people might be estimating and bad at it.  Many people will talk like they have more speed and endurance than they really do. 

 

It can go both ways too , with people lying about getting shorter range, having less power, etc. 

 

I'm 300 pounds and I got 20 minutes of very easy trail riding on hard pack , on a power setting that was supposed to be similar to a 125 , I'll have to try and go back and see if I can see how much power I started with and what was left.  I was not paying attention to the display at all but I noticed I could see it in video I took with a 360 camera.

I have a current generation  RMZ450 that I am thinking of doing a conversion on. If it felt anything close to how the Varg felt , even at that lower setting I rode one at. I would probable ride it everyday. 

2
Smith246
Posts
417
Joined
1/21/2024
Location
Jerramungup , WA AU
10/18/2024 8:45am
rivvs wrote:
The thing I hate the most about the electric mxbike community is that everybody is lying about the real performance of the bike. I built a...

The thing I hate the most about the electric mxbike community is that everybody is lying about the real performance of the bike. I built a custom electric Honda and I have overheating problem. But I go on diy ebike forum everybody says it is not possible etc. The specs of my bike are very close to those of the stark. I can get 80hp out of it too. But the overheating is the problem.

I 100% agree, but its not just about the ev bike community, it's everything. Haters will always hate and lovers will always love. How hard is to just tell it as it is is. Everyone on this forum I believe has a common interest in the love of dirt bikes. I couldnt care less if it is 2 stroke, 4 stroke, 3 stroke or electric, if it is good bad or somewhere inbetween ill tell it as it is.  

9
1
10/18/2024 8:50am Edited Date/Time 10/18/2024 8:50am
Smith246 wrote:
Once I knew Dean Porter was riding one on tracks like coastals that gave me a bit more confidence in my purchase. It is also why...

Once I knew Dean Porter was riding one on tracks like coastals that gave me a bit more confidence in my purchase. It is also why I am quiet shocked with my experience and was hoping there was simply something wrong with my bike. 

It must be noted that the races he has been doing have been very short races, only 4 maybe 5 laps top's so i could see this not being a problem. I'm hoping at some stage I may be able to get in touch with him somehow and find out more about his experience with the stark.

Beagle wrote:
On the other side (literally as it's just 2 days drive from your place 😆) Stark riders won 30+ and 40+ Aus MX national titles earlier...

On the other side (literally as it's just 2 days drive from your place 😆) Stark riders won 30+ and 40+ Aus MX national titles earlier this year. 

Mike Sleeter says he used 63% battery for 19 min race (55 hp, 40% regen) at Queensland Moto Park.

https://mytwowheellife.com/mytwowheellife/2024/8/18/2024-australian-vet…

Queensland's sand is on it's beaches, not it's motocross tracks...

Not sure why anyone would think QMP is anything resembling sand. The closest would have been Haworth Park at Leyburn.

fs
Posts
36
Joined
11/8/2011
Location
HR
10/18/2024 10:21am Edited Date/Time 10/18/2024 10:23am
Smith246 wrote:
It is definitely a battery issue as it is a battery indicator light that appears and stark have also said it is battery related. I'm no...

It is definitely a battery issue as it is a battery indicator light that appears and stark have also said it is battery related. I'm no electric wizard of any sort but I believe it is restricting current draw to stop the battery running hot, not because the battery is already running hot. There is 2 different warning lights that can appear on the stark phone, a battery one and a powertrain one I am only getting the battery one. 

It sounds like you are someone who knows alot about this stuff so any feedback or advice you could give me would be much appreciated.  

 

There are 12 temperature sensors inside the battery, six per side. It will limit on the hottest sensor. If one of them is problematic (reading a temperature significantly hotter than actual temperature) that will cause it to falsely limit. It will limit because it thinks the battery IS hot, not because it thinks the battery will BE hot.

The prototype bikes ran Molicel P42A. With those cells the weak point (thermal wise) was generally the battery. The batteries actually sold use Molicel P45B. With those cells the battery was generally no longer the thermal weak point. I say generally because it depends where in the RPM and torque range you are running the motor.  If the motor is mainly where it is most efficient then it could actually be the battery (which is completely fine) overheating. However, this was generally not my experience and the motor was the weakest link in the thermal chain.

So what Stark is telling you could be right, but I have a suspicion there is a good chance there is a questionable temperature sensor in the battery. I don't know if the technician has a log of all 12 sensor to check if they are all within a reasonable range. You can ask if he does at what the difference between the minimum, maximum, and average values is.

During the very early days (before the bikes were shipping to customers) the display looked like this:

image 623

State of charge is 68 percent, the average of all 12 battery temperature sensors is 26.8C, the lowest is 24.3C, and highest 27.3C

You would expect no more than a 7 deg C deviation except if there is a good reason for it -- like the sun has been shining on one side of the battery.

If the technician confirms the deviation seems to be OK, then it is likely you are the exception to the rule.

When is starts to limit on battery temperature you can take off your glove and put your bare hand on the battery. It won't burn your hand, but if you want to move your hand away after 2 seconds or so because it starts to get uncomfortable, then it is thermal limiting on the battery.

16
10/18/2024 12:17pm
soggy wrote:
It’d be much harder to start, fund, and field there own series. There’s so many hang ups, it’s just not practical. They are a manufacturer not...

It’d be much harder to start, fund, and field there own series. There’s so many hang ups, it’s just not practical. They are a manufacturer not a promoter.

It sounds like the varg would struggle with two 30’s but it would handle SX. 

You sure? I highly doubt it will do 20 minutes plus 2 on an AMA SX track ridden by a top 10 rider. It would either...

You sure? I highly doubt it will do 20 minutes plus 2 on an AMA SX track ridden by a top 10 rider. It would either overheat or run out of juice.

Obviously, forget about outdoors. It would do great in arenacross though.

davis224 wrote:
It's weird seeing all the varied run times that people have posted, I'm sure nobody is making their stories up, but my friend who bought a...

It's weird seeing all the varied run times that people have posted, I'm sure nobody is making their stories up, but my friend who bought a varg let a top 10 250sx pro ride it at his private track, and he was able to do a 30 minute moto on 50% (unsure on power settings and effort used), on a firmer track.

A top 10 250 Rider? Who would that be?

1
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
NY US
10/18/2024 12:26pm
2
davis224
Posts
7363
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL US
Fantasy
10/18/2024 1:57pm
You sure? I highly doubt it will do 20 minutes plus 2 on an AMA SX track ridden by a top 10 rider. It would either...

You sure? I highly doubt it will do 20 minutes plus 2 on an AMA SX track ridden by a top 10 rider. It would either overheat or run out of juice.

Obviously, forget about outdoors. It would do great in arenacross though.

davis224 wrote:
It's weird seeing all the varied run times that people have posted, I'm sure nobody is making their stories up, but my friend who bought a...

It's weird seeing all the varied run times that people have posted, I'm sure nobody is making their stories up, but my friend who bought a varg let a top 10 250sx pro ride it at his private track, and he was able to do a 30 minute moto on 50% (unsure on power settings and effort used), on a firmer track.

A top 10 250 Rider? Who would that be?

I feel weird about blowing out people when they didn't post it themselves publicly, but I don't want to be like, "I have super secret insider knowledge and won't say". Just saying, a dude who held a 2 digit number and had a few top 10s rode it, and the owner (who I wouldn't consider a fanatic by any means) claims he only used 50% of the battery on a fast, worn in track.

When I rode the same bike, it was a tight, deep, rutted track, getting play rode by the owner all day in between letting everybody spin laps on it, plugging it in to 110v while we took breaks, and it never had a problem. I didn't pay attention to battery life while I was riding it, but I used 2 maps, 60 hp and higher regen, and 48hp with low regen.

3
1
Smith246
Posts
417
Joined
1/21/2024
Location
Jerramungup , WA AU
10/18/2024 3:32pm Edited Date/Time 10/18/2024 5:47pm
Smith246 wrote:
It is definitely a battery issue as it is a battery indicator light that appears and stark have also said it is battery related. I'm no...

It is definitely a battery issue as it is a battery indicator light that appears and stark have also said it is battery related. I'm no electric wizard of any sort but I believe it is restricting current draw to stop the battery running hot, not because the battery is already running hot. There is 2 different warning lights that can appear on the stark phone, a battery one and a powertrain one I am only getting the battery one. 

It sounds like you are someone who knows alot about this stuff so any feedback or advice you could give me would be much appreciated.  

 

fs wrote:
There are 12 temperature sensors inside the battery, six per side. It will limit on the hottest sensor. If one of them is problematic (reading a...

There are 12 temperature sensors inside the battery, six per side. It will limit on the hottest sensor. If one of them is problematic (reading a temperature significantly hotter than actual temperature) that will cause it to falsely limit. It will limit because it thinks the battery IS hot, not because it thinks the battery will BE hot.

The prototype bikes ran Molicel P42A. With those cells the weak point (thermal wise) was generally the battery. The batteries actually sold use Molicel P45B. With those cells the battery was generally no longer the thermal weak point. I say generally because it depends where in the RPM and torque range you are running the motor.  If the motor is mainly where it is most efficient then it could actually be the battery (which is completely fine) overheating. However, this was generally not my experience and the motor was the weakest link in the thermal chain.

So what Stark is telling you could be right, but I have a suspicion there is a good chance there is a questionable temperature sensor in the battery. I don't know if the technician has a log of all 12 sensor to check if they are all within a reasonable range. You can ask if he does at what the difference between the minimum, maximum, and average values is.

During the very early days (before the bikes were shipping to customers) the display looked like this:

image 623

State of charge is 68 percent, the average of all 12 battery temperature sensors is 26.8C, the lowest is 24.3C, and highest 27.3C

You would expect no more than a 7 deg C deviation except if there is a good reason for it -- like the sun has been shining on one side of the battery.

If the technician confirms the deviation seems to be OK, then it is likely you are the exception to the rule.

When is starts to limit on battery temperature you can take off your glove and put your bare hand on the battery. It won't burn your hand, but if you want to move your hand away after 2 seconds or so because it starts to get uncomfortable, then it is thermal limiting on the battery.

Thanks heaps for your reply. I'm guessing there's no way I can see on the phone what temperature the sensors are at?

When it does limit itself the battery definitely feels very hot, like there's no way you can hold your bare hand on it very long.

I'm not sure you can answer this question but I'll try anyway. When riding in the sand would I be better off using a scoop tyre to lesson wheel spin which may cause more heat or would the extra traction create more load that would create more heat? 

Also if I'm constantly running the battery to point where it is derating will this significantly effect the lifespan of the battery?

1
1
Talltexan
Posts
17
Joined
9/30/2015
Location
Utley, TX US
10/18/2024 6:51pm
Smith246 wrote:
It is definitely a battery issue as it is a battery indicator light that appears and stark have also said it is battery related. I'm no...

It is definitely a battery issue as it is a battery indicator light that appears and stark have also said it is battery related. I'm no electric wizard of any sort but I believe it is restricting current draw to stop the battery running hot, not because the battery is already running hot. There is 2 different warning lights that can appear on the stark phone, a battery one and a powertrain one I am only getting the battery one. 

It sounds like you are someone who knows alot about this stuff so any feedback or advice you could give me would be much appreciated.  

 

fs wrote:
There are 12 temperature sensors inside the battery, six per side. It will limit on the hottest sensor. If one of them is problematic (reading a...

There are 12 temperature sensors inside the battery, six per side. It will limit on the hottest sensor. If one of them is problematic (reading a temperature significantly hotter than actual temperature) that will cause it to falsely limit. It will limit because it thinks the battery IS hot, not because it thinks the battery will BE hot.

The prototype bikes ran Molicel P42A. With those cells the weak point (thermal wise) was generally the battery. The batteries actually sold use Molicel P45B. With those cells the battery was generally no longer the thermal weak point. I say generally because it depends where in the RPM and torque range you are running the motor.  If the motor is mainly where it is most efficient then it could actually be the battery (which is completely fine) overheating. However, this was generally not my experience and the motor was the weakest link in the thermal chain.

So what Stark is telling you could be right, but I have a suspicion there is a good chance there is a questionable temperature sensor in the battery. I don't know if the technician has a log of all 12 sensor to check if they are all within a reasonable range. You can ask if he does at what the difference between the minimum, maximum, and average values is.

During the very early days (before the bikes were shipping to customers) the display looked like this:

image 623

State of charge is 68 percent, the average of all 12 battery temperature sensors is 26.8C, the lowest is 24.3C, and highest 27.3C

You would expect no more than a 7 deg C deviation except if there is a good reason for it -- like the sun has been shining on one side of the battery.

If the technician confirms the deviation seems to be OK, then it is likely you are the exception to the rule.

When is starts to limit on battery temperature you can take off your glove and put your bare hand on the battery. It won't burn your hand, but if you want to move your hand away after 2 seconds or so because it starts to get uncomfortable, then it is thermal limiting on the battery.

Smith246 wrote:
Thanks heaps for your reply. I'm guessing there's no way I can see on the phone what temperature the sensors are at?When it does limit itself...

Thanks heaps for your reply. I'm guessing there's no way I can see on the phone what temperature the sensors are at?

When it does limit itself the battery definitely feels very hot, like there's no way you can hold your bare hand on it very long.

I'm not sure you can answer this question but I'll try anyway. When riding in the sand would I be better off using a scoop tyre to lesson wheel spin which may cause more heat or would the extra traction create more load that would create more heat? 

Also if I'm constantly running the battery to point where it is derating will this significantly effect the lifespan of the battery?

This is a very interesting thread!  

Would changing the final drive gear ratio help? Add a tooth or two to the rear sprocket?

vdrsnk04
Posts
2026
Joined
9/5/2018
Location
IL US
10/18/2024 7:20pm

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

cmotodad
Posts
1007
Joined
12/18/2013
Location
Yorba Linda, CA US
10/18/2024 7:28pm

On my home built ecrf, outside temperature and traction are 2 contributing factors to controller over temp and ability to recharge battery caused by heat. On occasion, traction helps with run time because of less wide open throttle in turns. Outside temps are extremely critical on my application.

Talltexan
Posts
17
Joined
9/30/2015
Location
Utley, TX US
10/18/2024 7:29pm

You weigh ~210lbs, you are riding deep sand, Stark recently went to a 47 tooth rear sprocket from 48.

Can you modify the chain guide to accept a larger rear sprocket?

@fs, if I am off base please correct me.

10/18/2024 7:31pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

The Stark's maximum rear wheel torque is 938Nm, if you are riding at 20mph that's 32hp, even if power is set to 80hp.

The 60hp limit doesn't start until speed reaches 31mph, the 80hp limit doesn't start until speed reaches 49mph.

Smith246
Posts
417
Joined
1/21/2024
Location
Jerramungup , WA AU
10/18/2024 8:04pm
Talltexan wrote:
You weigh ~210lbs, you are riding deep sand, Stark recently went to a 47 tooth rear sprocket from 48.Can you modify the chain guide to accept...

You weigh ~210lbs, you are riding deep sand, Stark recently went to a 47 tooth rear sprocket from 48.

Can you modify the chain guide to accept a larger rear sprocket?

@fs, if I am off base please correct me.

From what I can see it's not the chain guide that is the problem its when a larger sprocket is fitted the wheel comes too far forward and some tyres can rub on the swingarm. The problem is the stark doesn't have a very large axle adjustment range so finding a gear ratio and chain length that will work might be the hard part.

 If a larger rear sprocket is something that will help the battery im more than willing to buy a few different sprockets and a chain to see what might work.

Smith246
Posts
417
Joined
1/21/2024
Location
Jerramungup , WA AU
10/18/2024 8:12pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I can get it to come on with still 60% battery left, at 56hp I got it down to around 35% left. Yesterday at 52hp I got it down to 20% before it came on.

I don't believe with the type of riding you describe you will have any issues at all.

Just to clarify, you said you started at 26% and went down to 7% and rode for 45mins. So are you saying you got 45mins of riding on 19% battery? 

mbw479
Posts
523
Joined
12/5/2021
Location
Daytona, FL US
10/18/2024 8:20pm
I mean 4 strokes have dominated championships for at least the last 2 decades so I would classify that as proven, Electric is new and unproven...

I mean 4 strokes have dominated championships for at least the last 2 decades so I would classify that as proven, Electric is new and unproven, the guy gave a honest opinion, it could be compared to the Suzuki/kawi partnership of 04, “this is going to work but don’t jump the gun just yet” people where sceptical back then and bikes were half the price, Every new technology has its teething problems doesn’t mean it’s not the future but all the guy is saying is don’t throw 5 figures just yet, 

Btw can you post a picture of you on your varg in sand please 

LungButter wrote:
This thread has been about calling the Varg a toy because it doesn't work for a couple very specific use cases.  How is that any different...

This thread has been about calling the Varg a toy because it doesn't work for a couple very specific use cases.  

How is that any different than 4 strokes not working for a specific use case?

Btw can you post a picture of you doing hard enduro on a 4 stroke please? 

There’s plenty of people competing at the highest level of hard enduro on 4 strokes, Johnny Walker is on a 4 stroke now. Billy Bolt won the world super enduro championship on a 4 stroke this year, a few years ago people were saying it was a 2 stroke only event as well.

The beauty of dirt bikes is that the bike means fuck all, the rider makes the difference.

1
vdrsnk04
Posts
2026
Joined
9/5/2018
Location
IL US
10/18/2024 8:44pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

The Stark's maximum rear wheel torque is 938Nm, if you are riding at 20mph that's 32hp, even if power is set to 80hp.The 60hp limit doesn't...

The Stark's maximum rear wheel torque is 938Nm, if you are riding at 20mph that's 32hp, even if power is set to 80hp.

The 60hp limit doesn't start until speed reaches 31mph, the 80hp limit doesn't start until speed reaches 49mph.

Makes sense, I am set at 50hp anyway.

vdrsnk04
Posts
2026
Joined
9/5/2018
Location
IL US
10/18/2024 8:46pm Edited Date/Time 10/18/2024 8:48pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

Smith246 wrote:
There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I...

There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I can get it to come on with still 60% battery left, at 56hp I got it down to around 35% left. Yesterday at 52hp I got it down to 20% before it came on.

I don't believe with the type of riding you describe you will have any issues at all.

Just to clarify, you said you started at 26% and went down to 7% and rode for 45mins. So are you saying you got 45mins of riding on 19% battery? 

huh, I guess I am just stumped. I’ve never had the issues happen to me you are talking about. 

Yep got 45 min of riding on 19% battery. But what I was doing, it’s nothing like deep sand full on moto riding like you are.

vdrsnk04
Posts
2026
Joined
9/5/2018
Location
IL US
10/18/2024 8:56pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

Smith246 wrote:
There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I...

There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I can get it to come on with still 60% battery left, at 56hp I got it down to around 35% left. Yesterday at 52hp I got it down to 20% before it came on.

I don't believe with the type of riding you describe you will have any issues at all.

Just to clarify, you said you started at 26% and went down to 7% and rode for 45mins. So are you saying you got 45mins of riding on 19% battery? 

I’ll try to remember to grab my Stark phone to get a screenshot of the ride. But until then here is a screenshot of my watch data. I think it follows prettt closely to what I describe above. You can see the obvious part where moto happened with the elevated heart rate and speed, again slower moto though and the rest was hard enduro which just isn’t hard on the battery.

IMG 5062
Smith246
Posts
417
Joined
1/21/2024
Location
Jerramungup , WA AU
10/18/2024 8:58pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

Smith246 wrote:
There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I...

There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I can get it to come on with still 60% battery left, at 56hp I got it down to around 35% left. Yesterday at 52hp I got it down to 20% before it came on.

I don't believe with the type of riding you describe you will have any issues at all.

Just to clarify, you said you started at 26% and went down to 7% and rode for 45mins. So are you saying you got 45mins of riding on 19% battery? 

vdrsnk04 wrote:
huh, I guess I am just stumped. I’ve never had the issues happen to me you are talking about. Yep got 45 min of riding on 19%...

huh, I guess I am just stumped. I’ve never had the issues happen to me you are talking about. 

Yep got 45 min of riding on 19% battery. But what I was doing, it’s nothing like deep sand full on moto riding like you are.

And I don't think you ever will have any issues with the riding you describe.

I'm still shocked with you saying you got 45 minutes ride time and only used 19% battery. I used 10% battery in 10 mins just play riding around my sheds and thats on hard gravel dirt. I believe you it's just shocking the drastic differences people get. 

How much do you weigh if you don't mind me asking?

2
10/18/2024 10:09pm Edited Date/Time 10/19/2024 3:52pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

Smith246 wrote:
There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I...

There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I can get it to come on with still 60% battery left, at 56hp I got it down to around 35% left. Yesterday at 52hp I got it down to 20% before it came on.

I don't believe with the type of riding you describe you will have any issues at all.

Just to clarify, you said you started at 26% and went down to 7% and rode for 45mins. So are you saying you got 45mins of riding on 19% battery? 

vdrsnk04 wrote:
I’ll try to remember to grab my Stark phone to get a screenshot of the ride. But until then here is a screenshot of my watch...

I’ll try to remember to grab my Stark phone to get a screenshot of the ride. But until then here is a screenshot of my watch data. I think it follows prettt closely to what I describe above. You can see the obvious part where moto happened with the elevated heart rate and speed, again slower moto though and the rest was hard enduro which just isn’t hard on the battery.

IMG 5062

If you are using full throttle at your max speed of 27.2mph, that's 44.4hp, full throttle at average speed of 5.8mph is 9.3hp, even when power is set to 80hp!

1
Beagle
Posts
1765
Joined
8/3/2023
Location
Toulouse FR
10/18/2024 11:51pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

Smith246 wrote:
There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I...

There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I can get it to come on with still 60% battery left, at 56hp I got it down to around 35% left. Yesterday at 52hp I got it down to 20% before it came on.

I don't believe with the type of riding you describe you will have any issues at all.

Just to clarify, you said you started at 26% and went down to 7% and rode for 45mins. So are you saying you got 45mins of riding on 19% battery? 

I think you should mention regen settings as well, going from 90% to 20% regen has probably much more effect on your battery temperature than decreasing power by 4-8 hp 😉

Smith246
Posts
417
Joined
1/21/2024
Location
Jerramungup , WA AU
10/19/2024 1:30am
vdrsnk04 wrote:
Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?I ask because for me...

Maybe I missed it, but is there a certain percentage every time that the light goes on and it de-rate’s the battery?


I ask because for me I rode mine tonight, started with 26% and took it to 7% battery and it still wasn’t having any issues. But I did a mix of hard enduro and slower moto for 45 minutes, a mix of mud, rock, many logs and hard pack with jumps on small moto track.

Smith246 wrote:
There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I...

There is no specific battery percentage that the light comes on at and it de-rates, it is all dependent on the battery temperature. At 60hp I can get it to come on with still 60% battery left, at 56hp I got it down to around 35% left. Yesterday at 52hp I got it down to 20% before it came on.

I don't believe with the type of riding you describe you will have any issues at all.

Just to clarify, you said you started at 26% and went down to 7% and rode for 45mins. So are you saying you got 45mins of riding on 19% battery? 

Beagle wrote:
I think you should mention regen settings as well, going from 90% to 20% regen has probably much more effect on your battery temperature than decreasing...

I think you should mention regen settings as well, going from 90% to 20% regen has probably much more effect on your battery temperature than decreasing power by 4-8 hp 😉

Yeah sorry should have mentioned that. Although I actually think the lower hp has more of an effect then the lower regen. 

Beagle
Posts
1765
Joined
8/3/2023
Location
Toulouse FR
10/19/2024 2:03am
Smith246 wrote:

Yeah sorry should have mentioned that. Although I actually think the lower hp has more of an effect then the lower regen. 

Thanks for all the details of your struggles with your Varg. And your awesome profile pic 😎

Just for clarity, to help other Varg owners, could you please sum up what worked best for you on your private sand track so far, you've found settings to get at least one full run without temperature warning, right?

Hp, regen, ride time, battery left, was it 52 hp, 20% regen for 20-30 min ride and 10% battery left?

3

Post a reply to: Stark Varg is just a Toy

The Latest