Is the USA on the verge of becoming the only relevant series?

motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
10/3/2024 7:29pm
vdrsnk04 wrote:
I’d agree more young talent coming up in MXGP world, who once going premier class moves to the AMA series, or at least seems to be...

I’d agree more young talent coming up in MXGP world, who once going premier class moves to the AMA series, or at least seems to be the past few years. I think that’s the point of the thread.

Bingo. My choice of words may have stirred up the troops but that's it in a nutshell. You look at the directions the two series are going, and I think a lot of the young guys worldwide are eyeballing coming here for a myriad of reasons. 

4
2
10/3/2024 7:43pm
GPs need a USGP round each year and rotate it to one of the Nationals track each year (does NOT need to coincide with USMX schedule)Pretty...

GPs need a USGP round each year and rotate it to one of the Nationals track each year (does NOT need to coincide with USMX schedule)
Pretty sure that will get full gates and increase fan base. 

Poor marketing not having a USGP. 

MXGPs are sanctioned by the governing body in the country hosting the race, a USGP would need to be AMA sanctioned.

Great who cares. Just make it happen. 

1
10/3/2024 7:49pm
GPs need a USGP round each year and rotate it to one of the Nationals track each year (does NOT need to coincide with USMX schedule)Pretty...

GPs need a USGP round each year and rotate it to one of the Nationals track each year (does NOT need to coincide with USMX schedule)
Pretty sure that will get full gates and increase fan base. 

Poor marketing not having a USGP. 

MXGPs are sanctioned by the governing body in the country hosting the race, a USGP would need to be AMA sanctioned.

Great who cares. Just make it happen. 

Politics, Feld and MX Sports have a lot of control over the AMA, do you think they want a competing series racing in their home turf?

2
10/3/2024 7:54pm

MXGPs are sanctioned by the governing body in the country hosting the race, a USGP would need to be AMA sanctioned.

Great who cares. Just make it happen. 

Politics, Feld and MX Sports have a lot of control over the AMA, do you think they want a competing series racing in their home turf?

That’s just red tape talk. 
They have had USGPs before so have them again. 

The Shop

decano51
Posts
2738
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Central Coast, NSW, AU
10/3/2024 8:08pm
Trickamoto wrote:
Bottom line, there's only five or six good guys in each class in the. That's not enough to make them a great series. And the tracks...

Bottom line, there's only five or six good guys in each class in the. That's not enough to make them a great series. And the tracks are so fucking terrible it's a joke. You've got to fight for 15th in the 250 class over here. The very top couple of guys in each class over there would be relevant here but after that, it's a bunch of garbage. 

To your argument, who is battling for 15th in the 250 ama class?
You could argue that with the american 250 class and 450 class. take the superstar names away and look at the time difference of gap between riders.. its pretty much similar in MXGP as far as gaps between riders.. 

You dont see Deegan battling for 15th? the same way you dont see de Wolf battling for 15th. 

 

10/3/2024 8:17pm Edited Date/Time 10/3/2024 8:32pm
Brent wrote:
Absolutely  not.Anyone who has been to a MXGP race knows that it is a special event with incredibly talented racers.  both series are different, but with equal...

Absolutely  not.

Anyone who has been to a MXGP race knows that it is a special event with incredibly talented racers. 

 both series are different, but with equal levels of  talent. 

 I have attended my share of both, and to go to some of these historic tracks in Europe and see the amazing fans,  the culture, the way they do things in the Paddock,  and the incredibly difficult tracks is special. 

 I do have to say that if you choose to do the VIP experience, MXGP leaves AMA motocross in the dust.

I just wish that the organizers of MXGP would stop racing on these stupid, flat parking lot style tracks that we have been seeing  waaay too much of lately. 

Sure, it’s making them money, but racing on these amateur style circuits is taking away from what makes European motocross special. Stick to the classic Euros style tracks  please?

The riders going keep jumping ship to over here because youthstream is holding races to who ever will pay them a million euros to hold a race and they do not pay any money the riders at all . Riders only make money from their teams and personal sponsors . Everyone hating on mxsports but they pay the riders

3
3
Ktm life
Posts
184
Joined
12/17/2012
Location
Tremonton, UT, USA
10/3/2024 8:25pm
The rats are jumping off the MXGP ship at a prodigious rate. I don't see how they can maintain the series with a quickly diminishing talent...

The rats are jumping off the MXGP ship at a prodigious rate. I don't see how they can maintain the series with a quickly diminishing talent base.

Nice try Davey 

3
Johnny Oz
Posts
262
Joined
3/26/2019
Location
AU
10/3/2024 8:28pm

Well I spoke with my wallet and cancelled my SX, MX & SMX subscription. Crap tracks, crap racing, crap commentators (JT is ok), it's catering for the common man, monster truck racing fans, for the money. Yeh sure I'll watch the highlight packages?

 

8
EuroGuy39
Posts
332
Joined
7/19/2014
Location
FI
10/3/2024 8:36pm

While there are some problems in MXGP, my answer is absolutely not. 

 

10/3/2024 11:17pm
Dude! Dude!! There’s a whole wide world out there, much bigger than the USA. YOU might think the US series is the only one relevant, and that’s fine...

Dude! Dude!! 
There’s a whole wide world out there, much bigger than the USA. 
YOU might think the US series is the only one relevant, and that’s fine, that’s up to you to think whatever makes you happy.

 But to even think the rest of the world agrees with you is plain arrogant. 

Send this thread to the dungeon FFS..

Well said

Paul333
Posts
2195
Joined
2/15/2012
Location
Virginia Beach, VA, USA
10/3/2024 11:31pm
GPs need a USGP round each year and rotate it to one of the Nationals track each year (does NOT need to coincide with USMX schedule)Pretty...

GPs need a USGP round each year and rotate it to one of the Nationals track each year (does NOT need to coincide with USMX schedule)
Pretty sure that will get full gates and increase fan base. 

Poor marketing not having a USGP. 

MXGPs are sanctioned by the governing body in the country hosting the race, a USGP would need to be AMA sanctioned.

Great who cares. Just make it happen. 

Absolutely awesome idea. 

Let’s get that done ASAP.

10/4/2024 12:41am

For Australians I think the USA is an easy choice, the money is similar to better. Europe has cold shitty weather, and in most parts Australians can’t speak the language. Europeans that can’t speak English are making a tough move coming to the USA..

2
Spoonguy
Posts
3510
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA, USA
10/4/2024 5:48am

Great who cares. Just make it happen. 

Politics, Feld and MX Sports have a lot of control over the AMA, do you think they want a competing series racing in their home turf?

That’s just red tape talk. 
They have had USGPs before so have them again. 

Different world now. AMA has the Lawrences, Vialle, getting Prado and every third 250f rider in the world wants to be here or is heading here. 

Spoonguy
Posts
3510
Joined
2/28/2022
Location
Mc Kean, PA, USA
10/4/2024 5:56am
Dude! Dude!! There’s a whole wide world out there, much bigger than the USA. YOU might think the US series is the only one relevant, and that’s fine...

Dude! Dude!! 
There’s a whole wide world out there, much bigger than the USA. 
YOU might think the US series is the only one relevant, and that’s fine, that’s up to you to think whatever makes you happy.

 But to even think the rest of the world agrees with you is plain arrogant. 

Send this thread to the dungeon FFS..

Bazzb1973 wrote:

Well said

India has a SX series too, that doesn't make it an important series, though it probably is taking talent from the GPs too. The chickens are coming home to roost for Luongo, lot of fine riders in the GPs, but the racing and the riders/teams taking a back seat to profits is making it's presence known in far too many apparent and detrimental ways for MXGP. The icons of 500 class in the 70s/80s wouldn't put up with Luongo's shit either, they would all be heading to the USA too.

1
10/4/2024 6:14am
Paul333 wrote:
If you truly want to fix the GP’s you need to ditch Youthsteam. Ever since the FIM abandoned the sport and sold it off those scumbags...

If you truly want to fix the GP’s you need to ditch Youthsteam. Ever since the FIM abandoned the sport and sold it off those scumbags most things have gotten worse. Youthstream does not own the sport, its not their property to destroy. They are merely leasing it from the FIM. 

MXA has been writing about this for 20 years….

Force Youthstream to (Not In Exact Order of Importance):

- Stop profiting off the teams. No more selling off team spots, charging them to race, etc. They are the talent/show. 

- Allow anyone who can quantify & meets lap time standards to race. Again, they are the talent/show. 

- Stop limiting the race to 20(ish) riders. The goal is the normal 40. 

- Pay legit purse money / pay purse money far enough back to help fund small teams/privateers. Again they are the show. 

- Stop basing as much of the schedule as possible on Third World countries, dictatorships, authoritarian governments who get races merely because they are willing to pay huge fees in an attempt to look like a normal country. 

- If you are scheduling races in these countries there should be fixed percentage of the money spent on start money for the riders/ teams, team/rider travel expenses, higher than normal purse money, etc. 

- ETC, ETC, ETC

T.V. coverage is the one exception. It’s very good 


Again, MXA has been writing about this for years. 

I believe the lease is up 2026 ? i think i read it somewhere. It would be best for the sport if loungo and his croonies get bought out but yeah wont happen. Sad how they are destroying it and every team /rider just watch and let it be.

1
10/4/2024 6:24am

I would say the average MX fan in US has maybe heard of MXGP but likely not a follower. Would the average MX fan in the rest of the world know of Pro Motocross or Supercross?

I might be ignorant, but I would guess per 100 fans, there are more non-US fans who follow US moto than US who follow MXGP.

motomike137
Posts
8180
Joined
4/22/2010
Location
Fenton, MI, USA
10/4/2024 6:37am
I would say the average MX fan in US has maybe heard of MXGP but likely not a follower. Would the average MX fan in the...

I would say the average MX fan in US has maybe heard of MXGP but likely not a follower. Would the average MX fan in the rest of the world know of Pro Motocross or Supercross?

I might be ignorant, but I would guess per 100 fans, there are more non-US fans who follow US moto than US who follow MXGP.

This thread isn't about the fans. I realize the fans across the pond are super passionate. I grew up in Michigan thinking of GP riders as gods for that matter back in the seventies. I'm really strictly talking business model and what it reaping here.

soggy
Posts
8754
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
10/4/2024 6:38am Edited Date/Time 10/4/2024 6:39am
64smoker wrote:
90 percent of this forum wouldn’t have been to a gp to ever know 😂 For me Mxgp is better than pro motocross for a couple of...

90 percent of this forum wouldn’t have been to a gp to ever know 😂 

For me Mxgp is better than pro motocross for a couple of reasons  , more depth for a start , variety of tracks makes it more interesting ,  90 percent of ama tracks are just a different layout prepped exactly the same. 
 
That being said supercross is where the money is and makes it the draw for these riders understandably so 👍

zehn wrote:

Define depth, because the American series are swimming in it right now with more coming soon on the horizon

64smoker wrote:
Depth ( depth of talent ) mx2 has 8-9 riders who can win all under the age of 23 .  Mx1 similar Herlings prado Febvre Gajser seewer...

Depth ( depth of talent ) mx2 has 8-9 riders who can win all under the age of 23 . 
 Mx1 similar Herlings prado Febvre Gajser seewer vlanderen Renaux can all win a race , tell me that’s not depth 

That’s called parody.  You can’t have depth when you have less then 20 riders on the gate some races. 

USA has depth top to bottom. MXGP is top loaded. 

2
2
Madmax31
Posts
2143
Joined
1/7/2009
Location
Cincinnati, OH, USA
Fantasy
10/4/2024 6:45am

Unless you live under a rock, the US has been the only legitimate series for years.  

I'm not taking anything away from some of the best Euro riders, but their series is a joke. 

7
10/4/2024 6:48am
vdrsnk04 wrote:
I’d agree more young talent coming up in MXGP world, who once going premier class moves to the AMA series, or at least seems to be...

I’d agree more young talent coming up in MXGP world, who once going premier class moves to the AMA series, or at least seems to be the past few years. I think that’s the point of the thread.

Bingo. My choice of words may have stirred up the troops but that's it in a nutshell. You look at the directions the two series are...

Bingo. My choice of words may have stirred up the troops but that's it in a nutshell. You look at the directions the two series are going, and I think a lot of the young guys worldwide are eyeballing coming here for a myriad of reasons. 

People were suggesting the same 10+ years ago - Pourcel, Searle, Rattray, Musquin and Roczen were the future. There has always been many young guys worldwide looking to race in the USA, but talent will continue to come through and MXGP will remain relevant. 

1
1
10/4/2024 6:54am
zehn wrote:

Define depth, because the American series are swimming in it right now with more coming soon on the horizon

64smoker wrote:
Depth ( depth of talent ) mx2 has 8-9 riders who can win all under the age of 23 .  Mx1 similar Herlings prado Febvre Gajser seewer...

Depth ( depth of talent ) mx2 has 8-9 riders who can win all under the age of 23 . 
 Mx1 similar Herlings prado Febvre Gajser seewer vlanderen Renaux can all win a race , tell me that’s not depth 

soggy wrote:
That’s called parody.  You can’t have depth when you have less then 20 riders on the gate some races. USA has depth top to bottom. MXGP is...

That’s called parody.  You can’t have depth when you have less then 20 riders on the gate some races. 

USA has depth top to bottom. MXGP is top loaded. 

Kullas and Butron have highlighted over the last couple of years, the Nationals doesn't have top to bottom depth. 

2
3
TeamGreen
Posts
37086
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
10/4/2024 7:01am

Questions for the gallery:

Did Kullas improve while over here racing weekly and having more local tracks/variations of tracks available to practice at? 

Is he happier and/or making money over here?

 

2
10/4/2024 7:09am
TeamGreen wrote:
Questions for the gallery:Did Kullas improve while over here racing weekly and having more local tracks/variations of tracks available to practice at? Is he happier and/or making...

Questions for the gallery:

Did Kullas improve while over here racing weekly and having more local tracks/variations of tracks available to practice at? 

Is he happier and/or making money over here?

 

In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has to be happier, he's still able to make money racing a dirt bike... but anyone suggesting there's top to bottom depth is high.

2
2
soggy
Posts
8754
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
10/4/2024 7:18am
TeamGreen wrote:
Questions for the gallery:Did Kullas improve while over here racing weekly and having more local tracks/variations of tracks available to practice at? Is he happier and/or making...

Questions for the gallery:

Did Kullas improve while over here racing weekly and having more local tracks/variations of tracks available to practice at? 

Is he happier and/or making money over here?

 

In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has...

In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has to be happier, he's still able to make money racing a dirt bike... but anyone suggesting there's top to bottom depth is high.

If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. 

If you were to ask any young mxgp rider all things being equal would they rather race mxgp or the US SX and MX series most are going to choose the US. Proof is in the pudding. 

2
2
10/4/2024 7:21am Edited Date/Time 10/4/2024 7:31am
TeamGreen wrote:
Questions for the gallery:Did Kullas improve while over here racing weekly and having more local tracks/variations of tracks available to practice at? Is he happier and/or making...

Questions for the gallery:

Did Kullas improve while over here racing weekly and having more local tracks/variations of tracks available to practice at? 

Is he happier and/or making money over here?

 

In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has...

In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has to be happier, he's still able to make money racing a dirt bike... but anyone suggesting there's top to bottom depth is high.

soggy wrote:
If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. If you were to ask any...

If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. 

If you were to ask any young mxgp rider all things being equal would they rather race mxgp or the US SX and MX series most are going to choose the US. Proof is in the pudding. 

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two MXGPs is twisting facts to suit your agenda! I'm not disputing the "proof in the pudding", but suggesting the Nationals have top to bottom depth is complete bollocks - those between 30th-40th are a hazard for the likes of Sexton, in the same way the locals are in Indonesia for Herlings.

1
2
Press516
Posts
5729
Joined
9/11/2018
Location
Gilbert, AZ, USA
Fantasy
10/4/2024 7:33am
In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has...

In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has to be happier, he's still able to make money racing a dirt bike... but anyone suggesting there's top to bottom depth is high.

soggy wrote:
If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. If you were to ask any...

If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. 

If you were to ask any young mxgp rider all things being equal would they rather race mxgp or the US SX and MX series most are going to choose the US. Proof is in the pudding. 

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two...

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two MXGPs is twisting facts to suit your agenda! I'm not disputing the "proof in the pudding", but suggesting the Nationals have top to bottom depth is complete bollocks - those between 30th-40th are a hazard for the likes of Sexton, in the same way the locals are in Indonesia for Herlings.

So the only relevant number of races to compare is the one that makes your argument work?  Got it.  

10/4/2024 7:46am
soggy wrote:
If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. If you were to ask any...

If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. 

If you were to ask any young mxgp rider all things being equal would they rather race mxgp or the US SX and MX series most are going to choose the US. Proof is in the pudding. 

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two...

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two MXGPs is twisting facts to suit your agenda! I'm not disputing the "proof in the pudding", but suggesting the Nationals have top to bottom depth is complete bollocks - those between 30th-40th are a hazard for the likes of Sexton, in the same way the locals are in Indonesia for Herlings.

Press516 wrote:

So the only relevant number of races to compare is the one that makes your argument work?  Got it.  

Why use a sample size of two races, when you can use the last 12 races. The data is there, use it! The reality is, over 32 MXGPs, Kullas has scored 7 points on average. Through 12 Nationals, he's averaged 19 points. Seems like he's found it easier

2
TeamGreen
Posts
37086
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
10/4/2024 7:47am
In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has...

In the twilight of his career, he has averaged 19 points per National. Through his MXGP career, 7 points per GP (without full gates!). He has to be happier, he's still able to make money racing a dirt bike... but anyone suggesting there's top to bottom depth is high.

soggy wrote:
If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. If you were to ask any...

If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. 

If you were to ask any young mxgp rider all things being equal would they rather race mxgp or the US SX and MX series most are going to choose the US. Proof is in the pudding. 

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two...

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two MXGPs is twisting facts to suit your agenda! I'm not disputing the "proof in the pudding", but suggesting the Nationals have top to bottom depth is complete bollocks - those between 30th-40th are a hazard for the likes of Sexton, in the same way the locals are in Indonesia for Herlings.

I get the feeling you're not "doing the math"...hence, Statistical Analysis...etc. 

If you're saying the US field isn't deep? Again...you might wanna quit throwing around the commentary about who is high or not. 

Are you aware of how many riders are competing for one of those 40 gates on any given Saturday at our nationals?  

(Let's take a look, shall we...?) Example: Washougal...69 Qualifiers 

How many competitive racers at the top/competing for podiums...? Five...Sexton, Plessinger, Anderson, H Lawrence, Cooper...

And, again, that's in 2 Motos with 40 riders. 

Later in the season we got Jett back...and we had 6 riders competing for the podium...and, again, FORTY riders out on the track...in each moto. 

1
4
10/4/2024 7:56am
soggy wrote:
If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. If you were to ask any...

If you look at his recent mxgp results they are pretty much in line with where he finishes in the US. 

If you were to ask any young mxgp rider all things being equal would they rather race mxgp or the US SX and MX series most are going to choose the US. Proof is in the pudding. 

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two...

Take the last 12 Nationals he has raced versus the last 12 MXGPs and it is clear where Kullas has struggled more. Taking his last two MXGPs is twisting facts to suit your agenda! I'm not disputing the "proof in the pudding", but suggesting the Nationals have top to bottom depth is complete bollocks - those between 30th-40th are a hazard for the likes of Sexton, in the same way the locals are in Indonesia for Herlings.

TeamGreen wrote:
I get the feeling you're not "doing the math"...hence, Statistical Analysis...etc. If you're saying the US field isn't deep? Again...you might wanna quit throwing around the commentary...

I get the feeling you're not "doing the math"...hence, Statistical Analysis...etc. 

If you're saying the US field isn't deep? Again...you might wanna quit throwing around the commentary about who is high or not. 

Are you aware of how many riders are competing for one of those 40 gates on any given Saturday at our nationals?  

(Let's take a look, shall we...?) Example: Washougal...69 Qualifiers 

How many competitive racers at the top/competing for podiums...? Five...Sexton, Plessinger, Anderson, H Lawrence, Cooper...

And, again, that's in 2 Motos with 40 riders. 

Later in the season we got Jett back...and we had 6 riders competing for the podium...and, again, FORTY riders out on the track...in each moto. 

There's a difference between quality and quantity. 

3
2
stimacr
Posts
105
Joined
11/13/2021
Location
Durango, CO, USA
10/4/2024 7:58am

Everyone saying Lawerence were lost to the us, but jett only raced the EMX one season and hunter race mx2 2x seasons but its not like they were from europe in the first place they're free agents and either way are far away from home. The US is probably closer feeling to AUS than being based in the EU I am not surprised they left for something that is more familiar. 

 

On another note, I think a lot of people just want to race SX, you get paid better you get to go to cities not some random field somewhere. I think this has much more to do with people wanting to move than anything else.

4

Post a reply to: Is the USA on the verge of becoming the only relevant series?

The Latest