Favorite Torque Wrench?

Chance1216
Posts
8501
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA US

Like the title says, what’s your favorite torque wrench. 
Proto, EPAuto, Snap On, Craftsman, Icon? 

I’m in need of a new one and, curious what the Vital experts have to say. No, that’s not sarcasm. Some people say, Icon (Harbor Fright) is just as accurate as a higher quality brand. 

Mods, I figured since I’m inquiring about tools used for working on bikes this would be Moto Related. 
If I’m wrong, please move it to the appropriate section. 
 

Once again, thanks fellas. 
 

 

1
|
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
1/15/2024 10:08pm Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 10:09pm

image-20240115220656-1

 

....but seriously.  I've got a digital Sears Craftsmen torque wrench I bought back in 1992, it has served me well.   

I use some HF tools too and have  never had any issues.

Get ready for the tool-snob responses.   

9
5
Chance1216
Posts
8501
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA US
1/15/2024 10:13pm
Magoofan wrote:
      ....but seriously.  I've got a digital Sears Craftsmen torque wrench I bought back in 1992, it has served me well.    I use...

image-20240115220656-1

 

....but seriously.  I've got a digital Sears Craftsmen torque wrench I bought back in 1992, it has served me well.   

I use some HF tools too and have  never had any issues.

Get ready for the tool-snob responses.   

I have a 48” pipe wrench. Is that enough for my seat bolts? Woohoo

4
martymac
Posts
36
Joined
10/17/2018
Location
AU
1/15/2024 11:42pm

Not sure if they sell them in the states, but in Australia Warren & Brown is the go. Also cat branded ones are good quality, as in Caterpillar earthmoving machinery brand.

1
race
Posts
3480
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
CA US
1/16/2024 12:09am

If you're going to use it on mtb bikes might want to invest in one that clicks in reverse. Funny story - in one of the e-mtb bike Facebook groups I'm on ( Trek Rail Owners World Wide ) there must have been over a dozen posts about owners snapping the UDH - Universal Derailleur Hanger. They all said they had been careful but the part snapped before they even clicked to the recommended 25Nm per the manual. BTW - the part is reverse thread! Someone eventually asked if their wrenches clicked in reverse ... you could hear the face palms going off. lol

2

The Shop

MKMX
Posts
493
Joined
3/3/2021
Location
Timbuktu, WA AU
1/16/2024 12:40am

The Cat ones mentioned above are manufactured by Snap-On. It’s a great way to save $ by buying the Cat branded ones as they’re much cheaper!

 

I personally use Snap-On and Norbar.

1/16/2024 1:33am

I got this 3/8 Snap On wrench off of EBay, stole it off the guy. Bid was starting at £175, I bid £250 at the dying seconds & I got it for the £175. Brand new in the box. 
 

https://shop.snapon.com/product/US-Torque-Instruments%3A-Dual-Scale-(ft-lb-N·m)/3-8%22-Drive-SAE-Adjustable-Click-Type-Fixed-Ratchet-Torque-Wrench-(20–100-ft-lb)/QD2R100A

sandtrack315
Posts
2834
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA US
1/16/2024 1:46am

CDI Torque 2502MRMH 3/8-Inch Drive Metal Handle Click Type Torque Wrench, Torque Range 30 to 250-Inc https://a.co/d/alv7BaW

3
cwel11
Posts
2643
Joined
12/4/2019
Location
Orangeville, PA US
1/16/2024 3:01am

Have the icon digital in 3/8 and 1/2. Nothing has come loose or been too tight upon disassembly so theres that. Think you’d be fine for basic bike stuff. Inside motor stuff may want to double check against a proven calibrated one first.

 

Donk122
Posts
127
Joined
2/24/2008
Location
CA
1/16/2024 3:04am

I've been a moto mechanic for 20+ years. My dad was a Truck mechanic and owned his own shop etc etc so I've had tools in my hands from a young age. I was brought up to believe Snap on/Mac was the only tools you trust, in which my boxes have several of each brand. Back in the day that statement was true... but there are plenty of quality tools out there now. I bought a 3/8 drive Icon click torque wrench from HF a while ago. I like it, haven't had any issues with it. I've done my own comparisons with my digital snap on to it and it seems equal. Had it tested on the snap on truck and it checks out the same as both my click and digital Snap on torque wrenches. I know there are other brands out there that are just as good quality as well. 

4
1/16/2024 4:34am

Mac tools for me personally 

1/16/2024 4:40am

If I could afford a Snap-On or Mac I would, but I've been using the same 3 Craftsman torque wrenches for almost 20 years. I'm assuming they are accurate as I haven't had any issues? *knocks on wood*

1
PNWMXer
Posts
1744
Joined
1/13/2022
Location
Washington, WA US
1/16/2024 4:56am

I have a 1/2” and 3/8” Craftsman digital wrenches, as well as 1/2” and 1/4” click-type. I thought I’d like the digital but I’m not totally sold on them (seems easier to overshoot your target). Other than that I’ve been pretty happy with them. The 1/4” is great for cam caps and other low-torque fasteners. 
 

Something I heard awhile back is that like a tire gauge, torque wrenches are most accurate near the middle of their torque range and least towards the ends. Hopefully someone will chime in to confirm or dispel this.

 

1
Johnnydirt
Posts
246
Joined
4/23/2021
Location
NY, NY US
1/16/2024 5:36am

Check out precision instruments made in USA.  I have there 1/4” and 3/8”.  1/2” I have a U.S. made craftsman.  I believe precision used to make them for snap on before CDI.  

https://torqwrench.com
 

3
OneZeroFive
Posts
70
Joined
12/7/2022
Location
Pleasant Hill, CA US
1/16/2024 6:01am

I use a Snap On digital torque wrench. Only Snap On product I own, but was worth the splurge.

2
forensic
Posts
117
Joined
12/3/2011
Location
Madison, WI US
1/16/2024 6:28am

I prefer click type over digital. There is a more clear and satisfying sensation when desired torque is reached IMO, where the digital wrenches start beeping faster and changing color approaching your target and it is easy to overshoot desired torque. I take batteries out of my digital ones after every use and one (CDI) requires a small screw to take the door on and off, so it's a PITA. The advantage the digital has over the click-type is you can see torque reading at any moment, but this is not all that important to most people and you can also do that with a dial-type.   

1
1
seth505
Posts
10183
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
SD, CA US
1/16/2024 6:35am

Digital Snap On, I don't really buy any of their other stuff but these are great. 

I have an older Craftsman (not digital) that is in fine shape also. If you want it let me know, I'll send it to you!

2
FasstCole
Posts
31
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
Washington, UT US
1/16/2024 7:05am
Zeke27G wrote:
  Hands down my favorite (spoke) torque wrench and I honestly don't know how the hell I survived without one in my toolbox.  [img]https://www.fasstco.com/cdn/shop/products/Untitled-191_750x.jpg?v=1669214363[/img] https://www.fasstco.com/products/spoke-torque-wrench?variant=39124559502

 

Hands down my favorite (spoke) torque wrench and I honestly don't know how the hell I survived without one in my toolbox. 

https://www.fasstco.com/products/spoke-torque-wrench?variant=39124559502

Thanks @Zeke! We at Fasst Company make that wrench completely in-house these days.  Originally CDI built it for us.  Currently all of our spoke torque wrenches are assembled and calibrated by two Loretta's champ Sophie Phelps who works for us while she's getting her engineering degree.  

17
1/16/2024 7:23am

Just picked up a LEXIVON  torque wrench 5-6 months ago.   I’m rather surprised by the quality, seems bulletproof so far .  Great buy, good reputation,  not pricey at all like snap on or Mac 

1
m21racing
Posts
649
Joined
7/19/2016
Location
Reno, NV US
1/16/2024 8:17am

This for base/mid speed nuts.20240116 081550

1
jaredkeller96
Posts
503
Joined
11/8/2015
Location
Huntersville, NC US
1/16/2024 8:43am

Nothing beats tohnichi. And can get them cheap from Amazon JP. With the USD/Yen. 

ricko
Posts
737
Joined
9/6/2011
Location
bfe, PA US
Fantasy
1/16/2024 9:01am

I am partial to my snap-on's but there not really justifiable anymore, the price skyrocketed these last few years. I bought before the increase. 

 

image-20240116120019-1

2
CR92
Posts
597
Joined
1/27/2010
Location
Beaverton, OR US
Fantasy
1/16/2024 9:07am

Not sure if anyone else on here watched this channel, but I like what this guy does to test a bunch of different brands of torque wrenches. Might be worth a watch before choosing which one to buy.  

 

 

9
Moto520
Posts
3632
Joined
2/4/2013
Location
Schaumburg, IL US
1/16/2024 9:29am

I like the CRaftsman Digi-click.   I have a couple different torque wrenches but i keep going back to the Digi-Click.  

HuskyEd
Posts
5201
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Palmdale, CA US
1/16/2024 9:55am
CR92 wrote:
Not sure if anyone else on here watched this channel, but I like what this guy does to test a bunch of different brands of torque...

Not sure if anyone else on here watched this channel, but I like what this guy does to test a bunch of different brands of torque wrenches. Might be worth a watch before choosing which one to buy.  

 

 

Project Farm and The Torque Test Channel are two of YouTubes finest channels.

7
Falcon
Posts
12318
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
1/16/2024 10:02am
race wrote:
If you're going to use it on mtb bikes might want to invest in one that clicks in reverse. Funny story - in one of the...

If you're going to use it on mtb bikes might want to invest in one that clicks in reverse. Funny story - in one of the e-mtb bike Facebook groups I'm on ( Trek Rail Owners World Wide ) there must have been over a dozen posts about owners snapping the UDH - Universal Derailleur Hanger. They all said they had been careful but the part snapped before they even clicked to the recommended 25Nm per the manual. BTW - the part is reverse thread! Someone eventually asked if their wrenches clicked in reverse ... you could hear the face palms going off. lol

I almost destroyed my MTB forks because the torque reading for the axle is in inch-pounds. I almost tightened the thing to 80 lb./ft! From now on, I'm measuring in N-M. 

slowgti
Posts
1006
Joined
1/14/2016
Location
Monroe, GA US
1/16/2024 10:23am

I’ve got a couple older Proto brand wrenches I use. I like the click style but have a couple dial type for setting bearing torque on automotive rear diffs. 
 

Luckily I have a friend that works for an airline in the metrology lab and I get them checked every year or so. The Proto wrenches are within the stated tollerence every time he checks them. 

2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA US
1/16/2024 10:28am

Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of spec. 

 

1
3

Post a reply to: Favorite Torque Wrench?

The Latest