SX should not race in mud like THAT.

ga_pike
Posts
2650
Joined
7/14/2011
Location
Valdosta, GA, USA
1/14/2024 10:00am

So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.  

 

That said, I didn't really enjoy last night's race.  I almost wonder if the racers today are not as adept in bad conditions for some reason.  

2
3
mvd61
Posts
1303
Joined
10/15/2021
Location
Brandon, SD, USA
1/14/2024 10:15am

Sounds like there’s a bunch of Sally’s in here who have never raced a real mudder so they don’t have any appreciation for how hard that track was to navigate. Lots of strings hanging out…

7
2
Brad460
Posts
4496
Joined
5/15/2012
Location
Richfield, WI, USA
Fantasy
1/14/2024 11:08am

Race is on NBC right now…

sandtrack315
Posts
2850
Joined
7/19/2013
Location
Philadelphia, PA, USA
1/14/2024 11:54am

Outdoor stadiums in rainy areas should source more sand.

2
2

The Shop

1/14/2024 11:57am
Gator724 wrote:

Been here for years. Other account got banned by guyb 

I am sure you were banned for a reason. My guess is stupidity. Evil

3
3
Brad460
Posts
4496
Joined
5/15/2012
Location
Richfield, WI, USA
Fantasy
1/14/2024 12:13pm Edited Date/Time 1/14/2024 12:13pm
Gator724 wrote:

Been here for years. Other account got banned by guyb 

lostboy819 wrote:
I am sure you were banned for a reason. My guess is stupidity. 

I am sure you were banned for a reason. My guess is stupidity. Evil

Guyb banned for lame reasons, so this is not a good argument ..

1
5
byke
Posts
3083
Joined
8/12/2015
Location
Auburn, CA, USA
1/14/2024 12:15pm Edited Date/Time 1/14/2024 12:16pm

I love a mudder and want to see at least one every season. And it's the same reason why we have multiple rounds and why they don't make the tracks the same for every round, because the widest variety of conditions is how you find out who the best rider is, which is the purpose of racing. 

5
1
1/14/2024 12:19pm
Gator724 wrote:

Been here for years. Other account got banned by guyb 

lostboy819 wrote:
I am sure you were banned for a reason. My guess is stupidity. 

I am sure you were banned for a reason. My guess is stupidity. Evil

Brad460 wrote:

Guyb banned for lame reasons, so this is not a good argument ..

Yes that is true, but the stupidity part has been established by his thread. Cool

2
3
mxracer666
Posts
781
Joined
10/28/2010
Location
NE Iowa, IA, USA
1/14/2024 12:24pm
Boomslang wrote:
I got up at 02h45 to watch live....I was falling asleep but somehow pulled through that shit show...it really sucked. Glad it's over and San Diego...

I got up at 02h45 to watch live....I was falling asleep but somehow pulled through that shit show...it really sucked. Glad it's over and San Diego will make up for it. Always good racing there.

sumdood wrote:
Extended forecast for next weekend, the weathermen are usually a little off on the timing, we shall see 😂

Extended forecast for next weekend, the weathermen are usually a little off on the timing, we shall see 😂

D64ABAC1-3410-40B3-B7AD-E5DBE78B5BB9.png?VersionId=mMKAeqa0T5tAOWCLasKrkOq

Boomslang wrote:

Please don't jinx us bud. One Mud race was enough...

"Always good racing in San Diego" ?   Remember Lime-gate?!

3
1/14/2024 1:06pm

There are 10 covered NFL stadiums in the US along with 8 MLB stadiums. Yes, hardcore racers will ride in anything, it's part of the roots of the sport, etc. But a SX mudder like this is usually a snoozer. And the AMA/Feld appear to be making a big push to grow the sport / viewership, yet what was on TV last night absolutely won't do that. Most fans are invested in the points chase and their favorite riders, but the average viewer might be more interested in a KTM mini race than a 10 mph 450 slopfest.

Oakland was cancelled last year due to rain, and San Fran got unlucky again this year. Obviously weather is generally unpredictable, but scheduling a Bay Area race in mid-January needs a re-think. Personally I don't care much about bringing in casual fans, just want to see good racing.

7
4
TeamGreen
Posts
37259
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
1/14/2024 1:11pm

It really does not matter that we call it Supercross; because, it’s still just a motocross race. A race that’s raced by competitors on…

“DIRT BIKES”…aka Off-Road Racing Motorcycles…”Motocross Bikes”…etc., etc., etc.

Now that we’ve established those facts…

Let’s be real, the bikes are actually designed to be raced in that soup we call mud that was in the stadium last night.
How many of the bikes finished last night’s program…? 
How many racers that started the night program and qualified for the mains finished last night’s program? 
So…it seems to me the race was a success and it will be remembered as just another mud race. 

12
3
Brad460
Posts
4496
Joined
5/15/2012
Location
Richfield, WI, USA
Fantasy
1/14/2024 1:18pm

My preference is there are no mud SX races, however I do like how unpredictable they are. It’s a shame the mud races trash the privateer bikes (bigger dealer than most will admit too)..

I don’t think the mud separate the boys from the men nor does it expose some special skill. I think there is a lot of luck at play here..

 

5
Chris_Buehler
Posts
8500
Joined
7/21/2019
Location
PORTLAND, CT, USA
1/14/2024 1:56pm
byke wrote:
I love a mudder and want to see at least one every season. And it's the same reason why we have multiple rounds and why they...

I love a mudder and want to see at least one every season. And it's the same reason why we have multiple rounds and why they don't make the tracks the same for every round, because the widest variety of conditions is how you find out who the best rider is, which is the purpose of racing. 

I don't know if I WANT to see one but it does throw some adversity at the riders. That was beyond a normal mudder though. The riders were all saying how brutal it was. They all had to race the same track though. 

1
aees
Posts
2807
Joined
8/20/2015
Location
USA
1/14/2024 2:32pm

The mud separates the men from the boys.its always good racing and shows a riders skill.

No it does not. The amount of luck involved is ridiculous. Just lock at the results 😂

Shimoda, Vohland, Trasher is by your standard worse riders than Yoder.

Mcelrath almost on the podium. You see that happening often this year? 

A little bit of wet or muddy conditions ok, if they can jump pretty much all the jumps. Most riders had wheels on ground in the finals yesterday. You think that is supercross?

1
11
aees
Posts
2807
Joined
8/20/2015
Location
USA
1/14/2024 2:47pm
byke wrote:
I love a mudder and want to see at least one every season. And it's the same reason why we have multiple rounds and why they...

I love a mudder and want to see at least one every season. And it's the same reason why we have multiple rounds and why they don't make the tracks the same for every round, because the widest variety of conditions is how you find out who the best rider is, which is the purpose of racing. 

There is no supercross over two finals with wheels on the ground for all jumps but one small. That's supermotard and not what we signed up for here.

4
zehn
Posts
7891
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK, USA
1/14/2024 3:15pm Edited Date/Time 1/14/2024 3:16pm

What’s funny to me is that the jumps actually turn in obstacles in mud races like that i.e. some that slows or impedes or prevents progress

1
kijen
Posts
1229
Joined
10/1/2010
Location
Jacksonville, FL, USA
1/14/2024 3:38pm
kijen wrote:

Curious the height of the ridets and how that played out in the results, wpild think the shorter guys would really struggle, on average.

Have you told RC that?

Did he race last night? Or was he too busy pushing a 50 or 100lb wheel barrow?

 

2
1
FLmxer
Posts
7310
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
SouthWest, FL, USA
Fantasy
1/14/2024 7:58pm

It was wild to see who could navigate the track in those conditions.  I sometimes stare at my phone while watching but I watched every second of that carnage. 1 a year is great IMHO. The dnfs suck but the anticipation of who makes it to the checkers is exciting and creates a lot of crazy scenarios for the rest of the season. Even though I love huge jumps I enjoyed racing in the mud once in awhile and actually kind of felt safer and more relaxed. 

5
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
1/14/2024 9:11pm
Chance1216 wrote:
I just feel bad for the privateers without the big budgets destroying their bikes. Besides that, mud makes it interesting and, unpredictable. Look how well McElrath...

I just feel bad for the privateers without the big budgets destroying their bikes. Besides that, mud makes it interesting and, unpredictable. Look how well McElrath did tonight. 

JB 19 wrote:

You realize that sometimes amateur GNCC racers do this for 2-3 hours for weeks in a row sometimes right?   I think everyone will be ok.  

Regardless of who’s choice it is to be out there in the elements, the excess wear and, tear sucks for everybody. 

1
1/14/2024 9:35pm
Magoofan wrote:

There's the door....don't let it hit you on the ass on the way out....

SX_336 wrote:
 That’s a bullshit response. He has a legitimate point.    3 riders had their seasons wrecked last night because of weather and their bikes dying. Not...

 That’s a bullshit response. He has a legitimate point. 
 

3 riders had their seasons wrecked last night because of weather and their bikes dying. Not because they fucked up. Mechanicals happen enough in normal conditions. Feld shouldn’t be compounding the probability. 
 

Feld are morons for scheduling anything in San Fran/Oakland in January. Why we have to have 4 rounds in CA within 300 miles of each other is beyond me. 
 

I guarantee if you did a poll with the fans they would rather see a normal condition SX race rather than watch a shit race like the one we saw last night. It’s like watching a D Class professional race as they can’t jump anything. 
 

 

Shimoda is fucked. Their season is not long enough to make up the point deficit. Really a shit deal.

I still say the 250 class should be 17 rounds.

2
1
Tumic
Posts
2833
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall, SE
1/14/2024 10:57pm
aees wrote:
No it does not. The amount of luck involved is ridiculous. Just lock at the results 😂 Shimoda, Vohland, Trasher is by your standard worse riders...

No it does not. The amount of luck involved is ridiculous. Just lock at the results 😂

Shimoda, Vohland, Trasher is by your standard worse riders than Yoder.

Mcelrath almost on the podium. You see that happening often this year? 

A little bit of wet or muddy conditions ok, if they can jump pretty much all the jumps. Most riders had wheels on ground in the finals yesterday. You think that is supercross?

Stop calling it luck. Shimoda crashed and thatcould have caused the bike problem. Vohland raped the clutch the same way Tomac has done it before and fried the bike.

The mud races takes skill to go fast and navigate the track in bad conditions.

And thanks to high compression race engines they become more fragile in the mud than a stock engine so the riders have to take care of the engine to.

 

So those things is not luck. BUT i would not say the RACING was great. Racing for me is when people switch places. Racing the other riders and the track, not rolling around trying to survive and then in the middle of it passes a guy that has stoped, tipped over or the bike has died.

 

1
Sully
Posts
9446
Joined
8/24/2006
Location
JP
1/14/2024 11:57pm

I’m so confused; do we not like a track where everyone does the same rhythm sections exactly the same, or do we not like a track that challenges the best riders in the world?

4
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
1/15/2024 12:00am
Sully wrote:
I’m so confused; do we not like a track where everyone does the same rhythm sections exactly the same, or do we not like a track...

I’m so confused; do we not like a track where everyone does the same rhythm sections exactly the same, or do we not like a track that challenges the best riders in the world?

Went from crying about no racing, how they’re racing to, the mud they’re racing in. 
Wonder what’s next. 

3
1
1/15/2024 12:13am

they should remove most of the jumps when they see it will be a shit show.. It would be better racing with less jumps when it is a muddy mess like this weekend. The riders would have more speed and make more passes and make better racing..

Now they just sit down and follow the ruts in between the jumps mostly and it's just boring to watch.

2
1
Sully
Posts
9446
Joined
8/24/2006
Location
JP
1/15/2024 12:36am
mx4all wrote:
they should remove most of the jumps when they see it will be a shit show.. It would be better racing with less jumps when it...

they should remove most of the jumps when they see it will be a shit show.. It would be better racing with less jumps when it is a muddy mess like this weekend. The riders would have more speed and make more passes and make better racing..

Now they just sit down and follow the ruts in between the jumps mostly and it's just boring to watch.

They chopped the triples down to doubles and cut a bunch of the jumps from the rhythm section.  They have to keep some shit out there, though, otherwise it’s just speedway racing in the mud.  

2
1/15/2024 12:58am

As always everyone has to race the same conditions, that said mudders especially in SX is like a coin flip, I feel for the guys who DNF due to bike or the conditions especially in 250's, 450's well it made the chase a lot more interesting and close that doesn't change the fact the racing was pure shit, my partner who wants to commit to her first SX season couldn't even watch it.

Anyway it couldn't have been avoided due to stadium, lets hope the rest of it is dry.

Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
1/15/2024 1:06am Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 1:08am
mx4all wrote:
they should remove most of the jumps when they see it will be a shit show.. It would be better racing with less jumps when it...

they should remove most of the jumps when they see it will be a shit show.. It would be better racing with less jumps when it is a muddy mess like this weekend. The riders would have more speed and make more passes and make better racing..

Now they just sit down and follow the ruts in between the jumps mostly and it's just boring to watch.

Sully wrote:
They chopped the triples down to doubles and cut a bunch of the jumps from the rhythm section.  They have to keep some shit out there...

They chopped the triples down to doubles and cut a bunch of the jumps from the rhythm section.  They have to keep some shit out there, though, otherwise it’s just speedway racing in the mud.  

Let’s just ask for a flat, figure 8 track 😂

 

2
1
WCRider
Posts
3129
Joined
8/19/2017
Location
BE
1/15/2024 1:16am

You should not training too much on groomed tracks bud. 

CPR
Posts
6989
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/15/2024 1:30am
mx4all wrote:
they should remove most of the jumps when they see it will be a shit show.. It would be better racing with less jumps when it...

they should remove most of the jumps when they see it will be a shit show.. It would be better racing with less jumps when it is a muddy mess like this weekend. The riders would have more speed and make more passes and make better racing..

Now they just sit down and follow the ruts in between the jumps mostly and it's just boring to watch.

Sully wrote:
They chopped the triples down to doubles and cut a bunch of the jumps from the rhythm section.  They have to keep some shit out there...

They chopped the triples down to doubles and cut a bunch of the jumps from the rhythm section.  They have to keep some shit out there, though, otherwise it’s just speedway racing in the mud.  

Chance1216 wrote:

Let’s just ask for a flat, figure 8 track 😂

 

My money would be on Friese.

2
1
RG437
Posts
368
Joined
2/5/2023
Location
Leicester, GB
1/15/2024 1:48am
zehn wrote:

What’s funny to me is that the jumps actually turn in obstacles in mud races like that i.e. some that slows or impedes or prevents progress

Prado actually mentioned that in his post race interview with Vital. Said riding SX in the mud was much different and more difficult than riding outdoors as the track is so tight with so many obstacles that it’s almost impossible to build any momentum. 

Post a reply to: SX should not race in mud like THAT.

The Latest