Question: Can factory teams add an electric start to a bike?

reynardfan1
Posts
825
Joined
7/28/2014
Location
Gretna, NE, USA

Or is it too much if a modification? Rules?

anyone know? 
 

this kickstarter discussion is getting old, but it does have validity…ever tried to kick a hot 450 that’s been laying on its side for 30 seconds while you gathered your bones? 

4
5
|
Motofinne
Posts
11567
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
FI
12/8/2022 6:02am Edited Date/Time 12/8/2022 6:09am

I assume we're talking about Suzuki. It would require changes to the cases so i don't think they could (you aren't allowed to make major case changes except adding material?). Or somehow use the RMX engine, which has the e-start.

1
ML512
Posts
17043
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
Fantasy
12/8/2022 6:05am

Yes, they could add it.

19
1
12/8/2022 6:07am
Or is it too much if a modification? Rules? anyone know?    this kickstarter discussion is getting old, but it does have validity…ever tried to kick...

Or is it too much if a modification? Rules?

anyone know? 
 

this kickstarter discussion is getting old, but it does have validity…ever tried to kick a hot 450 that’s been laying on its side for 30 seconds while you gathered your bones? 

Yeah, starts right up 

3
5
Motofinne
Posts
11567
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
FI
12/8/2022 6:09am
ML512 wrote:

Yes, they could add it.

Can you elaborate on how and would the rules support it? I thought the cases needed to be stock except you could add material?

1
2

The Shop

12/8/2022 6:22am

Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes it's going to be the end of the world, it's not. I'd be more concerned about the time lost because of the actual crash itself vs starting the bike back up.

Someone had made an intelligent comment that perhaps running a Rekluse clutch may solve any potential handicap. That may be a viable option.

Anyway, I think Kenny is going to be just fine and I wish him the best.

27
lumpy790
Posts
11740
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
12/8/2022 6:23am

Suzuki has probably been working on adding a whole new design with a E start for years so there could be a 2023 RMZ 250/450 factory edition to liven things up.

4
12/8/2022 6:31am
Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes...

Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes it's going to be the end of the world, it's not. I'd be more concerned about the time lost because of the actual crash itself vs starting the bike back up.

Someone had made an intelligent comment that perhaps running a Rekluse clutch may solve any potential handicap. That may be a viable option.

Anyway, I think Kenny is going to be just fine and I wish him the best.

The OP also said “laying on its side for 30 seconds” guy, 30 seconds on the ground, race over 

6
1
Crush
Posts
21135
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
12/8/2022 6:36am

Don't the cases have to be stock?

1
1
ML512
Posts
17043
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
Fantasy
12/8/2022 6:39am
Crush wrote:

Don't the cases have to be stock?

They have to start with stock cases but there's quite a few modifications certain teams do to their cases. Oil pickup lines for oil coolers, re-machining the insides for different bearings, adding in certain sensor areas if they aren't there in stock form.

1
12/8/2022 6:42am Edited Date/Time 12/8/2022 10:43am
Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes...

Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes it's going to be the end of the world, it's not. I'd be more concerned about the time lost because of the actual crash itself vs starting the bike back up.

Someone had made an intelligent comment that perhaps running a Rekluse clutch may solve any potential handicap. That may be a viable option.

Anyway, I think Kenny is going to be just fine and I wish him the best.

Makes you wonder how it was even possible for Tomac to win a national championship in 2018 and then Cianciarulo in 2019, both on kickstart bikes against nearly all electric-start competition. You would think it is a complete non-starter (pun fully intended).

29
pelosi826
Posts
67
Joined
12/5/2013
Location
Johnstown, NY, USA
12/8/2022 6:43am

I remember seeing a while back redneck Hubert build an E-Start RMZ 450 for Pastrana utilizing the RMX 450 set up.

5
reynardfan1
Posts
825
Joined
7/28/2014
Location
Gretna, NE, USA
12/8/2022 7:11am
Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes...

Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes it's going to be the end of the world, it's not. I'd be more concerned about the time lost because of the actual crash itself vs starting the bike back up.

Someone had made an intelligent comment that perhaps running a Rekluse clutch may solve any potential handicap. That may be a viable option.

Anyway, I think Kenny is going to be just fine and I wish him the best.

The OP also said “laying on its side for 30 seconds” guy, 30 seconds on the ground, race over 

Fair enough. And I agree he will be just fine. Yes there is too much being made of the Kickstarter. I actually agree. 
 

I was really just curious who knew about the rules or logistics for a factory team adding an e start. 
 

thought it might be a different angle than just ‘Suzukis suck’

I've ridden them for 20 years. 

4
1
12/8/2022 7:14am
Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes...

Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes it's going to be the end of the world, it's not. I'd be more concerned about the time lost because of the actual crash itself vs starting the bike back up.

Someone had made an intelligent comment that perhaps running a Rekluse clutch may solve any potential handicap. That may be a viable option.

Anyway, I think Kenny is going to be just fine and I wish him the best.

Makes you wonder how it was even possible for Tomac to win a national championship in 2018 and then Cianciarulo in 2019, both on kickstart bikes...

Makes you wonder how it was even possible for Tomac to win a national championship in 2018 and then Cianciarulo in 2019, both on kickstart bikes against nearly all electric-start competition. You would think it is a complete non-starter (pun fully intended).

THIS!! Excellent 'point'

12/8/2022 7:19am
Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes...

Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes it's going to be the end of the world, it's not. I'd be more concerned about the time lost because of the actual crash itself vs starting the bike back up.

Someone had made an intelligent comment that perhaps running a Rekluse clutch may solve any potential handicap. That may be a viable option.

Anyway, I think Kenny is going to be just fine and I wish him the best.

The OP also said “laying on its side for 30 seconds” guy, 30 seconds on the ground, race over 

Fair enough. And I agree he will be just fine. Yes there is too much being made of the Kickstarter. I actually agree.    I was...

Fair enough. And I agree he will be just fine. Yes there is too much being made of the Kickstarter. I actually agree. 
 

I was really just curious who knew about the rules or logistics for a factory team adding an e start. 
 

thought it might be a different angle than just ‘Suzukis suck’

I've ridden them for 20 years. 

Your question was totally valid, and I've wondered about it myself during the past couple of weeks with all the Suzuki talk. I hope I didn't come off like I was dumping on you (that was not my intent).

1
moto162
Posts
415
Joined
1/24/2022
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
12/8/2022 7:20am
Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes...

Man, does anyone else feel like there is way too much emphasis on the Suzuki not having an electric start? People chirping about when he crashes it's going to be the end of the world, it's not. I'd be more concerned about the time lost because of the actual crash itself vs starting the bike back up.

Someone had made an intelligent comment that perhaps running a Rekluse clutch may solve any potential handicap. That may be a viable option.

Anyway, I think Kenny is going to be just fine and I wish him the best.

Makes you wonder how it was even possible for Tomac to win a national championship in 2018 and then Cianciarulo in 2019, both on kickstart bikes...

Makes you wonder how it was even possible for Tomac to win a national championship in 2018 and then Cianciarulo in 2019, both on kickstart bikes against nearly all electric-start competition. You would think it is a complete non-starter (pun fully intended).

How about star wining all those titles on Kickstart 250fs in 16-18. I've had more people including myself ha e to push a bike back due to starter issues then Kickstart issues an that ruins a ride more often then Kickstart issues. This isn't the early 00's where 4 strokes were finicky to start when hot. Every single fully built 4 stroke I've had in the last 12 years still starts in 2-3 kicks when hot. I've crashed and gotten up and going just as fast as my electric start competition on quite a few occasions. In 2019 at monster mountain watched a guy from Michigan on a Honda crash hard due to the bike cutting out. It was a e start issue took 2 days to get parts. To lost days of riding. An another guy from Iowa on a ktm. Bike cut out due to a issue with the connections behind the front plate. Bike cut out over the back step up into ruts. That was a nasty crash. Electric start the most overhyped thing in our sport. 

8
1
reynardfan1
Posts
825
Joined
7/28/2014
Location
Gretna, NE, USA
12/8/2022 7:22am

The OP also said “laying on its side for 30 seconds” guy, 30 seconds on the ground, race over 

Fair enough. And I agree he will be just fine. Yes there is too much being made of the Kickstarter. I actually agree.    I was...

Fair enough. And I agree he will be just fine. Yes there is too much being made of the Kickstarter. I actually agree. 
 

I was really just curious who knew about the rules or logistics for a factory team adding an e start. 
 

thought it might be a different angle than just ‘Suzukis suck’

I've ridden them for 20 years. 

Your question was totally valid, and I've wondered about it myself during the past couple of weeks with all the Suzuki talk. I hope I didn't...

Your question was totally valid, and I've wondered about it myself during the past couple of weeks with all the Suzuki talk. I hope I didn't come off like I was dumping on you (that was not my intent).

No it’s all good! I could have worded the OP differently…

I have had several Suzukis and only last year did an electric start ktm land in my garage and oh man it is a nice feature…

1
GPrider
Posts
811
Joined
4/10/2014
Location
La Mesa, CA, USA
12/8/2022 7:43am

first, all of the competition worthy of a title will have ES. So Roczen is at a disadvantage before the first gate drop of the year. When the title comes down to one or two points, it matters. All it takes is one tip over during the season when the bike does not fire up quickly and all the other guys go by you. Points go out the window and ya, it matters.

1
12
mxtech1
Posts
1968
Joined
7/21/2011
Location
Galesburg, IL, USA
12/8/2022 7:45am
ML512 wrote:
They have to start with stock cases but there's quite a few modifications certain teams do to their cases. Oil pickup lines for oil coolers, re-machining...

They have to start with stock cases but there's quite a few modifications certain teams do to their cases. Oil pickup lines for oil coolers, re-machining the insides for different bearings, adding in certain sensor areas if they aren't there in stock form.

What kind of sensors?

Frodad78
Posts
2155
Joined
1/11/2012
Location
USA
12/8/2022 7:51am

Do hot start kits work on FI fourstrokes like we used to put on our old air cooled 4 strokes?  I had an XR400 and 280 that would never start after a tip over. Hot start kit solved those issues, I have no idea how they work though I was pretty young at the time. 

Mr. Afterbar
Posts
2425
Joined
5/13/2019
Location
Green Bay, WI, USA
12/8/2022 8:01am
GPrider wrote:
first, all of the competition worthy of a title will have ES. So Roczen is at a disadvantage before the first gate drop of the year...

first, all of the competition worthy of a title will have ES. So Roczen is at a disadvantage before the first gate drop of the year. When the title comes down to one or two points, it matters. All it takes is one tip over during the season when the bike does not fire up quickly and all the other guys go by you. Points go out the window and ya, it matters.

Bikes sometimes don’t fire over quickly with electric start as well. You’re talking a matter of a couple seconds to restart the bike. We’ve seen people DNF races because of E start and that would be a much greater detriment to a championship run than a couple of lost seconds IF you crash and IF the bike stalls. 

4
mxrose3
Posts
2373
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Delmar, DE, USA
12/8/2022 8:41am
ML512 wrote:

Yes, they could add it.

ML, could they rob the cases from a RMX450 off road bike to make it work on the RMZ if they wanted to?

Jrey2
Posts
413
Joined
11/6/2022
Location
Big Pine Key, FL, USA
12/8/2022 8:46am

Yeah when you lay a bike over all the fuel drains out of the carb and... wait a minute.

5
12/8/2022 9:01am
GPrider wrote:
first, all of the competition worthy of a title will have ES. So Roczen is at a disadvantage before the first gate drop of the year...

first, all of the competition worthy of a title will have ES. So Roczen is at a disadvantage before the first gate drop of the year. When the title comes down to one or two points, it matters. All it takes is one tip over during the season when the bike does not fire up quickly and all the other guys go by you. Points go out the window and ya, it matters.

Bikes sometimes don’t fire over quickly with electric start as well. You’re talking a matter of a couple seconds to restart the bike. We’ve seen people...

Bikes sometimes don’t fire over quickly with electric start as well. You’re talking a matter of a couple seconds to restart the bike. We’ve seen people DNF races because of E start and that would be a much greater detriment to a championship run than a couple of lost seconds IF you crash and IF the bike stalls. 

Sexton's bike took a while to fire up after he and Eli came together and  both bikes stalled.  I remember wondering why Chase was just sitting there at the time. Then in an interview he said he was hitting the button and it was not starting.  Had Chase's bike fired right away he would have gotten past Eli before Eli got his bike going again.  I'm sure there have been some other times where electric starters  did not help get the bike started  much faster than a kickstart. But It also makes me wonder how much harder the bike might have been to start in a case like  when Chase and Eli came together .  I feel like these days the electric start is an advantage in a lot of cases and is proven enough that there are not a lot failing at the highest level of racing. Just the right kind of crash  and the electric start would be a big advantage and just the right electrical gremlin and the kickstart will have an advantage. I guess we will have to wait and see which types of issues Kenny runs into .  I am a fan of his, and I hope the best for him this year and that he is able to get  a  SX title.  I do not see the lack of electric start being as big of a disadvantage for a rider like Kenny as  it might be for others. When Kenny has a crash , it tends to throw him off for most of the day or night anyway. So those few seconds lost are not as likely to make a big  of an impact on his race  if he finds himself in a crash . A slight bobble in a corner that results in a stall , yes that could hurt him.  I could be forgetting examples of him charging through the pack after a big crash recently, but I feel like he tends to back it down after a crash. I totally understand ,after all he has been through why he's that way. I think if he can get a bike he is comfortable , being uncomfortable on he could win a lot. And i hope the lack of electric start is not  an issue for him. And who knows , maybe we will see a Kenny Edition RMZ, how cool would that be. I think its too late for that to happen but who knows.

1
aeffertz
Posts
12765
Joined
7/16/2015
Location
La Crosse, WI, USA
12/8/2022 9:06am

The video of the vital user starting his RMZ-450 with his hand recently should be a video posted in every thread when people start talking about the kickstarter. 

9
TeamGreen
Posts
37533
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
12/8/2022 9:22am

Well, as a guy that’s got pllllenty of hours on this very motorcycle…and some real success on the track form Day in the Dirt to Mammoth MX and even a few marathons and poker runs (off-road)…

I never had a race result affected by what type of starter it had.

Seldom, if ever, stalled it. 

COULD NOT understand the way many riders “wrote the RMZ off” during tests and shootouts. 

Was constantly surprised at it's amazing dependability and low operating cost(s) including EXTREMELY in-expensive mods…like…Running a Yosh pipe and VP fuel REALLY woke it up (white plug). Factory Connection Suspension made it a track-master. 

This bike, in the same form it’s been in since 2018, has proven to be competitive and I’m quite sure KR will prove that it will STILL be competitive in 2023. 

7
eddie
Posts
3020
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Bragg Creek, AB, CA
12/8/2022 9:28am

Most of you guys have never kick started a bike in the air and it shows … 

12
mikelawlor
Posts
176
Joined
12/4/2022
Location
Johnsonville, NY, USA
12/8/2022 12:00pm

Chad reed had it on his Yamaha before it came on them. His bike had hydraulic clutch on it then too as have the Hondas since 09. You can mod the cases. Also I think the rmz450x had the starter on the ignition cover so that wouldn’t be hard to do at all. 

Steve125
Posts
1414
Joined
11/24/2010
Location
USA
12/8/2022 3:15pm Edited Date/Time 12/8/2022 3:16pm

I raced an RMZ450 in 2019-2020 and after a position costly stall, I installed a Rekluse auto clutch (go ahead Flame me). I never worried about having to restart the bike again. 

Wasn't HEP sponsored by Rekluse at one point?

Only problem I ever had with the kickstart is when everyone was all jammed up tight to head out for practice and I didn't have room to swing out the 'ol dino-lever.

1
12/8/2022 5:15pm

Brayton used a kick starter on the Honda even when the e-start was stock.

1
stremme12
Posts
1220
Joined
3/10/2015
Location
HA, HI, USA
12/8/2022 5:17pm
MX Dad #27 wrote:

Brayton used a kick starter on the Honda even when the e-start was stock.

So did Roczen.

3

Post a reply to: Question: Can factory teams add an electric start to a bike?

The Latest