So, the Altitude at SLC.........Advantage Tomac?

KX500
Posts
282
Joined
8/30/2018
Location
Chester, IL, USA
Or will it not matter a bit?

I've always figured the guys who train in Florida were smart to do so from a heat/humidity worst case scenario - they aren't likely to race anywhere that will be worse.

Except that it can leave open the question of - how well do they deal with high altitude? But then the races at altitude are few & far between, right?

I personally have no experience with exerting myself to exhaustion, at high altitude.

I have seen seen several sporting events, though, where the commentators talked about it a lot (as in 'home' team is used to it, opponents aren't) and then late in the event, the opponents do look more gassed than the home team.

I'd imagine, in one SX event, altitude won't matter. But then 7 races in 21 days? That's a little different. Does it add up, considering recovery times & all?

So does it all result in a Tomac advantage, since he lives/trains at higher altitude?

Full, disclosure - I do want to see Tomac get an SX championship before he is done. But, I can say the exact same thing for Roczen too.
6
4
|
Alex814
Posts
1300
Joined
12/18/2014
Location
USA
5/17/2020 6:08am
Yes it's an advantage, but Roczen is still very capable of pulling this off at his level. Remember Baggett showing Tomac around the track at Thunder Valley in 2017?
7
5
Sully
Posts
9643
Joined
8/24/2006
Location
JP
5/17/2020 6:17am
Kenny beat Tomac at Thunder Valley (higher alt. than SLC) last year. I think they’ll all be fine.
6
1
Myke
Posts
2500
Joined
9/28/2009
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
5/17/2020 7:08am
It will probably be Anderson with the issue.
1
1
KMC440
Posts
7764
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
5/17/2020 7:14am
Anderson ... I hope he can make it through without any / much complications.
1
1

The Shop

kkawboy14
Posts
11486
Joined
6/5/2015
Location
USA
5/17/2020 7:18am
The 2 SX a week might be a bigger problem for some
2
1
KX500
Posts
282
Joined
8/30/2018
Location
Chester, IL, USA
5/17/2020 7:43am
I completely get that these are world class athletes and I'd be surprised to see any effects of high altitude in the 1st 2-3 races.

My question was more from a 7 races in 21 days perspective. My assumption is that even world class athletes, who don't live/train at high altitude, will need more than normal recovery time after a race before being ready to race again at high elevation. And instead, they race again in 3 days.

After they've done 3 races in 8 days, with shortened recovery time (when they needed extra recovery time), will it add up for some racers? Are they going to be lacking their normal stamina by races 5, 6, 7?

I'm just thinking of some brutal summer MX races, where a rider gives his all, does well, pukes when it's over and, when interviewed after the race the following weekend, says - yeah I over did it so much last weekend, that I couldn't get fully recovered this week, only able to ride 80-90% today.

I suppose it's just that the variables of A) 7 races/21 days and Cool all races at about 4300 ft, that have me wondering. Both things unprecedented and will probably come down to hindsight to know if either mattered.
4
1
mx1313
Posts
106
Joined
3/23/2020
Location
Dubuque, IA, USA
5/17/2020 8:05am
Anytime Eli swings a leg over a bike, it's advantage Tomac.
27
10
5/17/2020 8:18am Edited Date/Time 5/17/2020 8:19am
Is altitude really that big of a deal? I live at 6500' and all my tracks are pretty close to that. The lowest I go is Turkey, TX at 2400' and the only thing I notice is that I'll nearly flip my bike the first time I hammer the throttle. When I come home after a weekend, I'm not out of breath or anything once I'm back home.

When I go hunting, I'm up to 8500-9000' and don't really notice any difference except my legs are screaming but what do you expect when you hike up and down mountains all day long?

3
davis224
Posts
7610
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL, USA
5/17/2020 9:16am
Is altitude really that big of a deal? I live at 6500' and all my tracks are pretty close to that. The lowest I go is...
Is altitude really that big of a deal? I live at 6500' and all my tracks are pretty close to that. The lowest I go is Turkey, TX at 2400' and the only thing I notice is that I'll nearly flip my bike the first time I hammer the throttle. When I come home after a weekend, I'm not out of breath or anything once I'm back home.

When I go hunting, I'm up to 8500-9000' and don't really notice any difference except my legs are screaming but what do you expect when you hike up and down mountains all day long?

Your 2nd sentence says it. I live at around 300 ft, and drove out to Colorado, slept at 8000 ft, and tried to climb a small crest nearby the next morning and was struggling for breath big time, had to stop about every 20 feet or so. It got better after a couple days, but it is definitely a giant smack in the face if you aren't living in it.
8
Excaliburbmx
Posts
1868
Joined
6/21/2014
Location
Indianapolis, IN, USA
5/17/2020 9:24am
KX500 wrote:
I completely get that these are world class athletes and I'd be surprised to see any effects of high altitude in the 1st 2-3 races. My...
I completely get that these are world class athletes and I'd be surprised to see any effects of high altitude in the 1st 2-3 races.

My question was more from a 7 races in 21 days perspective. My assumption is that even world class athletes, who don't live/train at high altitude, will need more than normal recovery time after a race before being ready to race again at high elevation. And instead, they race again in 3 days.

After they've done 3 races in 8 days, with shortened recovery time (when they needed extra recovery time), will it add up for some racers? Are they going to be lacking their normal stamina by races 5, 6, 7?

I'm just thinking of some brutal summer MX races, where a rider gives his all, does well, pukes when it's over and, when interviewed after the race the following weekend, says - yeah I over did it so much last weekend, that I couldn't get fully recovered this week, only able to ride 80-90% today.

I suppose it's just that the variables of A) 7 races/21 days and Cool all races at about 4300 ft, that have me wondering. Both things unprecedented and will probably come down to hindsight to know if either mattered.
You seen affects of Roczen in heat and it took him two or three weeks to recover.

Anyone who wants to discredit or “asterisk “ this season is talking nonsense. This is going to be an unprecedented challenging season ever.
7
3
avidchimp
Posts
5875
Joined
7/9/2008
Location
EGL, MN, USA
5/17/2020 9:54am
davis224 wrote:
Your 2nd sentence says it. I live at around 300 ft, and drove out to Colorado, slept at 8000 ft, and tried to climb a small...
Your 2nd sentence says it. I live at around 300 ft, and drove out to Colorado, slept at 8000 ft, and tried to climb a small crest nearby the next morning and was struggling for breath big time, had to stop about every 20 feet or so. It got better after a couple days, but it is definitely a giant smack in the face if you aren't living in it.
I'm one of those dudes who gets ragingly nauseous anywhere above 4k feet of elevation. Without meds I feel like I am dying.
2
TeamGreen
Posts
37814
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
5/17/2020 10:28am
There's some pretty good discussion goin on in here. Nice!

1. Altitude: 4,637 ft (at the stadium)
2. Recovery: 2 days before Weds races. 3 days before Sunday races.
3. Weather: looks like mid-upper 70s/low 80s in the end of May an up to mid 90s by June 21.
4. Time away: on the ground SLC 5/28-29 & leave 6/21-23 (24 - 27 days) we can start calling that "a month".
5. Living standards: food, rest, training, recovery...any special needs for these requirements needs to be planned for logistically & need to be maintained for the duration.
6. Expenses: it's kinda hard to deny... it's gonna cost A LOT to relocate to SLC for "a month".
7. East versus West. West 250 doesn't need to be there until race 4 of 7 (I believe it's 3 East, 2 West, 1 East, Shootout)




* "A Month": 22 days of racing PLUS 2 days on the front-end PLUS flying or driving & you can do the same on the back-end. Flight availability isn't normal...in-fact, it's pretty thin out there. I'm guessing plenty of west- coasters will drive. Either way, you can add a day or two on the back-end: now we're at 26-28 days. Again, all personnel must be there 2 days early plus travel time. It's a month.
4
Antonioni
Posts
220
Joined
6/11/2009
Location
Engelberg, CH
5/17/2020 10:29am
One race over one day, it's a completely other story.

Beyond training, obviously people aren't equal when it comes to this.

7 high intensity pro-races in 21 days at 4600ft (when the "Floridian" live and train at 100ft), even for pro-athletes it will be a factor.
3
1
FGR01
Posts
6164
Joined
10/1/2006
Location
USA
5/17/2020 11:37am
The altitude is not the only factor. The low humidity compounds the altitude. I live around 5,000ft and train 4500-7000 daily. Very similar to SLC. When people come here to visit from low, humid places they feel it. You can "gut it out" for a few days but on extended stays you might experience cracked lips, nose bleed, and persistent dehydration that is hard to overcome. The arid air is literally sucking the moisture out of you 24/7 but you don't notice it because you do not see liquid sweat on yourself. The West/SW is also in the most arid time of year right now before the monsoon arrives in a few months.
7
face biter
Posts
541
Joined
2/25/2019
Location
Lake Dallas, TX, USA
5/17/2020 11:48am
I’ll bet most of them just stay out there until all the races are complete.
2
MZ193
Posts
937
Joined
12/14/2018
Location
IT
5/17/2020 11:51am Edited Date/Time 5/17/2020 11:52am
FGR01 wrote:
The altitude is not the only factor. The low humidity compounds the altitude. I live around 5,000ft and train 4500-7000 daily. Very similar to SLC. When...
The altitude is not the only factor. The low humidity compounds the altitude. I live around 5,000ft and train 4500-7000 daily. Very similar to SLC. When people come here to visit from low, humid places they feel it. You can "gut it out" for a few days but on extended stays you might experience cracked lips, nose bleed, and persistent dehydration that is hard to overcome. The arid air is literally sucking the moisture out of you 24/7 but you don't notice it because you do not see liquid sweat on yourself. The West/SW is also in the most arid time of year right now before the monsoon arrives in a few months.
This.
Somebody for sure will have problems. I hope not roczen or eli.
If i were eli or roczar i'de be already in slc
1
crusty_xx
Posts
10318
Joined
6/8/2013
Location
CH
5/17/2020 11:59am
If I had to guess Roczen is packing up his stuff as we speak or he's already in Utah. Afaik he has a house there - his wife is from Utah.
Hope altitude isn't going to play a role in this title fight.
mb60
Posts
5714
Joined
3/7/2010
Location
GRAPEVINE, TX, USA
5/17/2020 12:00pm
The advantage goes to the riders who have been working the last 2 and half months. It's just like A1 and guys that come out ready.
2
trsixy
Posts
25
Joined
3/27/2018
Location
Henderson, NV, USA
5/17/2020 12:03pm
Is altitude really that big of a deal? I live at 6500' and all my tracks are pretty close to that. The lowest I go is...
Is altitude really that big of a deal? I live at 6500' and all my tracks are pretty close to that. The lowest I go is Turkey, TX at 2400' and the only thing I notice is that I'll nearly flip my bike the first time I hammer the throttle. When I come home after a weekend, I'm not out of breath or anything once I'm back home.

When I go hunting, I'm up to 8500-9000' and don't really notice any difference except my legs are screaming but what do you expect when you hike up and down mountains all day long?

hunting's a good comparison
2
MZ193
Posts
937
Joined
12/14/2018
Location
IT
5/17/2020 12:09pm Edited Date/Time 5/17/2020 12:10pm
mb60 wrote:
The advantage goes to the riders who have been working the last 2 and half months. It's just like A1 and guys that come out ready.
Should we expect barcia battling for the win? Since it's like A1... he should be up frint.
Maybe destryoing tomac in the first corner he can?
Giving roczen the title easily?
😁😁😁😁i fucking love motocross.
1
2
mb60
Posts
5714
Joined
3/7/2010
Location
GRAPEVINE, TX, USA
5/17/2020 12:22pm
MZ193 wrote:
Should we expect barcia battling for the win? Since it's like A1... he should be up frint. Maybe destryoing tomac in the first corner he can...
Should we expect barcia battling for the win? Since it's like A1... he should be up frint.
Maybe destryoing tomac in the first corner he can?
Giving roczen the title easily?
😁😁😁😁i fucking love motocross.
Not sure but riders using working on bike set up issues should stay quite. Also hate to use a football quote but riding hurt and being injured will bring on new meaning as well.
1
731chopper
Posts
4240
Joined
1/2/2015
Location
DFW, TX, USA
5/17/2020 1:50pm
I’m not trying to challenge the legitimacy of it but it is hard for me to understand Anderson having issues in SLC related to altitude when he’s from Albuquerque which is 1,000 feet higher in elevation.
4
Question
Posts
3179
Joined
6/26/2014
Location
FR
5/17/2020 2:07pm Edited Date/Time 5/17/2020 2:10pm
Legit question. Yes, very possible. But so much can happen that I don't think it will be the deciding factor at all. Starts, competitors, racing incidents, crashes, and staight up raw speed will probably account for 99% of the outcome. I predict Tomac, but everything is possible, any bad start and not finding his groove can as much crown Roczen ... or Tomac. Tomac seems to move more easily in the pack, but he doesn't find his rythm all the time, whereas Roczen seems to be a better starter but seems to be more unconfortable to make moves if mid pack. Both are very deserving so I will be cheering for both anyway.
1
avidchimp
Posts
5875
Joined
7/9/2008
Location
EGL, MN, USA
5/17/2020 2:23pm
731chopper wrote:
I’m not trying to challenge the legitimacy of it but it is hard for me to understand Anderson having issues in SLC related to altitude when...
I’m not trying to challenge the legitimacy of it but it is hard for me to understand Anderson having issues in SLC related to altitude when he’s from Albuquerque which is 1,000 feet higher in elevation.
I spent plenty of time at 7000 plus feet as a kid, now it makes me want to puke and die without medication, which WADA won't approve for Jason.
1
2
trexx
Posts
73
Joined
3/24/2019
Location
Central Coast, CA, USA
5/17/2020 2:37pm
Everyone racing has to stay in SLC for the 3 weeks of racing and if they leave SLC and come back they are quarantined for 48 hours. All riders have a choice of staying at 4 different hotels. As for the race the rider gets a mechanic and 1 “visitor”.
1
APLMAN99
Posts
13040
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
5/17/2020 2:38pm
crusty_xx wrote:
If I had to guess Roczen is packing up his stuff as we speak or he's already in Utah. Afaik he has a house there -...
If I had to guess Roczen is packing up his stuff as we speak or he's already in Utah. Afaik he has a house there - his wife is from Utah.
Hope altitude isn't going to play a role in this title fight.
I’d say that most of the top 10 should already be near there and at least riding even if they aren’t actually doing motos for training yet....
1
bigk218
Posts
1466
Joined
1/2/2018
Location
Summerville, SC, USA
5/17/2020 2:52pm
TOMAC *
Oldschool
Posts
1658
Joined
8/29/2006
Location
USA
5/17/2020 3:12pm
GUY B.
I HATE the thumbs UP / thumbs DOWN
It would make me not want to post anything anymore.

What do you think...?
2
35
5/17/2020 3:23pm
I think that it will be a factor without question. Altitude, the dry air, and so many races in such a short time will make it grueling.
Hcallz5
Posts
3279
Joined
8/20/2013
Location
USA
5/17/2020 3:46pm
The crazy thing to me about finishing in SLC is the lack of places to ride around here. Sadly we don't really have any decent tracks to speak of. I can't imagine the riders will want to fly back and fourth from Cali just to practice.

Post a reply to: So, the Altitude at SLC.........Advantage Tomac?

The Latest