If Stewy came back, does he beat Reed?

HD1200
Profile picture for user HD1200
Posts
1090
Joined
5/11/2008
Location
Greenville, GA US
HD1200 3/11/2019 3:32am
3/11/2019 3:32am
theprizefighter wrote:
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list. If the...
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list.

If the secret downvoters would like to dispute it, we could always go to the record books. Who has more sx wins? How about national titles?
Down voter here, Stewart definitely wins the lawn dart competition.
3
1
HD1200
Profile picture for user HD1200
Posts
1090
Joined
5/11/2008
Location
Greenville, GA US
HD1200 3/11/2019 3:51am
3/11/2019 3:51am
theprizefighter wrote:
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list. If the...
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list.

If the secret downvoters would like to dispute it, we could always go to the record books. Who has more sx wins? How about national titles?
Also, Stewart never ran the number 22 and I'm pretty sure Reed never wanted the numbers 259 or 7
4
brapgod69
Profile picture for user brapgod69
Posts
297
Joined
12/26/2017
Location
Salt Lake City, UT US
brapgod69 3/11/2019 5:13am
3/11/2019 5:13am
He will be back at Daytona..stamp it!! Lol
1
1
toroP
Profile picture for user toroP
Posts
4483
Joined
4/6/2009
Location
Cincinnati, OH US
toroP 3/11/2019 5:20am
3/11/2019 5:20am
theprizefighter wrote:
He has more wins in a shorter period, and when both finished the season together, Stew won out. It’s not really debatable.
2011
1

The Shop

See All »
CPR
Profile picture for user CPR
Posts
6818
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
CPR 3/11/2019 6:05am
3/11/2019 6:05am
You have to go back a full 10 years to find a SX series where Stewart beat Reed in a season they both finished. Even then there was only 4 points in it.
What makes anyone think that would be any different now?
3
mx 219
Profile picture for user mx 219
Posts
4040
Joined
8/15/2010
Location
South Central, PA US
mx 219 3/11/2019 6:27am
3/11/2019 6:27am
if he stays upright then I believe so
1
1
Crush
Profile picture for user Crush
Posts
21093
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney AU
Crush 3/11/2019 6:37am
3/11/2019 6:37am
I mean you're not talking about either of them at their peak, so it's irrelevant what their careers or head to head was like...

What's relevant is now. You're talking about one dude who's sustained far less injuries, particularly to the head, who's still racing to a bloody respectable level compared to another dude who appears to be full time Dad-ing it, belly and all.

Give James an off-season and perhaps you have a different story but even then, he wasn't himself in 2014. In fact, since he got popped he wasn't himself. You could argue as far back as 2012 or even 2009 at his last title.
5
tprice07
Profile picture for user tprice07
Posts
2384
Joined
9/29/2009
Location
Fort Dodge, IA US
tprice07 3/11/2019 7:06am
3/11/2019 7:06am
RBSR19 line them up and let's find out.
1
BobKerr
Profile picture for user BobKerr
Posts
910
Joined
11/3/2017
Location
Nowheresville, TN US
BobKerr 3/11/2019 7:23am
3/11/2019 7:23am
No
theprizefighter 3/11/2019 8:22am
3/11/2019 8:22am
theprizefighter wrote:
He has more wins in a shorter period, and when both finished the season together, Stew won out. It’s not really debatable.
Hank_Thrill wrote:
That was a decade ago. I think the poster asked who would win now. Stewart’s concussions were taking a toll evidenced by his last season on...
That was a decade ago. I think the poster asked who would win now. Stewart’s concussions were taking a toll evidenced by his last season on Suzuki. I’m pretty sure Reed would have him covered now.
He came back in 2016 and beat Dungey and Roczen at the 2016 straight rhythm. While not an actual sx race, that’s still impressive.
4
8
ruy
Profile picture for user ruy
Posts
4091
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
España ES
ruy 3/11/2019 8:39am
3/11/2019 8:39am

2
Tarz483
Profile picture for user Tarz483
Posts
6344
Joined
2/25/2009
Location
Mankato, MN US
Tarz483 3/11/2019 8:42am
3/11/2019 8:42am
No Way
3
ButteryWaffles 3/11/2019 9:16am
3/11/2019 9:16am Edited Date/Time 3/11/2019 9:17am
"Don't matter how long I'm off. Don't matter how old you think I am, if you think I'm washed up. I'm still a bad motherfucker."

That, that right there is all James needs to say.
1
1
Autotech1957
Profile picture for user Autotech1957
Posts
106
Joined
3/10/2018
Location
Wendell, NC US
Autotech1957 3/11/2019 9:36am
3/11/2019 9:36am
ButteryWaffles wrote:
"Don't matter how long I'm off. Don't matter how old you think I am, if you think I'm washed up. I'm still a bad motherfucker." That...
"Don't matter how long I'm off. Don't matter how old you think I am, if you think I'm washed up. I'm still a bad motherfucker."

That, that right there is all James needs to say.
17-0 stamp it!
3
STLSharky
Profile picture for user STLSharky
Posts
464
Joined
11/12/2016
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
STLSharky 3/11/2019 9:50am
3/11/2019 9:50am Edited Date/Time 3/11/2019 9:51am
Underground wrote:
Just finished watching that [url=https://www.redbull.com/int-en/tv/video/AP-1P5DV6DJ91W11/james-stewart]Redbull video of James back from suspension at Straight Rhythm[/url] and it got me thinking. Where would he finish? Would he be...
Just finished watching that Redbull video of James back from suspension at Straight Rhythm and it got me thinking. Where would he finish? Would he be beating his old rival?
No he pulls off with arm pump and blisters: outta the game way too long dude.
2
newmann
Profile picture for user newmann
Posts
24438
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
newmann 3/11/2019 10:22am
3/11/2019 10:22am
I'm just glad I got to see Stewart race a few times in his prime. Amazing stuff. Seems as if Reed has taken the opportunity to repay James for the Unadilla deal, has anyone got any good clips of that?
1
FlickitFlat 3/11/2019 10:30am
3/11/2019 10:30am
JS and Reed rivalry is fake news. JS always had him covered.
3
Squirrelings 3/11/2019 10:57am
3/11/2019 10:57am
ButteryWaffles wrote:
"Don't matter how long I'm off. Don't matter how old you think I am, if you think I'm washed up. I'm still a bad motherfucker." That...
"Don't matter how long I'm off. Don't matter how old you think I am, if you think I'm washed up. I'm still a bad motherfucker."

That, that right there is all James needs to say.
One of the baddest mother fuckers ever, I might add. Along with Chad Reed. This is just another fanboy "my guy is better than yours" type of thread.
1

Pit Row

See All »
STLSharky
Profile picture for user STLSharky
Posts
464
Joined
11/12/2016
Location
Edwardsville, IL US
STLSharky 3/11/2019 11:00am
3/11/2019 11:00am
theprizefighter wrote:
He has more wins in a shorter period, and when both finished the season together, Stew won out. It’s not really debatable.
toroP wrote:
2011
Pretty sure Reed with his record starts never pulled over with blisters
5
1
ctbale
Profile picture for user ctbale
Posts
1103
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
Gustavus, AK US
ctbale 3/11/2019 11:01am
3/11/2019 11:01am
Yeah, no, for sure ....
1
Squirrelings 3/11/2019 11:08am
3/11/2019 11:08am
theprizefighter wrote:
He has more wins in a shorter period, and when both finished the season together, Stew won out. It’s not really debatable.
toroP wrote:
2011
STLSharky wrote:
Pretty sure Reed with his record starts never pulled over with blisters
Hater.
1
DEMONDAVE
Profile picture for user DEMONDAVE
Posts
675
Joined
9/6/2013
Location
Apple Valley, CA US
DEMONDAVE 3/11/2019 11:37am
3/11/2019 11:37am
jemcee wrote:
Another thing I'll say, since I've been coming to this place there's two things that have been constant

Everyone underrates Reed's chances
Everyone overrates Stewart's chances
/\ this is it
MOTO732
Profile picture for user MOTO732
Posts
300
Joined
1/11/2019
Location
Elkhorn, WI US
MOTO732 3/11/2019 12:01pm
3/11/2019 12:01pm
Stewart's comeback to racing has the same chance of happening as Dale Earnhardt's.
uneasy_rider 3/11/2019 12:04pm
3/11/2019 12:04pm
theprizefighter wrote:
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list. If the...
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list.

If the secret downvoters would like to dispute it, we could always go to the record books. Who has more sx wins? How about national titles?
You may want to examine those records a little closer. Except for the Lites class (chad only lites 2 years), they have the same number of titles, indoors and out. JS has 6 more SX wins than Chad, which is cool, but not dominating by any stretch. Its cool to be a fan of the guy, but your facts are wrong and your opinion is biased.
uneasy_rider 3/11/2019 12:05pm
3/11/2019 12:05pm
FlickitFlat wrote:
JS and Reed rivalry is fake news. JS always had him covered.
Last man standing is the name of the game, who is still racing and currently sets 7th in points?
1
ruy
Profile picture for user ruy
Posts
4091
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
España ES
ruy 3/11/2019 12:13pm
3/11/2019 12:13pm


3
theprizefighter 3/11/2019 12:25pm
3/11/2019 12:25pm Edited Date/Time 3/11/2019 12:31pm
theprizefighter wrote:
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list. If the...
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list.

If the secret downvoters would like to dispute it, we could always go to the record books. Who has more sx wins? How about national titles?
uneasy_rider wrote:
You may want to examine those records a little closer. Except for the Lites class (chad only lites 2 years), they have the same number of...
You may want to examine those records a little closer. Except for the Lites class (chad only lites 2 years), they have the same number of titles, indoors and out. JS has 6 more SX wins than Chad, which is cool, but not dominating by any stretch. Its cool to be a fan of the guy, but your facts are wrong and your opinion is biased.
Reed never beat Stewart for a title when they raced together for the series, where as Stewart did beat Reed. Stewart was almost always faster and could catch and pass Reed almost at will in his prime as evidenced by how quickly James amassed his wins. Reed had been in the class for two seasons before James entered. James did a 24-0.
Stats, while a big part of it, aren’t the entire picture. Dungey has as many sx titles as RV, and not many more wins. Dungey has more 450 outdoor titles and wins than RV, but most people agree that RV had Dungey covered, much like Stewart did Reed.

Also, when looking at all-time greats, lites records are included. I don’t think that there’s much of an argument James will higher on the list than Reed.
1
7
davis224
Profile picture for user davis224
Posts
7422
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Cornland, IL US
Fantasy
218th
davis224 3/11/2019 1:05pm
3/11/2019 1:05pm
I bet Bill Brasky could still whoop 'em all! To Bill Brasky!
uneasy_rider 3/11/2019 1:45pm
3/11/2019 1:45pm
theprizefighter wrote:
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list. If the...
Stewart always had Reed’s number, and still would. It’s not a debate as to who will be ranked higher in the all-time great’s list.

If the secret downvoters would like to dispute it, we could always go to the record books. Who has more sx wins? How about national titles?
uneasy_rider wrote:
You may want to examine those records a little closer. Except for the Lites class (chad only lites 2 years), they have the same number of...
You may want to examine those records a little closer. Except for the Lites class (chad only lites 2 years), they have the same number of titles, indoors and out. JS has 6 more SX wins than Chad, which is cool, but not dominating by any stretch. Its cool to be a fan of the guy, but your facts are wrong and your opinion is biased.
theprizefighter wrote:
Reed never beat Stewart for a title when they raced together for the series, where as Stewart did beat Reed. Stewart was almost always faster and...
Reed never beat Stewart for a title when they raced together for the series, where as Stewart did beat Reed. Stewart was almost always faster and could catch and pass Reed almost at will in his prime as evidenced by how quickly James amassed his wins. Reed had been in the class for two seasons before James entered. James did a 24-0.
Stats, while a big part of it, aren’t the entire picture. Dungey has as many sx titles as RV, and not many more wins. Dungey has more 450 outdoor titles and wins than RV, but most people agree that RV had Dungey covered, much like Stewart did Reed.

Also, when looking at all-time greats, lites records are included. I don’t think that there’s much of an argument James will higher on the list than Reed.
Stats dont lie, you can say it as much as you want, but the record books dont lie. Since you want to play the he only won because card, who was Stews main competition when he went 24-0? Oh, thats right........
FlickitFlat 3/11/2019 2:18pm
3/11/2019 2:18pm
uneasy_rider wrote:
You may want to examine those records a little closer. Except for the Lites class (chad only lites 2 years), they have the same number of...
You may want to examine those records a little closer. Except for the Lites class (chad only lites 2 years), they have the same number of titles, indoors and out. JS has 6 more SX wins than Chad, which is cool, but not dominating by any stretch. Its cool to be a fan of the guy, but your facts are wrong and your opinion is biased.
theprizefighter wrote:
Reed never beat Stewart for a title when they raced together for the series, where as Stewart did beat Reed. Stewart was almost always faster and...
Reed never beat Stewart for a title when they raced together for the series, where as Stewart did beat Reed. Stewart was almost always faster and could catch and pass Reed almost at will in his prime as evidenced by how quickly James amassed his wins. Reed had been in the class for two seasons before James entered. James did a 24-0.
Stats, while a big part of it, aren’t the entire picture. Dungey has as many sx titles as RV, and not many more wins. Dungey has more 450 outdoor titles and wins than RV, but most people agree that RV had Dungey covered, much like Stewart did Reed.

Also, when looking at all-time greats, lites records are included. I don’t think that there’s much of an argument James will higher on the list than Reed.
uneasy_rider wrote:
Stats dont lie, you can say it as much as you want, but the record books dont lie. Since you want to play the he only...
Stats dont lie, you can say it as much as you want, but the record books dont lie. Since you want to play the he only won because card, who was Stews main competition when he went 24-0? Oh, thats right........
Cody Cooper at Unadilla and Tim Ferry at Steel City. That is pretty much the only times he was pressured.

Post a reply to: If Stewy came back, does he beat Reed?