MXA: We Propose A No Formula Two-Stroke Formula

Overdrive
Posts
1614
Joined
7/13/2008
Location
Fort Myers, FL, USA
11/24/2012 8:05pm
DC you said a few years ago that due to the economy you couldn't instate cc for cc rules, that if you did it would hurt the factory sales during a down economy.

Well the economy hasn't turned around and probably won't in the near future and the price of bikes is now hurting the local promoters and the sport. Something needs to change, 2 strokes need to be brought back and developed.

Will you revisit the idea of cc to cc racing on the pro level now. Its just an honest question to see if your thoughts have changed on the subject.
VET176
Posts
1358
Joined
5/13/2011
Location
Brisbane, AU
11/24/2012 8:17pm
Overdrive wrote:
DC you said a few years ago that due to the economy you couldn't instate cc for cc rules, that if you did it would hurt...
DC you said a few years ago that due to the economy you couldn't instate cc for cc rules, that if you did it would hurt the factory sales during a down economy.

Well the economy hasn't turned around and probably won't in the near future and the price of bikes is now hurting the local promoters and the sport. Something needs to change, 2 strokes need to be brought back and developed.

Will you revisit the idea of cc to cc racing on the pro level now. Its just an honest question to see if your thoughts have changed on the subject.
He also recently said:

"What am I going to do? I don't really think I can do anything to change the economy, nor can I pick up the bat phone and call Bob the Honda Builder or Mr. Kawasaki or anyone and tell them to lower the prices of their motorcycles and maintenance. I think the marketplace decides those matters....

But you can allow 250 2 strokes to race in the 250 class.
chump6784
Posts
1776
Joined
5/9/2011
Location
AU
11/24/2012 8:28pm
Just for comparison sake the November issue of Transmoto magazine did a test between the 2013 KTM 250sx and 250sx-f.
The track was hard packed and it was said multiple times in the article that a softer track with more loam may have swayed the times to the two stroke but this was the track they tested at.

Lap times are as follows

Brock Winston: 250sx - 1:28.8, 250sx-f - 1:27.4
AJ Roberts: 250sx - 1:29.9, 250sx-f - 1:28.6
Greg Smith: 250sx - 1:39.9, 250sx-f - 1:38.2

The quote from Brock Winston (pro tester) was this. "For a privateer to be competitive against the factory riders on their trick four strokes, the KTM 250sx is a really cost effective option. Its cheaper and easier to maintain and much cheaper to throw performance mods at, and it gets out of the start gates quickly - which is half the battle in motocross. But if i had the option between a factory two stroke and a factory four stroke - and i thought purely in terms of overall performance - i'd certainly consider the four stroke. Its easier to get on and instantly feel comfortable on and i find that it holds lines much better through corners and that can help save energy."

Pretty cut and dry really. Factories and factory riders aren't going to stick guys on 2 strokes because
a) the company is trying to promote 4 strokes, KTM dont need to advertise their 2 strokes, they sell out anyway.
b) pro riders want the most consistent bike over the whole season and that is the 4 stroke.

They also printed a dyno chart that is the actual rear wheel readings obtained from KTM Australia. They have the 250 sx-f at 40 hp and the 250 sx at 44 hp. This chart does seem inconsistent with what MXA posts on the 250 sx. They have the sx at 50 and the sx-f at 43, a 7 hp difference rather than 4 hp difference as shown by this chart. It also shows the sx peaking at 8000 rpm rather than 8500 that MXA quotes.

The Shop

Radical
Posts
2990
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
11/24/2012 9:19pm
This will fix the problems, and allow innovation. Sheesh! We have 3 threads going on the same topic.

Change the classes to:
125 2 stroke vs 175 4 stroke, possibly 200cc for the 4 strokes.
250 2 stroke vs 350 4 stroke

During a transition period of say 2 years for pro and 5 years for amateur, allow older 250 and 450 4 strokes to race with a rev limiter limiting maximum RPMs.

This gives the factories some time to retool, and keeps the cost down for amateurs who have recently purchased bikes.
It also brings the 125 back as the standard for the Lites class and provides the right stepping stone from the 85 class.

It also reduces the speed slightly which in my opinion is necessary to keep the riders safe.
Lowering displacement is something Indy car does every few years.
40Plus_922mx
Posts
2900
Joined
4/17/2009
Location
High Desert, CA, USA
11/24/2012 11:57pm
Speeds are too fast. Bringing 2 strokes up to the cc limit is not the answer.
Fearo
Posts
1383
Joined
12/17/2009
Location
BE
11/25/2012 3:00am Edited Date/Time 11/25/2012 3:09am
These 'comparison' tests that the mags sometimes do grind my gears to an unimaginable extent.
I will try to explain this is the most simplest of ways.

-If you ride a 250F and a 250 2-stroke, and you can't go faster on the 2-stroke, then you are just not riding that bike good enough.
I don't care if you ride on a linoleum floor, a bluegroove track or Lommel, if you're not faster on the 2-stroke it is because YOU didn't ride the bike to it's full capabilities.

There is absolutely no way that a 250F in any way, shape or form could ever hold a candle against a modern 250 2-stroke when both bikes are ridden in the way they are meant to be ridden. That's not a bad thing, I'm all for choice and if people prefer to ride 4-strokes than more power to them. If they're happy than I'm happy. But for the love of god, don't try to compare a 51HP, 215lbs razorblade to a 40HP 230lbs lawnmower.
daveoevo
Posts
194
Joined
5/1/2011
Location
GB
11/25/2012 3:45am
Fearo wrote:
These 'comparison' tests that the mags sometimes do grind my gears to an unimaginable extent. I will try to explain this is the most simplest of...
These 'comparison' tests that the mags sometimes do grind my gears to an unimaginable extent.
I will try to explain this is the most simplest of ways.

-If you ride a 250F and a 250 2-stroke, and you can't go faster on the 2-stroke, then you are just not riding that bike good enough.
I don't care if you ride on a linoleum floor, a bluegroove track or Lommel, if you're not faster on the 2-stroke it is because YOU didn't ride the bike to it's full capabilities.

There is absolutely no way that a 250F in any way, shape or form could ever hold a candle against a modern 250 2-stroke when both bikes are ridden in the way they are meant to be ridden. That's not a bad thing, I'm all for choice and if people prefer to ride 4-strokes than more power to them. If they're happy than I'm happy. But for the love of god, don't try to compare a 51HP, 215lbs razorblade to a 40HP 230lbs lawnmower.
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
Frodad78
Posts
2156
Joined
1/11/2012
Location
USA
11/25/2012 6:04am
Fearo wrote:
These 'comparison' tests that the mags sometimes do grind my gears to an unimaginable extent. I will try to explain this is the most simplest of...
These 'comparison' tests that the mags sometimes do grind my gears to an unimaginable extent.
I will try to explain this is the most simplest of ways.

-If you ride a 250F and a 250 2-stroke, and you can't go faster on the 2-stroke, then you are just not riding that bike good enough.
I don't care if you ride on a linoleum floor, a bluegroove track or Lommel, if you're not faster on the 2-stroke it is because YOU didn't ride the bike to it's full capabilities.

There is absolutely no way that a 250F in any way, shape or form could ever hold a candle against a modern 250 2-stroke when both bikes are ridden in the way they are meant to be ridden. That's not a bad thing, I'm all for choice and if people prefer to ride 4-strokes than more power to them. If they're happy than I'm happy. But for the love of god, don't try to compare a 51HP, 215lbs razorblade to a 40HP 230lbs lawnmower.
daveoevo wrote:
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke??? If the name of the game is to go...
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
You're off to see the wizard with your "fourstrokes have brought down the cost of racing" theory buddy. Some one help me out here but I'm pretty sure Mitch Payton was quoted talking about how he could build several 2-stroke motors for the cost of one 4-stroke.
11/25/2012 6:32am
Well, here are the facts from both perspectives:

Two stroke aficionado's
1. its all about cc's
2. peak hp wins races
3. four strokes are evil
4. four strokes blow up constantly
5. four strokes are at least 30 lbs heavier
6. if we all just click our heels three times and say 'we believe'...

Four stroke aficionado's
1. two stroke riders are dumber than doorknobs

does that help?
daveoevo
Posts
194
Joined
5/1/2011
Location
GB
11/25/2012 7:12am
Fearo wrote:
These 'comparison' tests that the mags sometimes do grind my gears to an unimaginable extent. I will try to explain this is the most simplest of...
These 'comparison' tests that the mags sometimes do grind my gears to an unimaginable extent.
I will try to explain this is the most simplest of ways.

-If you ride a 250F and a 250 2-stroke, and you can't go faster on the 2-stroke, then you are just not riding that bike good enough.
I don't care if you ride on a linoleum floor, a bluegroove track or Lommel, if you're not faster on the 2-stroke it is because YOU didn't ride the bike to it's full capabilities.

There is absolutely no way that a 250F in any way, shape or form could ever hold a candle against a modern 250 2-stroke when both bikes are ridden in the way they are meant to be ridden. That's not a bad thing, I'm all for choice and if people prefer to ride 4-strokes than more power to them. If they're happy than I'm happy. But for the love of god, don't try to compare a 51HP, 215lbs razorblade to a 40HP 230lbs lawnmower.
daveoevo wrote:
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke??? If the name of the game is to go...
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
Frodad78 wrote:
You're off to see the wizard with your "fourstrokes have brought down the cost of racing" theory buddy. Some one help me out here but I'm...
You're off to see the wizard with your "fourstrokes have brought down the cost of racing" theory buddy. Some one help me out here but I'm pretty sure Mitch Payton was quoted talking about how he could build several 2-stroke motors for the cost of one 4-stroke.
So you are using the team that puts out the blingest bike on the circuit as a mesuring stick for every one else when it comes to cost?
Since when have privateers been on the same level as factory teams??
2st are great but at top level you need the best machines possible no matter what the cc and 4st offer better characteristic's for racing.
Frodad78
Posts
2156
Joined
1/11/2012
Location
USA
11/25/2012 7:30am Edited Date/Time 11/25/2012 7:38am
Read the article...fourstroke mods =spending $$$$$ . 2 stroke mods= Labor. Which do you think is easier for a Privateer to come by? Oh forget it....Lets just price our new generations of MX racers out of the sport. And you know what, you just made a great point. As long as we are racing fourstrokes, privateers will NEVER be on the same level as PC because of the cost associated with building such a bike. Fourstrokes make the performance gap larger because of the amount of money that they have to put into that engine. Who the hell else can afford to do that?
RealityCheck
Posts
233
Joined
7/1/2012
Location
Davidsonville, MD, USA
11/25/2012 8:29am
daveoevo wrote:
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke??? If the name of the game is to go...
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion is easy and the market will sort itself out.

Your argument about changing pistons frequently on a 125 simply illustrates the lengths to which 4-stroke nutswingers will go to use incredibly convoluted, disingenuous "logic" to defend an indefensible stance. There are currently no competitive 125 4 strokes, so you have no point of reference. An apples to apples comparison would be the maintenance/reliability of a 250 2-stroke against a 250 4-stroke. I currently own both and there is no comparison: the 2-stroke requires much less maintenance and is easier to work on.

Finally, citing the fact that a modern 450 gets around the track faster than a 20 year old 500 (I don't care what year your KX is, it's 1980's technology) simply proves my point: since you can't make your case using any sort of reasonable logic, you have to resort to ridiculously inappropriate comparisons.

Seriously? 125 2-stroke maintenance requirements compared to a bike with twice the engine displacement? A new bike compared to a 20 year old one? This smells of desperation.
WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
USA
11/25/2012 8:48am
I just sent my son's YZ250 top end to Eric Gorr and got it ported and 295'ed; and I sent my '07 CR500AF top end to be rebored, ported and Nicasil'ed. The top end had never been off my 500. Total bill, including shipping and all gaskets: $975. I installed both top ends without removing either engine from the frame and we went out woods riding yesterday to get them broken in. Both bikes ripped (my 500 was just ridiculous in the woods).
11/25/2012 9:24am
daveoevo wrote:
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke??? If the name of the game is to go...
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion...
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion is easy and the market will sort itself out.

Your argument about changing pistons frequently on a 125 simply illustrates the lengths to which 4-stroke nutswingers will go to use incredibly convoluted, disingenuous "logic" to defend an indefensible stance. There are currently no competitive 125 4 strokes, so you have no point of reference. An apples to apples comparison would be the maintenance/reliability of a 250 2-stroke against a 250 4-stroke. I currently own both and there is no comparison: the 2-stroke requires much less maintenance and is easier to work on.

Finally, citing the fact that a modern 450 gets around the track faster than a 20 year old 500 (I don't care what year your KX is, it's 1980's technology) simply proves my point: since you can't make your case using any sort of reasonable logic, you have to resort to ridiculously inappropriate comparisons.

Seriously? 125 2-stroke maintenance requirements compared to a bike with twice the engine displacement? A new bike compared to a 20 year old one? This smells of desperation.
"why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement?"

I don't think they are. It's the powers that be that primarily don't want it, not the ordinary riders. Most of us just ride what we want.

On the maintenance side - generally over the years Iv'e found 4 strokes to be slightly cheaper to maintain but obviously more expensive in the event of a serious problem. I don't believe there's much, if any, difference in the day to day running costs though.
Frodad78
Posts
2156
Joined
1/11/2012
Location
USA
11/25/2012 9:48am
daveoevo wrote:
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke??? If the name of the game is to go...
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion...
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion is easy and the market will sort itself out.

Your argument about changing pistons frequently on a 125 simply illustrates the lengths to which 4-stroke nutswingers will go to use incredibly convoluted, disingenuous "logic" to defend an indefensible stance. There are currently no competitive 125 4 strokes, so you have no point of reference. An apples to apples comparison would be the maintenance/reliability of a 250 2-stroke against a 250 4-stroke. I currently own both and there is no comparison: the 2-stroke requires much less maintenance and is easier to work on.

Finally, citing the fact that a modern 450 gets around the track faster than a 20 year old 500 (I don't care what year your KX is, it's 1980's technology) simply proves my point: since you can't make your case using any sort of reasonable logic, you have to resort to ridiculously inappropriate comparisons.

Seriously? 125 2-stroke maintenance requirements compared to a bike with twice the engine displacement? A new bike compared to a 20 year old one? This smells of desperation.
"why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement?" I don't think they are. It's the powers that be that...
"why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement?"

I don't think they are. It's the powers that be that primarily don't want it, not the ordinary riders. Most of us just ride what we want.

On the maintenance side - generally over the years Iv'e found 4 strokes to be slightly cheaper to maintain but obviously more expensive in the event of a serious problem. I don't believe there's much, if any, difference in the day to day running costs though.
I think the big bore 450s can be reliable when raced by the average motocrosser. Its the high revving nature of the 250f that seems prone to constant valve adjustment. I used to race XR400s in scrambles, never revved that sucker and we never had any issues. Unfortunately they stopped manufacturing their most reliable line of 4-strokes. Go figure...
11/25/2012 9:53am
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion...
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion is easy and the market will sort itself out.

Your argument about changing pistons frequently on a 125 simply illustrates the lengths to which 4-stroke nutswingers will go to use incredibly convoluted, disingenuous "logic" to defend an indefensible stance. There are currently no competitive 125 4 strokes, so you have no point of reference. An apples to apples comparison would be the maintenance/reliability of a 250 2-stroke against a 250 4-stroke. I currently own both and there is no comparison: the 2-stroke requires much less maintenance and is easier to work on.

Finally, citing the fact that a modern 450 gets around the track faster than a 20 year old 500 (I don't care what year your KX is, it's 1980's technology) simply proves my point: since you can't make your case using any sort of reasonable logic, you have to resort to ridiculously inappropriate comparisons.

Seriously? 125 2-stroke maintenance requirements compared to a bike with twice the engine displacement? A new bike compared to a 20 year old one? This smells of desperation.
"why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement?" I don't think they are. It's the powers that be that...
"why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement?"

I don't think they are. It's the powers that be that primarily don't want it, not the ordinary riders. Most of us just ride what we want.

On the maintenance side - generally over the years Iv'e found 4 strokes to be slightly cheaper to maintain but obviously more expensive in the event of a serious problem. I don't believe there's much, if any, difference in the day to day running costs though.
Frodad78 wrote:
I think the big bore 450s can be reliable when raced by the average motocrosser. Its the high revving nature of the 250f that seems prone...
I think the big bore 450s can be reliable when raced by the average motocrosser. Its the high revving nature of the 250f that seems prone to constant valve adjustment. I used to race XR400s in scrambles, never revved that sucker and we never had any issues. Unfortunately they stopped manufacturing their most reliable line of 4-strokes. Go figure...
Fair point, I have to agree there.
daveoevo
Posts
194
Joined
5/1/2011
Location
GB
11/25/2012 10:48am
daveoevo wrote:
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke??? If the name of the game is to go...
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion...
If you really believe this, why are 4-stroke advocates so terrified of racing heads up against 2-strokes of equal displacement? Changing the rules per MXA's suggestion is easy and the market will sort itself out.

Your argument about changing pistons frequently on a 125 simply illustrates the lengths to which 4-stroke nutswingers will go to use incredibly convoluted, disingenuous "logic" to defend an indefensible stance. There are currently no competitive 125 4 strokes, so you have no point of reference. An apples to apples comparison would be the maintenance/reliability of a 250 2-stroke against a 250 4-stroke. I currently own both and there is no comparison: the 2-stroke requires much less maintenance and is easier to work on.

Finally, citing the fact that a modern 450 gets around the track faster than a 20 year old 500 (I don't care what year your KX is, it's 1980's technology) simply proves my point: since you can't make your case using any sort of reasonable logic, you have to resort to ridiculously inappropriate comparisons.

Seriously? 125 2-stroke maintenance requirements compared to a bike with twice the engine displacement? A new bike compared to a 20 year old one? This smells of desperation.
I am not terrified just using my past experience of racing and what I had to do to get my bikes up to be competitive at a national level.
The 125s required the most work and money and went pop for a pass time.
The 250s were better but still required a fair bit of work and still prone to siezing.
The 450 I bought it set up the suspension and raced it. Changed the oil every other ride and lived happily ever after.
I only ride the 500 as i am now as I am now bit older and want something different and fun for me to enjoy.
The fact is 4st are an advantage no matter what the capacity rules are. But you sound like you my of had a poorly maintained 250f and it went pop so now all 4st are the devil.
jeffro503
Posts
27650
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR, USA
11/25/2012 10:57am
When are you guys going to get it?

Manufactures could give a flying shit about the health of our riders! That IS basically what it all boils down to......it's MONEY!! On both ends of the spectrum! They NEED to sell you those 4 strokes....because that is what they have to sell. You WILL buy the parts for it when it breaks....and you WILL pay 2 - 3 times more for those parts compared to a 2 stroke!

The OEM's are the ones responsible for this! Every local track around the United states allows Same sized CC bikes to race against each other...hell even at LL's you can do this!

It's at the "Pro level" where it's not legal! Why?........because that IS what you see on TV!!

God forbid the unknowing audience / muscle head / flat biller / tatted out / monster truck fan to see and witness a 2 stroke on National TV! It would confuse the shit out of them.....and have them start to question " What was that funny sounding bike.....I like it!"

About the only 2 strokes we see out at any "pro level" ( if you can call it that )...is FMX. Which actually.......fits the group I posted above pretty well.

Us MX guys.......except for KTM....were basically fucked.
Frodad78
Posts
2156
Joined
1/11/2012
Location
USA
11/25/2012 12:01pm
^^^pretty much yeah.
pchak
Posts
29
Joined
6/6/2012
Location
King George, VA, USA
11/25/2012 12:17pm
I thought I remember Mitch Payton being asked about this somewhere. I think it was from a pulpmx podcast. But allowing 250 2 strokes to race against the 250 4 strokes. Teams like Pro Circuit will gravitate to what is has the greatest advantage. I think he said he would probably ride 250 2 strokes then. But it was quite some time ago my memory is not great.
Rupert X
Posts
11108
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Newark, OH, USA
11/25/2012 12:54pm
I'm one of those guys that believes that even on a level C.C playing field, that the four strokes will still get around

the track faster, they are easier to ride and hook up better. There, I said it.

The BEST thing about permitting 250T's in the 250Fs class, would be the inclusion of privateers that don't have

zillions of buckeroonie$. That is basically what it boils down to - fairness for all.

And so, it was written. And the villagers rejoiced and placed stickers on things they shouldn't.
watson
Posts
712
Joined
7/15/2012
Location
Houston, TX, USA
11/25/2012 1:42pm
With all due respect to DC, are manufacturers really going to pull their support or do anything drastic if a couple privateers race (KTM or Yamaha) 250 two strokes in the tiddler class?


The factory and satellite teams will still race and endorse the four strokes and the privateer's racing costs will be cut exponentially and they'll be more competitive to boot. Everyone's happy no?
Crush
Posts
21154
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
11/25/2012 2:46pm
This is scary if it's true...

"...Pro Circuit’s cost on a high-compression four-stroke piston is greater than his cost for everything he did on a two-stroke. When you add in the additional cost of the titanium exhaust system, you get sticker shock."
PFO186
Posts
110
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Brewerton, NY, USA
11/25/2012 5:59pm
Bone stock 2-stroke intro class for up and comers and locals (150, 200, 250cc??). Provide cheap racing for privateers.

Open class for high paid elite riders and manufacturer bike development.

Done
40Plus_922mx
Posts
2900
Joined
4/17/2009
Location
High Desert, CA, USA
11/25/2012 11:21pm
Go watch a mid nineties 2 stroke 250 race. Then watch any post 2004 250F race and see which bike is faster.
SwapperMX
Posts
2153
Joined
6/16/2010
Location
AU
11/26/2012 12:47am
Go watch a mid nineties 2 stroke 250 race. Then watch any post 2004 250F race and see which bike is faster.
spot on !!
Aaryn234
Posts
3328
Joined
8/19/2007
Location
South Australia, SA, AU
11/26/2012 2:42am
Go watch a mid nineties 2 stroke 250 race. Then watch any post 2004 250F race and see which bike is faster.
But how fast would the 250 two stroke be now if they had another 8 years of development, engine, frame and suspension wise ?

Also by watching a 2004 250 race compared to watching a 2012 250F race you are comparing the greats in the premier class compared to the class of younger riders making their way to the bigger class.

I would expect a RC or Reed from 2004 on their 250 two strokes would be as quick as any current 250F rider on their current bike, probably faster.

Now Reed or RC still on a 250 two stroke with another 8 years of development, that would have been cool to see Smile

Where would two strokes be right now if manufactures stayed that route? No doubt things would have continued to progress, a 250 two stroke could be fuel injected by now and maybe putting out more power than current 450 four strokes or at least the same with similar torque figures, Imagine that!

Bikes that are just as tractable, same or more power and even lighter, Current SX tracks would certainly be single jump sections down every straight! How much safer would racing be Whistling
Fearo
Posts
1383
Joined
12/17/2009
Location
BE
11/26/2012 5:44am
daveoevo wrote:
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke??? If the name of the game is to go...
So with this in mind Why would anyone pick a 2stroke over an easier to ride 4stroke???
If the name of the game is to go as fast as you can for as long as you can then the 4st has the advantage every time I am afraid.
I have raced 125, 250 2st/4st and 450. At the moment I race a kx500 but there is no doubt in my mind that a modern 450 is quickest way round a mx track to day.
And all those who go on about how cheap 2st are to run have short memory's. When I raced the 125s I had to put a piston in every 4 rides because they tailed off in power that much. The quick boys would have a new piston every meeting but I couldn't afford that let alone the pipes and tuning and special fuel just to stay competitive.
The 4strokes have brought costs down as well, you can go to your dealer and get a 450 and with minimal set up race a national. you couldn't do that in the good old days.
Why would you want a bike that is easy to ride? I thought the point of motocross was to go as fast as you can while having the most fun? If I wanted to do something easy, I would pick up another hobby.

My post refered to the 250 vs 250 arguement, at no point did I ever include the word 450, but my point remains the same. A 450 4-stroke should ALWAYS be faster than a 250 2-stroke. If you're not going faster on the 450, it is because YOU are not riding it to it's potential.

Why do people always insist on comparing 125s 250s and 450s? The way the displacement rules are right now, a blind monkey could see that comparing any one of these doesn't make sense.

If you wanted to have a happy marriage between 2-strokes and 4-strokes, the displacements would have to be completely re-evaluated with extensive dyno and track testing. I would probably ballpark it like this: 175 vs 250 (MX2) and 250 vs 350 (MX1).

Post a reply to: MXA: We Propose A No Formula Two-Stroke Formula

The Latest