What highly regarded musician or group did you just not ‘get’?

PNWMXer
Posts
1817
Joined
1/13/2022
Location
Washington, WA, USA
1 day ago Edited Date/Time 1 day ago

The Beatles, and Nirvana. I recognize both of their contributions to music history, but can’t stand the music from either one of them.

Edit to add U2 and Springsteen after folks reminded me…good lord they both suck.

3
1
downonmonday
Posts
644
Joined
2/14/2012
Location
Cornfields, IL, USA
1 day ago

It's already been mentioned, but the jam bands I don't understand. I guess it's more of how I don't get the culture of the jam bands. The cult following. 

1
shuggs
Posts
1874
Joined
8/6/2008
Location
Dunfermline, GB
1 day ago

Like a couple of Floyd - money,  Bowie Golden Years & Nazareth Bad Bad Boy were the tunes on the Jukebox back in the day.

U2 were good until Unforgetable Fire, after that it’s just a nah.

Could never get into Led Zep, JPaige. 

1
Moto Nomad
Posts
1296
Joined
1/19/2021
Location
Grass Valley, CA, USA
1 day ago

I could never get into Phish either. Even went to see them in the 90s. Nope, nothing. It was like where all the Deadheads went when the Dead wasn't on tour.

 

1

The Shop

1 day ago

Rush is #1 hands down. I have long contended that if you think Rush is the greatest ever then you used to or currently still do smoke pot. I have NEVER met a person who loves Rush that didn't used to smoke the stuff.

Phish, Grateful Dead, Dave Mathews Band, I don't get their appeal either.

I don't get what's so great about the Foo Fighters either. Grohl seems like a cool guy but the music does nothing for me.

I like Pink Floyd.

4
Spurdo
Posts
484
Joined
12/26/2016
Location
FI
1 day ago
Rush is #1 hands down. I have long contended that if you think Rush is the greatest ever then you used to or currently still do...

Rush is #1 hands down. I have long contended that if you think Rush is the greatest ever then you used to or currently still do smoke pot. I have NEVER met a person who loves Rush that didn't used to smoke the stuff.

Phish, Grateful Dead, Dave Mathews Band, I don't get their appeal either.

I don't get what's so great about the Foo Fighters either. Grohl seems like a cool guy but the music does nothing for me.

I like Pink Floyd.

I'll crank 'Everlong' in the car from time to time, when its just me. My old lady LOVES Foo Fighters, I can't help but to think everything they've done in the last 15-20 years is just garbage. 

sumdood
Posts
9482
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
1 day ago
Moto Nomad wrote:
I could never get into Phish either. Even went to see them in the 90s. Nope, nothing. It was like where all the Deadheads went when...

I could never get into Phish either. Even went to see them in the 90s. Nope, nothing. It was like where all the Deadheads went when the Dead wasn't on tour.

 

I had the opposite experience with the Grateful Dead. Didn't know who they were, went to see them and they were on fire, I was blown away. Then I got into them and started going to all the local shows. I didn't quit my job and follow them around in a microbus 😆, but I would go to the shows near me, and usually each night they played. I liked the fact that they never played anything the same, or even the same songs from night to night. Each show was completely unique. I also discovered that the nights they were "off" ?  Holy crap, yes the worse most god-awful unorganized hot mess of shit sound you'll ever hear. I can 100% see how people who's first experience was on and off night would run away full speed and never look back 😄 

Phish  ?  Nope, couldn't get into them, I tried, I thought I'd like them because they're pretty much the same format as the dead, but musically they never really got me excited, they're weird and different and off the wall and all, but just don't get into the same "zone" I guess ? I don't know. It's like they try so hard to be off the wall and different that it feels forced, and the "music" part of it isn't there. I tried to like them but just .....don't 🤷‍♂️😄 

Kind of feel the same way about "The Dead" with John Mayer. It's close but not the same.     

2
APLMAN99
Posts
13113
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
1 day ago Edited Date/Time 1 day ago
Rush is #1 hands down. I have long contended that if you think Rush is the greatest ever then you used to or currently still do...

Rush is #1 hands down. I have long contended that if you think Rush is the greatest ever then you used to or currently still do smoke pot. I have NEVER met a person who loves Rush that didn't used to smoke the stuff.

Phish, Grateful Dead, Dave Mathews Band, I don't get their appeal either.

I don't get what's so great about the Foo Fighters either. Grohl seems like a cool guy but the music does nothing for me.

I like Pink Floyd.

Spurdo wrote:
I'll crank 'Everlong' in the car from time to time, when its just me. My old lady LOVES Foo Fighters, I can't help but to think...

I'll crank 'Everlong' in the car from time to time, when its just me. My old lady LOVES Foo Fighters, I can't help but to think everything they've done in the last 15-20 years is just garbage. 

I'm a Foo Fighters fan but don't really listen to much of their music after about 2006 or so.  Maybe slightly later.  

I've seen them 6 times and they put on a decent show but Grohl became a little over the top after they really took off.  

Best Foo show for me was on their 2006 acoustic Skin and Bones tour, at the Paramount in Seattle.  6th row, 2 seats immediately left of center aisle.  The Paramount is a fun, intimate place anyway but it was perfect for the acoustic show.  Grohl was recognizing people in the audience that were behind us and he probably a little bit more storytelling about his time in Seattle than most of the other shows.  Their version of February Stars that night was an incredible, moving concert moment.  

Flatliner
Posts
4424
Joined
11/3/2009
Location
CA
1 day ago

Hey, little girl, is your daddy home?
Did he go away and leave you all alone?
I got a bad desire
Oh, oh, oh, I'm on fire

 

Simmer down Springsteen.  Yikes.

4
ShellyMX
Posts
1827
Joined
3/22/2026
Location
Smyrna, GA, USA
1 day ago

I should mention that I kinda like older foo fighters and the only Cd of theirs I own is their second CD with Monkey wrench on it. Have never gone to any of their concerts because I don’t want to sit through a show where I only like 4 or five songs 

Spurdo
Posts
484
Joined
12/26/2016
Location
FI
1 day ago

Is it too late to add Bob Dylan to the list?

5
kmc140
Posts
447
Joined
11/30/2024
Location
Green Bay, WI, USA
1 day ago Edited Date/Time 1 day ago

Beatles 🤮 ... probably had something to do with every 4th tune on the old Coronet 440 station wagon AM radio... carve my ears out with an ice pick. Try Suburban Lawns "Janitor" for a good pick me up. Oh my genitals... 😁👌

1
1 day ago

Tame Impala (and the Beatles for that matter. 

Has some good tracks but not my type of music. 

seth505
Posts
10242
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
SD, CA, USA
1 day ago
Rush is #1 hands down. I have long contended that if you think Rush is the greatest ever then you used to or currently still do...

Rush is #1 hands down. I have long contended that if you think Rush is the greatest ever then you used to or currently still do smoke pot. I have NEVER met a person who loves Rush that didn't used to smoke the stuff.

Phish, Grateful Dead, Dave Mathews Band, I don't get their appeal either.

I don't get what's so great about the Foo Fighters either. Grohl seems like a cool guy but the music does nothing for me.

I like Pink Floyd.

I guess I'm an outlier, I have literally never smoked pot and I love Rush.

That said, I agree with Phish, Grateful Dead and Beatles🤮

borg
Posts
7083
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
1 day ago
Falcon wrote:
I am a classically trained musician and a guitarist, so I love almost all the guitar greats and can respect their contributions. However, I've never understood...

I am a classically trained musician and a guitarist, so I love almost all the guitar greats and can respect their contributions. However, I've never understood the Eric Clapton hype. I guess you had to be there in the '60s or something. 

 

My best friend doesn't like Bowie or Radiohead and I think he's insane. Also, Spurdo and Borg are now dead to me for not liking Rush. 😔 Haha, J/K guys.

I'm with you on Clapton as a guitarist. He's always ranked in the top 5. He's not top 20. As a singer and songwriter he is an alltime great. Same with Neil Young. 

Sully
Posts
9683
Joined
8/24/2006
Location
JP
1 day ago

I'm really glad to see I'm not alone in hating The Beatles (and U2, Springsteen & Dylan). 

1
APLMAN99
Posts
13113
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
1 day ago
shuggs wrote:
Like a couple of Floyd - money,  Bowie Golden Years & Nazareth Bad Bad Boy were the tunes on the Jukebox back in the day.U2 were...

Like a couple of Floyd - money,  Bowie Golden Years & Nazareth Bad Bad Boy were the tunes on the Jukebox back in the day.

U2 were good until Unforgetable Fire, after that it’s just a nah.

Could never get into Led Zep, JPaige. 

I think Joshua Tree was their last really good album, but I did see them on their Vertigo tour and they put on a very good performance!  

Kenny Banyan
Posts
5375
Joined
6/2/2024
Location
NW Washington, WA, USA
1 day ago

First off The Beatles , Led Zepplin, The Who, Pink Floyd and Fleetwood Mac, are at the top of my list as the best bands of all time imo . The Band I couldn’t never get or why others think they are so great is. The Beastie Boys , I would rather listen to nails on a chalkboard than listen to their garbage. 

1
3
ShellyMX
Posts
1827
Joined
3/22/2026
Location
Smyrna, GA, USA
1 day ago
First off The Beatles , Led Zepplin, The Who, Pink Floyd and Fleetwood Mac, are at the top of my list as the best bands of...

First off The Beatles , Led Zepplin, The Who, Pink Floyd and Fleetwood Mac, are at the top of my list as the best bands of all time imo . The Band I couldn’t never get or why others think they are so great is. The Beastie Boys , I would rather listen to nails on a chalkboard than listen to their garbage. 

Kenny, you have to fight for your right to party

1
1
1 day ago
First off The Beatles , Led Zepplin, The Who, Pink Floyd and Fleetwood Mac, are at the top of my list as the best bands of...

First off The Beatles , Led Zepplin, The Who, Pink Floyd and Fleetwood Mac, are at the top of my list as the best bands of all time imo . The Band I couldn’t never get or why others think they are so great is. The Beastie Boys , I would rather listen to nails on a chalkboard than listen to their garbage. 

Love Fleetwood Mac.

1
Dudley
Posts
671
Joined
9/10/2012
Location
Denver, CO, USA
21 hours ago
ATKpilot99 wrote:

The Doors . And going a little more recent  , Nirvana . 

Sandusky26 wrote:

Nirvana changed the world, I do agree on the Doors though.

ATKpilot99 wrote:

Yep Nirvana is highly regarded ... I just could never understand why , lol .

Nirvana is my pick, 2nd is Green Day. I fault radio stations and genre. They are played on metal, alternative, classic rock, rock, classic and every other radio station. At any given time, one of their songs is playing. No other bands have such a large breadth of play. 

1
Kenny Banyan
Posts
5375
Joined
6/2/2024
Location
NW Washington, WA, USA
20 hours ago
Sandusky26 wrote:

Nirvana changed the world, I do agree on the Doors though.

ATKpilot99 wrote:

Yep Nirvana is highly regarded ... I just could never understand why , lol .

Dudley wrote:
Nirvana is my pick, 2nd is Green Day. I fault radio stations and genre. They are played on metal, alternative, classic rock, rock, classic and every...

Nirvana is my pick, 2nd is Green Day. I fault radio stations and genre. They are played on metal, alternative, classic rock, rock, classic and every other radio station. At any given time, one of their songs is playing. No other bands have such a large breadth of play. 

I’m from the NW and I never liked Nirvana. Of all of the Grunge bands imo they were on the very bottom tier.

2
Dudley
Posts
671
Joined
9/10/2012
Location
Denver, CO, USA
20 hours ago

I’m from the NW and I never liked Nirvana. Of all of the Grunge bands imo they were on the very bottom tier.

Yea, I prefer the pixies to nirvana and always have. 

APLMAN99
Posts
13113
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
16 hours ago

I’m from the NW and I never liked Nirvana. Of all of the Grunge bands imo they were on the very bottom tier.

Dudley wrote:

Yea, I prefer the pixies to nirvana and always have. 

Well to be fair, Cobain preferred the Pixies to Nirvana also…..!

1
APLMAN99
Posts
13113
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
16 hours ago
APLMAN99 wrote:
Just like the title says. For me, the first one I think of is Lou Reed. I don’t dislike his music, but if I didn’t have...

Just like the title says. For me, the first one I think of is Lou Reed. I don’t dislike his music, but if I didn’t have to hear any of his stuff again it wouldn’t bother me. 

Yours? 

TAUTOG wrote:

Lou Reed solo is pretty boring but have you listened to the Velvet underground?

Yeah, and I don’t hate it but it’s still not music that I will go out of my way for. Obviously a few songs are good and I like, but overall I just don’t get the near cult like following. 

1
ATKpilot99
Posts
10527
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI, USA
16 hours ago
APLMAN99 wrote:
Just like the title says. For me, the first one I think of is Lou Reed. I don’t dislike his music, but if I didn’t have...

Just like the title says. For me, the first one I think of is Lou Reed. I don’t dislike his music, but if I didn’t have to hear any of his stuff again it wouldn’t bother me. 

Yours? 

TAUTOG wrote:

Lou Reed solo is pretty boring but have you listened to the Velvet underground?

APLMAN99 wrote:
Yeah, and I don’t hate it but it’s still not music that I will go out of my way for. Obviously a few songs are good...

Yeah, and I don’t hate it but it’s still not music that I will go out of my way for. Obviously a few songs are good and I like, but overall I just don’t get the near cult like following. 

Check out his album "Metal Machine Music" . A double album of nothing but harsh noise and feedback . 

APLMAN99
Posts
13113
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
16 hours ago
TAUTOG wrote:

Lou Reed solo is pretty boring but have you listened to the Velvet underground?

APLMAN99 wrote:
Yeah, and I don’t hate it but it’s still not music that I will go out of my way for. Obviously a few songs are good...

Yeah, and I don’t hate it but it’s still not music that I will go out of my way for. Obviously a few songs are good and I like, but overall I just don’t get the near cult like following. 

ATKpilot99 wrote:

Check out his album "Metal Machine Music" . A double album of nothing but harsh noise and feedback . 

Sounds like straight artistic genius!!!!

flow
Posts
221
Joined
7/27/2022
Location
Ontario, OR, USA
16 hours ago

I've generally struggled to get into the 80's hair metal bands. Both in terms of sound and image the style just isn't my thing I guess. 

1
Chance1216
Posts
9081
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
14 hours ago Edited Date/Time 13 hours ago
flow wrote:

I've generally struggled to get into the 80's hair metal bands. Both in terms of sound and image the style just isn't my thing I guess. 

The only slice of hair metal I liked was the album, Shout at the Devil. That era needs to be forgotten. 

I thought both album covers by the Crue and, Poison were 4 chicks as a kid. 

IMG 9416 1.jpeg?VersionId=IRLLXPc3qfjsb6pKsJcbe9 UhteyPmIMG 9415 1.jpeg?VersionId=zILCly9

1
2

Post a reply to: What highly regarded musician or group did you just not ‘get’?

The Latest