The true World Championship?

MXRalph
Posts
352
Joined
11/13/2022
Location
Fresno, CA US
7/15/2025 10:03am
mxxxeR1 wrote:

It may be hard for an american to understand but the world is bigger than just america

Even with my limited American education, I understand the difference between a country (singular) and countries (plural). 

7/15/2025 10:05am
No those guys I wouldn’t classify as world class riders. But they’re pretty good and you could argue within the top 200-250 in the world. If...

No those guys I wouldn’t classify as world class riders. But they’re pretty good and you could argue within the top 200-250 in the world. If you can qualify for a US national you’re a good rider. 

But there are riders that show up at some mxgp rounds, don’t even have to qualify and are absolutely fucking horrible riders. I’ve seen riders at the china and Argentina rounds that wouldn’t even qualify for the C class at Loretta Lynn’s. And they’re out there scoring points!! 

Mxgp and US nationals are both good series and with some minor tweaks both could be great. But both of them are dying a slow death with mxgp seemingly heading down the shitter quicker. Its unfortunate for moto in general. 

The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.What’s the US equivalent...

The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

In theory yes, but in practice that’s not always the case. I think it was last year in Italy the kid that was like top 5 in emx did mx2 and I think got on the podium? 

The closest equivalent to emx in America would be the A class or even the B class at Loretta Lynn’s or other top amateur races. The top guys from the A class can and usually do jump right into the pro ranks and score top tens. And often times the top 3 in the B or amateur class are nearly just as fast. 

The advantage I would give to emx as far as being a premier feeder series, as they actually race more then a few times a year. 

You bringing up emx was kinda irrelevant to the point I was making, but I don’t mind jumping around. 

1
1
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65542
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
7/15/2025 10:26am
No those guys I wouldn’t classify as world class riders. But they’re pretty good and you could argue within the top 200-250 in the world. If...

No those guys I wouldn’t classify as world class riders. But they’re pretty good and you could argue within the top 200-250 in the world. If you can qualify for a US national you’re a good rider. 

But there are riders that show up at some mxgp rounds, don’t even have to qualify and are absolutely fucking horrible riders. I’ve seen riders at the china and Argentina rounds that wouldn’t even qualify for the C class at Loretta Lynn’s. And they’re out there scoring points!! 

Mxgp and US nationals are both good series and with some minor tweaks both could be great. But both of them are dying a slow death with mxgp seemingly heading down the shitter quicker. Its unfortunate for moto in general. 

The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.What’s the US equivalent...

The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

"What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? "

SMX Next.

3
7/15/2025 10:40am
mxxxeR1 wrote:

It may be hard for an american to understand but the world is bigger than just america

Falcon wrote:
You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been...

You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been the best at literally almost everything for a long time during the 20th century; we sometimes feel like there is so much to learn and know about the USA that we neglect learning about other countries. You'd be hard pressed to find an American citizen who knows how to speak even a 2nd language, and if so, that language is probably Spanish. 

As for Motocross, well, those of us who grew up in the 1980s got to witness the USA win the MXDN every single year. Add to that the American bravado surrounding everything else, and you may understand why we tend to think we're the best, even though recent years would prove otherwise. 

True about the 2nd language.  I speak a few it’s fun.  Every week I speak a little Iroquoian a30k yr old language from here . Originally Ny. Ontario ,  Quebec & now Wi.  Funny last week at 1 of there gas stations a 53 yr old woman asked me for my fed card nickname for Tribal id to skip the taxes .  I said I need another 1/8 . I had a wife beater  on she sees the tan.  She^ Koli pronounced she^ goli the k is a g.  Hellow .  Ya^ ko , Ya^ go , thank you .  Dada = 6.  I get gas I say pump dada . They understand it’s there language. This is a pause between letters,^ . It’s just fun to speak a old language.  My mom is from Holland 1902 to the 1940,s language is called low Dutch .  It could be gone now I don’t think many speak it anymore. 

3

The Shop

LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID US
7/15/2025 10:41am
The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.What’s the US equivalent...

The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

Ummmm I'd say it's the MXGP series.

🤣

4
8
DonM
Posts
8388
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
Fantasy
7/15/2025 11:07am Edited Date/Time 7/15/2025 11:46am
The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.What’s the US equivalent...

The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

LungButter wrote:

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

Ummmm I'd say it's the MXGP series.

🤣

I was going to say last weekends 17th-40th plus a few cherry pickers from the top 15.....😂

1
3
7/15/2025 11:18am
The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.What’s the US equivalent...

The wild card entries shouldn’t be there I agree, but remember how strong EMX is which is a level below MXGP in theory.

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

LungButter wrote:

What’s the US equivalent of EMX ? 

Ummmm I'd say it's the MXGP series.

🤣

DonM wrote:

I was going to say last weekends 17th-40th plus a few cherry pickers from the top 15.....😂

How did the 25th to 35th European riders get there pro card here ?  You need 60 points doing pro ams for American riders . Or 250 pro sport LL race.  So now there’s American riders at 44th + & not getting in. 

3
Shaft721
Posts
205
Joined
3/20/2021
Location
Elyria, OH US
7/15/2025 11:49am

Not the "world championship" but AMA Nationals is definitely the premier motocross championship. 

If MXGP and AMA is 1 and 2 lets rate them on these three things:

1: Tracks.... EASILY AMA

2: Riders..... AMA Jett Hunter Chase Tomac MXGP Lucas Gajser Herlings Febvre I give the nudge to AMA 

3: Atmosphere.... AMA 

 

One day MXGP might actually go back to the good tracks and then it will be closer, but as of now. No way. 

1
6
Beeby
Posts
2061
Joined
9/3/2009
Location
Chicago, IL US
7/15/2025 12:21pm
Shaft721 wrote:
Not the "world championship" but AMA Nationals is definitely the premier motocross championship. If MXGP and AMA is 1 and 2 lets rate them on these three...

Not the "world championship" but AMA Nationals is definitely the premier motocross championship. 

If MXGP and AMA is 1 and 2 lets rate them on these three things:

1: Tracks.... EASILY AMA

2: Riders..... AMA Jett Hunter Chase Tomac MXGP Lucas Gajser Herlings Febvre I give the nudge to AMA 

3: Atmosphere.... AMA 

 

One day MXGP might actually go back to the good tracks and then it will be closer, but as of now. No way. 

Which GP tracks have you been to?

3
Janko630
Posts
114
Joined
7/16/2018
Location
IL US
7/15/2025 12:34pm
mxxxeR1 wrote:

It may be hard for an american to understand but the world is bigger than just america

Falcon wrote:
You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been...

You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been the best at literally almost everything for a long time during the 20th century; we sometimes feel like there is so much to learn and know about the USA that we neglect learning about other countries. You'd be hard pressed to find an American citizen who knows how to speak even a 2nd language, and if so, that language is probably Spanish. 

As for Motocross, well, those of us who grew up in the 1980s got to witness the USA win the MXDN every single year. Add to that the American bravado surrounding everything else, and you may understand why we tend to think we're the best, even though recent years would prove otherwise. 

True about the 2nd language.  I speak a few it’s fun.  Every week I speak a little Iroquoian a30k yr old language from here . Originally...

True about the 2nd language.  I speak a few it’s fun.  Every week I speak a little Iroquoian a30k yr old language from here . Originally Ny. Ontario ,  Quebec & now Wi.  Funny last week at 1 of there gas stations a 53 yr old woman asked me for my fed card nickname for Tribal id to skip the taxes .  I said I need another 1/8 . I had a wife beater  on she sees the tan.  She^ Koli pronounced she^ goli the k is a g.  Hellow .  Ya^ ko , Ya^ go , thank you .  Dada = 6.  I get gas I say pump dada . They understand it’s there language. This is a pause between letters,^ . It’s just fun to speak a old language.  My mom is from Holland 1902 to the 1940,s language is called low Dutch .  It could be gone now I don’t think many speak it anymore. 

30k year old language 😂🤣🤣🤣😂. Sure thing hombre.

yak651
Posts
8595
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI US
Fantasy
7/15/2025 12:47pm

Tony said he would rather keep racing here than go race MXGP. Sorry it hurts your feelings but the us tracks and series is superior. You have some great racers in your series but if it wasn’t for SX more would be trying to find a way to get over here, it’s ok to admit it

2
Shaft721
Posts
205
Joined
3/20/2021
Location
Elyria, OH US
7/15/2025 1:04pm
Shaft721 wrote:
Not the "world championship" but AMA Nationals is definitely the premier motocross championship. If MXGP and AMA is 1 and 2 lets rate them on these three...

Not the "world championship" but AMA Nationals is definitely the premier motocross championship. 

If MXGP and AMA is 1 and 2 lets rate them on these three things:

1: Tracks.... EASILY AMA

2: Riders..... AMA Jett Hunter Chase Tomac MXGP Lucas Gajser Herlings Febvre I give the nudge to AMA 

3: Atmosphere.... AMA 

 

One day MXGP might actually go back to the good tracks and then it will be closer, but as of now. No way. 

Beeby wrote:

Which GP tracks have you been to?

Qatar. Netherlands on a road course :D what a joke. 

1
7/15/2025 1:05pm
Falcon wrote:
You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been...

You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been the best at literally almost everything for a long time during the 20th century; we sometimes feel like there is so much to learn and know about the USA that we neglect learning about other countries. You'd be hard pressed to find an American citizen who knows how to speak even a 2nd language, and if so, that language is probably Spanish. 

As for Motocross, well, those of us who grew up in the 1980s got to witness the USA win the MXDN every single year. Add to that the American bravado surrounding everything else, and you may understand why we tend to think we're the best, even though recent years would prove otherwise. 

True about the 2nd language.  I speak a few it’s fun.  Every week I speak a little Iroquoian a30k yr old language from here . Originally...

True about the 2nd language.  I speak a few it’s fun.  Every week I speak a little Iroquoian a30k yr old language from here . Originally Ny. Ontario ,  Quebec & now Wi.  Funny last week at 1 of there gas stations a 53 yr old woman asked me for my fed card nickname for Tribal id to skip the taxes .  I said I need another 1/8 . I had a wife beater  on she sees the tan.  She^ Koli pronounced she^ goli the k is a g.  Hellow .  Ya^ ko , Ya^ go , thank you .  Dada = 6.  I get gas I say pump dada . They understand it’s there language. This is a pause between letters,^ . It’s just fun to speak a old language.  My mom is from Holland 1902 to the 1940,s language is called low Dutch .  It could be gone now I don’t think many speak it anymore. 

Janko630 wrote:

30k year old language 😂🤣🤣🤣😂. Sure thing hombre.

The Indians where here  tens of thousands of yrs ago.  Decab,iL . Lost a 175 yr old court battle last year to a another Tribe that pushed out.  IL. Forged there land deeds . All of Chicago Land same thing numerous land deeds where forged.  Friendly advise don’t ever say hombre to a Indian on a reservation. Wayy tougher than any ghetto idiots 

4
stewie94
Posts
4659
Joined
2/25/2013
Location
La Plata, MD US
7/15/2025 1:08pm
yak651 wrote:
Tony said he would rather keep racing here than go race MXGP. Sorry it hurts your feelings but the us tracks and series is superior. You...

Tony said he would rather keep racing here than go race MXGP. Sorry it hurts your feelings but the us tracks and series is superior. You have some great racers in your series but if it wasn’t for SX more would be trying to find a way to get over here, it’s ok to admit it

tht still doesn’t qualify the pro nationals as a world championship league / series, tht just means the pro nationals are just better at the moment 

1
smee113
Posts
455
Joined
5/7/2014
Location
Houston, TX US
7/15/2025 1:23pm

A lot of people on here won't want to hear this, but the American series is a bigger deal because of Supercross. That's what brings in the money, and that's why so many top Euros want to race here. Of course, it's kind of a double edged sword, because it's also the reason a lot of them don't end of coming over because they wait too long to develop their Supercross skills.

 

That being said, it's hard to beat the atmosphere of some the European GP's, but it's weighed down by the ones that have nothing going for it.

6
DeStouwer
Posts
3457
Joined
2/17/2015
Location
BE
7/15/2025 1:24pm
HonDawg17 wrote:

We have the fastest racers...been proven true this year for sure. Where's Vialle?, Where's Prado? Reigning MXGP champs and they can't win motos...

DeStouwer wrote:
You're dragging other things into the discussion just to prove your point. The initial statement was "full gates of world class riders", which obviously isn't the...

You're dragging other things into the discussion just to prove your point. The initial statement was "full gates of world class riders", which obviously isn't the case. No one ever mentioned who has the fastest racers but you.

USA wrote:
Do you think this guy would qualify for a US national?

Do you think this guy would qualify for a US national? Screenshot 20250715 100330 Samsung Internet

With ease.

5
NotCore
Posts
741
Joined
8/9/2011
Location
Alpharetta, GA US
7/15/2025 1:27pm
mxxxeR1 wrote:

It may be hard for an american to understand but the world is bigger than just america

Falcon wrote:
You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been...

You have a point about some Americans. As a country, we are pathetically underinformed about other places. I think it comes from the USA having been the best at literally almost everything for a long time during the 20th century; we sometimes feel like there is so much to learn and know about the USA that we neglect learning about other countries. You'd be hard pressed to find an American citizen who knows how to speak even a 2nd language, and if so, that language is probably Spanish. 

As for Motocross, well, those of us who grew up in the 1980s got to witness the USA win the MXDN every single year. Add to that the American bravado surrounding everything else, and you may understand why we tend to think we're the best, even though recent years would prove otherwise. 

You can choose to be an apologists for your countrymen if you want, but let me ask you this:  If there was a historic common language across Europe, how many Europeans would choose to learn a second one? Its simply pragmatic for them, It's not worldly.  

1
joekarter
Posts
29
Joined
6/8/2022
Location
Cottonwood, AZ US
7/15/2025 1:40pm

I think the real discussion isn't whether our (the AMA series) is the world championship (it's not) but rather why is MXGP such a shadow of what it once was.  Tracks in countries around the world are and should be different and present riders with an array of challenges not to mention the travel, language barriers and just simple things like adapting to the food and cultures.  If you watch F1 and Indycar they're both exciting but there's no question which one is the world championship and which one is a domestic series...it's not even close.  And that's what MXGP should look and feel like.  Marty Motes won plenty of races but we really remember him for the day at Carlsbad.  Marty Smith won a boatload here in America but his campaign against Gaston made him a legend, and Deegan will be seen as a once in a lifetime rider but money and the diminishing status of the world championships will keep him from ever holding the title.  The question isn't really about who races where, it's more about what can be done to create a true world championship. 

3
shortty761
Posts
695
Joined
4/2/2024
Location
Newport News, VA US
7/15/2025 1:41pm

Hot take: Canadian Nationals are more enticing to watch, especially in person, than MXGP these days.

1
1
7/15/2025 1:52pm

Two different series.  Traveling within the contiguous 48 states isn’t anywhere comparable to traveling and acclimating between continents.  It’d kill most Americans.

3
1
USA
Posts
2536
Joined
9/4/2016
Location
Richmond, TX US
Fantasy
7/15/2025 1:55pm
DeStouwer wrote:
You're dragging other things into the discussion just to prove your point. The initial statement was "full gates of world class riders", which obviously isn't the...

You're dragging other things into the discussion just to prove your point. The initial statement was "full gates of world class riders", which obviously isn't the case. No one ever mentioned who has the fastest racers but you.

USA wrote:
Do you think this guy would qualify for a US national?

Do you think this guy would qualify for a US national? Screenshot 20250715 100330 Samsung Internet

DeStouwer wrote:

With ease.

You're probably right on that. But I do think its messed up to say Stav Orland isn't 'world class' (whatever that means) because he scored points, when he's regularly beating Jack Chambers and others that have scored many many GP points. 

2
Beeby
Posts
2061
Joined
9/3/2009
Location
Chicago, IL US
7/15/2025 2:05pm
Shaft721 wrote:
Not the "world championship" but AMA Nationals is definitely the premier motocross championship. If MXGP and AMA is 1 and 2 lets rate them on these three...

Not the "world championship" but AMA Nationals is definitely the premier motocross championship. 

If MXGP and AMA is 1 and 2 lets rate them on these three things:

1: Tracks.... EASILY AMA

2: Riders..... AMA Jett Hunter Chase Tomac MXGP Lucas Gajser Herlings Febvre I give the nudge to AMA 

3: Atmosphere.... AMA 

 

One day MXGP might actually go back to the good tracks and then it will be closer, but as of now. No way. 

Beeby wrote:

Which GP tracks have you been to?

Shaft721 wrote:

Qatar. Netherlands on a road course :D what a joke. 

Yeah, bad examples. Get yourself to one of the good ones and I think you'll change your opinion, especially the atmosphere one. I'd also argue the riders one too, but I only have the nations to go on and only one of the US riders you listed rode and he went 2 - 3 both times losing to Gajser.

1
CPR
Posts
6628
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
7/15/2025 2:15pm
mxxxeR1 wrote:

It may be hard for an american to understand but the world is bigger than just america

NotCore wrote:

It may be hard for a European to understand, but the USA is as large geographically as all of Europe.

Awesome, if geographic size is the standard, then the Aussie series just had a huge jump in status!

4
Gravel
Posts
1789
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA US
7/15/2025 2:31pm
mxxxeR1 wrote:

It may be hard for an american to understand but the world is bigger than just america

But does all those foreign places even matter? They got no BBQ, no Tacobell, no PBR.. 

3
Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW AU
7/15/2025 2:46pm

I reckon if it weren't for supercross MXGP would be in even more dire straits. I reckon the difficulty of learning SX keeps a lot of top tier GP riders from moving to the states. Generally they need to come over as young as possible before it gets too difficult. Prado is the exception (and leaving aside his present difficulties, we've yet to see how he'll do indoors). If the US just had the outdoors series I don't see any reason why the top Euros would stay in Europe. Worse money, worse tracks, worse practice and training facilities. 

It seems MXGP is determined to screw itself up. For example, with its overseas races they're based on going to wherever the local government is willing to pay the most. For example, the new Aus MXGP round is going to Darwin. It's the least populated part of Australia by a large margin and, as far as I know, has little to no MX scene or community. 

3
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID US
7/15/2025 2:54pm

Two different series.  Traveling within the contiguous 48 states isn’t anywhere comparable to traveling and acclimating between continents.  It’d kill most Americans.

Lets not act like they are constantly crossing the globe.

From the looks of it they do a fly away at the beginning and few at the end.  The rest are all pretty close, especially by US standards.  We have guys flying 3 time zones to race every weekend, most of Europe is in a single time zone.

Different countries, sure.  Globetrotters on extreme travel schdules.....no.

1
1
Titan1
Posts
9409
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT US
7/15/2025 3:05pm Edited Date/Time 7/15/2025 3:06pm

Is the Olympics a world championship, only held in one country?  

The track and field world championships are held ONLY in Tokyo this year?

The winner of the UCI Road World Championships Elite Men's Road Race is considered a world champion, even though that race is only held in one country...

How/Why are those considered world championships when they don't compete all over the world, and the athletes don't have to contend with jet lag, different food, passport and visa issues, different cultures etc.? 

They are world championships because athletes from all over the world compete in them...where an event is held is of lesser import than where the athletes competing in the event are from...

1
3
kijen
Posts
1212
Joined
10/1/2010
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
7/15/2025 3:20pm

Really few sports can claim to be a world championship, and further,  probably only the Olympics is deserving of that.  The fact MXGP races across the globe, does not make it world championship,  it does not have competitive riders from most of these far away places. MXGP  is just as regional as the AMA, since majority of its riders are European. Probably not popular opinion, but whatever...

1
matze
Posts
1866
Joined
3/1/2014
Location
Stuttgart DE
7/15/2025 3:34pm Edited Date/Time 7/15/2025 3:35pm
mxxxeR1 wrote:

It may be hard for an american to understand but the world is bigger than just america

NotCore wrote:

It may be hard for a European to understand, but the USA is as large geographically as all of Europe.

It may be hard for an American to understand, but Europe is as large geographically as all of USA.

1
2
Park Boys
Posts
3811
Joined
3/23/2012
Location
MH US
7/15/2025 3:44pm

Idk why we get all hung up on if it’s in USA or the “world” the MXGP championship leaves Europe three times over twenty rounds. When ever you ask riders about differences they always say here vs Europe. Americans have a very American centric outlook as do Europeans. The MXGP is basically the European motocross champ ship and has been this way for nearly its entire history. 

The talent of competitors is far more important then talking about the three times it leaves Europe. Injuries make or break a season weather it’s in the AMA series or MXGP. 

1
2

Post a reply to: The true World Championship?

The Latest