It's pretty cool how much influence this forum has on the industry

971_Fan
Posts
1176
Joined
4/11/2024
Location
Los Angeles, CA, USA
3/1/2025 12:49pm Edited Date/Time 3/1/2025 12:53pm
Juck wrote:
A week ago there was a thread on here about how Ricky was too hard on Sexton in the commentary booth and then the next race...

A week ago there was a thread on here about how Ricky was too hard on Sexton in the commentary booth and then the next race Ricky did not shut up about why he was hard on Sexton, saying it was because he has such high expectations of him and respects his ability so much.

I thought that was pretty funny. There's been quite a few other pro's and ex pro's I've heard mention reading about themselves on Vital. I think it's pretty stupid that they care that much, which makes it funny. 

That was being said all over social media. 

Giving my post a thumbs up 👍 

1
Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW, AU
3/1/2025 4:08pm
3strokemx wrote:
I think it's more likely that RC realized he went kind of hard, or one of Chases' sponsors said something, so he provided more context and...

I think it's more likely that RC realized he went kind of hard, or one of Chases' sponsors said something, so he provided more context and justification. 

No forum needed.


Also, a lot of people in the industry can't read or write.

 

And in RC's case, speak. 

1
8
JJ376
Posts
205
Joined
8/9/2016
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
3/1/2025 4:27pm

Thor lost it when they ditched the old logo and then doubled down with the new logo. Thor lost their whole identity. 

We just can’t live in the past, we’ve got eyes on the future and more great stuff on the way. It’s not for everyone, and that’s ok. We’ve made massive changes in the past, the logo has changed several times over 57 years, and we know full well that stagnation can be the death of a brand. We race forward. 

1
3
JJ376
Posts
205
Joined
8/9/2016
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
3/1/2025 4:37pm

To shed some light…many of us in the industry read along with this forum. Most have stopped responding because it is frustrating trying to exchange with the ill-informed who stand firm with their notably off base guesses about what’s really going on. I personally started chiming in because I have dedicated my life to this industry and love the banter, plus it is important to me to help clarify a lot of the aforementioned “guesses”, just trying to help folks out to better and more accurately understand how things work. 

15
4

The Shop

3/1/2025 4:57pm

I mean, I think the forum has minimal impact given how the broadcast caters to newbies (which I'm not entirely against). But the lack of technical and deep insights makes the value-add of the broadcast pretty low for people who ride bikes.

There have been some fairly constructive criticisms of the broadcast which they have not really changed, such as the race coverage (e.g. missing incidents), use of split screens / PiP, the terrible number board that used to have (hated the one on Speed across the top)... and list goes on. I don't understand why American broadcasts insist on doing stuff at a dumbed down level. Even mentioning Monster in tandem with Supercross makes the whole series sound less prestigious than what it could be. It could be worse - the Australian commentators name each section. One race I went to called a small section "Coolangatta Sands" (a popular beachside suburb) and every lap they mentioned it. 

When it comes to the bikes, again, hard to think the forum has much impact. I would say perhaps with the media given DC is on here, and RacerX. If anything, Vital is known just as a whinge channel.

3
3strokemx
Posts
2847
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
3/1/2025 5:04pm

Thor lost it when they ditched the old logo and then doubled down with the new logo. Thor lost their whole identity. 

The new Thor logo looks a lot like one of these
Screen Shot 2025-03-01 at 8.03.41 PM

6
3/1/2025 5:15pm
I mean, I think the forum has minimal impact given how the broadcast caters to newbies (which I'm not entirely against). But the lack of technical...

I mean, I think the forum has minimal impact given how the broadcast caters to newbies (which I'm not entirely against). But the lack of technical and deep insights makes the value-add of the broadcast pretty low for people who ride bikes.

There have been some fairly constructive criticisms of the broadcast which they have not really changed, such as the race coverage (e.g. missing incidents), use of split screens / PiP, the terrible number board that used to have (hated the one on Speed across the top)... and list goes on. I don't understand why American broadcasts insist on doing stuff at a dumbed down level. Even mentioning Monster in tandem with Supercross makes the whole series sound less prestigious than what it could be. It could be worse - the Australian commentators name each section. One race I went to called a small section "Coolangatta Sands" (a popular beachside suburb) and every lap they mentioned it. 

When it comes to the bikes, again, hard to think the forum has much impact. I would say perhaps with the media given DC is on here, and RacerX. If anything, Vital is known just as a whinge channel.

I always wonder why they dumb some stuff down for the "casual" viewer these days. It's being broadcast on a streaming service that we pay for each month, and you intentionally have to scroll thru and choose the link. It's not like anyone is just flipping channels & SX happens to be on ESPN2, so a viewer will watch because it looks exciting. That only happened in the 90's & '00's at 2am on a Sunday morning. 

Knowledgeable people are watching the broadcasts. It would be great to have knowledgeable broadcasters that can communicate well without the nonsense. 

Jmo of course...

12
JJ376
Posts
205
Joined
8/9/2016
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
3/1/2025 5:26pm
I mean, I think the forum has minimal impact given how the broadcast caters to newbies (which I'm not entirely against). But the lack of technical...

I mean, I think the forum has minimal impact given how the broadcast caters to newbies (which I'm not entirely against). But the lack of technical and deep insights makes the value-add of the broadcast pretty low for people who ride bikes.

There have been some fairly constructive criticisms of the broadcast which they have not really changed, such as the race coverage (e.g. missing incidents), use of split screens / PiP, the terrible number board that used to have (hated the one on Speed across the top)... and list goes on. I don't understand why American broadcasts insist on doing stuff at a dumbed down level. Even mentioning Monster in tandem with Supercross makes the whole series sound less prestigious than what it could be. It could be worse - the Australian commentators name each section. One race I went to called a small section "Coolangatta Sands" (a popular beachside suburb) and every lap they mentioned it. 

When it comes to the bikes, again, hard to think the forum has much impact. I would say perhaps with the media given DC is on here, and RacerX. If anything, Vital is known just as a whinge channel.

Neverclear wrote:
I always wonder why they dumb some stuff down for the "casual" viewer these days. It's being broadcast on a streaming service that we pay for...

I always wonder why they dumb some stuff down for the "casual" viewer these days. It's being broadcast on a streaming service that we pay for each month, and you intentionally have to scroll thru and choose the link. It's not like anyone is just flipping channels & SX happens to be on ESPN2, so a viewer will watch because it looks exciting. That only happened in the 90's & '00's at 2am on a Sunday morning. 

Knowledgeable people are watching the broadcasts. It would be great to have knowledgeable broadcasters that can communicate well without the nonsense. 

Jmo of course...

I have always struggled with this. All of your points are spot on, regarding how we knowledgeable fans seek out and watch these broadcasts. But we do need to have that balance for people who are otherwise new to the sport; Diffey is great for the lay person, while Carmichael and Stewie provide legit insights for those of us who know what’s going on? It was the same, I feel, with Ralph and Fro - one for the “civilian” and one for those of us in the scene. 

1
6
3/1/2025 6:56pm
JJ376 wrote:
I have always struggled with this. All of your points are spot on, regarding how we knowledgeable fans seek out and watch these broadcasts. But we...

I have always struggled with this. All of your points are spot on, regarding how we knowledgeable fans seek out and watch these broadcasts. But we do need to have that balance for people who are otherwise new to the sport; Diffey is great for the lay person, while Carmichael and Stewie provide legit insights for those of us who know what’s going on? It was the same, I feel, with Ralph and Fro - one for the “civilian” and one for those of us in the scene. 

The most common style of commentating is to have the lead commentator (examples, Diffey, Blair, Shaheen, Art etc.) who call the race, and then the "colour" commentator for technical comment (example, Fro, the past pro riders on MX season (my favourite season for race calling), Carmichael, Stew, AC, Martin (also pretty decent). Then you have a pit / roaming reporter (Erin Bates, Jt etc.). That's it.

It is a standard formula and tried and true. The current broadcast has up to 5 people involved with a race broadcast, not to mention the non-race elements.

The issue is finding a good colour commentator. You need to know your stuff AND be well spoken. In my view, both Carmichael and Stew need to work on the latter, although Stew is far more chill and thus easier to listen to. I would much prefer AC, Martin, Rick Johnson, Emig to name a few alternatives. As for the lead commentator, I think they all are decent, but Diffey or Blair I would say are my top picks. I do like Weege but he is does way more yelling in SX than MX - not sure if that is the broadcast director making him to that.

5
2
3/1/2025 7:25pm
Apparently not enough

Apparently not enough
IMG 8046 0.png?VersionId=tjzPvmD7nLlbCZ4TBkYpwP1nseYp7

OwenJakes wrote:

At least the jersey matches the pants. 

I thought that this place would like this stuff .   For a brand to be at the top, You have to continue to innovate and...

I thought that this place would like this stuff .   For a brand to be at the top, You have to continue to innovate and change. Doing the same stuff over and over is not going to allow for a lot of growth.   They were who they were at what was/is considered their prime, by doing stuff like this. Not just remaking old designs or recycling colorways. 

 

Look at what Seven did to motocross gear. Years ago when it came out there was nothing like it. Now every high end gear is made up of stretch materials and has that snug fit. If Seven just came out with gear and did it the same as everybody else , they may not still be around today. 

 

For every person asking for the old logo to come back, There have been people posting about how Thor gear never changes.  Hate it or love it, they are being talked about a lot on here. Getting eyes on the gear and brand .  

I like it. I was happy to see that it was bright and not a pale pink/blue.

Gotta disagree with what you said about Seven. Axo did it first but it didn’t really take off because it didn’t have the name behind it like seven. 

2
PNWMXer
Posts
1772
Joined
1/13/2022
Location
Washington, WA, USA
3/1/2025 7:31pm
MotoCoUSA wrote:

I’ll believe it when there’s a Japanese 350

There is…but they were made in the 70s and were called Scramblers or Enduros…😂

Tyler D
Posts
2411
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
La, CA, USA
3/1/2025 7:34pm

That thor stuff is fine. i like it. it'll catch on. 

2
1
Apers144
Posts
19
Joined
9/26/2022
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
3/1/2025 7:36pm
Apparently not enough

Apparently not enough
IMG 8046 0.png?VersionId=tjzPvmD7nLlbCZ4TBkYpwP1nseYp7

JJ376 wrote:

Took you guys long enough, I nearly posted it myself a couple days ago out of pure masochism 😂😂 - the THOR guy

Keep killin it JJ! 

2
1
StillSmokin
Posts
739
Joined
3/18/2022
Location
Edmond, OK, USA
3/1/2025 7:54pm

“I can’t believe that dickhead StillSmokin calls me BoxHead” - Sexton

*crashes again*

3
3/1/2025 11:02pm

*industrie 

2
Chain ChaTTer
Posts
178
Joined
12/15/2024
Location
Castle Rock, WA, USA
3/2/2025 2:01am
Nairb#70 wrote:

We need better and more examples of why you believe this to be true.

I may be completely wrong here but thought today that I didn't see another publication other than on vital of KTM's financial problems...I did see the usual socials presenting it but that was only after a 5+ page thread on here discussing it.

And then boom...this week KTM releases a social media post telling us of 'everything's ok and new beginnings' etc.

Maybe I'm off base but absolutely someone on the orange crew saw that.

5
3/2/2025 4:12am

I will say, the Daytona race was called in a way, way, way more chill manner. It's almost like they all took a chill pill... or some pill. Except for Diffy.

It was actually an enjoyable broadcast in my view. Ricky wasn't doing his usual "A lot of time left" statements (with 1 minute to go) and Stew kept it professional with less jokes and stuff. So maybe.... just maybe there is some impact. 

3
1
katooom
Posts
599
Joined
9/3/2010
Location
Broad Run, VA, USA
3/2/2025 5:08am
I will say, the Daytona race was called in a way, way, way more chill manner. It's almost like they all took a chill pill... or...

I will say, the Daytona race was called in a way, way, way more chill manner. It's almost like they all took a chill pill... or some pill. Except for Diffy.

It was actually an enjoyable broadcast in my view. Ricky wasn't doing his usual "A lot of time left" statements (with 1 minute to go) and Stew kept it professional with less jokes and stuff. So maybe.... just maybe there is some impact. 

Gotta agree.  Substitute Weege for Diff would be big improvement.  

Nice not have Screech chime in with her 3min long 'I talked to' diatribes.  They really only need one sideline reporter anyway.

4
arebnac
Posts
379
Joined
4/25/2021
Location
UY
3/2/2025 5:11am
Juck wrote:
A week ago there was a thread on here about how Ricky was too hard on Sexton in the commentary booth and then the next race...

A week ago there was a thread on here about how Ricky was too hard on Sexton in the commentary booth and then the next race Ricky did not shut up about why he was hard on Sexton, saying it was because he has such high expectations of him and respects his ability so much.

I thought that was pretty funny. There's been quite a few other pro's and ex pro's I've heard mention reading about themselves on Vital. I think it's pretty stupid that they care that much, which makes it funny. 

Really? Oh, let me try then:

- Hey, broadcast team, can you fellas PLEASE stop with the constant and exagerated compliments about the riders?? for f sake.
We understood that EVERY RIDER on the screen "has been different this year, its a new ~rider~, more motivated, more healthy, more strong, more confident with his bike". ...Jeezz cut that S out, PLEASE.
Daytona 25 was my first time watching most of the race on MUTE because this is getting out of their hands! 
Diffey, Weege are good, why not to have both on the team instead of the others?
Thanks!

hope it works

3
2
3strokemx
Posts
2847
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
3/2/2025 6:13am
I may be completely wrong here but thought today that I didn't see another publication other than on vital of KTM's financial problems...I did see the...

I may be completely wrong here but thought today that I didn't see another publication other than on vital of KTM's financial problems...I did see the usual socials presenting it but that was only after a 5+ page thread on here discussing it.

And then boom...this week KTM releases a social media post telling us of 'everything's ok and new beginnings' etc.

Maybe I'm off base but absolutely someone on the orange crew saw that.

Cooksy announced it before it caught fire on this forum.

2
4
Tyler D
Posts
2411
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
La, CA, USA
3/2/2025 8:07am
I will say, the Daytona race was called in a way, way, way more chill manner. It's almost like they all took a chill pill... or...

I will say, the Daytona race was called in a way, way, way more chill manner. It's almost like they all took a chill pill... or some pill. Except for Diffy.

It was actually an enjoyable broadcast in my view. Ricky wasn't doing his usual "A lot of time left" statements (with 1 minute to go) and Stew kept it professional with less jokes and stuff. So maybe.... just maybe there is some impact. 

Don't wanna jinx it, but I thought to myself Rick sounds like he might finally be done trying to play analyst. No wind in those sails tonight. Or maybe he just didn't drink enough white monster idk

1
3
lumpy790
Posts
11643
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
3/2/2025 8:16am

Did Daytona use a different TV crew? 

In the practice broadcast they kept showing riders just putting around the track not on a hot lap and they weren’t showing the lap times. 

TAUTOG
Posts
1707
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
3/2/2025 9:14am

Thor lost it when they ditched the old logo and then doubled down with the new logo. Thor lost their whole identity. 

3strokemx wrote:
The new Thor logo looks a lot like one of these

The new Thor logo looks a lot like one of these
Screen Shot 2025-03-01 at 8.03.41 PM

A couple of weeks ago one of my buddies and his wife where watching the races with me and she said "Does it say "T.H.O.T." on his shirt?" hahaha

2
JJ376
Posts
205
Joined
8/9/2016
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
3/2/2025 9:33am

Thor lost it when they ditched the old logo and then doubled down with the new logo. Thor lost their whole identity. 

3strokemx wrote:
The new Thor logo looks a lot like one of these

The new Thor logo looks a lot like one of these
Screen Shot 2025-03-01 at 8.03.41 PM

TAUTOG wrote:
A couple of weeks ago one of my buddies and his wife where watching the races with me and she said "Does it say "T.H.O.T." on...

A couple of weeks ago one of my buddies and his wife where watching the races with me and she said "Does it say "T.H.O.T." on his shirt?" hahaha

Dude, the original version of our “tech logo” fully looked like THOT, we had to make a change after a couple seasons, it was hilarious. 

2
Tiki
Posts
10637
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
Corona, CA, USA
Fantasy
3/2/2025 9:33am

Leigh Diffey is still making ears bleed with his announcing. I'd say we haven't enough influence. 

9
3strokemx
Posts
2847
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
3/2/2025 11:36am
katooom wrote:
Gotta agree.  Substitute Weege for Diff would be big improvement.  Nice not have Screech chime in with her 3min long 'I talked to' diatribes.  They really...

Gotta agree.  Substitute Weege for Diff would be big improvement.  

Nice not have Screech chime in with her 3min long 'I talked to' diatribes.  They really only need one sideline reporter anyway.

The thing I noticed about Leigh is that he spends 50% talking about something not on the screen.  It's kind of distracting when there is a good race happening.
 

1
devotid
Posts
834
Joined
12/16/2018
Location
Saginaw, MI, USA
3/2/2025 11:48am

"It's pretty cool how much influence this forum has on the industry"

The last time I mentioned vital around actual racers they stuffed me into a trash can after giving me a wedgie. I wont make that mistake again. Apparently watching racing and actually racing is WAY different. 

I learned. 

2
2
Tyler D
Posts
2411
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
La, CA, USA
3/2/2025 12:42pm
katooom wrote:
Gotta agree.  Substitute Weege for Diff would be big improvement.  Nice not have Screech chime in with her 3min long 'I talked to' diatribes.  They really...

Gotta agree.  Substitute Weege for Diff would be big improvement.  

Nice not have Screech chime in with her 3min long 'I talked to' diatribes.  They really only need one sideline reporter anyway.

3strokemx wrote:
The thing I noticed about Leigh is that he spends 50% talking about something not on the screen.  It's kind of distracting when there is a...

The thing I noticed about Leigh is that he spends 50% talking about something not on the screen.  It's kind of distracting when there is a good race happening.
 

There were a few times tho it was appreciated. He was trying to call a race while Bondo still wanted to play Blow the Leader. 

1
1
ML512
Posts
17001
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
Fantasy
3/2/2025 1:28pm
Juck wrote:
A week ago there was a thread on here about how Ricky was too hard on Sexton in the commentary booth and then the next race...

A week ago there was a thread on here about how Ricky was too hard on Sexton in the commentary booth and then the next race Ricky did not shut up about why he was hard on Sexton, saying it was because he has such high expectations of him and respects his ability so much.

I thought that was pretty funny. There's been quite a few other pro's and ex pro's I've heard mention reading about themselves on Vital. I think it's pretty stupid that they care that much, which makes it funny. 

Stop kidding yourself.  The opinions here are a gnat on a flea's ass.   

The amount of calls I get from around the industry about what's on the forum and what people comment towards it would beg to differ.

12

Post a reply to: It's pretty cool how much influence this forum has on the industry

The Latest