SX should not race in mud like THAT.

aees
Posts
2846
Joined
8/20/2015
Location
USA
1/15/2024 4:11am
aees wrote:
No it does not. The amount of luck involved is ridiculous. Just lock at the results 😂 Shimoda, Vohland, Trasher is by your standard worse riders...

No it does not. The amount of luck involved is ridiculous. Just lock at the results 😂

Shimoda, Vohland, Trasher is by your standard worse riders than Yoder.

Mcelrath almost on the podium. You see that happening often this year? 

A little bit of wet or muddy conditions ok, if they can jump pretty much all the jumps. Most riders had wheels on ground in the finals yesterday. You think that is supercross?

Tumic wrote:
Stop calling it luck. Shimoda crashed and thatcould have caused the bike problem. Vohland raped the clutch the same way Tomac has done it before and...

Stop calling it luck. Shimoda crashed and thatcould have caused the bike problem. Vohland raped the clutch the same way Tomac has done it before and fried the bike.

The mud races takes skill to go fast and navigate the track in bad conditions.

And thanks to high compression race engines they become more fragile in the mud than a stock engine so the riders have to take care of the engine to.

 

So those things is not luck. BUT i would not say the RACING was great. Racing for me is when people switch places. Racing the other riders and the track, not rolling around trying to survive and then in the middle of it passes a guy that has stoped, tipped over or the bike has died.

 

It is mostly luck, otherwise you would have the same riders ending up in the same place pretty much in every muddrace as you do in a normal race. It is impossible to be consistent.

Anderson going over the front at a start straight, you see that happening often? Smoking clutch In 2 laps? McElrath 4th? You put that to skills and not luck? You think he would do it again if he got 5 more tries?

Luck is about not having another riders falling across the track in front of you. Not getting mud or a stone caught in the chain. Your gate and rut not being filled with things you can't see. Not having the throttle or anything else brake for a small tip over that pretty much every rider had. 

1
4
Gordon Liddy
Posts
1387
Joined
8/19/2019
Location
Butte, MT, USA
1/15/2024 4:57am
Gworm wrote:
I’ll admit I gave the OP an up vote.  I always hated racing in it, but I did when I was young. And I don’t enjoy...

I’ll admit I gave the OP an up vote. 
I always hated racing in it, but I did when I was young. And I don’t enjoy watching muddy Supercross. I would much rather see them able to ride the track properly, rather than dog paddle around rolling the jumps. But maybe that would justify the cool kids calling it “Supy”  though 

I agree, once it’s all in place, you can’t cancel it, but I do think they should change the schedule. Why do all of the first rounds need to be in CA anyway?

Now outdoors, it’s a different situation. But also outdoors, there is a natural base that can absorb the moisture, and it’s not all in a flat area, so there is runoff. Yes, I know they can still get terrible, but 1/2 an inch won’t destroy most outdoor tracks like it does the thin layer of dirt in the stadiums. 
 

Feel free to call me a wimp. I’m tough enough to take it and old enough to not care!

Agreed. I watched the first minutes of the first 250 heat.  That was all I needed to see. It was going to be a night of...

Agreed.

I watched the first minutes of the first 250 heat. 

That was all I needed to see.

It was going to be a night of plodding around, just surviving. 

Then watched the start of the 450 main an hour ago.

Didn't even watch a full lap.

 

Not saying they shouldn't run the event.

Just saying it wasn't worth my time to watch it. 

It's always going to be a crap shoot at the races without a roof, in a series run mostly in the winter, and early spring months.

I didn't  watch either.  I checked  the results the next day.  

3
Gator724
Posts
901
Joined
4/7/2023
Location
Greenville, SC, USA
1/15/2024 6:34am
ga_pike wrote:
So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.     That said...

So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.  

 

That said, I didn't really enjoy last night's race.  I almost wonder if the racers today are not as adept in bad conditions for some reason.  

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

7
davistld01
Posts
9317
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Springfield, MO, USA
1/15/2024 6:39am

In that kind of quagmire, starts are absolutely priority. Look at Sexton. He was over a bike length ahead of everybody else going into the first corner, and it was enough to get him over the finish line first. Mud is the great equalizer for sure. 

The Shop

mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
1/15/2024 6:41am
ga_pike wrote:
So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.     That said...

So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.  

 

That said, I didn't really enjoy last night's race.  I almost wonder if the racers today are not as adept in bad conditions for some reason.  

Gator724 wrote:
Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a...

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

6
1
Gator724
Posts
901
Joined
4/7/2023
Location
Greenville, SC, USA
1/15/2024 7:24am
ga_pike wrote:
So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.     That said...

So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.  

 

That said, I didn't really enjoy last night's race.  I almost wonder if the racers today are not as adept in bad conditions for some reason.  

Gator724 wrote:
Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a...

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

mxb2 wrote:

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

Any race that they have to shorten, shorten the points too. Easy 

6
TyRod
Posts
115
Joined
4/9/2020
Location
USA
1/15/2024 7:51am Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 7:59am

Fingers crossed we don't have a repeat of the SF race in the remaining 10, open air stadium races!

Chance1216
Posts
8868
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
1/15/2024 8:12am Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 8:12am
Gator724 wrote:
Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a...

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

mxb2 wrote:

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

Gator724 wrote:

Any race that they have to shorten, shorten the points too. Easy 

I think they should get gold stars and, participation trophy’s that day instead of points. Nobody’s left out and, everybody wins. 

6
1
Gator724
Posts
901
Joined
4/7/2023
Location
Greenville, SC, USA
1/15/2024 8:17am
TyRod wrote:

Fingers crossed we don't have a repeat of the SF race in the remaining 10, open air stadium races!

50% chance of rain in San Diego 

3
ATKpilot99
Posts
10491
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI, USA
1/15/2024 8:26am
TyRod wrote:

Fingers crossed we don't have a repeat of the SF race in the remaining 10, open air stadium races!

Gator724 wrote:

50% chance of rain in San Diego 

Though there's only a 10% chance of that .

1/15/2024 8:42am
Gator724 wrote:
Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a...

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

mxb2 wrote:

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

Gator724 wrote:

Any race that they have to shorten, shorten the points too. Easy 

What about shortening a race for extreme heat?  Anytime they shorten a race it is because there is something making it more difficult.  Only time I might think awarding less points might be a good idea , is if You do not have a full gate in the heats and main.  Fewer racers making it easier to get points.    A mud race , or extreme heat or cold ad to the skill needed to finish.Yes its different from a dry race in many ways. And there can be bad luck that results in a DNF. But a skilled mud rider will also know how to keep the bike going in that mud. But I challenge you to find a rider who thinks it was easier. And reducing the points for a race that is more difficult is crazy. Everybody who races knows there is the chance of a Mud race. 

The Privateers that are going out and destroying their bikes , might even have a better chance at scoring a better finish. Look at some of the great finishes from mud races. Dowd and Henry at Hangtown. I'm not able to remember his name right now but there was a privateer that got a 3rd at Daytona in the 450 class on a Honda. I'm sure there are many others who were great mud riders and just like a more technical track will award some riders, the mud awards them with better finishes.  

 

I am a Jett fan, and bummed that he did so badly. But everybody had to ride the same track. Mud is a part of MX and SX. While I do like dry races better. I think its great that You can buy a ticket to a Pro race and not have to worry if it will be moved or canceled. I'm sure there are people who look forward to going to their local SX/MX all year. And they can plan on going , knowing that only the most extreme weather or global pandemic will cause it not to happen. With other forms of racing that are canceled or moved, You might end up buying a ticket and not getting to go after it gets postponed. Many tickets will say they are non refundable too. 

   

2
Press516
Posts
5856
Joined
9/11/2018
Location
Silver City, CX
Fantasy
1/15/2024 8:47am

A mudder every now and then?  Yep, let's do it.  It's another challenge that they have to be ready for.  Every week?  Please no.

Some of the old guys in here might remember the CMC Madera mud race in 1979...  

Madera mud

4
dsoll703
Posts
271
Joined
10/11/2023
Location
Canton, GA, USA
Fantasy
1/15/2024 8:51am Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 8:52am

The problem with having SF this early in the schedule is that logistically it makes sense to have as many west coast races as feasible in a row with A1 being the start of the season
 

Driving from one coast to the other side then back again doesn’t help any of the people associated with putting on a great show. From the drivers to Dirt Works and even the riders themselves.

1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/15/2024 8:54am
Chance1216 wrote:

17A2A4AB-9B90-43FC-ADCB-216D381156A1

...and here I thought it was only So Cal that suffered from Rain Freakout.        A light mist and people lose what little driving ability they may have had. 

 

1
mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
1/15/2024 8:55am
mxb2 wrote:

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

Gator724 wrote:

Any race that they have to shorten, shorten the points too. Easy 

Chance1216 wrote:

I think they should get gold stars and, participation trophy’s that day instead of points. Nobody’s left out and, everybody wins. 

Exactly. Or double the points on a perfect track. Lol

1
1
1/15/2024 8:58am

I'd love to see a Pro not follow protocol, and where the standard trash bag to "save the gear". It would look so normal for us mortal racers. To see a Factory guy racing looking like a weekend warrior would be funny once.

2
3
TeamGreen
Posts
37508
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
1/15/2024 9:22am
FLmxer wrote:
It was wild to see who could navigate the track in those conditions.  I sometimes stare at my phone while watching but I watched every second...

It was wild to see who could navigate the track in those conditions.  I sometimes stare at my phone while watching but I watched every second of that carnage. 1 a year is great IMHO. The dnfs suck but the anticipation of who makes it to the checkers is exciting and creates a lot of crazy scenarios for the rest of the season. Even though I love huge jumps I enjoyed racing in the mud once in awhile and actually kind of felt safer and more relaxed. 

I get the feeling you’ve raced in that kind of muck…Laughing

1
TeamGreen
Posts
37508
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
1/15/2024 9:25am Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 11:18am
Press516 wrote:
A mudder every now and then?  Yep, let's do it.  It's another challenge that they have to be ready for.  Every week?  Please no. Some of...

A mudder every now and then?  Yep, let's do it.  It's another challenge that they have to be ready for.  Every week?  Please no.

Some of the old guys in here might remember the CMC Madera mud race in 1979...  

Madera mud

The off-camber turn on the shoreline was like riding a trials section. Blink

1
1/15/2024 9:31am
TyRod wrote:

Fingers crossed we don't have a repeat of the SF race in the remaining 10, open air stadium races!

Gator724 wrote:

50% chance of rain in San Diego 

ATKpilot99 wrote:

Though there's only a 10% chance of that .

10% chance does not fit that clown gators agenda. Wink

1/15/2024 9:31am

I think a lot of the soy boys in here need to visit A1 2005. They were launching the triples while it was pouring in the Main event. But the Heat races were awesome to watch. They actually blitzed the whoops too, not cut them down..

 

 

4
1
1/15/2024 9:47am

I liked watching the race. It shakes up the points and separates the men from the boys. Some of guys had great attitudes and it showed in their results.

If the promoters wanted to avoid these, just eliminate the open air stadiums and allow places like Minneapolis host more consecutively instead of intermittent years...

5
1
RG437
Posts
370
Joined
2/5/2023
Location
Leicester, GB
1/15/2024 10:24am
dsoll703 wrote:
The problem with having SF this early in the schedule is that logistically it makes sense to have as many west coast races as feasible in...

The problem with having SF this early in the schedule is that logistically it makes sense to have as many west coast races as feasible in a row with A1 being the start of the season
 

Driving from one coast to the other side then back again doesn’t help any of the people associated with putting on a great show. From the drivers to Dirt Works and even the riders themselves.

Before or after Seattle could work?

1
tprice07
Posts
2384
Joined
9/29/2009
Location
Fort Dodge, IA, USA
1/15/2024 11:09am

I'm not a fan of watching the race but I do think it's a good way to mix up the race results and add some parody to the season as a whole. That said, they can mitigate the number of mud races based on how they pick locations. All sounds easy in practice but booking those stadiums and the logistics involved has to be an absolute nightmare.  I design and book the tradeshows for the company I work for, that alone is stressful. I can't imagine mixing in all of what takes for an event like this.

1
AMetts
Posts
1183
Joined
6/15/2022
Location
Lincolnton, NC, USA
1/15/2024 11:16am

SX tracks get muddy in a totally unique way. The dirt is all the same from top to bottom so its nothing like the dirt in the real world. In actual dirt once you get past that first foot of dirt its a bit more dense so the ruts can get really deep but they actually have some structure and support to them. Plus its built on a totally flat surface so water cant drain.

The General GNCC was really bad this year but if you compare the two one looks much more rideable. Granted the GNCC had 500 guys racing the track for 3 hours so it was still brutal but looks more "rideable"

Screenshot 2024-01-15 141607

264931 ga23-26.jpg?VersionId=50qr mS

1
Chance1216
Posts
8868
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
1/15/2024 11:31am Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 11:33am
ga_pike wrote:
So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.     That said...

So, I'm in the camp that you race in whatever conditions are present and that's one of the cool things about this sport.  

 

That said, I didn't really enjoy last night's race.  I almost wonder if the racers today are not as adept in bad conditions for some reason.  

Gator724 wrote:
Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a...

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

mxb2 wrote:

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

All the PTA moms on Vital 😂

1
1
mxb2
Posts
22437
Joined
6/15/2010
Location
Bowie, MD, USA
1/15/2024 11:38am
Gator724 wrote:
Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a...

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

mxb2 wrote:

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

Chance1216 wrote:

All the PTA moms on Vital 😂

Lol

burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
1/15/2024 11:51am Edited Date/Time 1/15/2024 11:51am

Also Monster Jam does not stop because of the rain 

 

 

2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/15/2024 11:52am
Gator724 wrote:
Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a...

Maybe for a super muddy race like that only reward 1/2 pts or something. It absolutely wrecks the 250 guys champ hopes if they have a bad night 

mxb2 wrote:

Lol. Who determines the mud. Factor.    Keep the points the same.   Its the same track for everybody. 

Chance1216 wrote:

All the PTA moms on Vital 😂

image-20240115115211-1

3
2
Phil109
Posts
640
Joined
7/7/2019
Location
Montgomery, TX, USA
1/15/2024 11:54am

I personally like watching the best riders in the world have to ride my speed for a bit 😂😂

5

Post a reply to: SX should not race in mud like THAT.

The Latest