So, nobody talking about this?!? #78

donman
Posts
715
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Golden, CO, USA

Screenshot 20240107-160336.png?VersionId=PUsJF Y6

 

Screenshot 20240107-160410

3
4
|
ky_savage
Posts
2669
Joined
12/4/2008
Location
Kentucky, KY, USA
1/7/2024 3:10pm

I saw it.  They said the triple clamp broke.  I moved on.

22
1
dsmith
Posts
4568
Joined
3/29/2011
Location
way north, IN, USA
Fantasy
1/7/2024 3:12pm

Yeah..they put some new ones on...

1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/7/2024 3:12pm

Why would you buy orange when you can buy yellow....

 

2
17
1/7/2024 3:14pm
donman wrote:
 

Screenshot 20240107-160336.png?VersionId=PUsJF Y6

 

Screenshot 20240107-160410

what would you like to discuss? (not trying to be a smart ass)

my perspective is, It seems his steering stem broke. its happened to people before, will pry happen again unfortunately.. glad he wasn't hurt and was able to race the night show!

4

The Shop

Tyler D
Posts
2292
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
La, CA, USA
1/7/2024 3:25pm

Whose clamps?

2
4DAIVIPAI2K5
Posts
1123
Joined
12/15/2016
Location
Coshocton, OH, USA
1/7/2024 4:02pm

I read the bike went flying,  which is why stuff broke, not that stuff broke and caused the bike to go flying. 

2
ML512
Posts
16960
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
Fantasy
1/7/2024 6:31pm
Tyler D wrote:

Whose clamps?

Stock.

6
1/7/2024 6:56pm

That's never happened before on a  KTM group bike.

4
3
StillSmokin
Posts
739
Joined
3/18/2022
Location
Edmond, OK, USA
1/7/2024 9:01pm

Nobody is talking about it cause the frame is fine as shown in the first photo. Every nerd has jergens next to their computer scouring the internet for ktm frame failures.

8
2
1/7/2024 10:02pm

No bike goes into press day hoping to come out of it in a skid steer.

 

6
1/7/2024 10:07pm

Made in China Wink 

7
6
Vet57
Posts
2519
Joined
12/13/2010
Location
BRO Town, MA, USA
1/8/2024 2:38am Edited Date/Time 1/8/2024 2:39am

Good time to grease the neck bearings...

6
1/8/2024 6:56am

That's never happened before on a  KTM group bike.

Ask Pingree

 

 

2
vdrsnk04
Posts
2178
Joined
9/5/2018
Location
USA
1/8/2024 7:13am

If that happened to a Stark Vitards would have created 10 new threads to show it broke cause the haters are gonna hate. 
 

I am assuming the poster maybe was getting at that?

1
9
1/8/2024 7:16am
Magoofan wrote:

Why would you buy orange when you can buy yellow....

 

Because orange still make 2 strokes. 

1
Redrcr34
Posts
1048
Joined
10/3/2008
Location
USA
1/8/2024 8:14am
Nobody is talking about it cause the frame is fine as shown in the first photo. Every nerd has jergens next to their computer scouring the...

Nobody is talking about it cause the frame is fine as shown in the first photo. Every nerd has jergens next to their computer scouring the internet for ktm frame failures.

😂😂😂

Darrin Willis
Posts
1105
Joined
11/16/2020
Location
Red Deer County, AB, CA
1/8/2024 10:57am
Nobody is talking about it cause the frame is fine as shown in the first photo. Every nerd has jergens next to their computer scouring the...

Nobody is talking about it cause the frame is fine as shown in the first photo. Every nerd has jergens next to their computer scouring the internet for ktm frame failures.

My first chuckle of the day. Thanks man.

burn1986
Posts
12246
Joined
4/16/2010
Location
bossier city, LA, USA
1/8/2024 11:45am

So the implication is that KTM group uses cheaper parts on their gasgas bikes, which is true. The moral of the story is: use better triple clamps than stock.

Luxon MX
Posts
1383
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
Fantasy
1/8/2024 3:11pm

First off, it's good to see that Varize is OK and went on to race the next day.

The clamps that failed in this case were the WP Powerparts clamps. They're stock on the factory edition, but I wouldn't consider them stock in the general sense. Most people are buying these as aftermarket parts to upgrade the clamps on their non-factory edition bikes. 

I do find it interesting that when it was our clamps that failed in this manner, it was a huge ordeal with multiple posts, Instagram mentions, podcast interviews, etc., but when it's a KTM/WP part it's not such a big deal and not much of anything is mentioned. Interesting...

And while I don't know the details of the failure on Varize's bike, whether it caused the crash or it was caused by the crash (I'd suspect the latter), it's pretty clear it failed at the stem/clamp interface with the pinch bolt design, which is the typical failure point of this general design. Our new Gen3 clamps have done away with the pinch bolt system and now use the "traditional" style double nut stem:

IMG 7864luxon-gen3-pro-triple-clamps-ktm-husqvarna-gasgas-image d01

This is a much stronger and more robust design which solves that issue entirely. 

18
1/8/2024 4:12pm
Luxon MX wrote:
First off, it's good to see that Varize is OK and went on to race the next day. The clamps that failed in this case were...

First off, it's good to see that Varize is OK and went on to race the next day.

The clamps that failed in this case were the WP Powerparts clamps. They're stock on the factory edition, but I wouldn't consider them stock in the general sense. Most people are buying these as aftermarket parts to upgrade the clamps on their non-factory edition bikes. 

I do find it interesting that when it was our clamps that failed in this manner, it was a huge ordeal with multiple posts, Instagram mentions, podcast interviews, etc., but when it's a KTM/WP part it's not such a big deal and not much of anything is mentioned. Interesting...

And while I don't know the details of the failure on Varize's bike, whether it caused the crash or it was caused by the crash (I'd suspect the latter), it's pretty clear it failed at the stem/clamp interface with the pinch bolt design, which is the typical failure point of this general design. Our new Gen3 clamps have done away with the pinch bolt system and now use the "traditional" style double nut stem:

IMG 7864luxon-gen3-pro-triple-clamps-ktm-husqvarna-gasgas-image d01

This is a much stronger and more robust design which solves that issue entirely. 

Excellent, that looks like a work of art!

1
1/8/2024 5:13pm
Luxon MX wrote:
First off, it's good to see that Varize is OK and went on to race the next day. The clamps that failed in this case were...

First off, it's good to see that Varize is OK and went on to race the next day.

The clamps that failed in this case were the WP Powerparts clamps. They're stock on the factory edition, but I wouldn't consider them stock in the general sense. Most people are buying these as aftermarket parts to upgrade the clamps on their non-factory edition bikes. 

I do find it interesting that when it was our clamps that failed in this manner, it was a huge ordeal with multiple posts, Instagram mentions, podcast interviews, etc., but when it's a KTM/WP part it's not such a big deal and not much of anything is mentioned. Interesting...

And while I don't know the details of the failure on Varize's bike, whether it caused the crash or it was caused by the crash (I'd suspect the latter), it's pretty clear it failed at the stem/clamp interface with the pinch bolt design, which is the typical failure point of this general design. Our new Gen3 clamps have done away with the pinch bolt system and now use the "traditional" style double nut stem:

IMG 7864luxon-gen3-pro-triple-clamps-ktm-husqvarna-gasgas-image d01

This is a much stronger and more robust design which solves that issue entirely. 

They are using traditional racing engineering. If it breaks, add material to make it stronger, if it holds up, remove material to make it lighter. LOL

3
forensic
Posts
118
Joined
12/3/2011
Location
Madison, WI, USA
1/8/2024 5:45pm

The video where that image is taken from, Varize's mechanic said that he endoed before the clamp broke. That's what it sounds like happens in most cases for the other pinchbolt-style clamp failures. With an impact to the front wheel, the forks act as lever arms and the bottom clamp/ stem bearing is a fulcrum. Pushing the front axle rearward effectively forces the top clamp forward (off the stem) and the pinchbolt fails in tension. That's my theory from my couch. The impact from a crash is outside the design envelope of normal usage (i.e., stresses gathered while riding x factor of safety) but nonetheless a crash is a forseeable and probable event. I like those new Luxon clamps-  beautiful!  

2
Markopolo400
Posts
1426
Joined
7/24/2012
Location
St. Paul-ish, MN, USA
1/8/2024 10:08pm

Billy its cause Vital expects it from KTM, not from Luxon.

I cant believe no one has posted Pings bike yet.

1
1/9/2024 4:57am
Luxon MX wrote:
First off, it's good to see that Varize is OK and went on to race the next day. The clamps that failed in this case were...

First off, it's good to see that Varize is OK and went on to race the next day.

The clamps that failed in this case were the WP Powerparts clamps. They're stock on the factory edition, but I wouldn't consider them stock in the general sense. Most people are buying these as aftermarket parts to upgrade the clamps on their non-factory edition bikes. 

I do find it interesting that when it was our clamps that failed in this manner, it was a huge ordeal with multiple posts, Instagram mentions, podcast interviews, etc., but when it's a KTM/WP part it's not such a big deal and not much of anything is mentioned. Interesting...

And while I don't know the details of the failure on Varize's bike, whether it caused the crash or it was caused by the crash (I'd suspect the latter), it's pretty clear it failed at the stem/clamp interface with the pinch bolt design, which is the typical failure point of this general design. Our new Gen3 clamps have done away with the pinch bolt system and now use the "traditional" style double nut stem:

IMG 7864luxon-gen3-pro-triple-clamps-ktm-husqvarna-gasgas-image d01

This is a much stronger and more robust design which solves that issue entirely. 

Sounds like the moral of the story is, if your top triple clamp utilizes a pinch bolt to clamp the triple clamp to the stem, you should replace it ASAP.  It seems like there is enough evidence that this is a dangerous design.  Why is it still being used?  The more traditional design without the clamp is tried and true and doesn’t show up in a catastrophic failure thread on Vital every few months.

1

Post a reply to: So, nobody talking about this?!? #78

The Latest