Mountain Biking Cross-Satisfaction?

plowboy
Posts
14033
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS US
12/4/2023 1:53pm
plowboy wrote:
This is an honest question to the bicycle crowd.  When my knees started going from years of Moto and running I bought a cheap ass MTN...

This is an honest question to the bicycle crowd.  When my knees started going from years of Moto and running I bought a cheap ass MTN bike.  30 mile rounds as fast possible.  The cardio was good but it wasn't as much of a workout as running but less pain so what ya gonna do?

Here's the rub (pun intended)...I tried every type of pant, shorts, seat...but the pain from nutsack to tailbone was more than I could bare.  How the fuck do you guys do it?  Don't tell me to "stand up more"...nobody stands up all the time.

DoctorJD wrote:
Some of it is simply conditioning your ass/taint to being in the seat for extended periods of time. Some of it could be poor saddle positioning...

Some of it is simply conditioning your ass/taint to being in the seat for extended periods of time. Some of it could be poor saddle positioning. It almost sounds like your seat is tilted too far back. Start with it completely level then ride for a while. Make (tilt) adjustments (nose down) if you feel like you're sliding off the back, or (nose up) if you feel yourself pushing yourself back onto the seat. Moreover, after these adjustments, sense where the pressure points are and see if moving either way takes that pressure off.

If you're really desperate, you go to your local shop that does saddle testing and/or bike fit. Good luck!

Thanks.

1
Ake27
Posts
82
Joined
12/7/2022
Location
Dublin, CA US
12/4/2023 4:24pm

Being a Moto guy I was a non believer in going tubeless on my mountain bike. My buddies all tried to convince me how much better my bike would handle and how few flats I would get. After about 6 months I finally pinch flat a tube and went tubeless. All I can say is don’t wait. Bike handles much better and I haven’t got a flat in over two years. 

3
Timo
Posts
1395
Joined
1/9/2021
Location
Wichita, KS US
12/4/2023 5:07pm
Ake27 wrote:
Being a Moto guy I was a non believer in going tubeless on my mountain bike. My buddies all tried to convince me how much better...

Being a Moto guy I was a non believer in going tubeless on my mountain bike. My buddies all tried to convince me how much better my bike would handle and how few flats I would get. After about 6 months I finally pinch flat a tube and went tubeless. All I can say is don’t wait. Bike handles much better and I haven’t got a flat in over two years. 

I go back and forth on tubeless and honestly can't tell a difference, would be interesting to have the same model bike and do a side by side comparison.

2
Rotaholic
Posts
1700
Joined
4/2/2013
Location
NZ
12/4/2023 5:14pm
Ake27 wrote:
Being a Moto guy I was a non believer in going tubeless on my mountain bike. My buddies all tried to convince me how much better...

Being a Moto guy I was a non believer in going tubeless on my mountain bike. My buddies all tried to convince me how much better my bike would handle and how few flats I would get. After about 6 months I finally pinch flat a tube and went tubeless. All I can say is don’t wait. Bike handles much better and I haven’t got a flat in over two years. 

Timo wrote:
I go back and forth on tubeless and honestly can't tell a difference, would be interesting to have the same model bike and do a side...

I go back and forth on tubeless and honestly can't tell a difference, would be interesting to have the same model bike and do a side by side comparison.

I can instantly tell the difference of tubeless, next time flip your bike upside down, spin the wheel and stop it with your hand by grabbing the tire. Tubeless will stop instantly with no effort, with tubes it will want to rip your hand off.

The Shop

Timo
Posts
1395
Joined
1/9/2021
Location
Wichita, KS US
12/4/2023 5:18pm
plowboy wrote:
This is an honest question to the bicycle crowd.  When my knees started going from years of Moto and running I bought a cheap ass MTN...

This is an honest question to the bicycle crowd.  When my knees started going from years of Moto and running I bought a cheap ass MTN bike.  30 mile rounds as fast possible.  The cardio was good but it wasn't as much of a workout as running but less pain so what ya gonna do?

Here's the rub (pun intended)...I tried every type of pant, shorts, seat...but the pain from nutsack to tailbone was more than I could bare.  How the fuck do you guys do it?  Don't tell me to "stand up more"...nobody stands up all the time.

DoctorJD wrote:
Some of it is simply conditioning your ass/taint to being in the seat for extended periods of time. Some of it could be poor saddle positioning...

Some of it is simply conditioning your ass/taint to being in the seat for extended periods of time. Some of it could be poor saddle positioning. It almost sounds like your seat is tilted too far back. Start with it completely level then ride for a while. Make (tilt) adjustments (nose down) if you feel like you're sliding off the back, or (nose up) if you feel yourself pushing yourself back onto the seat. Moreover, after these adjustments, sense where the pressure points are and see if moving either way takes that pressure off.

If you're really desperate, you go to your local shop that does saddle testing and/or bike fit. Good luck!

plowboy wrote:

Thanks.

The seats with the middle cutout and a level or slightly downward tilt on the saddle help the taint area a lot. The next is a saddle that's the correct width of your seat bones (pelvis), you can go to a good bike shop and get sized for the right saddle. Then proper positioning on the bike, saddles can move forward/rearward and it helps keep you sitting on the proper part of the seat. This can also be set by a good bike shop.

Big pads on the seat and in your riding pants are just a hotspot maker in my opinion. I can't do chamois pads, they are just a spong because I sweat a lot. My go-to is good synthetic athletic boxer briefs under training shorts. They really help keep you dry and eliminate hotspots. 

1
plowboy
Posts
14033
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS US
12/4/2023 5:25pm
DoctorJD wrote:
Some of it is simply conditioning your ass/taint to being in the seat for extended periods of time. Some of it could be poor saddle positioning...

Some of it is simply conditioning your ass/taint to being in the seat for extended periods of time. Some of it could be poor saddle positioning. It almost sounds like your seat is tilted too far back. Start with it completely level then ride for a while. Make (tilt) adjustments (nose down) if you feel like you're sliding off the back, or (nose up) if you feel yourself pushing yourself back onto the seat. Moreover, after these adjustments, sense where the pressure points are and see if moving either way takes that pressure off.

If you're really desperate, you go to your local shop that does saddle testing and/or bike fit. Good luck!

plowboy wrote:

Thanks.

Timo wrote:
The seats with the middle cutout and a level or slightly downward tilt on the saddle help the taint area a lot. The next is a...

The seats with the middle cutout and a level or slightly downward tilt on the saddle help the taint area a lot. The next is a saddle that's the correct width of your seat bones (pelvis), you can go to a good bike shop and get sized for the right saddle. Then proper positioning on the bike, saddles can move forward/rearward and it helps keep you sitting on the proper part of the seat. This can also be set by a good bike shop.

Big pads on the seat and in your riding pants are just a hotspot maker in my opinion. I can't do chamois pads, they are just a spong because I sweat a lot. My go-to is good synthetic athletic boxer briefs under training shorts. They really help keep you dry and eliminate hotspots. 

Good stuff.

sumdood
Posts
8607
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA US
Fantasy
12/4/2023 5:35pm

I switched to this seat with the built in taint cooler, night and day better.  I was worried it might be too wide in the low position when going down steep hills, but it’s a non issue, if anything it’s nice to have something to grab with your thighs, kind of like squeezing the tank with your legs.  Las Ramblas was tacky tonight ! Good stuff. Quite satisfying Laughing

22834C73-A00C-438B-B067-0130575AFE652FB7A0A6-E8B0-4E7F-8CF0-6D6CBA260A0B.jpeg?VersionId=D0.EPUwidU0IfTXp .M sDL

4
BS12
Posts
1054
Joined
1/13/2014
Location
AU
12/4/2023 7:01pm

Outside pedal down and weighted in tighter corners, especially flatter ones. 

Seat up when climbing, slammed for descending. General rule of thumb for seat height when up is knee should be slightly bent at the bottom of the pedal stroke. 

When climbing, try to stay "on top of the gearing" rather than grinding or spinning away. 

Many suspension calculators out there to assist in dialing in sag, rebound etc. 

2
les962
Posts
84
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Centennial, CO US
12/4/2023 10:44pm

OP, have fun on the YT. Great Bike. You'll notice all the tire choices,just research. Carry and extra tube and CO2. If you have a desire to go to a bike park, do it! That is a rush- almost moto rush. Find somebody that’s been or just go and somebody will help you out. I waited years to go up lifts , wish I would have done it sooner. Enjoy. Also once you get hooked and get non moto friends to go, have em ease into it because when they crash that is usually it and they won’t ride again. Moto peeps will hop back on and keep going!

1
OwenJakes
Posts
1657
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY US
12/5/2023 6:40am
les962 wrote:
OP, have fun on the YT. Great Bike. You'll notice all the tire choices,just research. Carry and extra tube and CO2. If you have a desire...

OP, have fun on the YT. Great Bike. You'll notice all the tire choices,just research. Carry and extra tube and CO2. If you have a desire to go to a bike park, do it! That is a rush- almost moto rush. Find somebody that’s been or just go and somebody will help you out. I waited years to go up lifts , wish I would have done it sooner. Enjoy. Also once you get hooked and get non moto friends to go, have em ease into it because when they crash that is usually it and they won’t ride again. Moto peeps will hop back on and keep going!

We have friends in birmingham AL and they live like 3 aerial miles from Ridebhm.com and about three other awesome bike spots. I'm looking forward to it! The bike arrives saturday so I'll post up some pictures too.

1
12/5/2023 6:52am

Coming from an inverse portion as the OP - I grew up riding motos (mostly trail riding on family property, not mx), and switched to mtbs when I went away to college. Nearly twenty years later, I was able to afford / justify purchasing a new moto (it's a tax write-off as a trail builder!). It's been interesting to compare & contrast the two experiences, as they are similar yet different in so many ways. 

It often seems to me that riding a moto is more like skiing in that being pro-active in your bike handling requires concentrating a lot of effort in pushing / weighting through your feet, whereas on bikes, there is a slightly more equal distribution of efforts between feet, and hands. Even though I knew it would do an good, I found myself yanking at the bars, and trying to scoop the bike up with my feet bunny-hop style on my moto, with the predictable non-results. Probably the steepest learning curve in getting back on a moto was learning to use the throttle to weight the chassis, and get pop over obstacles. 

Not having a throttle on a mtb means that you have to be much more precise with your speed management, and body placement, particularly with jumping or taking corners at speed, since there is no option of "when in doubt, throttle out." Riding a mtb (especially a single speed) will get you way more in tune to carrying speed through corners, and over obstacles. Getting used to engine braking again was also a trip - I hardly touched the brakes the first few weeks of being on my 350. 

Even with an Open OHV zone literally at the city limits, I find myself riding my mtb more than my moto simply because it's a much quicker process of loading up, and sorting shit out after the ride. Now that our local mtb trails are under seasonal closure, and winter conditions are a bit too slow / soggy / sloppy for pedal bikes, but tacky brownie mix hero dirt for motos I'm back to catching up on twisting the throttle. 

2
Lip44
Posts
29
Joined
1/21/2018
Location
PA US
12/5/2023 8:19am

As someone who has ridden both MX and MTB a bunch here are some of my thoughts:

Start out with flat pedals, you will most likely be dabbing a foot here and there as you get used to MTB riding. Five Ten or Ride Concept shoes are great 

Go tubeless for sure, get a tire pressure gauge or a quality floor pump that has a good gauge (or both)

Riding on kind-of-wet trails is ok, if the trails are really muddy that you make ruts on don’t ride

If you take a break on the trail, move off the trail, especially in a downhill section

Padded shorts are a must

I may get bashed for this but keep the trail dog at home

I may also get bashed for this but please no loud-ass Bluetooth speakers on the trail

Trailforks is a great app to navigate with. You can download areas for use offline in case you don’t have cell service

Keep some food with you, bonking sucks balls. I love Honey Stinger products but anything that works for you is good

Jumping is much different on a MTB than moto so start small

A shock pump is useful for checking / setting sag

Hope you have fun with it! 

5
1
Ob917
Posts
1034
Joined
9/29/2021
Location
Cardiff, CA US
12/5/2023 8:27am
Lip44 wrote:
As someone who has ridden both MX and MTB a bunch here are some of my thoughts: Start out with flat pedals, you will most likely...

As someone who has ridden both MX and MTB a bunch here are some of my thoughts:

Start out with flat pedals, you will most likely be dabbing a foot here and there as you get used to MTB riding. Five Ten or Ride Concept shoes are great 

Go tubeless for sure, get a tire pressure gauge or a quality floor pump that has a good gauge (or both)

Riding on kind-of-wet trails is ok, if the trails are really muddy that you make ruts on don’t ride

If you take a break on the trail, move off the trail, especially in a downhill section

Padded shorts are a must

I may get bashed for this but keep the trail dog at home

I may also get bashed for this but please no loud-ass Bluetooth speakers on the trail

Trailforks is a great app to navigate with. You can download areas for use offline in case you don’t have cell service

Keep some food with you, bonking sucks balls. I love Honey Stinger products but anything that works for you is good

Jumping is much different on a MTB than moto so start small

A shock pump is useful for checking / setting sag

Hope you have fun with it! 

Spot on

1
12/5/2023 8:54am

My previous house was across the street from a state park.  Got a couple MTB and rode a lot. 3-4 times per week.  Lots of fun but no replacement for mx bike for me. 

OwenJakes
Posts
1657
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY US
12/5/2023 12:44pm
Lip44 wrote:
As someone who has ridden both MX and MTB a bunch here are some of my thoughts: Start out with flat pedals, you will most likely...

As someone who has ridden both MX and MTB a bunch here are some of my thoughts:

Start out with flat pedals, you will most likely be dabbing a foot here and there as you get used to MTB riding. Five Ten or Ride Concept shoes are great 

Go tubeless for sure, get a tire pressure gauge or a quality floor pump that has a good gauge (or both)

Riding on kind-of-wet trails is ok, if the trails are really muddy that you make ruts on don’t ride

If you take a break on the trail, move off the trail, especially in a downhill section

Padded shorts are a must

I may get bashed for this but keep the trail dog at home

I may also get bashed for this but please no loud-ass Bluetooth speakers on the trail

Trailforks is a great app to navigate with. You can download areas for use offline in case you don’t have cell service

Keep some food with you, bonking sucks balls. I love Honey Stinger products but anything that works for you is good

Jumping is much different on a MTB than moto so start small

A shock pump is useful for checking / setting sag

Hope you have fun with it! 

Good stuff. I don't like pets or music so I'm already moving the right direction LOL

1
1
OwenJakes
Posts
1657
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY US
12/5/2023 12:45pm
My previous house was across the street from a state park.  Got a couple MTB and rode a lot. 3-4 times per week.  Lots of fun...

My previous house was across the street from a state park.  Got a couple MTB and rode a lot. 3-4 times per week.  Lots of fun but no replacement for mx bike for me. 

Did you think riding the MTB added value to your moto technique in ANY area? Fitness is a given

cwtoyota
Posts
2374
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
Tacoma, WA US
12/5/2023 2:40pm
My previous house was across the street from a state park.  Got a couple MTB and rode a lot. 3-4 times per week.  Lots of fun...

My previous house was across the street from a state park.  Got a couple MTB and rode a lot. 3-4 times per week.  Lots of fun but no replacement for mx bike for me. 

OwenJakes wrote:

Did you think riding the MTB added value to your moto technique in ANY area? Fitness is a given

MTB may or may not help you depending on your existing moto strengths and weaknesses...
For me MTB adds a bit of value to MX.


I was never a BMX kid, it was always motorcycles.   The BMX kids had more precision, better timing and they were more efficient.
I'm not slow, but I would say I'm not an efficient rider in the way Barcia is not an efficient rider.

Lip44 mentioned "Trailforks" app...   That app will tell you your time in each trail, so I started using that as a goal to improve my riding skill on the MTB.   I found that my max speed (mph) in the trails was high, but my elapsed times were longer.   I was coming into corners all over the brakes like you would do on a motocross bike.   I learned to be more efficient very quickly and my times to complete trails dropped substantially.

Getting back on the motorcycle, I am a bit more efficient as a result.  In my first race of 2023 a buddy mentioned that I look smoother and "less forced" in my riding style.

So, I think the bicycle can help take the rough edges off of some of your style if you make an effort there.

I've also been learning what I would call "pump track skills"...   Like pumping on a swingset, you can accelerate over small bumps, dips and out of some corners on the bicycle. It doesn't directly apply to motocross, but maybe those skills would help the kind of motocross riders who sit down too much and stay too static on the bike.

Sandusky26
Posts
3385
Joined
7/28/2021
Location
Eastern, NC US
12/6/2023 4:20am
Lip44 wrote:
As someone who has ridden both MX and MTB a bunch here are some of my thoughts: Start out with flat pedals, you will most likely...

As someone who has ridden both MX and MTB a bunch here are some of my thoughts:

Start out with flat pedals, you will most likely be dabbing a foot here and there as you get used to MTB riding. Five Ten or Ride Concept shoes are great 

Go tubeless for sure, get a tire pressure gauge or a quality floor pump that has a good gauge (or both)

Riding on kind-of-wet trails is ok, if the trails are really muddy that you make ruts on don’t ride

If you take a break on the trail, move off the trail, especially in a downhill section

Padded shorts are a must

I may get bashed for this but keep the trail dog at home

I may also get bashed for this but please no loud-ass Bluetooth speakers on the trail

Trailforks is a great app to navigate with. You can download areas for use offline in case you don’t have cell service

Keep some food with you, bonking sucks balls. I love Honey Stinger products but anything that works for you is good

Jumping is much different on a MTB than moto so start small

A shock pump is useful for checking / setting sag

Hope you have fun with it! 

OwenJakes wrote:

Good stuff. I don't like pets or music so I'm already moving the right direction LOL

That's the problem right there.

mimafia
Posts
326
Joined
5/17/2013
Location
Grand Rapids, MI US
12/6/2023 4:37am
Ake27 wrote:
Being a Moto guy I was a non believer in going tubeless on my mountain bike. My buddies all tried to convince me how much better...

Being a Moto guy I was a non believer in going tubeless on my mountain bike. My buddies all tried to convince me how much better my bike would handle and how few flats I would get. After about 6 months I finally pinch flat a tube and went tubeless. All I can say is don’t wait. Bike handles much better and I haven’t got a flat in over two years. 

Timo wrote:
I go back and forth on tubeless and honestly can't tell a difference, would be interesting to have the same model bike and do a side...

I go back and forth on tubeless and honestly can't tell a difference, would be interesting to have the same model bike and do a side by side comparison.

That's interesting. I wonder if you were running higher tire pressures than necessary when you went tubeless. Makes a big difference imo. With tubeless you can run lower tire pressures which lets the tires conform to bumps/rocks/roots which in turn provides better traction and feels more supple and less bouncy. 

mimafia
Posts
326
Joined
5/17/2013
Location
Grand Rapids, MI US
12/6/2023 4:49am
OwenJakes wrote:
Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and...

Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and make less money and "work" more hours (albeit maybe more flexible during the week?). We don't have kids yet either. I am taking a sober look at the money and ever-increasing difficulty of riding and wondering if a mountain bike will even shake a stick at motocross.

I've pretty much always ridden. Naturally, I'm pretty fast, skilled, and safe. If I miss a few weeks its not like going back to start. I'm cautious enough not to yardsale it by riding over my head. I could never imagine not riding, so maybe that's the answer right there but I just want to hear some experiences of others who have pursued this. May not be important but I have been a BMX guy most always so I've got cycle "skill" and I'm very very fit so that aspect is enjoyable. It wont be "unnatural".

What I do know is that riding every other month is a real sucky experience. I doubt it gets that bad but I'm not sure.. Discuss? Thanks everyone. Any rich philanthropists reading this I'll take a farm and a bulldozer plz thanks

 

Also do mountain bikes vacuum all your money up like mx? I just wanna ride and I don't need the worlds greatest stuff and I don't mind if everything isn't perfect.

I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking since the early 90's. Imo it's not nearly equal the satisfaction. At least the typical xc/singletrack type of trails I ride. Maybe if you're riding those downhill runs at Whistler with the big jumps you see in youtube videos it would be. Don't get me wrong, it's fun and challenging and a great workout, just not quite the same for me as mx. And I'd sure as hell rather mtb than run to stay in shape.

Mountain bikes can be ridiculously expensive but you don't "need" to spend more than $1500 on a hardtail or $2k on a full sus to have a great bike that doesn't need any upgrades right off the bat (other than saddle/pedals/grips to preference). Those prices will get you good components and an air fork. But spend a bit more and you'll get a better fork/shock and better brakes. All you really need to do is keep the drivetrain lubed and adjusted properly and you're good. It can be tempting to upgrade parts though. 

OwenJakes
Posts
1657
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY US
12/6/2023 5:34am
OwenJakes wrote:
Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and...

Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and make less money and "work" more hours (albeit maybe more flexible during the week?). We don't have kids yet either. I am taking a sober look at the money and ever-increasing difficulty of riding and wondering if a mountain bike will even shake a stick at motocross.

I've pretty much always ridden. Naturally, I'm pretty fast, skilled, and safe. If I miss a few weeks its not like going back to start. I'm cautious enough not to yardsale it by riding over my head. I could never imagine not riding, so maybe that's the answer right there but I just want to hear some experiences of others who have pursued this. May not be important but I have been a BMX guy most always so I've got cycle "skill" and I'm very very fit so that aspect is enjoyable. It wont be "unnatural".

What I do know is that riding every other month is a real sucky experience. I doubt it gets that bad but I'm not sure.. Discuss? Thanks everyone. Any rich philanthropists reading this I'll take a farm and a bulldozer plz thanks

 

Also do mountain bikes vacuum all your money up like mx? I just wanna ride and I don't need the worlds greatest stuff and I don't mind if everything isn't perfect.

mimafia wrote:
I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking...

I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking since the early 90's. Imo it's not nearly equal the satisfaction. At least the typical xc/singletrack type of trails I ride. Maybe if you're riding those downhill runs at Whistler with the big jumps you see in youtube videos it would be. Don't get me wrong, it's fun and challenging and a great workout, just not quite the same for me as mx. And I'd sure as hell rather mtb than run to stay in shape.

Mountain bikes can be ridiculously expensive but you don't "need" to spend more than $1500 on a hardtail or $2k on a full sus to have a great bike that doesn't need any upgrades right off the bat (other than saddle/pedals/grips to preference). Those prices will get you good components and an air fork. But spend a bit more and you'll get a better fork/shock and better brakes. All you really need to do is keep the drivetrain lubed and adjusted properly and you're good. It can be tempting to upgrade parts though. 

This is what I bought: https://us.yt-industries.com/products/outlet-sale/378/jeffsy-29-core-2/…

 

The aftermarket bike scene is wild with parts and tech and stuff so just being sober minded about what I buy is going to be important. I think for the next 6+ months I'm going to touch nothing except pedals. It comes with ODI grips even. I do want to fiddle with suspension valving though. There's no way the valving is optimal for a 200 pound guy out of the box.

2
mimafia
Posts
326
Joined
5/17/2013
Location
Grand Rapids, MI US
12/6/2023 5:46am
OwenJakes wrote:
Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and...

Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and make less money and "work" more hours (albeit maybe more flexible during the week?). We don't have kids yet either. I am taking a sober look at the money and ever-increasing difficulty of riding and wondering if a mountain bike will even shake a stick at motocross.

I've pretty much always ridden. Naturally, I'm pretty fast, skilled, and safe. If I miss a few weeks its not like going back to start. I'm cautious enough not to yardsale it by riding over my head. I could never imagine not riding, so maybe that's the answer right there but I just want to hear some experiences of others who have pursued this. May not be important but I have been a BMX guy most always so I've got cycle "skill" and I'm very very fit so that aspect is enjoyable. It wont be "unnatural".

What I do know is that riding every other month is a real sucky experience. I doubt it gets that bad but I'm not sure.. Discuss? Thanks everyone. Any rich philanthropists reading this I'll take a farm and a bulldozer plz thanks

 

Also do mountain bikes vacuum all your money up like mx? I just wanna ride and I don't need the worlds greatest stuff and I don't mind if everything isn't perfect.

mimafia wrote:
I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking...

I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking since the early 90's. Imo it's not nearly equal the satisfaction. At least the typical xc/singletrack type of trails I ride. Maybe if you're riding those downhill runs at Whistler with the big jumps you see in youtube videos it would be. Don't get me wrong, it's fun and challenging and a great workout, just not quite the same for me as mx. And I'd sure as hell rather mtb than run to stay in shape.

Mountain bikes can be ridiculously expensive but you don't "need" to spend more than $1500 on a hardtail or $2k on a full sus to have a great bike that doesn't need any upgrades right off the bat (other than saddle/pedals/grips to preference). Those prices will get you good components and an air fork. But spend a bit more and you'll get a better fork/shock and better brakes. All you really need to do is keep the drivetrain lubed and adjusted properly and you're good. It can be tempting to upgrade parts though. 

OwenJakes wrote:
This is what I bought: https://us.yt-industries.com/products/outlet-sale/378/jeffsy-29-core-2/?number=101400&variant=variant   The aftermarket bike scene is wild with parts and tech and stuff so just being sober minded about what I...

This is what I bought: https://us.yt-industries.com/products/outlet-sale/378/jeffsy-29-core-2/…

 

The aftermarket bike scene is wild with parts and tech and stuff so just being sober minded about what I buy is going to be important. I think for the next 6+ months I'm going to touch nothing except pedals. It comes with ODI grips even. I do want to fiddle with suspension valving though. There's no way the valving is optimal for a 200 pound guy out of the box.

Great choice! Really nice components. Hell it even comes with my fav saddle, and I've tried a ton of them. Only thing to consider are those tires. Great tires but going to be overkill and very heavy for local singletrack type biking. You can dramatically feel the difference when switching to lighter faster tires. Tradeoff is less traction obviously. All depends on where you're riding. Have fun!

Falcon
Posts
12190
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
12/6/2023 5:53am
OwenJakes wrote:
Morning friends. I anticipate receiving the bike this week. I have been thinking about how to be humble and approach this differently and not be a...

Morning friends. I anticipate receiving the bike this week. I have been thinking about how to be humble and approach this differently and not be a know it all because of my long history in moto. Some questions if you all feel so kind:

1. What are some general bike "no-no's" that I should avoid? For example, not setting it upside down? No pressure washing (obvious)? Transport? Whatever you feel is relevant that I may not know. Think maintenance too.

2. What are some general riding "no-no's" that should be avoided? Remember, I've been on bikes my whole life but specifically not a 29" mtb. I mostly do not want to end up wadding myself and getting hurt my first time out over something goofy because I assumed it was exactly like a dirtbike.

3. Needed Protection? I am scared of my shins but honestly I'm not intending on taking my feet off and slipping a pedal may not be so bad if you're seated. Knees are an always thing for me. General guidance mostly.

Falcon wrote:
Make sure you're comfy with the brakes being "wrong." You can swap your front brake over to the right hand, if you want.  (Interesting to note...

Make sure you're comfy with the brakes being "wrong." You can swap your front brake over to the right hand, if you want. 

(Interesting to note: that's how they come over in Europe. In America, we're backwards on bicycles.) 

OwenJakes wrote:

Like all hydraulic brakes - swap at the banjos and bleed?

In most cases you can just remove the whole lever assembly and switch sides - they're functionally ambidextrous for this precise issue.

Falcon
Posts
12190
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
12/6/2023 5:59am
OwenJakes wrote:
Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and...

Things are starting to get busier and busier as the important stuff naturally rises up in life. I am about to make a career change and make less money and "work" more hours (albeit maybe more flexible during the week?). We don't have kids yet either. I am taking a sober look at the money and ever-increasing difficulty of riding and wondering if a mountain bike will even shake a stick at motocross.

I've pretty much always ridden. Naturally, I'm pretty fast, skilled, and safe. If I miss a few weeks its not like going back to start. I'm cautious enough not to yardsale it by riding over my head. I could never imagine not riding, so maybe that's the answer right there but I just want to hear some experiences of others who have pursued this. May not be important but I have been a BMX guy most always so I've got cycle "skill" and I'm very very fit so that aspect is enjoyable. It wont be "unnatural".

What I do know is that riding every other month is a real sucky experience. I doubt it gets that bad but I'm not sure.. Discuss? Thanks everyone. Any rich philanthropists reading this I'll take a farm and a bulldozer plz thanks

 

Also do mountain bikes vacuum all your money up like mx? I just wanna ride and I don't need the worlds greatest stuff and I don't mind if everything isn't perfect.

mimafia wrote:
I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking...

I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking since the early 90's. Imo it's not nearly equal the satisfaction. At least the typical xc/singletrack type of trails I ride. Maybe if you're riding those downhill runs at Whistler with the big jumps you see in youtube videos it would be. Don't get me wrong, it's fun and challenging and a great workout, just not quite the same for me as mx. And I'd sure as hell rather mtb than run to stay in shape.

Mountain bikes can be ridiculously expensive but you don't "need" to spend more than $1500 on a hardtail or $2k on a full sus to have a great bike that doesn't need any upgrades right off the bat (other than saddle/pedals/grips to preference). Those prices will get you good components and an air fork. But spend a bit more and you'll get a better fork/shock and better brakes. All you really need to do is keep the drivetrain lubed and adjusted properly and you're good. It can be tempting to upgrade parts though. 

OwenJakes wrote:
This is what I bought: https://us.yt-industries.com/products/outlet-sale/378/jeffsy-29-core-2/?number=101400&variant=variant   The aftermarket bike scene is wild with parts and tech and stuff so just being sober minded about what I...

This is what I bought: https://us.yt-industries.com/products/outlet-sale/378/jeffsy-29-core-2/…

 

The aftermarket bike scene is wild with parts and tech and stuff so just being sober minded about what I buy is going to be important. I think for the next 6+ months I'm going to touch nothing except pedals. It comes with ODI grips even. I do want to fiddle with suspension valving though. There's no way the valving is optimal for a 200 pound guy out of the box.

You'd be surprised. Remember, you're going to be on air shocks, front and rear. There's your spring rate. Also, the net weight being damped is your body weight + about 35 pounds or less. It will probably work pretty well. Finally, you can add tokens to the air chamber to reduce the volume, which will in effect ramp up the progressivity of the air spring.  

1
dedi684
Posts
1385
Joined
8/21/2009
Location
Ravena, NY US
12/6/2023 6:00am Edited Date/Time 12/6/2023 6:51am
There is one thing about moto that is different from any sort of bicycle; if you don’t do it often enough, it takes awhile to build...

There is one thing about moto that is different from any sort of bicycle; if you don’t do it often enough, it takes awhile to build your pace up again. This obviously depends on your skill level to some degree but those first few rides back are brutal 😂 

If you are only going to miss a few weeks at a time between sessions or if you can schedule a couple days in a row once or twice a month, I’d say keep the bike. I ran that schedule for a few years and it filled the itch. Kept it safe, had fun and really appreciated every lap. 

OwenJakes wrote:
Dude if I go like 3-4 weeks off the bike, that first ride back is basically an anger session. I inevitably make changes to the bike...

Dude if I go like 3-4 weeks off the bike, that first ride back is basically an anger session. I inevitably make changes to the bike based on reading and research as well and end up at the track, with arm pump, pissed the bike doesnt feel good, and having a bad timeLaughing

I learned after the last time that a patient warm up moto to bring the technique back makes the day. Leaving the bike the same is big too. Doing this basically allows me to come back just as I left off. I train a LOT during the week (for fun + marathon running + rowing) which helps. Dummy here changed bar bends and materials and went an entire day limited to 10 minute motos because my forearms were turning into lava lol.

Lol I ride a yz 250 too. Just turned 50 but I've had 6 of these yz's I can take months off hop right back on it still feels the same. I also ride a super heavy transition patrol with a coil rear way more than I need at the current time.

1
Falcon
Posts
12190
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA US
12/6/2023 6:07am

PS-

I 100% agree with going tubeless. I used to flat every other ride and it got really old. Now I haven't had to worry about it for years. The weight change was barely noticeable for me, but for the flats alone, it's worth it. 

If your wheels are not already taped for tubeless, just run some Gorilla Duct Tape in the rim channel over the spokes. I much prefer the Orange Seal or Muc-Off tubeless valves, as well - they have a much firmer rubber block (the square one, not the conical one) that goes on the inside. It just works better and it's easier to set the bead when you inflate for the first time. 

2
12/6/2023 6:08am

Speaking of tires - Tire pressure has a much more noticeable effect on mtbs than motos. Checking your tire pressure before every ride (even if the last one was less than 24hrs ago) is one of the most key habits to enjoying a ride. If I'm feeling sluggish on the climbs, and squirrely on the descents, it's usually because I forgot to check my tire pressure. I generally find 25 f/27 r to be my go-to baseline. For steeper / rockier trails I'll go a bit lower; fast / flow trails I run closer to 30 psi. 

Also running CushCore, which I have found to be key for protecting rims (since mtb tires are basically knobby inner tubes compared moto tires), as well as providing more predictable ride qualities. I'm also usually the winner of the "Heaviest Bike Award" on any group ride. 

2
OwenJakes
Posts
1657
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY US
12/6/2023 6:22am
Speaking of tires - Tire pressure has a much more noticeable effect on mtbs than motos. Checking your tire pressure before every ride (even if the...

Speaking of tires - Tire pressure has a much more noticeable effect on mtbs than motos. Checking your tire pressure before every ride (even if the last one was less than 24hrs ago) is one of the most key habits to enjoying a ride. If I'm feeling sluggish on the climbs, and squirrely on the descents, it's usually because I forgot to check my tire pressure. I generally find 25 f/27 r to be my go-to baseline. For steeper / rockier trails I'll go a bit lower; fast / flow trails I run closer to 30 psi. 

Also running CushCore, which I have found to be key for protecting rims (since mtb tires are basically knobby inner tubes compared moto tires), as well as providing more predictable ride qualities. I'm also usually the winner of the "Heaviest Bike Award" on any group ride. 

lmaooo heaviest bike award got me laughing. Man, I would eventually like to go to a spring fork and shock with cush cores as well. I haven't even touched the bike yet so maybe I'll love the air but i doubt it. I'll always win heaviest bike too hahahaha.

OwenJakes
Posts
1657
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY US
12/6/2023 6:27am
mimafia wrote:
I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking...

I was in the exact same boat as you and did make the switch. Last mx bike was a 2020 kx250f. Though I've been mountain biking since the early 90's. Imo it's not nearly equal the satisfaction. At least the typical xc/singletrack type of trails I ride. Maybe if you're riding those downhill runs at Whistler with the big jumps you see in youtube videos it would be. Don't get me wrong, it's fun and challenging and a great workout, just not quite the same for me as mx. And I'd sure as hell rather mtb than run to stay in shape.

Mountain bikes can be ridiculously expensive but you don't "need" to spend more than $1500 on a hardtail or $2k on a full sus to have a great bike that doesn't need any upgrades right off the bat (other than saddle/pedals/grips to preference). Those prices will get you good components and an air fork. But spend a bit more and you'll get a better fork/shock and better brakes. All you really need to do is keep the drivetrain lubed and adjusted properly and you're good. It can be tempting to upgrade parts though. 

OwenJakes wrote:
This is what I bought: https://us.yt-industries.com/products/outlet-sale/378/jeffsy-29-core-2/?number=101400&variant=variant   The aftermarket bike scene is wild with parts and tech and stuff so just being sober minded about what I...

This is what I bought: https://us.yt-industries.com/products/outlet-sale/378/jeffsy-29-core-2/…

 

The aftermarket bike scene is wild with parts and tech and stuff so just being sober minded about what I buy is going to be important. I think for the next 6+ months I'm going to touch nothing except pedals. It comes with ODI grips even. I do want to fiddle with suspension valving though. There's no way the valving is optimal for a 200 pound guy out of the box.

Falcon wrote:
You'd be surprised. Remember, you're going to be on air shocks, front and rear. There's your spring rate. Also, the net weight being damped is your...

You'd be surprised. Remember, you're going to be on air shocks, front and rear. There's your spring rate. Also, the net weight being damped is your body weight + about 35 pounds or less. It will probably work pretty well. Finally, you can add tokens to the air chamber to reduce the volume, which will in effect ramp up the progressivity of the air spring.  

I also think that mtb guys generally have less to deal with than mx. A 200 pound motorcycle flailing in your hands on a high speed outdoor track is probably worse than root chatter lol. i could be wrong but i doubt i have any issues with plushness. As long as it has holdup, i should be fine.

As a person who exclusively grips the dirtbike with my hands, I think I can handle it lmao.

OwenJakes
Posts
1657
Joined
6/30/2023
Location
sebree, KY US
12/6/2023 6:29am
Falcon wrote:
Make sure you're comfy with the brakes being "wrong." You can swap your front brake over to the right hand, if you want.  (Interesting to note...

Make sure you're comfy with the brakes being "wrong." You can swap your front brake over to the right hand, if you want. 

(Interesting to note: that's how they come over in Europe. In America, we're backwards on bicycles.) 

OwenJakes wrote:

Like all hydraulic brakes - swap at the banjos and bleed?

Falcon wrote:

In most cases you can just remove the whole lever assembly and switch sides - they're functionally ambidextrous for this precise issue.

Sorry for the double quote.

I was really curious about this. I should be able to simply swap the levers at the bar mounts right? Just un bolt and swap sides? I am understanding you correctly, right?

Post a reply to: Mountain Biking Cross-Satisfaction?

The Latest