"Best" racer to race a 250 2-stroke?

erik_94COBRA
Posts
1137
Joined
7/21/2016
Location
Houston-ish, TX US

I'm curious to know if there is an agreed upon best 250 2-stroke racer from the 90s or 00s, particularly with good form and technique.  Would like to watch some old footage and see what good riding looks like when these were the top bikes.

Would also be interested in modern bikes/racers too, if any come to mind with plenty of video.

 

|
#434
Posts
1913
Joined
3/23/2017
Location
DE
8/14/2023 3:13pm

Have you seen the footage of Bubba on that KX250?

34
3
mx691
Posts
897
Joined
6/27/2008
Location
Stockholm SE
Fantasy
8/14/2023 3:16pm Edited Date/Time 8/14/2023 3:20pm

RC comes to mind…

Pichon was good!

 

 

 

 

12
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65389
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
8/14/2023 3:51pm

McGrath

Carmichael

Reed

22
2
183Matt
Posts
856
Joined
10/9/2019
Location
Mineral, CA US
8/14/2023 4:06pm

McGrath, hands down.

6
5

The Shop

8/14/2023 4:23pm

He said good form and technique, Everts, Pourcel, Picton, Reed. 

Bubba didn't have good technique?

4
1
8/14/2023 4:23pm

Rc won every outdoor title when he lined up in one , and was the last sx champ on one too 

15
8/14/2023 4:26pm

Then that would be JMB. 

 

I would still say: 

 

Stew

RC

The Rest

 

Good form and techniques are relative. If we are talking modern era, then Stew by a long shot. Considering what he went up against is even more of a consideration. 

3
5
Phil109
Posts
636
Joined
7/7/2019
Location
Montgomery, TX US
8/14/2023 4:28pm
scott_nz wrote:

Rc won every outdoor title when he lined up in one , and was the last sx champ on one too 

RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆 

Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m too young to comment on Bayle but from the one video I did see he was solid. Windham also. 

14
38special
Posts
653
Joined
6/30/2010
Location
US
8/14/2023 5:24pm

The OP is casting bait.  But since we’re biting, I’ll throw Stanton’s name into the mix. 

1
studworx
Posts
835
Joined
1/24/2022
Location
Canada, QC CA
8/14/2023 5:32pm Edited Date/Time 8/14/2023 5:33pm

The "best" form and technique is subjective. Is there any lab tests that show the most ideal position for moto? In F1, moto gp, etc they do tests to find the most efficient rider position. As far as I'm aware, nobody has done that in MX. Riders with "bad" technique have won tons of races, and riders with "good" technique have also won tons of races. But RC didn't have textbook technique and won a lot more than KDub, who did.

4
8/14/2023 5:32pm
scott_nz wrote:

Rc won every outdoor title when he lined up in one , and was the last sx champ on one too 

Phil109 wrote:
RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆  Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m...

RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆 

Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m too young to comment on Bayle but from the one video I did see he was solid. Windham also. 

I think Bubba is grouped in with RC as being this wild rider just hanging off the bike. I think his technique is overlooked because of all his get-offs. He had great technique.  Until he didn't if you know what I mean lmao

3
1
studworx
Posts
835
Joined
1/24/2022
Location
Canada, QC CA
8/14/2023 5:37pm
scott_nz wrote:

Rc won every outdoor title when he lined up in one , and was the last sx champ on one too 

Phil109 wrote:
RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆  Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m...

RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆 

Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m too young to comment on Bayle but from the one video I did see he was solid. Windham also. 

I think Bubba is grouped in with RC as being this wild rider just hanging off the bike. I think his technique is overlooked because of...

I think Bubba is grouped in with RC as being this wild rider just hanging off the bike. I think his technique is overlooked because of all his get-offs. He had great technique.  Until he didn't if you know what I mean lmao

One of the best technique riders especially in the ladder half of his career. And crashing doesn't have much to do with technique at that level, look at Sexton.

63e55a4f544c846aa7fab1eec3ab07d1.png?VersionId=4KlfrgegXGsfV1 xdBmsz191Yu5SPx

14
2
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65389
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
8/14/2023 5:46pm

Musquin

 

 

6
1
deanwhite51
Posts
2670
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
Sydney AU
8/14/2023 5:47pm

1) McGrath

2) Bubba

3) Reed

4) TP199

5) RC4

Ezra Lusk I always thought had amazing style on the 2 stroke.

little too young to keep going back to the OG's of our sport. But I'm sure them older riders prior to the 90's had some amazing rides that you would of had to see in person to appreciate

 

3
2
Sandusky26
Posts
3385
Joined
7/28/2021
Location
Eastern, NC US
8/14/2023 6:06pm

I'm not dissin Stew, but he rode flat footed.

1
3
TDeath21
Posts
6515
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
8/14/2023 6:14pm

Carmichael.

Championships:

00 MX, 01 SX, 01 MX, 02 SX, 02 MX, 03 SX, 03 MX, 05 SX. 

1
2
Forty
Posts
3035
Joined
7/27/2009
Location
Saint Paul, MN US
8/14/2023 6:15pm
TDeath21 wrote:

Carmichael.

Championships:

00 MX, 01 SX, 01 MX, 02 SX, 02 MX, 03 SX, 03 MX, 05 SX. 

perfect season on a 250, hard to top that.

2
erik_94COBRA
Posts
1137
Joined
7/21/2016
Location
Houston-ish, TX US
8/14/2023 7:31pm
38special wrote:

The OP is casting bait.  But since we’re biting, I’ll throw Stanton’s name into the mix. 

Nah, not baiting. 

When I think bulldogging types of racers, I think Carmichael, Villopoto, and Tomac. All ride great but have a riding style that maybe isn’t the most proper (“best”). 
 

When I think graceful, smooth, efficient I think about Windham, Dungey, Sexton, and now Lawrence. 
 

All of these bros are 4 stroke racers. I want to see some smooth, efficient, skilled 2-stroke racers. 

2
Phil109
Posts
636
Joined
7/7/2019
Location
Montgomery, TX US
8/14/2023 7:36pm
scott_nz wrote:

Rc won every outdoor title when he lined up in one , and was the last sx champ on one too 

Phil109 wrote:
RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆  Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m...

RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆 

Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m too young to comment on Bayle but from the one video I did see he was solid. Windham also. 

I think Bubba is grouped in with RC as being this wild rider just hanging off the bike. I think his technique is overlooked because of...

I think Bubba is grouped in with RC as being this wild rider just hanging off the bike. I think his technique is overlooked because of all his get-offs. He had great technique.  Until he didn't if you know what I mean lmao

100% agree. Didn’t meant that as a knock to bubbas technique. He was too talented to tell people to take notes from what he did. I couldn’t fathom the things he did on the bike sometime. However watching guys like MC Reed and Windham. That’s something you can show someone and be like that’s how your ride a dirt bike (within reason) lol

1
8/14/2023 7:40pm
38special wrote:

The OP is casting bait.  But since we’re biting, I’ll throw Stanton’s name into the mix. 

Nah, not baiting.  When I think bulldogging types of racers, I think Carmichael, Villopoto, and Tomac. All ride great but have a riding style that maybe...

Nah, not baiting. 

When I think bulldogging types of racers, I think Carmichael, Villopoto, and Tomac. All ride great but have a riding style that maybe isn’t the most proper (“best”). 
 

When I think graceful, smooth, efficient I think about Windham, Dungey, Sexton, and now Lawrence. 
 

All of these bros are 4 stroke racers. I want to see some smooth, efficient, skilled 2-stroke racers. 

JMB

2
studworx
Posts
835
Joined
1/24/2022
Location
Canada, QC CA
8/14/2023 7:51pm
38special wrote:

The OP is casting bait.  But since we’re biting, I’ll throw Stanton’s name into the mix. 

Nah, not baiting.  When I think bulldogging types of racers, I think Carmichael, Villopoto, and Tomac. All ride great but have a riding style that maybe...

Nah, not baiting. 

When I think bulldogging types of racers, I think Carmichael, Villopoto, and Tomac. All ride great but have a riding style that maybe isn’t the most proper (“best”). 
 

When I think graceful, smooth, efficient I think about Windham, Dungey, Sexton, and now Lawrence. 
 

All of these bros are 4 stroke racers. I want to see some smooth, efficient, skilled 2-stroke racers. 

Those 3 won the majority of races and championships they participated in. Makes you question this “proper” technique thing. But Jett, Chase, etc make it work. Maybe the best technique is the one that works for the rider!

4
8/14/2023 8:10pm

1 Mc, 2 Everts,3 Emig, 4 Huffman much better technique than JMB. 5 Bradshaw, 6 Larry Ward unbeatable in Bercy, 2nd to MC in 95 sx on a shoe string budget stock bike  , beat Stew on a stock 250f with a pipe in his 18 th yr as a pro.  7 Alex Puzar a 250 champ but watch the last race of 95 125 series. That’s how you win a race when you hv to. Perfect form entering & cornering. 

3
2
FWYT
Posts
3536
Joined
5/25/2014
Location
San Diego, CA US
8/14/2023 8:40pm Edited Date/Time 8/14/2023 8:56pm

Form and technique? As in sweet skills?

I always thought Pourcel was just poetic. Also K-Dub, JMB, Hanny, Christian Craig et. al. though those are not all specifically 250 two stroke.

As you can see, there is no "agreed upon" but as the discussion continues, you will start to see some names more than others. Then just start searching YouChoob.

wwdiii
Posts
2535
Joined
4/15/2019
Location
League City, TX US
8/14/2023 8:48pm

McGrath gets my vote.  

1
ATKpilot99
Posts
10416
Joined
4/13/2010
Location
Lake Geneva, WI US
8/15/2023 12:24am

I'd say Bayle . 

1
8/15/2023 1:52am

Not sure if he was the best 2 stroke rider ever but when JS7 was chasing 4 strokes that was pretty good to watch.

2
Richy
Posts
3086
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK GB
8/15/2023 2:52am
Phil109 wrote:
RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆  Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m...

RC won a shit ton on them. But his riding style was atrocious 😆 

Bubba was an animal but MC and Reed had excellent technique. I’m too young to comment on Bayle but from the one video I did see he was solid. Windham also. 

Technically speaking I agree.

But if you watch RC riding a rough track, some of the downhills at Glen Helen stick in my mind, it certainly worked for him.

You can watch the bike swapping left and right and kicking horribly and Ricky just don't care... he just lets it come back to him and does it lap after lap at warp speed.

I appreciate from a text book / technical standpoint he wasn't perfect, especially in the current era and with the benefit of hindsight, but everyone is different and he always did what got the job done.

Also, Pichon was definitely impressive on that RM at the end and Windham is always a pleasure to watch.

Post a reply to: "Best" racer to race a 250 2-stroke?

The Latest