Artificial Whoops??

zehn
Posts
7886
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK, USA
5/3/2023 3:25pm
I snorted. And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create...

I snorted.

And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create track "pieces" they could just drag around the country and put together in whatever configuration. Will destroy the SX sport and make MX even that much more special. man I hate modern sx tracks and THIS shit (fake whoops) is an ominous sign.

None of that is actually happening so you're just making shit up

The picture was from somebody's practice/training track and has nothing to do with the SX series/Feld

7
early
Posts
9925
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
5/3/2023 3:31pm
I snorted. And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create...

I snorted.

And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create track "pieces" they could just drag around the country and put together in whatever configuration. Will destroy the SX sport and make MX even that much more special. man I hate modern sx tracks and THIS shit (fake whoops) is an ominous sign.

Some indoor rc tracks have gone to carpet offroad tracks for 1/10 scale. This gives a clean consistent track, but sacrifices real dirt feel. Alot of places won't lease a space for an indoor track if you want to bring in dirt.

2
1
Ob917
Posts
1145
Joined
9/29/2021
Location
Cardiff, CA, USA
5/3/2023 5:39pm

Please no!

2

The Shop

5/3/2023 5:53pm
I snorted. And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create...

I snorted.

And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create track "pieces" they could just drag around the country and put together in whatever configuration. Will destroy the SX sport and make MX even that much more special. man I hate modern sx tracks and THIS shit (fake whoops) is an ominous sign.

zehn wrote:
None of that is actually happening so you're just making shit up The picture was from somebody's practice/training track and has nothing to do with the...

None of that is actually happening so you're just making shit up

The picture was from somebody's practice/training track and has nothing to do with the SX series/Feld

BREATHE man. I was simply forecasting my opinion on what might happen in the future and why it actually made sense for FELD. Go find a safe space.

4
5
5/3/2023 5:56pm
I snorted. And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create...

I snorted.

And sadly, I've sorta thought this would happen over time. the track jumps/spacing are universal...so it would make sense for Feld to basically create track "pieces" they could just drag around the country and put together in whatever configuration. Will destroy the SX sport and make MX even that much more special. man I hate modern sx tracks and THIS shit (fake whoops) is an ominous sign.

early wrote:
Some indoor rc tracks have gone to carpet offroad tracks for 1/10 scale. This gives a clean consistent track, but sacrifices real dirt feel. Alot of...

Some indoor rc tracks have gone to carpet offroad tracks for 1/10 scale. This gives a clean consistent track, but sacrifices real dirt feel. Alot of places won't lease a space for an indoor track if you want to bring in dirt.

yup. and can you imagine the execs at FELD salivating over the cost savings of NO dirt and just dragging some jumps/whoops/berms around the country and laying out a basic track???

2
-MAVERICK-
Posts
66558
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario, CA
5/3/2023 5:56pm Edited Date/Time 5/3/2023 6:08pm
As a fan i can see it both ways. On one hand, its fun watching pro's navigating a track that changes lap after lap, having to...

As a fan i can see it both ways.

On one hand, its fun watching pro's navigating a track that changes lap after lap, having to adjust their technique and line choice.

On the other hand, its boring AF to watch all 22 riders rip through a goal trail carved in the whoops and not venture anywhere else, so it would be cool if only the whoops didn't break down in that sense. 

Maybe its not a bad idea to do for the whoops but nowhere else? 

How slippery do these things get when wet? 

The top layer is made of textured/anti-slip rubber. I've seen it used around inground pools and walkways. 

The frame is made of aluminum. The middle layer is a composite, and the top is the textured rubber.

Frame

image-20230503204222-1

Middle Layer

 

image-20230503210706-1

Top Layer

 

image-20230503210740-2

image-20230503210809-3

image-20230503205447-6image-20230503205509-7

12
SmokinJoe439
Posts
2389
Joined
3/7/2012
Location
Renton, WA, USA
5/3/2023 6:13pm

Those would fit in with the cardboard box tuff blocks they had at world sx 

1
1
wsc96
Posts
1019
Joined
8/26/2013
Location
AU
5/3/2023 6:27pm

If nothing else; interesting stuff. Electric bikes on synthetic tracks 😮 

2
5/3/2023 7:02pm

Maybe I think a little different.  When I first saw the picture I thought it would be a great idea to have as a form to cover with dirt in order to cut down on the build time it would take to produce a set of whoops every weekend.  But that doesn't look like the intent.   So my second thought was, this sucks.  

1
Cobbler
Posts
432
Joined
3/13/2023
Location
cairo, IL, USA
5/3/2023 8:09pm

Riding your electric dirtbike over fake obstacles and then cooling off back at the e-car with your bros as you crack open a soylent green and talk about how much you’re going to miss Kamala Harris. 
 

motocross, baby. 

26
16
early
Posts
9925
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
5/3/2023 8:14pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:

They're going to be supplying the all-electric FIM E-Xplorer series.

https://www.fimexplorer.com/post/newpartner-x-track-canada

It will be interesting to see how the E-Xplorer series is received. They held that pilot race last year, it was ok, I think there's alot more could be done with it.  I think Eric Perronard is a promoter, he does good work, they post alot of high quality content on Instagram but it's just kinda lifestyle stuff, it's produced well.

It seems the electric market is splintering off into 2 types of bikes; ones that are smaller and less than 200 lbs like the surron, talria, cake, and electric motion, and full size bikes like the varg, Alta, and KTM freeride which are 250+ lbs. 

The lighter bikes seem more popular with people coming off bicycles and moving up to a motorcycle, while most people coming off dirtbikes are waiting for a replacement for what they are used to with gas bikes. 

An artificial track would benefit the lighter bikes as they would have more usable power and longer run times vs loamy dirt. The smaller bikes also benefit from a smaller scale track that makes it more feasible for an indoor facility, along with no exhaust. They seem to be a Canadian company, indoor electric tracks in Canada make alot of sense. 

I could see something like Ray's mtb park work for surron style electric bikes, not so much for full size bikes like the Alta or varg. 

Being that FELD often double dips their dirt with monster jam I don't think they would go to artificial jumps for that reason, but if the riders and fans are always bitching about the track conditions or if they think it would be safer for riders they may go to something like this.

What if they took the over-under bridge and put the ramps on the long side and they could use it as a elevated turn as well as a bridge and jump?

Anyway, looks like the surface would get chewed up in no time. Maybe you can trowel more surface material on to repair it every week. 

1
-MAVERICK-
Posts
66558
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario, CA
5/3/2023 9:22pm
-MAVERICK- wrote:

They're going to be supplying the all-electric FIM E-Xplorer series.

https://www.fimexplorer.com/post/newpartner-x-track-canada

early wrote:
It will be interesting to see how the E-Xplorer series is received. They held that pilot race last year, it was ok, I think there's alot...

It will be interesting to see how the E-Xplorer series is received. They held that pilot race last year, it was ok, I think there's alot more could be done with it.  I think Eric Perronard is a promoter, he does good work, they post alot of high quality content on Instagram but it's just kinda lifestyle stuff, it's produced well.

It seems the electric market is splintering off into 2 types of bikes; ones that are smaller and less than 200 lbs like the surron, talria, cake, and electric motion, and full size bikes like the varg, Alta, and KTM freeride which are 250+ lbs. 

The lighter bikes seem more popular with people coming off bicycles and moving up to a motorcycle, while most people coming off dirtbikes are waiting for a replacement for what they are used to with gas bikes. 

An artificial track would benefit the lighter bikes as they would have more usable power and longer run times vs loamy dirt. The smaller bikes also benefit from a smaller scale track that makes it more feasible for an indoor facility, along with no exhaust. They seem to be a Canadian company, indoor electric tracks in Canada make alot of sense. 

I could see something like Ray's mtb park work for surron style electric bikes, not so much for full size bikes like the Alta or varg. 

Being that FELD often double dips their dirt with monster jam I don't think they would go to artificial jumps for that reason, but if the riders and fans are always bitching about the track conditions or if they think it would be safer for riders they may go to something like this.

What if they took the over-under bridge and put the ramps on the long side and they could use it as a elevated turn as well as a bridge and jump?

Anyway, looks like the surface would get chewed up in no time. Maybe you can trowel more surface material on to repair it every week. 

It's a Canadian company out of Quebec. We've had a few indoor tracks pop up here and there, but as far as I know, none worked out long-term. Why did they all shut down? If I had to guess, the cost to operate a facility to the number of riders using them didn't make financial sense. 

Our riding population is likely too small, but with electric bikes like Surron, Talaria, etc., perhaps that segment could grow enough to sustain a year-round indoor facility.

I don't know how well the surface would hold up to the abuse of dirt bikes. Some people have done their driveways with a rubber coating, but they park on it. With wheelspin, braking, hard landings, crashes, etc., they might have to retouch the surface every few rounds. From what I've seen the cost is $8-$15 sq. ft. It's something they would have to keep in mind. 

I could see the whoops being something they use from round to round. Dirt Wurx builds the track as usual, and when the crew arrives with the tough blocks all they need to do is drop the modules for the whoops into place, and they're done. 

I'm sure the modules are not cheap to build. With dirt, you never need repairs. Need more dirt? Just buy more, and you're done. 

I think they're more suited for BMX/MTB parks/indoor tracks than MX/SX tracks. 

1
devotid
Posts
834
Joined
12/16/2018
Location
Saginaw, MI, USA
5/3/2023 10:10pm

Ive have watched carpet jumps and synthetic tracks completely ruin RC 1/10 scale "off road" racing over the last few years. It completely removes the "tuning throughout the day" aspect and they end up looking like trash after a few races from chipping. 

I beg the Moto industry to not even start with this. It's cool for about a week and then it loses all of its soul when everything "feels exactly the same". Its lazy. Thats all it is. There is nothing better than a freshly groomed track.

last... Tire wear would be brutal and even more important to have a brand new one with fresh edges. 

My worthless $0.02 rant.

 

3
burnside
Posts
4095
Joined
6/17/2009
Location
London, USA
5/4/2023 2:33am

Could be "a thing" just because they are easy to advertise on. 

2
Echo
Posts
326
Joined
12/27/2022
Location
London, GB
5/4/2023 4:12am
LungButter wrote:

Stupidest idea ever....they are called DIRT bikes...want the same perfect conditions lap after lap?  Go street bike racing....

Clearly never rode a street bike on track

3
1
vtnewb
Posts
122
Joined
7/16/2021
Location
Northfield, VT, USA
5/4/2023 5:14am

Would be sick in a minigolf course

3
Tumic
Posts
2823
Joined
11/27/2012
Location
Sundsvall, SE
5/4/2023 5:26am

Sorry but id rather see this than whoops turn in to jumpers mid night…

 

4
6
5/4/2023 6:03am
As a fan i can see it both ways. On one hand, its fun watching pro's navigating a track that changes lap after lap, having to...

As a fan i can see it both ways.

On one hand, its fun watching pro's navigating a track that changes lap after lap, having to adjust their technique and line choice.

On the other hand, its boring AF to watch all 22 riders rip through a goal trail carved in the whoops and not venture anywhere else, so it would be cool if only the whoops didn't break down in that sense. 

Maybe its not a bad idea to do for the whoops but nowhere else? 

How slippery do these things get when wet? 

-MAVERICK- wrote:
The top layer is made of textured/anti-slip rubber. I've seen it used around inground pools and walkways.  The frame is made of aluminum. The middle layer is...

The top layer is made of textured/anti-slip rubber. I've seen it used around inground pools and walkways. 

The frame is made of aluminum. The middle layer is a composite, and the top is the textured rubber.

Frame

image-20230503204222-1

Middle Layer

 

image-20230503210706-1

Top Layer

 

image-20230503210740-2

image-20230503210809-3

image-20230503205447-6image-20230503205509-7

If the term "giant waste of unnecessary effort and resources" had a product to sell. Just use dirt man. What a waste of a product. Costs way more than dirt, has even less give than dirt in a crash. Way more effort in making the track. No more skill to ride rough tracks and ruts required..

2
3
Question
Posts
3178
Joined
6/26/2014
Location
FR
5/4/2023 6:53am
burnside wrote:

Could be "a thing" just because they are easy to advertise on. 

I was gonna say both sets look scary but you've got a very solid point. That could quite become the "discount tyre whoops section". The tech behind is interesting, it looks like it can absorb some impact, which may make it feel like a set of whoops that have been a bit watered. But that looks big, only for pros ...

1
Crossup
Posts
1655
Joined
12/13/2007
Location
Freetown, MA, USA
5/4/2023 7:30am

It's sounds like MiniGolfCross. How about a windmill tunnel or a moat with a drawbridge that opens and closes during the race?

3
SonofThor32
Posts
862
Joined
5/30/2021
Location
Corryton, TN, USA
5/4/2023 7:38am
Cobbler wrote:
Riding your electric dirtbike over fake obstacles and then cooling off back at the e-car with your bros as you crack open a soylent green and...

Riding your electric dirtbike over fake obstacles and then cooling off back at the e-car with your bros as you crack open a soylent green and talk about how much you’re going to miss Kamala Harris. 
 

motocross, baby. 

You nailed it with the soy part, it puts hair on your chest Wink

Kidding aside, you can draw a contrast from offroad RC racing to SX.  Offroad RC used to be..  outdoors, dirt, and nitro.  Now it is indoors, electric, and carpet tracks are taking off like nobody's business.  I feel like I am a walking contradiction because I am not a fan of.. well, soy, but also the idea of electric SX/MX sounds ridiculous.  However, offroad RC racing, electric has definitely evolved the hobby, racing indoors is much more enjoyable, and I hate to say it, but the lack of maintenance racing on carpet for both the cars/buggies but also the lack of maintenance for the track operators and having a virtually modular track is kind of cool. 

I know it is not the same, but it sort of is.  Hopefully MX/SX can keep it's roots.

3
2
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
5/4/2023 11:38am

Besides that, there's no way DeCoster approves of it and releases his stranglehold on track design....

Show us where Decoster hurt you on the dolly....

 

As for the artificial whoops.   Good grief.

Start grates, holeshot devices, traction control, RPM lights.... 

WTF happened to this sport. 

 

3
4
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
5/4/2023 11:52am
Magoofan wrote:
Show us where Decoster hurt you on the dolly....   As for the artificial whoops.   Good grief. Start grates, holeshot devices, traction control, RPM lights....  WTF...

Show us where Decoster hurt you on the dolly....

 

As for the artificial whoops.   Good grief.

Start grates, holeshot devices, traction control, RPM lights.... 

WTF happened to this sport. 

 

Webb better hope like hell that they don't start using those in SX while he's still racing.... Tongue

1
wreckitrandy
Posts
4211
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC, USA
5/4/2023 1:07pm

Besides that, there's no way DeCoster approves of it and releases his stranglehold on track design....

Magoofan wrote:
Show us where Decoster hurt you on the dolly....   As for the artificial whoops.   Good grief. Start grates, holeshot devices, traction control, RPM lights....  WTF...

Show us where Decoster hurt you on the dolly....

 

As for the artificial whoops.   Good grief.

Start grates, holeshot devices, traction control, RPM lights.... 

WTF happened to this sport. 

 

Sarcasm. Magoo needs to up the prescription on his coke bottle glasses. 

5/4/2023 4:22pm
wsc96 wrote:
Let’s see some video of how it went. 

Let’s see some video of how it went. 

Zachintosh wrote:
   
 

 

I remembered that like it was yesterday.

Wink

5/4/2023 4:34pm

First thing I thought was this could be a cool training tool to get started on. Then you progress to actual dirt.

I think I'll se my most down votes ever for this post. LOL

TM

1
rawjahdesigns
Posts
343
Joined
4/22/2018
Location
Huntington Beach, CA, USA
5/4/2023 6:25pm

with this and stark coming along, we will see some week day practice and testing at hotels trying starts and working on whoops by manufacturers  ordering their own Technix whoop pad from who ever makes them.  could build the sport into a tremendous size to be real...   E Supercross with tracks that are put together like  puzzles, basically the same way a sx track is put together just in different 'pieces'  or, jumps, in different spots essentially.  the future!

Post a reply to: Artificial Whoops??

The Latest