Star Yam 250F what failed?

seth505
Posts
10218
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
SD, CA, USA
6/22/2016 9:13am
TSCHAM101 wrote:
whoops
Silly
colintrax
Posts
4695
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA, USA
6/22/2016 9:18am
Anyone got a screen shot, I don't remember it being blue smoke
resetjet
Posts
2560
Joined
3/16/2012
Location
Tampa, FL, USA
6/22/2016 9:38am
Dont matter blue or white. Lean can cause either, but i think i saw smoke coming from pipe and bluish.
norcal3737
Posts
262
Joined
1/24/2012
Location
Livermore, CA, USA
6/22/2016 9:49am
TSCHAM101 wrote:
whoops
Its a good thing you're a Vital keyboard team mechanic, and not an actual realworld tuner.

Read more, post less.

The Shop

Tpog496
Posts
1282
Joined
9/16/2014
Location
USA
6/22/2016 9:56am
TSCHAM101 wrote:
whoops
500guy wrote:
It's all about Lambda = perfect air to fuel ratio 14.7:1 , less air means less fuel is needed.
Stoich is 14.7:1. Lambda is the equivalence ratio or the ratio of actual air fuel mixture to stoich. So at 14.7:1 Lambda = 1.
Tpog496
Posts
1282
Joined
9/16/2014
Location
USA
6/22/2016 10:06am
colintrax wrote:
Anyone got a screen shot, I don't remember it being blue smoke


TSCHAM101
Posts
1063
Joined
12/7/2015
Location
Norco, CA, USA
6/22/2016 10:28am
TSCHAM101 wrote:
whoops
norcal3737 wrote:
Its a good thing you're a Vital keyboard team mechanic, and not an actual realworld tuner.

Read more, post less.
atleast im not a douche like yourself..
mb
Posts
775
Joined
7/22/2014
Location
Columbia, SC, USA
6/22/2016 10:44am
If you think those bikes are running 14.7:1 under acceleration than I'd guess you don't have any real world experience.
philG
Posts
11271
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
6/22/2016 10:59am
anyone running at 14.7:1 needs their head looking at ... way too lean. Good dyno numbers though
resetjet
Posts
2560
Joined
3/16/2012
Location
Tampa, FL, USA
6/22/2016 10:59am
No doubt that is smoke and not steam. Running too lean, top could not make it through race.
cwtoyota
Posts
2424
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
Tacoma, WA, USA
6/22/2016 12:19pm
philG wrote:
anyone running at 14.7:1 needs their head looking at ... way too lean. Good dyno numbers though
Haha. Really good dyno numbers, but only for a minute.
c0ncEpT
Posts
1320
Joined
5/13/2015
Location
Harrison Twp., MI, USA
6/22/2016 12:48pm
philG wrote:
anyone running at 14.7:1 needs their head looking at ... way too lean. Good dyno numbers though
Won't even make a good number. It will pick up power by adding fuel at that point.
philG
Posts
11271
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
6/22/2016 1:36pm
the custom maps my sponsor did were based on what he learned from early nissan GTR work.. a bit of trial and error to start, and then go with what you know, high 10's on full load, loads of HP , he always joked it was more likely to hydraulic lock than burn a valve, Supermoto is easier to see the difference, our 450 used fuel for fun, but nothing touched it for speed , even with a 25kg overweight rider on it.. with a proper pilot on board , it was faster than the factory bike of the time, even with their best rider on it.
6/22/2016 7:44pm
One point I am curious about is the attitude of the mechanics towards replacing engines after Alex Martin's went dead.

After Alex Martin DNF because of an engine failure, I personally thought they better change all the Star team engines in between moto's. Did J. Martin's tech ask for a new engine?

Was J. Martin's engine the same from moto one, or a new replacement?
When were the engines that went bad installed and who builds them?
If a map was so lean to cause an engine failure the rider should of been seriously lacking power?

So many questions and no answers.
Jspazz
Posts
159
Joined
2/1/2015
Location
CA
6/22/2016 7:47pm Edited Date/Time 6/22/2016 7:49pm
GTR needs 10:1 because it needs all the cooling the extra fuel from the hot charge coming from the turbos.

I would likely guess they are running around 13:1 +/- 0.5 at WOT, the tuner will always start out a map rich then gradually go leaner and advance ignition to make more power. Less fuel, advanced ignition = hotter and more powerful combustion. Plus less fuel used in the race - if 12:1 and 13:1 makes the same power, the race team will go 13:1, for those 1-2 lbs weight savings alone.

These guys rebuild these motors enough they know how lean they can go to last 2 motos. And to make 250 pro motocross power, they are probably REALLY lean and really advanced ignition with really hot cams, and a very specific fuel and ignition map for the fuel they are using. To the point that maybe some crap in the fuel (or even a bad batch of fuel) the Martin's bikes were fed could have caused the issue.

If they park next to each other under the tent, they probably get filled 1/2 of the same 5 gallon tank each.
lumpy790
Posts
11831
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
6/22/2016 7:58pm
Looks white like a blown head gasket burning coolant.

6/22/2016 8:02pm
One point I am curious about is the attitude of the mechanics towards replacing engines after Alex Martin's went dead. After Alex Martin DNF because of...
One point I am curious about is the attitude of the mechanics towards replacing engines after Alex Martin's went dead.

After Alex Martin DNF because of an engine failure, I personally thought they better change all the Star team engines in between moto's. Did J. Martin's tech ask for a new engine?

Was J. Martin's engine the same from moto one, or a new replacement?
When were the engines that went bad installed and who builds them?
If a map was so lean to cause an engine failure the rider should of been seriously lacking power?

So many questions and no answers.
If they didn't know exactly what caused the failure, then just switching out all of the engines on the other bikes could've been risky. Who is to say that the spares don't have the same fault. They could have switched a good one that was already in the bike for a bad spare one.

To me it would seem unwise to make changes without knowing the whole story. Heck, maybe they did know, I have no idea, but in that short of time between motos they may not have figured it out yet.
Grieby54
Posts
2826
Joined
7/1/2008
Location
Castle Rock, CO, USA
6/22/2016 10:17pm Edited Date/Time 6/22/2016 10:18pm
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day? What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down. Anyone have experience with a...
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day?

What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down.

Anyone have experience with a meltdown that looked similar?
Pulp show they mentioned water pump seal and also discussed the wrong map (lean fuel=heat).
From my couch it looked as though the water pump seal or shaft failed and they over heated.
An abnormal amount of those first 2014 pump shafts did fail, looks like maybe the team received a bad batch?

Let's never point our finger at an individual unless we have proof.

What do you all think? Any insiders have the goods?
And this is how stupid rumors get started. He was joking. He, JT, and Weege were all talking about how ridiculous that notion would be.
colintrax
Posts
4695
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA, USA
6/22/2016 10:58pm
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day? What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down. Anyone have experience with a...
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day?

What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down.

Anyone have experience with a meltdown that looked similar?
Pulp show they mentioned water pump seal and also discussed the wrong map (lean fuel=heat).
From my couch it looked as though the water pump seal or shaft failed and they over heated.
An abnormal amount of those first 2014 pump shafts did fail, looks like maybe the team received a bad batch?

Let's never point our finger at an individual unless we have proof.

What do you all think? Any insiders have the goods?
Lumpy don't you go to all the races? If somebody got a chance to smell it, that'd put an end to the oil or coolant debate.
colintrax
Posts
4695
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA, USA
6/22/2016 10:59pm
colintrax wrote:
Anyone got a screen shot, I don't remember it being blue smoke
Tpog496 wrote:
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2016/06/22/140530/s1200_AMART.jpg[/img]


Thank you, looks like coolant to me.
VRR7
Posts
868
Joined
6/1/2011
Location
ZA
6/22/2016 11:02pm
Smoke is not coming out the pipe ! It appears to be smoke coming out the crank case breather . Which makes forgetting to reset the EFI from hi altitude settings plausible. Running too lean the rings wore prematurely causing blow by which will cause smoke out the crank case breather v out of the pipe. Plus he was able to run for quite a long time before it stopped completely. Broken piston would be smoke out pipe. Valves smoke out pipe . Head gasket Steam out pipe. I figure the rings got very worn fast due to to lean EFI setting. That's not very professional considering it happened to a 2nd bike in the 2nd moto. Meaning they where for warned ? With Fuel injection is it not standard for the mechanics to set the optimum map for each track day ? ( Humidity and Temperature ?) Road race its standard plug in laptop and set it. Faster than chasing brass all practice day .

MotoGP - Yamaha said it was the controlled ECU that caused the motor to blow. Down the straight at the end there is a bump and full revs and throttle the controlled ECU was not fast enough to catch the over rev. So the both Yamaha's went into over rev conditions which never happened when they used there own ECU units.
tunedlength
Posts
2784
Joined
12/9/2006
Location
Ontario, CA, USA
6/22/2016 11:02pm
What failed?
Could be tuning, could be assembly.
Could be a part they have used for years but the supplier does one little thing different (heat treat or miss a slight machining tolerance) and some motors fail.
The vendor and customer may not even understand what really caused the failure for quite some time.

Why didn't they all fail?
Some riders bang off the rev limiter and some run between peak torque and peak power.
They both put different stresses on the motor so its logical that they may experience different failure scenarios.

What happened between motos?
Lets assume they knew what caused the failure (doubtful) and all the motors need to be swapped.
Why wouldn't they just change all the motors?
Think about the time frame required to swap motors with the new schedule (there are only 40 short minutes to retrieve bike, clean bike, swap a motor and complete normal race service. IMO this is simply ludicrous)
Now imagine you have to do this for a whole team with four bikes!
Star has been at this a long time and have finished hundreds of motos so I wouldn't say this is endemic of the brand.
One thing for sure this sport is a tough on riders as well as mechanics, its not now and never has been a sport for the faint hearted.
blackdiamond
Posts
1363
Joined
11/5/2015
Location
Grapevine, TX, USA
6/22/2016 11:45pm
philG wrote:
anyone running at 14.7:1 needs their head looking at ... way too lean. Good dyno numbers though
I run C12 mixed 40:1. Problem solved.

Sorry, I couldn't resist guys Laughing
philG
Posts
11271
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
6/23/2016 12:36am
Jspazz wrote:
GTR needs 10:1 because it needs all the cooling the extra fuel from the hot charge coming from the turbos. I would likely guess they are...
GTR needs 10:1 because it needs all the cooling the extra fuel from the hot charge coming from the turbos.

I would likely guess they are running around 13:1 +/- 0.5 at WOT, the tuner will always start out a map rich then gradually go leaner and advance ignition to make more power. Less fuel, advanced ignition = hotter and more powerful combustion. Plus less fuel used in the race - if 12:1 and 13:1 makes the same power, the race team will go 13:1, for those 1-2 lbs weight savings alone.

These guys rebuild these motors enough they know how lean they can go to last 2 motos. And to make 250 pro motocross power, they are probably REALLY lean and really advanced ignition with really hot cams, and a very specific fuel and ignition map for the fuel they are using. To the point that maybe some crap in the fuel (or even a bad batch of fuel) the Martin's bikes were fed could have caused the issue.

If they park next to each other under the tent, they probably get filled 1/2 of the same 5 gallon tank each.
Yes , that was where he started , knowing it was too rich, and went from there .. we didn't have a dyno , just went off feel and plug colour , and then when we had got to a point we were happy with , we would take the bike onto the same dyno Rinaldi were using back then as a benchmark to see where we were.

Our needs were different, we didn't have a fuel issue, tank was big enough, and we were selling on the maps to chosen customers with engines we knew would take it as we had them built , a top line guy would need a mid season refresh, normal guys would run a season on oil changes and valve checks.

Running the thing on the edge of death to save weight on the fuel is bizarre, although I know people do it.

We learned early on that rider feel and laptime tells you more than a dyno sheet , people who had our maps and went to a dyno , all got told ' I can make more HP than this easy' and all came back with bigger numbers, and a slower bike.

He took the same logic to the SXV road race series, which was supposed to be a spec motor series , and they agreed to allow the maps as long as they were freely available, as the motors lasted better , and were faster.

I know these guys run on the edge , this is why running 250's is a money pit.

you can bet they know why , this 'bad batch of parts ' thing always pisses me off .
6/23/2016 4:15am
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day? What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down. Anyone have experience with a...
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day?

What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down.

Anyone have experience with a meltdown that looked similar?
Pulp show they mentioned water pump seal and also discussed the wrong map (lean fuel=heat).
From my couch it looked as though the water pump seal or shaft failed and they over heated.
An abnormal amount of those first 2014 pump shafts did fail, looks like maybe the team received a bad batch?

Let's never point our finger at an individual unless we have proof.

What do you all think? Any insiders have the goods?
True words : resetjet

But mxking809 this Sports so fickle I'll put on the hat and just say it !!

It was fucking intentional

in order for pulp to maintain its integrity it cannot entertain this as fact

I get that

But ... No ... Those bikes were sabotaged


By who ? Probably Johnny O hahahaha


Star! Unlike the yosh #7 bike ! Where The team Purposely supplies a subpar bike because they are so pissed with all the money they've lost !

Star still wants to win!
Star didn't sabotage there own bikes, even if both guys are leaving the team!


But someone did!

Last year when marv lost the title due to bike failure ! That was bike failure !

Seeing the Martin brothers last weekend ? That was sabotage!
BobPA
Posts
8342
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
USA
6/23/2016 4:34am
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day? What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down. Anyone have experience with a...
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day?

What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down.

Anyone have experience with a meltdown that looked similar?
Pulp show they mentioned water pump seal and also discussed the wrong map (lean fuel=heat).
From my couch it looked as though the water pump seal or shaft failed and they over heated.
An abnormal amount of those first 2014 pump shafts did fail, looks like maybe the team received a bad batch?

Let's never point our finger at an individual unless we have proof.

What do you all think? Any insiders have the goods?
This is correct
6/23/2016 4:46am
I think it would be completely ignorant and infantile of Star racing to sabotage two bikes that the riders were in contention for a national title. Either of the Martins are still a threat to win. I don't see Star as the type to shoot themselves in the foot..... Webb is gone next year, why not sabotage him too...

Oh, and if they mechanics "forgot" to change the tune from the last race they should be fired immediately.... Again, I don't think they are that stupid....

BobPA
Posts
8342
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
USA
6/23/2016 6:06am Edited Date/Time 6/23/2016 6:12am
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day? What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down. Anyone have experience with a...
Last time 2 factory engines failed same day?

What we know? Both bikes went smoking or steaming before they shut down.

Anyone have experience with a meltdown that looked similar?
Pulp show they mentioned water pump seal and also discussed the wrong map (lean fuel=heat).
From my couch it looked as though the water pump seal or shaft failed and they over heated.
An abnormal amount of those first 2014 pump shafts did fail, looks like maybe the team received a bad batch?

Let's never point our finger at an individual unless we have proof.

What do you all think? Any insiders have the goods?
Naturally Aspirated engines are no where near high 10's during full load...turbo applications do not apply to our dirt bikes, get a new tuner
early
Posts
10109
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
6/23/2016 6:28am
Icespikes wrote:
True words : resetjet But mxking809 this Sports so fickle I'll put on the hat and just say it !! It was fucking intentional in order...
True words : resetjet

But mxking809 this Sports so fickle I'll put on the hat and just say it !!

It was fucking intentional

in order for pulp to maintain its integrity it cannot entertain this as fact

I get that

But ... No ... Those bikes were sabotaged


By who ? Probably Johnny O hahahaha


Star! Unlike the yosh #7 bike ! Where The team Purposely supplies a subpar bike because they are so pissed with all the money they've lost !

Star still wants to win!
Star didn't sabotage there own bikes, even if both guys are leaving the team!


But someone did!

Last year when marv lost the title due to bike failure ! That was bike failure !

Seeing the Martin brothers last weekend ? That was sabotage!
Baggetts bike look pretty good for a moto. Is there some secret remote controlled eject button on James' bike? Would sure explain Daytona and Hangtown.
philG
Posts
11271
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
6/23/2016 7:57am
BobPA wrote:
Naturally Aspirated engines are no where near high 10's during full load...turbo applications do not apply to our dirt bikes, get a new tuner
i just rode it , it was faster than anything else , with just DLC coating's good mapping and put together by a proper guy.

all the guys that rode it, nobody had ridden one faster.

I am aware that turbo applications dont apply, but the logic of where you really need to be, as opposed to where t you think you need to be is the same.. nothing ever got faster using less fuel.

Post a reply to: Star Yam 250F what failed?

The Latest