mxa/ stewart news?

ChrisB10
Posts
2082
Joined
5/24/2014
Location
Plattsburgh, NY, USA
12/16/2014 2:31pm
I love James but he's shown some immaturity over the years. I thought he was past that but failing to provide a TUE is just moronic. I'm so bummed but don't want to hear sh*t about WADA being too harsh. Rules are rules. Clear as fn day. This all could of been avoided. Let's be adults about this instead of acting like kids by pouting and blaming WADA. One of life's lessons learned the hard way. James, you are not above the rules.
davistld01
Posts
9423
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Springfield, MO, USA
12/16/2014 2:40pm Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 2:42pm
If i was him i wouldnt give an interview to anyone. That is a pathetic shame! Punishment yes. Suspending him for that long is disgusting!
Agreed. If the powers that be want to make an example out of James, the example has been made. I'm not saying for a second that he didn't do things the wrong way...because he did, and it was a stupid mistake on his part. But...to take a rider like James who still has what it takes to win a championship before he retires, and put him into all but forced retirement over bullshit like this is just kinda rubbing his nose in it unnecessarily. But...those are just my thoughts.
wydopen
Posts
1306
Joined
8/17/2011
Location
805, CA, USA
12/16/2014 2:48pm
ChrisB10 wrote:
I love James but he's shown some immaturity over the years. I thought he was past that but failing to provide a TUE is just moronic...
I love James but he's shown some immaturity over the years. I thought he was past that but failing to provide a TUE is just moronic. I'm so bummed but don't want to hear sh*t about WADA being too harsh. Rules are rules. Clear as fn day. This all could of been avoided. Let's be adults about this instead of acting like kids by pouting and blaming WADA. One of life's lessons learned the hard way. James, you are not above the rules.
The main thing that drives me nuts about this whole situation is the fact that people are assuming way to much..I'm referring to the internet poster as well as the media and people participating in the various discussions on PulpMx over the last several months..

People are going on and on about how its so stupid and confusing how James and "his people" didn't provide a TUE, how he isn't "above the rules" etc etc..Do you people know this as fact?

Isn't it quite possible that they did submit a TUE and filled out all the required paperwork but it was either rejected or there was an error which rendered it invalid? Doesn't that sound a little more likely than his entire camp simply forgot or were too stupid or just didn't feel like filling out the paperwork?

As we have now seen it takes WADA a very long time to render a decision..maybe he had a TUE submitted and it took until right before Seattle for them to reject it...the point is we don't know so stop acting like you do...

That said I hope they just take his points away from last year and let him go for the championship this year..

gsxrcr28
Posts
7417
Joined
3/5/2009
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA
12/16/2014 2:57pm
ChrisB10 wrote:
I love James but he's shown some immaturity over the years. I thought he was past that but failing to provide a TUE is just moronic...
I love James but he's shown some immaturity over the years. I thought he was past that but failing to provide a TUE is just moronic. I'm so bummed but don't want to hear sh*t about WADA being too harsh. Rules are rules. Clear as fn day. This all could of been avoided. Let's be adults about this instead of acting like kids by pouting and blaming WADA. One of life's lessons learned the hard way. James, you are not above the rules.
wydopen wrote:
The main thing that drives me nuts about this whole situation is the fact that people are assuming way to much..I'm referring to the internet poster...
The main thing that drives me nuts about this whole situation is the fact that people are assuming way to much..I'm referring to the internet poster as well as the media and people participating in the various discussions on PulpMx over the last several months..

People are going on and on about how its so stupid and confusing how James and "his people" didn't provide a TUE, how he isn't "above the rules" etc etc..Do you people know this as fact?

Isn't it quite possible that they did submit a TUE and filled out all the required paperwork but it was either rejected or there was an error which rendered it invalid? Doesn't that sound a little more likely than his entire camp simply forgot or were too stupid or just didn't feel like filling out the paperwork?

As we have now seen it takes WADA a very long time to render a decision..maybe he had a TUE submitted and it took until right before Seattle for them to reject it...the point is we don't know so stop acting like you do...

That said I hope they just take his points away from last year and let him go for the championship this year..

Racer X and TWMX both said he applied for a TUE immediately after the failed test, and now has an approved TUE for future races.

The Shop

12/16/2014 2:58pm
wydopen wrote:
The main thing that drives me nuts about this whole situation is the fact that people are assuming way to much..I'm referring to the internet poster...
The main thing that drives me nuts about this whole situation is the fact that people are assuming way to much..I'm referring to the internet poster as well as the media and people participating in the various discussions on PulpMx over the last several months..

People are going on and on about how its so stupid and confusing how James and "his people" didn't provide a TUE, how he isn't "above the rules" etc etc..Do you people know this as fact?

Isn't it quite possible that they did submit a TUE and filled out all the required paperwork but it was either rejected or there was an error which rendered it invalid? Doesn't that sound a little more likely than his entire camp simply forgot or were too stupid or just didn't feel like filling out the paperwork?

As we have now seen it takes WADA a very long time to render a decision..maybe he had a TUE submitted and it took until right before Seattle for them to reject it...the point is we don't know so stop acting like you do...

That said I hope they just take his points away from last year and let him go for the championship this year..

If it was rejected then he continued to take the drug knowing he wasn't allowed which is obviously a worse situation than forgetting to submit.
If it was invalid then I'm sure he would have been contacted.

Surely he needed to submit a TUE before ever taking the drug? It certainly isn't a drug that his life depends on so he couldn't have waited until he heard back about his TUE if he did submit one? Lets be real here, they forgot, or didn't know the rules. Ignorance is bliss, except it isn't.
Gbizzle
Posts
89
Joined
2/7/2011
Location
USA
12/16/2014 3:19pm
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a valid prescription for an amphetamine at the time? Since that test it is possible a doctor wrote him a prescription and he then applied and was granted a TUE?
rippaaa
Posts
366
Joined
11/22/2014
Location
CA
12/16/2014 3:30pm
Gbizzle wrote:
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a...
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a valid prescription for an amphetamine at the time? Since that test it is possible a doctor wrote him a prescription and he then applied and was granted a TUE?
At the time of the test, he had a perscription but no TUE and he had not applied for one.

WHen they accepted his TUE, during a failed test case for the same drug he failed the test with you can bet your ass they reviewed it extra carefully and checked when the perscription was given.

Im talking out of my ass here because none of us really know much about this whole thing.
gsxrcr28
Posts
7417
Joined
3/5/2009
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA
12/16/2014 3:33pm
Gbizzle wrote:
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a...
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a valid prescription for an amphetamine at the time? Since that test it is possible a doctor wrote him a prescription and he then applied and was granted a TUE?
I don't think it's as simple as showing a prescription. I think they do a thorough background check of your medical history when applying for a TUE. And all of the info that has come out has said he has been taking it for "years"
endurox
Posts
2110
Joined
3/22/2014
Location
Garden City, ID, USA
12/16/2014 4:02pm
I JS7 is ineligable to race, he and Jlow should do a few exhibiiton laps on some 250 2 strokes right before the first evening race at all the supercross events.
jasen.bougher
Posts
249
Joined
1/12/2013
Location
Park Ridge, NJ, USA
12/16/2014 4:19pm Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 4:23pm
Gbizzle wrote:
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a...
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a valid prescription for an amphetamine at the time? Since that test it is possible a doctor wrote him a prescription and he then applied and was granted a TUE?
It's a drug thats very easy to get a prescription for. That's why the vast majority of athletes that have a prescription are using it to cheat
Xracer
Posts
530
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/16/2014 4:22pm
Never happen. Bubba turning a hot lap on a 250 2-stroke would make the rest of the night show seem boring. Ever see Orlando 05'?
kiwifan
Posts
9868
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
USA
12/16/2014 4:27pm
Gbizzle wrote:
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a...
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a valid prescription for an amphetamine at the time? Since that test it is possible a doctor wrote him a prescription and he then applied and was granted a TUE?
rippaaa wrote:
At the time of the test, he had a perscription but no TUE and he had not applied for one. WHen they accepted his TUE, during...
At the time of the test, he had a perscription but no TUE and he had not applied for one.

WHen they accepted his TUE, during a failed test case for the same drug he failed the test with you can bet your ass they reviewed it extra carefully and checked when the perscription was given.

Im talking out of my ass here because none of us really know much about this whole thing.
and we may never know the true story about what has gone on both personally with JS and through his team/WADA/etc

We probably dont need to know the details, only when he is racing again....whether thats in 3 weeks time or in 1 year or whatever.
LoudLove
Posts
3024
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
USA
12/16/2014 4:56pm
The most simple answer is often the truth, and it's not missing TUE filings, after-the-fact mea culpas, etc. It's that JSE thought they could get away with it.

WADA has heard and seen it all, and James is just another athlete looking for an edge. Plus it's hard to argue "medical necessity", when the vast majority of his wins and all of his titles came prior to his taking the violating drug (December 2012).
rippaaa
Posts
366
Joined
11/22/2014
Location
CA
12/16/2014 5:08pm Edited Date/Time 12/16/2014 5:08pm
LoudLove wrote:
The most simple answer is often the truth, and it's not missing TUE filings, after-the-fact mea culpas, etc. It's that JSE thought they could get away...
The most simple answer is often the truth, and it's not missing TUE filings, after-the-fact mea culpas, etc. It's that JSE thought they could get away with it.

WADA has heard and seen it all, and James is just another athlete looking for an edge. Plus it's hard to argue "medical necessity", when the vast majority of his wins and all of his titles came prior to his taking the violating drug (December 2012).
What connection do you have to the FIM or WADA that supports you're claim? (about him cheating)
kiwifan
Posts
9868
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
USA
12/16/2014 6:34pm
Gbizzle wrote:
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a...
So there is an assuming he either didn't apply for for TUE or it was not approved. What is the probability he did not have a valid prescription for an amphetamine at the time? Since that test it is possible a doctor wrote him a prescription and he then applied and was granted a TUE?
rippaaa wrote:
At the time of the test, he had a perscription but no TUE and he had not applied for one. WHen they accepted his TUE, during...
At the time of the test, he had a perscription but no TUE and he had not applied for one.

WHen they accepted his TUE, during a failed test case for the same drug he failed the test with you can bet your ass they reviewed it extra carefully and checked when the perscription was given.

Im talking out of my ass here because none of us really know much about this whole thing.
kiwifan wrote:
and we may never know the true story about what has gone on both personally with JS and through his team/WADA/etc We probably dont need to...
and we may never know the true story about what has gone on both personally with JS and through his team/WADA/etc

We probably dont need to know the details, only when he is racing again....whether thats in 3 weeks time or in 1 year or whatever.
In saying that...I still wonder about the IV drip thing...the elephant in the room?
ando
Posts
4636
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth, AU
12/16/2014 6:35pm
Robgvx wrote:
So what happened about it being OK to race outdoors because the Nationals weren't an FIM sanctioned event?
He was only provisionally suspended at the time, pending the outcome of the case.

Even though they aren't obliged to do so, I think it would take massive balls for MX Sports to allow a rider who is suspended by the FIM to compete in their series. Plus it would make a mockery of MX Sports own drugs policy and testing regime.
12/16/2014 6:46pm
kiwifan wrote:
In saying that...I still wonder about the IV drip thing...the elephant in the room?
You can't prove it a/k/a it didn't happen.
ando
Posts
4636
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth, AU
12/16/2014 6:53pm
ChrisB10 wrote:
I love James but he's shown some immaturity over the years. I thought he was past that but failing to provide a TUE is just moronic...
I love James but he's shown some immaturity over the years. I thought he was past that but failing to provide a TUE is just moronic. I'm so bummed but don't want to hear sh*t about WADA being too harsh. Rules are rules. Clear as fn day. This all could of been avoided. Let's be adults about this instead of acting like kids by pouting and blaming WADA. One of life's lessons learned the hard way. James, you are not above the rules.
wydopen wrote:
The main thing that drives me nuts about this whole situation is the fact that people are assuming way to much..I'm referring to the internet poster...
The main thing that drives me nuts about this whole situation is the fact that people are assuming way to much..I'm referring to the internet poster as well as the media and people participating in the various discussions on PulpMx over the last several months..

People are going on and on about how its so stupid and confusing how James and "his people" didn't provide a TUE, how he isn't "above the rules" etc etc..Do you people know this as fact?

Isn't it quite possible that they did submit a TUE and filled out all the required paperwork but it was either rejected or there was an error which rendered it invalid? Doesn't that sound a little more likely than his entire camp simply forgot or were too stupid or just didn't feel like filling out the paperwork?

As we have now seen it takes WADA a very long time to render a decision..maybe he had a TUE submitted and it took until right before Seattle for them to reject it...the point is we don't know so stop acting like you do...

That said I hope they just take his points away from last year and let him go for the championship this year..

Both of your hypotheticals would actually paint Stewart in a worse light when it came to the positive result, as they would show definitively that he knew Adderall was banned and had to file a TUE, but continued to use it anyway.

And based on the number of athletes in other sports over the years that have been caught with medications that could have been dealt with via a TUE, I'd say that the forgot/too stupid/too lazy scenarios are absolutely plausible.
nascarnate326
Posts
3008
Joined
11/3/2014
Location
Charlotte, MI, USA
12/16/2014 6:54pm
Wish the FIM would just get this over with. Waste of server space IMO. Let the guy race.
Crush
Posts
21154
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
12/16/2014 7:19pm
TripleFive wrote:
You can't prove it a/k/a it didn't happen.
Allegedly it came from the Nurse to an AMA official in the presence of others...

More than not proving shit tho, it's pretty fucking ridiculous you've got a drug issue going on and that shit happens. There is a saying about smoke and fire.
Dsigner
Posts
1048
Joined
8/31/2006
Location
Eagle, ID, USA
12/16/2014 7:29pm
Let's take a break here....


Crush
Posts
21154
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
12/16/2014 7:32pm
Wow, that gear is fuckin sweet!
DonM
Posts
9082
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
12/16/2014 7:34pm
Wish the FIM would just get this over with. Waste of server space IMO. Let the guy race.
They did...the rules state that they can't say anything...it's in Stewarts hands now...he is the one that will issue a press release...or not...
12/16/2014 7:36pm
Crush wrote:
Wow, that gear is fuckin sweet!
How about those green forks doe?!
12/16/2014 7:42pm
Crush wrote:
Allegedly it came from the Nurse to an AMA official in the presence of others... More than not proving shit tho, it's pretty fucking ridiculous you've...
Allegedly it came from the Nurse to an AMA official in the presence of others...

More than not proving shit tho, it's pretty fucking ridiculous you've got a drug issue going on and that shit happens. There is a saying about smoke and fire.
Bro, the IVs always came after the motos... Whistling Whistling

In all seriousness, James rides a bike like nobody has ever ridden. It's a loss to the sport not having him on the line. While his inconsistency has prevented him from being a championship contender since '09, the dude is magic on a bike.
machine
Posts
6404
Joined
1/5/2011
Location
Collettsville, NC, USA
12/16/2014 7:46pm
TripleFive wrote:
Bro, the IVs always came after the motos... :whistle: :whistle: In all seriousness, James rides a bike like nobody has ever ridden. It's a loss to...
Bro, the IVs always came after the motos... Whistling Whistling

In all seriousness, James rides a bike like nobody has ever ridden. It's a loss to the sport not having him on the line. While his inconsistency has prevented him from being a championship contender since '09, the dude is magic on a bike.
Yeah, magic in a bottle...Grinning
Zracer
Posts
1479
Joined
2/17/2013
Location
Saint Clair, MI, USA
12/16/2014 10:09pm
kongols wrote:
Who want`s to bet me 20 bucks he`ll be on a line at A1? If they are waiting for Stewart to brake the news it`s all...
Who want`s to bet me 20 bucks he`ll be on a line at A1? If they are waiting for Stewart to brake the news it`s all good.
Zracer wrote:
Ill take your 20.
So Kongols , you gonna pay up?
Fraser
Posts
780
Joined
9/12/2008
Location
Leics, GB
12/17/2014 12:09am Edited Date/Time 12/17/2014 12:27am
Robgvx wrote:
So what happened about it being OK to race outdoors because the Nationals weren't an FIM sanctioned event?
ando wrote:
He was only provisionally suspended at the time, pending the outcome of the case. Even though they aren't obliged to do so, I think it would...
He was only provisionally suspended at the time, pending the outcome of the case.

Even though they aren't obliged to do so, I think it would take massive balls for MX Sports to allow a rider who is suspended by the FIM to compete in their series. Plus it would make a mockery of MX Sports own drugs policy and testing regime.
I believe (AMA Pro Racing) MX Sports have to uphold a WADA sanctioned ban. They are affiliated to USADA who are obliged to follow WADA's rulings. The suspension from competition was issued by the FIM which (AMA Pro Racing) MX Sports are not a part of.

edited as Crush below pointed out. I was using MX Sports from the previous poster.
Crush
Posts
21154
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney, AU
12/17/2014 12:14am
Mxsports are the promoter, it goes through WADA->usada and fim-ama(pro racing)

Post a reply to: mxa/ stewart news?

The Latest