RD5

Rj87
Posts
3
Joined
11/25/2012
Location
Hutchinson, MN US
Edited Date/Time 12/3/2012 1:20am
Everyone claims Ryan isn't aggressive enough, isn't at the level that RV, CR and JS are at. What does he need to work on to be at that level? Does he not have the natural talent those other guys have to go to the next level at any given time, or is he just more reserved and consistent?
I am personally an RD fan, but i fail to see why he doesn't get the respect that most do at that level. Any positive or negative feedback would be nice!
|
11/26/2012 2:14pm
Who doesn't give Dung respect? Pretty sure he's had all but RV handled over the last couple season. He doesn't need to change anything he is doing.
Rj87
Posts
3
Joined
11/25/2012
Location
Hutchinson, MN US
11/26/2012 2:18pm
I'd like to agree. It seems as though a lot of people think he hasn't earned his championships saying things like "if so and so were here he would have been screwed." Which may be true, but no one really says those things when everyone gets hurt and RV wins the supercross champ. Maybe he doesn't hang it out like most would, but i think his cornering skills are pretty crazy.
GuppyGahoo
Posts
155
Joined
11/16/2009
Location
Ringle, WI US
11/26/2012 3:41pm
RD5 is to RV2 as CR22 is to JS7.

More skill, smaller stones.

From what I can see at least. Villopoto and Stewart are able to hang it out a little bit more and make it work most of the time. Dungey and Reed are more technical riders but have trouble riding outside of their comfort zone. Yet while riding in their comfort zone they are still able to push Villopoto and Stewart.

For me its added depth to the racing, and creates parity as certain tracks suit each style respectively.
motokiwi
Posts
3039
Joined
4/2/2008
Location
2t4L, AL US
Fantasy
101st
11/26/2012 4:11pm
I believe RD can turn it up another notch at times, however he takes the smart choice of good consistent laps rather than riding the ragged edge and risking everything..
When you look at the odds the RD approach wins most of the time..
IMO people who claim RD is not aggressive enough just don't realize RD is playing the game at a whole nother level. And winning.

The Shop

11/26/2012 4:50pm
When Dungey and James Stewart are going for the same spot on the track and contact will be unavoidable, you can count on Ryan to let off. I don't know if that's by nature or nurture.

"How do I not pass him? How do I catch him and then not pass him?" --Dungey after Washougal moto 1, as documented in Orange Assault, Ep. 5. This makes me think there's less game-playing than motokiwi (above) thinks.

People say he got his "slow n steady" thing from DeCoster, but he's also spent lots of time training with two of the most insanely fast riders ever, Carmichael and Stewart, and he's seen what consistency but not enough speed has gotten Reed. Seemingly his hesitation is just a mental roadblock, i.e. he lacks the "balls" (known in some circles as stupidity) of the more on-edge guys.

If Roger isn't annoyed yet at Dungey's lack of aggression, he eventually will be. He's mentioned before that Ryan needs to get aggressive, but it hasn't really been necessary yet, what with all Dungey's wins and titles. It's not yet adapt or die, but that may be on the approach. Look at Roczen just a few months ago. In another OA episode, Roger said of Ken, "How many times is Baggett gonna ride around him?" "The riders ride different, they're more aggressive than in Europe." Roczen was one of the more consistent guys over 24 motos, but his lack of aggression limited him to, what, one moto win the whole season?

It's kinda hard to fault the guy, as what he's doing has sure been working. But with the same guys who wouldn't budge for Roczen (and Roczen himself) making their way into Dungey's class, will it continue to work? The answer to this question and much more in the next installment of Monster Energy Supercross!!!
wwoberg
Posts
744
Joined
11/19/2010
Location
Soddy Daisy, TN US
11/26/2012 5:19pm
RD just does it differently. I hate all the a$$holes on here who bag any of these pros. Just watching local pros, I can't understand how a motorcycle can be ridden that fast. The guys at RD, RV, CR, etc.....anyone qualifying, level, is absolutely amazing. Those of us who actually ride can appreciate it.

RD just goes about different. Not to use stick and ball sports, but, who would you rather have as a quarterback......Vick or Manning (either one). Brees or Rogers or Brady. They all are great, just different. MX is the same way, different athletes do things differently, but they all are effective. Too bad we are all so hillbilly dumbass throttle heads that we can't recognize the differences.
cheers_22
Posts
342
Joined
2/20/2012
Location
TN US
11/26/2012 5:31pm Edited Date/Time 11/26/2012 5:32pm
Who doesn't give Dung respect? Pretty sure he's had all but RV handled over the last couple season. He doesn't need to change anything he is...
Who doesn't give Dung respect? Pretty sure he's had all but RV handled over the last couple season. He doesn't need to change anything he is doing.
he had nothing for rv2 nor CR22.

he was not on there pace.

Chad beat him straight up in 2011 multiple times outdoors as well.

I like dungey, just i don't think he was.
11/26/2012 5:47pm
cheers_22 wrote:
he had nothing for rv2 nor CR22. he was not on there pace. Chad beat him straight up in 2011 multiple times outdoors as well. I...
he had nothing for rv2 nor CR22.

he was not on there pace.

Chad beat him straight up in 2011 multiple times outdoors as well.

I like dungey, just i don't think he was.
"Not on their pace" is a total misBROmer. He just can't get around.

https://youtu.be/HEvPwWjRyg8
xray52
Posts
31
Joined
10/11/2012
Location
Phoenix, AZ US
11/26/2012 5:55pm
Agree with most of the statements....people like to see the "knockout" blow in boxing, not the "win by decision" for the most part. RV and JS have the knock out speed on most occasions (more so than Dunge although he certainly has it in many cases outdoors) and they both can be aggressive. CR certainly is not afraid to make a pass especially against the one guy most guys won't (JS). With Barcia and next year Tomac, I think Dungey will be forced to be more aggressive just to stay on the podium as much as he wants let alone win. I think we will see that side of him.
11/26/2012 6:17pm Edited Date/Time 11/26/2012 6:32pm
people like to see the "knockout" blow in boxing, not the "win by decision" for the most part.

Perfect.

Oh, and to the OP, people (RD fans) do try (spitefully) to say RV didn't earn his title this year, but the fact is he was crushing foos all year before he got hurt. RV SMASH!

Dungey just shrugs bashfully and says, "Gosh, is everyone hurt again? You guys should really be more careful. Welp, I guess I'll help myself to all these wins you dropped and be on my way! Hum-deedum-deedum."
UpTiTe
Posts
7962
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
CA US
Fantasy
4617th
11/26/2012 6:59pm
Anyone who doesn't think these two aren't evenly matched is an idiot.
UpTiTe
Posts
7962
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
CA US
Fantasy
4617th
11/26/2012 7:03pm
[b]people like to see the "knockout" blow in boxing, not the "win by decision" for the most part.[/b] Perfect. Oh, and to the OP, people (RD...
people like to see the "knockout" blow in boxing, not the "win by decision" for the most part.

Perfect.

Oh, and to the OP, people (RD fans) do try (spitefully) to say RV didn't earn his title this year, but the fact is he was crushing foos all year before he got hurt. RV SMASH!

Dungey just shrugs bashfully and says, "Gosh, is everyone hurt again? You guys should really be more careful. Welp, I guess I'll help myself to all these wins you dropped and be on my way! Hum-deedum-deedum."
He beat him straight up for a supercross title in 2010 and was an empty tank away from beating him straight up for a national title in 2011. Go back to 2011 and see who won more overalls outdoors, you might be suprised.
zook11
Posts
1276
Joined
9/28/2011
Location
Cincinnati, OH US
11/26/2012 7:07pm
[b]people like to see the "knockout" blow in boxing, not the "win by decision" for the most part.[/b] Perfect. Oh, and to the OP, people (RD...
people like to see the "knockout" blow in boxing, not the "win by decision" for the most part.

Perfect.

Oh, and to the OP, people (RD fans) do try (spitefully) to say RV didn't earn his title this year, but the fact is he was crushing foos all year before he got hurt. RV SMASH!

Dungey just shrugs bashfully and says, "Gosh, is everyone hurt again? You guys should really be more careful. Welp, I guess I'll help myself to all these wins you dropped and be on my way! Hum-deedum-deedum."
UpTiTe wrote:
He beat him straight up for a supercross title in 2010 and was an empty tank away from beating him straight up for a national title...
He beat him straight up for a supercross title in 2010 and was an empty tank away from beating him straight up for a national title in 2011. Go back to 2011 and see who won more overalls outdoors, you might be suprised.
Then after that go back and see who had 2x the wins. RV is slightly better than dungey.
fader418
Posts
2832
Joined
9/14/2009
Location
Lake Forest, CA US
11/26/2012 7:11pm
He may not be as fast as JS or RV. But look at those other guys injuries. Then look at RD's injuries. Smartest guy out there IMO...
brimx153
Posts
3345
Joined
5/3/2012
Location
IE
11/26/2012 7:36pm
outdoor s duge is as fast as RV, JS and CR, Cant understand this RV is on a whole other level crap the 4 guy are all level on speed , as someone said look at the 2011 season , dunge should have won it bar bike trouble , i think this season i seen him make a lot more agressive passes aswell ,
11/26/2012 7:41pm Edited Date/Time 11/26/2012 7:42pm
UpTiTe wrote:
He beat him straight up for a supercross title in 2010 and was an empty tank away from beating him straight up for a national title...
He beat him straight up for a supercross title in 2010 and was an empty tank away from beating him straight up for a national title in 2011. Go back to 2011 and see who won more overalls outdoors, you might be suprised.
I would not be surprised. Dungey was riding his very fast Dungey pace all year. But overalls are overalls.



Moto wins after first 12 motos:

Reed: 6
Sick Villopoto: 4
Dunge: 2

Moto wins in motos 13-24:

Villopoto: 6
Dunge: 4 ....."You don't want these, Chad? Well, OK then. If you're sure." Cheerful
Injured/timid Reed: 1
zook11
Posts
1276
Joined
9/28/2011
Location
Cincinnati, OH US
11/26/2012 7:42pm
brimx153 wrote:
outdoor s duge is as fast as RV, JS and CR, Cant understand this RV is on a whole other level crap the 4 guy are...
outdoor s duge is as fast as RV, JS and CR, Cant understand this RV is on a whole other level crap the 4 guy are all level on speed , as someone said look at the 2011 season , dunge should have won it bar bike trouble , i think this season i seen him make a lot more agressive passes aswell ,
He looked the same this year as always, couldn't pass stewart at all and struggled passing alessi abunch. No matter what Dunge is the man
11/26/2012 7:54pm
GuppyGahoo wrote:
RD5 is to RV2 as CR22 is to JS7. More skill, smaller stones. From what I can see at least. Villopoto and Stewart are able to...
RD5 is to RV2 as CR22 is to JS7.

More skill, smaller stones.

From what I can see at least. Villopoto and Stewart are able to hang it out a little bit more and make it work most of the time. Dungey and Reed are more technical riders but have trouble riding outside of their comfort zone. Yet while riding in their comfort zone they are still able to push Villopoto and Stewart.

For me its added depth to the racing, and creates parity as certain tracks suit each style respectively.
awesome. Smile
loftyair
Posts
2804
Joined
7/3/2009
Location
riverside, CA US
11/26/2012 8:58pm
Not aggressive? Might not look like it, just because he doesn't have Barcia's style. If I remember right, he 'straight-up' put an aggressive pass on the almighty RV, causing him to do quite the amateurish-looking over-the-bars auger. I bet lots of these pros can go even faster than JS7, but they wouldn't last long at that speed. So, lesson learned here, going full-throttle ape-shit ain't the way to get it done dumbshits!
11/26/2012 11:37pm
Seems to me the other three guys could learn a thing or two from RD5 about being fast and consistent, seeing as how they keep pushing past their comfort zone and crashing a lot, particularly Stewart. But also both RV and CR have had a lot of serious crashes the last couple of years. RD5 can just do what he's been doing and wait for these guys to crash out and continue to collect his Championship trophies. Isn't he already in the top 5 on the all time wins list after only three or four years? That speaks volumes.
IWreckALot
Posts
8678
Joined
3/12/2011
Location
Fort Worth, TX US
11/27/2012 4:49am
This little debate has me ready for some A1!!! And motivated, you need to post more with that avatar. Didn't even read your post but I like it.

My opinion of Mr. Dungey is that he is an adaptor. He will ride much more aggressively towards the end of the season than he will at the beginning of the season. We just haven't really seen his balls to the wall at the end of a season except 2011 outdoors in which he seemed ready to get aggressive with RV2. He just got the short end of a lapper.
Outsider
Posts
10632
Joined
1/29/2009
Location
Huntington Beach, CA US
11/27/2012 5:29am
Yeah, JS, CR, and RV can all learn from Dungey... those guys have never won anything. Blink

RD is a true champ, but if everyone rides around waiting for the other to crash? Not really a race now is it?
Suns_PSD
Posts
989
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Austin, TX US
11/27/2012 8:58am
The Dunge is so smooth and in control that it makes him look slow when in reality he is hauling some serious ass. He is deadly thru the turns.

I don't count Championships but hasn't he already surpassed RV, CR, & JS in number of Championships won individually? Either way his career is certainly going to be more lengthy than RVs or JSs.
mjskier
Posts
1880
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
CO US
11/27/2012 9:09am
RV2 and JS7 seem to split their time between winning and recovering from injury.
Dungey can have the kind of career length Windham has enjoyed, but with more titles when things work out.
zook11
Posts
1276
Joined
9/28/2011
Location
Cincinnati, OH US
11/27/2012 9:17am
Suns_PSD wrote:
The Dunge is so smooth and in control that it makes him look slow when in reality he is hauling some serious ass. He is deadly...
The Dunge is so smooth and in control that it makes him look slow when in reality he is hauling some serious ass. He is deadly thru the turns.

I don't count Championships but hasn't he already surpassed RV, CR, & JS in number of Championships won individually? Either way his career is certainly going to be more lengthy than RVs or JSs.
RV has 3 big bike titles RD had 3* as well
jeffro503
Posts
27514
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR US
11/27/2012 9:51am
RD....may not ride past his limit to often like RV , and Stewart.........but he finishes more seasons because of it.

Just a different approach at racing.........and for him.....it works.

His championship trophy case at his house agrees with me also.

He doesn't need to change anything.
11/27/2012 10:07am
jeffro503 wrote:
RD....may not ride past his limit to often like RV , and Stewart.........but he finishes more seasons because of it. Just a different approach at racing.........and...
RD....may not ride past his limit to often like RV , and Stewart.........but he finishes more seasons because of it.

Just a different approach at racing.........and for him.....it works.

His championship trophy case at his house agrees with me also.

He doesn't need to change anything.
You mean he hasn't had to change anything yet.

Lotta people seem to feel that Dungey is smarter than Reed. I don't think so. Reed is still the better racer (see my moto wins tally above), and he's learned a lot in a decade in the sport. Remember this Reed quote, from A1 press day this year?

“I think you need to win races. Year after year, other than ‘10, I’ve been here every weekend, being on the podium. And in all the years I’ve been so close but yet so far, I’ve only had a couple of race wins. I think you need to need to be able to have five race wins this year to win.”

Reed saw that his old strategy, the one Dungey now employs, wasn't working for him, and he adapted. That's not dumb, even if it didn't work like he planned.

And yeah, loftyair, RV is faster than JS7, and he does it without wrecking nonstop. A person would really be stretching to say his injuries this year and in '10 were a direct result of him pushing past his comfort zone, in my BROpinion.
11/27/2012 10:21am
jeffro503 wrote:
RD....may not ride past his limit to often like RV , and Stewart.........but he finishes more seasons because of it. Just a different approach at racing.........and...
RD....may not ride past his limit to often like RV , and Stewart.........but he finishes more seasons because of it.

Just a different approach at racing.........and for him.....it works.

His championship trophy case at his house agrees with me also.

He doesn't need to change anything.
You mean he hasn't had to change anything yet. Lotta people seem to feel that Dungey is smarter than Reed. I don't think so. Reed is...
You mean he hasn't had to change anything yet.

Lotta people seem to feel that Dungey is smarter than Reed. I don't think so. Reed is still the better racer (see my moto wins tally above), and he's learned a lot in a decade in the sport. Remember this Reed quote, from A1 press day this year?

“I think you need to win races. Year after year, other than ‘10, I’ve been here every weekend, being on the podium. And in all the years I’ve been so close but yet so far, I’ve only had a couple of race wins. I think you need to need to be able to have five race wins this year to win.”

Reed saw that his old strategy, the one Dungey now employs, wasn't working for him, and he adapted. That's not dumb, even if it didn't work like he planned.

And yeah, loftyair, RV is faster than JS7, and he does it without wrecking nonstop. A person would really be stretching to say his injuries this year and in '10 were a direct result of him pushing past his comfort zone, in my BROpinion.
There is no way raw speed vs. raw speed that RV is as fast as JS. CR outdoors has more raw speed then RV, I don't get where this wonder child thing is about him he is very fast and faster then RD. In most cases but I still think JS is a tick above them all.
11/27/2012 11:40am
There is no way raw speed vs. raw speed that RV is as fast as JS. CR outdoors has more raw speed then RV, I don't...
There is no way raw speed vs. raw speed that RV is as fast as JS. CR outdoors has more raw speed then RV, I don't get where this wonder child thing is about him he is very fast and faster then RD. In most cases but I still think JS is a tick above them all.
I don't know where you get your information, but according to the MX Sports archive:

Fastest-lap honors in the first 8 motos of 2011: Villopoto 5, Dungey 2, Reed 1.

Reed won five of 'em, though, 'cause he's a friggin' bulldog, and not even repeated blows to the head will stop him.

And I think Stewart maybe has a chance at regaining his fastest-man crown, if he's comfy enough, but in case you missed his SX performances over the last 13 months, RV is really fucking fast these days.
Husqerdo
Posts
596
Joined
7/23/2011
Location
Minneapolis, MN US
11/27/2012 1:02pm
You mean he hasn't had to change anything yet. Lotta people seem to feel that Dungey is smarter than Reed. I don't think so. Reed is...
You mean he hasn't had to change anything yet.

Lotta people seem to feel that Dungey is smarter than Reed. I don't think so. Reed is still the better racer (see my moto wins tally above), and he's learned a lot in a decade in the sport. Remember this Reed quote, from A1 press day this year?

“I think you need to win races. Year after year, other than ‘10, I’ve been here every weekend, being on the podium. And in all the years I’ve been so close but yet so far, I’ve only had a couple of race wins. I think you need to need to be able to have five race wins this year to win.”

Reed saw that his old strategy, the one Dungey now employs, wasn't working for him, and he adapted. That's not dumb, even if it didn't work like he planned.

And yeah, loftyair, RV is faster than JS7, and he does it without wrecking nonstop. A person would really be stretching to say his injuries this year and in '10 were a direct result of him pushing past his comfort zone, in my BROpinion.
Once again claiming to know what others think, and not having a clue. I have never heard anyone claim "Dungey is smarter than Reed", The reality is "Lotta people know Dungey is smarter than RV" as exhibited by RV's brain fart crashes that have removed him from 3 of 4 possible 450MX series. ( Should probably mention RV did make the first 2 races 2009MX then out) .

Post a reply to: RD5

The Latest