2027 MX - No More Grates?

SEEMEFIRST
Posts
14114
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX, USA
1 day ago
ando wrote:

Is there actual evidence that grates are contributing to first turn crashes?

mx_563 wrote:

Is there actual evidence that the introduction of starting grates in motocross has yielded any benefit to the racing, or the sport in general? 

ando wrote:
Someone obviously thought there was a benefit to it.  If I had to guess (and I really don’t have any clue) I’d say the biggest beneficiaries...

Someone obviously thought there was a benefit to it.  If I had to guess (and I really don’t have any clue) I’d say the biggest beneficiaries are the track owners who have been able to do away with a lot of upkeep on the start area.

My question still stands - many people are hypothesising that grates = more first turn crashes but I haven’t seen any data.

We never had grates, but I wonder how you clean out build up.

You'd have to lift each one individually and scrape under it.

I think I'll take a couple of passes with the skid steer any day.

yzr250r
Posts
42
Joined
8/16/2020
Location
Douglas, WY, USA
1 day ago

They are called dirt bikes because we ride them on the dirt. The tires are designed for dirt. Most riders only have access to dirt to practice starts as not everyone has the money or place to put concrete or metal start grates. This is the equivalent of Moto GP bikes having to start on dirt when they are clearly designed for pavement.

11
Radical
Posts
2922
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
1 day ago Edited Date/Time 1 day ago
-MAVERICK- wrote:
From Chase Curtis at Swap Moto:[quote]It sounds like there are some talks about changing the starting rules and procedures for the 2027 Pro Motocross Championship... No...

From Chase Curtis at Swap Moto:

It sounds like there are some talks about changing the starting rules and procedures for the 2027 Pro Motocross Championship... No more grates?
Rapo-X wrote:

And ban the start devices while you're at it ...

10000hrs wrote:

And ban the foot stools too (if thats what they are called?)

They should be allowed for shorter riders with some rules.

No spikes or anything that ties them to the ground or start grates.  They should only be a few inches tall, maybe determined by rider height or inseam.  Their only purpose should be for shorter riders to be able to sit stabely on the bike.

It seems that the way they are now, they attach firmly to the grate, with grip on the top as well, allowing riders to "push off" for added advantage.

4
3
1 day ago
huck wrote:

Cut the field to 20 and give each person a double wide gate....

 

SMX had 10 riders on each gate starting in opposite directions...

image 3691
1

The Shop

mb60
Posts
5680
Joined
3/7/2010
Location
GRAPEVINE, TX, USA
1 day ago

How about making the starts straight as well. The inside gates should not be directed to right at any track. 

1
2
Gravel
Posts
1913
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA, USA
21 hours ago
Rapo-X wrote:

And ban the start devices while you're at it ...

10000hrs wrote:

And ban the foot stools too (if thats what they are called?)

Radical wrote:
They should be allowed for shorter riders with some rules.No spikes or anything that ties them to the ground or start grates.  They should only be...

They should be allowed for shorter riders with some rules.

No spikes or anything that ties them to the ground or start grates.  They should only be a few inches tall, maybe determined by rider height or inseam.  Their only purpose should be for shorter riders to be able to sit stabely on the bike.

It seems that the way they are now, they attach firmly to the grate, with grip on the top as well, allowing riders to "push off" for added advantage.

Well said.

But if they’re not anchored down, and not very long, they can be whatever height and still have no push-off advantage, they’ll just flop over. Maybe an 8x8” base with a smooth bottom? 

Not that the AMA would ever do anything..

2
PRM31
Posts
3774
Joined
8/7/2009
Location
Northern, VA, USA
Fantasy
18 hours ago

I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your bike, and in front of rear tire. 

1
1
Gravel
Posts
1913
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA, USA
18 hours ago
PRM31 wrote:
I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your...

I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your bike, and in front of rear tire. 

If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?

I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a problem reaching the ground. I’m pretty sure they do that for some reason..

1
1
avidchimp
Posts
5838
Joined
7/9/2008
Location
EGL, MN, USA
18 hours ago
PRM31 wrote:
I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your...

I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your bike, and in front of rear tire. 

Gravel wrote:
If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a...

If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?

I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a problem reaching the ground. I’m pretty sure they do that for some reason..

The amount of pushing off is negligible, it's more about getting your feet on the pegs as soon as possible after the gate starts dropping. Some of those blocks are so tall their feet are practically already on the pegs.

4
18 hours ago

start blocks are ridiculous. So someone is too short to effectively start? Someone taller is better? Well, isn't that what professional sports is about - everyone has an even playing field and may the best win. And those with more/better attributes for the sport will generally excel.

2
2
Renner153
Posts
1655
Joined
12/10/2008
Location
Mulberry, FL, USA
18 hours ago
PRM31 wrote:
I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your...

I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your bike, and in front of rear tire. 

Gravel wrote:
If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a...

If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?

I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a problem reaching the ground. I’m pretty sure they do that for some reason..

They arent pushing off of them. The bike is moving too fast for them to be of any value for pushing off of. They anchor them down so they do move when they do take off. The tall ones are so you dont have to move your feet to the pegs as much.

Gravel
Posts
1913
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA, USA
18 hours ago
PRM31 wrote:
I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your...

I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your bike, and in front of rear tire. 

Gravel wrote:
If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a...

If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?

I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a problem reaching the ground. I’m pretty sure they do that for some reason..

Renner153 wrote:
They arent pushing off of them. The bike is moving too fast for them to be of any value for pushing off of. They anchor them...

They arent pushing off of them. The bike is moving too fast for them to be of any value for pushing off of. They anchor them down so they do move when they do take off. The tall ones are so you dont have to move your feet to the pegs as much.


Yup, you guys are right. No push, but feet on the pegs before the gate drops in some cases.

Now I want to try this! 

IMG 1141 7
1
1
Timo
Posts
1482
Joined
1/9/2021
Location
Wichita, KS, USA
17 hours ago

Dead engine starts at select rounds just to switch it up a bit.

1
2
holeshot413
Posts
689
Joined
2/24/2008
Location
Prosperity, SC, USA
17 hours ago

Make dirt starts great again! Indoors and out! We shouldn’t be doing what the lousy FIM is doing. Starts, sound or fuel.

Radical
Posts
2922
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
16 hours ago
PRM31 wrote:
I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your...

I don’t think you can push off them whether tied down or not. Having them tied down just keeps you from accidentally kicking it under your bike, and in front of rear tire. 

Gravel wrote:
If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a...

If they’re anchored to the ground, why couldn’t they be pushed off?

I’ve seen photos of wildly tall starting blocks, used by riders who don’t have a problem reaching the ground. I’m pretty sure they do that for some reason..

avidchimp wrote:
The amount of pushing off is negligible, it's more about getting your feet on the pegs as soon as possible after the gate starts dropping. Some...

The amount of pushing off is negligible, it's more about getting your feet on the pegs as soon as possible after the gate starts dropping. Some of those blocks are so tall their feet are practically already on the pegs.

Getting traction and reducing spinning is probably the most important for the first 2 feet of a start, when starting from no forward momentum.

A small push off is an advantage.

1
Mavetism
Posts
6590
Joined
4/15/2019
Location
Hannover, DE
16 hours ago
yzr250r wrote:
They are called dirt bikes because we ride them on the dirt. The tires are designed for dirt. Most riders only have access to dirt to...

They are called dirt bikes because we ride them on the dirt. The tires are designed for dirt. Most riders only have access to dirt to practice starts as not everyone has the money or place to put concrete or metal start grates. This is the equivalent of Moto GP bikes having to start on dirt when they are clearly designed for pavement.

Well said

whethefakawe
Posts
235
Joined
10/14/2021
Location
Scottsdale, AZ, USA
16 hours ago

"Start blocks".... just more pu**y gimmicks that turn MX into lawn bowls for the young. 

If you can't reach the ground on a 250 or 450, go ride the PW50 class ya poof! . 

Metal grates, start devices, traction control , lean angle sensors, ABS,....now the iPhone generation mouthbreathers want radio comms between riders and pits so they have more bitch gossip to argue about.....

I'm hearing motos will be 12 minutes long next season.   

1
Gravel
Posts
1913
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA, USA
13 hours ago
Timo wrote:

Dead engine starts at select rounds just to switch it up a bit.

Left hand on the helmet too! And maybe my old favorite, straddle the front wheel and the start flag behind the starting line! 

10 hours ago
Timo wrote:

Dead engine starts at select rounds just to switch it up a bit.

Are you a Kenny hater?

Talon
Posts
857
Joined
1/18/2022
Location
Beaver, UT, USA
Fantasy
10 hours ago

Motocross should always start on dirt

Yep. Make qualifying times have even more meaning. Not only do you want the best line in front of the gate but then you need the best start rut behind the gate too. 

1
Kawboy14!
Posts
507
Joined
5/15/2021
Location
Georgetown, TX, USA
7 hours ago

YES…..please!

Kawboy14!
Posts
507
Joined
5/15/2021
Location
Georgetown, TX, USA
7 hours ago

And or no start devices

Gravel
Posts
1913
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA, USA
7 hours ago
Timo wrote:

Dead engine starts at select rounds just to switch it up a bit.

Are you a Kenny hater?

I got better jumps on the start on a kickstart YZ250 than I did on a e-start KTM. 

Kenny might have a big advantage!

1
Not hillbilly
Posts
1305
Joined
6/8/2024
Location
Gaithersburg, MD, USA
6 hours ago

Motocross should always start on dirt

Talon wrote:
Yep. Make qualifying times have even more meaning. Not only do you want the best line in front of the gate but then you need the...

Yep. Make qualifying times have even more meaning. Not only do you want the best line in front of the gate but then you need the best start rut behind the gate too. 

You wanna make qualifying times more meaningful? Start on a staggered grid like MotoGP.

Jkawi
Posts
607
Joined
3/5/2015
Location
CA
6 hours ago

If Carmichael figured out the start without start blocks, then any dwarf can.

2

Post a reply to: 2027 MX - No More Grates?

The Latest