James Stewart Interview

FreshTopEnd
Posts
13260
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
1/12/2011 10:05am
05 was Stewart's first year in the big bike class (on a 250).

Guys get bumped on the start all the time. Every one of the guys running at the front is probably going to have an issue with at some point this year.
GrapeApe
Posts
8877
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
1/12/2011 10:07am
Racer111 wrote:
Stewart is leaning left to counteract the impact from Dungey going to his right and hitting him smart guy! If he would have gone with the...
Stewart is leaning left to counteract the impact from Dungey going to his right and hitting him smart guy! If he would have gone with the momentum of Dungey hitting him he would have gone straight to the ground.

Obviously you have never been tagged in the front wheel off a start.
When you get hit in the front wheel, you fall into the contact. Go take out someone's front wheel and see if they fall away from you or over your back fender.
raddad
Posts
2286
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Wrenshall, MN, USA
1/12/2011 11:20am
Nerd, i am ashamed of you. How can you make such a statement without looking at the actual race footage? If you slow it down you can see that it was in fact Bubba that gets slightly out of shape and veers towards Millsaps tapping him or coming very close to it, he then tries to correct his error and goes right into Dungey who is already half a bike length ahead of Bubba. It happens all the time and for you to insinuate that it was some how RD's fault is poor journalism.. tsk tsk.

Still pictures never ever tell the story, only a part of it. I bet if you would have asked bubba what happened he would have told you the truth, it was him that got out of shape and caused his own misfortune. Next time before you print such nonsense, research it first and now that you are proven wrong what do you have to say?
Nerd
Posts
6155
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/12/2011 11:32am
raddad wrote:
Nerd, i am ashamed of you. How can you make such a statement without looking at the actual race footage? If you slow it down you...
Nerd, i am ashamed of you. How can you make such a statement without looking at the actual race footage? If you slow it down you can see that it was in fact Bubba that gets slightly out of shape and veers towards Millsaps tapping him or coming very close to it, he then tries to correct his error and goes right into Dungey who is already half a bike length ahead of Bubba. It happens all the time and for you to insinuate that it was some how RD's fault is poor journalism.. tsk tsk.

Still pictures never ever tell the story, only a part of it. I bet if you would have asked bubba what happened he would have told you the truth, it was him that got out of shape and caused his own misfortune. Next time before you print such nonsense, research it first and now that you are proven wrong what do you have to say?
I have a sequence of it. It's not a big deal. If I were Dungey, I'd have done the same thing. Dungey got a jump on James and moved over on him. Look at how close Dungey is to Millsaps and how far he is from Windham.

The starting order, from the box to the inside, was Brayton, Reed, Windham, Dungey, Stewart, Millsaps, Short, Regal, Chisholm, Thomas.

Again, look at how close Dungey is to Millsaps, and how close Millsaps is to Short, etc. Then look how far Windham is from Dungey. Dungey got the jump on James and then turned left. This isn't a character judgment. It's totally fair game. If Dungey wouldn't have gotten the jump, he couldn't have done it, and if the roles were reversed, Dungey likely would've gotten pinched off just the same.

I don't know why you guys are arguing, except that I think maybe you guys think I'm trying to make Dungey out to be a bad guy or Stewart a good guy, but the truth is that Dungey turned left to shut Stewart down. That's just true. It's not dirty or bad, just true.

The Shop

mxgeoff
Posts
1261
Joined
5/26/2008
Location
vegas, SH
1/12/2011 11:38am
raddad wrote:
Nerd, i am ashamed of you. How can you make such a statement without looking at the actual race footage? If you slow it down you...
Nerd, i am ashamed of you. How can you make such a statement without looking at the actual race footage? If you slow it down you can see that it was in fact Bubba that gets slightly out of shape and veers towards Millsaps tapping him or coming very close to it, he then tries to correct his error and goes right into Dungey who is already half a bike length ahead of Bubba. It happens all the time and for you to insinuate that it was some how RD's fault is poor journalism.. tsk tsk.

Still pictures never ever tell the story, only a part of it. I bet if you would have asked bubba what happened he would have told you the truth, it was him that got out of shape and caused his own misfortune. Next time before you print such nonsense, research it first and now that you are proven wrong what do you have to say?
Nerd wrote:
I have a sequence of it. It's not a big deal. If I were Dungey, I'd have done the same thing. Dungey got a jump on...
I have a sequence of it. It's not a big deal. If I were Dungey, I'd have done the same thing. Dungey got a jump on James and moved over on him. Look at how close Dungey is to Millsaps and how far he is from Windham.

The starting order, from the box to the inside, was Brayton, Reed, Windham, Dungey, Stewart, Millsaps, Short, Regal, Chisholm, Thomas.

Again, look at how close Dungey is to Millsaps, and how close Millsaps is to Short, etc. Then look how far Windham is from Dungey. Dungey got the jump on James and then turned left. This isn't a character judgment. It's totally fair game. If Dungey wouldn't have gotten the jump, he couldn't have done it, and if the roles were reversed, Dungey likely would've gotten pinched off just the same.

I don't know why you guys are arguing, except that I think maybe you guys think I'm trying to make Dungey out to be a bad guy or Stewart a good guy, but the truth is that Dungey turned left to shut Stewart down. That's just true. It's not dirty or bad, just true.
If Dungey did do that I have more respect for him now than ever. Move over son this is my championship and you are old news might just be the thought of mind. AWESOME!!!!!
LastCall211
Posts
419
Joined
8/1/2008
Location
Whitehaven, MD, USA
1/12/2011 1:42pm
Watch the race again. Dungey completely came over on Stewart. That being said, that's racing. I've seen Stewart do it many times. RC too. Same with Reed.

I swear I bet guys like Hannah and RJ sit back and watch these races and laugh about how worked up people get over contact on the racetrack. I love the bar bangin, as long as guys aren't intentionally putting each other on the ground.
raddad
Posts
2286
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Wrenshall, MN, USA
1/12/2011 2:02pm
Watch the race again. Dungey completely came over on Stewart. That being said, that's racing. I've seen Stewart do it many times. RC too. Same with...
Watch the race again. Dungey completely came over on Stewart. That being said, that's racing. I've seen Stewart do it many times. RC too. Same with Reed.

I swear I bet guys like Hannah and RJ sit back and watch these races and laugh about how worked up people get over contact on the racetrack. I love the bar bangin, as long as guys aren't intentionally putting each other on the ground.
slow it down then tell me that bubba didn't get into 18 first then came into dungey. Dungey was ahead of stew when he started to move left..

Look at the whole thing not just the end..It was no big deal but to say in any way shape or form that RD caused bubba to mess up the start i just cannot see. remember to start at the beginning and then s-l-o-w it downSmile
mxgeoff
Posts
1261
Joined
5/26/2008
Location
vegas, SH
1/12/2011 2:07pm
Watch the race again. Dungey completely came over on Stewart. That being said, that's racing. I've seen Stewart do it many times. RC too. Same with...
Watch the race again. Dungey completely came over on Stewart. That being said, that's racing. I've seen Stewart do it many times. RC too. Same with Reed.

I swear I bet guys like Hannah and RJ sit back and watch these races and laugh about how worked up people get over contact on the racetrack. I love the bar bangin, as long as guys aren't intentionally putting each other on the ground.
raddad wrote:
slow it down then tell me that bubba didn't get into 18 first then came into dungey. Dungey was ahead of stew when he started to...
slow it down then tell me that bubba didn't get into 18 first then came into dungey. Dungey was ahead of stew when he started to move left..

Look at the whole thing not just the end..It was no big deal but to say in any way shape or form that RD caused bubba to mess up the start i just cannot see. remember to start at the beginning and then s-l-o-w it downSmile
and if he did cause Stewart to get into that problem then well done.
dirthead1
Posts
1440
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Southern, CA, USA
1/12/2011 2:13pm
That's racing folks!
MXR
Posts
3780
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
City, WA, USA
1/12/2011 2:15pm
bullpen58 wrote:
No matter who hit who, the fact is, JS got a shitty jump outta the gate and put himself in the position to get squeezed out.
^ DING ! DING ! DING ^ We have a winner folks .
mccread
Posts
5934
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/12/2011 2:16pm
The ability to get good starts and move through traffic could be key to this championship.

Stewart will pass you in a revolving door he is the best I have ever seen at passing people, RV will put you down if he needs too. Dungey and Reed are maybe a little to nice so it takes them longer to get through the pack.

Dungey doing that to Stewart is cool - its shows he is not going to get pushed around this year and that could be key in the series.
LastCall211
Posts
419
Joined
8/1/2008
Location
Whitehaven, MD, USA
1/12/2011 2:22pm Edited Date/Time 1/12/2011 2:24pm
Watch the race again. Dungey completely came over on Stewart. That being said, that's racing. I've seen Stewart do it many times. RC too. Same with...
Watch the race again. Dungey completely came over on Stewart. That being said, that's racing. I've seen Stewart do it many times. RC too. Same with Reed.

I swear I bet guys like Hannah and RJ sit back and watch these races and laugh about how worked up people get over contact on the racetrack. I love the bar bangin, as long as guys aren't intentionally putting each other on the ground.
raddad wrote:
slow it down then tell me that bubba didn't get into 18 first then came into dungey. Dungey was ahead of stew when he started to...
slow it down then tell me that bubba didn't get into 18 first then came into dungey. Dungey was ahead of stew when he started to move left..

Look at the whole thing not just the end..It was no big deal but to say in any way shape or form that RD caused bubba to mess up the start i just cannot see. remember to start at the beginning and then s-l-o-w it downSmile
mxgeoff wrote:
and if he did cause Stewart to get into that problem then well done.
It does look like Stewart and Millsaps got together a bit. Even if Dungey had caused it, I didn't have any issues with anything that happened. But let's also not try to act like Dungey just eased over on him. He gated and immediately cut over to take away Stewart's line. It's fine. It made for a much better main event to see Stewart come through the pack.
ayearinmx
Posts
2760
Joined
3/5/2007
Location
GB
1/12/2011 2:26pm
yea.... moving over on the start straight is fine*



*unless you are antonio cairoli
mxgeoff
Posts
1261
Joined
5/26/2008
Location
vegas, SH
1/12/2011 2:38pm
ayearinmx wrote:
yea.... moving over on the start straight is fine*



*unless you are antonio cairoli
Moving over on the start line would be like winning a cricket match on the last ball, it's nearly cheating.
raddad
Posts
2286
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Wrenshall, MN, USA
1/12/2011 2:39pm
ayearinmx wrote:
yea.... moving over on the start straight is fine*



*unless you are antonio cairoli
Depends if you have a wheel on the guy you move over on or if you are side by side!Smile That's how it works in my world and most of us racers see it that way i think. If you are ahead its yours baby!Wink
ayearinmx
Posts
2760
Joined
3/5/2007
Location
GB
1/12/2011 2:42pm
mxgeoff wrote:
Moving over on the start line would be like winning a cricket match on the last ball, it's nearly cheating.
we know your country is suffering down there a bit, what with the Ashes and floods, so we felt sorry for you and made it interesting...... obviously we still had to beat you (losing would be stupid and we had a world-record to create).... we just had to make it look like you guys were actually still good at the game Wink
nmanley
Posts
76
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/12/2011 8:00pm
Doesn't matter who did what on the start. If Bubba stays cool all year like he did at this race he will win the 2011 SX Championship. Mark it on your Calender. I'm sayin it!!!!
PC
Posts
474
Joined
8/24/2009
Location
USA
1/13/2011 10:53am
I re-watched the race last night and I could clearly see James lose traction on the start and get out of shape. Dungey may have moved over, but James opened the door for him plain and simple.

I'm a JS fan, so no bias here. He straight up botched the start.
Good thing too, cause the passing clinic he put on was epic. So much aggression, yet such control. I think he's gonna slay the field next weekend.
Jefro98
Posts
2470
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
6712, NL
1/13/2011 11:19pm
ayearinmx wrote:
yea.... moving over on the start straight is fine*



*unless you are antonio cairoli
I was thinking the same thing when I started reading this thread.
FreshTopEnd
Posts
13260
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
1/13/2011 11:38pm
Well, they're all aiming for a patch of dirt in the first turn that's a lot narrower than the gate, so, yup, there's going to be some moving over. I didn't really get the sense that Stewart was complaining about it.
AusMxFan
Posts
74
Joined
1/17/2009
Location
Melbourne, AU
1/14/2011 12:41am
Over analysing 2-3 seconds of mayhem is ridiculous.

Twenty 450's in a flat out drag race one stretch track isn't always going to be pretty.
devonb
Posts
177
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
1/14/2011 7:33am Edited Date/Time 1/14/2011 7:38am
Jesus guys. James got a bad start and came through the pack like only James could. RV got a great start and backed it up by riding great like RV always has. Personally I think of the "Big Four" Dungey did the worst. Add in the "Big Five" and he still was the least impressive. For those of us who have actually raced know it only takes a mistake that costs you 6" down the start straight to put you 60' behind after the first turn. It's going to happen to all of them this year. Dungey's biggest advantage is he seems to always get a good start.
151
Posts
536
Joined
9/15/2009
Location
Olive Branch, MS, USA
1/14/2011 7:47am
Man I hope that is really a new James we are listening to. It boggles my mind to think what he can do with a little...
Man I hope that is really a new James we are listening to. It boggles my mind to think what he can do with a little patience.
ocscottie wrote:
You know the young James of just a few short years ago would of gone completely balls to the wall to try and catch the two...
You know the young James of just a few short years ago would of gone completely balls to the wall to try and catch the two Ryans and win the race at all costs. I do believe we are seeing an older, wiser man who is more focused on the big picture, rather than the younger kid who just had to win every race he entered.

At least thats how i see it.
I understand everyone has opinions and different things they like about racing.

But why the hell anyone would do anything other than try to win a race I will never understand.

Championships do nothing for racing. Anything that provides motivation for doing less than your best in a race is a deterent to good racing.

Obviously a series championship can show who had the focus long term who had the fitness long term and so on, but it still has the opportunity to take a little away from each and every single RACE of the year.

I agree 100% JS looked wiser, in that he likely made choices motivated by long term goals. But a race isnt a long term event. Its a race and the winner is the guy in first at the end we all know that.

What I can't figure out is why fans would WANT to see any racer hold back during a race.

Series championships are for sponsors and promoters don't be fooled otherwise, and they know that by offering the riders the big prize at the end that the riders will (they hope) make a championship their goal.

And guess who loses out, everyone not monitarily connected to the race.
mxgeoff
Posts
1261
Joined
5/26/2008
Location
vegas, SH
1/14/2011 8:04am
Man I hope that is really a new James we are listening to. It boggles my mind to think what he can do with a little...
Man I hope that is really a new James we are listening to. It boggles my mind to think what he can do with a little patience.
ocscottie wrote:
You know the young James of just a few short years ago would of gone completely balls to the wall to try and catch the two...
You know the young James of just a few short years ago would of gone completely balls to the wall to try and catch the two Ryans and win the race at all costs. I do believe we are seeing an older, wiser man who is more focused on the big picture, rather than the younger kid who just had to win every race he entered.

At least thats how i see it.
151 wrote:
I understand everyone has opinions and different things they like about racing. But why the hell anyone would do anything other than try to win a...
I understand everyone has opinions and different things they like about racing.

But why the hell anyone would do anything other than try to win a race I will never understand.

Championships do nothing for racing. Anything that provides motivation for doing less than your best in a race is a deterent to good racing.

Obviously a series championship can show who had the focus long term who had the fitness long term and so on, but it still has the opportunity to take a little away from each and every single RACE of the year.

I agree 100% JS looked wiser, in that he likely made choices motivated by long term goals. But a race isnt a long term event. Its a race and the winner is the guy in first at the end we all know that.

What I can't figure out is why fans would WANT to see any racer hold back during a race.

Series championships are for sponsors and promoters don't be fooled otherwise, and they know that by offering the riders the big prize at the end that the riders will (they hope) make a championship their goal.

And guess who loses out, everyone not monitarily connected to the race.
The big prize is the Championship. Sure everyone wants to be number one, not just in racing, but in life in general, we all want to be respected and taken seriously.

Stewart has crashed as much as he has won, the fastest man on the planet has lost more championships because of his wild style than probably anyone else in recent time. I think half the MX fans don't really take him seriously because of that (remember his trips to Europe have brought him ZERO in victories, two MXoN, a Bercy SX and that 80cc race in 2001 or whatever it was). We can all laugh at him when he crashes, but holding back and going for solid points, now that is something to respect.

Slowing down for a Championship seems like a good idea to me. And yes seeing him start from the front and totally dominate will also be enjoyable, because at the end of the day he is still the fastest man on the planet!!
151
Posts
536
Joined
9/15/2009
Location
Olive Branch, MS, USA
1/14/2011 10:06am Edited Date/Time 1/14/2011 10:09am
mxgeoff wrote:
The big prize is the Championship. Sure everyone wants to be number one, not just in racing, but in life in general, we all want to...
The big prize is the Championship. Sure everyone wants to be number one, not just in racing, but in life in general, we all want to be respected and taken seriously.

Stewart has crashed as much as he has won, the fastest man on the planet has lost more championships because of his wild style than probably anyone else in recent time. I think half the MX fans don't really take him seriously because of that (remember his trips to Europe have brought him ZERO in victories, two MXoN, a Bercy SX and that 80cc race in 2001 or whatever it was). We can all laugh at him when he crashes, but holding back and going for solid points, now that is something to respect.

Slowing down for a Championship seems like a good idea to me. And yes seeing him start from the front and totally dominate will also be enjoyable, because at the end of the day he is still the fastest man on the planet!!
That is where I tend to disagree with most everyone else. I lose respect for a rider or anyone for that matter that does less than their best, in order to achieve a championship.

A championship is nothing but a series of races tied together. What exactly is the point of doing that? Why award points to races and determine a winner at the end of a series.

The winner is the guy who wins the race.

It is truly not a big deal because the best/fastest guy usually comes out on top anyhow. But just the possibility for a second place rider to win what many view as the "big prize" bugs me to death.

There is no argueing that in order to have the best possible racing each weekend, the best racers should be trying to win.

For example the last race of the year and the "points leader" needs to finish tenth or better to lock in the "championship" that guy is going to play it safe and is very unlikely to even try to win the race.

In my opinion, and I am aware it aint worth shit, that sucks. A system where a rider enters a race with no intention of racing to win, LAME.

Post a reply to: James Stewart Interview

The Latest