Will the USA balkanize?

10/12/2025 3:48pm
lumpy790 wrote:

I have been in the MC industry for 45 years and roughly 98% of motorcycle industry are right leaning.  Most of the left leaning are silent.

Oh how things have changed, just look at this forum.

1
10
TAUTOG
Posts
1846
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
10/12/2025 3:55pm
lumpy790 wrote:

I have been in the MC industry for 45 years and roughly 98% of motorcycle industry are right leaning.  Most of the left leaning are silent.

Oh how things have changed, just look at this forum.

bro you are delusional

thats like saying fisherman are left leaning 

4
1
10/12/2025 3:58pm
Flatliner wrote:
This thread proves the point about dialogue.  I gave a brief explanation on the lack of ID's , face coverings, got nobody who wanted to discuss...

This thread proves the point about dialogue.  I gave a brief explanation on the lack of ID's , face coverings, got nobody who wanted to discuss it,  yet there's two dislikes.

I didn’t downvote it because I generally don’t have an issue with what ICE is doing. That said, “it’s just how these operations are done” isn’t...

I didn’t downvote it because I generally don’t have an issue with what ICE is doing. That said, “it’s just how these operations are done” isn’t a strong argument in favor of it. That’s not to say there’s any merit to the argument against it. 

Flatliner wrote:
I suppose more context was needed.  I'm sure as most know, one of the main reasons its done are officer safety.   If tomorrow a law...

I suppose more context was needed.  I'm sure as most know, one of the main reasons its done are officer safety.   If tomorrow a law came in saying tactical gear was done, and all operations will be completed with full ID given, faces on display, you'd have no swat, emergency response, tac teams exc.  Nearly all members would leave.   It's simply a case of officer safety, and their families not being targeted.

Yeah for anyone thinking there's a civil way to show up in a marked car and uniform, and hop out and introduce yourself with your badge without putting yourself in danger, then I suggest you go for a ride-along with a squad car in the city to see what law enforcement has to deal with.  This would be a really good way to let the criminals get a head start on foot and let their homeys get in place to throw rocks at your dome, or worse.  

Reality vs Fantasy World 

2
8
10/12/2025 4:01pm
lumpy790 wrote:

I have been in the MC industry for 45 years and roughly 98% of motorcycle industry are right leaning.  Most of the left leaning are silent.

Oh how things have changed, just look at this forum.

TAUTOG wrote:

bro you are delusional

thats like saying fisherman are left leaning 

I lean left all the time when I have a big tuna hooked, you can't help it, those boys fight you hard.

Kidding aside, I've seen this place completely flip flop in the last 10 years.  You haven't been around long enough to witness it.  You are a perfect example.

2
11

The Shop

10/12/2025 6:39pm
Flatliner wrote:
This thread proves the point about dialogue.  I gave a brief explanation on the lack of ID's , face coverings, got nobody who wanted to discuss...

This thread proves the point about dialogue.  I gave a brief explanation on the lack of ID's , face coverings, got nobody who wanted to discuss it,  yet there's two dislikes.

I'll bite. Law enforcement is not going to run in announcing their names and home addresses. As for the masks, there are plenty of people willing to spend hours, if not days or weeks searching images and connecting data points to Dox ICE agents and other law enforcement. Then they get harassed and threatened at home, their wives/husbands/sons/daughters/extended families get the same. Until unhinged people don't have the ability to find peoples personal information, masks it is. 

5
2
10/12/2025 6:44pm
Dudley wrote:
Following are differences I see between MAGA and Republicans (my definition of republicans is 2008 Bush era, just as reference);Securing borders - no differences.Restoring Law and...

Following are differences I see between MAGA and Republicans (my definition of republicans is 2008 Bush era, just as reference);

Securing borders - no differences.


Restoring Law and Order - MAGA believes in federal tax dollars being spent on policing. They also believe in federalizing the national guard. Republicans historically see this as a state issue and would not bring in national guard without a governors approval. My view, best way to fight crime is at local level. If you voted to defund the police, then you need to correct that in your local elections.


Deporting illegals who are flooding our systems and costing billions in tax dollars - MAGA is willing to deport people without due process. Republicans would not. My view, the asylum law needs a closer look. People here illegally need to be removed but we also need temporary workers and H1-B’s cause we don’t have the workforce. Immigration is good overall.


Strengthen military and national security - MAGA believes in isolating USA from its allies. An example is economic policies implemented on India forcing them to partner with China. Huge loss in my opinion. Republicans agree with military spending and strengthening NATO and allies. My personal view is we need to police less in the world and also reduce spending so I’m mixed in views. 



Draining the swamp and getting rid of corruption (DOGE) - MAGA believes this is an executive branch authority. Republicans believe this is a legislative branch decision with executive approval, I’m 100% we need to make tough decisions to reduce budget, but I believe congress needs to do this otherwise I lose my voice in the matter. 


American Energy Independence - no differences. I was upset when Biden opted to bolster OPEC than pursue more independence. 
 
Traditional family values - no differences. My libertarian side would like to see separation of church and state, however.

America first with funding and trade policy - MAGA believe in tariffs, Republicans believe in free trade and free markets. By far this is my biggest separation with MAGA. I am not a fan of tariffs and I am upset this revenue is not being disclosed or used to reduce deficit spending. 

Good discussions, I’m glad you asked. 
 

Republicans and their free trade/free markets. They loved NAFTA, didn't they? Worst deal ever made. Was good for Mexico though. 

2
3
TAUTOG
Posts
1846
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
10/12/2025 7:04pm

Oh how things have changed, just look at this forum.

TAUTOG wrote:

bro you are delusional

thats like saying fisherman are left leaning 

I lean left all the time when I have a big tuna hooked, you can't help it, those boys fight you hard.Kidding aside, I've seen this...

I lean left all the time when I have a big tuna hooked, you can't help it, those boys fight you hard.

Kidding aside, I've seen this place completely flip flop in the last 10 years.  You haven't been around long enough to witness it.  You are a perfect example.

lol

How is it more left now with ML in charge rather than GuyB? Riddle me that? And how long has politics been permitted here? How does the politics from 10 years ago mean anything if there were no politics here?

ML is doing an amazing job. 

Relax man. I'd say switch to decaf but I think you're beyond that

 

4
3
LoudLove
Posts
3024
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
USA
10/13/2025 4:51am

Manny and others were suspending because nearly every response became a personal attack.  It is possible to state an opinion w/o resorting to insults, even if a person completely disagrees with the other’s perspective. 

10
1
plowboy
Posts
14859
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
10/13/2025 5:13am

I see a lot of the problem with the world today is that when some folks hear "right and wrong"...they believe "right" is what's right for THEM.  

As far as this board, I asked someone that was really being a turd if they actually believed what they were saying. They answered, "no" but just enjoyed the chaos it caused.  That just blows my mind.

6
1
Zycki11
Posts
7967
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL, USA
10/13/2025 7:05am

Honestly it feels like everyone gets so caught up in the nuances of nothing and forget the bigger picture at hand. Just stay calm and watch what happens. Democrats will get slaughtered come midterms and can’t see it coming. Then the real work will begin. Get this country back on track to having morals, work ethic, raising well mannered respectful children, faith. 
 


Until the Democratic Party comes back to reality it will continue to struggle. Look across the polls(even though I don’t believe in them) CNN even shows dems underwater in every single category, and dropping. Makes sense when you stand for emotions over morals and what “feels good”. No leader, no direction, and just complain about a person. Nothing has changed for them and this is the very same reason why the house, and senate will belong to conservatives. Locally it is shifting in every state as well. The red wave is a coming and I am here for it. 

13
12
arcjunkie329
Posts
84
Joined
10/24/2024
Location
Mapleton, UT, USA
10/13/2025 7:57am
ns503 wrote:
This is a right leaning board, no question. There are really not that many left/Dem supporters here. But the majority can't see that. They automatically assume...

This is a right leaning board, no question. There are really not that many left/Dem supporters here. But the majority can't see that. They automatically assume somone saying something critical of someone on their side is defacto supportive of the other. When in fact, it is people in the middle, who have neither side as their side and have been critical of each at one time or the other. Someone should throw up a post supporting a prominent Dem to check that out, and see how many replies of support they get. Would like to see that. As opposed to all the DT echo chamber replies so common here.

All the right leaners are getting banned and clicked so there aren't too many around right now.  The forum has definitely gone left with a few...

All the right leaners are getting banned and clicked so there aren't too many around right now.  The forum has definitely gone left with a few who fight for good ole American values. It appears the problem is getting hung up with an individual as you just did, instead of looking at the movement behind the individual.  I think most are completely open to a rational discussion, as I am.  So people must forget about specific individuals they hate and focus on the values of the administration, because we are never going to find a perfect individual that makes everyone happy, on either side.

So let's do just that.  What is it about the following that you or anyone else doesn't like that this administration stands for?

Securing borders
Restoring Law and Order
Deporting illegals who are flooding our systems and costing billions in tax dollars
Strengthen military and national security
Draining the swamp and getting rid of corruption (DOGE)
American Energy Independence
Traditional family values
America first with funding and trade policy
 

 

        Sorry BDB, but I disagree that most folks on either side of the coin are willing to sit down and have a...

        Sorry BDB, but I disagree that most folks on either side of the coin are willing to sit down and have a rational conversation. In fact, I would say that is the crux of the problem in the USA, NOBODY is willing to have a rational conversation. 

Charlie was.

9
4
avidchimp
Posts
5881
Joined
7/9/2008
Location
EGL, MN, USA
10/13/2025 8:05am
plowboy wrote:
I see a lot of the problem with the world today is that when some folks hear "right and wrong"...they believe "right" is what's right for...

I see a lot of the problem with the world today is that when some folks hear "right and wrong"...they believe "right" is what's right for THEM.  

As far as this board, I asked someone that was really being a turd if they actually believed what they were saying. They answered, "no" but just enjoyed the chaos it caused.  That just blows my mind.

Two types of people in this world.. One type who actually enjoys participating in constructive conversations, and the other who just wants to hear their opinion coming out of your mouth. The latter is who keeps getting put into time out's.

Sorry, a third type exists that just wants to watch the world burn.

9
Zycki11
Posts
7967
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL, USA
10/13/2025 9:01am
plowboy wrote:
I see a lot of the problem with the world today is that when some folks hear "right and wrong"...they believe "right" is what's right for...

I see a lot of the problem with the world today is that when some folks hear "right and wrong"...they believe "right" is what's right for THEM.  

As far as this board, I asked someone that was really being a turd if they actually believed what they were saying. They answered, "no" but just enjoyed the chaos it caused.  That just blows my mind.

avidchimp wrote:
Two types of people in this world.. One type who actually enjoys participating in constructive conversations, and the other who just wants to hear their opinion...

Two types of people in this world.. One type who actually enjoys participating in constructive conversations, and the other who just wants to hear their opinion coming out of your mouth. The latter is who keeps getting put into time out's.

Sorry, a third type exists that just wants to watch the world burn.

Ye old Batman quote from the great Michael Cane 

1
1
10/13/2025 10:50am
Zycki11 wrote:
Honestly it feels like everyone gets so caught up in the nuances of nothing and forget the bigger picture at hand. Just stay calm and watch...

Honestly it feels like everyone gets so caught up in the nuances of nothing and forget the bigger picture at hand. Just stay calm and watch what happens. Democrats will get slaughtered come midterms and can’t see it coming. Then the real work will begin. Get this country back on track to having morals, work ethic, raising well mannered respectful children, faith. 
 


Until the Democratic Party comes back to reality it will continue to struggle. Look across the polls(even though I don’t believe in them) CNN even shows dems underwater in every single category, and dropping. Makes sense when you stand for emotions over morals and what “feels good”. No leader, no direction, and just complain about a person. Nothing has changed for them and this is the very same reason why the house, and senate will belong to conservatives. Locally it is shifting in every state as well. The red wave is a coming and I am here for it. 

Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as it's not a coincidence they all seem to be from small towns.  Perfect example, Early's comment about ICE:

"Having said that the new ICE tactics I can't get behind for the most part. Masked guys with no identification jumping out of unmarked vehicles is not the way law enforcement should be done in this country, we're better than that, that's what happens in shit hole countries"

By stating this or agreeing with it you couldn't identify yourself any better than someone who does not understanding reality in the cities and urban environments.  Come on out to LA guys and take a drive with me, this is one of the most in-the-dark comments you could possibly make.  Please take a look at what reality is in the streets before being judgmental from a cozy little town in the sticks.

I get it, you are from a small town and think your method might fly with your local sheriff who attends your weekend BBQ's, but this is not reality in the cities (aka war zones).  As mentioned previously, these guys are under attack and their lives are in danger and there is zero chance any of you would do this job the way you think it should be done with marked cars, no mask, and "Hello everyone, I'm Johnny from ICE, here's my badge".

Guess what Early...."Shit hole countries" is exactly what we have in our "Shit hole cities" so you might reconsider this stance you have on this one.  I agree in a perfect world the old fashioned method is best and should work, but that's not reality anymore.  

5
8
early
Posts
10122
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH, USA
10/13/2025 11:09am
Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as...

Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as it's not a coincidence they all seem to be from small towns.  Perfect example, Early's comment about ICE:

"Having said that the new ICE tactics I can't get behind for the most part. Masked guys with no identification jumping out of unmarked vehicles is not the way law enforcement should be done in this country, we're better than that, that's what happens in shit hole countries"

By stating this or agreeing with it you couldn't identify yourself any better than someone who does not understanding reality in the cities and urban environments.  Come on out to LA guys and take a drive with me, this is one of the most in-the-dark comments you could possibly make.  Please take a look at what reality is in the streets before being judgmental from a cozy little town in the sticks.

I get it, you are from a small town and think your method might fly with your local sheriff who attends your weekend BBQ's, but this is not reality in the cities (aka war zones).  As mentioned previously, these guys are under attack and their lives are in danger and there is zero chance any of you would do this job the way you think it should be done with marked cars, no mask, and "Hello everyone, I'm Johnny from ICE, here's my badge".

Guess what Early...."Shit hole countries" is exactly what we have in our "Shit hole cities" so you might reconsider this stance you have on this one.  I agree in a perfect world the old fashioned method is best and should work, but that's not reality anymore.  

I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.

If these tactics are good for ICE why are they not employed for all law enforcement? Why are police officers subject to badge numbers and body cameras? Why are police cars marked when they could be more effective if unmarked?

1
2
10/13/2025 11:16am
Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as...

Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as it's not a coincidence they all seem to be from small towns.  Perfect example, Early's comment about ICE:

"Having said that the new ICE tactics I can't get behind for the most part. Masked guys with no identification jumping out of unmarked vehicles is not the way law enforcement should be done in this country, we're better than that, that's what happens in shit hole countries"

By stating this or agreeing with it you couldn't identify yourself any better than someone who does not understanding reality in the cities and urban environments.  Come on out to LA guys and take a drive with me, this is one of the most in-the-dark comments you could possibly make.  Please take a look at what reality is in the streets before being judgmental from a cozy little town in the sticks.

I get it, you are from a small town and think your method might fly with your local sheriff who attends your weekend BBQ's, but this is not reality in the cities (aka war zones).  As mentioned previously, these guys are under attack and their lives are in danger and there is zero chance any of you would do this job the way you think it should be done with marked cars, no mask, and "Hello everyone, I'm Johnny from ICE, here's my badge".

Guess what Early...."Shit hole countries" is exactly what we have in our "Shit hole cities" so you might reconsider this stance you have on this one.  I agree in a perfect world the old fashioned method is best and should work, but that's not reality anymore.  

early wrote:
I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.If these tactics are good for ICE why are...

I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.

If these tactics are good for ICE why are they not employed for all law enforcement? Why are police officers subject to badge numbers and body cameras? Why are police cars marked when they could be more effective if unmarked?

Different units handle different things.  There are plenty of unmarked police cars and under cover cops out there, even the highway patrol is using unmarked cars to stay stealth...but keep in mind ICE is faced with detaining illegals which is not something that your daily law enforcement deals with. They handle things like traffic tickets, domestic disputes, disturbing the peace, etc. 

2
avidchimp
Posts
5881
Joined
7/9/2008
Location
EGL, MN, USA
10/13/2025 11:54am
Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as...

Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as it's not a coincidence they all seem to be from small towns.  Perfect example, Early's comment about ICE:

"Having said that the new ICE tactics I can't get behind for the most part. Masked guys with no identification jumping out of unmarked vehicles is not the way law enforcement should be done in this country, we're better than that, that's what happens in shit hole countries"

By stating this or agreeing with it you couldn't identify yourself any better than someone who does not understanding reality in the cities and urban environments.  Come on out to LA guys and take a drive with me, this is one of the most in-the-dark comments you could possibly make.  Please take a look at what reality is in the streets before being judgmental from a cozy little town in the sticks.

I get it, you are from a small town and think your method might fly with your local sheriff who attends your weekend BBQ's, but this is not reality in the cities (aka war zones).  As mentioned previously, these guys are under attack and their lives are in danger and there is zero chance any of you would do this job the way you think it should be done with marked cars, no mask, and "Hello everyone, I'm Johnny from ICE, here's my badge".

Guess what Early...."Shit hole countries" is exactly what we have in our "Shit hole cities" so you might reconsider this stance you have on this one.  I agree in a perfect world the old fashioned method is best and should work, but that's not reality anymore.  

early wrote:
I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.If these tactics are good for ICE why are...

I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.

If these tactics are good for ICE why are they not employed for all law enforcement? Why are police officers subject to badge numbers and body cameras? Why are police cars marked when they could be more effective if unmarked?

Different units handle different things.  There are plenty of unmarked police cars and under cover cops out there, even the highway patrol is using unmarked cars...

Different units handle different things.  There are plenty of unmarked police cars and under cover cops out there, even the highway patrol is using unmarked cars to stay stealth...but keep in mind ICE is faced with detaining illegals which is not something that your daily law enforcement deals with. They handle things like traffic tickets, domestic disputes, disturbing the peace, etc. 

The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running amok unchecked and just grabbing people off the street with zero documentation to prove they have a legitimate cause or reason. Not to mention the reports of abuse by said officers with zero recourse.

This also brings potential kidnapping/traffic'ing scenarios into play by unscrupulous entities. I'm not trying to wear a tinfoil hat, but where there is opportunity to be shady, shady will show up.

9
3
Zycki11
Posts
7967
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL, USA
10/13/2025 12:22pm
early wrote:
I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.If these tactics are good for ICE why are...

I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.

If these tactics are good for ICE why are they not employed for all law enforcement? Why are police officers subject to badge numbers and body cameras? Why are police cars marked when they could be more effective if unmarked?

Different units handle different things.  There are plenty of unmarked police cars and under cover cops out there, even the highway patrol is using unmarked cars...

Different units handle different things.  There are plenty of unmarked police cars and under cover cops out there, even the highway patrol is using unmarked cars to stay stealth...but keep in mind ICE is faced with detaining illegals which is not something that your daily law enforcement deals with. They handle things like traffic tickets, domestic disputes, disturbing the peace, etc. 

avidchimp wrote:
The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running...

The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running amok unchecked and just grabbing people off the street with zero documentation to prove they have a legitimate cause or reason. Not to mention the reports of abuse by said officers with zero recourse.

This also brings potential kidnapping/traffic'ing scenarios into play by unscrupulous entities. I'm not trying to wear a tinfoil hat, but where there is opportunity to be shady, shady will show up.

Well, the problem I have is that the person of question got into this country, given rights etc without going through proper channels.  Federal law, come into country without documents, and proper approval is breaking a law #1 thing they did was break our laws as non citizens. They don't have the same birth rights we have inside of USA. Why do you bypass the actual part of how we got to this point? Illegals do not, shall not, ever, have the same rights as myself UNTIL they come through the system legally. Then they have every right I do.  (We can talk about the length and chaos of said process and agree it needs heavy updating). Even still, the current law is the current law.  Cities like Chicago, LA, NY, Dearborn MI, sanctuary cities are not holding the standards of law by allowing any criminal illegal or legal to the real process of law.  Instead, they let them go free and try and turn it into votes.  Then that same city, turns around and gifts them a place to stay, healthcare and money, followed by ID's, and voting rights.  It is a complete farce.  So Trump said, if you won't protect your crime riddled cities, I will.  ICE comes in, y'all bitch and complain and here we are.  

Why doesn't any democrat who downvotes in here understand that Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton, Schummer, Obama before term 1, Biden, all say the same thing? Illegal immigrants are bad and to protect borders.  They are all on tape saying the exact same thing Trump has said all along.  Further proof of how far out to lunch they have gone.  

9
4
10/13/2025 12:22pm
early wrote:
I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.If these tactics are good for ICE why are...

I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.

If these tactics are good for ICE why are they not employed for all law enforcement? Why are police officers subject to badge numbers and body cameras? Why are police cars marked when they could be more effective if unmarked?

Different units handle different things.  There are plenty of unmarked police cars and under cover cops out there, even the highway patrol is using unmarked cars...

Different units handle different things.  There are plenty of unmarked police cars and under cover cops out there, even the highway patrol is using unmarked cars to stay stealth...but keep in mind ICE is faced with detaining illegals which is not something that your daily law enforcement deals with. They handle things like traffic tickets, domestic disputes, disturbing the peace, etc. 

avidchimp wrote:
The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running...

The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running amok unchecked and just grabbing people off the street with zero documentation to prove they have a legitimate cause or reason. Not to mention the reports of abuse by said officers with zero recourse.

This also brings potential kidnapping/traffic'ing scenarios into play by unscrupulous entities. I'm not trying to wear a tinfoil hat, but where there is opportunity to be shady, shady will show up.

I totally understand, but here's the reality that people in small towns won't see on most MSM.  They are forced into doing what they are doing now, nothing but thugs and a war zone out there.  Hence the national guard having to be deployed for situations like these.  And some say leave it up to the state? Well when your state like CA promotes this with zero punishment, it's time to deploy the troops and stop the anarchy:

2
3
plowboy
Posts
14859
Joined
1/3/2010
Location
Norwich, KS, USA
10/13/2025 12:40pm
avidchimp wrote:
Two types of people in this world.. One type who actually enjoys participating in constructive conversations, and the other who just wants to hear their opinion...

Two types of people in this world.. One type who actually enjoys participating in constructive conversations, and the other who just wants to hear their opinion coming out of your mouth. The latter is who keeps getting put into time out's.

Sorry, a third type exists that just wants to watch the world burn.

And there's more of the 3rd type than I ever could have imagined.

4
1
10/13/2025 1:05pm
Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as...

Based on this thread, it's become apparent that a lot of these opinions are unfortunately a result of simply being isolated and uneducated on reality, as it's not a coincidence they all seem to be from small towns.  Perfect example, Early's comment about ICE:

"Having said that the new ICE tactics I can't get behind for the most part. Masked guys with no identification jumping out of unmarked vehicles is not the way law enforcement should be done in this country, we're better than that, that's what happens in shit hole countries"

By stating this or agreeing with it you couldn't identify yourself any better than someone who does not understanding reality in the cities and urban environments.  Come on out to LA guys and take a drive with me, this is one of the most in-the-dark comments you could possibly make.  Please take a look at what reality is in the streets before being judgmental from a cozy little town in the sticks.

I get it, you are from a small town and think your method might fly with your local sheriff who attends your weekend BBQ's, but this is not reality in the cities (aka war zones).  As mentioned previously, these guys are under attack and their lives are in danger and there is zero chance any of you would do this job the way you think it should be done with marked cars, no mask, and "Hello everyone, I'm Johnny from ICE, here's my badge".

Guess what Early...."Shit hole countries" is exactly what we have in our "Shit hole cities" so you might reconsider this stance you have on this one.  I agree in a perfect world the old fashioned method is best and should work, but that's not reality anymore.  

early wrote:
I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.If these tactics are good for ICE why are...

I've been busy, but I'll get back to you on some of the other points when I can.

If these tactics are good for ICE why are they not employed for all law enforcement? Why are police officers subject to badge numbers and body cameras? Why are police cars marked when they could be more effective if unmarked?

These tactics are not being employed by other law enforcement agencies because they aren't necessary to achieve the purpose of those law enforcement agencies. I think you're misunderstanding the greater strategy of the Trump administration with these ICE tactics. 

First, we can agree that the ultimate goal is to get as many of the illegal aliens that are in the country out as quickly as possible. The largest obstacle to rounding up and shipping these people out is the due process clause of the 14th amendment because, as written, all "persons" in US territories are entitled to due process. As it's relevant to immigration, procedural due process requires a notice and a hearing before a person can be deprived of certain rights. Despite what you've likely been led to believe, the ICE raids have complied with this due process requirement. The laws under which ICE has been operating have remained largely unchanged since their inception in the 2002 Homeland Security Act, save for some administrative discretionary rules that are legally within the purview of the administrative branch to promulgate. ICE is acting lawfully.

Though lawful, the ICE activity has seemed heavy handed. Why? Well due process only applies when the government acts to remove your rights. Due process is not an issue if you leave the country of your own volition or decide not to enter at all. This is where the numbers are important. During Trump's current term, about 400,000 people have been deported. However, DHS estimates that roughly 1.6 million have self deported. 

That second number is why we have these well publicized and seemingly militaristic ICE tactics. The Trump administration is intentionally creating an environment that is hostile to illegal aliens in hopes that they will deport themselves or forgo entry in the first place. This avoids the due process requirement and has a magnifying effect where fewer resources can create a greater effect. It's also created a perfect storm where the optics of ICE and a media eager to paint this administration as totalitarian have collided to create shitstorm of protests and people engaging in actual illegal acts in attempts to prevent ICE from doing what it is congressionally ordained to do. Neither group in this wants to lower the temperature because the poor optics serve both party's goal.

So to summarize, ICE is acting legally but is making it as ugly as it can because, as indicated by the 4X number of self-deportees, the easiest way to get people out of the country is to convince them to show themselves the exit. Neither side is eager to reframe the story because the common narrative is mutually beneficial. 

I personally do not have an issue with this strategy. It achieves the goal and complies with the law. Your argument is essentially an aesthetic argument. That's fine, but it's entirely subjective. I think most of the left's argument boils down to not liking the aesthetics of a Trump presidency. 

15
10/13/2025 4:39pm
avidchimp wrote:
The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running...

The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running amok unchecked and just grabbing people off the street with zero documentation to prove they have a legitimate cause or reason. Not to mention the reports of abuse by said officers with zero recourse.

This also brings potential kidnapping/traffic'ing scenarios into play by unscrupulous entities. I'm not trying to wear a tinfoil hat, but where there is opportunity to be shady, shady will show up.

That thought had occurred to me as well. How difficult would it be for bad actors to conduct snatch and run ops  dressed up like law enforcement? Honestly I can see it not being uncommon in some countries, but I think it would take a hell of a lot of balls to do it here. Is it possible? Yes. I don't think it's very likely though. 

4
10/13/2025 4:59pm
avidchimp wrote:
The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running...

The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running amok unchecked and just grabbing people off the street with zero documentation to prove they have a legitimate cause or reason. Not to mention the reports of abuse by said officers with zero recourse.

This also brings potential kidnapping/traffic'ing scenarios into play by unscrupulous entities. I'm not trying to wear a tinfoil hat, but where there is opportunity to be shady, shady will show up.

That thought had occurred to me as well. How difficult would it be for bad actors to conduct snatch and run ops  dressed up like law...

That thought had occurred to me as well. How difficult would it be for bad actors to conduct snatch and run ops  dressed up like law enforcement? Honestly I can see it not being uncommon in some countries, but I think it would take a hell of a lot of balls to do it here. Is it possible? Yes. I don't think it's very likely though. 

What's the motive to kidnap illegals? If people wanted to kidnap legals or illegals, they could also dress up in a police uniform and do it that way.  There are million of other ways to kidnap if that's your motive, you don't have to imitate under cover ICE agents, they can just wear fake ICE uniforms.

2
3
avidchimp
Posts
5881
Joined
7/9/2008
Location
EGL, MN, USA
10/13/2025 5:18pm

You misread my comment, I meant the potential for ANYONE to be kidnapped under the guise of immigration enforcement exists due to the lack of visibility on who is doing the detaining. 

4
3
lumpy790
Posts
11872
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
10/13/2025 5:36pm

Have any of you tried to process to become an American? It takes many many years of paying paying paying lawyers all along the way.

I ask this because I know a lady that came here with her parents when she was very young and after over 15 years of paying attorneys her parents are finally now Americans but her paperwork was somehow lost along the way so now she is an illegal.

Its a fucked up system that the lawyers alway$ win.

1
7
10/13/2025 6:48pm
avidchimp wrote:
You misread my comment, I meant the potential for ANYONE to be kidnapped under the guise of immigration enforcement exists due to the lack of visibility...

You misread my comment, I meant the potential for ANYONE to be kidnapped under the guise of immigration enforcement exists due to the lack of visibility on who is doing the detaining. 

Since you want to use all caps, ANYONE can be kidnapped in ANY WAY.  Stop using ICE as a potential excuse for kidnapping.   People have already been taking advantage of illegals for years, while dressing up as ICE agents.  Just like people dress up as cops and do the same.  Ole' JS7 got arrested one time for impersonating a police officer...

Kidnapping could be performed in a number of ways either forcefully, under cover, or impersonating an officer.  The fact that ICE has under cover agents is not starting some new movement or making it easier to kidnap people.  People are more vulnerable to kidnapping for those who dress up in fake uniforms.

4
6
10/13/2025 6:50pm
lumpy790 wrote:
Have any of you tried to process to become an American? It takes many many years of paying paying paying lawyers all along the way.I ask...

Have any of you tried to process to become an American? It takes many many years of paying paying paying lawyers all along the way.

I ask this because I know a lady that came here with her parents when she was very young and after over 15 years of paying attorneys her parents are finally now Americans but her paperwork was somehow lost along the way so now she is an illegal.

Its a fucked up system that the lawyers alway$ win.

I would think it would be in the system somewhere...

TAUTOG
Posts
1846
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
10/13/2025 7:02pm
avidchimp wrote:
The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running...

The problem I see with this I.C.E. deal is dudes in unmarked, plain jane cars, with outfits you and I can buy online with ease, running amok unchecked and just grabbing people off the street with zero documentation to prove they have a legitimate cause or reason. Not to mention the reports of abuse by said officers with zero recourse.

This also brings potential kidnapping/traffic'ing scenarios into play by unscrupulous entities. I'm not trying to wear a tinfoil hat, but where there is opportunity to be shady, shady will show up.

That thought had occurred to me as well. How difficult would it be for bad actors to conduct snatch and run ops  dressed up like law...

That thought had occurred to me as well. How difficult would it be for bad actors to conduct snatch and run ops  dressed up like law enforcement? Honestly I can see it not being uncommon in some countries, but I think it would take a hell of a lot of balls to do it here. Is it possible? Yes. I don't think it's very likely though. 

What's the motive to kidnap illegals? If people wanted to kidnap legals or illegals, they could also dress up in a police uniform and do it...

What's the motive to kidnap illegals? If people wanted to kidnap legals or illegals, they could also dress up in a police uniform and do it that way.  There are million of other ways to kidnap if that's your motive, you don't have to imitate under cover ICE agents, they can just wear fake ICE uniforms.

Lol is human and/or sex trafficking not a thing in the "big cities" that we regular folk couldn't possibly go to or see? You are ignorant in the way that you think anyone without your same point of view is under or miss informed. 

2
1
10/13/2025 7:14pm

The answer is no.

No matter what, 20% of "us" live where "they" live. 

That's too high of a percentage to logically  think genocide will happen anywhere in the US.

TAUTOG
Posts
1846
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA, USA
10/13/2025 7:40pm
The answer is no.No matter what, 20% of "us" live where "they" live. That's too high of a percentage to logically  think genocide will happen anywhere in...

The answer is no.

No matter what, 20% of "us" live where "they" live. 

That's too high of a percentage to logically  think genocide will happen anywhere in the US.

I've not heard the word genocide mentioned. Not sure where that came from. But to pull only "brown" people off the streets to question and not white, black, or yellow? Even without probable cause? 

Post a reply to: Will the USA balkanize?

The Latest