Another horrible take from Catanzaro

LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
3/7/2025 2:53pm
FWYT wrote:
All I know is that when I watch the vids of the guys ripping through the woods, particularly those ones like Paddycam, I crash right out...

All I know is that when I watch the vids of the guys ripping through the woods, particularly those ones like Paddycam, I crash right out of my chair at least twice and bash my knuckles god-knows-how.

And if I watch the vids of the fast guys doing the bomb run in a desert race, I break fingers from gripping the chair so tight and usually have to change my shorts afterward.

Inconclusive and non-scientific, but there you go.

Makes sense.  But you're also watching the top 1% in the world.  I'm sure you tense up a little watching some of the helmet cams from Stew back in the day too!  😉

4
28hall
Posts
309
Joined
4/16/2019
Location
AU
3/7/2025 3:16pm
FWYT wrote:
All I know is that when I watch the vids of the guys ripping through the woods, particularly those ones like Paddycam, I crash right out...

All I know is that when I watch the vids of the guys ripping through the woods, particularly those ones like Paddycam, I crash right out of my chair at least twice and bash my knuckles god-knows-how.

And if I watch the vids of the fast guys doing the bomb run in a desert race, I break fingers from gripping the chair so tight and usually have to change my shorts afterward.

Inconclusive and non-scientific, but there you go.

LungButter wrote:
Makes sense.  But you're also watching the top 1% in the world.  I'm sure you tense up a little watching some of the helmet cams from...

Makes sense.  But you're also watching the top 1% in the world.  I'm sure you tense up a little watching some of the helmet cams from Stew back in the day too!  😉

From my perspective that’s part of the issue with off-road though, a lot of situations with open areas or long straights where I can potentially be going as fast as the top guys without near the skill or experience because of bike speeds. In MX unless you are riding like an absolute idiot you can’t jump the big stuff if you can’t get through the turn quick enough so in most cases the track conditions limit speed capability. Of course there are always exceptions. I could roll around in the forest and not fall over but I would be bored out of my brain. 

2
1
Titan1
Posts
9418
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
3/7/2025 3:29pm
Titan1 wrote:

Exactly!

LungButter wrote:
I'm enjoying the variety of answers though.It's definitely not as cut and dry as I thought.  I'm surprised how many moto dudes that probably do some...

I'm enjoying the variety of answers though.

It's definitely not as cut and dry as I thought.  I'm surprised how many moto dudes that probably do some gnarly jumps are afraid of trees 🤣

I'm surprised as well...As a desert guy, I'm kind of scared of trees too though...I wonder how those dudes that are afraid of trees would feel about a bomb run at a hare and hound? 

2
Kawboy14!
Posts
496
Joined
5/15/2021
Location
Georgetown, TX, USA
3/7/2025 3:51pm
Ramrod wrote:

If a person crashes in the woods, does it make a sound? 

DJS721 wrote:

Vital needs more takes like this

Well done

If the rider goes fast enough, will he miss the forest for the trees?

1
3

The Shop

Kkawi
Posts
195
Joined
6/14/2014
Location
Northville, MI, USA
3/7/2025 4:02pm

i didn’t know people don’t like AJ, I think he has a good way of explaining technique. 

2
4
3/7/2025 5:03pm
Kkawi wrote:

i didn’t know people don’t like AJ, I think he has a good way of explaining technique. 

AJ I think is a good teacher. But he comes across as arogant to me a bit. Like the expert on everything. How the world works is you need accomplishments to back it up. He was a good racer, won some amateur titles I think. But he isn't the authority. He also says silly stuff, but sometimes it is taken out of context. He also posted a video saying he jumped 200 ft or something, and it looked like, at best, 100 ft (can't remember the specifics).

To answer his claim, I think it depends on your level of skill. Motocross has a fairly predictable track lap after lap. I think that is what AJ is getting at. Woods racing is more variable, especially when you get into hard enduro. I would say though, for most people, the chance of serious injury is highest in motocross. With trails, you may come off and dump the bike, but you're far less likely to do a femur, spine, neck etc.

3
2
Hcallz5
Posts
3279
Joined
8/20/2013
Location
USA
3/7/2025 6:25pm

I don't think it matters if its a jump, a tree or a minivan, moto is just inherently dangerous. 

 

And that's why its awesome. 

1
1
disbanded
Posts
6927
Joined
8/26/2007
Location
Evergreen, CO, USA
3/7/2025 6:56pm

I broke my back during an enduro, and shattered my ankle racing motocross.  Anything can happen in a dangerous sport, which is motorcycling in general.

1
1
Dirtysmile56
Posts
2210
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Bend, OR, USA
3/7/2025 8:09pm
3strokemx wrote:

If you get hurt in the woods they just leave you there, no need for an ambulance.

They feed you to the Bears Wink  

1
Dirtysmile56
Posts
2210
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Bend, OR, USA
3/7/2025 8:11pm
Ramrod wrote:

If a person crashes in the woods, does it make a sound? 

If there is no one there to hear it and the rider is concussed, then no. If his buddy is there he hears the "Oh Shit" loud and clear just before impact LOL 

1
3/7/2025 8:21pm

I know this - I'm a 35 yr moto guy from A to Vet.........LOVE IT. I tried a few off road races ! ! ! yah, those are feeking mad, skilled and crazy AF. We Moto boys are princess's. Truth hurts.  

2
2
mustard530
Posts
68
Joined
5/18/2020
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
3/7/2025 10:08pm

I’d say there’s definitely more variables in the woods and things to bounce your head and body off of but big jumps on a moto track are pretty dangerous also, so they are probably at the same level of danger in my opinion. However I will say desert racing is far more dangerous than moto. High speeds, no idea what is coming up next, and you’re putting your life in the hands of volunteer club members who hopefully marked all of the dangers you’re coming up on. I’ve seen way more life flights out of a desert race than I have at a moto track. Shit I’ve ridden some stuff in southern Utah where if you make a mistake and go 12” on way or another, best case scenario you pick up the pile of metal and plastic that used to be your bike at the bottom of the 1000’ cliff, worst case someone picks the mush that used to be you up at the bottom of the cliff. Never had to worry about that on a moto track 

1
1
OldPro277
Posts
1875
Joined
11/9/2009
Location
Avonmore, PA, USA
3/8/2025 6:49am
Titan1 wrote:

Exactly!

LungButter wrote:
I'm enjoying the variety of answers though.It's definitely not as cut and dry as I thought.  I'm surprised how many moto dudes that probably do some...

I'm enjoying the variety of answers though.

It's definitely not as cut and dry as I thought.  I'm surprised how many moto dudes that probably do some gnarly jumps are afraid of trees 🤣

Well Lung , after breaking up my 65 yo body on some of those trees, I am not ashamed to admit that yes I’m afraid of them. Those fuckers do not move !! Not matter how hard you hit them !! 

However, that’s racing at A class speeds. Just trail riding is a completely different animal, no scary business there 

1
1
MX558
Posts
1976
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
3/8/2025 7:04am

I mostly ride MX but have done some woods stuff and he's not wrong . If you try to go fast in the woods it's just as dangerous as MX if not more , trees don't move lol

1
goinrcn44h
Posts
378
Joined
9/20/2011
Location
Sedro Woolley, WA, USA
3/8/2025 7:32am
I think in part he is right, there is a lot more variables in the woods than the track. In theory if you get a few...

I think in part he is right, there is a lot more variables in the woods than the track. In theory if you get a few laps in on say burnt ridge and feel comfy you should be fine if you can keep your head on straight. 

In the woods a trail you rode last week may have a washout, more exposed rocks, a log or exposed roots up a hill that would take both tires and throw them to third base. Impact wise I would say definitely motocross track has more risk, but the woods are just more of an unknown. I have gotten hurt riding woods more than my buddies tracks just because of that one damn rock that roll out of the side of the will that was not there before we went and ate lunch at the truck or the rain didn't fully dry up and I misjudged how greasy the off camber rooted up hill corner was and sent myself on a exploration off trail. lol

I have hurt myself doing wheelies in the yard on my TTR125, I think it all has a risk thats just part of the deal.

I used to legit enjoy watching AJ's video. Just an interesting few minutes of content but lately he is seemingly going off the deepest end for some weird reason. 

Hes building a great deal I admit, but the outlandish hot takes seem forced

1
Elliot
Posts
2353
Joined
5/8/2021
Location
GB
3/8/2025 7:52am

I started out in MX but raced woods most my adult life and I only actually hit a tree hard a few times. I think it must be the level of concentration you instinctively adopt dodging them. I had more serious injuries racing a few years in MX than decades in woods.  

1
3/8/2025 8:22am

It's not about the terrain of which type of riding is more dangerous.  tt's how hard a person is pushing their limits and how fast they are going.  Riding on a vet track at half speed playing around with buddies is not much different than putt putting through the woods or desert with buddies.  But balls out racing a MX track, pushing the limits and pace with bigger obstacles at a faster pace and the risk goes way up.  Same for going faster through the woods or desert.  There's a reason why life insurance companies will cover a rider if they die in a practice crash, but the same life insurance policy is not covered if racing.  Both are risky, but that risk goes up with riding intensity.

2
PNWMXer
Posts
1758
Joined
1/13/2022
Location
Washington, WA, USA
3/8/2025 12:49pm Edited Date/Time 3/8/2025 1:02pm
I don't ride woods at all, just cause I like moto. In the OHV areas near me there are WAY too many people on UTVs, drinking...

I don't ride woods at all, just cause I like moto. In the OHV areas near me there are WAY too many people on UTVs, drinking beer and shooting guns, for me to feel safe (oh I like guns, just not in OTHER people's hands!). And I don't think I'd enjoy the technicality of PNW woods - it's always wet and slick in there with so many ways to crash. With moto I usually know what I'm getting for track prep, I can see ahead of me, and if I don't feel it I can just pack up and not ride. 

I ride street too and that has its own hazards and minefields. I'm pretty cautious out there and I avoid city traffic, period. I only ride out in the countryside on nice days. I'm old and I got nuthin to prove to anyone about how tough I am. Smile

Any form of motorcycle riding is dangerous. The more goons, beginners, and drunks there are the worse it is. Dunes? Oh hell no........

Late to the party but was going to post something similar. I can’t speak to woods RACING as the closest I’ve come to that was Hannegan’s 45 min Thursday night hare scrambles that were about 75% moto with some trails thrown in (I miss those). 

However, public trail riding is insane. I wouldn’t necessarily say there are more injuries than moto, but I would say that most moto injuries are self-inflicted, while many at public areas involve some drunk/stoned/stupid dipshit on a quad or in a UTV hitting you through no fault of your own.

I grew up riding at Exit 202 on I-5 (aka 116th, Donna’s, etc in Marysville, WA)…even back in the 90s, smart moto folks got in and out early before the drunks and dopers woke from the night before. The amount of stupidity in that place was amazing.

2
1
3/8/2025 12:59pm Edited Date/Time 3/8/2025 12:59pm
LungButter wrote:
I wish I knew how to link it, does this guy just say stupid/controversial shit to make himself get clicks and stay relevant?He said "I think...

I wish I knew how to link it, does this guy just say stupid/controversial shit to make himself get clicks and stay relevant?

He said "I think riding in the woods is more dangerous than motocross.  There are way more variables and way more things that can go wrong."

Yeah AJ....let's take a look at how many ambulance rides there are at moto races and how many there are from off road races.  It's not even close.  It's a BIG deal typically when someone leaves an off road race in an ambulance, it's an every weekend occurrence for moto races 

@Hammer 663s just posted about more ambulance rides from one moto race at Hangtown than I see going to 20+ off road events a year.

AJ can't possibly be stupid enough to believe what he said right?

Rant over.

Just feel flattered that being a woods rider makes you kind of gnarly in his eyes I guess?

1
1
3/8/2025 1:05pm

Hard enduro probs the safest even though the obstacles can be gnarly. It’s low speed. Bikes take most of the beating 

1
1
Darrin Willis
Posts
1105
Joined
11/16/2020
Location
Red Deer County, AB, CA
3/8/2025 1:07pm
I don't ride woods at all, just cause I like moto. In the OHV areas near me there are WAY too many people on UTVs, drinking...

I don't ride woods at all, just cause I like moto. In the OHV areas near me there are WAY too many people on UTVs, drinking beer and shooting guns, for me to feel safe (oh I like guns, just not in OTHER people's hands!). And I don't think I'd enjoy the technicality of PNW woods - it's always wet and slick in there with so many ways to crash. With moto I usually know what I'm getting for track prep, I can see ahead of me, and if I don't feel it I can just pack up and not ride. 

I ride street too and that has its own hazards and minefields. I'm pretty cautious out there and I avoid city traffic, period. I only ride out in the countryside on nice days. I'm old and I got nuthin to prove to anyone about how tough I am. Smile

Any form of motorcycle riding is dangerous. The more goons, beginners, and drunks there are the worse it is. Dunes? Oh hell no........

PNWMXer wrote:
Late to the party but was going to post something similar. I can’t speak to woods RACING as the closest I’ve come to that was Hannegan’s...

Late to the party but was going to post something similar. I can’t speak to woods RACING as the closest I’ve come to that was Hannegan’s 45 min Thursday night hare scrambles that were about 75% moto with some trails thrown in (I miss those). 

However, public trail riding is insane. I wouldn’t necessarily say there are more injuries than moto, but I would say that most moto injuries are self-inflicted, while many at public areas involve some drunk/stoned/stupid dipshit on a quad or in a UTV hitting you through no fault of your own.

I grew up riding at Exit 202 on I-5 (aka 116th, Donna’s, etc in Marysville, WA)…even back in the 90s, smart moto folks got in and out early before the drunks and dopers woke from the night before. The amount of stupidity in that place was amazing.

I grew up near Vancouver.  I remember racing a harescramble at hannegans in 86. Ya it was moto mixed with flowy trails. Great for a moto guy.

1
1
McG194
Posts
4120
Joined
9/7/2017
Location
Palm Coast, FL, USA
3/8/2025 3:28pm

As someone who raced nothing but moto as a kid and now as a +50 guy races mostly Hare Scrambles I can tell you that off road is so much more gnarly. MX tracks are fairly constant and predictable, you know the things that scare you and the obstacles you'll probably crash on. When I'm racing off road everything is going great and in the blink of an eye I'm on my head. You don't see a root and you are on the ground. Hit something wrong and you are headed towards a tree and internal bleeding. 

2
1
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
3/18/2025 9:36pm

Just heard Kellen Brauer say on a Podcast that he was at a Vet MX Race in Arizona this weekend and some of the motos on Sunday were cancelled since they were running so far behind due to medical emergencies. 

A Vet Race…..

Made me think of this thread.  

3
Farmer J
Posts
978
Joined
11/26/2022
Location
Steelville, MO, USA
3/19/2025 3:14am
LungButter wrote:
Just heard Kellen Brauer say on a Podcast that he was at a Vet MX Race in Arizona this weekend and some of the motos on...

Just heard Kellen Brauer say on a Podcast that he was at a Vet MX Race in Arizona this weekend and some of the motos on Sunday were cancelled since they were running so far behind due to medical emergencies. 

A Vet Race…..

Made me think of this thread.  

Yes some guy had a heart attack I believe.  Nothing happened on the track. He pulled off and died in the pits. They retired his number i think he said. 

1
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
3/19/2025 8:06am
Farmer J wrote:
Yes some guy had a heart attack I believe.  Nothing happened on the track. He pulled off and died in the pits. They retired his number...

Yes some guy had a heart attack I believe.  Nothing happened on the track. He pulled off and died in the pits. They retired his number i think he said. 

I thought the guy who had a heart attack was from a previous race, I doubt they'd have something put together to retire someones number if they died that weekend.

I took it as so many people got hurt they didn't have time to run the last motos.  I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure I'm not.

Saz
Posts
260
Joined
7/27/2023
Location
E, FL, USA
3/19/2025 2:28pm

Desert Racing is also extremely dangerous, when you crash you are out there for HOURS potentially badly injured and the speeds are very high even if the jumps are Moto sized. 

shortty761
Posts
766
Joined
4/2/2024
Location
Newport News, VA, USA
3/19/2025 2:45pm

It’s all dangerous and we all do it anyways. 

2
BikePilot
Posts
380
Joined
9/27/2014
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/19/2025 8:10pm

I've raced about every form of off road you can on two wheels.  From what I've seen and experienced trials is by far the safest, then woods (East Coast enduro stuff -- real woods), then MX, then desert.  The dez is super sketchy because it is so fast and races are really long. GNCC is kinda all over the place since they run in many different locations and terrains.  They tend to be pretty high speed races, and can certainly be quite dangerous.  I don't think of that as woods racing, but maybe AJ does.

GateDropGoGo
Posts
121
Joined
1/27/2022
Location
Redlands, CA, USA
3/20/2025 8:33am

Who's Catanzaro? Never heard of him. 

2

Post a reply to: Another horrible take from Catanzaro

The Latest