It's amazing how good Ricky Carmichael has gotten in the booth.

flyinb501
Posts
675
Joined
7/25/2011
Location
Lakewood Ranch, FL, USA
2/4/2024 5:51pm

Ricky is by far the weakest link of the commentating team. There's no reason the color commentator needs to be a multi time champion. That just limits the options too much. I would rather have someone that can speak well and is articulate. 

14
cwel11
Posts
2794
Joined
12/4/2019
Location
Orangeville, PA, USA
2/4/2024 5:52pm

Fire Ricky hire Brayton. Broadcast fixed

6
ILoveMoto
Posts
3598
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL, USA
2/4/2024 5:59pm
flyinb501 wrote:
Ricky is by far the weakest link of the commentating team. There's no reason the color commentator needs to be a multi time champion. That just...

Ricky is by far the weakest link of the commentating team. There's no reason the color commentator needs to be a multi time champion. That just limits the options too much. I would rather have someone that can speak well and is articulate. 

There's a reason Michael Jordan, another GOAT, doesn't do NBA commentary other than being a billionaire. He knows it's not his thing. RC didn't get the memo 😕 

8
1
number six
Posts
388
Joined
2/27/2019
Location
efnli77643qrv, FM, USA
2/4/2024 6:09pm

The usual & customary protocol for dealing with a head injury ; 

Diagnosis ; Traumatic brain injuries may be emergencies. In the case of more-severe traumatic brain injuries (TBIs), consequences can worsen rapidly without treatment. Doctors or first responders need to assess the situation quickly.

Glasgow Coma Scale

This 15-point test helps a doctor or other emergency medical personnel assess the initial severity of a brain injury by checking a person's ability to follow directions and move their eyes and limbs. The coherence of speech also provides important clues.

Abilities are scored from three to 15 in the Glasgow Coma Scale. Higher scores mean less severe injuries.

Information about the injury and symptoms

If you saw someone sustain an injury or arrived immediately after an injury, you may be able to provide medical personnel with information that's useful in assessing the injured person's condition.

Answers to the following questions may be beneficial in judging the severity of injury:

How did the injury occur?

Did the person lose consciousness?

How long was the person unconscious?

Did you observe any other changes in alertness, speaking, coordination or other signs of injury?

Where was the head or other parts of the body struck?

Can you provide any information about the force of the injury? For example, what hit the person's head, how far did he or she fall, or was the person thrown from a vehicle?

Was the person's body whipped around or severely jarred?

Imaging tests

Computerized tomography (CT) scan. This test is usually the first performed in an emergency room for a suspected traumatic brain injury. A computed tomography (CT) scan uses a series of X-rays to create a detailed view of the brain. A CT scan can quickly visualize fractures and uncover evidence of bleeding in the brain (hemorrhage), blood clots (hematomas), bruised brain tissue (contusions), and brain tissue swelling. 

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). An Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) uses powerful radio waves and magnets to create a detailed view of the brain. This test may be used after the person's condition stabilizes, or if symptoms don't improve soon after the injury.

Intracranial pressure monitor

Tissue swelling from a traumatic brain injury can increase pressure inside the skull and cause additional damage to the brain. Doctors may insert a probe through the skull to monitor this pressure.

 

3

The Shop

vetmxr
Posts
1113
Joined
1/10/2009
Location
USA
2/4/2024 6:23pm

Broc Glover......impressed me when he did one...A year or two back....

4
2
OldTech
Posts
1386
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur, AL, USA
2/4/2024 6:35pm
number six wrote:
The usual & customary protocol for dealing with a head injury ;  Diagnosis ; Traumatic brain injuries may be emergencies. In the case of more-severe traumatic...

The usual & customary protocol for dealing with a head injury ; 

Diagnosis ; Traumatic brain injuries may be emergencies. In the case of more-severe traumatic brain injuries (TBIs), consequences can worsen rapidly without treatment. Doctors or first responders need to assess the situation quickly.

Glasgow Coma Scale

This 15-point test helps a doctor or other emergency medical personnel assess the initial severity of a brain injury by checking a person's ability to follow directions and move their eyes and limbs. The coherence of speech also provides important clues.

Abilities are scored from three to 15 in the Glasgow Coma Scale. Higher scores mean less severe injuries.

Information about the injury and symptoms

If you saw someone sustain an injury or arrived immediately after an injury, you may be able to provide medical personnel with information that's useful in assessing the injured person's condition.

Answers to the following questions may be beneficial in judging the severity of injury:

How did the injury occur?

Did the person lose consciousness?

How long was the person unconscious?

Did you observe any other changes in alertness, speaking, coordination or other signs of injury?

Where was the head or other parts of the body struck?

Can you provide any information about the force of the injury? For example, what hit the person's head, how far did he or she fall, or was the person thrown from a vehicle?

Was the person's body whipped around or severely jarred?

Imaging tests

Computerized tomography (CT) scan. This test is usually the first performed in an emergency room for a suspected traumatic brain injury. A computed tomography (CT) scan uses a series of X-rays to create a detailed view of the brain. A CT scan can quickly visualize fractures and uncover evidence of bleeding in the brain (hemorrhage), blood clots (hematomas), bruised brain tissue (contusions), and brain tissue swelling. 

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). An Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) uses powerful radio waves and magnets to create a detailed view of the brain. This test may be used after the person's condition stabilizes, or if symptoms don't improve soon after the injury.

Intracranial pressure monitor

Tissue swelling from a traumatic brain injury can increase pressure inside the skull and cause additional damage to the brain. Doctors may insert a probe through the skull to monitor this pressure.

 

Are you telling us Rick needs an intracranial pressure monitor ?

brocster
Posts
4673
Joined
6/9/2009
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
2/4/2024 6:38pm Edited Date/Time 2/4/2024 6:39pm
Magoofan wrote:

Ashley Reynard was awesome...she was so much better than than Shrill Chrisitien.       I also think Haley Shanley (RDL) is very good. 

 

1911 wrote:

I liked Georgia Lindsay, though she did a good job and had a easy to listen to voice.

Magoofan wrote:

Georgia was excellent too.

 

The best of all time was Jenny Taft....  Smart and great with the riders.   

If there has to be a woman, it’s Ashley hands down. She is fantastic and is in the sport day in and day out. Knows her shit even if you want to talk parts on the motorcycle. 
 

Big oops for me in my line up though. I would have Blair in there somewhere as well. 

1
2
Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW, AU
2/4/2024 9:07pm
braaap wrote:

RC….. G.O.A.T. on the track, W.O.A.T. in the booth. 
 

There has never been a worse announcer in dirt bike history. End of discussion. 

Maybe not in colour commentary, but Ralph is the all-time WOAT of play by play. 

1
1
Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW, AU
2/4/2024 9:12pm
bens 152 wrote:
It’s the fluff about racing and story lines that drives me insane. Talk about the shit that is happening in front of us as it happens. ...

It’s the fluff about racing and story lines that drives me insane. Talk about the shit that is happening in front of us as it happens. 
 

they get halfway through the same monologues about how the riders got here and miss some action then bring up said action, then go back to the boring ass story.

ILoveMoto wrote:
The dumbing down of the commentary is mine. RC explaining what an endo is and also cross-rutting during the race. They don't explain what off-sides is...

The dumbing down of the commentary is mine.

RC explaining what an endo is and also cross-rutting during the race. They don't explain what off-sides is during football, or traveling in basketball!

Don't give me that line, "they're trying to attract new viewers" excuse please and thank you.

I've brought up this in multiple other RC commentating - and commentating in general - threads.  Don't the broadcasters realise there is an invention called the internet, and on that invention people can quickly look up facts on topics they know nothing about? 

1
Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW, AU
2/4/2024 9:19pm
dboivin wrote:
you know, if ricky didn't try to say so much, he would be 10 times better. let weege carry the load, hes knows how to do...

you know, if ricky didn't try to say so much, he would be 10 times better. let weege carry the load, hes knows how to do it. all ricky has to do is point out things when they get missed by weege. its like hes trying to hard to force the conversation. just let the race go and point out little things u see. weeg can handle the rest.

I disagree that it's to do with the pace of live commentating.  He just has no capacity to add any insight about racing in general - except occasionally about his own experiences.  Just check out Title24, the whole show is carried by RV. 

1
Tyler D
Posts
2499
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
La, CA, USA
2/4/2024 9:53pm
Spoonguy wrote:
Ricky has to purposely be speaking like a fourth grade dropout to appeal to the powers that be's idea what the average fan wants to hear...

Ricky has to purposely be speaking like a fourth grade dropout to appeal to the powers that be's idea what the average fan wants to hear or what they want someone to sound like. Grass roots or homey, whatever. It has to be on purpose, nobody being payed to speak on TV can be that totally dumb fuckery and babble mothed. I feel embarassed for him, and he makes our sport look bush league. Pleade someone tell me it's staged.

Agreed it's like they WANT it to sound like he's announcing lawn mower racing. 

2/4/2024 10:28pm
dv12.com wrote:

Haha That’s funny man. I clicked on differences between the stock market and the economy. Funny stuff but mostly true. I hv an extended family member that does investing for entertainers in LA. He’s actually a really stupid guy.  Hey Lucky you didn’t hv Troy Aikman, Lawrence Tailer & other nfl stars invester in the 90,s. He cleaned them out he was sent to prison but there money was all gone.  Ps I saw you race in 97 Minneapolis you finished 2nd I think. KW won he was really feeling it , his bike sounded a lot stronger too.  97 125 gp Duke video I watched that a million times. I saw you in front of some big riders. 98 Foxhill up to that time that was the best race ever if you include the fans. It was loud Chiodi up front as usual then Carl Nunn is swamping the lead he’s having the ride of his life. Then you come out of nowhere lead it.  That was probably your break out race.  A exciting one for sure. 

1
2/5/2024 1:44pm
flyinb501 wrote:
Ricky is by far the weakest link of the commentating team. There's no reason the color commentator needs to be a multi time champion. That just...

Ricky is by far the weakest link of the commentating team. There's no reason the color commentator needs to be a multi time champion. That just limits the options too much. I would rather have someone that can speak well and is articulate. 

david bailey was great back in the day.....he could put things in simple terms so noobs could understand moto terminology.

3
soggy
Posts
9064
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
2/5/2024 1:56pm

Ricky’s a fucking idiot and a puppet. I can’t believe they put someone on the broadcast that has the vocabulary of a troglodyte. 
 

3
2

Post a reply to: It's amazing how good Ricky Carmichael has gotten in the booth.

The Latest