Penalty Report for San Fran

Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/17/2024 11:26am
Magoofan wrote:

Credibility rating "ZERO" without Hunter on that list.

 

MxAddic wrote:
When I watched it was like hey wait a minute. Thinking about if he would have tried to re-enter and got hung would it have been...

When I watched it was like hey wait a minute. Thinking about if he would have tried to re-enter and got hung would it have been a hazard to traffic entering them?

Unless of course it was intentional.

Nobody was blizting the whoops.   At those speeds, I can't see it being  a danger.  Hell, people were wadded up everywhere on the track.

 

2
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
1/17/2024 11:28am
Magoofan wrote:

Can't have one of the Cash Cow Bros not make a main 2 weeks in a row.....    That would be bad for business. 

I suspect Honda sales have tripled.

2
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
1/17/2024 11:32am
Magoofan wrote:

Nobody was blizting the whoops.   At those speeds, I can't see it being  a danger.  Hell, people were wadded up everywhere on the track.

 

No blitzing but you still have to commit. If you enter and have to change lines suddenly bad juju. @ pro speed it's a whole other ball game than us mortals.

Shred
Posts
1545
Joined
10/21/2021
Location
Brighton, CO, USA
Fantasy
1/17/2024 11:46am Edited Date/Time 1/17/2024 11:50am
Magoofan wrote:

Nobody was blizting the whoops.   At those speeds, I can't see it being  a danger.  Hell, people were wadded up everywhere on the track.

 

MxAddic wrote:
No blitzing but you still have to commit. If you enter and have to change lines suddenly bad juju. @ pro speed it's a whole other...

No blitzing but you still have to commit. If you enter and have to change lines suddenly bad juju. @ pro speed it's a whole other ball game than us mortals.

It is the responsibility of the rider re-entering the track to do so in a safe manner.  If that means he has to wait for someone to go by then he has to wait.  Then he safely re-enters.  It’s pretty simple.  If a rider re-enters in a manner that causes a conflict/crash then he should be penalized.  It’s seems like some are more concerned about the rider that left the track?  Don’t want to wait to safely re-enter?…don’t go off the track..  and yes…I know the rider doesn’t mean to much of the time but that doesn’t change the fact he is responsible to safely re-enter.

5
3

The Shop

MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
1/17/2024 12:03pm
Shred wrote:
It is the responsibility of the rider re-entering the track to do so in a safe manner.  If that means he has to wait for someone...

It is the responsibility of the rider re-entering the track to do so in a safe manner.  If that means he has to wait for someone to go by then he has to wait.  Then he safely re-enters.  It’s pretty simple.  If a rider re-enters in a manner that causes a conflict/crash then he should be penalized.  It’s seems like some are more concerned about the rider that left the track?  Don’t want to wait to safely re-enter?…don’t go off the track..  and yes…I know the rider doesn’t mean to much of the time but that doesn’t change the fact he is responsible to safely re-enter.

When was the last time you watched a pro race and the rider sits in one place waiting to enter unless there is no other option.

C'Mon Man!

 

3
5
Shred
Posts
1545
Joined
10/21/2021
Location
Brighton, CO, USA
Fantasy
1/17/2024 12:12pm
Shred wrote:
It is the responsibility of the rider re-entering the track to do so in a safe manner.  If that means he has to wait for someone...

It is the responsibility of the rider re-entering the track to do so in a safe manner.  If that means he has to wait for someone to go by then he has to wait.  Then he safely re-enters.  It’s pretty simple.  If a rider re-enters in a manner that causes a conflict/crash then he should be penalized.  It’s seems like some are more concerned about the rider that left the track?  Don’t want to wait to safely re-enter?…don’t go off the track..  and yes…I know the rider doesn’t mean to much of the time but that doesn’t change the fact he is responsible to safely re-enter.

MxAddic wrote:
When was the last time you watched a pro race and the rider sits in one place waiting to enter unless there is no other option...

When was the last time you watched a pro race and the rider sits in one place waiting to enter unless there is no other option.

C'Mon Man!

 

Pretty much every race.  For example…Often guys get pushed wide in the first turn and keep checking over their shoulder for a gap to safely re-enter.  Happens all of the time.  They may not come to a stop, although once in a while they do, but they wait for some gap to re-enter….often loosing places waiting for the gap.  Do you even watch races?  
C’Mon Man!

2
3
CPR
Posts
6995
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/17/2024 12:37pm Edited Date/Time 1/17/2024 12:45pm
Press516 wrote:

Yep, number 3 on that list above was completely ignored for Hunter.  And I'm not anti-Lawrence at all...  But it was egregious. 

CPR wrote:
😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?! Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block...

😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?!

Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block and lost a few seconds. Second time, he lost 9 secs and two positions.

Now please, anyone of you, tell everyone how he gained time and deserved a penalty that matches these offences. I look forward to your rational and logical replies, but instead I expect you’ll just downvote and go on to repeat this bullshite on other threads about a hundred times.

Shred wrote:
Hey…this is what I was talking about^^^.  Someone that uses live timing….lol….to come to the conclusion he wants.  First time…Hunter went over the tuff block and...

Hey…this is what I was talking about^^^.  Someone that uses live timing….lol….to come to the conclusion he wants.  First time…Hunter went over the tuff block and then proceeded to go faster then he had gone in the whoops previously and to gap Anderson more then just before the whoops…but hey…why believe your eyes.  Then he dumped it going in to the whoops(they show the clip in the recap of him picking his bike up right there and 2? riders going by)….gets passed as he picks up his bike…proceeds to exit the track on purpose and again rolls by the whoops at a higher speed then he could go through them.  You don’t get to exit the track to make up time from your own mistake.  ANYBODY that watches him go through the whoops on lap 1, when they were in the best condition, and compares his pace to when they show him rolling by them can easily see he is going faster bypassing them(and it is the rider’s responsibility to not accelerate/go faster)….thus gaining an advantage over staying on the track.  Plain to see….unless you don’t want to….and you don’t want to.  When you say he lost 9 seconds and was passed by 2 riders….that’s his fault and irrelevant to then after rolling by the whoops faster then you can ride through them.  If I fall and loose 20 seconds then can I cut part of the track and make up some of the time because I made a mistake??  That is the point you are trying to make.  That or you are trying to convince us that Hunter rolled by the whoops sooooo slow that he lost 9 seconds and 2 positions….lol.

btw…I don’t care that it was Hunter….I care that the AMA can’t be fair to riders across the board to save their life.  The AMA is pathetic.

I get your logic, and have often thought the same, but if the AMA officiated using that, then nearly every rider that went off track last weekend, and that’s most of them, would be penalised. See the issue there.

As for: “That or you are trying to convince us that Hunter rolled by the whoops sooooo slow that he lost 9 seconds and 2 positions….lol.”….no I’m not trying to convince you of that. I’m saying he crashed and lost time and positions, so it doesn’t deserve penalty unless he enters in an unsafe manner, that is all.

 

2
2
CPR
Posts
6995
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/17/2024 12:41pm
CPR wrote:
😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?! Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block...

😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?!

Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block and lost a few seconds. Second time, he lost 9 secs and two positions.

Now please, anyone of you, tell everyone how he gained time and deserved a penalty that matches these offences. I look forward to your rational and logical replies, but instead I expect you’ll just downvote and go on to repeat this bullshite on other threads about a hundred times.

Makes sense the biggest Aussie pro blower doesn’t want to admit hunter got away with it just cause he’s a lawrence bro. The dude should have...

Makes sense the biggest Aussie pro blower doesn’t want to admit hunter got away with it just cause he’s a lawrence bro. The dude should have been in B practice too…

Ha thanks for your constructive criticism, it’s a great contribution to the conversation.

1
2
gerg
Posts
1545
Joined
10/29/2014
Location
AU
1/17/2024 12:44pm
Hunter fan here and I agree this is total bullshit.  If the whoops were so "gnarly" that they had to mow them down, then how is...

Hunter fan here and I agree this is total bullshit.  If the whoops were so "gnarly" that they had to mow them down, then how is a rider able to completely skip them at least twice from what I saw?  If they are so gnarly pros can't ride across them, then how is a rider not gaining an advantage by skipping them completely?

Hunter could have easily stopped and re-entered the whoops safely at any point.  

Barcia's looked way more accidental and legitimate than both of Hunter's detours.

Press516 wrote:

Yep, number 3 on that list above was completely ignored for Hunter.  And I'm not anti-Lawrence at all...  But it was egregious. 

CPR wrote:
😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?! Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block...

😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?!

Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block and lost a few seconds. Second time, he lost 9 secs and two positions.

Now please, anyone of you, tell everyone how he gained time and deserved a penalty that matches these offences. I look forward to your rational and logical replies, but instead I expect you’ll just downvote and go on to repeat this bullshite on other threads about a hundred times.

CPR you need to allow the haters to vent the steam.

1
2
ThatOneMXGuy
Posts
1073
Joined
12/28/2023
Location
Somewhere, MO, USA
1/17/2024 12:47pm

Until they become harsher on their penalties, people will continue to cut the track. The risk reward is well worth it. 

10
Shred
Posts
1545
Joined
10/21/2021
Location
Brighton, CO, USA
Fantasy
1/17/2024 12:48pm Edited Date/Time 1/17/2024 12:49pm
CPR wrote:
😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?! Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block...

😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?!

Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block and lost a few seconds. Second time, he lost 9 secs and two positions.

Now please, anyone of you, tell everyone how he gained time and deserved a penalty that matches these offences. I look forward to your rational and logical replies, but instead I expect you’ll just downvote and go on to repeat this bullshite on other threads about a hundred times.

Shred wrote:
Hey…this is what I was talking about^^^.  Someone that uses live timing….lol….to come to the conclusion he wants.  First time…Hunter went over the tuff block and...

Hey…this is what I was talking about^^^.  Someone that uses live timing….lol….to come to the conclusion he wants.  First time…Hunter went over the tuff block and then proceeded to go faster then he had gone in the whoops previously and to gap Anderson more then just before the whoops…but hey…why believe your eyes.  Then he dumped it going in to the whoops(they show the clip in the recap of him picking his bike up right there and 2? riders going by)….gets passed as he picks up his bike…proceeds to exit the track on purpose and again rolls by the whoops at a higher speed then he could go through them.  You don’t get to exit the track to make up time from your own mistake.  ANYBODY that watches him go through the whoops on lap 1, when they were in the best condition, and compares his pace to when they show him rolling by them can easily see he is going faster bypassing them(and it is the rider’s responsibility to not accelerate/go faster)….thus gaining an advantage over staying on the track.  Plain to see….unless you don’t want to….and you don’t want to.  When you say he lost 9 seconds and was passed by 2 riders….that’s his fault and irrelevant to then after rolling by the whoops faster then you can ride through them.  If I fall and loose 20 seconds then can I cut part of the track and make up some of the time because I made a mistake??  That is the point you are trying to make.  That or you are trying to convince us that Hunter rolled by the whoops sooooo slow that he lost 9 seconds and 2 positions….lol.

btw…I don’t care that it was Hunter….I care that the AMA can’t be fair to riders across the board to save their life.  The AMA is pathetic.

CPR wrote:
I get your logic, and have often thought the same, but if the AMA officiated using that, then nearly every rider that went off track last...

I get your logic, and have often thought the same, but if the AMA officiated using that, then nearly every rider that went off track last weekend, and that’s most of them, would be penalised. See the issue there.

As for: “That or you are trying to convince us that Hunter rolled by the whoops sooooo slow that he lost 9 seconds and 2 positions….lol.”….no I’m not trying to convince you of that. I’m saying he crashed and lost time and positions, so it doesn’t deserve penalty unless he enters in an unsafe manner, that is all.

 

A lot of riders went down but not off the track….of the ones going off track we have talked about for the most part.  Do you have another example?  Dylan went off with a little gap on Hunter and re-entered with less of a gap.

1
2
CPR
Posts
6995
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/17/2024 12:48pm
Press516 wrote:

Yep, number 3 on that list above was completely ignored for Hunter.  And I'm not anti-Lawrence at all...  But it was egregious. 

CPR wrote:
😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?! Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block...

😂 Are you blokes still going on about this?!

Again; Hunter went off track at the whoops twice. First time he went over a tuff block and lost a few seconds. Second time, he lost 9 secs and two positions.

Now please, anyone of you, tell everyone how he gained time and deserved a penalty that matches these offences. I look forward to your rational and logical replies, but instead I expect you’ll just downvote and go on to repeat this bullshite on other threads about a hundred times.

gerg wrote:

CPR you need to allow the haters to vent the steam.

Ha yeah, but I thought they would have got it all out by now. It runs deep! 

2
4
CPR
Posts
6995
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/17/2024 12:50pm
Shred wrote:
Hey…this is what I was talking about^^^.  Someone that uses live timing….lol….to come to the conclusion he wants.  First time…Hunter went over the tuff block and...

Hey…this is what I was talking about^^^.  Someone that uses live timing….lol….to come to the conclusion he wants.  First time…Hunter went over the tuff block and then proceeded to go faster then he had gone in the whoops previously and to gap Anderson more then just before the whoops…but hey…why believe your eyes.  Then he dumped it going in to the whoops(they show the clip in the recap of him picking his bike up right there and 2? riders going by)….gets passed as he picks up his bike…proceeds to exit the track on purpose and again rolls by the whoops at a higher speed then he could go through them.  You don’t get to exit the track to make up time from your own mistake.  ANYBODY that watches him go through the whoops on lap 1, when they were in the best condition, and compares his pace to when they show him rolling by them can easily see he is going faster bypassing them(and it is the rider’s responsibility to not accelerate/go faster)….thus gaining an advantage over staying on the track.  Plain to see….unless you don’t want to….and you don’t want to.  When you say he lost 9 seconds and was passed by 2 riders….that’s his fault and irrelevant to then after rolling by the whoops faster then you can ride through them.  If I fall and loose 20 seconds then can I cut part of the track and make up some of the time because I made a mistake??  That is the point you are trying to make.  That or you are trying to convince us that Hunter rolled by the whoops sooooo slow that he lost 9 seconds and 2 positions….lol.

btw…I don’t care that it was Hunter….I care that the AMA can’t be fair to riders across the board to save their life.  The AMA is pathetic.

CPR wrote:
I get your logic, and have often thought the same, but if the AMA officiated using that, then nearly every rider that went off track last...

I get your logic, and have often thought the same, but if the AMA officiated using that, then nearly every rider that went off track last weekend, and that’s most of them, would be penalised. See the issue there.

As for: “That or you are trying to convince us that Hunter rolled by the whoops sooooo slow that he lost 9 seconds and 2 positions….lol.”….no I’m not trying to convince you of that. I’m saying he crashed and lost time and positions, so it doesn’t deserve penalty unless he enters in an unsafe manner, that is all.

 

Shred wrote:
A lot of riders went down but not off the track….of the ones going off track we have talked about for the most part.  Do you...

A lot of riders went down but not off the track….of the ones going off track we have talked about for the most part.  Do you have another example?  Dylan went off with a little gap on Hunter and re-entered with less of a gap.

For real?!

2
Shred
Posts
1545
Joined
10/21/2021
Location
Brighton, CO, USA
Fantasy
1/17/2024 12:56pm Edited Date/Time 1/17/2024 12:56pm
CPR wrote:
I get your logic, and have often thought the same, but if the AMA officiated using that, then nearly every rider that went off track last...

I get your logic, and have often thought the same, but if the AMA officiated using that, then nearly every rider that went off track last weekend, and that’s most of them, would be penalised. See the issue there.

As for: “That or you are trying to convince us that Hunter rolled by the whoops sooooo slow that he lost 9 seconds and 2 positions….lol.”….no I’m not trying to convince you of that. I’m saying he crashed and lost time and positions, so it doesn’t deserve penalty unless he enters in an unsafe manner, that is all.

 

Shred wrote:
A lot of riders went down but not off the track….of the ones going off track we have talked about for the most part.  Do you...

A lot of riders went down but not off the track….of the ones going off track we have talked about for the most part.  Do you have another example?  Dylan went off with a little gap on Hunter and re-entered with less of a gap.

CPR wrote:

For real?!

Yes for real…it’s like screaming systemic racism with no specific examples of racism.  Watch the race and give me some actual examples.

2
3
1/17/2024 1:37pm
Magoofan wrote:

Credibility rating "ZERO" without Hunter on that list.

 

-MAVERICK- wrote:

Credibility with the AMA went out the door years ago. Guys missing entire rhythm section and speeding off track with no consequences, cutting entire corners, etc. 

Enter 2017 Savatgy...

CPR
Posts
6995
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/18/2024 12:43am
Shred wrote:
A lot of riders went down but not off the track….of the ones going off track we have talked about for the most part.  Do you...

A lot of riders went down but not off the track….of the ones going off track we have talked about for the most part.  Do you have another example?  Dylan went off with a little gap on Hunter and re-entered with less of a gap.

CPR wrote:

For real?!

Shred wrote:

Yes for real…it’s like screaming systemic racism with no specific examples of racism.  Watch the race and give me some actual examples.

😂 I apologise, I didn’t realise your Labrador couldn’t communicate every time someone went off the track.

1
1
Tyler D
Posts
2396
Joined
12/5/2022
Location
La, CA, USA
1/18/2024 8:25am

the second time, hunter accelerated off track. this warrants a penalty by operation of law. 

 

frisco.jpg?VersionId=yJ U4ZS0QuhZkt

1
2
mx617
Posts
1622
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Trail, CA
1/18/2024 8:40am
Rule is places gained + 1.  They must have decided Vince gained 2 positions and Justin only gained 1.

IMG 5061 1Rule is places gained + 1.  They must have decided Vince gained 2 positions and Justin only gained 1.

That's not what it says at all. It says IF position(s) are gained then the MINIMUM penalty is pos gained plus one. If NO positions are gained minimum penalty is one position. 

So based on what the rule says there is discretion for penalizing beyond the minimum and you can't draw any conclusions about the positions gained or not based solely on the penalty that was given. 

 

1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/18/2024 9:09am
gerg wrote:

CPR you need to allow the haters to vent the steam.

How is it hating when pretty much everyone agrees that everyone that received an infraction deserved it?   The majority also believe Hunter deserved one. 

Hunter flat out cheated.... no doubt scared of ending up in the LCQ and missing another main. 

 

3
5
Shred
Posts
1545
Joined
10/21/2021
Location
Brighton, CO, USA
Fantasy
1/18/2024 10:09am Edited Date/Time 1/18/2024 10:13am
CPR wrote:

For real?!

Shred wrote:

Yes for real…it’s like screaming systemic racism with no specific examples of racism.  Watch the race and give me some actual examples.

CPR wrote:

😂 I apologise, I didn’t realise your Labrador couldn’t communicate every time someone went off the track.

Yea…no specific examples.  I thought so.  I’ve rewatched the race.  You are wrong.  It the 450 main the ONLY other rider I saw go off track was Anderson when he was getting lapped by Tomac.  He waited until Eli was well past him and then re-entered the track.  So…your comment is just wrong.  Prove it…or make another lame comment dodging your inability to prove your wrong statement.  I’ll wait….

kxking
Posts
1955
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Oakville, Ontario, CA
Fantasy
1/18/2024 10:33am
Shred wrote:

Yes for real…it’s like screaming systemic racism with no specific examples of racism.  Watch the race and give me some actual examples.

CPR wrote:

😂 I apologise, I didn’t realise your Labrador couldn’t communicate every time someone went off the track.

Shred wrote:
Yea…no specific examples.  I thought so.  I’ve rewatched the race.  You are wrong.  It the 450 main the ONLY other rider I saw go off track...

Yea…no specific examples.  I thought so.  I’ve rewatched the race.  You are wrong.  It the 450 main the ONLY other rider I saw go off track was Anderson when he was getting lapped by Tomac.  He waited until Eli was well past him and then re-entered the track.  So…your comment is just wrong.  Prove it…or make another lame comment dodging your inability to prove your wrong statement.  I’ll wait….

Wait, you re-watched the entire race from all angles or just what the camera was focused on. If you did, I believe what you say,,, but I find it hard to believe that the only people that went off the track were JA21, HL96, JB51 and VF125.

2
Shred
Posts
1545
Joined
10/21/2021
Location
Brighton, CO, USA
Fantasy
1/18/2024 10:46am
CPR wrote:

😂 I apologise, I didn’t realise your Labrador couldn’t communicate every time someone went off the track.

Shred wrote:
Yea…no specific examples.  I thought so.  I’ve rewatched the race.  You are wrong.  It the 450 main the ONLY other rider I saw go off track...

Yea…no specific examples.  I thought so.  I’ve rewatched the race.  You are wrong.  It the 450 main the ONLY other rider I saw go off track was Anderson when he was getting lapped by Tomac.  He waited until Eli was well past him and then re-entered the track.  So…your comment is just wrong.  Prove it…or make another lame comment dodging your inability to prove your wrong statement.  I’ll wait….

kxking wrote:
Wait, you re-watched the entire race from all angles or just what the camera was focused on. If you did, I believe what you say,,, but...

Wait, you re-watched the entire race from all angles or just what the camera was focused on. If you did, I believe what you say,,, but I find it hard to believe that the only people that went off the track were JA21, HL96, JB51 and VF125.

Obviously I only had what the camera showed…but you can see a broad view of the track much of the time.  A lot of riders went down but the comment that “nearly every rider” went off track is just wrong.

1
1
FIREfish148
Posts
5485
Joined
1/20/2009
Location
Kirkland, WA, USA
1/18/2024 11:06am

Hunta wasn’t feeling the whoops so he made a positive out of a negative. I recon a good +6 seconds.

5
gerg
Posts
1545
Joined
10/29/2014
Location
AU
1/18/2024 12:48pm
gerg wrote:

CPR you need to allow the haters to vent the steam.

Magoofan wrote:
How is it hating when pretty much everyone agrees that everyone that received an infraction deserved it?   The majority also believe Hunter deserved one.  Hunter flat...

How is it hating when pretty much everyone agrees that everyone that received an infraction deserved it?   The majority also believe Hunter deserved one. 

Hunter flat out cheated.... no doubt scared of ending up in the LCQ and missing another main. 

 

Mate you are virtually the Grand Poobah of the Hunter hate club so don't try to weave logic through those hate colored glasses.

"Hunter cheated because he was scared of the LCQ"...just nonsense.

If he cut the track and gained an advantage then yes he should have received a penalty.  I guess the AMA saw it more objectively than some people.

Whatever the fact shouldn't you be over the moon that he's had 2 bad results in a row?  I bet you were doing air high fives and screaming out "FUCK YEAH !!!!!" when he went down at A1.

3
5
1/18/2024 12:57pm

Until they become harsher on their penalties, people will continue to cut the track. The risk reward is well worth it. 

I was thinking I could do well in a main if I could just get a decent start into the first turn.  Then just make a detour and ride my laps on the side of the track without gaining any positions.  Finish the main without dealing with the obstacles....the new era way of safely and easily maintaining your position to the checkered flag.

2
2
zookrider62!
Posts
6825
Joined
12/22/2008
Location
Plano, TX, USA
1/18/2024 1:12pm

Until they become harsher on their penalties, people will continue to cut the track. The risk reward is well worth it. 

I was thinking I could do well in a main if I could just get a decent start into the first turn.  Then just make a...

I was thinking I could do well in a main if I could just get a decent start into the first turn.  Then just make a detour and ride my laps on the side of the track without gaining any positions.  Finish the main without dealing with the obstacles....the new era way of safely and easily maintaining your position to the checkered flag.

Webb tried that when he hurt his hand - didnt go over well

1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/18/2024 2:02pm
gerg wrote:
Mate you are virtually the Grand Poobah of the Hunter hate club so don't try to weave logic through those hate colored glasses. "Hunter cheated because...

Mate you are virtually the Grand Poobah of the Hunter hate club so don't try to weave logic through those hate colored glasses.

"Hunter cheated because he was scared of the LCQ"...just nonsense.

If he cut the track and gained an advantage then yes he should have received a penalty.  I guess the AMA saw it more objectively than some people.

Whatever the fact shouldn't you be over the moon that he's had 2 bad results in a row?  I bet you were doing air high fives and screaming out "FUCK YEAH !!!!!" when he went down at A1.

Reading that....all I see is:

image-20240118140147-1

9
Alex814
Posts
1236
Joined
12/18/2014
Location
USA
1/18/2024 2:10pm

I'm just laughing at the timing of this penalty report. How can you let guys race the main (and destroy their bike) and later DQ, saying they were not eligible to make the main? Why even send AMA to the race if this can't be done in real time?

1
1
1/18/2024 4:25pm
Alex814 wrote:
I'm just laughing at the timing of this penalty report. How can you let guys race the main (and destroy their bike) and later DQ, saying...

I'm just laughing at the timing of this penalty report. How can you let guys race the main (and destroy their bike) and later DQ, saying they were not eligible to make the main? Why even send AMA to the race if this can't be done in real time?

Sorry I am confused. This report tells you who got a penalty on the night and what for.

Nate lost his fastest qualifying lap, so his second lap is what determined his heat race not his fastest lap.

Vince finished 9th in the heat and then lost positions due to his penalty which forced him to have to race the lcq and Dean got the final transfer position from the heat

Barcia finished 2nd in the lcq and then copped a penalty which relegated him to 4th and still transferring to the main.

 

Where did someone race the main and get disqualified because of their penalty from either the heat or lcq?

3
Alex814
Posts
1236
Joined
12/18/2014
Location
USA
1/18/2024 6:17pm
Alex814 wrote:
I'm just laughing at the timing of this penalty report. How can you let guys race the main (and destroy their bike) and later DQ, saying...

I'm just laughing at the timing of this penalty report. How can you let guys race the main (and destroy their bike) and later DQ, saying they were not eligible to make the main? Why even send AMA to the race if this can't be done in real time?

Sorry I am confused. This report tells you who got a penalty on the night and what for. Nate lost his fastest qualifying lap, so his...

Sorry I am confused. This report tells you who got a penalty on the night and what for.

Nate lost his fastest qualifying lap, so his second lap is what determined his heat race not his fastest lap.

Vince finished 9th in the heat and then lost positions due to his penalty which forced him to have to race the lcq and Dean got the final transfer position from the heat

Barcia finished 2nd in the lcq and then copped a penalty which relegated him to 4th and still transferring to the main.

 

Where did someone race the main and get disqualified because of their penalty from either the heat or lcq?

I was under the assumption these penalties were assessed after the racing, it sounds like I was wrong. Thanks for clarifying. 

2

Post a reply to: Penalty Report for San Fran

The Latest