Favorite Torque Wrench?

slowgti
Posts
1010
Joined
1/14/2016
Location
Monroe, GA, USA
1/16/2024 10:35am
Magoofan wrote:
Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of...

Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of spec. 

 

What part of the country are you in? There are a couple around the space coast in Florida. 

Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/16/2024 10:56am
Magoofan wrote:
Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of...

Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of spec. 

 

slowgti wrote:

What part of the country are you in? There are a couple around the space coast in Florida. 

Sunny San Diego.   

 

3
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/16/2024 11:10am
Magoofan wrote:

Sunny San Diego.   

 

slowgti wrote:

Yeah.  I found them.   Just looking for recommendations/experiences. 

3

The Shop

Gravel
Posts
1943
Joined
2/22/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA, USA
1/16/2024 11:11am

CDI has traditionally been a great value.

1
Rickyisms
Posts
5946
Joined
10/5/2017
Location
USA
1/16/2024 11:18am

I’ve run the cheaper HF ones for years now with no problems. Lifetime warranty, take it in after a couple years when calibration has been thrown off and exchange it for a fresh one. Built tons of dirt bike motors, forks, chassis, and the rear end of my F150 clicking everything to spec with them. No complaints and plenty of money saved. 

1
ricko
Posts
741
Joined
9/6/2011
Location
bfe, PA, USA
1/16/2024 11:32am
Gravel wrote:

CDI has traditionally been a great value.

CDI is a snapon company, good torque wrenches for sure

1
Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/16/2024 2:34pm
Magoofan wrote:

Sunny San Diego.   

 

slowgti wrote:
Magoofan wrote:

Yeah.  I found them.   Just looking for recommendations/experiences. 

Reached out to these guys... $70+tax for a 1/2 250 ft/lb....       

 

2
2
AgentOrange
Posts
348
Joined
1/21/2020
Location
Forest Lake, MN, USA
1/16/2024 2:45pm
Magoofan wrote:
Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of...

Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of spec. 

 

I watched a YouTube video how to check calibration on my 30 yr old 3/8" Craftsman click type and found it to be right on! I was amazed, I guess the key is to zero it while in storage. 

2
aees
Posts
2904
Joined
8/20/2015
Location
USA
1/16/2024 2:54pm

Since 95% of everyone don't compensate for stretched or lubed vs dry threads and same with nuts anyway, just get a cheap one with decent build quality.

1
ToolMaker
Posts
10444
Joined
11/19/2011
Location
Escondido, CA, USA
1/16/2024 3:06pm
Magoofan wrote:
      ....but seriously.  I've got a digital Sears Craftsmen torque wrench I bought back in 1992, it has served me well.    I use...

image-20240115220656-1

 

....but seriously.  I've got a digital Sears Craftsmen torque wrench I bought back in 1992, it has served me well.   

I use some HF tools too and have  never had any issues.

Get ready for the tool-snob responses.   

Chance1216 wrote:
I have a 48” pipe wrench. Is that enough for my seat bolts? 

I have a 48” pipe wrench. Is that enough for my seat bolts? Woohoo

Go big or go home right?

1
ToolMaker
Posts
10444
Joined
11/19/2011
Location
Escondido, CA, USA
1/16/2024 3:21pm

For my really tiny 1/4" drive I have a Utica, 3/8" and 1/2" drive I have Craftsman. I also have a 3/8" electronic that goes between the ratchet and the socket.

TM

ToolMaker
Posts
10444
Joined
11/19/2011
Location
Escondido, CA, USA
1/16/2024 3:25pm
aees wrote:
Since 95% of everyone don't compensate for stretched or lubed vs dry threads and same with nuts anyway, just get a cheap one with decent build...

Since 95% of everyone don't compensate for stretched or lubed vs dry threads and same with nuts anyway, just get a cheap one with decent build quality.

The difference from wet to dry is so significant that you really need to compensate for it. If not you can do some real damage. Depending on the bolt and material the bolt is going in, you might have to reduce your torque setting 30%-50% using lube.

1
aees
Posts
2904
Joined
8/20/2015
Location
USA
1/16/2024 3:36pm Edited Date/Time 1/16/2024 11:53pm
aees wrote:
Since 95% of everyone don't compensate for stretched or lubed vs dry threads and same with nuts anyway, just get a cheap one with decent build...

Since 95% of everyone don't compensate for stretched or lubed vs dry threads and same with nuts anyway, just get a cheap one with decent build quality.

ToolMaker wrote:
The difference from wet to dry is so significant that you really need to compensate for it. If not you can do some real damage. Depending...

The difference from wet to dry is so significant that you really need to compensate for it. If not you can do some real damage. Depending on the bolt and material the bolt is going in, you might have to reduce your torque setting 30%-50% using lube.

Yes kind of mynt point. Chasing cents while dropping dollars. If a wrench is off by 5-10%, and I think that's rare being off that much. Sure it's not good, but thats not where you should be looking if you want accurate torque.

Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/16/2024 3:39pm
Magoofan wrote:
Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of...

Where you guys sending Torque wrenches for calibration.   I'm thinking after watching that video and 30 years of use, wondering if my Craftsmen is out of spec. 

 

I watched a YouTube video how to check calibration on my 30 yr old 3/8" Craftsman click type and found it to be right on! I...

I watched a YouTube video how to check calibration on my 30 yr old 3/8" Craftsman click type and found it to be right on! I was amazed, I guess the key is to zero it while in storage. 

Yeah, I checked out how to do it yourself.  I'll probably give that a try.  $70 bucks seems pretty excessive for something that probably takes someone 15 minutes to do.

....and I ALWAYS zero my torque wrenches when done. Cool

2
j368
Posts
584
Joined
7/13/2014
Location
Tulsa, OK, USA
1/16/2024 3:44pm Edited Date/Time 1/16/2024 4:56pm
Zeke27G wrote:
  Hands down my favorite (spoke) torque wrench and I honestly don't know how the hell I survived without one in my toolbox.  [img]https://www.fasstco.com/cdn/shop/products/Untitled-191_750x.jpg?v=1669214363[/img] https://www.fasstco.com/products/spoke-torque-wrench?variant=39124559502

 

Hands down my favorite (spoke) torque wrench and I honestly don't know how the hell I survived without one in my toolbox. 

https://www.fasstco.com/products/spoke-torque-wrench?variant=39124559502

FasstCole wrote:
Thanks @Zeke! We at Fasst Company make that wrench completely in-house these days.  Originally CDI built it for us.  Currently all of our spoke torque wrenches...

Thanks @Zeke! We at Fasst Company make that wrench completely in-house these days.  Originally CDI built it for us.  Currently all of our spoke torque wrenches are assembled and calibrated by two Loretta's champ Sophie Phelps who works for us while she's getting her engineering degree.  

I’ll second that on Fasst Co. spoke torque wrench. I’ve had one for years. High quality and never had any problems with it. 

1
Forty
Posts
3093
Joined
7/27/2009
Location
Saint Paul, MN, USA
1/16/2024 4:18pm

S-K   no complaints

1
colintrax
Posts
4695
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA, USA
1/16/2024 6:53pm
Forty wrote:

S-K   no complaints

SK is Chinese now aside from sockets

AS64
Posts
1761
Joined
5/14/2012
Location
CA
1/16/2024 6:55pm Edited Date/Time 1/16/2024 7:00pm

As much as I love using brands like Proto, Snap-On and Wera… I’ve found Gearwrench to make great quality tools for the money. I have a couple of their smaller torque wrenches at home and they’ve been reliable 

Timo
Posts
1511
Joined
1/9/2021
Location
Wichita, KS, USA
1/16/2024 7:22pm

My 250ftlbs is a icon, I'd recommend it to anyone.

My 100ftlbs is a Pittsburgh Pro, I'd also recommend it.

My 10-250 inch pound torque wrench was a craftsman, it had a plastic handle that I melted somehow. The lock on it was part of the plastic handle and felt cheap. I've replaced it with a Pittsburgh Pro and it just feels better with the metal handle.

I've also got a couple of cheaper Pittsburgh 150ftlbs wrenches in my trailer and another one in my RV. They work fine, and have short handles which makes them fit in my travel boxes. The Pittsburgh Pro and Icon are definitely a better quality, but these are good for travel tools.

1
captmoto
Posts
5922
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, USA
1/16/2024 8:13pm

I have the HF Quinn 1/2" and 3/8" digital. These will do left hand threads and do degrees too. I have a Tecton 1/4". I have an old Craftsman 3/8" digital and have seen it with different labels on line. I have an old Craftsman click type but for some work I've done I needed the degree settings.  The Tecton looks like almost every other torque wrench on Amazon.
  

Forty
Posts
3093
Joined
7/27/2009
Location
Saint Paul, MN, USA
1/16/2024 8:46pm
Forty wrote:

S-K   no complaints

colintrax wrote:

SK is Chinese now aside from sockets

Still      no complaints    

Magoofan
Posts
10401
Joined
5/4/2021
Location
Shadow Glen (for those who remember), CA, USA
1/16/2024 8:53pm
Forty wrote:

S-K   no complaints

colintrax wrote:

SK is Chinese now aside from sockets

Just because something is made in China, doesn't make it junk.         Sure, there's a lot of junk coming from China...that's what people tend to focus on.

Plenty of junk products made here in the good ol USA too. 

 

1
3
flatspin
Posts
96
Joined
1/6/2024
Location
Washington D.C., WA, USA
1/16/2024 9:19pm

Snap on digital TechAngle 3/8 flex head. Many features and customizable settings. It’s not particularly cheap but you get what you pay for. The Snap on is where it’s at

1
colintrax
Posts
4695
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA, USA
1/16/2024 9:26pm
Forty wrote:

S-K   no complaints

colintrax wrote:

SK is Chinese now aside from sockets

Forty wrote:

Still      no complaints    

My point is the torque wrench you own is unlikely to be what's sold now. SK got bought out by a Chinese conglomerate and is now made overseas. The only thing that's the same is brand name slapped on it.

bowens971
Posts
55
Joined
3/9/2015
Location
Childress, TX, USA
1/16/2024 11:21pm Edited Date/Time 1/16/2024 11:22pm

I calibrate torque wrenches for a living ( https://elitetoolingservices.com ) I’ve done just about every brand and model you can imagine. With that being said, I prefer Snap On click wrenches. Snap On, CDI, and Wright are all made together and differ in the drives. Snap On digital are incredibly accurate but require a little more patience as there’s no “click” or “break” to stop your torque, you can overrun your value easily. It’s pretty rare that I come across a Snap On that’s outside the calibration window, they’re great tools. If you don’t like twisting a click wrench to value or burning through batteries in digital, check out Stahlwille brand. They’re pricey but by far the easiest wrench to change values with. Wind turbine site use this brand nearly exclusively. 

3
dwight955
Posts
169
Joined
11/20/2014
Location
Hillsboro, MO, USA
1/17/2024 6:24am

Does anyone here have any experience with Suercup brand torque wrenches? I saw one on Amazon. What caught my eye was not the price, but the torque range was only 5 to 45 ft.lbs. Would this be more accurate than torque wrenches with torque ranges from 10 to 80 ft. lbs. like the Craftsman I have now?

bowens971
Posts
55
Joined
3/9/2015
Location
Childress, TX, USA
1/17/2024 7:08am
dwight955 wrote:
Does anyone here have any experience with Suercup brand torque wrenches? I saw one on Amazon. What caught my eye was not the price, but the...

Does anyone here have any experience with Suercup brand torque wrenches? I saw one on Amazon. What caught my eye was not the price, but the torque range was only 5 to 45 ft.lbs. Would this be more accurate than torque wrenches with torque ranges from 10 to 80 ft. lbs. like the Craftsman I have now?

Yes I had a customer that got some brand new. 9 of 10 failed calibration right out of the box and had to be adjusted. They’re junk. 

Forty
Posts
3093
Joined
7/27/2009
Location
Saint Paul, MN, USA
1/17/2024 8:46am
colintrax wrote:

SK is Chinese now aside from sockets

Forty wrote:

Still      no complaints    

colintrax wrote:
My point is the torque wrench you own is unlikely to be what's sold now. SK got bought out by a Chinese conglomerate and is now...

My point is the torque wrench you own is unlikely to be what's sold now. SK got bought out by a Chinese conglomerate and is now made overseas. The only thing that's the same is brand name slapped on it.

Yes - it's unfortunate too, although I do not know the quality of the current offering, I doubt it's the same.  

It's the problem with building a quality item -  it lasts, and the company relies primarily on rare failure replacement or new order from new users.  

My SK Torque Wrench is 25 year old, I have had it checked once, it was spot on and no issues at all.  When one sells a product like that, you'd better have another revenue stream. 

dwight955
Posts
169
Joined
11/20/2014
Location
Hillsboro, MO, USA
1/17/2024 9:50am
dwight955 wrote:
Does anyone here have any experience with Suercup brand torque wrenches? I saw one on Amazon. What caught my eye was not the price, but the...

Does anyone here have any experience with Suercup brand torque wrenches? I saw one on Amazon. What caught my eye was not the price, but the torque range was only 5 to 45 ft.lbs. Would this be more accurate than torque wrenches with torque ranges from 10 to 80 ft. lbs. like the Craftsman I have now?

bowens971 wrote:
Yes I had a customer that got some brand new. 9 of 10 failed calibration right out of the box and had to be adjusted. They’re...

Yes I had a customer that got some brand new. 9 of 10 failed calibration right out of the box and had to be adjusted. They’re junk. 

Thank you for the warning. I will keep looking for a  narrow range torque wrench. Any suggestions?

 

Post a reply to: Favorite Torque Wrench?

The Latest