How can Bennick race pro sport classes at LL having scored 54 points?

piscokid
Posts
321
Joined
10/22/2013
Location
OH US
Edited Date/Time 7/27/2023 11:12am

The rule reads (to me at least) up to 40 points and 3 nationals.  Bennick has 3 nationals and 54 points.

10
|
bigk218
Posts
1455
Joined
1/2/2018
Location
Summerville, SC US
7/27/2023 11:16am

They need to make the rule in the A class at Loretta’s one that you must race at least three nationals in order to compete…

 

1
7
ML512
Posts
16946
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA US
Fantasy
7/27/2023 11:19am

The rule gets misinterpreted. You can break the 40 points, it's just at that point you can't do anymore if you still want to go to Loretta Lynn's.

If you race three rounds or break the 40 points threshold, you have to give up your amateur eligibility to race your next national. So you either park it until LL's, or if you do another national you can't go back to LL's.

I know they're going to re-word the rule for 2024 to try and eliminate some confusion.

29
slowgti
Posts
1006
Joined
1/14/2016
Location
Monroe, GA US
7/27/2023 11:41am

Never change AMA

7
9
chasetwo79
Posts
1587
Joined
12/1/2019
Location
Truckee, CA, CA US
7/27/2023 12:55pm

I’m pretty sure you can race pro sport still after anyhow. Just not A. 

1

The Shop

7/27/2023 2:54pm
bigk218 wrote:

They need to make the rule in the A class at Loretta’s one that you must race at least three nationals in order to compete…

 

Majority of the kids racing A have never raced a pro national and won’t until they’re done racing A class. 

1
7/28/2023 12:52am
slowgti wrote:

Never change AMA

While the wording can be better, they got this one right to prevent riders from “taking a dive” and pulling off to avoid going over. 

3
1
pdub187
Posts
765
Joined
1/28/2013
Location
AU
7/28/2023 3:32am

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

36
1
yak651
Posts
8645
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI US
Fantasy
7/28/2023 4:04am
pdub187 wrote:

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

Yep just another way to cater to the factory supported teams while still keeping entries up in the A classes. 

6
2
7/28/2023 4:32am

If you hold a current Pro license you are a Pro IMO you should not be able to be a Pro Amateur 

15
1
ned.
Posts
56
Joined
7/19/2023
Location
EC, WI US
7/28/2023 4:42am
pdub187 wrote:

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

yak651 wrote:

Yep just another way to cater to the factory supported teams while still keeping entries up in the A classes. 

Agree with both of these. Kinda feels like these kids are more or less being given a hall pass to sandbag in the amateur ranks. They already went pro, they already have a ride, what’s the point even?

10
1
7/28/2023 4:55am

If you hold a current Pro license you are a Pro IMO you should not be able to be a Pro Amateur 

I disagree. Pro-Privateers need a place to showcase their talents. 

1
13
mx313
Posts
1532
Joined
10/5/2021
Location
Brisbane City, QLD AU
7/28/2023 5:28am
pdub187 wrote:

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

yak651 wrote:

Yep just another way to cater to the factory supported teams while still keeping entries up in the A classes. 

ned. wrote:
Agree with both of these. Kinda feels like these kids are more or less being given a hall pass to sandbag in the amateur ranks. They...

Agree with both of these. Kinda feels like these kids are more or less being given a hall pass to sandbag in the amateur ranks. They already went pro, they already have a ride, what’s the point even?

I actually think the purpose is the complete opposite. But the factory teams take advantage of the rules.

I think it's so a top local/ 40th place national rider can race the local pro national then still be able to race Loretta's. Otherwise if your not quite pro level. If you do try 1 national you cannot be amateur again. So it allows that level rider some flexibility. Then the factory's take advantage of the rules.

 

ned.
Posts
56
Joined
7/19/2023
Location
EC, WI US
7/28/2023 5:44am
mx313 wrote:
I actually think the purpose is the complete opposite. But the factory teams take advantage of the rules. I think it's so a top local/ 40th...

I actually think the purpose is the complete opposite. But the factory teams take advantage of the rules.

I think it's so a top local/ 40th place national rider can race the local pro national then still be able to race Loretta's. Otherwise if your not quite pro level. If you do try 1 national you cannot be amateur again. So it allows that level rider some flexibility. Then the factory's take advantage of the rules.

 

Yeah, there’s totally some value there for privateers. Most in those circumstances will not go pro and drop back down to do LL’s a few weeks later.

It’s a double edged sword really. It’s easier to have rules that apply to everyone equally, and the larger, factory teams having a presence at LL’s undoubtedly have a positive impact on the turnout.

bigk218
Posts
1455
Joined
1/2/2018
Location
Summerville, SC US
7/28/2023 6:42am Edited Date/Time 7/28/2023 6:45am
ML512 wrote:
The rule gets misinterpreted. You can break the 40 points, it's just at that point you can't do anymore if you still want to go to...

The rule gets misinterpreted. You can break the 40 points, it's just at that point you can't do anymore if you still want to go to Loretta Lynn's.

If you race three rounds or break the 40 points threshold, you have to give up your amateur eligibility to race your next national. So you either park it until LL's, or if you do another national you can't go back to LL's.

I know they're going to re-word the rule for 2024 to try and eliminate some confusion.

They need to eliminate the rule. It’s pathetic for our sport. You race a pro race your done with Loretta’s.. It’s just a dam free for all. Not a good look.   

4
5
7/28/2023 6:47am

He can race Pro Sport all he wants... Whats the problem?

2
ML512
Posts
16946
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA US
Fantasy
7/28/2023 6:47am Edited Date/Time 7/28/2023 6:57am
bigk218 wrote:
They need to eliminate the rule. It’s pathetic for our sport. You race a pro race your done with Loretta’s.. It’s just a dam free for...

They need to eliminate the rule. It’s pathetic for our sport. You race a pro race your done with Loretta’s.. It’s just a dam free for all. Not a good look.   

I'm on the unpopular side of this one. I like the rule and most guys, especially outside the factory level, always seem to be blown away at how gnarly the pro field really is. I like the idea of them getting a small taste, getting their teeth kicked in, and hopefully walking away going "Shit, I really have to dig deep if I want to do this".

Personally, I think it can help some guys make the transition as they can learn what to really expect before it's too late and they've gone full-time. Quite a few kids who have made it through amateurs on talent and just a lot of riding time struggle with the real thing. I'd like the younger kids coming up to be more successful and not get booted for lack of results quite as quickly. Our sport has seemed to have struggled a lot in the last 5-8 years it seems like. That's just my opinion.

15
1
GrapeApe
Posts
8835
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX US
7/28/2023 6:50am
ML512 wrote:
The rule gets misinterpreted. You can break the 40 points, it's just at that point you can't do anymore if you still want to go to...

The rule gets misinterpreted. You can break the 40 points, it's just at that point you can't do anymore if you still want to go to Loretta Lynn's.

If you race three rounds or break the 40 points threshold, you have to give up your amateur eligibility to race your next national. So you either park it until LL's, or if you do another national you can't go back to LL's.

I know they're going to re-word the rule for 2024 to try and eliminate some confusion.

bigk218 wrote:
They need to eliminate the rule. It’s pathetic for our sport. You race a pro race your done with Loretta’s.. It’s just a dam free for...

They need to eliminate the rule. It’s pathetic for our sport. You race a pro race your done with Loretta’s.. It’s just a dam free for all. Not a good look.   

Who does it harm?

1
1
tyler113
Posts
169
Joined
3/24/2011
Location
Fg, WI US
7/28/2023 7:14am
pdub187 wrote:

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

yak651 wrote:

Yep just another way to cater to the factory supported teams while still keeping entries up in the A classes. 

There should only be displacement classes at LL. I get this is capitalism, and it's all about money, but I don't even bother paying attention to LL's because there's so many filler classes. C classes should completely be eliminated from at least the premier amateur national.

As for advancement they should really look at the USA BMX model, it's pretty cut and dry.  

4
2
KHNC
Posts
633
Joined
5/24/2023
Location
East Flat Rock, NC US
7/28/2023 7:25am

Hopefully Bennick will be beating deegan next year anyway. 

5
7
bigk218
Posts
1455
Joined
1/2/2018
Location
Summerville, SC US
7/28/2023 7:32am
bigk218 wrote:
They need to eliminate the rule. It’s pathetic for our sport. You race a pro race your done with Loretta’s.. It’s just a dam free for...

They need to eliminate the rule. It’s pathetic for our sport. You race a pro race your done with Loretta’s.. It’s just a dam free for all. Not a good look.   

ML512 wrote:
I'm on the unpopular side of this one. I like the rule and most guys, especially outside the factory level, always seem to be blown away...

I'm on the unpopular side of this one. I like the rule and most guys, especially outside the factory level, always seem to be blown away at how gnarly the pro field really is. I like the idea of them getting a small taste, getting their teeth kicked in, and hopefully walking away going "Shit, I really have to dig deep if I want to do this".

Personally, I think it can help some guys make the transition as they can learn what to really expect before it's too late and they've gone full-time. Quite a few kids who have made it through amateurs on talent and just a lot of riding time struggle with the real thing. I'd like the younger kids coming up to be more successful and not get booted for lack of results quite as quickly. Our sport has seemed to have struggled a lot in the last 5-8 years it seems like. That's just my opinion.


 I think whenever you have amateurs competing against the pros, with a “open door come and go as you please policy”  it waters down how elite and exclusive the the class is. You don’t see college football stars competing in the NFL just to see where they stand… There’s so MUCHHH more prestige with sports that have a defined boundary when it comes to amateurs and professionals . 

plus, what is a Loretta’s title going to do for bennick anyway. he already has a ride.  If he doesn’t annihilate the field that looks bad and regardless he only probably has a 2 year make or break contract with star. It changes nothing 


 

 

3
7
183Matt
Posts
856
Joined
10/9/2019
Location
Mineral, CA US
7/28/2023 8:10am

I think the whole thing needs an overhaul.  C racers should be true C racers, B, A etc…. This sandbagging stuff is stupid.  Otherwise just divide it by age and let it be unlimited, run what you bring who ever you are.  IMO it shocked some people last year when Cole Martinez came out and beat all those “up and coming kids”, and I was surprised that didn’t create more change.

2
1
piscokid
Posts
321
Joined
10/22/2013
Location
OH US
7/28/2023 9:56am
ML512 wrote:
The rule gets misinterpreted. You can break the 40 points, it's just at that point you can't do anymore if you still want to go to...

The rule gets misinterpreted. You can break the 40 points, it's just at that point you can't do anymore if you still want to go to Loretta Lynn's.

If you race three rounds or break the 40 points threshold, you have to give up your amateur eligibility to race your next national. So you either park it until LL's, or if you do another national you can't go back to LL's.

I know they're going to re-word the rule for 2024 to try and eliminate some confusion.

Thanks ML,  Not sure why the down votes, I have zero skin in the game, just trying to understand how he pointed over and was still showing up to LL.

 

1
cwel11
Posts
2643
Joined
12/4/2019
Location
Orangeville, PA US
7/28/2023 1:49pm
183Matt wrote:
I think the whole thing needs an overhaul.  C racers should be true C racers, B, A etc…. This sandbagging stuff is stupid.  Otherwise just divide...

I think the whole thing needs an overhaul.  C racers should be true C racers, B, A etc…. This sandbagging stuff is stupid.  Otherwise just divide it by age and let it be unlimited, run what you bring who ever you are.  IMO it shocked some people last year when Cole Martinez came out and beat all those “up and coming kids”, and I was surprised that didn’t create more change.

This is my biggest beef with LL. It screws up local racing classes. C class is beginner. Not a pimply faced kid scrubbing every jump running A rider lap times hoping to turn pro. It really is quite a mess at the local races. 

7
1
7/28/2023 2:15pm

I think it's lame. He was a top 10-15 guy, and now he's heading back to LL's for what? He has the ride, he's part of the program, he has the pro experience, what's the point? Is he going to start his career at Dilla anyways?

1
2
Meister
Posts
3241
Joined
3/21/2013
Location
Canton, OH US
7/28/2023 2:41pm
pdub187 wrote:

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

You mean like the vet classes at the amature national? Yeah. Pretty damn dumb.

Any pro kids should only be eligible for pro sport. 

3
Renner153
Posts
1619
Joined
12/10/2008
Location
Mulberry, FL US
7/28/2023 2:49pm
pdub187 wrote:

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

Meister wrote:

You mean like the vet classes at the amature national? Yeah. Pretty damn dumb.

Any pro kids should only be eligible for pro sport. 

Dude, we get it. You don’t want to have to race anyone faster than you.

I bet none of you guys will be crying about matti jorgensen or anyone else that raced 3 pro races though. 

2
2
slowgti
Posts
1006
Joined
1/14/2016
Location
Monroe, GA US
7/28/2023 3:02pm

While the wording can be better, they got this one right to prevent riders from “taking a dive” and pulling off to avoid going over. 

I was talking about their easily misunderstood wording in the rule book. 

7/28/2023 3:11pm
I think it's lame. He was a top 10-15 guy, and now he's heading back to LL's for what? He has the ride, he's part of...

I think it's lame. He was a top 10-15 guy, and now he's heading back to LL's for what? He has the ride, he's part of the program, he has the pro experience, what's the point? Is he going to start his career at Dilla anyways?

I really think IF they would actually enforce the Claiming rule - claim that bike! IMO it was a travesty Deagans bike was not taken away from him once claimed!

4
yak651
Posts
8645
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI US
Fantasy
7/28/2023 3:12pm

My local races I asked if I could try the A class and if I didn’t feel comfortable can I go back and they told me no. Once you try it you are in it. Seems odd to have this rule for the “pro” class but guess there are only a handoff people using it so in the end doesn’t make a difference one way or the other

Meister
Posts
3241
Joined
3/21/2013
Location
Canton, OH US
7/28/2023 9:41pm
pdub187 wrote:

It's so fucking stupid allowing these kids to turn professional and then just turn amateur again a few weeks later.

Meister wrote:

You mean like the vet classes at the amature national? Yeah. Pretty damn dumb.

Any pro kids should only be eligible for pro sport. 

Renner153 wrote:
Dude, we get it. You don’t want to have to race anyone faster than you. I bet none of you guys will be crying about matti...

Dude, we get it. You don’t want to have to race anyone faster than you.

I bet none of you guys will be crying about matti jorgensen or anyone else that raced 3 pro races though. 

I have no problem racing guys faster than me that aren't milking a system. I love seeing a fast mfker that puts 40-50 hours in at work a week who has never been paid by a factory to hone their professional level skill set.. 

"TrY hArDeR". How about no, they can keep trying harder and continue to race with people of their skill level instead of taking the cherry picking route and going at it with minimal training relying on their skill set that will never disappear.. Their fitness will dwindle because they quit working as hard.  

A vet pro class would put guys together that have similar skill sets. Or, they can go race the appropriate A class at the few vet nationals a year. If they don't like it, quit. 

 

Again, these factory kids who have raced nats, should be forced to be in pro sport and only pro sport. 

 

1
5

Post a reply to: How can Bennick race pro sport classes at LL having scored 54 points?

The Latest